CourtListener 10793872•In re Martinez CA2/5
Full text
Filed 2/13/26 In re Martinez CA2/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FIVE
In re B345970
LUIS MARTINEZ (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. KA088341)
on
Habeas Corpus.
ORIGINAL PROCEEDINGS; petition for habeas corpus.
H. Clay Jacke II, Judge. Petition granted.
Eric R. Larson for Petitioner.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Charles C. Ragland, Chief
Assistant Attorney General, Susan Sullivan Pithey, Senior
Assistant Attorney General, Steven D. Matthews and Gary A.
Lieberman, Deputy Attorneys General for Respondent.
Petitioner Luis Martinez petitions for habeas relief under
People v. Chiu (2014) 59 Cal.4th 155 (Chiu), which held an aider
and abettor may not be convicted of first degree murder under
the natural and probable consequences doctrine. He contends,
and the People agree, the record does not establish beyond a
reasonable doubt he was convicted of first degree murder under
another, valid theory of liability. We grant the petition and
remand to the trial court so the People may decide whether to
retry petitioner on the first degree murder charge or accept a
reduction of the conviction to second degree murder.
FACTS
A. The Murder
On April 17, 2009, eighteen-year-old Le Blanc went to a
large party in Pomona with friends.1 The boys were not familiar
with Pomona. They learned about another party in Pomona
through a “party text.” They were not able to find the party, but
as they were driving they saw a bunch of kids parking cars and
walking down the street. The boys asked if there was a party and
were told there was, so they decided to park and go to the party.
The party was held at Leslie C.’s house. She asked her
adult cousin, Deborah M., to help her set up the party and to
arrange for security. Leslie C. wanted to exclude certain boys
from the party, including Martinez, Adam Delgado, Victor
1 The party was attended by teenagers mostly between the
ages of 13 and 19 years old, so we refer to the party-goers using
terms that describe minors. Martinez was 15 years old at the
time. No disrespect is intended.
2
Guillen, Edgar Cisneros, and “their . . . crowd” because they were
“troublemakers.” Deborah M.’s boyfriend, Joshua R., who worked
as a security guard at a nightclub, provided security along with
two other people. The party was held in Leslie C.’s back yard.
The kids entered through the front gate where security was
stationed. No one was allowed inside the house. Deborah M.
mostly stayed inside with her young son and Leslie C.’s mother.
Deborah M. was at the front gate talking to Joshua R.
when Le Blanc arrived. Le Blanc seemed cheerful and excited to
go to the party. Le Blanc was one of the few Black people there.
The majority of the party-goers were Hispanic. By the time
Le Blanc arrived, the backyard had become very crowded.
Martinez and the other boys that Leslie C. had intended to
exclude tried to enter through the front door of the house, but a
girl slammed the door shut. The boys went to look for another
entrance. Leslie C. called security, but security was unable to
find Martinez and the other boys.
Le Blanc tried to dance with several girls unsuccessfully. A
Hispanic boy who was wearing a jacket with “Pomona” written on
it walked up to Le Blanc. The boy pointed to a tattoo on his neck
and asked Le Blanc if he had seen it. Le Blanc told the boy he
did not want any problems and then walked away.
Later, Le Blanc was in the dance area of the backyard
surrounded by Martinez, Guillen, Cisneros, and Ralph Alfaro.
The boys started arguing with Le Blanc. The argument escalated
and Delgado punched Le Blanc in the face. Le Blanc pulled out a
gun and waved it around. Le Blanc then asked “if anyone wanted
to fuck with him now.” People began to run and yell “He has a
gun.”
3
Someone in the crowd yelled “He can’t shoot us all. Get
him.” Multiple people yelled “Get that [derogatory racial
epithet]!” and “Kill that [derogatory racial epithet]!” several
times. Delgado grabbed a piece of construction wood and shouted
“Fuck that [derogatory racial epithet]!” Le Blanc ran toward the
front gate. A large group of people, including Martinez, Delgado,
and Alfaro chased Le Blanc. The mob knocked Le Blanc down on
the front stairs, and punched and kicked him.
