CourtListener 10784105•People v. Trejo CA1/1
Full text
Filed 2/4/26 P. v. Trejo CA1/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or
ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
THE PEOPLE,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
A172755
v.
OSVALDO GARNICA TREJO, (Mendocino County
Super. Ct. No. 23CR02647)
Defendant and Appellant.
Defendant Osvaldo Garnica Trejo appealed from a contested probation
violation hearing and his counsel filed a brief identifying no arguable issues
and asking us to perform an independent review of the record under
People v. Wende (1979) 25 Cal.3d 436. Garnica Trejo was advised of the
opportunity to file a supplemental brief but did not do so. Having reviewed
the record and finding no arguable issues, we affirm.
I. BACKGROUND
In exchange for the suspended execution of a prison sentence and
placement on probation, Garnica Trejo pled no contest to robbery (Pen. Code
§ 211)1 and to “residential burglary” (§ 459). A presentence investigation
report prepared by the probation department, however, recommended against
a grant of probation given Garnica Trejo’s criminal history, presumptive
1 All further statutory references are to the Penal Code.
ineligibility for probation, and its assessment that Garnica Trejo was not an
adequate candidate for supervision.
In February 2024, the court followed the plea agreement and placed
Garnica Trejo on probation. Among other things, the accepted terms and
conditions of probation required Garnica Trejo to “totally abstain from
possessing and using alcohol,” marijuana, or any controlled substance (absent
a prescription). Garnica Trejo was required to attend AA and NA meetings
as directed by probation, to submit to an evaluation by a substance abuse
treatment specialist, and to follow any course of treatment that was
recommended. The court further ordered Garnica Trejo to complete
residential treatment, the length of which would be determined by the
treatment specialist.
In May 2024, the Mendocino County Probation Department filed a
petition alleging that Garnica Trejo violated the terms of probation.
Specifically, it was alleged that Garnica Trejo committed a new assault,
possessed controlled substances, and consumed alcohol on numerous
occasions and marijuana on one occasion.
A preliminary hearing was scheduled for Garnica Trejo’s new assault
case, which also served as the probation violation hearing. Before the
hearing began, Garnica Trejo admitted violating probation by consuming
alcohol and marijuana in April 2024 and consuming alcohol and testing
positive for alcohol in May 2024. During the hearing, a prosecution witness
testified he was approached and “maybe nicked” by someone with a 19-inch
knife. But the witness could not identify Garnica Trejo as the person who
wielded the knife and the court therefore found insufficient evidence that he
committed an assault. The case was continued to another date for sentencing
on the probation violation hearing.
2
Garnica Trejo submitted a report prepared by Dr. Veronica Sanchez
Varela, a bilingual psychologist. At the sentencing hearing, his attorney
argued that he should be kept on probation and referred to behavioral health
court. The attorney emphasized Garnica Trejo’s “odd” behavior during the
underlying offenses,2 the fact that he admitted using marijuana and alcohol
in violation of probation, and the psychologist’s belief that he suffers from
“some kind of schizophrenic spectrum disorder.”
The prosecutor disagreed, citing Garnica Trejo’s lengthy criminal
record, his unwillingness to participate in treatment, and his noncompliance
with the current probation terms. He characterized Garnica Trejo as a public
safety risk. The probation department also recommended execution of the
suspended prison sentence based on Garnica Trejo’s 22 criminal convictions
and history of poor performance on formal probation and mandatory
supervision.
The trial court focused on Garnica Trejo’s lengthy criminal record
“going back 20 years,” his current probation performance, and the report
prepared by Dr. Sanchez Varela. The court was concerned about the report’s
accuracy. Dr. Sanchez Varela did not identify the basis for her diagnosis and
acknowledged it was “only as accurate as Mr. Garnica Trejo is forthcoming
and honest in his answers.” Furthermore, the report did not indicate that Dr.
Sanchez Varela had administered any testing. The court stated it did not
want to rely on diagnoses formed only in response to information provided by
2 In the underlying offense, Garnica Trejo was alleged to have
repeatedly entered the home of a stroke victim without consent
(including when the victim was present inside) to take and prepare
food. On one of these occasions, Garnica Trejo aimed a black
“handgun” at the victim to take money. The handgun was later
determined to be a BB gun revolver.
3
Garnica Trejo. Nevertheless, the court allowed that if there were “some valid
mental health issues, the Court needs to consider that in determining what
the appropriate sentence should be.” Accordingly, over the prosecutor’s
objection, the court did not sentence Garnica Trejo to prison. Instead, he was
committed to the Department of Corrections for a diagnostic evaluation
pursuant to section 1203.03.3
The trial court’s commitment order explained that Garnica Trejo had
“presented evidence for the first time at judgment and sentencing that he
may be suffering from previously undiagnosed mental illnesses, including
unspecified schizophrenia and an unspecified depressive disorder that may
mitigate his culpability at the time of the offenses in light of recent changes
to Penal Code section 1385. The Court believes the proper disposition in this
matter requires consideration of the diagnostic and treatment services
available at the California Department of Corrections.”
In December 2024, the Department of Corrections returned a
recommendation that Garnica Trejo be sentenced to prison. As part of its
evaluation, Garnica Trejo had received a mental health screening, but
“screened negative” and was thus “not included in the prison’s mental health
services.” The trial court concluded that the Department did not believe
Garnica Trejo would be “a good candidate to be placed back on probation.”
3 Section 1203.03, subdivision (a), allows the court, if it
determines that a “just disposition of the case requires [a] diagnosis
and treatment services as can be provided at a diagnostic facility of the
Department of Corrections, [to] order that defendant be placed
temporarily in such facility for a period not to exceed 90 days, with the
further provision in such order that the Director of the Department of
Corrections report to the court his diagnosis and recommendations
concerning the defendant within the 90-day period.”
4
At the continued sentencing hearing, defense counsel indicated there
was no legal cause to delay sentencing. Garnica Trejo again asked to be
maintained on probation with terms including abstinence from all
substances, substance abuse treatment, and individual therapy to address
childhood trauma, impulse control, and proactive decision-making, among
other things. At that time, he was already on the waitlist for one inpatient
program and had “a bed waiting for him” at another. Additionally, Garnica
Trejo’s counsel commented on the health issues he faced as another reason to
continue him on probation.
The trial court revoked probation and executed the previously
suspended sentence to the Department of Corrections. For the robbery
conviction, the court sentenced Garnica Trejo to the middle term of four
years. For the residential burglary conviction, the court imposed a
consecutive one year, four-month sentence. Against this aggregate prison
sentence of five years, four months, the court credited Garnica Trejo for days
he had already served and earned. It reserved direct victim restitution, set
restitution fines at the statutory minimum, and imposed the previously
stayed probation revocation fee. It also stayed the court security fee and the
criminal conviction assessment. Lastly, the court advised Garnica Trejo of
his appellate rights.
II. DISCUSSION
After examining the entire record, we are satisfied that no
arguable issues exist, and that Garnica Trejo’s attorney has complied with
the responsibilities of counsel. (People v. Kelly (2006) 40 Cal.4th 106, 125–
126; People v. Wende, supra, 25 Cal.3d at pp. 441–442.)
III. DISPOSITION
The judgment of the trial court is affirmed.
5
_________________________
SMILEY, J.
WE CONCUR:
_________________________
HUMES, P. J.
_________________________
BANKE, J.
People v. Trejo / A172755
6
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.