In re I.Z. CA2/5

CourtListener 10676368CalctappSep 23, 2025

Full text

Filed 9/23/25 In re I.Z. CA2/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on
opinions not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule
8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or ordered published for
purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION FIVE

In re I.Z., a Person Coming Under the B339381
Juvenile Court Law.

LOS ANGELES COUNTY (Los Angeles County
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN Super. Ct. No.
AND FAMILY SERVICES, 24CCJP01080A)

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

A.Z.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Jean M. Nelson, Judge. Affirmed.
Jennifer Peabody and Keilana Truong, under appointment
by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Navid Nakhjavani, Principal
Deputy County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
The juvenile court assumed dependency jurisdiction over
(then) four-year-old I.Z. (Minor) after sustaining allegations that
Father was a daily abuser of marijuana, previously used and was
under the influence of marijuana while caring for Minor, exposed
Minor to firearms, and disobeyed law enforcement commands
while with Minor—thereby exposing him to potential and actual
violence. Father asks us to decide whether substantial evidence
supports the trial court’s jurisdiction finding.

I. BACKGROUND
This dependency case originated in early April 2024, after
the Los Angeles Department of Children and Family Services
(the Department) received a referral reporting Father had been
arrested on suspicion of raping a woman.1 The woman reported
she met Father at a taco stand, she smoked fentanyl and Father
used cocaine, and Father subsequently raped her in the front seat
of his car.
When law enforcement later located Father’s car outside
the home where he lived with Minor and Minor’s mother
(Mother), Father walked out of the residence, saw the police, and
ran back inside. Father thereafter refused to come outside as
directed by law enforcement. At some point, Father took Minor
to their neighbor’s home (unbeknownst to the officers on scene,
apparently) and then returned to the family home and refused to
exit for an additional period of time. During that time, Father

1
Before this, in September 2022, Father was arrested after a
road rage incident in which he pulled a firearm on someone in
another car while Minor was in the back seat. A court issued a
protective order protecting Minor from Father. The protective
order later expired after Father was released from custody.

2
ran to a shed at the rear of the property and appeared to hide
several items.
Eventually, Father did exit the home and was taken into
custody. Law enforcement found items belonging to the woman
who accused Father of rape, including drug paraphernalia and
her purse.
When interviewed by a social worker, Father denied
knowing the woman who accused him of rape, denied using drugs
with her, and denied having any sexual contact with her. Father
also initially denied having taken any of the woman’s belongings.
When informed that law enforcement had reported Father was in
possession of some of her belongings, Father said he took them
accidentally and threw them in the trash. When the social
worker stated law enforcement found the items in a shed, Father
denied this was true. Father admitted to using marijuana on a
daily basis, but he said he did so when he was alone—he claimed
he would typically smoke before beginning work for DoorDash at
around 5 p.m. Father also admitted to having a criminal history
and being on parole at the time of the interview.
When interviewed, Mother said she thought Father was
arrested for stealing someone’s bag. Mother admitted Father
smokes marijuana daily, and she admitted to being aware Father
may sometimes be impaired when he picks Minor up from
daycare. Mother denied that Father used any other drugs, and
said she no longer wants to be in a relationship with him.
The Department filed a three-count dependency petition
alleging Minor was at risk of serious physical harm because
Father was a current user of cocaine and daily abuser of
marijuana and previously cared for Minor while under the
influence of marijuana (count 1); Father placed Minor in a

3
detrimental situation by taking Minor to a neighbor’s home and
leaving him unattended for an unknown period of time (count 2);
and Mother created an endangering home environment by
allowing Father, who Mother knew had a history of assaultive
behavior and who Mother knew abused marijuana daily, to have
unlimited access to Minor (count 3).
At an initial hearing, Minor was detained from Father and
released to Mother’s care. Before the jurisdiction hearing on the
dependency petition, a social worker reinterviewed Father and
Mother and spoke to Minor and his maternal grandmother.
Father admitted using marijuana, but he asserted he never
used it around Minor. He claimed he would use the drug once a
week or less, and he said he only used the drug outside of the
home (at a park, for instance) and would come home only once
the smell and effects had worn off. When Father was able to find
work, he would smoke on his breaks and work until the effects
wore off. When he kept marijuana at home, he kept it in the
garage and put up a gate so Minor could not get to it. Father
denied ever using cocaine. When asked about his arrest, Father
said he took Minor to the neighbor’s home so Minor would not
witness him being arrested. Father maintained he did not carry
weapons anymore and said he regularly checked in with his
parole officer. Just prior to the jurisdiction hearing, Father also
said he had been released from custody and all charges related to
the alleged rape incident had been dropped.
Mother said the only drug Father uses is marijuana. She
claimed he kept the marijuana in a box in the garage, where
Minor cannot access it, and he never smokes the drug at home or
around Minor. Mother did not know why Father took Minor to a
neighbor’s home the night he was arrested, but she thought it

