CourtListener 10769740•In re Ella G. CA2/2
Full text
Filed 1/6/26 In re Ella G. CA2/2
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has
not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION TWO
In re ELLA G., Persons Coming B345505
Under the Juvenile Court Law. (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct.
No. 22CCJP00047E, F)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILY SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
C.G.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Mark A. Davis, Judge. Affirmed.
Patricia K. Saucier, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Sally Son, Deputy County
Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
******
Appellant C.G. (mother) appeals from an order terminating
her parental rights to two of her children, Ella G. (born
September 2017) and Emily R. (born July 2019).1 Mother
contends the juvenile court erred in declining to apply the sibling
relationship exception to termination of parental rights, and
there was error under the Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978 (25
U.S.C. § 1901 et seq.) (ICWA) and related California statutes.
As we find mother failed to show the sibling relationship
exception to termination of parental rights applied, the juvenile
court therefore did not err in declining to grant the exception.
However, because the Los Angeles County Department of
Children and Family Services (DCFS) concedes the record does
not reflect DCFS made a diligent and good faith effort to gather
information about the children’s membership status or eligibility
under ICWA, we conditionally reverse with instructions to the
court and DCFS to comply with the inquiry requirement of
1 At the time of the proceedings, mother had six minor
children: Steven R. (born January 2004), Angelica R. (born
December 2005), Joshua R. (born January 2011), Isabella R.
(born April 2013), Ella G. (born September 2017), and Emily R.
(born July 2019). Mother also had an adult child, Bryan R. This
appeal pertains only to Ella and Emily, mother’s two youngest
children. The other siblings are mentioned as necessary.
2
Welfare and Institutions Code section 224.2 and comply with the
notice provisions if necessary.2
COMBINED FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL
BACKGROUND
Family history
Humberto R. (father) is the presumed father of mother’s six
minor children.3 He died in 2021.
The family had a history in the dependency system. In
December 2016, the juvenile court assumed jurisdiction over
mother’s then five minor children, Bryan, Steven, Angelica,
Joshua, and Isabella, based on the parents’ domestic violence and
mother leaving the children in the care of a maternal aunt
without a plan for their ongoing care. The court terminated
jurisdiction in August 2018 with an order placing the children
with mother.
Current referral, section 300 petition and detention
In December 2021, Ella and Emily’s sister, eight-year-old
Isabella, was found walking on the street alone, crying and wet
from rain. She reported being hit by mother. Law enforcement
discovered mother, her boyfriend Gustavo G., and the children
Joshua, Ella, and Emily, driving in a car. The family was
homeless and living in the car. The interior of the car was in a
disastrous state, strewn with clothing and partially eaten food.
In addition, all the children had lice. The back window of the car
was broken, and the child seat was not properly installed.
2 All further statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code unless otherwise noted.
3 Gustavo G. was initially believed to be the father of Ella,
but during the proceedings it was discovered he was not.
3
It was reported mother and Gustavo were locked in the
bathroom of a motel room and Isabella needed to use the
restroom. According to mother, the child “threw a fit” and left
the motel room. It was unknown how long she was missing
before mother realized she was gone and went looking for her.
Gustavo had methamphetamine in his pocket and mother did not
have a license to drive. Mother was arrested for child
endangerment and corporal punishment. Gustavo was arrested
for child endangerment, drug possession and outstanding
warrants.
On January 4, 2022, DCFS filed a petition pursuant to
section 300 on behalf of Ella, Emily and their siblings based on
Gustavo G.’s substance abuse and mother’s inadequate
supervision of Isabella.
Mother was present at the detention hearing on January 7,
2022. The juvenile court found DCFS had established a prima
facie case and ordered the children detained from mother.
Jurisdiction and disposition
In a January 26, 2022 jurisdiction/disposition report, DCFS
reported Steven and Angelica were detained at large and their
whereabouts were unknown. Angelica reported she was staying
with her boyfriend but did not disclose the address. In a
February 2022 last minute information for the court, DCFS
reported minor Angelica was two months pregnant.
On January 18, 2022, the child protection hotline received a
call from Manuel R., a paternal uncle to the children. The
paternal uncle stated he heard the children were in foster care
and was calling to inquire about providing care for the children.
