CourtListener 10700404•In re Angel B. CA2/1
Full text
Filed 10/10/25 In re Angel B. CA2/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
In re ANGEL B., a Person B341429
Coming Under the Juvenile (Los Angeles County
Court Law. Super. Ct. No. DK21285)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF
CHILDREN AND FAMILY
SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
E.B.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County, Gabriela H. Shapiro, Judge Pro Tempore.
Affirmed.
Cristina Gabrielidis, under appointment by the
Court of Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Jane Kwon, Principal Deputy
County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
____________________
Appellant mother’s appeal raises one issue: Did the
juvenile court abuse its discretion in requiring four monitored
visits before mother could have unmonitored visitation with her
daughter, Angel. The juvenile court assumed jurisdiction over
Angel when she was five years old and she is now a young teen.
As long as Angel has been in the dependency system, mother has
vacillated between wanting a relationship with Angel and
eschewing reunification, which in turn, has sometimes triggered
Angel’s extreme negative behavior. We conclude the juvenile
court thus did not abuse its discretion in setting the above
limited visitation parameter before allowing unmonitored
visitation. We thus affirm.
BACKGROUND
Angel was born in March 2012 and became a dependent of
the juvenile court in 2017.1 In 2016, prior to the dependency
proceedings, Angel lived with maternal great grandmother
because mother was overwhelmed and unable to care for Angel.
After Angel returned to mother’s care, maternal great
1 In September 2017, Angel’s half sibling was born. This
appeal does not involve Angel’s half sibling. We summarize only
those facts relevant to the sole issue mother raises on appeal.
2
grandmother noticed that Angel would visit with new bruises and
complain of mother spraying hot sauce in her mouth.
Angel has been in and out of her mother’s care during the
dependency proceedings, and mother’s ambivalence towards
parenting Angel has materially negatively affected Angel’s well-
being. We thus detail below these circumstances leading to the
visitation restriction at issue in this appeal.
A. The Juvenile Court Sustains the Original and
Supplemental Petitions
In June 2017, the juvenile court sustained allegations
mother physically abused Angel by repeatedly striking her body
and face with a belt and mother’s open hand and by pouring “hot
sauce in the child’s mouth as a form of discipline. The child is
afraid of the mother. Such physical abuse was excessive and
caused the child unreasonable pain and suffering.”
In May 2018, the juvenile court sustained supplemental
allegations that mother physically abused Angel by pinching her
face and such abuse caused unreasonable pain and suffering.
The juvenile court also sustained the allegation that Angel was at
risk of physical and emotional harm because her half sibling’s
father was convicted of a lewd or lascivious act with a child
under 14.
3
B. Mother’s Visits Are Inconsistent During Angel’s
Placements, and Shortly After Mother Regains
Custody of Angel, Mother Requests Angel’s Removal
1. DCFS places Angel with maternal great
grandparents
In January 2017, DCFS placed Angel with maternal great
grandparents. Angel was four years old at the time. Maternal
great grandmother reported Angel was physically and verbally
aggressive, defiant, and impulsive.
In February 2017, the court ordered mother’s visits
monitored but mother did not visit Angel. In March 2017,
mother told a social worker, “I want my daughter, but I need 4 to
6 months.”
Mother visited Angel on March 31, 2017, and Angel “was
visibly anxious before and after her visit with her mother [and]
that after the visit Angel fell asleep for 2 hours due to
exhaustion.” In December 2017, DCFS reported mother started
visiting consistently, arrived prepared for visits, and set
appropriate limits for Angel. DCFS reported mother and Angel
were “mutually affectionate.”
In December 2017, the juvenile court ordered mother’s
visits unmonitored. The unmonitored visits “reportedly went
well, with no major concerns reported by caregiver or child.”
2. Angel returns to mother’s custody
In February 2018, the juvenile court returned Angel to
mother’s custody. Within two weeks, mother reported Angel was
verbally and physically aggressive and would kick and hit
mother.
