CourtListener 10708942•In re S.K. CA2/8
Full text
Filed 10/22/25 In re S.K. CA2/8
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION EIGHT
In re S.K. et al., Persons Coming
Under the Juvenile Court Law. B342576
LOS ANGELES COUNTY (Los Angeles County Super.
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN Ct. No. 18LJJP00487FGHIJ)
AND FAMILY SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
N.W.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Syna N. Dennis, Judge Pro Tempore. Affirmed.
Lillian Hamrick, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Melania Vartanian, Deputy
County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
___________________________
SUMMARY
N.W. (Mother) appeals from the trial court’s finding that
the Los Angeles County Department of Children and Family
Services (DCFS) provided her with reasonable reunification
services at a six-month review hearing pursuant to Welfare and
Institutions Code section 266.21, subdivision (e).1 We conclude
that substantial evidence supports the court’s finding, by clear
and convincing evidence, that DCFS provided reasonable services
to Mother, where DCFS remained in reasonable contact with
Mother and made reasonable efforts to assist Mother in areas
where compliance proved difficult. We affirm the trial court’s
finding that reasonable services were provided.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. DCFS Referral and Initial Investigation
In late July 2023, DCFS received a referral that Mother left
her five children,2 ages four to thirteen, alone in the home for
three weeks. The caller reported the living conditions were
“horrible” with feces and trash everywhere. Law enforcement
went to the home, but neither Mother nor any of the children
were present.
A children’s social worker (CSW) spoke with a paternal
aunt, who reported the two youngest children, ages six and four,
were living with her. The aunt reported that she had not spoken
to Mother since June 2023, when Mother dropped off the
1 All further undesignated statutory references are to the
Welfare and Institutions Code.
2 The juvenile court made paternity findings for each of the
children and identified four different fathers for the five children.
None of the court’s findings or orders regarding the fathers are
the subject of this appeal.
2
youngest child. The aunt also reported that Mother’s landlord
informed her the three oldest children had been left alone for
three weeks, and one of the children (aged nine) was banging on
the door and crying that she was hungry. The CSW was told that
maternal grandfather had picked up the three oldest children.
The CSW observed the two youngest children with paternal aunt
and spoke with Germany L., the six-year old. Germany reported
that “she does not feel safe at home with her mom because mom
leaves for a long time.”
The CSW was told that the three older children had been
staying with various friends and family members for the past
several weeks, but the three oldest children and Mother could not
be located at the time of the initial investigation. The CSW
learned that the children were previously declared dependents of
the juvenile court in 2018 based in part on Mother’s substance
abuse and domestic violence between Mother and one of the
fathers. The juvenile court terminated jurisdiction in 2020 and
2021 and granted sole physical and legal custody to Mother. The
prior case was initiated by a referral that the children were left
home alone without supervision.
On August 10, 2023, the juvenile court authorized removal
orders to detain all of the children from Mother.
B. Detention and Arraignment Hearings
On August 14, 2023, DCFS filed a petition as to the five
children, pursuant to section 300, subdivisions (b)(1) and (j)(1).
DCFS alleged that the “home was found to be in a filthy,
unsanitary, and hazardous condition” and Mother “left the
children . . . home alone for an extended period of time, in the
home, and the mother’s whereabouts were unknown.” DCFS also
alleged that Mother “failed to make an appropriate plan for the
3
children’s ongoing care and supervision, and failed to provide the
children with the necessities of life including food, clothing,
shelter, and medical care.”
At the detention hearing the following day, counsel for
DCFS and the two youngest children appeared. The court
ordered the children detained from Mother and their respective
fathers and issued protective custody warrants for the three older
children and an arrest warrant for Mother. On September 19,
2023, the three older children were located at school and
detained.
The Dependency Investigator (DI) made multiple contacts
with family members and friends and attempted to reach Mother
at all telephone numbers and email addresses that were
provided, but Mother did not respond. Mother appeared at the
arraignment hearing on September 26, 2023 and was appointed
counsel.