4
was most likely to prevent Minor from watching the arrest. She
reported Minor witnessed Father being arrested in 2022 and it
was traumatizing. Mother said she was the one who dropped
Minor off at school and picked him up, and she said Father used
her car to drive for DoorDash at night, so Minor did not have a lot
of time alone with him. When asked about the risk of harm to
Minor, as this was the second referral the family received as a
result of Father’s alleged criminal actions, Mother said she was
frustrated and disappointed; she had hoped Father’s
incarceration would have prompted him to change. Mother and
Minor had moved out of the family home and were living with
maternal grandmother.
Minor’s maternal grandmother similarly reported Father
smokes marijuana but does not do so in Minor’s presence. She
told the social worker she had no safety concerns with the family.
Minor was also interviewed, but the social worker
concluded he did not seem to be able to tell the difference
between a truth and a lie. Minor seemed preoccupied by Father’s
prior arrest. Among other things, he told the social worker he
was once in a car with his dad while his dad was driving really
fast, his dad took out a gun, the police came and arrested him,
the police also put Minor in handcuffs and took him to jail, and
Mother later came and took him home. Minor said this time
Father took him to another child’s house and asked her father to
watch Minor because the police were there to talk to him, and
then Father was arrested.
The court held a jurisdiction and disposition hearing in
July 2024. After hearing argument from the parties, it amended
the petition by interlineation and sustained count b-1. As
amended, the court found Father was a daily abuser of

5
marijuana; Minor was in Father’s care and supervision on prior
occasions when Father was under the influence of marijuana;
Father endangered Minor by exposing him to firearms and did
not follow law enforcement commands when confronted by the
police, further endangering Minor by exposing him to actual and
potential violence; Minor was of a young age and required
constant care and supervision; and Father’s substance abuse
interfered with the provision of that care and supervision. The
court dismissed counts b-2 and b-3, and struck all allegations
against Mother from the petition.
Explaining the reasons for its ruling, the juvenile court said
there were “several” issues pertaining to Father that, taken
together, showed “Father does not know how to be safe when
around his child.” The court identified Father’s daily use of
marijuana when he is about to run errands and driving while
under the influence of marijuana, which the court stated was not
safe and showed an inability to function without having a
substance in one’s system. The court also said it was concerned
Father had Minor present during two very dangerous situations.
First, Minor was in the vehicle with Father during the earlier
road rage incident in 2022. Second, Father essentially initiated a
stand-off with law enforcement by refusing to exit the home when
instructed to do so. Instead, Father apparently went to hide
evidence and relocate Minor, actions that law enforcement could
have interpreted as necessitating their intervention. The court
stated Father’s desire to avoid having Minor watch his arrest did
not excuse his behavior. Overall, the court was concerned with
Father’s judgment, pointing to his decisions to pull a firearm
during a road rage incident in front of Minor, to not comply with
law enforcement commands when Minor was present, to use

6
marijuana daily, and to run errands and care for Minor after
using marijuana.
The court removed Minor from Father’s care and released
Minor to Mother’s care. Father was ordered to participate in
weekly drug testing, conjoint counseling with Mother (if they
decided to reconcile), a fatherhood parenting class, and individual
counseling to address the cycle of violence and its harmful impact
on children.

II. DISCUSSION
Substantial evidence supports the trial court’s jurisdiction
finding. (See generally In re R.T. (2017) 3 Cal.5th 622, 633 [in
undertaking substantial evidence review, a reviewing court
draws “‘all reasonable inferences from the evidence to support the
findings . . . [and] review[s] the record in the light most favorable
to the court’s determinations . . . .’ [Citations]”].) As we go on to
detail, Father’s noncompliance with law enforcement orders on
the day of his arrest—and his movement with Minor to another
house while the officers were on scene—posed a substantial risk
of causing serious physical harm to Minor. Especially when
combined with Father’s daily marijuana use (sometimes before
driving) and the sufficient, albeit somewhat unspecific, evidence
that Father sometimes picked Minor up from daycare, there was
adequate evidence justifying the juvenile court’s jurisdiction
finding.
The juvenile court appropriately found Father put Minor at
risk of harm by initiating what was effectively a standoff with
police. When the police told Father to exit the home, he
disregarded the instruction and proceeded to move Minor to a
neighbor’s home and spend time hiding evidence of his

