People v. Mudashiru CA3

CourtListener 10733245CalctappNov 7, 2025

Full text

Filed 11/7/25 P. v. Mudashiru CA3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for publication or
ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or ordered published for
purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

THIRD APPELLATE DISTRICT

(Sacramento)
----

THE PEOPLE, C100143

Plaintiff and Respondent, (Super. Ct. No. 20FE012871)

v.

OLUWATOYIN MUDASHIRU,

Defendant and Appellant.

A jury found defendant Oluwatoyin Mudashiru guilty of two counts of felony
elder abuse (Pen. Code, § 368, subd. (b)(1) – counts 1 and 3; undesignated statutory
references are to the Penal Code) and one count of involuntary manslaughter (§ 192,
subd. (b) – count 2), as to victim Loretta W. As to the first count of elder abuse, the jury
also found true the allegation that the abuse caused the victim’s death. (§ 368, subd.
(b)(3)(A).) On appeal, defendant does not challenge either conviction related to causing
Loretta’s death. Rather, she challenges only the elder abuse conviction based on her
conduct in the days leading up to the victim’s death. As to that conviction, she contends
(1) there was insufficient evidence to sustain the conviction, and (2) the trial court erred

1
in failing to instruct the jury on the lesser included offense of misdemeanor elder abuse.
We disagree and affirm the judgment.

FACTS AND HISTORY OF THE PROCEEDINGS
In 2018, defendant began working as a full-time live-in caregiver at a small,
assisted living facility for the elderly operated by Patrick A. in Sacramento. Loretta
moved into that facility that same year. Loretta was diagnosed with mental illness years
earlier and by 2020, her health had seriously deteriorated. She was frail with little
strength, was bed-ridden, had difficulties carrying on a conversation, and relied on others
for her bathroom needs and feeding. Defendant was the only live-in caregiver at the
facility, providing care for six residents, including Loretta.
Silent video recordings showed defendant’s physical and verbal abuse of Loretta
between July 27 and August 10, 2020. This conduct included several instances where
defendant appeared to yell at Loretta, at times inches from her face. On three instances
defendant appears to have spit in Loretta’s face and at other times defendant appears to
have forced liquid or food into Loretta’s mouth, one time pushing her whole head back
with a cup hard enough to push the wheelchair backwards, and another time causing
Loretta to spit up or vomit.
Several times, defendant suddenly pushed Loretta forward in her wheelchair by
using her hand to forcefully push Loretta in the back or on the back of Loretta’s head. At
times, defendant slapped or hit Loretta in the face with her fingers, a closed fist, the back
of her hand, or with an open palm, sometimes hard enough to cause her wheelchair to
move backward. Loretta, a much smaller woman than defendant, put up no resistance
during these episodes.
The morning of August 11, 2020, defendant called Patrick and told him he needed
to come to the home “right now” because Loretta was unresponsive. Patrick said he was
about three minutes away and told her to call 911.

2
Upon arriving, Patrick found defendant in Loretta’s bedroom administering CPR
to Loretta, who was lying on her bed. Patrick noted that Loretta’s leg felt cold and she
was not breathing. Patrick asked defendant if she had called 911. When defendant said
she had not, Patrick rushed out of the room to call 911. At the direction of the 911
dispatcher, Patrick and defendant moved Loretta to the floor and Patrick began
administering CPR. Paramedics arrived about four minutes later and pronounced Loretta
dead at the scene. She was 66 years old at the time.
Patrick eventually asked defendant what had happened. Defendant said that she
put Loretta to bed before 8:00 p.m., checked on Loretta once during the night, and then
found Loretta unresponsive and on the ground in the morning.
The chief forensic pathologist with the Sacramento County Coroner’s Office,
Dr. Jason Tovar, testified to the results of Loretta’s autopsy. The autopsy showed that
Loretta had a number of internal injuries, including bruising and bleeding under the scalp
and hemorrhaging in the neck, back, and shoulder areas. Dr. Tovar opined that Loretta’s
injuries were consistent with blunt force being applied or with Loretta being held down
by her back or shoulders. Dr. Tovar further opined that Loretta’s neck injuries were
caused by compression to her neck, consistent with someone using their hands in a C-
shape, and that pressure was applied to her neck until she stopped breathing, causing her
death sometime between 4:00 a.m. and 8:00 a.m. on August 11, 2020. Dr. Tovar could
not determine whether the injuries to Loretta’s head, back, and shoulders happened at the
same time as the injuries to her neck. However, he agreed that they could have been a
few days old and were consistent with a frail woman being slapped in the head or hit in
the back while sitting in a wheelchair.
An amended information charged defendant with one count of elder abuse and one
count of involuntary manslaughter for her conduct on or about August 11, 2020 (counts 1
and 2), and one count of elder abuse for her conduct on or about and between July 29,
2020, and August 10, 2020 (count 3). The amended information further alleged multiple

