In re K.B. CA3

CourtListener 10676947CalctappSep 24, 2025

Full text

Filed 9/24/25 In re K.B. CA3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THIRD APPELLATE DISTRICT
(Butte)
----

In re K.B., a Person Coming Under the Juvenile Court C102502
Law.

BUTTE COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF (Super. Ct. No. 22DP00241)
EMPLOYMENT AND SOCIAL SERVICES,

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

K.S. et al.,

Defendants;

K.B.,

Appellant.

K.B. (minor) appeals from the juvenile court’s orders (1) terminating parental
rights and freeing the minor for adoption, and (2) denying grandmother’s request for

1
placement. (Welf. & Inst. Code,1 §§ 366.26, 361.3.) The minor contends the juvenile
court erred in not placing the minor with grandmother at the initial detention hearing, at
the disposition hearing, at the six-month review hearing, or when the minor was moved to
a new placement. Minor also contends it was in the minor’s best interest to place her
with her relatives (her grandmother and younger brother, C.B.) under section 361.3. We
affirm.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
On October 7, 2022, Chico Police searched for father, J.B. (father), who was a
suspect in a stabbing. During their search, they discovered the minor, a five-month-old
female infant, in a tent in a homeless camp. Police also found marijuana and
methamphetamine drug paraphernalia in the tent near the minor. The tent was filled with
trash and infested with bugs.
Police arrested father on an outstanding warrant and for possession of a controlled
substance and mother for child endangerment. Social workers took the minor into
protective custody.
Mother said she had been in an “ ‘off and on’ ” relationship with father since she
was 14 and the pair had been homeless for the last several months. They had been
staying in the tent for the last week and a half or two weeks and, prior to that, had been
staying with relatives. Mother admitted she had a history of methamphetamine use but
claimed she had gotten clean during her pregnancy with the minor. She asserted now she
used only marijuana.
Father denied involvement in the stabbing but admitted methamphetamine and
marijuana use. He had previously completed three months of substance abuse treatment
prior to the minor’s birth but relapsed shortly after leaving that program. He claimed he,
mother, and the minor had been staying in the park for only a day or two.

1 Further undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions Code.

2
Grandmother, L.A. (grandmother), expressed an interest in placement. The
detention report noted, however, grandmother lived in Lancaster and the physical
distance between Butte County and her residence would interfere with parental visitation.
The Butte County Department of Employment and Social Services (Department)
filed a dependency petition under section 300, subdivisions (b)(1) and (g). The petition
alleged there was a substantial risk the minor would suffer serious physical harm or
illness due to the willful or negligent failure of the parents or the inability of the parents
to provide care due to substance abuse. The petition further alleged the minor was left
without parental support due to the arrest of both parents.
The juvenile court held the detention hearing on October 12, 2022. Father
objected at that hearing. The minor submitted on the reports. The juvenile court detained
the minor, placed her with the Department, and ordered services for the parents pending
further proceedings. The minute order reflects later that morning, when mother appeared
and submitted, the juvenile court confirmed its prior findings. No one objected to the
failure of the juvenile court to place the minor with grandmother, the efforts of the
Department, or sought appellate review of that order.
Mother and father attended the jurisdictional hearing in November 2022. Mother
signed a waiver of rights and submitted; father objected without evidence or testimony.
The juvenile court found the petition allegations true. The juvenile court ordered
reasonable visitation and set a disposition hearing. Again no party objected to the
placement or sought appellate review of that order.
In the disposition report, the Department reported the minor was in foster care and
that grandmother and great-grandmother were interested in placement but lived in
Southern California. The Department noted it was currently attempting to provide
reunification services to the parents who lived in Butte County and moving the minor out
of county would inhibit those services. Mother and father agreed that to be safe and
stable parents for the minor, they needed to remain clean and sober. Mother and father

