CourtListener 10758422•In re Christopher R. CA2/8
Full text
Filed 12/15/25 In re Christopher R. CA2/8
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION EIGHT
In re Christopher R. et al., Persons B340784
Coming Under the Juvenile Court
Law. Los Angeles County
______________________________ Super. Ct. No. 24CCJP01717A–B
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILY SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
CHRISTIAN R.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from jurisdictional and dispositional findings and
orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles County, Daniel Z.
Zeidler, Judge. Affirmed in part, dismissed in part.
Sean A. Burleigh, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, and Aileen Wong,
Deputy County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
INTRODUCTION
Appellant Christian R. (Father) appeals the juvenile court’s
jurisdictional and dispositional findings and order as to minor
children Christopher R. (born February 2019) and Sofia R. (born
April 2024). Father contends the juvenile court erred in finding
that he sexually abused his then–minor half-sister Paris, and
that he and Mother engaged in domestic violence, placing
Christopher and Sofia at substantial risk of serious harm.
Father also argues the juvenile court erred when it ordered the
children removed from his care and physical custody. Mother is
not a party to this appeal.
The Los Angeles County Department of Children and
Family Services (DCFS) contends Father’s appeal is moot given
post-disposition events. Alternatively, DCFS argues substantial
evidence supports the juvenile court’s findings and orders.
We affirm the juvenile court’s jurisdictional findings and
dismiss as moot Father’s appeal of the dispositional orders.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. Referrals and Investigation
On September 20, 2023, DCFS received a referral that
Father emotionally abused four-year-old Christopher and
Father’s 17-year-old half-sister Paris.1 According to Mother, then
three months pregnant with Sofia, events commenced when
Father threw a mug with warm coffee at her back on September
17, 2023. Mother has a photograph of a huge coffee stain on her
1 Paris was detained from her own parents in May 2023 and
placed in Father’s home in June 2023. Paris is the children’s
paternal aunt.
2
back. According to Father, the coffee accidentally spilled on
Mother’s back. He said Mother is pregnant and “hormonal.”
Christopher was asleep in the house during the incident and
Paris was there for part of the incident. Mother stated Father
has been “physically and emotionally abusive to her” and has
“pushed her around and thrown items around.” Mother said
Christopher was usually not asleep during past domestic violence
incidents. Mother packed up her belongings, moved out of
Father’s home, and moved into maternal grandmother’s (MGM)
apartment next door.
On November 28, 2023, DCFS received another referral in
response to Mother’s 1:30 a.m. call to law enforcement. Mother
stated she arrived home from work at 1:00 a.m., heard running,
turned the lights on, and saw Father’s boxers and Paris’s
underwear and bra on Paris’s bed (in the living room). Mother
grabbed her phone and recorded for the next 10 minutes. Paris
was hiding naked in the closet in Father’s bedroom and Father
was lying on his bed, asleep with “a shirt on and no pants.”
Mother slapped Father several times. Paris denied engaging in
sexual behavior with Father. She said she was “taking naked
pictures for her Snapchat.” When Paris heard the door opening,
she was startled and ran to the bedroom where Father was
sleeping. Father denied having sex with Paris. Law enforcement
arrested Mother as the aggressor.
The children’s social worker (CSW) interviewed Mother
about the incident. Mother said she arrived at Father’s home
and found Paris “naked inside the bedroom closet” while Father
was lying on a bed inside the same bedroom. Mother started
screaming and called the police. Paris denied sexual abuse by
Father and stated she was “taking naked pictures inside the
3
closet.” Mother told the CSW that Christopher spends the nights
at Father’s home because Mother works nights cleaning offices.
After this incident, Father and Mother broke up.
