Shochat v. Cohen CA2/7

CourtListener 10738414CalctappNov 18, 2025

Full text

Filed 11/18/25 Shochat v. Cohen CA2/7
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION SEVEN

AMOS SHOCHAT, B335222

Petitioner and (Los Angeles County
Appellant, Super. Ct. No.
23STRO00753)
v.

YORAM COHEN,

Respondent.

APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Gary C. Eto, Judge. Affirmed.
Amos Shochat, in pro. per., for Petitioner and Appellant.
Westwood Lawyers and Lottie Cohen for Respondent.
__________________________

Amos Shochat appeals from an order denying his request
for a civil harassment restraining order (CHRO) against Yoram
Cohen. Shochat contends the trial court abused its discretion by
barring him from calling Yoram’s wife, Lottie Cohen (who
represented Yoram at the hearing),1 as a witness and by not
considering other evidence of harassment Shochat claimed he
provided to the police and other government agencies. Shochat
also contends he presented sufficient evidence to support
issuance of a CHRO. Finally, he argues the court erroneously
made credibility determinations in granting Yoram’s motion to
dismiss at the close of Shochat’s evidentiary presentation. We
affirm.

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

A. Shochat’s Request for a Restraining Order
Shochat, representing himself, filed his request for a CHRO
on February 6, 2023, and the operative first amended request on
April 23, 2023. The request stated Yoram worked for the
apartment building where Shochat lived, and it sought an order
prohibiting Yoram from harassing or contacting Shochat and
requiring Yoram to stay 100 yards away from Shochat and his
home, car, and workplace.
In an attachment to his request, Shochat described three
incidents of alleged harassment. In May 2022 Shochat was
sitting outside his apartment when Yoram exited a car, crossed
the street toward him, “came close to [Shochat] with a fist closer
and closer,” then left after Shochat called 911.
In or around July 2022, Yoram came to Shochat’s
apartment “with another person and pushed himself inside . . . to
check something for a short time.” Shochat initially told Yoram

1 We refer to Yoram Cohen and Lottie Cohen by their first
names to avoid confusion.

2
not to come in but then let Yoram inside because Shochat “was
afraid of what [would] happen” if he refused.
In the most recent incident on January 28, 2023, Yoram
came to Shochat’s apartment to serve a notice to enter dwelling,
and Shochat saw Yoram opening and reaching into Shochat’s
mailbox. After Shochat began filming the incident, Yoram
“charg[ed] at [Shochat] from the right side and hit [him] in the
shoulder and the face.” Yoram then approached Shochat again,
started pushing him backward, and continued to approach him
despite Shochat shouting and warning that he would call 911.2
Shochat attached to his request copies of multiple notices to
enter his dwelling unit from late 2022 to early 2023 signed by
Lottie as the landlord and owner, screenshots from videos
allegedly taken during the May and July incidents (with
handwritten notes narrating what is purportedly shown in the
videos), and a largely illegible police report pertaining to the
January 28, 2023 incident.

B. Pre-hearing Proceedings
From the time Shochat filed his original CHRO request in
February 2023 to July 2023, Shochat had difficulty serving
Yoram with notice of his request and the hearing date. However,
on July 25, 2023, after Shochat testified to his attempts to serve
Yoram at three addresses, the trial court authorized Shochat to
provide alternative service by certified mail with return receipt
requested. On August 22 Shochat and Lottie (representing

2 Shochat’s request also cited two other incidents when he
was “attacked by twin brothers who cornered [him], and raised
their hands in [his] face.” Shochat stated he believed the
brothers acted based on “[Yoram’s] involvement.”