3
visited the minor twice weekly. Mother began parent engagement classes, and she
completed an assessment with behavioral health and began participating in a behavioral
health program. Father began the parent engagement classes but was not participating in
any drug or alcohol counseling services. Mother and father, however, both admitted to
recent ongoing methamphetamine use.
The parents identified grandmother and great-grandmother as the family’s
preference for placement in the event neither parent successfully reunified with the
minor. The Department recommended the minor be placed under its supervision and that
a plan of family reunification should be ordered as to mother, but reunification services
should not be offered to father.
At the disposition hearing on November 30, 2022, mother, father, and the minor
submitted on the matter. The juvenile court declared the minor a dependent, removed her
from mother’s and father’s custody, and ordered family reunification services for both
parents. No party objected to the placement or filed a notice of appeal.
The May 2023 six-month status report noted mother had recently relapsed and was
arrested for violating her probation. Father had not been able to maintain sobriety or
abide by the terms of his probation. Both parents were unemployed, without a car or safe
home, and in the early stages of recovery from their methamphetamine addiction.
Both mother and father agreed they did not have the ability to safely care for their
daughter or a home or resources to do so. Mother and father again named grandmother
as their preferred concurrent plan for the minor so they are able to ensure her safety with
a relative. Both grandmother and great-grandmother were ready and willing to be a
concurrent plan for the minor. In the report, the Department recommended family
reunification services be denied to both father and mother and that the juvenile court set a
section 366.26 permanency plan hearing.
The juvenile court held a six-month review hearing on May 17, 2023.
Grandmother attended the hearing. Mother objected to the Department’s

4
recommendation and requested a contested hearing; father joined that request. The
juvenile court set the matter for a contested six-month review hearing on June 27, 2023.
At the contested hearing in June, the parties agreed they would submit on the
recommendation to terminate family reunification services and to set a section 366.26
hearing with the understanding the parents’ intended permanent plan would be legal
guardianship with grandmother. The juvenile court terminated reunification services for
both the parents and set a section 366.26 hearing for October 25, 2023. The juvenile
court ordered visitation consistent with the well-being of the minor and with the
grandparents in a manner that served the best interests of the minor. There was no
objection to this order or appellate review requested.
The section 366.26 hearing commenced on October 25, 2023, but did not conclude
until October 30, 2024. The juvenile court allowed the parties to brief the issue of
whether the minor should be placed with grandmother in their closing briefs.
In the original section 366.26 report, the Department recommended that the
juvenile court terminate parental rights as to both parents and find the minor adoptable.
Adoptions Specialist Heather Knight echoed this recommendation in an attachment to the
section 366.26 report.
According to Knight, the minor had a four-month-old full brother who was
currently in the hospital and grandmother intended to apply for guardianship of the
brother, but there was no significant positive relationship between the siblings. Although
grandmother had engaged in a video call with the minor for a minimal amount of time,
she had not followed through with the resource family approval process. The initial
resource family approval referral had been made in May 2023, but the referral had been
closed due to the lack of her follow through. Knight conducted a parent‑child suitability
assessment of grandmother and determined placement and permanency were not
appropriate. Grandmother was not able to articulate or provide documentation of her
sobriety date and had not taken the next steps necessary to be resource family approved

5
for the placement. Knight concluded, “[G]randmother and great-grandmother do not
have the capacity to parent safely full-time and cannot meet the [minor]’s long-term
needs. Based on the parent‑child suitability assessment completed to date, the placement
appears to not be appropriate. Therefore, permanency cannot be approved.”
At the continued hearing in November 2023, the juvenile court noted there had
been some family members seeking placement, but the report was not clear. The juvenile
court asked the Department to file an addendum to the report to address this issue and
continued the hearing.
The Department filed an addendum to the section 366.26 report on November 21,
2023. The Department noted the minor had been in a foster home since October 2022,
but that family was not in a position to provide her with permanency. The minor had
recently matched with an adoptive family and would be transitioned to a new home in
November. The addendum confirmed grandmother (and great-grandmother) expressed
an interest in placement and began the resource family approval process in Los Angeles
in May 2023, but the two did not complete the initial required classes and the application
was withdrawn due to their lack of follow through. A new referral had been sent to Los
Angeles County in August of 2023, which was still being processed. The addendum
noted the social worker’s concerns with grandmother’s sobriety date and her ability to
care for two children under two, including the minor’s brother.
The juvenile court held the continued section 366.26 hearing and a periodic review
hearing in early December 2023, but continued the matter to allow father’s counsel to
locate father. At the next hearing, the court set the matter for a contested section 366.26
hearing in February 2024.
At the February 2024 hearing, the social worker testified the Department
recommended terminating the mother’s and father’s parental rights. The social worker
testified that when she made her permanency recommendation, she assessed
grandmother. The social worker confirmed grandmother did not make much progress in