A few months later, on March 21, 2024, DCFS received a
referral alleging Father had sexually abused Paris. The referral
alleged that beginning in June 2023 when Paris was placed at
Father’s home, he began to sexually abuse her. The abuse
escalated to sexual intercourse. Paris was “afraid to tell the
truth about the abuse then” and did not report Father until
March 2024 when her half-sister in Oregon encouraged her to
report the abuse. Paris stated the sexual abuse lasted for about
six months. As for the November 28, 2023 incident, Paris
explained that “once the police left the residence, [Father] began
making statements such as ‘What am I going to do?’ and ‘How
can I get out of this?’ ” He “decided to come up with a cover story
for what had happened” and “convinced her to tell this story.”
She stated Father “used guilt to make her not tell anyone as he
would lose his kid, go to jail, and ruin his life.”
On April 2, 2024, the CSW interviewed Father and
completed a home assessment of his one-bedroom home. Father
denied sexually abusing Paris and denied having any contact
with her since she moved to Oregon in December 2023. As for the
November 28, 2023 incident, Father reported he was asleep and
heard someone running inside the bedroom and “fully woke up
when [M]other started yelling at him.” Father told the CSW that
Mother has previously slapped or hit him.
On April 3, 2024, Father’s drug tests results were positive
for marijuana. Father denied smoking when Christopher is in
his care.
In late April 2024, Sofia was born.
4
On April 30, 2024, the CSW interviewed Paris, who
confirmed she and Father engaged in sexual acts and intercourse
when she was under the age of 18. Paris reported the sexual
abuse started in June 2023 when she was placed in Father’s
home; they “would watch TV or shows on the couch and laying
down on the bed. It turned into that.” She “closed her eyes” and
was falling asleep when he began kissing her face and her “heart
sank.” He told her he “had gotten a ‘hard-on’ while watching the
movie with her” and “lifted the blanket off of his lap and revealed
a bulge in his pants.” He then placed his hands between her legs.
Paris revealed to the CSW she was a virgin before this. Father
purchased a package of three condoms and “they had used them
all.” Paris told the CSW that “sexual intercourse happened
mostly inside of the residence and once inside of the car” and “he
would have sex with her anywhere from one time a week up to 3
to 4 times a week.”
Paris confirmed the last time they had sex was on
November 28, 2023; she and Father were having sex in the living
room and upon hearing Mother’s entry into the home, Father
“ran to the bedroom, and quickly put on his clothes.” When
Mother entered the bedroom, Father “pretended to be asleep on
the bed.” Paris reported when she and Father had sex,
sometimes Christopher was at the home with them; “there were
times [Christopher] was awake and would be playing his video
games in another part of the house.” Father called Paris
“multiple times” after she moved out of his house on December 5,
2023, telling her he wanted her in his life and is in love with her.
She confirmed he was also in contact with her by text messages.
She previously denied the sexual abuse to law enforcement
5
because she did not want Father to get in trouble but decided to
disclose it after her half-sister encouraged her to do so.
B. Petition and Detention
On June 4, 2024, DCFS filed a Welfare and Institutions
Code2 section 300 petition on behalf of Chrisopher and Sophia. It
alleged:
• Counts b-1, d-1: Father “sexually abused the children’s
now adult paternal aunt, [Paris], when the paternal
aunt was a minor and resided in the children’s home.”
Father’s sexual abuse of Paris took place from June
through November 2023 while she was under Father’s
care and supervision. Paris is now a “non-minor
dependent of the court.” On numerous occasions in
2023, including November 28, 2023, Father sexually
abused Paris “by penetrating [her] vagina with [his]
penis, while the child Christopher was in the home.”
Mother “knew or reasonably should have known of the
sexual abuse” and allowed Father to have unlimited
access to and reside in the home with Paris and
Christopher. “Such sexual abuse of the children’s
paternal aunt by [Father], and [Mother’s] failure and
unwillingness to protect . . . endangers the children’s
physical health and safety and places the children at
substantial risk of serious harm, damage, danger, sexual
abuse.”
2 Undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.
6
At the June 18, 2024 detention hearing, minors’ counsel,
DCFS, and Mother all asked the court to detain the children from
Father. At the request of DCFS, Christopher testified in
chambers to support the request for detention. When asked if
anybody has touched his private parts, he answered, “No.”