3
Yoram) appeared in court for the hearing on the CHRO.
However, a Hebrew language interpreter was not available for
Shochat, and the court continued the hearing to September 26,
2023.
On September 15, 2023 Shochat served Lottie by mail with
a subpoena duces tecum for personal appearance and production
of documents at the September 26 hearing.3 The trial court
continued the hearing to October 19 because an interpreter was
still not available. On October 16 Yoram filed objections to
Shochat’s subpoena with a supporting declaration from Lottie,
arguing service was defective and untimely under Code of Civil
Procedure section 1987.4

C. The Hearing on Shochat’s Request for a CHRO
The trial court held a hearing on Shochat’s request for a
CHRO on October 19, 2023. A Hebrew language interpreter
translated for Shochat. The court began the hearing by
explaining it would accept the statements and allegations in
Shochat’s request as his testimony, the court would summarize
those statements, and Shochat could correct the court’s summary
or provide additional details.
Shochat testified at the hearing that he had been living in
his apartment building for nine years and was told by Lottie that
Yoram was serving as the building’s manager. The May 2022

3 On our own motion, we augment the record to include the
proof of service Shochat filed on September 15, 2023 with respect
to his service of the subpoena duces tecum on Lottie. (Cal. Rules
of Court, rule 8.155(a)(1)(A).)
4 Further undesignated statutory references are to the Code
of Civil Procedure.

4
incident was the “first attack.” Shochat stated he was sitting on
the grass on the side of the road when Yoram exited Lottie’s
vehicle and started walking toward Shochat. Shochat told Yoram
to stay away several times as Yoram approached. But, as
Shochat explained, Yoram “continued coming towards me” and
“pushed his hand against my face, . . . [a]nd his ring was pushed
into my eye socket.”
With respect to the July 2022 incident, Shochat explained
that Lottie tried to serve him with a “forged” service order, but he
would not let her in. A few minutes later Yoram came with a
second man, who was six feet tall and weighed at least
300 pounds. Yoram pressured Shochat to permit his entry,
blocked the door, and started coming in. Shochat was afraid and
stepped aside. Once Yoram was inside, he started taking
pictures despite Yoram’s request to stop. The second man
prevented Shochat from leaving.
Shochat explained with respect to the January 28, 2023
incident (described in the request as when Shochat hit Yoram in
the face and right shoulder), that Yoram served him with a
“falsified” notice to enter his apartment. Shochat was
videotaping the service, and he suddenly “felt an impact and a
push on [his] right side” by Yoram. Several seconds later, Yoram
approached him again. Shochat started yelling to stay away from
him, but Yoram came closer and was “not more than
two . . . inches” away when Shochat put up his arm to prevent
Yoram from hitting him.5

5 Shochat started to testify regarding a fourth incident in
2022 involving a contractor forcibly entering his apartment and
“cuss[ing] him out.” Shochat stated the contractor said he was
sent by Yoram, but the trial court sustained Yoram’s objection on

5
Shochat then offered to present videos of the three
incidents,6 and the trial court directed him to first show “the best
one you have.” As described by the court, the first video depicted
a man (who the court assumed was Yoram) “walking across the
street in a suit with his hands in his pocket. . . . [¶] . . . with his
hand up not wanting to be videoed, apparently.” The man then
“seem[ed] to be moving away or at least moving to . . . [his] left”
before “walking away, then turning to say something . . ., and
then crossing the street again with his hands in his pocket.” The
court stated the video was “of little or no probative value” because
“it [did]n’t depict an act.”
The trial court next asked Shochat if he had another video
showing Yoram attacking him. Shochat played a video that the
court described as showing a man (again, presumably Yoram)
stooping over a box, picking something up, and then “walking
away . . . holding something.” The video then showed Lottie
sitting in a car. The court stated it did not see Shochat or any
assault or attack in the video. Shochat responded that he was
holding the camera. Shochat next presented a photograph of
himself holding a newspaper purchased a few days after the
January 2023 incident to “prove that [Yoram] hit [him].” The
court described the photograph simply as “a picture of [Shochat]
holding a newspaper.”
The trial court then inquired whether Shochat had
anything else to present, and Shochat stated he “would like . . . to

the basis there was no evidence Yoram sent the person. Shochat
does not challenge this ruling on appeal.
6 None of the videos Shochat offered at the hearing is part of
the record on appeal. However, the trial court described the
content of the videos as they were played.

6
get access to the subpoena materials that are in the file.” The
court noted Yoram had filed objections to two subpoenas duces
tecum Shochat had served on Lottie. The court sustained the
objections on the basis the subpoenas were improperly served by
mail.
Yoram then moved to dismiss Shochat’s request for a
CHRO on the basis he had not shown credible evidence of
violence or threats of violence. In response, the trial court asked,
“Do you have any other evidence, Mr. Shochat?” Shochat
responded, “No, I don’t, but—I don’t.” The court stated it had
“heard the evidence, read the files, . . . and observed [Shochat]
testify and his demeanor, [and the] court does not find petitioner
credible. [The] court finds that the petitioner has not sustained
his burden of proof by clear and convincing evidence.” On this
basis, the court denied Shochat’s CHRO request.
Shochat timely appealed.

