Tenchil v. Scott CA2/3

CourtListener 10782017CalctappJan 30, 2026

Full text

Filed 1/30/26 Tenchil v. Scott CA2/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION THREE

JOSE LUIS TENCHIL et al., B338663

Plaintiffs and Appellants, Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No.
v. 20STCV26672

ZACHARY SCOTT,

Defendant and Respondent.

APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County, Lynne M. Hobbs, Judge. Affirmed.

Law Offices of Andy Basseri and Andy Basseri for Plaintiffs
and Appellants.

Law Office of Jeffrey Cabot Myers and Jeffrey Cabot Myers
for Defendant and Respondent.
_________________________
Plaintiffs Jose Luis Tenchil (Jose) and Luis Daniel Tenchil
(Daniel) appeal from the trial court’s order denying Jose’s motion
to set aside/vacate the dismissal of their complaint under Code
of Civil Procedure1 section 473, subdivision (b) (section 473(b)).
We affirm.
BACKGROUND
In July 2020, plaintiffs filed a personal injury complaint
against defendant Zachary Scott arising from a July 2018
car accident. They did not serve defendant with the summons
and complaint until August 2022. Defendant filed an answer
(a general denial with affirmative defenses) and served initial
discovery requests on each plaintiff—form interrogatories,
special interrogatories, and demands for identification and
inspection of documents. The court set a final status conference
for August 23, 2023, and a trial date for September 6, 2023.2
Neither plaintiff responded to defendant’s discovery
requests, nor did their counsel respond to defense counsel’s
meet and confer letter. Accordingly, on November 18, 2022,
defendant filed concurrent motions to compel each plaintiff’s
responses to the unanswered discovery requests and for
sanctions. Plaintiffs did not oppose the motions. The court
granted the motions to compel as to Jose on March 29, 2023,
and as to Daniel on March 30, 2023. The court denied the
requests for sanctions. On April 10, 2023, defendant’s counsel
served a notice of ruling on plaintiffs’ counsel stating plaintiffs

1 Statutory references are to the Code of Civil Procedure.
2 As of August 5, 2022, plaintiffs’ case was assigned to
Department 30, the Honorable Jill Feeney presiding.

2
were to serve responses to the outstanding discovery within
15 days.
After receiving no response, defendant filed motions
for terminating sanctions on April 25, 2023, asking the court
to dismiss plaintiffs’ complaint. Plaintiffs did not file written
oppositions to the motions, but their counsel appeared at the
June 13, 2023 hearing. After hearing argument, the court3
granted the motions, reasoning:
“Plaintiffs’ failure [sic] to obey the Court’s March
29 and 30, 2023 orders. Plaintiffs did not respond
to Defendant’s requests and have now delayed
responding to the discovery requests for nine months.
It appears Plaintiffs are no longer interested in
litigating this matter as no opposition was filed
against this motion. Therefore the Court finds
terminating sanctions proper.”
On June 16, 2023, defendant’s counsel served notice of the
court’s ruling on plaintiffs’ counsel. Plaintiffs did not move
for reconsideration.
Although the court granted terminating sanctions, it
did not enter an order of dismissal in the “court system.” As
a result, the final status conference and trial dates apparently
were not vacated. Neither side appeared for the August 23, 2023
final status conference. On that date, the court vacated/took off
calendar the final status conference, noted the September 6, 2023
trial date remained on calendar, and ruled it “may dismiss the
case pursuant to CCP Section 581(b)(3)” if the parties did not

