Williams v. Wolfe CA2/7

CourtListener 10774493CalctappJan 14, 2026

Full text

Filed 1/14/26 Williams v. Wolfe CA2/7
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION SEVEN

BRIAN WILLIAMS, B328835

Plaintiff and Appellant, (Los Angeles County Super.
Ct. No. 20STCV29187)
v.

UMILTA MARIA WOLFE et al.,

Defendants and Respondents.

APPEAL from orders and a judgment of the Superior Court
of Los Angeles County, Bruce G. Iwasaki, Judge. Dismissed in
part and affirmed in part.
Brian Williams, in pro. per., for Plaintiff and Appellant.
No appearance for Defendants and Respondents.

__________________________
Brian Williams1 appeals from the trial court’s judgment
dismissing his civil lawsuit against over 30 defendants and from
the subsequent order denying his motion to vacate the judgment.
The court dismissed the case due to Williams’s failure to serve
any of the defendants with the complaint for over two years after
he filed suit. The court later concluded Williams failed to show
he was entitled to discretionary relief from that dismissal under
Code of Civil Procedure section 473, subdivision (b).2 Because we
conclude the appeal from the judgment is untimely, we dismiss
that appeal for lack of jurisdiction. We affirm the order denying
the motion to vacate.

1 Williams filed his case under the name Mr. BW. The trial
court asked Williams under oath if his real name was Brian
Williams, and Williams initially “plead[ed] the 5th amendment
and refuse[d] to answer the Court’s question regarding his true
name.” At a later hearing, however, Williams stated “Mr.
Williams” was his “true name.” Because Williams did not obtain
court authorization to appear under the pseudonym Mr. BW, we
refer to him by his real name. (See, e.g., Roe v. Smith (2025)
116 Cal.App.5th 227, 238 [“ ‘Outside of cases where anonymity is
expressly permitted by statute, litigating by pseudonym should
occur “only in the rarest of circumstances.” ’ ”]; Santa Ana Police
Officers Assn. v. City of Santa Ana (2025) 109 Cal.App.5th 296,
306 [“Unless a statute specifically allows a plaintiff to sue under
a pseudonym, a plaintiff must obtain court authorization in order
to appear anonymously.”].)
2 Undesignated statutory references are to the Code of Civil
Procedure.

2
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

Williams filed suit on August 3, 2020, alleging in summary
fashion a string of claims against numerous defendants for “Anti-
Retaliation - Retaliatory Eviction ([Civ. Code] § 1942.5); Unlawful
forcible entry detainer action (in violation of [Code Civ. Proc.]
§§ 1159 and 1160); [Civ. Code] § 789.3 Illegal Removable of
Property; Violation of American with Disabilities Act; Intentional
Infliction of Distress; Mental Anguish; Intentional Infliction of
Emotional Tranquility; etc . . . .” (Boldface and italics omitted.)
The trial court set an order to show cause (OSC) hearing for
December 2020 for Williams’s failure to file proofs of service
showing service of the summons and complaint on the
defendants. No one appeared at the December hearing, which
the court continued to February 2021.
Williams appeared in propria persona at the February 2021
hearing, but he had not yet served the defendants. At his
request, the court continued the OSC hearing until June. At the
June hearing, Williams represented he still needed more time to
serve the defendants, and the court once again continued the
OSC hearing to September 2021.
On the September 2021 hearing date, Williams filed an
amended complaint naming over 30 defendants,3 and asserting

3 Defendants in the amended complaint are: “UMILTA
MARIA WOLFE, aka: Umilta M. Wolfe, an individual; UMILTA
MARIA WOLFE, (Parent/GrandParent) as Trustee of the
UMILTA MARIA WOLFE REVOCABLE TRUST DATED
MARCH 5, 2017, individually; UMILTA MARIA WOLFE, as
Trustee of the UMILTA MARIA WOLFE LIVING TRUST
DATED MAY 26, 2010, individually; UMILTA MARIA WOLFE,