6
the May 2023 resource family approval process because she was having construction in
her home and did not complete the required training. Due to that construction, she was
unable to keep the minor in her care. As of this hearing date, grandmother still needed to
have her home assessed and complete a “bio psycho social assessment.” The social
worker confirmed placement with grandmother during the early stages of the case would
have interfered with visitation from the mother and father.
The social worker testified as to her concerns about grandmother’s sobriety.
Grandmother reported different dates of sobriety and then was not sure of the date. From
there, she was vague on the steps she had taken to become sober. The social worker also
had concerns about grandmother’s ability to care for the minor because she was also
caring for the minor’s younger brother who was medically fragile and needed extensive
follow-up care. In addition, the social worker did not believe grandmother could protect
the minor from her parents. The social worker told grandmother that if the minor was in
her home, father could not be there. She responded that she understood but wanted to
help father.
In terms of visitation, the social worker said grandmother and the minor have had
phone calls and video calls. Grandmother also visited the minor once when she was in
the prior foster home. The two did not interact much and the social worker did not
believe there was a significant relationship between the two.
When the social worker finished testifying, the Department asked to continue the
hearing to allow it additional time to complete the resource family approval process and
provide the juvenile court with the assessment. The juvenile court granted the
continuance and ordered that the relatives requesting placement be fully assessed.
The Department filed a second addendum to the section 366.26 report in March
2024, noting the minor was now in a home that was willing to provide permanency in the
form of adoption should the minor be found adoptable and the parental rights terminated.
That addendum repeated that grandmother’s initial application for the resource family

7
approval had been withdrawn due to the lack of her follow through and the current
resource family approval had not yet been completed. Grandmother and
great‑grandmother continued to put up barriers to completing the resource family
approval process and had not provided the required documentation. The social worker
working on the resource family approval process reported that grandmother would
change or withhold information and then later provide new information. For these
reasons, the Los Angeles County social worker did not learn grandmother had lived in
Texas for some period of time until the second interview, which caused a delay in the
resource family approval assessment.
According to the second addendum, grandmother resided with the maternal
great‑grandmother and the minor’s brother. The maternal great-grandmother had several
arrests dating back to 1995 through 1996, including for possession of a controlled
substance for sale, welfare fraud, and perjury. In addition, grandmother’s background
checks were incomplete because she had lived in Texas in 2018. Grandmother had prior
issues with heavy drinking and methamphetamine use, and further investigation revealed
grandmother and her ex-husband were the subject of referrals stating that they fought
often and both abused methamphetamines. There were reports that grandmother
attempted suicide while the unspecified children in her care were sent over to a
neighbor’s home. The second addendum continued that grandmother had not followed
through with providing supporting documents and repeated the prior concerns about
grandmother’s ability to protect the minor.
The second addendum further reported grandmother told the social worker she
admitted herself into an in-patient treatment center in October 2019 for alcohol and
methamphetamine use and was discharged after 30 days. The statement that her
treatment was for both drugs and alcohol contradicted a previous conversation where
grandmother stated she sought treatment only for alcohol. Grandmother admitted one
relapse in August of 2022 related to methamphetamines and alcohol but again had

8
previously admitted only to alcohol use. In 2021, a mandated reporter reported
grandmother had used methamphetamines with mother and that grandmother tested
positive for methamphetamines. Grandmother denied ever using methamphetamines
with her daughter and said she had never been ordered to drug test.
The second addendum indicated grandmother had followed up on the guardianship
of the minor’s brother but had not yet provided documentation of those efforts. She also
failed to provide documentation showing she continued to work on her sobriety.
Grandmother also admitted allowing the father to stay at her home for three weeks.
During that stay, father stole her car.
The second addendum indicated the minor did not have a substantial relationship
with grandmother or the maternal great-grandmother. Grandmother had video calls with
the minor during mother’s visits but had not visited her in person. The addendum
concluded there were many factors prohibiting the placement with grandmother (and
great-grandmother), including their “good moral character, providing an accurate
representation of [their prior] substance abuse history, and the relationship dynamic” with
grandmother’s ex-husband and the parents.
The Department also submitted an amended adoptions report. This report noted
grandmother failed to fully fill out the family history questionnaires. She did not respond
to questions about her recent use of drugs and alcohol, her recovery, mental health
services, and medications for mental illnesses. During the follow-up conversation,
grandmother stated she began using illegal substances at the age of 15, but later stated it
was 2018. She claimed to have completed a treatment program in 2019 and relapsed in
2022. She did not, however, provide the requested documentation on these subjects to
the adoption specialist or to the Los Angeles County social worker.
The report provided the social worker’s evaluation of the best interest of the
minor, the wishes of the parents, the placement of her sibling in grandmother’s home, the
good moral character of the relatives, the nature and duration of the relationship between

