CourtListener 10796323•In re Ne.L. CA1/1
Full text
Filed 2/19/26 In re Ne.L. CA1/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or
ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
In re Ne.L. et al., Persons Coming
Under the Juvenile Court Law.
SAN MATEO COUNTY HUMAN
SERVICES AGENCY,
Plaintiff and Respondent, A172290
v.
(San Mateo County
N.L.,
Super. Ct. Nos. 23-JD-0577, 23-
Defendant and Appellant. JD-0578, 23-JD-0579)
This dependency proceeding originated in Santa Cruz County. After
Mother moved to San Mateo County, the Santa Cruz court transferred the
case to that jurisdiction. The San Mateo court immediately transferred the
case back to Santa Cruz to allow that county to handle the 12-month review
hearing. Mother appealed, challenging the validity of the San Mateo court
transfer order. Following the review hearing, the Santa Cruz court again
transferred the case to San Mateo. San Mateo accepted the transfer, and
there the case has remained. Accordingly, Mother’s appeal is now moot, and
we dismiss it.
1
BACKGROUND1
In February 2024, the Santa Cruz County Human Services Department
(Santa Cruz Department or Department) filed a fourth amended Welfare and
Institutions Code section 300 petition for Ne.L., No.L., and Na.L. Two
months later, the Santa Cruz juvenile court sustained the petition in large
part and set a six-month review hearing date for September, which was
subsequently continued to December.
Before the December hearing, Mother moved to San Mateo County.
At the hearing, the Santa Cruz court conducted the six-month review
and also heard a motion to transfer the case to San Mateo. The court ordered
six more months of reunification services, set a 12-month review hearing at
the end of January 2025, and granted the motion to transfer to San Mateo
County.
The transfer-in hearing in San Mateo County was scheduled for
January 6. Prior to the hearing date, the San Mateo County Human Services
Agency (San Mateo Agency or Agency) filed a motion to transfer the case back
to Santa Cruz asserting it was in the best interests of the children for the
case to remain in Santa Cruz because of the now fast-approaching 12-month
review hearing date. The Agency explained that, assuming the San Mateo
court held the 12-month review hearing on the statutory deadline of
February 5, 2025, “the FR-12 Court Report and Case Plan would be due to
[the] court on January 24, 2025,” giving the Agency only 18 days from the
date of the transfer-in hearing to assign a social worker, make a
recommendation, and create a case plan, which would involve interviewing
1 We grant respondent’s request for judicial notice, which Mother does
not oppose, of the January 30, 2025, Santa Cruz minute orders; the signed
orders authorizing transfer to San Mateo County; and the San Mateo minute
orders accepting transfer from Santa Cruz County. (Evid. Code, § 452.)
2
service providers, the parents, the children, and other interested parties. The
Agency cited to the County Welfare Directors Association Inter-County
Transfer Protocol, which stated transferring a case is “ ‘not appropriate if the
next review hearing is less than 90 days’ ” away. Although not the law, the
protocol “was written for a reason, to serve the best interests of families when
transferring cases.” Additionally, there were issues with the inquiry under
the Indian Child Welfare Act (25 U.S.C. § 1901 et seq.) that the Agency
asserted should be addressed by the Santa Cruz Department “as it is the
entity most knowledgeable with this process.”2
Mother opposed the motion, pointing out the inter-county protocol was
not the law, and there had been approximately 57 days before the 12-month
review statutory deadline when the motion was made, giving the Agency
approximately a month to make its assessment. Counsel maintained this
should be plenty of time to “prepare for an uncontested 12 month hearing.”
Counsel further stated the county could seek a continuance, “which would not
be objected to by mother.” Finally, counsel asserted it was in the family’s
best interest for the case to remain in San Mateo where Mother “can fluidly
access services during her time sensitive reunification period.”
At the January 6 hearing, the San Mateo court accepted transfer and
set the matter for a contested hearing to be held the following week. At the
contested hearing, county counsel reiterated arguments that transfer back to
Santa Cruz was in minor’s best interest. All three counsel for the children
2 No.L.’s father also filed a brief requesting transfer back to Santa
Cruz County on grounds that there was insufficient “time for the agency to
properly assess the family and make recommendations for reunification,
continued services or termination of services” and the Santa Cruz
Department was “familiar with this family since they have been working
with them since July of 2023.”
3
joined with the county, arguing it was in the children’s best interest for the
case to return to Santa Cruz. No.L.’s father’s counsel also agreed, stating
“This is a complicated case” and the “proper thing would be to send it back” to
the county that “has been working with them for a good 18 months or so.”
Mother’s counsel acknowledged the inter-agency protocol but reiterated
it was only “a recommendation,” “not the law.” Counsel went on to state
Mother felt she “received substandard care, services, attention, and legal
standards in Santa Cruz County,” and had “been discriminated against and
that there has been bias in that county against her.” This had “resulted in
injury to her” and she believed if the case was transferred back to Santa Cruz
“it will cause further injury to her.”