4
On April 3, 2018, Angel told a counselor mother pinched
her left cheek and burnt her teddy bear on the stove. The
counselor reported, “[M]other is becoming more aggressive with”
Angel. Mother admitted to scratching Angel’s cheek “while
trying to restrain her” and also admitted to burning the teddy
bear on the stove. 2 Mother told the social worker Angel kicked
her in the groin and stomach and they constantly fought. Mother
told the social worker she was “overwhelmed” and “needed a
break.” Mother reported she had called the police a month
earlier to request “Angel to be removed from her care,” but the
police did not respond to her call. Mother stated Angel was
aggressive, and mother could not control her. The social worker
observed that mother’s home was “filthy” and Angel did not have
a bed.
When the social worker interviewed Angel, Angel “admitted
fighting her mother and kicking her sometimes.”
In April 2018, Mother requested that Angel be removed
from her care and was “relieved” when DCFS did so.
3. DCFS places Angel in shelter care
On April 3, 2018, DCFS detained Angel and placed her in
shelter care. Maternal great grandmother “stated that she [was]
happy that DCFS intervened and removed [Angel] from mother.”
Maternal great grandmother told the social worker mother was
unable to control Angel and that they were constantly fighting.
2 Although mother initially admitted to scratching Angel’s
cheek, she later denied the allegation.
5
4. DCFS places Angel in E.C.’s foster home
On April 13, 2018, DCFS moved Angel to E.C.’s foster
home. Angel looked forward to her monitored visits with mother
and wanted to live with mother. Mother visited two times per
week for two hours. E.C. had unexpected medical issues
requiring Angel to be removed from her care.
5. DCFS places Angel in a respite home
DCFS requested mother identify any possible nonrelated
extended family members for placement. Mother did not respond
in six days. In May 2018, DCFS placed Angel in a “respite home,
licensed through Building Bridges.”
6. DCFS places Angel in B.N. and A.N.’s foster
home
On June 1, 2018, DCFS placed Angel in B.N. and A.N.’s
foster home. On June 1, 2018, DCFS reported mother had not
visited in two weeks. Mother stated she did not want to reunify
with Angel.
In July 2018, however, DCFS reported mother was visiting
consistently and Angel’s foster parents reported no concerns after
mother’s visits. Angel reported enjoying her visits with mother.
At the end of July or beginning of August 2018, the foster
parents requested that Angel be removed from their care because
Angel tripped the foster mother. The foster parents also reported
Angel tried to remove the foster parents’ daughter’s pants and
underwear.
6
7. In August 2018, DCFS places Angel with
maternal great grandparents
On August 3, 2018, Angel returned to her maternal great
grandparents’ care. Angel liked living with maternal great
grandparents, but was “impulsive” and threatened violence.
Angel also threatened to kill paternal grandfather. Angel also
exhibited sexual behavior, such as removing her clothing and
simulating masturbation.
Mother had monitored visits with Angel once a week for
two hours. Angel enjoyed the visits. Maternal great
grandmother reported, “[M]other does not engage well with Angel
and spends a good portion of the visit on her phone while Angel
plays with her toys.” Maternal great grandmother also reported,
Angel said, “[S]he loves her mom.” Angel said she was living
with maternal great grandparents because mother “doesn’t want
me.” Angel told the social worker she preferred living with
maternal great grandparents than with mother.
In December 2019, DCFS reported that Angel did not want
to go to school and would kick and bite maternal great
grandmother. Maternal great grandmother wanted mother to
attend therapy with Angel but mother refused. At that time,
mother continued to visit once a week. (DCFS did not indicate
whether these weekly visits were monitored.) Angel’s behavior
became “more defiant” after her visits with mother. Mother
again told the social worker she no longer wanted to reunify with
Angel.
After maternal great grandfather died, maternal great
grandmother requested that Angel be removed from her home.
Angel had been physically aggressive with maternal great
7
grandmother, used her credit card without permission, and would
watch pornography on television without permission.
8. DCFS places Angel in A.B.’s home
On May 22, 2020, DCFS moved Angel to A.B.’s foster home.
Mother visited once weekly with a monitor.
In February 2021, A.B. reported Angel was defiant, wiped
feces on the walls, wrote on furniture, and broke items in the
home. Angel’s behavior deteriorated when she had visits with
mother. In September 2020, mother stopped visiting.