9
the minor and grandmother, the ability to provide legal permanence, and the safety of the
home. At this point, the minor had not met her brother and did not have a positive
relationship with him. The lack of a completed resource family approval process also
called into question the safety of grandmother’s home.
Meanwhile, the contested section 366.26 hearing was continued multiple times to
August 2024.
Prior to the continued hearing, the Department filed an amended addendum report
in March 2024 containing the following information. The potential adoptive family had
agreed to facilitate appropriate contact with the minor’s family members who wanted to
be part of the minor’s life. The report stated the parents wanted the minor placed with
grandmother, and the Department had made efforts pursuant to the Family Code
regarding relative placement. The background check had been received, and a third
interview with grandmother had been scheduled. A probate investigator in Los Angeles
who was doing an investigation for the guardianship of the minor’s brother also had
concerns about grandmother’s relapse in 2022 and had said she had no way to confirm
grandmother was no longer drinking. The investigator reported grandmother had not
timely applied for guardianship in Los Angeles and the investigator would be denying the
guardianship due to her lack of being “forthcoming” and withholding of previous child
welfare history. The investigator also expressed concerns about grandmother’s ability to
provide for the minor as the services that provide her with diapers, formula, and other
provisions would not be provided if the guardianship was not approved. Mother also had
confirmed using methamphetamines with grandmother, contrary to grandmother’s
statement.
The Department filed an additional addendum report in July 2024, informing the
juvenile court grandmother had reached out for three video visits with the minor. The
video visits were short as the minor was easily distracted, but the minor was quickly

10
redirected when shown her baby brother as the minor enjoys babies. The minor was
comfortable in her current placement and was attached to her caregiver.
At this time, the Department was still waiting for the final decision from the Los
Angeles resource family approval assessment. But the social worker had been informed
that the Los Angeles social worker had submitted the assessment as a denial to the legal
team and the final decision would be up to their legal counsel.
During an unannounced visit to grandmother’s (and great-grandmother’s) home,
social worker Erin Sweet observed the home was cluttered with tools, clothing, and
belongings. It needed some structural repairs, as the subfloor had been exposed in one
bedroom. The bedroom was very hot because the only air conditioning in the house was
a window unit in the living room. The crib set up for the minor was full of items. In
another room, there were vape pens within a child’s reach. During her conversation with
grandmother, the social worker noted that grandmother’s sobriety timelines did not make
sense.
On August 20, 2024, the juvenile court held the second day of the contested
hearing and the third day of testimony on September 5, 2024.
Sweet testified as to her unannounced visit to grandmother’s home in line with the
report she submitted. She noted the cluttered state of the porch and the home, the lack of
any place for the family to sit and have a meal, the extreme warmth of the bedroom, the
crib piled with belongings, the exposure of the subfloor in the bedroom, and the room
with vape pens.
She also spoke with grandmother about her sobriety. Sweet testified to her
concerns about the length of grandmother’s sobriety, that she was not in a recovery
program, had no formal support, and was intentionally omitting details. Sweet also had
concerns about grandmother’s ability to keep the minor safe in the home, concluding it
would be a struggle for grandmother to add a second child to her care.