The dependency investigator confirmed with mother that
Manuel R. was a paternal uncle to the children. DCFS requested
an “ICPC,” as Manuel R. lived in Nevada.
4
Ella, Emily, Isabella and Joshua had been placed together
at the foster home of Mr. and Mrs. S. However, Joshua became
increasingly aggressive and was placed on a psychiatric hold at
Harbor-UCLA Medical Center, and the caregivers requested
Joshua be re-placed. Isabella, Emily and Ella remained placed in
the home of Mr. and Mrs. S.
On April 14, 2022, the juvenile court sustained the section
300 petition as to mother’s failure to appropriately supervise
Isabella.
At the disposition hearing on June 30, 2022, the juvenile
court declared the children dependents of the court, ordered the
children removed from mother and suitably placed, and ordered
family reunification services. The court also ordered DCFS to
facilitate sibling visits.
Section 342 petition
In August 2022, mother tested positive for
methamphetamine.
On September 14, 2022, DCFS filed a subsequent petition
under section 342 alleging the children were at risk due to
domestic violence between mother and her companion, Erick L.,
and because mother had a history of substance abuse and was
currently abusing alcohol and methamphetamine. The petition
also alleged mother allowed her companion to drive Ella and
Emily in his car without a car seat and left Joshua in a
dangerous situation by leaving him for extended periods without
supervision.
On February 8, 2023, the juvenile court sustained the
petition and ordered mother to participate in a full drug
treatment program and random drug testing.
5
Family reunification period
The children began having sibling visits in
September 2022. Mother attended some of those visits. During
the visits, the children appeared to enjoy each other’s company
and seemed well-bonded.
In December 2022, mother stopped coming to visits and
stopped communicating with DCFS. Mother briefly resumed
contact with DCFS in May 2023 but did not resume visiting the
children. DCFS contacted several family members including
maternal great aunt, maternal aunts and uncles, and maternal
grandmother, all of whom were unwilling to provide mother with
support or assist in possible relative care for the children.
An October 2022 letter from the children’s therapist
reported they had been participating in therapy since April 2022.
Ella and Emily quarreled regularly, and the therapist was
working to decrease their negative behaviors. In August 2022, it
was determined Emily no longer needed therapy, and she
stopped.
The children continued to have sibling visits, including
overnight visits at Joshua’s foster home from December 2022
through February 2023. Visits were suspended in February and
March 2023 due to Isabella not wanting to attend, Joshua
allegedly hitting the children, and the children not feeling
comfortable resuming sibling visits. After much engagement and
encouragement, visits resumed.
Sibling visits were again temporarily suspended in May
2023 due to Angelica not being motivated to visit and Joshua
having outbursts and runaway episodes. Joshua was moved to
another placement only to receive another request to have him
removed. However, visits resumed in June 2023 and the
situation stabilized.
6
During an August 2023 visit to the children’s caregivers,
the caregivers reported Isabella would get upset when things did
not go her way. Ella was easily upset and fought a lot with
Emily. The children had overly friendly behaviors and would
wander around with others. The children appeared comfortable
with the caregivers, were in good spirits and reported no
concerns.
Twelve-month review hearing
At the 12-month review hearing on September 18, 2023,
mother was not present. The court found mother’s progress to be
unsubstantial. Reunification services were terminated, and the
court set a permanency planning hearing.
Permanency planning
In a March 2024 report, it was noted Isabella, Emily and
Ella loved each other and wanted to be together. They comforted
each other and played together. Ella’s therapist reported she was
working on reducing Ella’s tantrums and aggressive behaviors
towards her sister. In October 2023, a sibling visit was canceled
because Joshua did not want to attend. The children’s caregiver
noted Joshua preferred to be with other boys and not with his
sisters.
DCFS reported Isabella, Ella, and Emily were strongly
bonded with their caregivers and continued to thrive in their
home. The children referred to their caregivers as “mama Mila”
and “Papa Felix.” The children wanted to continue sibling visits
with Joshua and Angelica, but Joshua and Angelica’s interest in
the visits waned, and the visits became less frequent. Isabella,
Ella and Emily each expressed a desire to stay with their
caregivers if they were unable to return to mother. The
caregivers expressed a strong desire to provide the children
permanency through adoption.