On June 30, 2021, A.B. requested DCFS remove Angel from
her home.
9. DCFS places Angel in Hillsides Residential
Treatment Program
On July 27, 2021, DCFS placed Angel in Hillsides
Residential Program. In July 2021 mother resumed weekly
monitored visits. Angel was happy to see mother during the
visits but did not want to live with mother.
In December 2021, mother began unmonitored visits. On
December 8, 2021, the court permitted Angel to have an extended
holiday visit with mother.
10. DCFS places Angel in C.C.’s foster home
On December 14, 2021, DCFS placed Angel in C.C.’s foster
home. Within one month, C.C. “reported having difficulties
managing Angel’s behavior” and expressed concern that Angel
refused to go to school. Angel’s school reported Angel slept in
class and would bully other children. Angel had overnight and
weekend visits with mother. According to a social worker, “The
quality of the overnights have varied. On two visits, Angel has
8
become physical with mother. One incident resulted in Angel
leaving a bruise on mother’s arm.”
On August 13, 2022, Angel “was placed on a 72-h[ou]r
hold . . . after throwing objects at caregiver, chasing the other
child in the home with a wooden stake, and running in the
streets.” The hospital released Angel on August 29, 2022 and she
returned to C.C.’ s home.
Angel lived with C.C. for approximately one year until C.C.
requested Angel’s removal “due to escalating aggressive
behaviors towards peers and caregiver . . . .”
11. DCFS places Angel at Five Acres
On January 24, 2023, DCFS placed Angel at Five Acres, a
residential therapeutic program.
DCFS reported, “Mother would like to resume overnights
with Angel once [mother] moves . . . to a bigger apartment . . . .”
DCFS reported Angel had unmonitored visits with mother every
other weekend.
On July 14, 2023, Angel expressed suicidal ideation and
was hospitalized. Angel returned to Five Acres on August 10,
2023.
In September 2023, DCFS reported that mother started
conjoint therapy with Angel. The therapist, however,
“determined mother was not ready” and discontinued the conjoint
therapy. Mother was unable to focus on Angel during the
conjoint therapy sessions. Mother and Angel continued their
overnight visits every other weekend. Angel’s therapist reported,
“Angel has regressed, and her tantrums have become childlike,
e.g., stomping her feet when upset.”
9
On September 12, 2023, Angel ran away from school and
the police located her later that date and transported her back to
Five Acres.
On September 13, 2023, when Angel was told to clean her
room and complete her hygiene tasks, Angel “began to yell at
staff and made statements that she was ‘going to kill everyone by
burning this place down.’ ” Angel repeated she would kill
everyone and added that she would kill herself. Angel was
transported to a hospital and then returned to Five Acres the
next day.
On September 21, 2023, Angel was physically aggressive on
the school bus and was suspended from riding the bus for
six days.
On October 4, 2023, Angel left Five Acres and took public
transportation to mother’s home. Mother contacted Five Acres
and Angel returned there.
On October 5, 2023, Angel threatened “to blow up” Five
Acres. She said that she made that statement because she
did not want to live there. The next day Angel was placed on a
psychiatric hold. On October 11, 2023 Angel returned to Five
Acres.
12. DCFS places Angel in F.T.’s home
On December 1, 2023, DCFS placed Angel in F.T.’s home.
In March 2024, DCFS reported mother no longer visited
Angel. On December 13, 2023, mother decided she no longer
wanted overnight visits and no longer wanted to reunify with
Angel. Angel had a planned visit with mother in January 2023,
but “mother turned [Angel] . . . away stating that she was going
to a concert instead and could no longer visit.” Angel was “very
upset” and asked mother how “she could turn” her away.
10
Mother told Angel that mother would not reunify with her
and that “she won’t be visiting as often.” DCFS reported that
mother statements “affected Angel emotionally and she has a
difficult time talking about it.” Mother told the social worker
“she felt pressure from family to reunify with Angel, but now
recognizes that she is not equipped to parent Angel.”
In an undated report, DCFS reported mother was no longer
approved for unmonitored visits.
On March 29, 2024, the juvenile court issued a protective
custody warrant for Angel because she was missing. The court
recalled the warrant on April 4, 2024 because Angel was located.