C. DCFS Ongoing Investigation
During the investigation, the DI was provided with a
notarized affidavit from Mother, signed on July 2, 2023 and
notarized on August 25, 2023. The affidavit states: “I, [Mother],
am signing over temporary guardianship over to Lashawnda J[.]
for Semaj K[.], Eden N[.], and Eunique G[.] until further notice.
My children have been in Lashawnda J[.’s] care since July 2,
2023. I am dealing with severe PTSD at the moment am unable
to care for them.” Lashwanda J. is a paternal relative of Semaj.
After Mother appeared, the DI interviewed Mother
regarding the allegations. Mother stated: “I am not in a place to
take care of them right now because I’m really going through it.”
Mother told the DI, “I just know it’s PTSD and feel like I’m
severely depressed. I have a lot of downtime mentally and I can’t
4
handle it. I went to my doctor and he gave me meds because my
heart was always racing.” Mother reported that she is no longer
taking the medication and she could not recall the name of the
medication she was taking. She further noted that she had not
followed up with her doctor in three to four months regarding her
mental health concerns.
Mother also stated: “I believe it’s all due to stress. I have
nightmares and dreams that I see my mom and that I’m going
outside to smoke a cigarette with her. Sometimes I’m not even
sleeping when I see her. That’s not regular stuff. I’m so
overwhelmed. It’s hard for a family to operate with two parents
so imagine me as a single parent trying to do it all on my own
and having these problems.” Mother reported that she had been
exhibiting these behaviors for the past nine months.
Mother reported to the DI that she had been struggling
with depression and anxiety although she was never formally
diagnosed. She reported that her mother passed away in 2021
and she had been struggling to cope with her loss. Mother
reported seeing a therapist in the past for two years. She
reported she stopped attending as she believed she had met the
goals she set out to accomplish.
After speaking with Mother, DCFS filed an amended
petition on October 10, 2023, adding allegations that Mother “has
mental and emotional problems, including Post Traumatic Stress
Disorder and exhibits hallucinations, paranoia, nightmares and
heart palpitations which renders the mother incapable of
providing regular care for the children.” DCFS further alleged
that Mother failed to obtain recommended mental health
treatment.
5
D. Adjudication and Disposition
The adjudication and disposition hearings took place on
February 26, 2024. Between the filing of the amended petition
and the February hearing, Mother tested positive for marijuana
on one occasion and missed drug testing in January and
February.
The court sustained counts b-2, b-3, and b-4, finding that
Mother failed to make an appropriate plan for the two youngest
children by leaving them with an aunt, failed to provide the
necessaries of life, and failed to provide appropriate parental care
and supervision for the children by leaving them home alone for
extended periods of time. The court also found that Mother’s
mental and emotional problems endangered the children’s health
and safety.
The court removed the children from Mother and their
respective fathers. The two youngest children were placed with
their paternal aunt, and the three older children were placed
with a family friend. The court ordered reunification services for
Mother and ordered Mother to complete the following programs:
random and on-demand drug and alcohol testing, and if Mother
had any unexcused, missed or dirty tests, she was to participate
in a full drug treatment program with 12-Step, court card,
sponsor, and aftercare; psychiatric evaluation, and take all
prescribed psychotropic medication; parenting program;
individual counseling to address case issues including child
safety and how drugs affect children; follow-up with mental
health treatment as recommended. Mother was also given
6
monitored visits with the children three times per week for three
hours each, for a total of nine hours.3
A progress hearing was set for April 25, 2024, and the six-
month review hearing was set for August 26, 2024.
E. Mother’s Compliance with Her Case Plan
Even before the February 26, 2024 hearing at which the
court ordered reunification services, the CSW provided Mother
with a referral packet for individual counseling, grievance
support group, parenting education, and the Bringing Families
Home Program. Mother was also referred to random drug
testing. Mother missed testing on February 6, February 21, and
March 29 and tested positive for marijuana on March 15, 2024.
Prior to the April 25, 2024 progress hearing, Mother was
given referrals for a psychiatric evaluation, but Mother did not
report any progress in seeking an evaluation or any information
as to any prescribed psychotropic medications.
