Rhyne v. Does 1 through 100 CA2/1

CourtListener 10734291CalctappNov 10, 2025

Full text

Filed 11/10/25 Rhyne v. Does 1 through 100 CA2/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION ONE

CHARLIE RHYNE, B344861

Plaintiff and Appellant, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. 23BBCV00009)
v.

DOES 1 THROUGH 100,
INCLUSIVE et al.,

Defendants and Respondents.

APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County, Sarah J. Heidel, Judge. Appeal dismissed.
Bay Cities Law Group and Steven Zelig for Plaintiff and
Appellant.
No appearance for Defendants and Respondents.
____________________________
Code of Civil Procedure1 section 340.1, which governs civil
actions arising from childhood sexual assault, requires under
certain circumstances that a defendant be designated as a “Doe”
in the pleadings “until there has been a showing of corroborative
fact as to the charging allegations against that defendant.”
(§ 340.1, former subd. (l).)2
In this case, the trial court denied plaintiff Charlie Rhyne’s
request to substitute defendant Doe 2’s true name into the
complaint. The court found plaintiff’s counsel’s “certificate of
corroborative fact” deficient because the sole corroboration came
from plaintiff herself. Plaintiff appealed, contending
section 340.1 allows a plaintiff to corroborate her own complaint.
We conclude the trial court’s denial of plaintiff’s request to
use Doe 2’s true name in the complaint is not an appealable
order. Plaintiff identifies no statutory basis for the appeal.
Rather, she argues the trial court’s ruling constitutes a
“dismissal per se” because she claims she cannot serve Doe 2
until Doe 2 is actually named in the complaint. Section 340.1,
however, does not preclude service on a Doe defendant—indeed,
the statute contemplates that in some cases the defendant’s
actual name will not be substituted in until after the defendant
has appeared in the action. The trial court’s denial of plaintiff’s
request to use Doe 2’s actual name in the complaint therefore
does not prevent the action from proceeding.

1Undesignated statutory citations are to the Code of Civil
Procedure.
2 As we explain post, a former version of section 340.1 is
applicable to plaintiff’s case.

2
Accordingly, we dismiss the appeal.3

BACKGROUND
On January 3, 2023, plaintiff filed a complaint alleging a
school employee sexually molested her on multiple occasions in
1968 and 1969, when plaintiff was seven and eight years old. She
named as defendants the school, the school district, and the
alleged perpetrator. Pursuant to section 340.1, the complaint
identified the school and school district as Does 1 and 2,
respectively. Pursuant to sections 340.1 and 474, the complaint
identified the perpetrator as Doe 3. The complaint also listed
unidentified defendants Does 4–100 pursuant to section 474.
On February 24, 2023, plaintiff’s counsel and a mental
health practitioner filed certificates of merit as required by
section 340.1.
At a case management conference on May 31, 2023,
plaintiff’s counsel stated he had yet to serve the summons and
complaint. The trial court ordered him to do so.
On November 3, 2023, Doe 2, the school district, moved to
quash service of summons. Doe 2 argued plaintiff could not
include Doe 2 as a defendant unless plaintiff either used Doe 2’s
actual name in the complaint, or plaintiff satisfied the

3 On October 21, 2025, plaintiff filed a “Motion for
Immediate Disposition Without Oral Argument, Or If The Court
Has Questions, An Early Hearing Pursuant to Rule 8.240 of the
California Rules of Court” (some capitalization omitted). In her
motion, plaintiff requests we decide this appeal without oral
argument. Because respondents have not made an appearance in
this appeal, we address the appeal without argument and
pursuant to an early submission order. Plaintiff’s motion is thus
moot.