3
aggravating circumstances with respect to both elder abuse counts, specifically that (1)
the crimes “involved great violence, great bodily harm, threat of great bodily harm, or
other acts disclosing a high degree of cruelty, viciousness, or callousness,” (Cal. Rules of
Court, rule 4.421(a)(1); rule references that follow are to the California Rules of Court);
(2) the victim “was particularly vulnerable,” (rule 4.421(a)(3)); and (3) the defendant
“took advantage of a position of trust or confidence to commit the offense,” (rule
4.421(a)(11)).
The jury convicted defendant on all three counts and found that defendant
personally and proximately caused Loretta’s death within the meaning of section 368,
subdivision (b)(3). As to both elder abuse counts, the jury also found all the aggravating
circumstances under rule 4.421(a) true.
The trial court sentenced defendant to four years on the conviction for elder abuse
alleged in count 1 (§ 368, subd. (b)(1)), plus five years for proximately causing Loretta’s
death (§ 368, subd. (b)(3)(A)), and a consecutive one-year on the conviction for elder
abuse alleged in count 3, for an aggregate term of 10 years. On the involuntary
manslaughter conviction, the court imposed and stayed a four-year term under section
654. Defendant timely appealed.

DISCUSSION

I

Sufficiency of the Evidence

Defendant challenges the sufficiency of the evidence to support her conviction for
elder abuse alleged in count 3. She argues there was insufficient evidence that her
conduct on or about July 29, 2020, to August 10, 2020, the days leading up to Loretta’s
death, was committed under circumstances or conditions likely to cause great bodily
harm or death. Defendant does not contest the sufficiency of the evidence as to any other
element in count 3.

4
“When considering a challenge to the sufficiency of the evidence to support a
criminal conviction, we review the whole record in the light most favorable to the verdict,
drawing all inferences that reasonably support it, and determine whether it contains
substantial evidence—that is, evidence which is reasonable, credible, and of solid
value—from which a trier of fact could rationally find the defendant guilty beyond a
reasonable doubt. [Citations.] In making this determination, we do not reweigh the
evidence, resolve conflicts in the evidence, draw inferences contrary to the verdict, or
reevaluate the credibility of witnesses.” (People v. Little (2004) 115 Cal.App.4th 766,
771.) “ ‘Before the judgment of the trial court can be set aside for the insufficiency of the
evidence, it must clearly appear that on no hypothesis whatever is there sufficient
substantial evidence to support the verdict of the [finder of fact].’ ” (People v. Racy
(2007) 148 Cal.App.4th 1327, 1332 (Racy).) “However, ‘[a] reasonable inference may
not be based on suspicion alone, or on imagination, speculation, supposition, surmise,
conjecture, or guesswork; a finding of fact must be an inference drawn from evidence
rather than a mere speculation as to probabilities without evidence.’ ” (People v. Grant
(2020) 57 Cal.App.5th 323, 330.)
A defendant is guilty of felony elder abuse when he or she “knows or reasonably
should know that a person is an elder or dependent adult and who, under circumstances or
conditions likely to produce great bodily harm or death, willfully causes or permits any
elder or dependent adult to suffer, or inflicts thereon unjustifiable physical pain or mental
suffering.” (§ 368, subd. (b)(1).) Whether an injury is inflicted under circumstances or
conditions likely to produce great bodily injury is a question for the trier of fact. (People
v. Clark (2012) 201 Cal.App.4th 235, 243-245 (Clark) [discussing and applying the great
bodily injury requirement of the felony elder abuse and felony child abuse statutes
similarly]; see also Racy, supra, 148 Cal.App.4th at p. 1335 [noting that the language of
the felony elder abuse statute derives verbatim from the felony child abuse statute].)