Mother reported that she enrolled in a 12-week parenting
course at Desert Vineyard and individual counseling. The CSW
contacted the therapist on two occasions but was unable to
confirm Mother’s individual counseling because Mother had not
signed consent forms. The CSW informed Mother she needed to
sign the consent forms. A few weeks later, Mother informed the
CSW that she was not attending the parenting class at Desert
Vineyard, and the CSW provided Mother with a referral to a
different parenting class at Grace Resources. Mother indicated
she enrolled in the parenting class at Grace Resources, but the
CSW was unable to confirm her enrollment.
3 On August 13, 2025, DCFS’s Motion to Augment was
granted and the record was augmented with the Court-Ordered
Case Plan for Mother dated February 26, 2024.
7
Mother advised the CSW that three-hour visits were too
long, so her visits were shortened to two hours. Mother regularly
complained about visitation rules, including the requirement to
confirm her visits the day before and the location of the visits.
Mother did visit with the children regularly, but her behavior
was often volatile, she used foul language, and on more than one
occasion, Mother threatened the caregiver and the caregiver’s
children. The CSW reported that Mother and the children enjoy
being in each other’s company.
At the April 25, 2024 progress hearing, the juvenile court
reviewed Mother’s progress. Mother’s counsel reiterated that
Mother had enrolled in counseling and would sign the consent
forms so DCFS could get confirmation before the six-month
review hearing. Mother was present at the hearing. The court
reminded Mother of the order for drug testing and encouraged
Mother to contact the social worker if she needed assistance, and
the court ordered Mother to sign releases so DCFS could confirm
her program enrollment.
Between the April 25, 2024 progress hearing and the six-
month review hearing on August 26, 2024, Mother missed five
drug testing appointments and tested positive for marijuana on
June 11, 2024. Mother did not have any clean drug tests.
Mother reported no progress on the psychiatric evaluation.
Mother reported that she stopped attending the parenting course
at Grace Resources and was now attending a class at Parent
Anonymous. The CSW was unable to confirm Mother’s
enrollment with the instructor, and Mother did not provide the
CSW with an enrollment letter.
Mother continued to visit with the children, although she
routinely failed to confirm visits, so numerous visits were
8
cancelled. At the visits, Mother was attentive and engaged with
the children. At times, the CSW had difficulty reaching Mother.
Mother did not always answer her phone, or would tell the CSW
she was busy and would call back, but Mother did not always call
back. DCFS reported that Mother’s lack of communication made
it difficult for DCFS to identify possible barriers to reunification.
At the August 2024 six-month review hearing, DCFS
recommended continued reunification services for Mother.
Mother requested a contested hearing, which took place on
October 22, 2024. Prior to the contested hearing, DCFS delivered
“Title XX’s”4 from November 7, 2023 to August 26, 2024.
F. Contested Six-Month Review Hearing
At the contested hearing, CSW Ramos was called as the
only witness. CSW Ramos testified that she monitored many of
Mother’s visits and spoke to Mother about her case plan at those
visits. Mother’s counsel asked CSW Ramos if her duties in
documenting delivered services were reflected in the service logs.
CSW Ramos replied, “[t]here might be certain things that I had
forgotten to put on there, but most of the important things I
believe are there documented.”
CSW Ramos testified that she provided Mother with
referrals at least three different times and Mother was aware
that she had to enroll in mental health services, a parenting
class, and drug testing. CSW Ramos was asked if she would
provide Mother with an alternate referral if she was placed on a
waiting list for any services. CSW Ramos replied that as far as
4 As noted in several unpublished cases, “Title XX’s” refer to
DCFS’s case activity logs setting forth all contacts, services and
visits. (See, e.g., In re Marco W. (Dec. 12, 2012, B238471)
[nonpub. opn.].)
9
she was aware, Mother never reported that she was waitlisted.
CSW Ramos also confirmed that she told Mother she needed to
sign releases so she could speak to her therapist, and Mother told
her she would “take care of it.” CSW Ramos testified that she
spoke to Mother a few times about how to get a mental health
assessment. When asked if this information was reflected in the
service logs, CSW Ramos testified that she was not sure if it was
reflected in the service logs. CSW Ramos testified that Mother
never asked for funds for any reason. She also testified that she
had not been able to contact Mother in over two months.