3
requirements for serving fictitiously named defendants under
section 474. Doe 2 contended plaintiff could not, however, use
Doe 2’s actual name because plaintiff had not filed a certificate of
corroborative fact, nor had plaintiff complied with section 474,
because she had not alleged in the complaint that she was
ignorant of Doe 2’s name. Doe 2 further contended plaintiff
did not provide sufficient certificates of merit.
Plaintiff did not oppose the motion to quash. At the
hearing on the motion, held on December 8, 2023, plaintiff’s
counsel indicated he had withdrawn service due to a technical
defect and assumed Doe 2 therefore would withdraw its motion.
Doe 2’s counsel stated Doe 2 did not intend to withdraw its
motion. Plaintiff’s counsel stated, “I don’t mind if the motion to
quash is granted because I have withdrawn service.” The court
stated, “I will grant the motion, apparently [plaintiff’s counsel] is
going to serve it again and then [Doe 2] can move to quash again
or whatever [its] response should be.”
The trial court then issued a written order granting the
motion to quash. It found, “Plaintiff has not complied with the
code to properly name [Doe 2] as a defendant . . . in this action,
either pursuant to [section] 340.1 or [section] 474.” The court
further found plaintiff’s certificates of merit did not comply with
section 340.1. Plaintiff did not appeal that ruling.4
On October 21, 2024, plaintiff’s counsel filed an “attorney
certificate of corroborative facts.” (Capitalization omitted.) In
the certificate, plaintiff’s counsel states he had interviewed
plaintiff, who “appears to be the only witness to the specific

4 Orders granting motions to quash are appealable under
section 904.1, subdivision (a)(3).

4
sexual assault per se,” and summarized the information she had
provided to him regarding the molestation.
On that same date, plaintiff filed a motion seeking
permission, based on the certificate of corroborative facts, to list
Doe 2’s actual name in the complaint and serve Doe 2.
In a tentative ruling dated November 20, 2024, the court
stood by the finding it made when it granted the earlier motion to
quash, that is, that plaintiff’s certificates of merit were
insufficient to allow service on Doe 2. It further found the
certificate of corroborative fact was insufficient because it “relies
only [on] the plaintiff’s allegations and information provided by
plaintiff. Corroboration means to provide evidence that would
support a contention. Merely reiterating the allegations in the
complaint is not corroboration. Indeed, if the Certificate of
Corroborative Fact could be satisfied by statements and
information provided by the plaintiff there would be no point to
the requirement.” The court then denied plaintiff’s request to
name Doe 2 in the complaint.
After issuing its tentative ruling, the trial court heard
argument on November 22, 2024 and took the matter under
submission. On November 27, 2024, plaintiff filed a
supplemental brief arguing she had submitted adequate
certificates of merit, copies of which she attached to her brief. As
for the certificate of corroborative fact, plaintiff argued section
340.1 does not require independent corroboration apart from
plaintiff herself.
The trial court issued its ruling on December 13, 2024. In a
section of the ruling entitled “Motion to Name Doe 2,” the court
reiterated its conclusion from its tentative ruling that plaintiff
could not herself corroborate the allegations in the complaint for

5
purposes of section 340.1: “It would make little sense to permit
the plaintiff to act as the corroborating witness since any plaintiff
could satisfy the corroborative fact requirement by reiterating
their own allegations in the complaint.”
In a section of the ruling entitled “Motion to Serve Doe 2,”
the court departed from its tentative ruling on the question of the
certificates of merit, now finding those certificates complied with
section 340.1. It stated, however, “[P]laintiff still has not
addressed the basis for the court’s December 8, 2023 order to
quash under [section] 474. Accordingly, the court denies the
motion to serve Doe 2.”
Plaintiff filed a notice of appeal from the December 13,
2024 order. Plaintiff also challenged the order by petition for
writ of mandate, which we summarily denied on April 2, 2025.

DISCUSSION

A. Applicable Law
Section 340.1 sets forth procedural requirements for civil
actions arising from childhood sexual assault. In this opinion, we
cite the version of the statute in effect when plaintiff filed her
complaint. (See Stats. 2022, ch. 444, § 1.)5
At issue here are special requirements applicable to
complaints filed by “plaintiff[s] 40 years of age or older at the

5 The current statute eliminates the statute of limitations
for claims arising from childhood sexual assault. (§ 340.1,
subd. (a)). It applies only to claims arising from sexual assaults
occurring on and after January 1, 2024. (Id., subd. (p)). The
procedural requirements at issue in this appeal are materially
identical in both the current statute and the prior version
applicable to plaintiff’s complaint.