5
“Great bodily injury” is harm that is significant or substantial and does not refer to
trivial or insignificant injury. (§ 368, subd. (b)(2) [referring to § 12022.7 for definition of
great bodily injury]; § 12022.7 [defining great bodily injury as “a significant or
substantial physical injury”]; People v. Cortes (1999) 71 Cal.App.4th 62, 80 (Cortes).)
An elder abuse conviction does not require actual harm or injury; rather it requires that
great bodily injury or harm were likely, under the circumstances or conditions. (Roman
v. Superior Court (2003) 113 Cal.App.4th 27, 35.) “Likely” in this context means a
substantial danger or a serious and well-founded risk. (Clark, supra, 201 Cal.App.4th at
p. 245.)
In determining whether circumstances or conditions are such that great bodily
injury is likely to result, the jury may consider “(1) the characteristics of the victim and
the defendant, (2) the characteristics of the location where the abuse took place, (3) the
potential response or resistance by the victim to the abuse, (4) any injuries actually
inflicted, (5) any pain sustained by the victim, and (6) the nature of and amount of force
used by the defendant.” (Clark, supra, 201 Cal.App.4th at p. 245, fn. omitted.) To
convict a defendant of elder abuse, the jury is not required to unanimously agree on one
circumstance or condition likely to produce great bodily harm or death. (Racy, supra,
148 Cal.App.4th at p. 1334.)
Here, a rational juror could have found that under the totality of the circumstances
and conditions, defendant’s conduct in the days leading up to Loretta’s death created a
substantial danger of great bodily injury to the victim or that defendant’s actions actually
caused great bodily injury. Specifically, a rational juror could have found that Loretta’s
frail state and the nature and amount of force applied by defendant made it likely that
Loretta would suffer great bodily injury due to defendant’s conduct. The jury heard
extensive testimony regarding Loretta’s weakened state and viewed numerous video clips
showing defendant’s physical abuse of Loretta in the days leading up to her death. While
defendant’s actions might not result in great bodily injury to a younger and healthier

6
adult, Loretta’s age and seriously deteriorated physical condition made her especially
vulnerable. She was frail, bed-ridden, and had little strength. And her age created an
increased risk of bone fractures from a fall. (See Racy, supra, 148 Cal.App.4th at p. 1333
[it is a matter of common knowledge that age carries with it an increased risk of bone
fractures from a fall].) Given these circumstances, defendant repeatedly suddenly and
forcefully pushing Loretta forward in her wheelchair and slapping or hitting her in the
face could have caused Loretta to fall out of her wheelchair and hit the ground, causing
her to break a bone or other substantial injury. (See ibid. [force likely could have caused
the victim to fall and suffer great bodily harm, given victim’s advanced age and physical
condition].) Defendant’s actions also created a risk of choking, given that Loretta was
frequently being fed when defendant used force against her, and at times defendant
appeared to force liquids or food into Loretta’s mouth. Indeed, the videos showed at least
once defendant spit up or vomited during feeding. A reasonable juror could find that this
choking risk presented a substantial danger of great bodily injury.
A rational juror could have also found that defendant’s repeated pushing of Loretta
in the back or head or slapping and hitting Loretta in the face directly caused great bodily
injury. Loretta had bruising and hemorrhaging under her scalp and on her back and
shoulders, which the pathologist testified could have been caused by Loretta being
slapped in the head or back a few days before her death. While defendant minimizes the
victim’s injuries, the forensic evidence was more than enough for a juror to find that
these injuries were significant or substantial. (See Cortes, supra, 71 Cal.App.4th at p. 80
[great bodily injury is harm that is significant or substantial and not trivial or
insignificant].) Overall, the evidence was sufficient to support the jury’s conviction on
count 3.