3 By this time, the Honorable Lynne M. Hobbs had been
assigned to Department 30.

3
appear on the trial date. The court ordered no further notice
was required, as counsel/the parties had received notice of
those dates when they originally were set.
On September 6, 2023, the Honorable Steven A. Ellis
temporarily presided over Department 30 matters in Judge
Hobbs’s absence. As no party had appeared for trial, or
communicated with the court, Judge Ellis ordered plaintiffs’
complaint dismissed without prejudice. The clerk served
plaintiffs’ counsel with the minute order. Judge Hobbs signed
the order of dismissal. The clerk served it on plaintiffs’ counsel.
Almost six months later, on March 1, 2024, Jose4 filed a
motion to vacate or set aside the dismissal under the mandatory
relief provision of section 473(b) along with plaintiffs’ attorney’s
affidavit of fault. Plaintiffs’ attorney declared he failed to
appear at the September 6, 2023 trial date because—due to a
calendaring error—he mistakenly believed the trial date was
October 6. The motion, however, stated the court had “dismissed
the case on September 6, 2023 due to terminating sanctions
due to plaintiff not providing discovery responses.” Relying on
Rodriguez v. Brill,5 the motion argued the mandatory relief
provision of section 473(b) applied to a judgment of dismissal
following the granting of terminating sanctions due to

4 It appears from the appellate record that only Jose brought
the section 473(b) motion. As Daniel did not join in the motion,
he has no standing to challenge the court’s denial of it. (See
§ 902.) His appeal is therefore dismissed.
5 Neither the moving papers, nor the opening brief on appeal,
include a citation to this case. It is Rodriguez v. Brill (2015) 234
Cal.App.4th 715 (Brill).

4
“inexcusable failures of plaintiff’s attorney.” The motion
asserted, “All verified discovery responses have already been
emailed to defense counsel.” Attached to counsel’s declaration
were the separate discovery responses of Jose and Daniel to
defendant’s form interrogatories (set 1), demand for production
of documents (set 1), and special interrogatories (set 1)—all
signed by plaintiffs’ counsel on February 28, 2024. The appellate
record also includes two caption pages entitled “Exhibit List,”
with several documents attached to each, but no actual “list”;
Jose’s verifications to his discovery responses—each signed
February 29, 2024; and Daniel’s verifications to his discovery
responses—each signed “February, 2024.”6
Defendant opposed Jose’s motion. Defendant argued the
case had been dismissed on June 13, 2023 with the granting
of his motion for terminating sanctions. The motion thus
was untimely, having been filed more than six months later.
Defendant also argued there was no mistake, inadvertence,
surprise, or excusable neglect. Finally, defendant argued he
would be prejudiced if the court granted the motion, noting the
accident happened in July 2018, plaintiffs had ignored the court’s
order to respond to defendant’s discovery, and they otherwise had
failed to pursue their case. Jose did not file a reply to defendant’s
opposition.
The court (Judge Hobbs) heard Jose’s motion on April 3,
2024 and took the matter under submission. On April 23, the
court denied the motion. The court acknowledged it had granted
defendant’s motion for terminating sanctions on June 13, 2023,

6 The verifications were appended to the second “Exhibit
List” caption page.

5
but had “erred in not dismissing the complaint in the court
system and in allowing the matter to progress to the jury trial
date approximately three months later.” The court continued:
“Thus, on September 6, 2023, when no
parties appeared for jury trial, the Court dismissed
the entire action. Instead of recognizing that
terminating sanctions had already disposed of the
case, the court stated that the dismissal was without
prejudice due to no parties appearing for jury trial.
“What Plaintiffs [sic] seek to set aside is
the ruling the Court made granting the terminating
sanctions. They are too late. Plaintiff mistakenly
argues that the terminating sanction was entered
on September 6, 2023. However, the terminating
sanction dismissing Defendant Scott, the only
defendant in this matter, was entered on June 13,
2023. The court agrees that a motion under CCP
section 473 would be available to Plaintiff, but only
if it was timely filed. [Citations.]
“While Plaintiffs are not too late to move to
set aside the order of dismissal on September 6, 2023,
it would be a futile act for the Court to grant such
a request. The complaint would still have been
dismissed. The Court, therefore, denies the motion.”
Plaintiffs filed a notice of appeal on May 7, 2024. In
response to this court’s inquiry, plaintiffs made clear their appeal
was timely as to the April 23, 2024 order denying the section
473(b) motion to set aside/vacate the dismissal of their complaint