DISCUSSION

A. Governing Law and Standard of Review
Under section 527.6, subdivision (a)(1), “[a] person who has
suffered harassment . . . may seek a temporary restraining order
and an order after hearing prohibiting harassment as provided in
this section.” “Harassment” is defined as “unlawful violence, a
credible threat of violence, or a knowing and willful course of
conduct directed at a specific person that seriously alarms,
annoys, or harasses the person, and that serves no legitimate
purpose.” (§ 527.6, subd. (b)(3).)
“Unlawful violence” is “any assault or battery, or stalking
as prohibited in Section 646.9 of the Penal Code, but does not

7
include lawful acts of self-defense or defense of others.” (§ 527.6,
subd. (b)(7).) An “assault” is “an unlawful attempt, coupled with
a present ability, to commit a violent injury on the person of
another.” (Pen. Code, § 240.) A “battery” is “any willful and
unlawful use of force or violence upon the person of another.”
(Pen. Code, § 242.) “Credible threat of violence” is a “knowing
and willful statement or course of conduct that would place a
reasonable person in fear for the person’s safety or the safety of
the person’s immediate family, and that serves no legitimate
purpose.” (§ 527.6, subd. (b)(2).)
“Course of conduct” is defined as “a pattern of conduct
composed of a series of acts over a period of time, however short,
evidencing a continuity of purpose, including following or
stalking an individual, making harassing telephone calls to an
individual, or sending harassing correspondence to an individual
by any means, including, but not limited to, the use of public or
private mails, interoffice mail, facsimile, or email.” (§ 527.6,
subd. (b)(1).)
“‘Section 527.6 was enacted “to protect the individual’s
right to pursue safety, happiness and privacy as guaranteed by
the California Constitution.” [Citations.] It does so by providing
expedited injunctive relief to victims of harassment.’” (Parisi v.
Mazzaferro (2016) 5 Cal.App.5th 1219, 1227, disapproved on
another ground in Conservatorship of O.B. (2020) 9 Cal.5th 989,
1010, fn. 7; accord, Brekke v. Wills (2005) 125 Cal.App.4th 1400,
1412.) “If the judge finds by clear and convincing evidence that
unlawful harassment exists, an order shall issue prohibiting the
harassment.” (§ 527.6, subd. (i).)
“[W]hen presented with a challenge to the sufficiency of the
evidence associated with a finding requiring clear and convincing

8
evidence, the court [generally] must determine whether the
record, viewed as a whole, contains substantial evidence from
which a reasonable trier of fact could have made the finding of
high probability demanded by this standard of proof.”
(Conservatorship of O.B., supra, 9 Cal.5th at p. 1005.) However,
“‘[i]n a case where the trier of fact has determined that the party
with the burden of proof did not carry its burden and that party
appeals, “it is misleading to characterize the failure-of-proof issue
as whether substantial evidence supports the judgment [or
order].” [Citations.] Instead, “where the issue on appeal turns on
a failure of proof at trial, the question for a reviewing court
becomes whether the evidence compels a finding in favor of the
appellant as a matter of law.” [Citation.] Specifically, we ask
“whether the appellant’s evidence was (1) ‘uncontradicted and
unimpeached’ and (2) ‘of such a character and weight as to leave
no room for a judicial determination that it was insufficient to
support a finding.’”’ [Citation.] This is ‘an onerous standard’
[citation] and one that is ‘almost impossible’ for a losing [party] to
meet, because unless the trier of fact made specific factual
findings in favor of the losing [party], we presume the trier of fact
concluded that ‘[the party’s] evidence lacks sufficient weight and
credibility to carry the burden of proof.’” (Estes v. Eaton Corp.
(2020) 51 Cal.App.5th 636, 651; accord, In re A.P. (2024)
103 Cal.App.5th 1137, 1142.)