11
Social worker Leslie Lopez testified she asked for paperwork from grandmother
concerning her attendance at Narcotics Anonymous and Alcoholics Anonymous, her
recovery paperwork, and her guardianship paperwork. Grandmother did not provide
them.
As of this hearing date, Los Angeles County had denied the resource family
approval for grandmother. The social worker testified grandmother’s visits with the
minor were sporadic and through video. As of this August hearing, she had not engaged
in a visit since July 3, 2024.
The social worker restated her opinion that the parent’s parental rights should be
terminated at this time. She considered the minor’s relationship with her younger brother
in that assessment. She noted, “[The minor] was only five months [old] when she was
detained; she doesn’t have an actual relationship with [the brother] or with the other
sibling. They do have video visits, and they will continue to have those video visits with
the current caretaker to have a relationship, but I don’t think that it’s strong enough for us
to not [terminate the parental rights].”
The social worker also testified she did not believe the minor should be placed
with grandmother. She based this opinion on her conversations with grandmother, her
lack of a sobriety date, her changing timelines as to her sobriety, and her concealment of
her use of methamphetamines. She was also concerned that grandmother would not
protect the minor from her parents. The social worker was also concerned about maternal
great-grandmother’s presence in the home given her unwillingness to provide disclosures
of her past and her criminal record.
Adoptions Specialist Knight, who prepared the original adoption assessment,
testified she found the minor generally adoptable. When the minor transitioned from her
first foster home to the second foster home, she had already been working with
grandmother and great-grandmother to preliminarily assess them, but they had not been
resource family approved. She confirmed she asked for a second referral to Los Angeles

12
County for a resource family approval to assess them in August 2023. Her preliminary
assessment was that they were not appropriate for placement, but she encouraged them to
continue with the resource family approval process.
Like the other social worker, Knight did not find grandmother or
great‑grandmother to be forthcoming with information, especially on issues of drug and
alcohol abuse, and said they would provide new information that contradicted the original
information given. This caused her to question grandmother’s moral character. She did
consider that the minor’s brother lived with grandmother. She noted that there had not
been much growth in that sibling relationship given the children’s young ages and limited
visitation. She was also concerned about grandmother’s ability to provide a safe and
stable environment given her lack of employment and lack of longevity in her home.
Grandmother had also allowed the parents into her home during the dependency case.
On cross-examination, Knight said that if grandmother had been resource family
approved, she would have had the ability to further assess her and ask additional
questions, but she did not believe that would change her opinion. She stated resource
family approval is not a guarantee of placement, so the parenting classes are not required,
but it is something that she considers in determining whether a family can meet a child’s
ongoing and long-term needs. She did say that resource family approval was required for
placement and funding.
Grandmother testified next via video conferencing. Grandmother testified she had
custody of the minor’s one-year-old brother since September 2023 and had been granted
guardianship in June 2024. She asserted the minor’s brother did not have any special
needs. She had no concerns about being able to care for both the minor and her baby
brother. Her guardianship made her eligible for assistance through Temporary Assistance
for Needy Families, CalFresh, and Women, Infants & Children.
Grandmother believed hanging out with the wrong people and her failing marriage
were the reasons she started to abuse methamphetamines in 2016. To avoid repeating

13
this pattern, her solution was to “keep to herself.” She could not identify any tools, skills,
or classes that would help her in the future.
Grandmother testified that her sobriety date was August 2, 2022. She stated she
never gave any of the investigators different dates but may have misstated the date she
went into rehabilitation in 2019. She also admitted a relapse with alcohol and
methamphetamines in July 2022. She claimed she started to go to Narcotics Anonymous
meetings and was still attending meetings twice a week, she enrolled in a 26-week
outpatient program, and she underwent some counseling. Grandmother testified she
engaged in voluntary drug testing on her own. She was no longer going to counseling.
She claimed she had provided her certificate of completion to the social worker sometime
in 2023. Grandmother knew the Butte County social workers questioned her honesty and
chalked it up to her being “terrible with timelines.” She again denied ever using
methamphetamines with mother.
Grandmother testified the minor and the minor’s mother had lived with her the
first three months of the minor’s life, and she had daily contact with the minor during that
time. Since then, she has had only a single in-person visit with the minor. She also had
two to three video visits each month.
Grandmother first claimed never to have received any notice she was denied for
resource family approval certification. She later claimed to have completed all the
paperwork but admitted she failed to take the classes in this process but was informed
that she would have to reapply for resource family approval. When asked about this, she
asserted her application was complete, but she was in the middle of a remodel job and did
not complete it in a timely fashion. She then admitted she received a letter stating they
were ceasing the application process. She reapplied sometime in July or August of 2023.
She testified she completed all the classes in the second application. She also testified
she had received nothing indicating the second application had been denied.