Christopher acknowledged Paris used to live with him. When
asked, “What did [Paris and Father] do when they were
together?” Christopher answered, “They love” and confirmed
they were “in love.” When asked, “When your daddy and Paris
were together, what did they do together?” Christopher
answered, “They doing pow pow (phonetic).” Next, Christopher
was asked whether Mother and Father fight, and he stated,
“They all fight, and I just cry.” Christopher indicated they fight
“in the face” and demonstrated by taking “his left hand closed
into a ball and hit himself on the forehead.”
Following Christopher’s testimony, the juvenile court
detained the children from Father and released them to Mother’s
care. Father was permitted monitored visitation.
C. Continued Investigations
On July 8, 2024, Mother was interviewed by the CSW.
Initially Mother stated Christopher was asleep in his toddler bed
during the November 28, 2023 incident. Later during the same
interview, Mother admitted Christopher “woke up” and that
Mother and Father “acted like nothing was happening, and he
started playing on his tablet.”
Detective Gabriela Guillen of the Los Angeles County
Sheriff’s Department was assigned to the investigation of Paris’s
sexual abuse claims against Father. Detective Guillen informed
the CSW that Paris had reported to her that she was in a
romantic relationship with Father until March 2024.
7
During her July 10, 2024 interview with the CSW, Paris
reported Mother and Father would “fight a lot.” Paris witnessed
Mother hit Father “at least three times.” Paris stated Father
“will drink at work and at home” and has seen him drink. She
recalled an occasion where she left for a Halloween party and
found multiple bottles and cans of beer in the home upon
returning. Paris also reported that after she left Father’s home
in December 2023, he “continued to contact her, make her feel
guilty, and attempt to resume a relationship.” He was “very
obsessive” and would both call and text her. “[T]he last contact
was over a month ago and ‘he told me he still loves me and still
wanted to talk to me every day. He asked me to call him every
day.’ ” He tried to call her pet names, which made her
uncomfortable. When Paris informed Father of her new
boyfriend, he was “upset.”
The CSW interviewed Paris’s half-sister who reported Paris
disclosed the sexual abuse on December 5, 2023. The half-sister
was “in shock” when Paris explained Father had “anal sex and
oral [sex]” with her first and then “took her virginity.” Father
had asked Paris to take a Plan B pill; she contracted a sexually
transmitted disease for which she took medication.
D. First Amended Petition
On July 30, 2024, DCFS filed a first amended petition,
adding allegations pursuant to section 300, subdivisions (a) and
(b)(1), as follows:
Counts a-1, b-2: Father and Mother have a “history of
engaging in physical and verbal altercations in the presence of
the minor Christopher.” On November 28, 2023, Mother “struck”
Father several times. On prior occasions, the parents pushed
each other and threw objects at each other. Father previously
8
removed Mother from their home and “restricted her” from taking
Christopher. Mother previously “punched [Father] on the chest,
struck his face and pulled his hair.” The parents’ “violent
conduct” endangers the children’s physical health and safety,
creates a detrimental home environment, and places the children
at risk of serious physical harm.
E. Adjudication
On September 16, 2024, the juvenile court convened the
jurisdictional and dispositional hearing. After argument, the
juvenile court sustained the amended petition—counts b-1, b-2,
and d-1 as to Mother and counts a-1, b-1, b-2, and d-1 as to
Father. The court proceeded to disposition, finding return of the
children to Father detrimental to their safety, protection, or
physical or emotional well-being. They were ordered released to
Mother’s home, with monitored visitation by Father.
Father’s court-ordered case plan included participation in a
batterer’s intervention program, sex abuse counseling for
perpetrators, six random or on-demand drug/alcohol tests,
parenting classes, and individual counseling to address case
issues.
Father timely appealed.
F. Post-Disposition Events3
On February 11, 2025, while Father’s appeal was pending,
the juvenile court terminated the home-of-Mother order and
made a home-of-parents order. On June 6, 2025 the juvenile
3 We grant DCFS’s July 30, 2025 request for judicial notice
as to exhibits A and B—the minute orders issued February 11,
2025 and June 6, 2025. (Evid. Code, § 452, subds. (c), (d).)