The court noted under California Rules of Court, rule 5.612(f), a
receiving county must accept a transfer, and where the county disagrees the
remedy is to appeal or hold a transfer-out hearing. Pursuant to California
Rules of Court, rule 5.610(e)(2), the court shall not transfer the case unless it
determines it will protect or further the best interest of the children. In this
case, the court stated the “protocols were designed with the big picture of the
best interest of the family and the children in mind,” and a “timeline was
established by the Child Welfare Directors in California indicating that a
case would not be recommended for transfer when there is a status review
hearing within 90 days from the date the transfer is requested.” The court
ruled the initial transfer to San Mateo “was not appropriate because the
FR12 hearing was within the 90 days from the transfer out.” This timeframe
“is not arbitrary. It represents the timeframe needed for a family to receive
a[n] appropriate assessment, including a safety assessment for the children
and an assessment for the recommendation as to whether or not to reunify
the children, continue services or terminate services.” The court thus
4
concluded it was in the children’s best interest to have Santa Cruz conduct
the 12-month review hearing and ordered the case transferred. The court
additionally stated that following the review hearing, San Mateo would
accept the case back “regardless of ICWA status.”
Mother appealed the transfer back to Santa Cruz.
The Santa Cruz court duly held the 12-month review hearing at the
end of January 2025 and ordered an additional six months of reunification
services. At the hearing, the Santa Cruz Department requested, and the
court ordered, that the matter be sent back to San Mateo County and set a
hearing date in San Mateo a week later.
At the San Mateo hearing, the court accepted the transfer and set an
interim hearing for April, and the 18-month review hearing for June.
As we have observed, the sole relief Mother seeks on appeal is reversal
of the San Mateo court’s order returning the case to the Santa Cruz court for
the 12-month hearing so that the case continues to be handled in the San
Mateo court.
“Various events occurring after a notice of appeal is filed can render the
appeal ‘moot’ and thus subject to dismissal on respondent’s motion.”
(Eisenberg et al., Cal. Practice Guide: Civil Appeals and Writs (The Rutter
Group 2025) ¶ 5:21.) “A case is moot when the decision of the reviewing court
‘can have no practical impact or provide the parties effectual relief.
[Citation.]’ [Citation.] ‘When no effective relief can be granted, an appeal is
moot and will be dismissed.’ (In re Jessica K. (2000) 79 Cal.App.4th 1313,
1315–1316 . . . , citing Eye Dog Foundation v. State Board of Guide Dogs for
the Blind (1967) 67 Cal.2d 536, 541.)” (MHC Operating Limited Partnership
v. City of San Jose (2003) 106 Cal.App.4th 204, 214.) “ ‘ “ ‘[T]he duty of this
court . . . is to decide actual controversies by a judgment which can be carried
5
into effect, and not to give opinions upon moot questions or abstract
propositions, or to declare principles or rules of law which cannot affect the
matter in issue in the case before it.’ ” [Citation.] . . . “[W]hen, pending an
appeal from the judgment of a lower court, and without any fault of the
[respondent], an event occurs which renders it impossible for this court, if it
should decide the case in favor of [appellant], to grant him [or her] any
effectual relief whatever, the court will not proceed to a formal judgment, but
will dismiss the appeal.” ’ ” (In re Jessica K., at p. 1316.)
Here, Mother has already obtained the relief she seeks on appeal—
namely, having the case returned to the San Mateo court—by virtue of the
Santa Cruz court’s January 2025 transfer order.
There are situations in which it is appropriate for an appellate court to
exercise its discretion to retain a moot appeal—for example, cases in which
the issue raised is of broad public interest and likely to recur (Eisenberg et
al., Cal. Practice Guide: Civil Appeals and Writs, supra, ¶ 5:32 [Discretion to
retain such an appeal is likely to be exercised “when the issue is ‘presented in
the context of a controversy so short-lived as to evade normal appellate
review.’ ”]; id., ¶ 5:33 [cases where “it appears the same controversy between
the parties is likely to recur]; id., ¶ 5:33.1 [cases where “a material question
remains for the court’s determination (such as the right to declaratory
relief)].) None of these exceptions apply here.
Mother nevertheless maintains her appeal should not be dismissed
because the transfers assertedly caused her harm due to “the twin effects of
easing the administrative burden on the agency at a time when it was
required by law to help [her] reunify with her children, and of unnecessarily
running the clock on the time allotted to mother by statute to complete that
reunification process.” This claim is simply not pertinent to whether her
6
appeal—which sought only reversal of the transfer order—has become moot.
Further, to the extent Mother may be suggesting she has not received
reasonable services, this is not the type of error that will “evade review.”
Indeed, in addition to the instant appeal, Mother has filed a petition for
extraordinary writ relief challenging the reasonableness of the services she
has been provided.3
DISPOSITION
The appeal is dismissed as moot.
3 On our own motion, we take judicial notice of case No. A175055.
(Evid. Code, §§ 452, 459.)
7
_________________________
Banke, Acting P. J.
We concur:
_________________________
Langhorne Wilson, J.
_________________________
Smiley, J.
A172290, San Mateo Human Services v. Ne.L.
8
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.