3
as Trustee of the UMILTA WOLFE REVOCABLE LIVING
TRUST DATED MAY 26, 2010, individually; UMILTA MARIA
WOLFE aka: UMILTA M. WOLFE, an individual and in her
official capacity as Trustee of the UMILTA MARIA WOLFE
REVOCABLE TRUST DATED MARCH 5, 2017, individually;
UMILTA MARIA WOLFE, individually, and in her official
capacity as Trustee, Grantor/Grantee and OWNER of 827 Austin
Avenue, Inglewood, California 90302, individually; 827 AUSTIN
AVENUE aka: APN No. # and/or Parcel No. 4017-021-077, Lot 7
of Tract No. 17443, in the City of Inglewood, State of CA.,
individually; UMILTA MARIA WOLFE, individually and in her
official capacity as Trustee, Grantor/Grantee and OWNER of
4161 Sutro Avenue, Los Angeles, California 90008, individually;
4161 SUTRO AVENUE aka: APN No. # and/or Parcel No. 5023-
019-009, the NORTHERLY 4 Feet of Lot 196 and all of Lot 197 of
Tract No. 9741, in the City of Los Angeles, individually; UMILTA
MARIA WOLFE, individually and in her official capacity and
SHELLY-ANN ELIZABETH BOURNE, individually and in her
official capacity as Trustees Grantees, Grantors and OWNERS of
1055 W. 102nd, Street, Los Angeles, California 90044, as
individuals; 1055 W. 102nd, STREET aka: APN No. # and/or
Parcel No. 6060-026-020, Lot 86 of Tract No 2752 in the County
of Los Angeles, individually; UMILTA MARIA WOLFE,
individually and in her official capacity as Trustee,
Grantor/Grantee and OWNER of 5132 S. Wilton Place, Los
Angeles, California 90062, individually; 5132 WILTON PLACE
aka: APN No. # and/or Parcel No. 5015-011-018, Lot 261 of
Chesterfield Square, in the City of Los Angeles, County of Los
Angeles, as per Map Recorded in Book 21 Pages 90 and 91 of
Maps, individually; SHELLY-ANN ELIZABETH BOURNE,
individually and in her official capacity and UMILTA MARIA
WOLFE, individually and in her official capacity as Trustees,
Grantor, Grantees and OWNERS of 5930-5934 1/2 Arlington
Avenue, Los Angeles, California 90043, as individuals; 5930-5934

4
1/2 ARLINGTON AVENUE aka: APN No. # and/or Parcel No.
4005-027-008, Lot 8 and the Northerly 20 Feet of Lot 9 in block 8
of Tract No. 5347, in the City of Los Angeles, County of Los
Angeles, as per Map Recorded in book 57 page 31 of maps,
individually; SHELLY ANN ELIZABETH WADALLEY, aka:
SHELLY-ANN ELIZABETH BOURNE, an individually;
SHELLY-ANN ELIZABETH BOURNE aka: SHELLYANN
ELIZABETH WADALLEY, an individually; SHELLYANN
WADALLEY as Trustee of the SHELLY ANN WADALLEY
REVOCABLE LIVING TRUST DATED MAY 26, 2010,
individually; SHELLY ANN E. WADALLEY as Trustee of the
SHELLYANN WADALLEY LIVING TRUSTED DATED MAY 26,
2010, individually; SHELLYANN E. WADALLEY aka: SHELLY
ANN ELIZABETH WADALLEY, individually and in her official
capacity as Trustee of the SHELLYANN WADALLEY
REVOCABLE LIVING TRUST DATED MAY 26, 2010,
individually; SHELLYANN ELIZABETH BOURNE, as Trustee of
the SHELLYANN BOURNE TRUST DATED APRIL 11, 2018,
individually; SHELLY-ANN ELIZABETH BOURNE, individually
and in her official capacity as Trustee of the SHELLY-ANN
BOURNE TRUST DATED APRIL 11, 2018, individually;
SHELLY-ANN ELIZABETH BOURNE, individually and in her
official capacity as Trustee, Grantor, Grantee and OWNER of
8820 S. Gramercy Place, Los Angeles, California 90047,
individually; 8820 S. GRAMERCY AVENUE aka: APN No. #
and/or Parcel No. 6036-007-029, Lot 62 of Tract No 11169 in the
City of Los Angeles, individually; KERWIN WADALLEY, an
individual; KEVIN JOSEPH WADALLEY, an individual;
KATELYN RANE WADALLEY, an individual; JESHELL A.
BERNARDEZ aka: JESHELL ASHLEY BERNARDEZ, an
individual; WADALLEY HANDYMAN SERVICE aka:
WADALLEY’S HANDYMAN SERVICES, individually; JUANITA
L. JAMES, individually; and DOES 1 thru 200, inclusive.”
(Boldface and italics omitted.)