9
court found the conditions justifying the initial assumption of
jurisdiction ceased to exist and are not likely to reoccur if
supervision is withdrawn. The court terminated jurisdiction over
the minor children.
DISCUSSION
Father argues on appeal that insufficient evidence supports
the juvenile court’s jurisdictional and dispositional findings,
warranting reversal of the court’s orders. DCFS contends
Father’s appeal is moot given post-disposition events or, in the
alternative, that substantial evidence supports the juvenile
court’s findings and orders.
We address these contentions below.
A. Justiciability/Mootness
1. Applicable Law
“A reviewing court must ‘ “decide on a case-by-case basis
whether subsequent events in a juvenile dependency matter
make a case moot and whether [its] decision would affect the
outcome in a subsequent proceeding.” ’ ” (In re D.P. (2023)
14 Cal.5th 266, 276.) “As a general rule, an order terminating
juvenile court jurisdiction renders an appeal from a previous
order in the dependency proceedings moot.” (In re C.C. (2009)
172 Cal.App.4th 1481, 1488.) “A court is tasked with the duty
‘ “to decide actual controversies by a judgment which can be
carried into effect, and not to give opinions upon moot questions
or abstract propositions, or to declare principles or rules of law
which cannot affect the matter in issue in the case before it.” ’ ”
(In re D.P., at p. 276.) A case becomes moot when events render
it impossible for a court, if it should decide the case in favor of
plaintiff, to grant him any effective relief. (Ibid.) An important
10
requirement for justiciability is the availability of effective relief.
(In re I.A. (2011) 201 Cal.App.4th 1484, 1489.)
A reviewing court may exercise its inherent discretion to
reach the merits of the parent’s arguments when “(1) the
jurisdictional finding serves as the basis for dispositional orders
that are also challenged on appeal; (2) the findings could be
prejudicial to the appellant or could impact the current or any
future dependency proceedings; and (3) the finding could have
consequences for the appellant beyond jurisdiction.” (In re A.R.
(2014) 228 Cal.App.4th 1146, 1150.)
2. Analysis
In light of the juvenile court’s order terminating
jurisdiction and releasing the children with a home-of-parents
order, DCFS argues this appeal should be dismissed as moot.
Father urges us to exercise our discretion to address the merits of
his appeal because the jurisdictional findings that his children
were at risk of sexual abuse or serious physical harm could be
prejudicial to him. Father argues the allegations concern
particularly pernicious or stigmatizing conduct as to both the
sexual abuse and domestic violence allegations, which may
detrimentally impact him in a future family law or dependency
court case. Father concedes that the children’s subsequent return
to his custody has technically mooted his challenge to the removal
order, but he requests that we exercise our discretion to reach the
merits.
We consider the merits of Father’s appeal as to jurisdiction.
The children will remain minors for a considerable length of time,
as Sofia is one year old and Christopher is six years old; future
action as to the children is possible, either in the family law or
dependency context, until they reach the age of majority. It is
11
also plausible Mother or the family law court may rely on the
juvenile court’s findings in making future, modified custody or
visitation orders; thus, prejudice in subsequent family law or
dependency proceedings is possible, rendering Father’s appeal
from the jurisdictional findings justiciable.
However, we agree with DCFS that Father’s challenge to
the juvenile court’s dispositional order removing the children
from his physical custody/care has been rendered moot by the
juvenile court’s order returning the children to both parents’ care,
with a home-of-parents order. Father has received the precise
relief he seeks by way of this appeal, and there is no further relief
we can provide as to removal. “[T]he critical factor in considering
whether a dependency appeal is moot is whether the appellate
court can provide any effective relief if it finds reversible error.”
(In re N.S. (2016) 245 Cal.App.4th 53, 60.) We decline to exercise
discretion to adjudicate the merits of his appeal of the removal
order and dismiss the appeal of that order as moot.