7
Isabella was present at a review hearing on March 15,
2024. Maternal relatives Patricia, Felipe and Diana were present
at the hearing. Maternal great aunt Patricia requested
placement of Isabella and her sisters. Isabella’s attorney
explained this was the first time she was made aware that
maternal relatives were “even in the picture.” However, when
she let Isabella know her family was present “she did get a little
emotional because she hadn’t seen them in so long” and “she
really did want to establish or reestablish that relationship with
her family.”
In an April 2024 meeting, it was noted the children’s
paternal relatives appeared in court to request visits and be
considered for placement.4 The caregivers explained they were
no longer interested in providing permanency through adoption
for the children. The caregivers were not in agreement with
visits with the children’s relatives, noting that since Isabella was
informed of the relatives’ involvement, she displayed challenging
behaviors they had worked hard to decrease. The caregivers
expressed concern that involvement of the relatives had caused
their relationship with Isabella to decline.
When the social worker followed up with the children,
Isabella said she was not sure about wanting to be adopted by
her caregivers. She wanted to have visits with her aunt Diana
and uncle Felipe first to “see how it is.” Isabella acknowledged
she had previously been in agreement with adoption but, after
learning about her relatives, changed her mind. Ella too wanted
visits with her relatives because “Bella told us that we were going
4 Though the report mentions paternal relatives, it appears
they were referencing the maternal relatives’ recent appearance
in court.
8
to live with our tia,” but after further discussion, expressed she
wanted to live permanently with her caregivers. Emily wanted to
stay with the current caregivers.
DCFS requested a 120-day continuance in order to identify
the best permanent plan for the children.
On May 9, 2024, the juvenile court ordered DCFS to
conduct a child and family team meeting with the current
caregivers to try to preserve the placement for the children.
Mrs. S. expressed her desire for a closed adoption. She was
in favor of phone and virtual visitation only and in-person
visitation for special occasions or holidays. She noted changes in
the children’s behavior following family visits. Specifically,
Isabella would ignore the caregiver and say, “Why should I listen
to you when I have my family.” Isabella would also tell Ella and
Emily not to listen to the caregiver because she was not their
mother. The caregiver was afraid of the children’s adult brother,
Bryan, who Joshua said had a gun. After much discussion
between the social worker and the family, the caregivers decided
to proceed with the adoption process.
In a status review report filed in August 2024, DCFS
reported Isabella, Ella and Emily all reported wanting to stay
with their current caregivers if they could not go home.
Alternatively, they wanted to be placed with Angelica’s caregiver.
In an addendum report filed later in August 2024, the
caregivers confirmed they would continue with the adoption
process. They also agreed to support postadoption contact with
the children’s sister, presumably Angelica. When interviewed
privately, Isabella reported she was unsure about the adoption
and did not know if it was her only option. Ella and Emily
expressed they liked living with their current caregivers.
9
In a last minute information to the court filed
September 12, 2024, DCFS reported contact with maternal uncle
Felipe and maternal grandmother during efforts to reach mother,
but neither relative requested visits or custody of the children.
Though Isabella expressed a desire to be placed with
Angelica’s caregiver, she also felt “okay” staying with her current
caregivers. As to her aunt Patricia, Isabella felt “okay but not
that safe.” Isabella wanted the judge to know she wanted to stay
with her sisters.
When asked about Patricia, Ella said she did not remember
her but wanted to live with her because “Bella (Isabella) told me
she has three rooms and toys. She has things to do our hair.”
She also expressed wanting to live with Angelica but did not
mind remaining in the home of her current caregivers.
Emily wanted to remain in her current home.
In November 2024, Mr. and Mrs. S. communicated that
they were still committed to providing permanency for the
children, but they expressed concern regarding Isabella and her
behavior. She had become increasingly aggressive towards her
sisters and often told the caregivers they were not part of her
family. Her behaviors had escalated in the past month.
Isabella reported feeling safe in the home but continued to
express hesitance about the adoption. She did not want to be
adopted but wanted to remain with her sisters. She was unable
to elaborate on the reasons she was no longer open to adoption.