6
time the action is filed,” as plaintiff is in this case. (§ 340.1,
former subd. (f).) These requirements are “procedural safeguards
designed to protect against meritless childhood sexual abuse
claims” brought by plaintiffs above a specified age. (Sen. Com. on
Judiciary, Analysis of Assem. Bill No. 2846 (1993–1994 Reg.
Sess.), as amended June 14, 1994, p. 7.)6
Before a plaintiff aged 40 or older may serve a defendant
with a complaint alleging childhood sexual assault, plaintiff’s
counsel and a mental health practitioner must execute
“[c]ertificates of merit.” (§ 340.1, former subd. (g).) Counsel must
declare that, based on counsel’s review of the facts and
consultation with at least one mental health practitioner, “there
is reasonable and meritorious cause for the filing of the action.”
(Id., former subd. (g)(1).) The mental health practitioner must
declare, inter alia, that “there is a reasonable basis to believe
that the plaintiff had been subject to childhood sexual abuse.”
(Id., former subd. (g)(2).) Both declarations must “set[ ] forth the
facts which support the declaration.” (Id., former subd. (g).) The
plaintiff may not serve a defendant “until the court has reviewed
the certificates of merit . . . and has found, in camera, based
solely on those certificates of merit, that there is reasonable and
meritorious cause for the filing of the action against that
defendant.” (Id., former subd. (i).)
In addition to the above subdivisions concerning service on
a defendant, section 340.1 has subdivisions concerning how that

6 The procedural requirements at issue in this case largely
mirror those first enacted by Assembly Bill No. 2846 (Stats. 1994,
ch. 288, § 1). As first enacted, the requirements applied to
plaintiffs aged 26 and older. In 2019, the Legislature raised the
age to 40 years and older. (Stats. 2019, ch. 861, § 1.)

7
defendant is to be identified in the complaint. Section 340.1,
former subdivision (l) provides, “In any action subject to [former]
subdivision (f)”—that is, any action filed by a plaintiff aged 40 or
older—“a defendant shall be named by ‘Doe’ designation in any
pleadings or papers filed in the action until there has been a
showing of corroborative fact as to the charging allegations
against that defendant.” (§ 340.1, former subd. (l).)
If a plaintiff wishes “to amend the complaint to substitute
the name of the defendant or defendants for the fictitious
designation,” plaintiff’s counsel must execute “a certificate of
corroborative fact.” (§ 340.1, former subd. (m)(1).) “The
certificate shall declare that the attorney has discovered one or
more facts corroborative of one or more of the charging
allegations against a defendant or defendants, and shall set forth
in clear and concise terms the nature and substance of the
corroborative fact. If the corroborative fact is evidenced by the
statement of a witness or the contents of a document, the
certificate shall declare that the attorney has personal knowledge
of the statement of the witness or of the contents of the
document, and the identity and location of the witness or
document shall be included in the certificate.” (Ibid.) “The court
shall review the application and the certificate of corroborative
fact in camera and, based solely on the certificate and any
reasonable inferences to be drawn from the certificate, shall, if
one or more facts corroborative of one or more of the charging
allegations against a defendant has been shown, order that the
complaint may be amended to substitute the name of the
defendant or defendants.” (Id., former subd. (n).)

8
B. The Trial Court’s Order Denying Plaintiff’s Request
To Name Doe 2 in the Complaint Is Not An
Appealable Order
On appeal, plaintiff argues the trial court erred in rejecting
her counsel’s certificate of corroborative fact for lack of
corroboration by someone other than plaintiff. Plaintiff contends
pursuant to the language of section 340.1, plaintiff may herself
provide the corroboration required under section 340.1, former
subdivision (m)(1).
We cannot reach plaintiff’s arguments because the trial
court’s ruling is not an appealable order. There is no final
judgment in this case. An order denying permission to substitute
a defendant’s name for the Doe designation under section 340.1
is not listed among the appealable orders under section 904.1, nor
does plaintiff identify any other statute rendering the order
appealable. (Arzate v. ACE American Ins. Co. (2025)
108 Cal.App.5th 1191, 1197 [“ ‘the right of appeal is wholly
statutory in origin’ ”].)
Plaintiff argues the trial court’s order is appealable because
it “effectively constitutes a dismissal per se, or a ‘death knell’
relative to subsequent proceedings.” Plaintiff contends
substituting Doe 2’s name into the complaint is a prerequisite to
serving Doe 2. Because the trial court rejected plaintiff’s
certificate of corroborative fact and denied her request to name
Doe 2 in the complaint, “the case is doomed as service will not be
able to be effectuated on [Doe 2].”
Plaintiff’s premise is incorrect. The statute does not
preclude her from serving a Doe defendant absent a certificate of
corroborative fact. Instead, that certificate is a prerequisite to
substituting the true name of a Doe defendant in the complaint.

