In re G.L. CA2/5

CourtListener 10703762CalctappOct 14, 2025

Full text

Filed 10/14/25 In re G.L. CA2/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FIVE

In re G.L., a Person Coming B339654
Under the Juvenile Court Law.

LOS ANGELES COUNTY (Los Angeles County
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN Super. Ct.
AND FAMILY SERVICES, No. 22CCJP04792B)

Plaintiff,

v.

J.U.,

Defendant and Appellant;

G.L.,

Respondent.

APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Juan M. Valles, Temporary Judge. Affirmed.
John Benjamin Ekenes, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Aida Aslanian, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Respondent.
Mother appeals from an order terminating dependency
jurisdiction under Welfare and Institutions Code section 362.41
and granting sole legal custody of G.L. (daughter) to father.2
Mother contends that because the Department of Children and
Family Services (Department) had recommended joint legal
custody, and the court had previously ordered mother and father
to share joint physical and legal custody of E.L.-M. (son), the
court abused its discretion when it granted father sole legal
custody of daughter. Respondent daughter contends the juvenile
court’s custody order was within the bounds of its discretion. We
affirm.

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

A. Dependency Investigation and Adjudication

The family came to the attention of the Department in
October 2022, when both children were living with mother, and
there was no family law custody order in place. The Department
received a referral due to son’s violent and aggressive behavior at
school. The Department’s detention report summarizes the social
worker’s investigation and concerns about mother’s ability to care
for and supervise son, who likely had an autism diagnosis and
was repeatedly physically aggressive with mother and his

1 All further statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code unless otherwise indicated.
2 Father has not appealed.

2
teachers. During the Department’s initial investigation, son was
evaluated by the county psychiatric mobile response team three
times and hospitalized twice. In early November 2022, when son
was 7 years old and daughter was 6 years old, son physically
attacked mother and mother’s case manager, and after they de-
escalated the situation, son re-escalated and threw daughter onto
the ground, slamming her head on the floor.
After mother failed to comply with the terms of a voluntary
family maintenance agreement, the Department obtained a
warrant and placed son with father on December 7, 2022.
Daughter remained with mother, because there were no concerns
about mother’s ability to supervise and care for daughter,
separate from protecting daughter from son’s violent behavior.
The Department filed a dependency petition alleging, under
section 300, subdivisions (b) and (j), that both son and daughter
were at risk of harm based on mother’s inability to provide son
with appropriate parental care and supervision.
The Department’s February 2023 jurisdiction and
disposition report summarized that son lived with father during
the week, but was also bonded to mother and stayed with mother
on weekends. Based on the juvenile court’s order that daughter
not be present during son’s unmonitored visits with mother,
daughter stayed with mother during the week and with father on
weekends. According to father, with assistance and guidance
from the wraparound team, son’s behavior had improved
dramatically. Mother reported that son continued to hit mother
and act out when he stayed with her, and she asked for the
wraparound team to provide her with the type of support that
father was receiving. The Department had previously noted that

3
mother had access to intensive support services but neglected to
take the necessary steps to access them to help her care for son.
At a jurisdiction and disposition hearing in February 2023,
the juvenile court sustained amended allegations under section
300, subdivisions (b) and (j), that both children were at risk of
harm based on mother’s inability “to provide [son] with
appropriate parental care and supervision due to her failure to
ensure the child receives appropriate medical and therapy, care,
which without services the child acts out in the home, including
violent, aggressive conduct towards the mother and [daughter].”
Based on father’s statements about difficulties getting son back
into a routine after visits with mother, the court tentatively
planned to order mother’s visits with son to be monitored. Based
on the court’s tentative ruling, mother asked to set the
disposition for a contest.
No visits took place during the interim period between the
adjudication and disposition hearings. Father reported that
mother was raising financial disputes with him that prevented
an exchange of children, and mother reported visits had not
taken place either because daughter refused or due to bad
weather. Father reported he resolved the dispute by giving
mother money. No concerns were raised regarding mother’s
ability to care for daughter, but the social worker noted that
mother’s comments were focused on raising complaints about
father, including financial matters and accusing father of
drinking.
At the disposition hearing in March 2023, the court ordered
the current custody arrangement to remain in place as a home of
parents placement order. Mother’s case plan included a
parenting program for special needs children, a family

4
preservation program, participating in wraparound services for
son, individual counseling to address case issues, and protective
parenting, plus conjoint counseling when recommended by son’s
therapist. The court denied the Department’s request for father
to participate in parenting and individual counseling, but ordered
father to continue participating in wraparound services for son,
and conjoint counseling if recommended by the therapist.