14
Grandmother agreed her home was very cluttered during the unannounced visit
because she was going through a storage shed. She indicated that the subflooring
observed by the adoption specialist has since been covered by carpet. She claimed to
have cleaned up the house since then.
On rebuttal Adoption Specialist Knight testified grandmother contacted the current
foster parents to visit with the minor only one time per month and this was typically right
before court hearings. She also stated grandmother first claimed to have used “ ‘meth’ ”
when she was 15. She later changed that statement to be when she was an adult. Knight
confirmed that the first resource family approval process was stalled because of a lack of
progress in completing the process.
Social worker Lopez testified she received an e-mail from the Los Angeles social
worker in August of 2024 indicating that they intended to deny grandmother’s resource
family approval application. She also testified the Department never received any
information from grandmother about her participation in a 26-week treatment program.
Indeed, she could not find the program grandmother said she attended. When she looked
up the address of the program, it turned out to be a six bedroom residential home.
After receiving briefing from the parties, the juvenile court found the minor
adoptable and terminated the parental rights, as there was no evidence to support any of
the exceptions to terminating parental rights.
The juvenile court provided a detailed ruling as to why it declined the request to
place the minor with grandmother. The juvenile court affirmed it was making an
independent placement decision under section 361.3.
The juvenile court agreed grandmother was mentioned in all of the reports starting
with the detention report. At the start of the case, however, placement with grandmother
was not appropriate because the parents, who lived in Butte County, desired to reunify
and grandmother lived in Los Angeles.

15
The juvenile court found the first resource family approval was started with
grandmother in May of 2023. The court stated, “[G]randmother did not attend any of the
classes required, and although the timing may have been unfortunate, was not in a
position to have the [minor] placed with her because her housing was in need of repairs.·
Reunification services were terminated on June 27th, 2023, and, therefore, [the minor’s]
need for permanence was set in motion.”
The juvenile court noted the October 2023 report revealed that the minor’s current
placement would not provide permanence, which put everyone on notice that a new
placement was being contemplated. The adoption report discussed the assessment of
grandmother and determined that placement and permanency with her was not
appropriate. The juvenile court stated that if there were concerns about that
determination, they should have been raised at that point.
The juvenile court stated the November 2023 report noted the new adoptive home
had been discovered and the plan was to move the minor to that new home. The report
noted a second resource family approval was started for grandmother in August 2023.
The juvenile court acknowledged counsel argued grandmother had not been assessed,
however, she was assessed, and counsel should have raised questions as to that
assessment at that point in time.
The juvenile court found the facts of this case diverged from those of Cesar V. v.
Superior Court (2001) 91 Cal.App.4th 1023: “The [c]ourt also notes that the facts in
Cesar V are somewhat different in that the social worker in that case began looking for
another foster family even before that relative had received the forms needed for the
assessment. That is not the case here. [G]randmother had the opportunity to become
approved starting in May of 2023, and did not complete the process. The adoptions
specialist did not start matching until sometime after, and did not propose . . . to move
[the minor] until six months after . . . grandmother started and then stopped the process.”

16
In making its independent placement decision, the juvenile court considered the
best interest of the minor. The juvenile court was mindful that the delay in completing
the contested hearing meant the minor had become more bonded with her potential
adoptive parents. These delays were due to father’s custodial status, the resource family
approval processes in Los Angeles, and illnesses in some instances. The juvenile court
relied on the fact that grandmother did not demonstrate she was serious about the
resource family approval process. It found that if grandmother had been serious, she
would have completed the required classes, and she did not do so until after the second
referral had been made. The juvenile court considered the wishes of mother and father
and found Family Code section 7950 had been followed.
The juvenile court found the factor that the minor’s sibling was living with
grandmother complicated the analysis. The court continued: “However, [the minor and
her brother] were not removed at the same time, obviously, because [the brother] had not
yet been born. And [the brother] is not a dependent of the [c]ourt, but rather in a probate
guardianship situation with . . . grandmother. They do not have a sibling relationship.
And while one, obviously, could be formed, the [c]ourt is concerned about placing the
child with a relative who was denied [resource family] approval.”
The juvenile court did not put much weight on the issue of the good moral
character of grandmother, but did note that it was concerned with her vague answers and
grandmother’s former use of drugs (coupled with that of the parents). It was also
concerned with some of grandmother’s answers during her testimony and found she had
been evasive.
The juvenile court found the nature and duration of grandmother’s relationship
with the minor was minimal. The record disclosed that after the initial five months of
living with the minor, grandmother made limited efforts to maintain that relationship.
Her video visits two or three times a month were not significant in this minor’s young