After Angel ran away, F.T. requested that Angel be removed from
her care.
13. DCFS places Angel with maternal great
grandmother
On April 16, 2024, DCFS placed Angel with maternal great
grandmother. Mother visited several times and her visits
initially included overnights, but Angel then refused overnight
visits with mother because she was upset with her. In July 2024,
DCFS removed Angel from maternal great grandmother’s home
because of “Angel’s daily defiance, stealing, and physical
aggression.”
14. DCFS places Angel in J.S.’s foster home
On July 15, 2024, DCFS placed Angel in J.S.’s foster home.
Except for attending a dance recital, mother did not have contact
with Angel since Angel was placed in J.S.’s home. DCFS reported
when mother learned Angel was doing well in J.S.’s home,
mother stated “she no longer plans to reunify with Angel.” DCFS
11
reported mother said that she was “foregoing visits” so that she
did not “disrupt” Angel’s new placement.
C. Despite Mother’s Inconsistency In Visiting Angel and
Desire Not To Reunify, the Court Permitted Mother
Additional Reunification Services
In September 2018, mother waived further reunification
services, indicating she did not wish to reunify with Angel. The
juvenile court ordered no further reunification services.
In April 2019, mother filed a Welfare and Institutions
Code3 section 388 petition requesting her reunification services
be reinstated. Mother asserted: “I have made progress in my
parenting and individual counseling. I have learned tools to
parent Angel in an appropriate and loving way. Angel is also
receiving therapy and medication for her ADHD, which helps to
reduce her behavioral issues. I am also keeping up with my
anger management classes, individual counseling and have
completed family communication skills.” On July 2, 2019, the
court granted mother’s request for additional reunification
services. As of December 2019, mother had not participated in
any reunification services. In December 2019, DCFS reported
again mother no longer wanted to reunify with Angel.
In January 2020, the juvenile court terminated mother’s
reunification services.
On July 19, 2021, mother filed another section 388 petition
requesting additional reunification services. Mother asserted
Angel’s “behavior hasn’t improved because the fact is she feels I
don’t want her but that’s not true. I’m more mentally and
3 Undesignated statutory citations are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.
12
financially stable now than before.” On September 7, 2021, the
court noted mother waived reunification services, then obtained
additional reunification services and then her reunification
services were terminated. Nevertheless, the court was willing to
consider mother’s section 388 petition on the merits, hoping for “a
chance to help this child.”
“This is the last one.” The court stated, “Let’s see if
mother’s really going to follow through.” The court ordered DCFS
“to work with mother to reunify” with Angel and to provide
mother referrals.
D. In September 2024, After a Hearing, the Court
Ordered Four Monitored Visits Prior To Permitting
Mother Unmonitored Visitation
At a September 23, 2024 hearing, mother’s counsel stated,
“Mother would be objecting to her visits being reverted to
monitored today.” Counsel indicated that DCFS misunderstood
mother. Mother did not want to forego visits completely, but
“only [to] halt visits until Angel is . . . stable in the home of the
caregiver.” Mother’s counsel asserted (without evidentiary
support) that mother had visited August 4, 2024 (approximately
six weeks before the hearing). Mother’s counsel requested
Angel’s therapist “assess when it would be appropriate for
mother to resume her visits . . . .”
DCFS requested the juvenile court order mother’s visits
monitored. DCFS’s counsel noted the “tenuousness” of Angel’s
placements and reminded the court that this case was not in
reunification period.
Angel’s counsel argued, “I do think it would be in Angel’s
best interest that visits stay as they are” (which counsel did not
further explain). According to Angel’s counsel, “Mother is a very
13
important person to Angel.” Acknowledging that mother had not
been visiting, counsel added, “[H]opefully mother will begin to
start visiting Angel, soon.”
The court stated, “The court does have concerns and notes
that we are not in reunification and would like to see some
monitored visits before the court allows the visits to continue as
unmonitored in light of the new placement changes that have
occurred and will order that four monitored visits occur. [¶] And
if there are no concerns or issues and Angel seems to be doing
well, then the visits can revert back to unmonitored in a neutral
setting.”