Ella and Emily reported they were happy in their
placement.
By March 2025, Isabella expressed she was unhappy in her
current placement and only remained there because of her
sisters. She wanted to be with her sisters, but she was sacrificing
her happiness for them. Her caregivers were strict, which
10
hindered her ability to be herself. She was no longer interested
in adoption or legal guardianship with the current caregivers and
requested to be moved from the home. No concerns as to abuse or
neglect were expressed. According to the social worker, Isabella
“is hopeful for relatives to step forward to care for her and her
siblings, reflecting her longing for familial ties and the possibility
of maintaining a connection with her biological family. This shift
highlights the complexity of her emotions given that her
biological family show no sense of care as to Isabella and her
siblings.” On March 25, 2025, Isabella told a social worker, “I
don’t think I could handle being [at the caregivers’ home] any
longer.” The caregivers wanted to honor Isabella’s request and
agreed to a placement change for Isabella.
There were no concerns for Ella or Emily. They appeared
to have a strong attachment to the caregivers and a sense of
security. They were happy in their placement and wanted to
continue with the adoption. The children had been in the home
since December 2021.
In March 2025, a postadoption contact agreement was
established between the caregivers and adult sibling Angelica.
The parties agreed the children would continue contact with their
sibling.5 Mrs. S. “recently demonstrated insight as to sibling
bond and the willingness to support sibling visits.”
5 At the section 366.26 hearing, Emily and Ella’s attorney
stated the postadoptive contract also provided for postadoption
contact with “an adult sibling,” Isabella, and Joshua. Neither
party has provided a citation to the record showing the actual
signed agreement. Mother’s attorney did not disagree with the
assertion regarding the postadoption contract, nor did she clarify
the record as to the scope of the agreement. Instead, mother’s
counsel stated, “I understand [Emily and Ella’s attorney] did
11
DCFS recommended termination of parental rights as to
Emily and Ella in order to offer them a permanent adoptive home
with Mr. and Mrs. S. A 90-day continuance was requested as to
Isabella and Joshua.
Section 366.26 hearing
The section 366.26 hearing took place on April 11, 2025.
Mother was present in custody with counsel. No children were
present.
Ella and Emily’s attorney noted she had not been informed
Isabella was leaving the placement and was unsure how that
would affect Ella and Emily. However, she noted the girls had
been in the home for three years and were very young. She
further noted there was a postadoptive contract ensuring sibling
contact following adoption.
Mother’s counsel objected to termination of parental rights,
arguing the sibling bond exception found under section 366.26,
subdivision (c)(1)(B)(v) applied. Counsel argued the termination
of mother’s parental rights would be detrimental to Ella and
Emily given their bond with their siblings. Counsel pointed out
that Emily and Ella had always been in the same placement with
mention a consortium referral as to the siblings; however, as she
noted, her own client’s [sic] position would likely change knowing
that Isabella would be no longer living with them as well.” In her
reply brief on appeal, mother argues the children’s trial counsel
“erroneously” assured the juvenile court that the consortium
agreement protected the children’s sibling relationships and
included Isabella. Mother contends, without citation to the
record, that Isabella’s proposed removal from Ella and Emily’s
caregiver’s home meant she was no longer part of the agreement.
Because mother has failed to cite evidence supporting this
contention, we decline to consider it.
12
Isabella, and Isabella would now be removed from the home.
Although Emily and Ella expressed that they wanted to be
adopted, counsel said, “I’m not sure they grasp or understand
what that means under the law, that they would not have any
contact with their biological siblings under the law.” Counsel
argued it was likely Ella and Emily would “lose that contact with
all biological siblings once the court terminates mother’s parental
rights.” The caregivers had expressed concern about visits with
the extended family, and with Isabella being removed, there
would be a further issue with ensuring the sibling bond stayed
intact. Counsel further pointed out even Ella and Emily’s
counsel was not sure how they would feel about adoption
knowing that Isabella would not be living with them. Counsel
requested the court grant legal guardianship as the permanent
plan given her position that the sibling bond exception applied in
the case.