Deborah M. had seen Le Blanc waving the gun in the
backyard through the window. She was afraid for her son and
ran to the side door to lock it. Deborah M. initially saw
approximately 10 to 13 guys attacking Le Blanc. More people
were behind them, rushing forward to join the attack. Le Blanc
was hunched over on the front steps. He was on his knees
surrounded by a group of male Hispanics. Deborah M. testified
that “[t]hey were around him punching him, kicking him, just
beating the life out of him.” Martinez admitted that he was in
the group. He participated in the beating and punched Le Blanc
more than twice while Le Blanc was cowering on the stairs.
Deborah M. went outside, “because here’s this guy on the front
steps covering himself, and it’s just so many guys just beating the
life out of him.” She testified that they were yelling “Oh, get that
[derogatory racial epithet]. Get that [derogatory racial epithet].
Get that [derogatory racial epithet]. That’s what he gets. Get
him. Get him. Don’t let him get away.” “They were punching
him with closed fists, to the point where you could hear as they
were punching him the thud sounds. Like, when you hit
somebody really hard and it just makes that sound on flesh, you
could hear it. And they were just kicking and just beating him
really bad.” Deborah M. saw the mob stomping on Le Blanc.
4
Le Blanc had his hands over his head. Deborah M. could see Le
Blanc’s hands clearly. He was not holding the gun.
Deborah M. screamed for the mob to stop, but the beating
continued. She was able to push some people back and help
Le Blanc. The males were hitting her as she was trying to free
Le Blanc from the crowd. Leslie C.’s mother came outside and
tried to help Deborah M. One of the males swung his fist at
Deborah M.’s head. She moved her face out of the way and the
blow hit her arm and her aunt’s thigh. Deborah M. was able to
pull Le Blanc up and push the gate open. She screamed at
Le Blanc to run. The crowd pushed Deborah M. back. Le Blanc
looked exhausted, but he was able to run down the street. A
group of males, including Martinez, chased after him. Deborah
M. later identified for the police approximately 20 of the people
who were involved in the beating. All of the people she identified
were Hispanic males.
As Le Blanc fled, someone called Deborah M. a “[derogatory
racial epithet] lover” and another person threw a glass bottle at
her and hit her feet. Deborah M. testified, “I got scared, because
I thought that what had happened to [Le Blanc], they would start
doing to me. So I backed off.” She was afraid that the mob was
so angry that they would come back and turn on her after they
“got” Le Blanc. Deborah M. went to close and lock the gate so
that no one could get in or out. As she did so, she tripped over
the gun that Le Blanc had been waving in the back yard. Joshua
R. picked up the gun and took it away. Deborah M. saw a male
running back from the direction the mob had gone. He retrieved
what looked like a gun from a car parked across the street and
ran back toward the mob.
5
Sandra A. lived down the street from Leslie C. She and her
husband, Pablo A., heard screaming and looked out the window
to see what was happening. Sandra A. saw a group of 20 to 30
kids running in the street toward her house. They gathered in
one area and a fight broke out. Everyone in the group was
attacking one kid—Le Blanc—kicking and hitting him. Pablo A.
estimated that there was a group of 20 to 25 people beating
Le Blanc. Sandra A. testified, “They were . . . hitting him, just—
there was just so many of them, and again, it was just shocking
to see all that happening.” Le Blanc was lying on the ground and
appeared unconscious. Sandra A. saw a male pull out a gun and
shoot Le Blanc. The male got into a dark SUV and drove away.
Party-goer Arturo C. followed the mob down the street.
Arturo C. saw Alfaro knock Le Blanc to the ground. Le Blanc
was defenseless and unable to fight back. Le Blanc got “stomped”
by 15 to 20 people after he was on the ground. Arturo C. stole
Le Blanc’s shoes as Le Blanc was being beaten. He saw Delgado
stab Le Blanc in the chest. Earlier in the evening, Delgado had
shown Arturo C. a pocket knife and told him not to worry if
anything happened because he had the knife. As Arturo C. was
leaving he heard gunshots.
Deborah M. also heard a gunshot. She heard someone yell,
“Pomona, Pomona.” Several people were yelling, “ ‘They’re
coming back. They’re come back. They have a gun. They have a
gun.’ ” Girls were screaming and running.
When he arrived at the scene, City of Pomona Police Officer
Melvon Bird saw 30 to 40 kids running away. Le Blanc was lying
face down on the side of the road with his feet up on the sidewalk.
