People v. Grissom CA6

CourtListener 10758472CalctappDec 15, 2025

Full text

Filed 12/15/25 P. v. Grissom CA6
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SIXTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

THE PEOPLE, H052002
(Santa Clara County
Plaintiff and Respondent, Super. Ct. No. B2100597)

v.

DONALD WAYNE GRISSOM,

Defendant and Appellant.

A jury convicted Donald W. Grissom of domestic violence and misdemeanor
vandalism, and the trial court granted probation and sentenced him to a term on electronic
monitoring. On appeal, Grissom argues that the court prejudicially erred in admitting
audio recordings of conversations between Grissom and his then-girlfriend, in which he
admitted or failed to deny prior uncharged acts of abuse. Because the court acted within
its discretion in balancing the recordings’ probative value against their prejudicial impact,
we will affirm.
I. BACKGROUND

The Santa Clara County District Attorney charged Grissom with inflicting
corporal injury on a person with whom he was in a dating relationship (Pen. Code,
§ 273.5, subd. (a); count 1), and misdemeanor vandalism (Pen. Code, § 594,
subd. (b)(2)(A); count 2). Both counts arose from a February 2021 altercation between
Grissom and his then-girlfriend, Kelly K., at the home Kelly was living in.
A. Prior Uncharged Acts

Under Evidence Code section 1109,1 the prosecutor moved in limine to admit
eight audio recordings of conversations between Kelly and Grissom, as well as Kelly’s
“accompanying testimony” about prior uncharged acts of abuse purportedly addressed in
those conversations. After listening to the recordings, the trial court overruled Grissom’s
section 352 objection and admitted all but two. The court reasoned that the recordings
had probative value because they consisted “mostly of [Kelly] making statements about
being hit or choked or physically assaulted by Mr. Grissom, and him either not denying
it, when they were clearly engaged in conversation, or actually admitting that he had done
so.”2 While the court acknowledged “some danger” that the recordings would confuse
the jury, the court intended to “try and straighten it out with [jury] instructions.” And
with “about 30 minutes’ worth of recordings,” the court did not believe admission of the
recordings would cause an “undue expenditure” of time.
The prosecution played excerpts from the admitted recordings, and Kelly testified
and provided context about the incidents captured in each. According to Kelly, Grissom
became abusive during the first year of their relationship. Grissom’s first acts of abuse
included yelling and screaming in her face, calling her a “bitch” and “cunt,” and spitting
at her. At some point, Kelly began recording conversations between herself and Grissom

1
Undesignated statutory references are to the Evidence Code.
2
The audio recordings were not included as a part of the record on appeal but
were summarized without objection in the prosecutor’s closing argument. In one
recording, Grissom denied Kelly’s accusation that he had choked her and replied: “ ‘I
didn’t choke you. I grabbed you by the neck, and you talked about my kids. That’s what
happens when you talk about my kids.’ ” In another, Grissom told Kelly: “ ‘This is why
you got pushed[.] [B]ecause you were in my face last time.’ ” In a third recording, Kelly
accused Grissom of causing “bruises” on her body, to which Grissom replied, “ ‘Well,
you started it because you woke me up and called me a liar so that’s what you get.’ ”
And in a fourth excerpt, Kelly said that Grissom had “ ‘kissed [her] bruises,’ ” and
Grissom replied, “ ‘Oh, was that not good enough for you?’ ”

2
to avoid Grissom “turn[ing] the arguments on” her. Although Kelly told Grissom she
was recording their conversations, “he didn’t care.” But whenever confronted with the
recordings, Grissom would break Kelly’s phone by “slapp[ing] it out of [her] hands.”
Kelly testified that during their relationship, Grissom had (1) punched her,
(2) given her a “fat” or “swollen lip” by hitting her in the face, (3) pushed her “more than
20 [times],” (4) given her a bruise on the leg, and then kissed the bruise while promising
never to hit her again, and (5) grabbed her by the throat three times, and on one of those
occasions, squeezed so hard that she was not able to talk, swallow, or breathe.
B. Charged Acts