5
45 causes of action that included unlawful detainer, conversion,
fraudulent misrepresentation, invasion of privacy, and numerous
statutory and constitutional violations, for which he sought
damages in excess of $999 million. At the hearing, the court
noted Williams had filed an amended complaint. It then
discharged the OSC and set a case management conference for
February 1, 2022, ordering Williams to give notice to the
defendants. On January 31, 2022, Williams filed an “emergency
notice for continuance” due to “unforeseen medical issues.” At
the hearing the following day, Williams did not appear. The
court continued the case management conference to August 2022
and set another OSC for that date, stating Williams “must show
cause why [his] case should not be dismissed for [his] failure to
file a proof of service of the summons and complaints on
defendants.”
At the hearing on August 4, 2022, Williams did not appear.
The court found Williams had failed to timely serve the
defendants and dismissed the case with prejudice under section
583.410, subdivision (a), and California Rules of Court, rule
3.110.4

4 Section 583.410, subdivision (a), gives the court discretion
to “dismiss an action for delay in prosecution pursuant to this
article on its own motion . . . if to do so appears to the court
appropriate under the circumstances of the case.” Section
583.420, subdivision (a)(1), permits a court to dismiss an action
for such a delay in prosecution if service has not been made
within two years after the action is commenced, as was the case
here. California Rules of Court, rule 3.110(b) provides that a
complaint “must be served on all named defendants and proofs of
service on those defendants must be filed with the court within

6
In January 2023 Williams filed a “motion to set
aside/vacate dismissal, due to a neurology medical issues [sic]”
under section 473 and rule 3.1332(b)(c)(2), which governs motions
for continuances. Williams stated he had experienced a head
trauma and had been hospitalized, his mother suffered her fifth
stroke, he had been homeless, he had experienced a mini-stroke
and then an ischemic stroke, and he was assaulted. Williams
explained he missed the August 4, 2022 hearing because he had
an appointment with his neurologist.
Following the hearing on February 10, 2023 at which
Williams was present and provided additional oral arguments,
the court denied the motion to vacate dismissal. The court noted
Williams could only seek discretionary relief under section 473,
subdivision (b), because he was not represented by counsel. The
court stated it was “sympathetic” to Williams’s medical ailments,
including his August 2021 head injury leading to a concussion,
which required numerous doctors’ visits between September 2021
and February 2022, his March 2022 mini-stroke and subsequent
ischemic stroke, his mother passing away in August 2022, and
his reported assault in December 2022. However, the court noted
Williams “has not shown how any of those issues interfered with
his ability to attempt service on the defendants between August
2020 and August 2022.” The court observed Williams appeared
at the February, June, and September 2021 hearings. The court
acknowledged Williams “attended a medical visit on August 4,
2022, the day this case was dismissed, but the problems in this
case date back to 2020.”

60 days after the filing of the complaint.” Subsequent references
to rules are to the California Rules of Court.