Initially the court addressed Isabella’s counsel’s request
that the court order DCFS to “make best efforts to facilitate
sibling visitation moving forward between my client and the
other siblings.” The court responded, “Absolutely. [DCFS] please
make your best efforts to facilitate sibling visitation between all
of the kids and certainly between Isabella, Joshua, Ella, and
Emily.”
The court then addressed mother’s argument regarding the
application of the sibling exception. The court did not believe
mother had standing to make the argument, as none of the
children’s attorneys had made the argument. Because none of
the attorneys for the children made the request, the court found
the exception did not exist in this case.
Counsel for DCFS then pointed out to the court that
detriment would have to be evaluated from the perspective of the
13
children who are going to be adopted—Ella and Emily. These
two children had consistently indicated a desire to be adopted. In
addition, counsel for DCFS pointed out there was no evidence of
detriment to Ella and Emily, particularly as the caregivers had
already voluntarily signed a postadoptive agreement. “They have
shown through that the willingness and an agreement to
continue sibling contact; so I would submit there’s no evidence
that there would be an interference” with the sibling
relationships. The court noted, “I’m in agreement with all of
that.”
The court found by clear and convincing evidence Ella and
Emily were adoptable, and there were no applicable exceptions to
termination of parental rights. The court then terminated
mother’s parental rights.
Mother’s counsel objected on the grounds she had standing
to raise the sibling exception. The court acknowledged mother’s
objection but stated, “[the] court finds there is no sibling bond
information submitted sufficient enough to provide that
[exception].”
ICWA investigation
The ICWA-010 form attached to the section 300 petition
stated mother had been asked about her ancestry and denied any
known Indian ancestry.
On January 7, 2022, mother and Gustavo G. each filed
parental notification of Indian status forms (ICWA-020)
indicating none of the listed factors regarding Indian children
applied to their children. Mother submitted a relative
information sheet identifying a maternal great aunt, a maternal
cousin, and Ella’s paternal grandmother for consideration for
placement or to serve as visitation monitors.
14
On January 10, 2022, the juvenile court found it had no
reason to know Ella and Emily were Indian children. Mother and
Gustavo denied having any American Indian heritage. Mother
reported she was born in Los Angeles and partially raised in
Mexico.
On January 18, 2022, father’s brother, Manuel R.,
contacted DCFS expressing interest in caring for the children. It
does not appear he was questioned about the children’s possible
Native American ancestry.
On October 7, 2022, mother denied American Indian
ancestry and any knowledge of any American Indian ancestry as
to father, who was of Mexican descent.
In a July 2023 report, DCFS reported the children were
unaware of any American Indian ancestry. Maternal
grandmother and maternal aunts also denied any American
Indian ancestry, reporting they were of Mexican heritage.
In an August 2023 report, DCFS reported maternal aunt
Patricia denied any American Indian heritage. The maternal
relatives were not in contact with the paternal relatives, and the
children had no contact information for paternal relatives.
Angelica denied any American Indian heritage on either side of
her family but stated she did not really speak to any relatives.
DCFS unsuccessfully sought to contact Bryan.
In October 2023, DCFS filled out a family tree with
Angelica in an effort to identify relatives with information
regarding potential American Indian heritage. She identified the
maternal grandmother and maternal aunts Diana, Vanessa, and
Felipe. She could not provide any information as to paternal
relatives and noted she shared her name with an aunt.
15
In January 2024, Angelica reported her father was born in
Mexico. Angelica believed the maternal grandmother was from
Tijuana, Mexico.
Isabella did not know of any American Indian ancestry but
reported doubt because her family was from Mexico.
In March 2024, maternal aunt Patricia denied any Native
American heritage, adding the family was of Mexican heritage
with roots in Tijuana. Maternal aunt Vanessa said the same
thing. She noted both maternal grandmother and maternal
grandfather were from Mexico.
On March 6, 2024, maternal grandmother denied any
Native American heritage in herself, mother, or the children,
reporting the family was Mexican as far back as she knew.
Maternal grandmother’s mother and father were born in Tijuana.
On April 11, 2025, DCFS noted father was deceased and
DCFS had no contact information as to any paternal relatives.