In addition to CSW Ramos’s testimony, the court admitted
into evidence the reports prepared by DCFS for prior hearings
and the Title XX service logs from November 7, 2023 to August
26, 2024.
At the conclusion of the six-month review hearing, Mother
argued that DCFS did not make reasonable efforts for her to
reunify with her children. DCFS argued that reasonable services
were provided and Mother’s lack of communication made it
difficult for DCFS to fully assist Mother. DCFS also noted that
Mother missed several drug tests and tested positive at others;
she began and then stopped parenting classes; she had not
enrolled in a mental health evaluation; and had never indicated
that there was a financial issue or requested any funds from
DCFS.
The juvenile court found that continued jurisdiction under
section 300 was necessary because the conditions justifying
jurisdiction still existed. The court found that returning the
children to their parents’ custody would create a substantial risk
of detriment and that out-of-home placement remained
appropriate. The court found by clear and convincing evidence
10
that DCFS provided reasonable services. The court found CSW
Ramos credible and stated: “It’s clear to the court that
everything that the social worker did was not documented in the
Title XX’s, but it’s also clear to the court that, just because the
services provided were not documented, doesn’t mean that the
services weren’t provided.” The court also found Mother to be in
partial compliance with her case plan and ordered continued
reunification services.
Mother filed an application for rehearing, and on November
14, 2024, the court denied Mother’s application. Mother then
filed this timely appeal.
DISCUSSION
I. Mother’s Appeal of the Reasonable Services Finding
is Proper
Mother specifically appeals the juvenile court’s finding that
DCFS made reasonable efforts at the six-month review hearing.
Prior cases questioned whether a parent can appeal a
reasonable services finding. “[W]e conclude that there is no right
to appeal a finding that reasonable reunification services were
provided to the parent or legal guardian unless the court takes
adverse action based on that finding, because, in the absence of
such action, there is no appealable order resulting from that
finding.” (Melinda K. v. Superior Court (2004) 116 Cal.App.4th
1147, 1154.) The court in Melinda K. concluded that “a petition
for writ of mandate is the appropriate method by which to
challenge a finding made by a juvenile court at a review hearing
which does not result in an appealable order.” (Id. at p. 1157.)
Subsequent cases recognized the potential negative impact
of an erroneous reasonable services finding. “[A] parent or child
can [be] aggrieved by a reasonable services finding at the time of
11
the six-month review hearing if it is not supported by
substantial evidence. Such a finding can put the interests of
parents and children in reunification at a significant procedural
disadvantage.” (In re T.G. (2010) 188 Cal.App.4th 687, 695.)
As a result, our colleagues in Division Two recently held that a
parent may challenge a reasonable services finding by way of a
direct appeal rather than a writ of mandate. “Because a parent is
aggrieved by an erroneous reasonable services finding, the parent
may obtain appellate review of the finding by appealing the order
in which it was made, even if the parent is not challenging any
other part of that order.” (In re A.O. (2025) 111 Cal.App.5th
1048, 1061.) Thus, we conclude that Mother’s appeal is proper.
II. Substantial Evidence Supports the Court’s
Reasonable Services Finding
At the six-month review hearing, the juvenile court “shall
order the return of the child to the physical custody of their
parent or legal guardian unless the court finds, by a
preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the child to
their parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of
detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-
being of the child.” (§ 366.21, subd. (e)(1).) “If the child is not
returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall
determine by clear and convincing evidence whether reasonable
services that were designed to aid the parent or legal guardian in
overcoming the problems that led to the initial removal and the
continued custody of the child have been provided or offered to
the parent or legal guardian.” (§ 366.21, subd. (e)(8).)
“When a finding that reunification services were adequate
is challenged on appeal, we review it for substantial evidence.”
(In re Alvin R. (2003) 108 Cal.App.4th 962, 971 (Alvin R.).)