By February 2021, Grissom had moved out of the home he and Kelly had briefly
shared. The day of the charged acts, Grissom returned to pick up his mail, and he and
Kelly argued. Grissom became angry and verbally abusive, then threw his mail in the
driveway and left. Returning later that day, he appeared contrite and asked to give Kelly
a hug. When he leaned in for the hug, he saw a knife Kelly was hiding under some couch
cushions. Grissom became “enraged,” grabbed the knife, and put it to his own throat,
threatening to kill himself.
Scared, Kelly tried to get Grissom to leave the house by saying “anything he
wanted to hear.” Reacting to something Kelly said, Grissom seemed like he was going to
hit her, so she began screaming for help. At that point, Grissom punched Kelly five times
in her chest, ribs, and solar plexus. In prior statements, Kelly had recounted that Grissom
also grabbed her by the throat. Kelly fell to the ground and Grissom fled. At some point
before assaulting Kelly, Grissom also damaged a wall heater inside the home.
Kelly was diagnosed with a bruised rib and prescribed a lidocaine patch for pain
and a medical device to help her breathe. The emergency room nurse reported the
suspected domestic abuse to police, who responded and took Kelly’s statement. The

3
officers observed a bruise in Kelly’s chest area, which was still visible when they took
photos a week later.3
C. Defense Case

Grissom denied assaulting Kelly. He stated that Kelly invited him in to watch a
video but then accused Grissom of cheating and “blew up,” waving a knife and
screaming at him to “ ‘get the fuck out.’ ” When Grissom opened the front door to leave,
Kelly began screaming “help, help, help,” while twice pushing Grissom’s face into the
screen door. Grissom suffered cuts to his forehead and nose as a result. Grissom
admitted to hitting the wall heater “out of frustration” on his way out.
As to the audio recordings, Grissom admitted pushing Kelly on one prior occasion
and “grabb[ing] her by her shirt” on another. He explained that when he pushed Kelly, it
was to move her out of the way because she was physically blocking him from leaving
the room. Grissom denied ever grabbing Kelly by the throat but clarified that he had
grabbed her shirt after she made derogatory comments about his daughter. Grissom
otherwise denied punching, hitting, or strangling Kelly and explained his recorded
admissions and failures to deny hurting Kelly as his either being “sarcastic” or instead
trying to defuse the situation, end the argument, and “get out of there.” Grissom admitted
having prior domestic violence convictions from “the ‘90[’]s and 2007,” and said that
Kelly used the prior convictions as a weapon during their relationship, threatening to send
him to jail.
Additional witnesses testified that they had never seen Grissom physically abuse
Kelly but that Kelly was physically aggressive and verbally abusive to Grissom. Some of
these witnesses opined that Kelly was lying in this case because she is a vindictive

3
The prosecution’s case-in-chief also included the testimony of Richard Ferry, an
expert on intimate partner violence and its effect on victims.

4
person. In a fit of jealous rage, Kelly had once rammed a car belonging to Grissom’s
female friend.
The jury found Grissom guilty as charged. At sentencing, the court declined
Grissom’s request to reduce the charge to a misdemeanor under Penal Code section 17,
subdivision (b) but granted Grissom probation. Grissom timely appealed.
II. DISCUSSION

On appeal, Grissom does not dispute that Kelly’s account of prior uncharged acts
of domestic abuse was admissible under section 1109.4 But because the admission of
such uncharged acts remains subject to section 352, Grissom contends that the trial court
erred in admitting the recorded conversations. We conclude that the court acted within
its discretion in admitting the recordings upon balancing the probative value of the
recordings against any potential prejudicial impact. (People v. Johnson (2010)
185 Cal.App.4th 520, 531 (Johnson) [reviewing § 352 determination for abuse of
discretion]; People v. Montes (2014) 58 Cal.4th 809, 859–860 [same].)
In considering whether exclusion was warranted under section 352, a trial court
must balance “ ‘the probative value of the evidence . . . against four factors: (1) the
inflammatory nature of the uncharged conduct; (2) the possibility of confusion of issues;
(3) remoteness in time of the uncharged offenses; and (4) the amount of time involved in
introducing and refuting the evidence of uncharged offenses.’ ” (People v. Culbert
(2013) 218 Cal.App.4th 184, 192.)