B. Substantial Evidence Supports the Juvenile Court’s
Jurisdictional Findings
On appeal, Father challenges the juvenile court’s
jurisdictional findings as to counts a-1, b-1, b-2, and d-1 for lack
of substantial evidence. When, as here, several bases of
jurisdiction are challenged on appeal, “[t]he reviewing court may
affirm a juvenile court judgment if the evidence supports the
decision on any one of several grounds.” (In re Jonathan B.
(1992) 5 Cal.App.4th 873, 875.) “[T]he paramount purpose
underlying dependency proceedings is the protection of the child.”
(Id. at p. 877.) Where one basis for jurisdiction is supported by
substantial evidence, the reviewing court does not need to
consider sufficiency of evidence to support other grounds. (See
12
Randi R. v. Superior Court (1998) 64 Cal.App.4th 67, 72 (Randi
R.); see also In re I.A., supra, 201 Cal.App.4th at p. 1492 [The
minor is a dependent if the actions of a parent bring the minor
within one of the statutory definitions of a dependent.].) “For this
reason, an appellate court may decline to address the evidentiary
support for any remaining jurisdictional findings once a single
finding has been found to be supported by the evidence.” (In re
I.A., at p. 1492.)
We proceed with our review of the juvenile court’s
jurisdictional findings per section 300, subdivision (b)(1)—i.e.,
counts b-1 and b-2. We need not reach the merits of the other
counts if we conclude counts b-1 and/or b-2 are supported by
substantial evidence.
1. Standard of Review
In reviewing a challenge to the sufficiency of the evidence
supporting jurisdictional findings and related dispositional
orders, we “consider the entire record to determine whether
substantial evidence supports the juvenile court’s findings.”
(In re T.V. (2013) 217 Cal.App.4th 126, 133; accord, In re I.J.
(2013) 56 Cal.4th 766, 773.) “Substantial evidence is evidence
that is ‘reasonable, credible, and of solid value’; such that a
reasonable trier of fact could make such findings.” (In re Sheila
B. (1993) 19 Cal.App.4th 187, 199.) In making our
determination, we draw all reasonable inferences from the
evidence to support the findings and orders of the dependency
court; we review the record in the light most favorable to the
court’s determinations and we note that issues of fact and
credibility are within the province of the trial court. (In re I.J., at
p. 773.) “ ‘ “We do not reweigh the evidence or exercise
independent judgment, but merely determine if there are
13
sufficient facts to support the findings of the trial court.” ’ ”
(Ibid.) We uphold the juvenile court’s findings unless they are
“ ‘ “so lacking in evidentiary support as to render them
unreasonable.” ’ ” (Jamieson v. City Council of the City of
Carpinteria (2012) 204 Cal.App.4th 755, 763.)
2. Applicable Law
Under section 300, subdivision (b)(1), a juvenile court may
assert jurisdiction over a child if “[t]he child has suffered, or there
is a substantial risk that the child will suffer, serious physical
harm or illness as a result of . . . [¶] (A) The failure or inability of
the child’s parent . . . to adequately supervise or protect the
child.” (§ 300, subd. (b)(1).) A jurisdictional finding under section
300, subdivision (b)(1) requires DCFS to demonstrate by a
preponderance of the evidence: (1) neglectful conduct by the
parent in one of the specified forms; (2) causation; and (3) serious
physical harm or illness to the child or a substantial risk of such
harm or illness. (In re L.W. (2019) 32 Cal.App.5th 840, 848.)
3. Analysis
We find substantial evidence supports the juvenile court’s
jurisdictional findings in counts b-1 and b-2—that Father’s
sexual abuse of his then-minor half-sister Paris and the parents’
history of domestic violence placed Christopher and Sofia at
substantial risk of harm pursuant to section 300,
subdivision (b)(1).
Within a few weeks of her placement at Father’s home
under his care and supervision, he began sexually abusing Paris
and continued to do so for the next six months. Paris reported to
the CSW that Father had sex with her one to four times a week
and that, oftentimes, Christopher “was awake and would be
14
playing his video games in another part of the house.”