The juvenile court found it had no reason to believe ICWA
applied.
Notice of appeal
On April 11, 2025, mother filed a notice of appeal from the
court’s order terminating her parental rights to Ella and Emily.
DISCUSSION
I. Sibling relationship exception
A. Applicable law and standard of review
At a section 366.26 hearing the trial court is required to
select and implement a permanent plan for the dependent child.
(§ 366.26, subd. (b).) If the court determines by clear and
convincing evidence the child is likely to be adopted, the court
“shall” terminate parental rights and order the child placed for
adoption unless one of the statutory exceptions is met. (§ 366.26,
16
subd. (c)(1).) “The parent has the burden of establishing an
exception to termination of parental rights.” (In re Daisy D.
(2006) 144 Cal.App.4th 287, 291; see Cal. Rules of Court, rule
5.725(d)(2).)
The sibling relationship exception exists when the juvenile
court determines there is a compelling reason for the court to
conclude the termination of parental rights would be detrimental
to the child due to substantial interference with a sibling
relationship. (In re Daniel H. (2002) 99 Cal.App.4th 804, 813.) In
making this determination, the court should consider the “nature
and extent of the relationship,” including, but not limited to,
“whether the child was raised with a sibling in the same home,
whether the child shared significant common experiences or has
existing close and strong bonds with a sibling, and whether
ongoing contact is in the child’s best interest, including the child’s
long-term emotional interest, as compared to the benefit of legal
permanence through adoption.” (§ 366.26, subd. (c)(1)(B)(v).)
“The author of the legislation adding the sibling relationship
exception anticipated that ‘use of the new exception “will likely be
rare,”’ meaning ‘that the child’s relationship with his or her
siblings would rarely be sufficiently strong to outweigh the
benefits of adoption.’” (In re Daisy D., supra, 144 Cal.App.4th at
p. 293.) “The sibling relationship exception contains strong
language creating a heavy burden for the party opposing
adoption.” (In re Daniel H., supra, at p. 813.)
The party opposing adoption first must show termination of
parental rights would be detrimental to the child due to
substantial interference with the sibling relationship. (§ 366.26,
subd. (c)(1)(B)(v).) “If the court determines terminating parental
rights would substantially interfere with the sibling relationship,
the court is then directed to weigh the child’s best interest in
17
continuing that sibling relationship against the benefit the child
would receive by the permanency of adoption.” (In re L. Y. L.
(2002) 101 Cal.App.4th 942, 952.)
The factual question of whether the sibling relationship
exception to termination of parental rights is applicable is
reviewed for substantial evidence. The court’s weighing of
competing interests is reviewed for abuse of discretion. (In re
D.O. (2016) 247 Cal.App.4th 166, 174.)6
B. The trial court did not err in determining
mother failed to meet her burden of showing the
sibling relationship exception existed
Mother does not dispute Ella and Emily were adoptable.
Thus, the juvenile court was required to terminate parental
rights and proceed with adoption unless mother met her burden
of showing one of the exceptions to termination of parental rights
existed. (§ 366.26, subd. (c)(1).) The only exception mother
raised was the sibling relationship exception. (§ 366.26, subd.
(c)(1)(B)(v).)
Mother was required to show termination of parental rights
would be detrimental to Ella and Emily due to substantial
6 Mother points out the question of standing is a question of
law reviewed de novo. (T.P. v. T.W. (2011) 191 Cal.App.4th 1428,
1432.) Therefore, mother argues, the issue before this court is
subject to de novo review. However, DCFS concedes mother had
standing to raise the sibling relationship exception, and while the
trial court initially erred in suggesting mother did not have
standing to assert the exception, the court ultimately corrected
its error and determined mother had not presented sufficient
evidence to show the exception existed. Therefore, we find the
court’s initial error harmless and decline to discuss the issue of
standing or apply independent review to the trial court’s decision.
18
interference with a sibling relationship. (In re L. Y. L., supra,
101 Cal.App.4th at pp. 951–952.) Mother first argued the
siblings had a bond, particularly among Isabella, Ella and Emily.
While Ella and Emily stated they wanted to be adopted, mother’s
counsel was not sure they understood that meant they would not
have any contact with their biological siblings under the law.