7
With respect to Williams’s health issues, the court
concluded the showing was insufficient for relief under section
473. Williams’s declaration provided no details on the “severity
or length” of Williams’s condition and many of the attached
medical reports contained doctors’ notes that “merely indicate[d]
the visit was for fatigue or itchy skin,” “generalized follow-up
visits after the concussion,” or “sleep difficulties.”
Even assuming Williams’s medical condition was
significant, however, the court observed service of the summons
and complaint could be conducted by someone who was not a
party. The court stated, “It is unclear how [Williams’s] medical
difficulties precluded him from arranging for service on the
defendants. He does not provide any details on any attempts or
even efforts engaged in thus far to effect service, such as hiring a
process server or conducting due diligence on defendants’
locations.” The court stated Williams had raised the “the
difficulties of service stemming from the [COVID-19] pandemic”
but had offered no evidence of his attempts to serve the
defendants, and Williams had not shown why he was unable to
effectuate service when other litigants were able to do so.
Williams appealed. His notice of appeal states he is
appealing from the judgment, but he lists the date of the order he
is appealing from as February 10, 2023, which is the date of the
order denying his motion to vacate. Williams’s case information
statement and his notice designating the record on appeal both
state that he is appealing from the February 10, 2023 order.
Construing his notice of appeal liberally, as we must (In re
Joshua S. (2007) 41 Cal.4th 261, 272; rule 8.100(a)(2)), we treat
Williams’s appeal as from both the August 2022 judgment and
from the February 2023 order denying his motion to vacate.

8
On March 13, 2023 Williams filed a motion for
reconsideration, based on largely the same allegations as the
motion to vacate, but adding information that he had been paying
a process server to attempt service multiple times and submitting
a declaration from that process server.
In May 2023 the court denied Williams’s motion for
reconsideration. The court concluded the motion was untimely
and failed to show new facts, circumstances, or law.
At the end of May 2023, Williams filed a motion for
reconsideration of the court’s May order, which the court also
denied.

DISCUSSION

A. Applicable Law and Standard of Review
Section 473, subdivision (b), “provides ‘two distinct
provisions for relief’ from default or dismissal. [Citation.] One
affords discretionary relief, and the other makes relief
mandatory.” (Jackson v. Kaiser Foundation Hospitals, Inc. (2019)
32 Cal.App.5th 166, 173.) Because Williams represented himself,
he could move only for discretionary relief. (Esther B. v. City of
Los Angeles (2008) 158 Cal.App.4th 1093, 1100 [“the
discretionary provision [of section 473, subdivision (b)] applies to
a party, including a party appearing in propria persona, and an
attorney representing a party, whereas the mandatory provision
only applies to an attorney representing a party”].) The
discretionary relief provision of section 473, subdivision (b),
provides the trial court “may, upon any terms as may be just,
relieve a party or [his or her] legal representative from a
judgment, dismissal, order, or other proceeding taken against
him or her through [his or her] mistake, inadvertence, surprise,

9
or excusable neglect.” “The party seeking relief . . . bears the
burden of proof in establishing a right to relief.” (Hopkins &
Carley v. Gens (2011) 200 Cal.App.4th 1401, 1410.) “We review
the trial court’s discretionary decision to grant or deny relief
under section 473[, subdivision] (b) for an abuse of discretion.”
(County of San Bernardino v. Mancini (2022) 83 Cal.App.5th
1095, 1103.)

B. The Appeal from the Judgment of Dismissal Is Untimely
Williams posits the court abused its authority when it
“outright dismissed [his] case although [he] had not come to the
three (3) year mark yet as outline[d] in Civ. Code of Proc.
§ 583.210.” (Capitalization omitted.) However, Williams did not
timely appeal from the court’s August 4, 2022 judgment of
dismissal. Williams originally had 180 days to appeal that
judgment, or until January 31, 2023. (See rule 8.104(a)(1)(C)
[where notice of entry of judgment or file-stamped copy of the
judgment was not served on appellant, deadline to appeal is 180
days after entry of judgment]; accord, Huff v. Interior Specialists,
Inc. (2024) 107 Cal.App.5th 970, 979.) On January 19, 2023,
Williams filed his motion to vacate the dismissal under rule
3.1332(b)(c)(2) and section 473, which motion the court denied on
February 10, 2023. The clerk’s certificate of mailing of the denial
order is dated the same day. That extended William’s time to
appeal from the judgment by 30 days—until March 13. (See rule
8.108(c)(1) [time to appeal judgment is extended until 30 days
after the clerk serves an order denying a motion to vacate a
judgment].) However, Williams did not file a notice of appeal
until April 11, 2023. That was too late. We thus lack jurisdiction
to review the August 2022 judgment of dismissal. (See Ventura

10
Coastal, LLC v. Occupational Safety & Health Appeals Bd. (2020)
58 Cal.App.5th 1, 36 [“ ‘ “Compliance with the time for filing a
notice of appeal is mandatory and jurisdictional.” ’ ”)
Williams’s failure to timely appeal from the judgment of
dismissal also precludes his contention that the court abused its
discretion when it failed to grant him a continuance in February
2022. We note, however, that the court did grant Williams’s
request for a continuance. Williams had requested a continuance
until July 2022, and the court continued the hearing until August
2022, a month more than Williams requested.