12
“In general, when presented with a challenge to the sufficiency of
the evidence associated with a finding requiring clear and
convincing evidence, the court must determine whether the
record, viewed as a whole, contains substantial evidence from
which a reasonable trier of fact could have made the finding of
high probability demanded by this standard of proof.”
(Conservatorship of O.B. (2020) 9 Cal.5th 989, 1005.)
To support a finding that reasonable services were
provided, “the record should show that the supervising agency
identified the problems leading to the loss of custody, offered
services designed to remedy those problems, maintained
reasonable contact with the parents during the course of the
service plan, and made reasonable efforts to assist the parents in
areas where compliance proved difficult.” (In re Riva M. (1991)
235 Cal.App.3d 403, 414.) “When the sufficiency of the evidence
to support a finding or order is challenged on appeal, even where
the standard of proof in the trial court is clear and convincing
evidence, the reviewing court must determine if there is any
substantial evidence—that is, evidence which is reasonable,
credible and of solid value—to support the conclusion of the trier
of fact.” (In re Jasmine C. (1999) 70 Cal.App.4th 71, 75.)
Here, substantial evidence supports the juvenile court’s
findings. DCFS identified the problems leading to the loss of
custody. The court sustained the section 300 petition in February
2024 by finding that Mother failed to make an appropriate plan
for her children by leaving them with a relative, failed to provide
the necessaries of life, and failed to provide appropriate parental
care and supervision for her children by leaving them home alone
for extended periods of time. In addition, the court found that
13
Mother’s mental and emotional problems endangered the
children’s health and safety.
Mother’s case plan specifically offered services designed to
remedy these problems. Mother was ordered to complete a
psychiatric evaluation and participate in individual counseling to
address her underlying mental health issues. She was ordered to
participate in a parenting class to address her failure to provide
the necessaries of life for her children and failure to provide
appropriate care and supervision for her children. In addition,
due to Mother’s prior substantiated history of substance abuse
and her positive drug test before the disposition hearing, Mother
was ordered to participate in random and on-demand drug
testing. All of these programs were designed to remedy the
problems that led to the loss of custody.
CSW Ramos maintained reasonable contact with Mother
during the course of the service plan. CSW Ramos monitored
visits with Mother and she testified that she provided Mother
with referrals at least three different times and spoke to Mother
about her progress with the programs. In addition, CSW Ramos
testified that she advised Mother to sign releases so DCFS could
confirm her participation in a parenting class and individual
counseling, and Mother told her she would “take care of it.” CSW
Ramos also testified that she spoke to Mother a few times about
how to get a mental health assessment. Notwithstanding these
contacts, DCFS reported that Mother’s lack of communication
made it difficult for DCFS to identify possible barriers to
reunification. CSW Ramos testified that she had not been able to
contact Mother in over two months.
Mother argues that some of these discussions are not
reflected in the service logs. However, the court found CSW
14
Ramos’s testimony credible and specifically stated: “[J]ust
because the services provided were not documented, doesn’t mean
that the services weren’t provided.” Witness credibility is the
sole province of the trial court. “It is axiomatic that an appellate
court defers to the trier of fact on such determinations, and has
no power to judge the effect or value of, or to weigh the evidence;
to consider the credibility of witnesses; or to resolve conflicts in,
or make inferences or deductions from the evidence. We review a
cold record and, unlike a trial court, have no opportunity to
observe the appearance and demeanor of the witnesses. ‘Issues of
fact and credibility are questions for the trial court.’ ” (In re
Sheila B. (1993) 19 Cal.App.4th 187, 199–200, quoting In re
Kristin W. (1990) 222 Cal.App.3d 234, 251, internal citation
omitted.)
The juvenile court acted within its discretion to base its
finding on CSW Ramos’s oral testimony, notwithstanding the fact
that not all interactions between CSW Ramos and Mother were
documented in the service logs. “[T]he testimony of one witness
is sufficient to support a finding of fact and this court cannot
overturn the findings even though other evidence is to the
contrary.” (Western Tire Co. v. Furstman (1968) 268 Cal.App.2d
446, 450.)