4
Section 1109 provides that “in a criminal action in which the defendant is
accused of an offense involving domestic violence, evidence of the defendant’s
commission of other domestic violence is not made inadmissible by Section 1101 if the
evidence is not inadmissible pursuant to Section 352.” (§ 1109, subd. (a)(1).)
Section 352, in turn, gives the trial court discretion to admit or exclude evidence upon
balancing its “probative value” against “the probability that its admission will
(a) necessitate undue consumption of time or (b) create substantial danger of undue
prejudice, of confusing the issues, or of misleading the jury.”

5
Grissom first argues that the audio recordings were minimally probative. We
disagree. Much of the trial centered on Kelly’s credibility, which Grissom sought to
undermine both through cross-examination and witnesses who came to court to opine
about Kelly’s purported dishonesty and motive to lie. In that context, the audio
recordings—specifically, portions where Grissom admitted to pushing Kelly, grabbing
her by the neck, and giving her bruises—tended to corroborate Kelly’s testimony
regarding the prior uncharged acts, as well as the charged incidents. (See, e.g., People v.
Thomas (2023) 14 Cal.5th 327, 372–373 [rejecting § 352-based challenge to admission of
crime scene photos upon finding that the photos “corroborate[d] and illustrate[d] the
testimony of the [testifying] witnesses”].) And though Grissom now contends Kelly
lacked sufficient independent recollection of the incidents detailed in the recordings, her
testimony shows otherwise. While not recalling every detail, Kelly was able to provide
relevant context for each prior act of abuse she and Grissom discussed, and to use the
recordings as a springboard for testifying about additional prior incidents of abuse.5 So
we cannot say the trial court exceeded the bounds of reason in implicitly determining that
the audio recordings had probative value beyond that of Kelly’s testimony alone.
The court also acted within its discretion in finding that the probative value of the
recordings was not “ ‘substantially outweighed’ by [their] prejudicial impact.” (Johnson,
supra, 185 Cal.App.4th at p. 531.) While the most incriminating excerpts of the
recordings included Grissom admitting to pushing Kelly, grabbing her throat, and giving
her a bruise, these admissions are not “more inflammatory” than the conduct for which
Grissom was on trial. (Id., at p. 534, fn. 11 [noting that in assessing prejudice, “[c]ourts
are primarily concerned where the past bad act was ‘more inflammatory’ than the offense
for which the defendant is on trial”].) Indeed, Kelly testified that while Grissom had

5
In any event, exclusion of the recordings would not have prevented the
prosecution from using them to refresh Kelly’s recollection, if needed. (§ 771.)

6
engaged in prior acts of abuse, he had “[n]ever” hurt her as badly as he did during the
February 2021 incident. By the court’s estimation, there were “30 minutes’ worth of
recordings,” and Kelly’s testimony about the prior acts took just over two hours. In the
context of a four-day trial, where Kelly was the sole percipient witness to the charged
conduct, this expenditure of time was not unreasonable. And despite some initial concern
about jury confusion, the trial court followed through on its promise to “straighten . . .
out” any such confusion by providing detailed jury instructions, including instructions on
adoptive admissions and the predicate findings the jury must make before relying on
evidence of prior uncharged conduct. And questions the jury posed during deliberations
did not suggest that the jury was confused about what conduct it was being asked to
render a verdict upon.
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in admitting the audio recordings under
sections 1109 and 352. As this court explained in People v. Jandres (2014)
226 Cal.App.4th 340, 357, “[i]n general, ‘the application of ordinary rules of evidence
like Evidence Code section 352 does not implicate the federal Constitution.’ ” There
being no violation of the rules of evidence, we need not address Grissom’s additional
claim that the putative section 352 error denied him due process.
III. DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.

7
____________________________________
LIE, J.

WE CONCUR:

____________________________________
GROVER, Acting P. J.

____________________________________
KULKARNI, J.

People v. Grissom
H052002


Judge of the Santa Clara County Superior Court assigned by the Chief Justice pursuant to
article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution.

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.