B. First Review Period

Mother was participating in individual counseling, and her
clinician reported that mother’s mental health symptoms had led
to impairments in functioning with her housing, employment,
education, and interpersonal relationships. Both the social
worker and mother’s counselor observed that mother had
disorganized thoughts and challenges with comprehension,
particularly on subject matters related to her children, raising
serious concerns about her ability to parent daughter and son.
For example, mother was not able to understand the importance
of spending time with daughter. Mother participated in a
program that provided mother with 52 hours of free childcare per
week. The babysitter was a friend of mother’s, who reported she
would pick daughter up from school and bring her home at 8 p.m.
on weekdays. Until recently, she would also babysit daughter
from 11 a.m. until 8 p.m. on weekends. When the social worker
and mother’s counselor were trying to make mother understand
the value of mother spending more time with daughter, mother’s
response was that if the program gave her the hours for
childcare, she was going to use them. Mother reported she had a
hard time understanding things, but also told the social worker

5
she knew how to get free things just sitting at home and putting
on a show.
Daughter missed 48 days of school and was tardy 62 times
during the 2022-2023 school year, and she had already missed 5
days of school in the fall of 2023, following a pattern similar to
son’s when he was in mother’s care. Mother did not seem to
understand the importance of daughter attending school every
day and lacked a clear understanding of the correlation between
absences and school performance, and of the differing roles and
responsibilities of a parent and child, instead blaming daughter
for not wanting to go to school.
Daughter was enrolled in individual counseling, but her
attendance, participation, cooperativeness, and prognosis were
rated as poor. Mother cancelled and rescheduled daughter’s
counseling sessions 20 times. Daughter was discharged from
services for missing more than 3 weeks of sessions in a row.
In March 2023, mother enrolled in parenting classes at one
organization, but by April, she was not able to remember the
name of the organization. In May, she informed the social
worker she was no longer attending classes, and the social
worker provided her with new referrals. In June, mother
reported she planned to enroll in a six-week parenting course at a
different organization and was waiting to hear back from the
organization. The organization confirmed to the social worker
that mother had enrolled in an online course scheduled to start
on July 26, 2023, but in September 2023, mother reported she did
not attend the class because she was not comfortable with remote
classes. Ultimately, by mid-September, mother had completed
only 6 of 14 classes at the first organization.

6
By early August 2023, the social worker referred daughter
to wraparound services, more intensive services to address her
behaviors that include not wanting to go to school, defiance, and
disrespect towards mother. Wraparound services could also
provide a different support system for mother, including one-on-
one support and team support. By the time of the Department’s
report, daughter’s wraparound services had just started, and the
team was just beginning to build rapport with the family.
Mother had agreed to services and appeared to be cooperative
with the team. The social worker considered daughter to be at
high risk of harm if left in mother’s care, but thought that six
months of intensive services would help mother address
daughter’s behaviors and give mother the knowledge and support
to make changes and provide better parenting for daughter.
Son’s wraparound facilitator reported that mother had not
participated in son’s wraparound services, despite being invited
to participate in January and February 2023. Both mother and
son enjoyed their unmonitored weekend visits, and son asked if
he could return to mother. The social worker observed one
custody exchange, when mother returned son to father’s custody.
While both parents were cordial with each other and
communicated appropriately, son became aggressive and was
rude towards his mother over his toys. Son was also rude to the
social worker and would not listen when he was asked to sit
down. Rather than responding or correcting son’s behavior,
mother told the social worker she could not believe son was
behaving like that after she took him to eat at every restaurant
he wanted and bought him all the junk food he asked for. In
contrast, father intervened with a stern correction and a renewed