17
life, especially when grandmother could have easily made two or three times a week
visits via video.
Finally, the juvenile court stated, “Regarding the factors under [section 361.3,
subdivision (a)(7)], the denial of the [resource family approval] does call into question
the ability to provide a safe, secure, and stable environment, as well as to exercise proper
and effective control of the [minor], and to provide the home and necessities of life. [¶]
The descriptions elicited during the social workers’ testimony . . . indicate that maybe she
could, but the [c]ourt is concerned with placing a child in an unapproved home. [¶] In
addition, I’m concerned about her ability to protect the [minor] from her parents.” This
latter concern was evidenced by grandmother’s open door policy with the parents and
failure to call law enforcement when father stole her car. In the end, the juvenile court
put “the most weight on the best interest of the child, the minimal relationship [with
grandmother], and her lack of commitment to following through with the process when
she was initially given the opportunity.”
Minor appeals.2
DISCUSSION
I
Forfeiture
Minor argues: (1) the Department failed to meet the requirements of section 309
and place the minor in grandmother’s home when she was first removed from the
parents’ custody, (2) substantial evidence does not support the juvenile court’s finding at
the disposition hearing that the Department made diligent efforts to locate and investigate
grandmother during the proceedings, and (3) the juvenile court erred when it approved
relocating the minor to another foster placement without considering grandmother’s

2 Mother also filed a notice of appeal, but this court dismissed her appeal after she
failed to file an opening brief.

18
request for placement under section 361.3. Each of these contentions is forfeited by
minor’s failure to pursue the matter in the juvenile court or seek appellate review of these
now final orders.
“ ‘Dependency appeals are governed by section 395, which provides in relevant
part: “A judgment in a proceeding under [s]ection 300 may be appealed from in the same
manner as any final judgment, and any subsequent order may be appealed from as from
an order after judgment . . . .” ’ [Citation.] Section 395 makes the dispositional order the
appealable ‘judgment.’ Therefore, all subsequent orders are directly appealable, except
for orders setting a section 366.26 hearing, challenged by a timely writ petition, which
was summarily denied or not decided on the merits.” (In re A.K. (2017) 12 Cal.App.5th
492, 500-501.) In A.K., the court concluded that if the father believed the Department
“had not complied with statutory requirements in pursuing . . . a relative placement, he
could have raised the issue in the juvenile court and, thereafter, on appeals from the
disposition order, the 12-month review order, or [any of the other] appealable orders.”
(Id. at p. 501.) He did not do so and thus forfeited his objection to the Department’s
actions regarding relative placement. (Ibid.)
Similarly here, the minor could have raised this issue in response to each of the
orders challenged, at detention, at jurisdiction, at the six-month review hearing, or when
the minor was moved to a new placement in November 2023. No one raised an objection
in the juvenile court and the record demonstrates no party sought appellate review of
those orders. That failure forfeited these issues.
II
Relative Placement
The minor alternatively contends that it was in the minor’s best interest to be
placed with her grandmother and sibling under section 361.3. We disagree.
In determining where to place a child removed from the physical custody of the
child’s parents, preferential consideration is given to relatives. (§ 361.3, subd. (a); see