6
—an appealable order under section 904.1, subdivision (a)(2).7
(Austin v. Los Angeles Unified School Dist. (2016) 244
Cal.App.4th 918, 927, fn. 6.)
DISCUSSION
Plaintiffs challenge the court’s denial of Jose’s motion to
set aside or vacate the dismissal of their complaint under the
mandatory provision of section 473(b). That provision provides:
“[T]he court shall, whenever an application for relief is made
no more than six months after entry of judgment, is in proper
form, and is accompanied by an attorney’s sworn affidavit
attesting to the attorney’s mistake, inadvertence, surprise, or
neglect, vacate any . . . dismissal entered against the attorney’s
client, unless the court finds that the default or dismissal was
not in fact caused by the attorney’s mistake, inadvertence,
surprise, or neglect.” (§ 473(b), italics added.)8 “The six-month
limit is mandatory; a court has no authority to grant relief under
section 473, subdivision (b), unless an application is made within

7 Plaintiffs’ notice of appeal does not state the date of
the appealed judgment or order. It checks the box indicating
the appeal is from a judgment of dismissal under sections
581d, 583.250, 583.360, or 583.430. Plaintiffs’ corrected case
information statement indicates the motion to set aside/vacate
dismissal was denied on April 23, 2024. The May 7, 2024
notice of appeal thus was timely.
8 In the case of a dismissal due to terminating sanctions,
an application for mandatory relief would be in “proper form” “if
verified discovery responses [were] served on or before the motion
for relief is served.” (Brill, supra, 234 Cal.App.4th at p. 729.)
As discussed, Jose presented no evidence that counsel had served
defense counsel with plaintiffs’ verified discovery responses.

7
the six-month period.” (Arambula v. Union Carbide Corp. (2005)
128 Cal.App.4th 333, 340.) Mandatory relief is available only
where the attorney caused the dismissal. (Martin Potts &
Associates, Inc. v. Corsair, LLC (2016) 244 Cal.App.4th 432,
439; Jimenez v. Chavez (2023) 97 Cal.App.5th 50, 63 (Jimenez)
[trial court “is only required to grant a motion for relief under
the mandatory relief provision of section 473(b)” if it is timely
filed, in proper form, and “accompanied by an attorney affidavit
attesting to, and showing that the challenged order was taken
due to, attorney fault”].) The moving party bears the burden
of establishing entitlement to mandatory relief. (Rodriguez v.
WNT, Inc. (2025) 116 Cal.App.5th 791, 803.) “Whether section
473, subdivision (b)’s requirements have been satisfied in any
given case is a question we review for substantial evidence
where the evidence is disputed and de novo where it is
undisputed.” (Martin Potts, at p. 437.)
Plaintiffs’ attorney attested it was his fault—his
miscalendaring of the trial date—that he and his clients did
not appear on September 6, 2023, and it was that failure to
appear that led to the dismissal of plaintiffs’ complaint.9 As the
trial court noted, Jose’s motion to set aside the September 6 order

9 On appeal, plaintiffs assert—without citing to the record—
their attorney “thought that discovery responses had already
been provided at the last hearing earlier as well.” We see no such
statement in counsel’s declaration that is part of the appellate
record. We do not consider it. (See Kern County Dept. of Child
Support Services v. Camacho (2012) 209 Cal.App.4th 1028, 1038
[arguments not raised in the trial court are forfeited on appeal];
Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.204(a)(1)(C) [references in an appellate
brief to matter in the record must include citation to the volume
and page number of the record where the matter may be found].)