9
Nothing in section 340.1 indicates a plaintiff may not serve a
defendant designated as Doe under that statute. The statutory
prerequisite for service in cases involving plaintiffs over the age
of 40 is the trial court’s approval of certificates of merit. (See
§ 340.1, former subd. (i) [“a defendant shall not be served . . .
until the court has reviewed the certificates of merit . . . and has
found . . . that there is reasonable and meritorious cause for the
filing of the action against that defendant”].) The trial court in
the instant case approved plaintiff’s certificates of merit, and
therefore plaintiff satisfied section 340.1’s requirements for
service on Doe 2. The trial court’s rejection of plaintiff’s
certificate of corroborative fact affected whether she could
substitute Doe 2’s true name in the complaint but not whether
she could serve Doe 2.
Other language in section 340.1 supports our conclusion
that a plaintiff may serve a defendant under the statute even if
the court has yet to grant permission to substitute the
defendant’s true name for the Doe designation. Former
subdivision (m)(3) of the statute provides, “If the application to
name a defendant is made after that defendant’s appearance in
the action, the application shall be served on all parties and proof
of service provided to the court, but the certificate of
corroborative fact by the attorney shall not be served on any
party or their counsel of record.”7 (§ 340.1, former subd. (m)(3),
italics added.) This language contemplates that “an application
to name a defendant”—that is, a request “for permission to
amend the complaint to substitute the name of the defendant . . .

7 The current version of section 340.1 contains a similar
provision. (See § 340.1, subd.(l)(3).)

10
for the fictitious designation” (id., former subd. (m))—can be filed
after the defendant has been served and appeared in the action.
We further observe the trial court here did not deny
plaintiff’s request to serve Doe 2 because of the purported
insufficient certificate of corroborative fact. The court divided
plaintiff’s requests into two parts—a motion to name Doe 2, and a
motion to serve Doe 2. The trial court rejected the certificate of
corroborative fact in the context of the motion to name Doe 2. It
separately concluded although plaintiff’s certificates of merit
were sufficient, plaintiff had failed to address the trial court’s
earlier finding that she had not complied with section 474, and
denied the motion to serve Doe 2 on that basis.
Section 474 governs the use of fictitious names when a
plaintiff “is ignorant of the name of a defendant.” (§ 474.)8 It
is not clear from the record why the trial court found section 474
applicable here, where plaintiff designated Doe 2 fictitiously not
because she was ignorant of Doe 2’s true identity, but instead,
pursuant to the requirements of section 340.1, former
subdivision (l). In the section of her appellate brief summarizing

8 Under section 474, the plaintiff must state in the
complaint the fact that plaintiff is ignorant of the defendant’s
name, “and when [the defendant’s] true name is discovered, the
pleading or proceeding must be amended accordingly.” (§ 474.)
Further, “no default or default judgment shall be entered against
a defendant so designated, unless it appears that the copy of the
summons or other process, or, if there be no summons or process,
the copy of the first pleading or notice served upon such
defendant bore on the face thereof a notice stating in substance:
‘To the person served: You are hereby served in the within action
(or proceedings) as (or on behalf of) the person sued under the
fictitious name of (designating it).’ ” (Ibid.)

11
the procedural history of the case, plaintiff observes any
allegation she did not know Doe 2’s identity would have been
false. Plaintiff, however, did not address section 474 below and
mentions it only tangentially on appeal in summarizing the case’s
procedural history. We thus would not reach the matter even if
arguendo denial of permission to serve Doe 2 were appealable.
In sum, plaintiff has not demonstrated the trial court’s
denial of plaintiff’s request to use Doe 2’s actual name is the
death knell plaintiff posits, and plaintiff’s argument that the
denial is appealable as a per se dismissal fails.

DISPOSITION
The appeal is dismissed. No costs are awarded.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.

BENDIX, J.

We concur:

ROTHSCHILD, P. J.

WEINGART, J.

12

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.