Le Blanc did not appear to be breathing and did not respond to
the officer. There was a bullet casing next to his head. Officer
6
Bird felt for a pulse and found none. He saw that there was blood
in Le Blanc’s ears and a puddle of blood under his head. The
officer called for paramedics.
B. Cause of Death and Injuries
Deputy Medical Examiner Dr. Lisa Scheinin of the Los
Angeles County Coroner’s Office determined that the cause of
Le Blanc’s death was a combination of stabbing and gunshot
wounds. He was stabbed three times, including a stab to the
heart. After the stabbing, Le Blanc was turned face down and
shot once through the back of the head. In addition to the
stabbing and gunshot wounds, Le Blanc suffered multiple head
injuries, including abrasions, contusions, and shallow lacerations.
His nasal bridge and ear cartilage were fractured. Dr. Scheinin
opined that Le Blanc likely suffered the injuries as a result of
being kicked in the head and stomped on the face. She opined
that it requires significant force to break cartilage.
C. Gang Evidence
City of Pomona Police Officer Greg Freeman testified that
the 12th Street gang (12th Street) is the largest Hispanic gang in
Pomona. Officer Freeman explained that the Hispanic gangs in
Pomona are “very territorial,” and that the party was within 12th
Street territory. 12th Street is notorious for its hatred of Black
people. The officer explained that members of a gang are people
who live for the gang. They have no other job and are focused on
bettering the gang at all times. Associates are people who have a
life outside the gang that may include a job or school but “when
7
they’re called upon by the gang, they drop everything” and go to
assist the gang. Tagging crews are bonded groups of younger
people who operate within a gang’s territory and are a source of
future recruits for the gang. Tagging crews commit crimes that
benefit the gang. The Tinto Killers (Tinto Killers) or TK is a
tagging crew that operates within 12th Street’s territory. “Tinto
Killers” means Black Killers. MBK is another tagging crew that
feeds into 12th Street. 12th Street engages in a wide variety of
criminal offenses; one of their major activities is murder. Gang
members increase respect for their gang by committing crimes. A
12th street member would garner the most respect for killing a
Black person. 12th Street is also known as “Pomona 12th Street”
and “The Sharkies Gang.” Their symbols include sharks, the
letter “P”, the number “12”, and “P-12.”
Given hypothetical facts that mirror this case and a prior
contact that Officer Freeman had with Martinez, Officer
Freeman opined that the person in the hypothetical was “at least
an associate” of the hypothetical gang. Guillen and Cisneros
were both members of 12th Street. Delgado was a member of
MBK in 2009, but belonged to 12th Street by the time of trial.
Alfaro was a member of Tinto Killers in 2009, and later became a
12th Street member.
Arturo C. also knew Alfaro to be a member of Tinto Killers.
He said that many people involved in the beating were members
of Tinto Killers.
D. Martinez’s Interview with Police
In an interview with police, Martinez initially said that he
did not go into the back yard when he arrived at the party
8
because there was a fight starting. After he was confronted with
information about his participation in the beating, Martinez was
more forthcoming.
Martinez confirmed that there was a Black male in the
dance area and that people around the Black male (Le Blanc)
were starting a fight. Delgado, Guillen, Cisneros, and Alfaro
were part of the group fighting with Le Blanc. Things became
heated and Le Blanc pulled out a gun. Delgado punched Le
Blanc in the face. Someone in the crowd yelled “He can’t shoot us
all. Get him.” Le Blanc ran for the gate.
Martinez, Delgado, and Alfaro gave chase. Le Blanc was
knocked down on the stairs, punched, and kicked. Martinez
admitted that he punched Le Blanc more than twice while
Le Blanc was cowering on the stairs. He described the beating in
the same terms that Deborah M. had—he said that Le Blanc was
kicked, punched, and “stomped out.”
Martinez admitted that he was part of the mob that chased
Le Blanc after he fled through the gate. Martinez, Alfaro,
Delgado, Cisneros, and Prado led the pack. Alfaro knocked Le
Blanc to the ground and the beating continued. Le Blanc
appeared to be unconscious to Martinez as Le Blanc’s eyes were
closing. Delgado stabbed Le Blanc twice in the upper torso.
Alfaro stood over Le Blanc and shot him once.
Martinez denied assaulting Le Blanc after he chased him
from the stairs. He told police that Delgado was a member of
12th Street and Alfaro was a Tinto Killer.