7
request for son to sit down, and son listened to father and sat
down.
The Department recommended terminating jurisdiction
over son, with parents sharing joint physical and legal custody,
and father having primary physical custody. It also
recommended continuing jurisdiction over daughter with family
maintenance services and that the court order a mental health
evaluation of mother under Evidence Code section 730.
Mother continued to make worrisome statements in
October and November 2023, and daughter’s behavioral problems
continued. At a child and family team meeting, mother reported
daughter would have temper tantrums, throw herself on the sofa,
and hit mother. Mother spoke negatively about father in front of
daughter without seeming to understand the negative impact she
was having on daughter. Mother also made statements like “I
lives in lies now, I use to live in the truth and reality but not
anymore.”
In November 2023, mother reported she had falsely told an
SSI worker that she had not bathed in 20 days, just to receive
additional services from SSI.3 Mother’s therapist raised concerns
that mother left daughter in the care of a neighbor who allowed
daughter to go to the playground unattended. The following

3 The Department’s reports do not define “SSI,” but we
understand it to be a reference to a federal program named
Supplemental Security Income. According to a “frequently asked
questions” page for the Social Security Administration, “SSI
provides payments to people with limited income and resources
who are age 65 or older, blind, or have a qualifying disability.”
(<https://www.ssa.gov/faqs/en/questions/KA-02274.html, [as of
Sept. 25, 2025], archived at <https://perma.cc/25HP-BVD2>.)

8
week, mother spoke aggressively to the therapist, complaining
that she did not like people getting in her business, they were
stressing her out, and that wraparound told her they were going
to steal daughter from her. When the therapist tried to explain
that mother had misread the situation, mother changed the
subject. Mother also told the therapist she had purchased a one-
way ticket to El Salvador, was planning to leave daughter with
maternal grandmother and then send for daughter when the case
was over.
Between August and November 2023, daughter was in first
grade and had 9 absences and 23 tardies. Daughter reported
that mother did daughter’s homework for her, and when the
social worker discussed the matter with mother, mother found it
amusing and laughed it off.
The Department continued to recommend terminating
jurisdiction over son, but continuing jurisdiction over daughter
with family maintenance services and a mental health evaluation
of mother.
At the review hearing in December 2023, minor’s counsel
for son stated he joined the Department’s recommendation to
terminate jurisdiction with joint physical and legal custody over
son, with father having primary physical custody, but asked the
court to keep the current legal custody arrangement in place and
to give father tie-breaking authority. Son’s attorney pointed out
that mother had not gained insight or participated in services,
but that son was only with mother on weekends, so father had
taken primary responsibility for ensuring son received services.4

4 We grant appellant’s June 11, 2025 Request for Judicial
Notice of the juvenile court’s December 13, 2023 custody order
and final judgment regarding son E.L.-M., which provides for

9
Concerning mother’s care of daughter, the court declined to
order a mental health evaluation of mother, but found it would be
detrimental to allow daughter to remain in mother’s care during
the week. While the court did not remove daughter from
mother’s custody, the court did change its placement order from
home of parents to home of father, with mother having
unmonitored weekend visits. The court noted the importance of
daughter being in a safe environment where one parent does not
speak negatively about the other parent in the child’s presence,
and stated that if mother’s conduct changed in the next six
months, it would revisit its decision at that point. The court
added that if there was no progress in the next six months, it
planned to make its temporary home of father order a permanent
one.

C. Second Review Period

By the time the Department submitted its June 2024
status report, mother had completed all of her services, but
continued to exhibit an inability to focus on developing the skills
necessary to effectively parent either child.
Father had met all of daughter’s physical, medical, and
emotional needs, providing her with structure and a supportive
home environment, participating in her annual individualized
education plan (IEP) meeting, ensuring she was attending school
and participating in wraparound services and therapy to address
her behaviors. Father was an active participant in wraparound

joint legal and physical custody of son to mother and father, with
primary residence with father.