7
II

Lesser Included Offense Instruction

Defendant also argues the trial court prejudicially erred by failing to instruct the
jury on the lesser included offense of misdemeanor elder abuse.
“A trial court has a sua sponte duty to ‘instruct on a lesser offense necessarily
included in the charged offense if there is substantial evidence the defendant is guilty
only of the lesser.’ [Citation.] Substantial evidence in this context is evidence from
which a reasonable jury could conclude that the defendant committed the lesser, but not
the greater, offense. [Citation.]. . . . [T]he court need instruct the jury on a lesser
included offense only ‘[w]hen there is substantial evidence that an element of the charged
offense is missing, but that the accused is guilty of’ the lesser offense.” (People v.
Shockley (2013) 58 Cal.4th 400, 403-404.) “We review the trial court’s failure to instruct
on a lesser included offense de novo [citations] considering the evidence in the light most
favorable to the defendant.” (People v. Brothers (2015) 236 Cal.App.4th 24, 30.)
A defendant is guilty of misdemeanor elder abuse when he or she “knows or
reasonably should know that a person is an elder or dependent adult and who, under
circumstances or conditions other than those likely to produce great bodily harm or death,
willfully causes or permits any elder or dependent adult to suffer, or inflicts thereon
unjustifiable physical pain or mental suffering.” (§ 368, subd. (c).) “[T]he difference
between felony elder abuse and misdemeanor elder abuse is whether the abuse is
perpetrated ‘under circumstances or conditions likely to produce great bodily harm or
death.’ If it is, the crime is a potential felony. (§ 368, subd. (b)(1).) If it is not, the crime
is a misdemeanor. (§ 368, subd. (c).) Misdemeanor elder abuse is a lesser included
offense of felony elder abuse.” (Racy, supra, 148 Cal.App.4th at pp. 1334-1335.)
“In a noncapital case, the error in failing to instruct on a lesser included offense is
reviewed for prejudice under People v. Watson (1956) 46 Cal.2d 818, which requires

8
reversal of the conviction for the greater offense ‘if, “after an examination of the entire
cause, including the evidence” [citation], it appears “reasonably probable” the defendant
would have obtained a more favorable outcome had the error not occurred.’ (People v.
Breverman[ (1998)] 19 Cal.4th [142,] 178[ (Breverman)].) Probability under Watson
‘does not mean more likely than not, but merely a reasonable chance, more than an
abstract possibility.’ ” (Racy, supra, 148 Cal.App.4th at p. 1335.)
In this case, we do not need to separately analyze whether the court erred in failing
to instruct the jury on the lesser included offense of misdemeanor elder abuse, because
we conclude an error, if any, was harmless. As discussed above, for the jury to conclude
that defendant committed the lesser offense of misdemeanor elder abuse but not the
greater offense of felony elder abuse, it would have to find that defendant acted under
circumstances other than those likely to produce great bodily harm. (§ 368, subd. (c).)
However, in addition to finding defendant guilty on count 3, the jury separately found
true the aggravating circumstances that (1) the victim was particularly vulnerable and (2)
the crime involved great violence, great bodily harm, threat of great bodily harm, or other
acts disclosing a high degree of cruelty, vicious, or callousness.
In order to find the latter aggravating circumstance true, the jury had to find that
the defendant “[d]uring the commission of the crimes [] used great violence, inflicted
great bodily harm or committed other acts showing a high degree of . . . callousness” and
“[t]he type of violence, bodily harm or cruelty, viciousness or callousness was
distinctively worse than what was necessary to commit the crimes.” The jury was further
instructed that in this context, “ ‘[v]iciousness’ means dangerously aggressive or marked
by violence or ferocity” and that “[a]n act discloses cruelty when it demonstrates a
deliberate infliction of [] physical or mental suffering.”
Based on the jury’s additional findings regarding the aggravating circumstances
and the evidence in this case showing that Loretta suffered significant injuries due to
blunt force, it was not reasonably probable that the jury would have found defendant

9
acted under circumstances other than those likely to produce great bodily harm. (Cf.
Racy, supra, 148 Cal.App.4th at pp. 1334-1336 [jury could have found that a large older
man with physical limitations was not likely to suffer great bodily injury from single stun
gun shock to leg where he retreated, made a 911 call, and emerged “unscathed”].)
Loretta was a frail, bed-ridden elderly woman. As the videos depicted, defendant was
younger, bigger, and stronger than Loretta. The jury saw the numerous times defendant
aggressively pushed and hit a defenseless and frail woman, sometimes hard enough to
force her wheelchair backwards, and heard evidence that the victim suffered bruising and
hemorrhaging under her scalp and on her back and shoulders, injuries consistent with a
woman in a wheelchair being slapped in the head or hit in the back. Loretta offered no
resistance to defendant’s assaults, not putting her hands up to defend herself or even
flinching away.
Based on the evidence and the jury’s findings, it was not reasonably probable that
defendant would have been convicted of misdemeanor elder abuse and not felony elder
abuse had the misdemeanor instruction also been given, and any instructional error was
therefore harmless. (See Breverman, supra, 19 Cal.4th at p. 178.)

DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.

____________________________
HULL, Acting P. J.

We concur:

____________________________
RENNER, J.

____________________________
MESIWALA, J.

10

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.