Mother’s counsel argued it is “likely” Ella and Emily will “lose
that contact with all biological siblings once the court terminates
mother’s parental rights.” She pointed out the caregivers had
expressed concern about the aftermath of sibling visits for
Isabella. Counsel pointed out that earlier in the proceedings, the
caregivers had wavered in their commitment to provide
permanency because of the sibling visits. While she
acknowledged the existence of a sibling consortium agreement,
she argued the girls’ position would likely change knowing that
Isabella would no longer be living with them.
After the court’s erroneous statement that mother had no
standing to raise the sibling relationship exception, counsel for
DCFS corrected the court and pointed out “detriment would have
to be assessed by the children who are anticipated to be adopted.”
Those children were Emily and Ella, who had consistently stated
they wanted to be adopted. In addition, there was no evidence of
substantial interference with the sibling relationship, given the
existence of the postadoptive agreement and the caregivers’
willingness to continue sibling contact. The court noted its
agreement with everything counsel for DCFS had said.
19
Mother’s counsel did not dispute the children’s counsel’s
statement that the postadoption contract guaranteed the
caregivers would provide sibling visitation.7
Mother points out evidence of Isabella’s perspective was
relevant and may be considered by the court as indirect evidence
of the effect the adoption may have on Ella and Emily. (In re
Celine R. (2003) 31 Cal.4th 45, 54.) Isabella stated she wanted to
be with her sisters and was sacrificing her happiness for them.
Mother argues these statements reflected the close sibling bond
among Isabella, Ella and Emily. However, the court granted
Isabella’s counsel’s request that DCFS be required to facilitate
sibling visitation moving forward, ordering that DCFS “make [its]
best efforts to facilitate sibling visitation between all of the kids
and certainly between Isabella, Joshua, Ella, and Emily.” There
was no objection to the court’s order.
While mother emphasized a previous hesitation on the part
of the caregivers to facilitate sibling visitation, the record shows
the caregivers had changed their position and showed a
willingness to support sibling visits. The caregivers went so far
as to agree to a postadoption contract, guaranteeing the
7 On appeal, mother argues the postadoption contract was
allegedly only between the caregivers and the two older siblings.
Although it was her burden to show the existence of the sibling
relationship exception, mother did not dispute the statements at
trial suggesting the contract covered Joshua and Isabella.
Regardless of the precise details of the contract, its existence
demonstrates the willingness on the part of the caregivers to
support Ella and Emily’s relationships with their siblings. “[I]t
was appellants’ burden to establish there would be substantial
interference, not the Agency’s burden to establish there would
not.” (In re D.O., supra, 247 Cal.App.4th at p. 176.)
20
continuation of contact between the children and their siblings.
Mother provided no evidence that the caregivers currently
opposed sibling visitation or that Isabella’s removal from their
home would cause any resistance to visitation. On the contrary,
the caregivers had been committed to providing permanence for
Isabella and only agreed to have the child re-placed to honor her
wishes. The caregivers knew Isabella well and there was no
evidence suggesting they would oppose visitation in the future.
There was no evidence the caregivers intended to interfere
with any sibling relationships going forward. Mother failed to
meet her burden of showing the requirements of the sibling
relationship exception were met.
Even if mother had established substantial interference
with the children’s relationships with their siblings, mother
presented no evidence that any potential detriment to the
children outweighed the benefits of adoption. As mother
admitted, Ella and Emily had consistently expressed a desire to
remain in the home of their caregivers, with whom they had
established a strong bond and whom they referred to as “mama
Mila” and “papa Felix.” The children, who were ages five and
seven at the time of the section 366.26 hearing, had been in the
caregivers’ home for over three years. Although Isabella had
expressed that she remained in the caregivers’ home because of
her sisters, Ella and Emily had never expressed any desire to
remain with Isabella or any other sibling. Instead, they
maintained they wanted to stay with the caregivers.
The trial court did not err in determining mother failed to
present sufficient evidence to show the sibling relationship
exception. Mother failed to show that Ella and Emily would
suffer detriment from substantial interference with a sibling
relationship or that any such detriment would outweigh the
21
benefits of a permanent home through adoption by their
caregivers.