9
B. The Trial Court Did Not Err in Denying Shochat’s Request
for a Restraining Order7
1. The trial court did not erroneously bar Shochat from
calling Lottie as a witness
Shochat contends the trial court erred by prohibiting him
from calling Lottie as a witness at the October 19 hearing.
However, the record shows Shochat never made this request. As
discussed, Shochat provided his own testimony at the October 19
hearing, and the court considered two videos of incidents he
alleged in his request for a CHRO. When the court asked
Shochat whether he had any additional evidence, Shochat
requested access to the documents he had subpoenaed, but he did
not request to examine Lottie. After Yoram moved to dismiss
Shochat’s request for a CHRO, the court provided Shochat yet
another opportunity to present further evidence, asking “do you
have any other evidence?” Shochat responded by stating, “Well,
no, I don’t, but—I don’t. [¶] . . . [¶] He attacked me. I’m not
lying.” Then he added, “And there are many people who are
attacked, and they don’t have a video of the attack.” Shochat did
not make any further statements or request to call Lottie or any
other witness. In the absence of a request by Shochat to call

7 We do not address the following issues that were raised by
the parties in their appellate briefing because they are not
relevant to this appeal (many of which are also not supported by
an adequate record): Shochat’s current mental state; Shochat’s
prior and ongoing civil harassment lawsuits against Yoram and
Lottie; and the history of inspection and repair notices for
Shochat’s apartment. We also do not reach Shochat’s contention
the trial court erred in failing to accept a prior proof of service of
his request for CHRO on Yoram. Because Yoram was ultimately
served, this issue is not before us on appeal from the CHRO.

10
Lottie as a witness, he forfeited his challenge to the denial of his
right to examine Lottie. (Mendoza v. Ramos (2010)
182 Cal.App.4th 680, 687 [appellant’s failure to request live
testimony at a hearing forfeited his right to challenge denial of
right to examine witness]; see In re Marriage of Cohen (2023)
89 Cal.App.5th 574, 582 [same].)8

2. Shochat’s evidence did not compel a finding of
harassment as a matter of law
Shochat contends the trial court erred because he
presented sufficient evidence to support issuance of the CHRO,
including his testimony, the videos, and the photographs.
Shochat has failed to meet his burden to show the evidence he
presented compels a finding of harassment as a matter of law.
Shochat argues the videos he presented at the hearing
show the “attacks and assaults” by Yoram. The record does not
support this contention. Although Shochat testified that in
May 2022 Yoram approached him with his fist extended and
pushed his ring into Shochat’s eye socket, the first video played
(which appears to be of the May 2022 incident) only showed

8 Shochat does not contend his request to “access . . . the
subpoena materials” was intended as a request to call Lottie as a
witness (as opposed to obtaining subpoenaed documents). In any
event, Shochat’s service of the subpoena duces tecum on Lottie
was defective. Under section 1987, subdivision (a), a subpoena
compelling a nonparty witness’s attendance must be served
personally. (See § 1987, subd. (a) [with limited exceptions for
public employees, “the service of a subpoena is made by
delivering a copy, or a ticket containing its substance, to the
witness personally”].) The proof of service Shochat lodged with
the court shows he served the subpoena on Lottie by mail.

11
Yoram walking with his hand up to avoid being recorded before
he walked away. Similarly, Shochat testified that Yoram hit him
in the shoulder and face on January 28, 2023, but the second
video Shochat played (which appears to be of that incident) did
not show any assault or attack. According to the court’s colloquy
with Shochat during the hearing, these were the best videos
Shochat had of the alleged incidents of harassment. Shochat also
relies on photographs of bruises on his face, but the record does
not contain any photographs showing bruises.
The trial court weighed the video and photographic
evidence, along with Shochat’s testimony at the hearing and in
his CHRO request, and after determining Shochat lacked
credibility, the court found he had not provided clear and
convincing evidence of harassment. We defer to the court’s
credibility findings and do not reweigh the evidence. (Herriott v.
Herriott (2019) 33 Cal.App.5th 212, 223 [“It was for the trial court
to weigh the evidence and consider the demeanor and credibility
of the witness, as ‘credibility issues [are] routinely resolved by
[the] trier[ ] of fact.’”]; In re Marriage of Evilsizor & Sweeney
(2015) 237 Cal.App.4th 1416, 1426-1427 [“the trial court was in
the best position to evaluate credibility and to resolve factual
disputes”].)
Shochat also argues the trial court abused its discretion by
not considering evidence presented to various government
agencies including the Los Angeles Police Department and the
Los Angeles County District Attorney’s Office. However, the only
documents in the record from governmental entities are a largely
illegible police report for the January 2023 incident and two
letters from the Los Angeles Housing Department confirming
receipt of housing violation complaints filed by Shochat. Shochat