9
PROCEDURAL HISTORY
The People tried Martinez for first degree murder on two
theories—(1) direct aiding and abetting and (2) aiding and
abetting under the natural and probable consequences doctrine.
The People did not allege that Martinez stabbed or shot Le Blanc.
He was charged based on his role in the mass beating.
The jury found Martinez guilty of first degree murder. The
jury further found that the murder was committed for the benefit
of a criminal street gang (Pen. Code, § 186.22, subd. (b)(1)(C))2,
and that a principal personally and intentionally discharged a
firearm proximately causing the victim’s death (§ 12022.53,
subds. (d), (e)(1)). The trial court sentenced Martinez to 50 years
to life in state prison. Another panel of this court affirmed the
judgment.
Shortly after issuance of remittitur, our Supreme Court
held in Chiu, supra, 59 Cal.4th 155 that an aider and abettor
may not be convicted of first degree premeditated murder under
the natural and probable consequences doctrine. Alfaro and
Prado’s convictions, which were not yet final at the time, were
reversed under Chiu and their cases remanded to the trial court.
(People v. Prado et al. (Jan. 13, 2015, B243204 [nonpub. opn.].)
The People elected not to retry Alfaro and Prado, and their
convictions were reduced to second degree murder.
Martinez sought similar relief by way of a motion to recall
the remittitur. We denied the motion in an order noting
“[d]efendant remains free to litigate the instructional error
contention in a habeas corpus petition filed in the trial court.”
2 All further statutory references are to the Penal Code.
10
(People v. Martinez (Oct. 24, 2014, B242710) [nonpub. order].) No
such petition was filed.
In February 2019, Martinez petitioned to be resentenced
under former section 1170.95, now section 1172.6. The People
opposed the petition. The trial court appointed counsel, held an
evidentiary hearing pursuant to section 1172.6, subdivision
(d)(3), and denied the petition, finding the People had met their
burden of proving beyond a reasonable doubt that Martinez was
guilty of aiding and abetting implied malice murder. We
affirmed. (People v. Martinez (Apr. 22, 2025, B336031) [nonpub.
opn.].)
On May 7, 2025, petitioner filed a habeas petition seeking
relief under Chiu. In a return to our order to show cause why
relief should not be granted, the People conceded petitioner’s
conviction for first degree murder should be reversed under Chiu
and ask us to remand the matter to the trial court so the People
may retry the first degree murder charge or accept a reduction to
second degree murder. We agree and now grant the petition.
DISCUSSION
Our Supreme Court held in Chiu that “natural and
probable consequences liability cannot extend to first degree
premeditated murder because punishing someone for first degree
premeditated murder when that person did not actually
perpetrate or intend the killing is inconsistent with ‘reasonable
concepts of culpability.’ ” (Chiu, supra, 59 Cal.4th at p. 165.)
This holding is retroactive to convictions already final at the time
Chiu was decided. (In re Martinez (2017) 3 Cal.5th 1216, 1222.)
11
“When a trial court instructs a jury on two theories of guilt,
one of which was legally correct [e.g., direct aiding and abetting]
and one legally incorrect [i.e., natural and probable
consequences], reversal is required . . . unless we conclude beyond
a reasonable doubt that the jury based its verdict on the legally
valid theory that defendant directly aided and abetted the
premeditated murder.” (Chiu, supra, 59 Cal.4th at p. 167; see
also In re Lopez (2023) 14 Cal.5th 562, 568 [“a reviewing court
may hold the error harmless where it would be impossible, based
on the evidence, for a jury to make the findings reflected in its
verdict without also making the findings that would support a
valid theory of liability”].)
Although the attack was vicious, we cannot say beyond a
reasonable doubt the jury convicted Martinez of first degree
murder based on a direct aiding and abetting theory. In closing
arguments, the prosecutor relied heavily upon a natural and
probable consequences theory of liability, telling the jury that
Martinez “and all of the others who participated in the assault fit
squarely within the definition of natural and probable
consequences defined by the law” and that “[y]ou couldn’t get a
factual scenario more suited to the theory of natural and probable
consequences than this one.”
12
DISPOSITION
The petition for writ of habeas corpus is granted. On
remand, the People may elect to retry the first degree murder
charge or accept a reduction of the conviction to second degree
murder.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.
MOOR, J.
We concur:
BAKER, Acting P. J.
KIM (D.), J.
13
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.