DCFS also made reasonable efforts to assist Mother in
areas where compliance proved difficult. Mother argues that
DCFS did not take the necessary steps to help Mother complete
the psychiatric assessment or access further services. But CSW
Ramos testified that she spoke to Mother a few times about how
to get a mental health assessment.
Mother also argues there was no evidence DCFS followed
up with Mother’s individual therapist, assisted Mother in
15
submitting the necessary consent forms, or offered alternative
referrals. The record does not support this argument. The CSW
contacted Mother’s therapist on at least two occasions but was
unable to confirm Mother’s individual counseling because Mother
had not signed consent forms. The CSW informed Mother she
needed to sign the consent forms, and the trial court ordered
Mother to sign the consent forms, but there was no evidence
Mother signed the forms before the six-month review hearing.
CSW Ramos also offered alternative referrals when Mother
stopped attending parenting classes with the suggested
providers. There was no evidence Mother was ever placed on a
waiting list for services.
In In re Alvin R., on which Mother heavily relies, the Court
of Appeal found insufficient evidence to support the trial court’s
finding that reasonable services were provided where the father
had fully complied with his case plan and the remaining barrier
to reunification was regular visitation with his eleven-year-old
son. The case plan set up a domino effect of services, requiring
the minor to participate in eight sessions of individual
counseling, after which the therapist could approve participation
in conjoint counseling with father and the minor, after which the
minor could agree to visits with father. (Alvin R., supra, 108
Cal.App.4th at p. 967.) The juvenile court recognized that until
the minor participated in conjoint therapy, the minor was
unlikely to agree to visits with father. (Id. at p. 968.)
At a contested six-month review hearing, nearly eight
months after adjudication and disposition, the father and minor
had not yet attended one conjoint counseling session. The minor
did not attend any individual counseling sessions for five months.
DCFS argued that the delay in counseling was due to the minor’s
16
caregiver, who requested a therapist closer to home to manage
her challenging schedule. DCFS also conceded that the minor
was placed on a waiting list for a therapist. The trial court found
that reasonable services were provided, but the Court of Appeal
reversed that finding.
“Father had done all that was required of him under the
plan. Thus, one service, getting Alvin into eight sessions of
individual therapy, stood in the way of all measures remaining
under the reunification plan, and the Department submitted no
evidence of having made a good faith effort to bring those
sessions about. . . . And there was no evidence with regard to any
follow-up by the Department to move things along or to assist the
overwhelmed [caregiver] in any respect other than a referral to a
therapist with a waiting list.” (Alvin R., supra, 108 Cal.App.4th
at p. 973; see also T.J. v. Superior Court (2018) 21 Cal.App.5th
1229, 1242, disapproved on another ground in Michael G. v.
Superior Court (2023) 14 Cal.5th 609 [“Maintaining Mother on a
waiting list was not equivalent to ‘providing’ or ‘offering’
services.”].) Here, there was no evidence that any delays in
Mother’s case plan were due to Mother or minors being placed on
a waiting list.
Mother also argues that DCFS failed to address her
transportation and housing barriers. Again, the record does not
support this argument. Mother reported to DCFS that housing
was her biggest barrier on November 30, 2023. But in April
2024, Mother reported that she had moved to a new apartment in
Lancaster and was now closer to her children. Thus, Mother
appears to have addressed her own housing and transportation
issues nearly six months before the contested six-month review
hearing on October 22, 2024. In addition, CSW Ramos testified
17
that Mother never asked for funds for any reason. There is no
evidence that housing or transportation barriers prevented
Mother from complying with her case plan from April to October
2024.
“The standard is not whether the services provided were
the best that might be provided in an ideal world, but whether
the services were reasonable under the circumstances.” (In re
Misako R. (1991) 2 Cal.App.4th 538, 547.) We find that
substantial evidence supports the court’s finding by clear and
convincing evidence that DCFS provided reasonable reunification
services to Mother.
DISPOSITION
The court’s order is affirmed.
UZCATEGUI, J.*
We Concur:
STRATTON, P. J.
WILEY, J.
* Judge of the Los Angeles County Superior Court, appointed
by the Chief Justice pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the
California Constitution.
18
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.