12
has failed to identify any other documents in the record that
support his contention. (See Nellie Gail Ranch Owners Assn. v.
McMullin (2016) 4 Cal.App.5th 982, 996 [on appeal, “‘“the
appellant bears the burden of providing an adequate record
affirmatively proving error”’”]; Acquire II, Ltd. v. Colton Real
Estate Group (2013) 213 Cal.App.4th 959, 970 [same].) The
documents in the record do not provide evidence of harassment
by Yoram and therefore do not compel a finding in his favor.

3. The trial court did not misapply the standard for
ruling on a request for a CHRO
Shochat contends the trial court erred in denying his
request for CHRO because the court improperly based its decision
on Shochat’s credibility instead of accepting Shochat’s evidence
as true, as required in ruling on a motion for nonsuit under
section 581c.9 Shochat is correct that a court, when ruling on a
section 581c motion for nonsuit, may not consider witness
credibility. (Campbell v. General Motors Corp. (1982) 32 Cal.3d
112, 118; Murray’s Iron Works, Inc. v. Boyce (2008)
158 Cal.App.4th 1279, 1285.) However, section 581c only applies
to a motion for a judgment of nonsuit in a jury trial. (See § 581c,
subd. (a) [“Only after, and not before, the plaintiff has completed
his or her opening statement, or after the presentation of his or

9 At the hearing, Yoram requested the trial court “dismiss
the case,” without specifying a section of the Code of Civil
Procedure. In his respondent’s brief, Yoram incorrectly
characterized the motion as an oral motion for nonsuit pursuant
to section 581c. However, the court never treated the motion as
one for a nonsuit, nor, as we discuss, would a section 581c motion
have been proper.

13
her evidence in a trial by jury, the defendant, without waiving his
or her right to offer evidence in the event the motion is not
granted, may move for a judgment of nonsuit.”].)
Requests for a CHRO are tried before the trial court, which
serves as both the factfinder and decisionmaker. (See § 527.6,
subd. (i) [“At the hearing, the judge shall receive any testimony
that is relevant, and may make an independent inquiry. If the
judge finds by clear and convincing evidence that unlawful
harassment exists, an order shall issue prohibiting the
harassment.”].) “[I]n a trial by the court a motion for nonsuit is
not recognized. The correct motion is for judgment pursuant to
Code of Civil Procedure section 631.8, the purpose of which is to
enable the court, after weighing the evidence at the close of the
plaintiff’s case, to find the plaintiff has failed to sustain the
burden of proof, without the need for the defendant to produce
evidence.” (Ford v. Miller Meat Co. (1994) 28 Cal.App.4th 1196,
1200; accord, Jazayeri v. Mao (2009) 174 Cal.App.4th 301, 315,
fn. 23.) Moreover, in a motion for judgment under section 631.8,
unlike a motion for nonsuit, “the trial court must decide questions
of credibility, must weigh the evidence, and must make findings
of fact.” (Lingenfelter v. County of Fresno (2007) 154 Cal.App.4th
198, 204, italics added; see Jazayeri, at p. 314, fn. 23.)
We therefore construe Yoram’s motion to dismiss, made at
the close of Shochat’s case, as a motion for judgment in a court
trial under section 631.8. (See Jazayeri v. Mao, supra,
174 Cal.App.4th at p. 314, fn. 23 [deeming a mislabeled motion
for “nonsuit” as made under section 631.8].) Accordingly, the

14
trial court permissibly weighed the evidence and made credibility
determinations at the October 19 hearing.

DISPOSITION

The order denying Shochat’s request for a civil harassment
restraining order against Yoram is affirmed. Yoram is to recover
his costs on appeal.

FEUER, J.
We concur:

SEGAL, Acting P. J.

STONE, J.

15

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.