II. ICWA
A. Applicable law
ICWA was enacted “to protect Indian children and to
promote the stability and security of Indian tribes and families by
establishing minimum federal standards that a state court,
except in emergencies, must follow before removing an Indian
child from his or her family.” (In re Austin J. (2020) 47
Cal.App.5th 870, 881, disapproved on other grounds in In re
Dezi C. (2024) 16 Cal.5th 1112, 1152, fn. 18.)
An “Indian child” is defined under California law as an
unmarried child who “is either (a) a member of an Indian tribe or
(b) is eligible for membership in an Indian tribe and is the
biological child of a member of an Indian tribe.” (25 U.S.C.
§ 1903(4); see § 224.1, subds. (a) and (b).) Under California law,
DCFS and the juvenile court “have an affirmative and continuing
duty to inquire” into whether a dependent child “is or may be an
Indian child.” (§ 224.2, subd. (a).) This includes making an
initial inquiry, which “includes, but is not limited to, asking the
child, parents, legal guardian, Indian custodian, extended family
members, others who have an interest in the child, and the party
reporting child abuse or neglect, whether the child is, or may be,
an Indian child and where the child, the parents, or Indian
custodian is domiciled.” (§ 224.2, subd. (b).)
Federal regulations require the juvenile court to “ask each
participant . . . whether the participant knows or has reason to
know that the child is an Indian child. The inquiry is made at
the commencement of the proceeding and all responses should be
on the record.” (25 C.F.R. 23.107, subd. (a); see also § 224.2,
subd. (c).) Further inquiry is required where there is reason to
22
believe that a child is an Indian child. (§ 224.2, subd. (e).)
Further inquiry includes gathering information from the parents
and relatives and contacting the tribes. (§ 224.2, subd. (e)(2).)
Once the agency has complied with its duty of inquiry and
there is no reason to know that the child is an Indian child, the
court may find that ICWA does not apply. (§ 224.2, subd. (i)(2);
Cal. Rules of Court, rule 5.481(b)(3)(A).) However, before the
juvenile court makes such a finding, it must ensure the agency
has made an adequate inquiry under ICWA and related
California law. (In re Dominick D. (2022) 82 Cal.App.5th 560,
566–567.) “A juvenile court’s finding that ICWA does not apply
implies ‘that social workers [have] fulfilled their duty of inquiry.’”
(Id. at p. 567.)
Notice to tribes is required if there is reason to know that
the child is an Indian child. (§ 224.2, subd. (f).)
A trial court’s findings relating to ICWA notice and inquiry
issues are reviewed for substantial evidence. (In re E.W. (2009)
170 Cal.App.4th 396, 404.)
B. Remand for ICWA inquiry is appropriate
Mother contends DCFS and the juvenile court failed to
comply with their duty of inquiry because the record does not
reflect DCFS asked all available extended family members,
including Manuel R., the only known paternal extended family
member, whether the children had Indian ancestry. (§ 224.2,
subd. (b).) DCFS concedes mother’s argument has merit.
In In re Dezi C., supra, 16 Cal.5th at page 1136, the
Supreme Court held that error resulting in an inadequate ICWA
inquiry requires conditional reversal with directions for the child
welfare agency to comply with the inquiry requirements. In light
of the Supreme Court’s decision, DCFS does not oppose a
conditional reversal of the order terminating parental rights and
23
remand of the matter to ensure proper initial inquiry is
conducted pursuant to ICWA.
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s order terminating parental rights to
Ella and Emily is conditionally reversed. The matter is
remanded with directions that the juvenile court order DCFS to
make reasonable efforts to interview the children’s available and
ascertainable extended family members who were not previously
questioned about the children’s possible status as Indian children
under ICWA. If it is determined the children are Indian children,
the matter should proceed pursuant to ICWA. If not, the order
terminating mother’s parental rights to Ella and Emily is to be
reinstated.
CHAVEZ, J.
We concur:
LUI, P. J.
SIGGINS, J.*
* Retired Presiding Justice of the Court of Appeal, First
Appellate District, assigned by the Chief Justice pursuant to
article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution.
24
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.