8
of dismissal was not untimely—he filed it within six months of
that order, on March 1, 2024. Plaintiffs, however, never moved
to set aside the court’s June 13, 2023 order granting defendant’s
motion for terminating sanctions—i.e., the dismissal of plaintiffs’
complaint. Jose’s current motion was untimely as to that ruling,
having been filed outside the mandatory six-month window.
In any event, as the court found, setting aside the September 6,
2023 order of dismissal due to counsel’s failure to appear would
have been futile—the court still would have had to dismiss
plaintiffs’ complaint based on the unchallenged June 13, 2023
order. Accordingly, plaintiffs have failed to demonstrate they
were prejudiced by the trial court’s purported error in denying
the section 473(b) motion to set aside or vacate the September 6,
2023 order of dismissal. (See Cal. Const., art. VI, § 13; Cassim v.
Allstate Ins. Co. (2004) 33 Cal.4th 780, 800 [error is not reversible
unless it is reasonably probable a more favorable result would
have been reached absent the error]; see also Century Surety Co.
v. Polisso (2006) 139 Cal.App.4th 922, 963 [reviewing court
“cannot presume prejudice and will not reverse the judgment
in the absence of an affirmative showing there was a miscarriage
of justice”].)
Plaintiffs argue they “should not suffer harm and
prejudice” due to the court’s error in failing to enter the dismissal
in the court system after it granted defendant’s motion for
terminating sanctions, asserting they relied on the court system
having accurate information. The point is not well-taken.
Defendant gave plaintiffs’ counsel notice of entry of the order
granting the requested terminating sanctions. They took no
action to set that order aside nor do they challenge the validity
of that order on appeal.

9
Plaintiffs also appear to contend—without citing to
any authority—Jose’s motion was timely because, even though
the court granted the terminating sanctions in June 2023, the
date of the dismissal controls for purposes of mandatory relief
under section 473(b). Plaintiffs are correct that the mandatory
provision of section 473(b) can apply to an order granting
dismissal as a terminating sanction. (See Rodriguez v. WNT,
Inc., supra, 116 Cal.App.5th at p. 806 [mandatory relief provision
of section 473(b) applies to order granting defense motion for
dismissal as a terminating sanction only if plaintiff failed
to oppose the motion]; Brill, supra, 234 Cal.App.4th at p. 726
[mandatory relief under section 473(b) “encompasses dismissals
entered as a terminating sanction for discovery abuse”].) Even
if the trial court should have construed the September 6, 2023
order of dismissal as having been entered due to its earlier order
granting terminating sanctions, substantial evidence nonetheless
supported the court’s denial of Jose’s motion. (See Rodas v.
Spiegel (2001) 87 Cal.App.4th 513, 517 [appellate court does
not “review the validity of the trial court’s reasoning but only
the propriety of the ruling itself”].)
The court granted defendant’s motion for terminating
sanctions after plaintiffs failed to respond to defendant’s
discovery requests and to comply with the court’s order
compelling their responses. Plaintiffs’ attorney, however, never
attested that his clients’ failure to respond to the discovery,
or to the motion for terminating sanctions, was due to his—
rather than their—“mistake, inadvertence, surprise, or neglect.”
(§ 473(b); cf. Jimenez, supra, 97 Cal.App.5th at pp. 57–58 [party
is entitled to mandatory relief under § 473(b) even when attorney
error is inexcusable if attorney’s affidavit “shows the error was

10
the fault of the attorney rather than the client”].) Counsel took
the blame only for plaintiffs’ nonappearance at the “trial” date.
His affidavit thus did not show the order granting terminating
sanctions—what plaintiffs argue resulted in the September 6
dismissal—was his fault. Accordingly, Jose’s motion failed to
establish he satisfied the requirements for mandatory relief
under section 473(b) from the September 6, 2023 order of
dismissal, even if it were based on the court’s earlier order
granting terminating sanctions.
DISPOSITION
The trial court’s April 23, 2024 order is affirmed.
Respondent is entitled to his costs on appeal.

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

EGERTON, J.

We concur:

EDMON, P. J.

HANASONO, J.

11

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.