C. Williams Has Not Shown the Trial Court Abused Its
Discretion in Denying His Motion To Vacate the Judgment
Williams generally contends the trial court erred in
denying his motion to vacate, but he does not explain how the
court erred. (See LNSU #1, LLC v. Alta Del Mar Coastal
Collection Community Assn. (2023) 94 Cal.App.5th 1050, 1070
[“where, as here, the appellants’ opening brief makes contentions
unsupported by proper record citations or cogent legal
arguments, we may treat the contentions as forfeited”]; Lee v.
Kim (2019) 41 Cal.App.5th 705, 721 [“the scope of our review is
limited to those issues that have been adequately raised and
supported in the appellant’s brief”].) Even if his contention was
not forfeited, we find no error in the court’s ruling. Williams did
not demonstrate in his motion to vacate any “mistake,
inadvertence, surprise, or excusable neglect” that warranted
relief from the judgment of dismissal. (§ 473, subd. (b).)
Although Williams alleged in his motion that he had medical
difficulties, was assaulted, and suffered other maladies, he did
not explain why he could not have served the defendants over the

11
course of two years as a result. As the trial court correctly noted,
Williams could have effectuated service through someone not
party to the case. The court did not abuse its discretion in
denying Williams’s motion to vacate the judgment.
Williams also asserts the judge in his case was biased and
he was therefore denied due process. Williams does not provide
any evidence the court was biased or any explanation as to how
the court was biased except that it dismissed his case. “ ‘The
mere fact that the trial court issue[s] rulings adverse to [a party]
. . . , even assuming one or more of those rulings were erroneous,
does not indicate an appearance of bias, much less demonstrate
actual bias.’ ” (In re M.V. (2025) 109 Cal.App.5th 486, 517; see
Guardianship of Baby Boy M. (1977) 66 Cal.App.3d 254, 278
[reviewing court will not “impute judicial misconduct upon the
mere speculation of the parties” where “nothing in the record . . .
suggests that the court’s decision was prompted by improper or
retaliatory designs”].) Williams has not demonstrated the trial
judge was biased against him.
Williams also argues the court erred in denying his two
motions requesting reconsideration of the denial of his motion to
vacate. Ordinarily, the denial of the motion for reconsideration is
reviewable as part of an appeal from an underlying appealable
order. (§ 1008, subd. (g); see Lowry v. Port San Luis Harbor Dist.
(2020) 56 Cal.App.5th 211, 217 [“we consider the motion for
reconsideration as part of the appeal from the judgment”].)
However, under section 916, the trial court lacked jurisdiction to
hear a motion for reconsideration after Williams filed his notice
of appeal. (See § 916, subd. (a) [“the perfecting of an appeal stays
proceedings in the trial court upon the judgment or order

12
appealed from or upon the matters embraced therein or affected
thereby”].)
Williams has failed to demonstrate any abuse of discretion
in the court’s denial of his motion to vacate the judgment of
dismissal.5

DISPOSITION

The appeal from the judgment of dismissal is dismissed.
The order denying Williams’s motion to vacate the judgment of
dismissal is affirmed. No costs are awarded.

STONE, J.
We concur:

SEGAL, Acting P. J.

FEUER, J.

5 Williams asserts it is unclear if his case was dismissed
with or without prejudice. There appears to be a clerical error on
the case register in which there are entries for both a dismissal
with and without prejudice. However, the court’s minute order
from the August 2022 hearing unambiguously states, “The court
hereby orders the case dismissed, with prejudice, as to the entire
action.”

13

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.