7
interaction with the woman who accused him of rape. Even if we
credit Father’s assertion that his concern at the time was
ensuring Minor did not witness his arrest (because Minor had
been traumatized by witnessing Father’s prior arrest), Father did
so in a manner that exposed Minor to the possibility of greater
and physical harm. The police could have easily interpreted
Father’s actions as cause to immediately apprehend him by force,
and that would have obviously placed Minor—who Father had
with him for at least part of the standoff period—in physical
danger.2
While this alone would have justified the juvenile court’s
jurisdictional intervention, the court was also appropriately
concerned with Father’s substance abuse. Dependency
jurisdiction for substance abuse exists under Welfare and
Institutions Code section 300 when there is excessive use of drugs
or alcohol and this renders “a parent or guardian unable to
provide regular care for a child and either cause[s] the child to
suffer serious physical harm or illness or place[s] the child at
substantial risk of suffering such harm or illness.” (In re N.R.
(2023) 15 Cal.5th 520, 531.) There was substantial evidence to

2
We reject Father’s effort to frame this as an aberrant
episode of endangering conduct. Father had previously risked
seriously harming Minor during the road rage incident when he
brandished a firearm with Minor in the car with him. While that
incident occurred in 2022, and the incident that led to the
initiation of dependency proceedings occurred in 2024, Father
was incarcerated for much of that time; the record indicates the
incident that led to dependency jurisdiction occurred
approximately four months after he resumed living with Mother
and Minor.

8
support the juvenile court’s finding Father was abusing
marijuana. Though statements made in the different interviews
were somewhat conflicting, the court was entitled to credit
Mother and Father’s earlier statements revealing Father smoked
marijuana daily. While the reports were consistent that he did so
away from the home, and did not leave any marijuana in places
Minor might access it, the reports were also consistent that
Father smoked marijuana prior to driving on a regular basis.
Daily marijuana use and driving under the influence on a regular
basis constitute drug abuse, not mere use.
In addition, in an early conversation with the Department,
Mother admitted she was aware Father might at times be
impaired when he picks Minor up from daycare. While, as
Father contends, there is no direct evidence of a specific incident
in which he drove Minor while under the influence, Mother’s
admission establishes Father sometimes picked Minor up from
daycare. That, coupled with the evidence that Father used
marijuana daily, and regularly used the drug before driving,
permitted the juvenile court to draw a reasonable inference that
Father drove with Minor in the car while Father was under the
influence.3 And that only amplifies the evidentiary basis
justifying the juvenile court’s conclusion that Minor was at

3
While there is contrary evidence in the record, such as
Mother’s assertion that she was the one who picked Minor up
after school, this at most created a conflict in the evidence. We
defer to the juvenile court’s resolution of such conflicts when
undertaking substantial evidence review. (In re I.J. (2013) 56
Cal.4th 766, 773; In re Tania S. (1992) 5 Cal.App.4th 728, 733-
734.)

9
substantial risk of suffering serious physical harm absent the
court’s intervention.4

4
Father contends this case is like In re L.C. (2019) 38
Cal.App.5th 646, where the Court of Appeal reversed a
jurisdiction finding based on drug abuse where the legal guardian
used methamphetamine six to seven times, stayed in a hotel
when he did so, and arranged for an adult the child knew to care
for her. (Id. at 650.) Unlike L.C., there was evidence here from
which the court could conclude Minor was under Father’s care
while Father was (driving) under the influence.
Father also argues there is no evidence he ignored his
parental responsibilities as a result of his marijuana use nor
evidence that Minor was actually harmed. Section 300, however,
does not limit juvenile court jurisdiction to situations where a
child actually suffers harm. (In re Christopher R. (2014) 225
Cal.App.4th 1210, 1216 [a “court need not wait until a child is
seriously abused or injured to assume jurisdiction and take steps
necessary to protect the child”]; see also In re I.J., supra, 56
Cal.4th at 773.)

10
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s order is affirmed.

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

BAKER, J.

We concur:

HOFFSTADT, P. J.

MOOR, J.

11

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.