19
also § 319, subd. (h)(2).) A “ ‘[r]elative’ ” is defined as “an adult who is related to the
child by blood, adoption, or affinity within the fifth degree of kinship.” (§ 361.3,
subd. (c)(2); see § 319, subd. (h)(2).) “ ‘Section 361.3 gives “preferential consideration”
to a relative’s request for placement, which means “that the relative seeking placement
shall be the first placement to be considered and investigated.” (§ 361.3, subd. (c)(1).)’
[Citation.] ‘When considering whether to place the child with a relative, the juvenile
court must apply the [section 361.3] placement factors, and any other relevant factors,
and exercise its independent judgment concerning the relative’s request for placement.’ ”
(In re A.K., supra, 12 Cal.App.5th at p. 498.) Placement with a relative is neither
required nor guaranteed. (§ 16519.5, subd. (c)(6).)
We review a juvenile court’s determination regarding relative placement pursuant
to section 361.3 for abuse of discretion. (In re Robert L. (1993) 21 Cal.App.4th 1057,
1067.) “[E]valuating the factual basis for an exercise of discretion is similar to analyzing
the sufficiency of the evidence for the ruling.” (Ibid.) “Broad deference must be shown
to the trial judge. The reviewing court should interfere only ‘ “if [it] find[s] that under all
the evidence, viewed most favorably in support of the [juvenile] court’s action, no judge
could reasonably have made the order that he[, she, or they] did.” ’ ” (Ibid.)
“Subdivision (a) of section 361.3 lists a panoply of criteria [that] the agency and
the court must consider when faced with a request for placement with a relative”
(In re Luke L. (1996) 44 Cal.App.4th 670, 680), including “[t]he best interest of the
child”; “[t]he wishes of the parent, relative, and child”; placement of siblings in the same
home “unless that placement is found to be contrary to the safety and well-being of any
of the siblings”; “[t]he good moral character of the relative and any other adult living in
the home”; the nature and duration of the child’s relationship with the relative; and the
relative’s desire and ability to provide legal permanency for the child if reunification is
unsuccessful. (§ 361.3, subd. (a)(1)-(8); see Luke L., at p. 680; Samantha T. v. Superior
Court (2011) 197 Cal.App.4th 94, 111.)

20
Here, the juvenile court held multiple placement/section 366.26 hearings over the
course of a year, after which the court considered the Department’s numerous reports and
heard testimony from several witnesses, including grandmother and the social workers
involved in this case. We reject the minor’s contentions that the juvenile court did not
consider the factors in section 361.3.
The juvenile court properly stated its reasons on the record for denying placement
of the minor with grandmother and the minor’s sibling. In particular, the juvenile court
acknowledged its duty to make an independent placement decision, and included in its
analysis of the best interest of the child, the wishes of the mother and father, the
compliance with Family Code section 7950,3 the presence of the minor’s brother in
grandmother’s home, good moral character, the relationship between the minor and
grandmother, and whether she could provide a safe, secure, and stable environment for
the minor and to provide the home and necessities of life.
In the end, the juvenile court put “the most weight on the best interest of the child,
the minimal relationship [with grandmother], and her lack of commitment to following
through with the process when she was initially given the opportunity.” In that regard,
the court noted visits between the minor and grandmother were very limited in number
and in time and were video visits only. The juvenile court found minor had bonded with
her potential adoptive parents due to the delay that was caused in large part by
grandmother’s failure to demonstrate she was serious about the resource family approval
process. The juvenile court also found the relationship between the minor and her sibling
was nonexistent, as both were very young and had spent no time together. The court

3 As the juvenile court noted, substantial evidence in the record established the
Department engaged in the resource family approval assessment process of grandmother
and that she hindered the completion of that process due to her lack of follow through.
Grandmother was given a fair chance to seek placement but failed to take the necessary
actions to make that a reality. (Cesar V. v. Superior Court, supra, 91 Cal.App.4th at
p. 1033.)

21
found the assessment process had been completed, albeit not to grandmother’s
satisfaction. “ ‘The overriding concern of dependency proceedings . . . is not the interest
of extended family members but the interest of the child,’ whose bond with a foster
parent may require that placement with a relative be rejected.” (In re J.Y. (2022)
76 Cal.App.5th 473, 486.) In other words, “[t]he linchpin of a section 361.3 analysis is
whether placement with a relative is in the best interests of the minor.” (Alicia B. v.
Superior Court (2004) 116 Cal.App.4th 856, 862-863.)
Here, the juvenile court determined placement with grandmother was not in the
best interest of the minor. Each of the court’s statements is supported by the numerous
reports and testimony in the record as recounted in detail in this opinion. Viewing the
evidence in the light most favorable to the juvenile court’s order and the juvenile court’s
careful recitation of the reasons for that order (In re Caden C. (2021) 11 Cal.5th 614,
640-641), substantial evidence established it was not in the minor’s best interest to be
placed with grandmother and the juvenile court did not abuse its discretion in making that
determination.

22
DISPOSITION
There having been no argument regarding the section 366.26 finding the minor is
adoptable and the parental rights were terminated, that portion of the order is affirmed.
All other orders of the juvenile court are affirmed.

/s/
ROBIE, J.

We concur:

/s/
EARL, P. J.

/s/
WISEMAN, J.*

* Retired Associate Justice of the Court of Appeal, Fifth Appellate District, assigned
by the Chief Justice pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution.

23

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.