10
services, as well as in meetings and sessions with the parent
partner. In contrast, mother continued to exhibit disorganized
thoughts and challenges with comprehension. During a child and
family team meeting with the wraparound team in March 2024,
mother had trouble following the rules of the meeting and
continued to speak negatively about father; mother’s therapist
had to continually redirect mother and re-explain the rules to
her. Mother also made random statements when speaking with
the social worker, or focused on her own trauma, and mother
repeatedly sent the social worker bizarre texts with attachments
unrelated to case issues.
Daughter felt safe with both mother and father and loved
both of them. Daughter reported that son would sometimes call
her inappropriate names when they were both staying with
mother over the weekend. Father reported that daughter’s
negative behaviors with mother occurred because mother would
allow it, and he did not have issues with daughter exhibiting
negative behaviors. He said he was always talking to daughter
about respecting mother, and mother knows she can call him to
help with any behavior problems.
The Department recommended terminating the
dependency case and ordering joint physical and legal custody of
daughter to both parents, with father having primary physical
custody.

D. June 2024 Status Review Hearing and Exit Order

At the June 2024 review hearing, after the Department
noted its recommendation for terminating daughter’s case with a
custody order giving mother and father joint legal and physical

11
custody over daughter, daughter’s counsel asked the court to
enter an order giving father sole physical and legal custody over
daughter, noting mother’s ongoing struggles with mental health
and her inability to meaningfully participate in meetings
concerning daughter. Daughter’s counsel argued that joint legal
custody would be unworkable and too much of a burden on
father, as it would be extremely difficult for father to consult with
mother. Mother did not appear able to respond in a meaningful
way and there was no indication father would make any decisions
that were not in daughter’s best interests. Father’s counsel
joined in the request for sole physical and legal custody with the
same custody arrangement already in place. Mother’s attorney
noted that mother was seeking sole physical and legal custody,
and also pointed out that there was evidence that mother and
father were able to communicate effectively regarding daughter’s
needs, particularly concerning her difficulties with son.
Emphasizing the bond between mother and daughter, and the
fact that mother was able to provide for daughter, counsel asked
the court to keep those facts in mind and enter an appropriate
custody order. The court expressed a high degree of concern with
mother’s ongoing disorganized and bizarre thinking and
behavior, concluding it would preclude parents from making joint
decisions about daughter’s well-being. Relying on the recitation
of facts and law stated by minor’s counsel, the court found it to be
in daughter’s best interests to award father sole legal and
physical custody, with mother continuing to have unmonitored
visits. The custody order was filed on June 20, 2024.

12
DISCUSSION

A. Legal Principles

“Section 362.4 governs the termination of juvenile court
jurisdiction and related orders.” (In re J.M. (2023) 89
Cal.App.5th 95, 112 (J.M.).) “The statute authorizes a juvenile
court to make ‘exit orders’ regarding custody and visitation upon
terminating dependency jurisdiction over a child.” (Ibid.; In re
Chantal S. (1996) 13 Cal.4th 196, 202–203.) “These exit orders
remain in effect until modified or terminated by a subsequent
order of the superior court.” (J.M., supra, 89 Cal.App.5th at
p. 112, citing § 362.4, subd. (b); see also Cal. Rules of Court, rule
5.700.)
“ ‘[I]n making exit orders, the juvenile court must look at
the best interests of the child.’ ” (J.M., supra, 89 Cal.App.5th at
p. 112.) “The juvenile court has a special responsibility to the
child as parens patriae and must look to the totality of a child’s
circumstances when making decisions regarding the child.” (In re
Chantal S., supra, 13 Cal.4th at p. 201.) “Because juvenile
dependency proceedings arise when children are subject to or at
risk of abuse or neglect, ‘[t]he presumption of parental fitness
that underlies custody law in the family court just does not
apply. . . . Rather the juvenile court, which has been intimately
involved in the protection of the child, is best situated to make
custody determinations based on the best interests of the child
without any preferences or presumptions.’ [Citation.]” (J.M.,
supra, 89 Cal.App.5th at p. 112.) “[A] finding that neither parent
poses any danger to the child does not mean that both are equally
entitled to half custody, since joint physical custody may not be in

13
the child’s best interests for a variety of reasons.” (In re Nicholas
H. (2003) 112 Cal.App.4th 251, 268.)
When it makes exit orders, the juvenile court has broad
discretion to decide custody matters, and we review the orders for
an abuse of discretion. (J.M., supra, 89 Cal.App.5th at pp. 112–
113.) We do not disturb the court’s order unless appellant
demonstrates that it exceeds the bounds of reason. (In re
Stephanie M. (1994) 7 Cal.4th 295, 318–319 [reviewing court
cannot substitute its decision for that of the trial court when the
facts can support more than one reasonable inference]; In re N.M.
(2023) 88 Cal.App.5th 1090, 1094.)

