CourtListener 10741571•People v. Ray CA1/5
Full text
Filed 11/24/25 P. v. Ray CA1/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or
ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FIVE
THE PEOPLE,
A171438
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v. (Alameda County
Super. Ct. No. 153993A)
EDWARD VINCENT RAY, JR.,
Defendant and Appellant.
Edward Vincent Ray, Jr. (appellant), appeals from the trial court’s
order denying appellant’s request for a transcript of audio discovery provided
to him pursuant to Penal Code section 1054.9.1 We reverse and remand for
further proceedings.
BACKGROUND
In 2007, appellant was convicted of 21 counts of second degree robbery
and sentenced to 38 years 4 months in state prison. (People v. Ray (Nov. 23,
2009, A117630) [nonpub. opn.].)
In 2022, appellant filed a motion for postconviction discovery. (People
v. Ray (Sept. 13, 2023, A166077) [nonpub. opn.].) As relevant here, appellant
1 All undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.
1
sought statements made by two accomplices. (Ibid.) We reversed the trial
court’s denial of this request, directing the trial court “to grant the motion as
to any recordings and/or transcripts of: (a) an Oakland Police Department
interview with Melissa Ray on or about August 29, 2006; and (b) an interview
by deputy district attorney Sabrina Farrell with Larry Carrington at the
North County Jail on March 5, 2007.” (Ibid.)
On remand, the People sent appellant audio recordings of the
interviews. Appellant subsequently filed a motion seeking an order directing
the People to also provide him with transcripts of the interviews.2 Appellant
submitted a report from a prison litigation coordinator stating that appellant
had the opportunity to listen to the audio recordings but, after listening, the
litigation coordinator would “mail the disk back . . . to the Alameda District
Attorney’s Office as inmates are not allow[ed] to retain a compact disc[].”
Appellant’s motion argued he was therefore unable “to possess this evidence”
and, further, the audio recording “is NOT an admissible or useable form of
evidence, that can be presented to a Court in support of his future filings of a
petition for writ of habeas corpus.”
The trial court issued a written order noting the prosecutor “has
advised this court that it has located a transcription of the Melissa Ray
interview in the file, and will provide that to Defendant.” As to the
Carrington interview, the court found that appellant “has provided no
information as to why it is needed. Defendant’s motion does not refer to any
specific content within the recording and does not explain how or why a
transcript is necessary to support his anticipated habeas petition.”
Accordingly, the court denied the request without prejudice “to Defendant
2 Appellant proceeded in propria persona in the trial court but is
represented by appointed counsel on appeal.
2
providing a satisfactory explanation of why he believes a transcript is
needed.”
Appellant filed a renewed motion seeking a transcript of Carrington’s
interview. Appellant asserted that Carrington’s statement “contain[s]
valuable[,] relevant impeachment evidence,” but provided no further
information. The trial court denied the motion, finding appellant again
“fail[ed] to include any information about the content of the interview or any
specific statements by Carrington, or why such statements constitute Brady[3]
material.”
DISCUSSION
“Section 1054.9 authorizes postconviction discovery in certain felony
cases.”4 (People v. Superior Court (Jones) (2021) 12 Cal.5th 348, 361.) Where
certain defendants are prosecuting or preparing to file a writ of habeas
corpus or a motion to vacate the judgment, and have made “a showing that
good faith efforts to obtain discovery materials from trial counsel were made
and were unsuccessful, the court shall,” with exceptions not relevant here,
“order that the defendant be provided reasonable access to any of the
materials described in subdivision (c).” (§ 1054.9, subd. (a), italics added.)
Section 1054.9, subdivision (c) provides, “For purposes of this section,
‘discovery materials’ means materials in the possession of the prosecution and
law enforcement authorities to which the same defendant would have been
entitled at time of trial.” (Italics added.)
3 Brady v. Maryland (1963) 373 U.S. 83.
4 Amendments to section 1054.9 enacted earlier this year are not yet in
effect and, in any event, are not material to our resolution of this appeal.
(Stats. 2025, ch. 444, § 1.)
3
Appellant has previously established his entitlement to the Carrington
interview under section 1054.9. (People v. Ray, supra, A166077.) The trial
court denied appellant’s request for a transcript of the interview on the
ground that appellant failed to demonstrate the content of the interview was
relevant or necessary to any future habeas corpus petition. Section 1054.9
does not impose any such requirement, and we see no basis to do so.
Accordingly, the content of the interview is not material to the question
before us.
The People argue that, because section 1054.9 discovery is limited to
materials “in the possession” of the prosecutor and the People do not possess
a transcript of the Carrington interview, they are therefore not required to
provide it. But the discovery material sought by appellant is the interview
itself; the transcript is merely a guide or aid to his use of this material. This
is consistent with the treatment of transcripts at trials, where courts
regularly allow their use to assist the factfinder while only admitting into
evidence the audio or video recording itself. (See People v. Jones (2017) 3
Cal.5th 583, 611 [trial court did not abuse its discretion by “permitting the
jurors to use a transcript of the conversation as an aid while listening to the
tape during trial”]; People v. Brown (1990) 225 Cal.App.3d 585, 599 [where no
showing that “the transcript was so inaccurate as to mislead the jury[,]
. . . the court did not abuse its discretion in allowing the jurors to use the
transcript as a guide while listening to the tape”].) Thus, that the People do
not possess a transcript is not the end of the inquiry.
Instead, we agree with appellant that the material question is whether
a transcript is required to ensure appellant has “reasonable access” to the
interview. Appellant argues we should resolve this question in his favor. To
4
be sure, appellant has established that he is unrepresented below,5 is unable
to retain the recording in prison, and was only able to listen to it on one
occasion. However, we conclude that whether a transcript is required for
appellant to have reasonable access to the Carrington interview is a
determination that should be made by the trial court in the first instance.
The trial court may wish to solicit additional information, for example, the
length of the interview, whether appellant was able to listen to it multiple
times or only once, and any other relevant information. Accordingly, we will
remand for further proceedings.6
DISPOSITION
The order is reversed and remanded for further proceedings.
SIMONS, J.
We concur.
JACKSON, P. J.
CHOU, J.
(A171438)
5 As the prosecutor represented to the trial court, if appellant “ha[d] his
own investigator or lawyer, I can send that person a copy of the interview so
he could have them more permanently.”
6 Appellant also argues that a transcript is required for any future
habeas corpus petition, relying on the requirement stated in People v. Duvall
(1995) 9 Cal.4th 464, 474, that such petitions should “include copies of
reasonably available documentary evidence supporting the claim.” For
guidance on remand, we agree with the trial court that, if the court
determines a transcript is not necessary to provide appellant with reasonable
access to the Carrington interview pursuant to section 1054.9, the transcript
is not “reasonably available” for purposes of any future habeas corpus
petition.
5
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.