E. Juvenile Court Order
The court’s September 23, 2024 order stated in pertinent
part: “Mother is to have 4 monitored visits with Angel . . . and if
no concerns, then DCFS is to permit unmonitored visit to
resume . . . .” This is the order that is the subject of this appeal.
DISCUSSION
Mother argues, “The juvenile court erred when it restricted
mother to monitored visitation.” (Boldface & capitalization
omitted.) According to mother, “There is no benefit to Angel for
requiring monitored visitation and the child was not at risk in
Mother’s care.”
When a juvenile court orders visitation between a parent
and child, visitation shall be as frequent as possible, but no
visitation order shall jeopardize the child’s safety. (§ 362.1,
subd. (a).) This includes both the child’s physical and emotional
safety. (In re T.M. (2016) 4 Cal.App.5th 1214, 1219.) In
fashioning visitation orders, the juvenile court’s focus is on the
child’s best interests. (In re C.M. (2019) 38 Cal.App.5th 101,
14
109.) We review a visitation order for an abuse of discretion.
(In re J.P. (2019) 37 Cal.App.5th 1111, 1119 [“Visitation orders in
dependency cases are typically reviewed for abuse of discretion
and will not be reversed absent a ‘clear showing of an abuse of
discretion.’ ”].) “ ‘ “The appropriate test for abuse of discretion is
whether the trial court exceeded the bounds of reason. When two
or more inferences can reasonably be deduced from the facts, the
reviewing court has no authority to substitute its decision for
that of the trial court.” ’ [Citation.]” (In re Stephanie M. (1994)
7 Cal.4th 295, 318–319.)
Given Angel’s dependency history, we conclude the juvenile
court did not abuse its discretion in requiring four monitored
visits before allowing unmonitored visitation.
Throughout the dependency proceedings, Angel has been
shuttled in and out of multiple caretaking placements either
because mother, by her own admission, either was unable to
handle Angel or was not interested in reunifying with her. Most
recently, Angel began living with J.S. on July 15, 2024, about
two months prior to the juvenile court’s order. During that time,
mother stopped visiting. Although mother’s counsel represented
mother visited on August 4, 2024, the evidence demonstrates that
except for attending a dance recital, Mother did not have contact
with Angel since Angel was living in J.S.’s home. The four
monitored visits are a reasonable means to allow the monitor to
assess mother’s and Angel’s relationship after mother had
voluntarily stopped visiting and after mother had abandoned a
scheduled visit just to attend a concert. Monitored visitation
would also give data to the court in assessing whether the
physical aggression present earlier in mother and Angel’s
relationship was resolved and whether mother was able to
15
commit to Angel’s needs during the visits, something maternal
great grandmother and the conjoint therapist questioned.
Although mother had progressed to unmonitored overnight visits,
Angel refused the overnight visits shortly before mother stopped
visiting. Mother never completed conjoint counseling and there
was no therapist assessment as to mother’s ability to interact
with Angel positively so as to ensure Angel’s physical and
emotional well-being.
Ordering four monitored visits did not prevent Angel from
seeing mother or in any way limit the frequency of Angel and
mother’s visits. Contrary to mother’s assertion, it did not prevent
her from “preserv[ing]” her relationship with Angel. Instead, the
court imposed a short limitation on unfettered visitation to
ensure Angel’s well-being, an apt term given mother’s repeated
assertions of inability or lack of desire to reunify with Angel.
Even mother appeared to acknowledge whether her visits were in
Angel’s best interest when she asked that Angel’s therapist
assess when it would be appropriate for mother to resume her
visits. In sum, we agree with respondent that in light of mother’s
ambivalence about parenting Angel and the emotional toll that
ambivalence has taken on Angel throughout the dependency
proceedings, the juvenile court’s order requiring four monitored
visits was “measured” and “did not exceed the bounds of reason.”
16
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s September 23, 2024 order requiring
four monitored visits is affirmed. Mother has not otherwise
challenged the September 23, 2024 order, which we therefore
affirm in its entirety.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.
BENDIX, Acting P. J.
We concur:
WEINGART, J.
M. KIM, J.
17
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.