B. Analysis

Mother does not contend that the court erred in granting
father sole physical custody of daughter, with unmonitored visits
for mother. Instead, she only challenges the court’s order giving
father sole legal custody, focusing her argument on the
purportedly inadequate reasons for making that order. The court
adopted the reasoning proffered by daughter’s counsel and
father’s counsel, that mother’s bizarre statements and
challenging behaviors could cause difficulties for joint
decisionmaking regarding daughter’s education or medical
treatment. Regardless of the court’s stated reasoning, mother
has not shown the order exceeded the bounds of reason. Her
argument on appeal is nothing more than an argument that we
should weigh the evidence anew, and substitute our judgment for
that of the juvenile court, which we may not do.
In her opening brief, mother cites inapt authorities to argue
that minor’s counsel and father’s counsel bore the burden of proof

14
to convince the court that a sole custody order was warranted,
and they failed to do so. Mother’s argument also highlights
father’s willingness to serve as a resource to assist mother if she
had difficulties with daughter’s behavior. Ultimately, father’s
willingness to work with mother does not overcome the record
evidence of mother’s inability to meaningfully participate in
decisionmaking about daughter’s educational, medical, or
emotional needs. While father was fully engaged in ensuring son
and daughter were engaged with supportive services and
attending school, mother’s track record with schooling and
wraparound services demonstrates that an order of joint legal
custody would not be in daughter’s best interests. On multiple
occasions, mother demonstrated a singular focus on her own
needs at daughter’s expense. Mother kept daughter with a
babysitter simply because a program gave her free babysitting
time, used financial matters to preclude daughter’s visits with
father until he paid her, spoke negatively about father in front of
daughter, did her daughter’s homework, and lied to serve her
own needs. When mother was asked about daughter’s high
number of absences and tardies at school, mother simply said
that daughter did not want to go to school. Mother was unable to
ensure daughter attended therapy regularly. When daughter
started exhibiting defiance and signs of manipulating mother, the
social worker initiated wraparound services, and mother was
initially cooperative. However, mother later accused the
wraparound team of trying to steal daughter from her, and made
plans to fly to El Salvador and send for daughter later. These
facts provide ample basis for the juvenile court to have exercised
its discretion to grant minor’s request to give father sole legal
custody.

15
To the extent mother contends it was error for the juvenile
court to award father sole legal custody because circumstances
had not changed from six months earlier, when the court granted
mother and father joint legal and physical custody of son, no
relevant legal authorities support mother’s argument that the
juvenile court was under any obligation to make its earlier order
concerning son’s custody and visitation equally applicable to
daughter. A court’s custody and visitation orders consider what
is in the best interests of a particular child in light of the totality
of the circumstances. (In re Chantal S., supra, 13 Cal.4th at
p. 201.) The circumstances surrounding son and daughter were
different through the full course of this dependency case. When
the Department began its investigation, it had no concerns with
mother’s ability to care for daughter, and there were no signs of
any issues beyond mother’s inability to protect daughter from
son’s anger and violence. However, during the first review
period, daughter’s behavior deteriorated to the point that the
Department started wraparound services for daughter and
expressed concerns about risk of harm to daughter. At the
December 2023 hearing, the court advised mother that if things
did not improve, it was inclined to keep daughter with father.
Son and daughter are different children with different needs and
circumstances, and through their counsel, they argued that
different exit orders served their best interests. When the
juvenile court terminated dependency jurisdiction over son, no
objection was raised to the Department’s recommendation for
joint legal and physical custody. In contrast, while the
Department still recommended joint legal and physical custody
over daughter, daughter’s attorney argued to the court that an

16
order giving father sole legal custody would better serve
daughter’s interest, and father’s counsel joined in that argument.
On the record before us, mother has not persuaded us that
the juvenile court’s order granting father sole legal custody over
daughter was an abuse of discretion.

DISPOSITION

The juvenile court’s June 20, 2024 custody order is
affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.

MOOR, J.
WE CONCUR:

HOFFSTADT, P. J.

KIM (D.), J.

17

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.