Christopher testified and confirmed that Father and Paris were
“in love” and when asked what Paris and Father did when they
were together, Christopher answered, “They doing pow pow
(phonetic).” Mother admitted to the CSW during her July 8, 2024
interview that Christopher “woke up” during the November 28,
2023 incident and that Mother and Father “acted like nothing
was happening, and he started playing on his tablet.” The
juvenile court aptly noted at the June 18, 2024 hearing that “case
law . . . looks at various factors. Maybe . . . it was occurring in
the same room the boy was sleeping in, or it was occurring in the
home where the boy might possibly wander in, which here might
be an issue” since “Mother walked in, so surely [Christopher]
could have walked in.” We find the nature and extent of the
sexual abuse and the fact that it was conducted in a place
“capable of being observed” by other children, placed all the
children residing in the home at substantial risk of harm. (In re
Ana C. (2012) 204 Cal.App.4th 1317, 1332.)
Father argues the children would take 12 to 17 years to
reach Paris’s age when she was sexually abused, and so there
was no current risk of harm to Christopher and Sofia. We
disagree. In In re Ricky T. (2013) 214 Cal.App.4th 515, for
instance, Juan T.—maternal grandfather and legal guardian to
three-year-old Ricky T.—appealed the jurisdictional and
dispositional findings and orders made with respect to Ricky.
(Id. at p. 517.) Juan T. argued “his sexual abuse of his
stepgranddaughters, A.G. and D.G., then ages 12 and nine years,
is insufficient to show Ricky T. was at risk of harm in his care.”
(Ibid.) The reviewing court disagreed and concluded that Juan
T.’s “conviction of crimes involving sexual abuse of A.G. gave rise
15
to a presumption Ricky T. was at risk of harm in Juan T.’s care.”
(Ibid.) The reviewing court further found “given that Juan T.
boldly abused A.G. . . . , the juvenile court reasonably could
conclude Juan T. might sexually abuse a child in Ricky T.’s
presence.” (Ibid., italics added.) Overwhelmingly, case law
categorically holds that “sexual abuse of one child may constitute
substantial evidence of a risk to another child in the household—
even to a sibling of a different sex or age or to a half sibling.”
(Los Angeles County Dept. of Children & Family Services v.
Superior Court (2013) 215 Cal.App.4th 962, 968.)
As for the parents’ domestic violence, Mother stated Father
threw a mug with warm coffee at her back on September 17,
2023—when she was three months pregnant. Christopher was in
the house during the incident. Mother also stated Father was
physically abusive to her, had “pushed her around and had
thrown items around.” Mother admitted Christopher was usually
not asleep during past domestic violence incidents. Mother also
slapped Father several times during the November 28, 2023
incident, resulting in her arrest as the aggressor. Paris reported
domestic violence in Father’s home during her July 10, 2024
interview with the CSW. In addition, Christopher himself
testified that Mother and Father “fight, and I just cry.”
Christopher indicated his parents fight “in the face” and
demonstrated by taking “his left hand closed into a ball and hit
himself on the forehead.” We find this qualifies as substantial
evidence supporting the juvenile court’s jurisdictional finding
that the parents’ domestic violence placed the children at
substantial risk of harm.
16
We conclude that the evidence “view[ed] . . . in the light
most favorable to the juvenile court’s determinations” (In re
Yolanda L. (2017) 7 Cal.App.5th 987, 992) is sufficient to support
the jurisdictional findings in counts b-1 and b-2 as to Father. We
need not consider the sufficiency of the evidence as to the other
counts. (See Randi R., supra, 64 Cal.App.4th at p. 72; see also In
re I.A., supra, 201 Cal.App.4th at p. 1492.)
DISPOSITION
We affirm the juvenile court’s jurisdictional findings and
dismiss as moot Father’s appeal from the dispositional order.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
STRATTON, P. J.
We concur:
VIRAMONTES, J.
RUBIN, J.*
* Retired Presiding Justice of the Court of Appeal, Second
Appellate District, assigned by the Chief Justice pursuant to
article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution.
17
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.