CourtListener 10674434•People v. Topal CA4/3
Full text
Filed 9/19/25 P. v. Topal CA4/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION THREE
THE PEOPLE,
Plaintiff and Respondent, G063958
v. (Super. Ct. No. 20HF1040)
GARY TOPAL, OPINION
Defendant and Appellant.
Appeal from a judgment of the Superior Court of Orange County,
Larry Yellin, Judge. Affirmed.
Jared G. Coleman, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief Assistant
Attorney General, Charles C. Ragland, Assistant Attorney General,
Christopher P. Beesley and Caelle Oetting, Deputy Attorneys General, for
Plaintiff and Respondent.
* * *
Defendant Gary Topal made numerous angry phone calls for over
two years to the Orange County Sheriff’s Department (OCSD). In one call,
Topal told Captain Jared Dahl “that there had been several shootings
recently, and he would hate to see that happen again.” On May 28, 2020,
Topal called Dahl and told him, “‘I will f*cking kill you.’”
In July 2020, the People charged Topal with threatening a public
official (a felony), and making harassing and annoying communications (a
misdemeanor). A jury later found Topal guilty of the charged crimes. The
trial court granted Topal two years of formal probation.
Topal claims that the misdemeanor charge was barred by a one-
year statute of limitations. We disagree. The People commenced prosecution
by filing a complaint within the one-year limitations period.
Topal also argues the trial court erred by failing to instruct on a
lesser included offense (an attempted threat). We disagree. An attempted
threat can occur when the intended victim does not reasonably fear for their
safety. But at trial, there was undisputed evidence that the intended victim,
Captain Dahl, reasonably feared for his safety.
Topal also asks this court to review sealed records to determine if
the trial court erred in failing to disclose Captain Dahl’s personnel records.
We have done so, and we find no errors. Thus, we affirm the judgment.
I.
FACTS AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
In 2017, Topal was involved in an incident with the OCSD. Topal
owned some unlicensed trailers that were towed away from his home. At
some point during the encounter, Topal charged a sheriff’s deputy who
stopped Topal by displaying pepper spray. Topal was arrested for obstructing
2
a peace officer, but the district attorney’s office did not file charges. Topal
later filed a complaint with the OCSD, and began repeatedly calling
Lieutenant Chad Taylor, who was then in the internal affairs division. Topal
was upset about how the investigation of his complaint was being handled.
In October 2017, during a call with Lieutenant Taylor, Topal
said, “Listen, I don’t want to have a Vegas, I don’t want to have a Vegas
1
incident, man.” Topal later came to the OCSD headquarters in Santa Ana
and yelled obscenities at Taylor within the foyer of the building. Taylor
perceived Topal as an indirect threat, and referred the matter to a specialized
investigation unit. The OCSD issued a “‘be on the lookout’” (BOLO) officer
safety bulletin regarding Topal “to let the staff know to be careful.”
Starting in the beginning of January 2019, Topal repeatedly
called OCSD Captain Dahl, who had just begun working out of the sheriff’s
substation in Lake Forest. The station was in a leased portion of a
commercial building with an open parking lot. In his initial call, Topal told
Dahl about the 2017 incident involving the trailers. Topal said he had
problems with the prior captain (Dubsky) and the prior lieutenant
(Valentine). Dahl told Topal that he would investigate the matter.
Captain Dahl spoke to Lieutenant Valentine, who told him that
the matter with Topal’s trailers had already been taken care of. Valentine
said that he had several contacts with Topal, who “was an angry man.”
Valentine mentioned that Topal had sent “clown wigs” to him and Captain
Dubsky. Valentine noted that Dubsky began parking his vehicle in different
portions of the Lake Forest parking lot for security reasons. Dahl also spoke
1
During the trial, the court took “judicial notice of the fact that
on October 1st, 2017 there was a mass shooting in the City of Las Vegas at
the Route 91 Music Festival.”
3
to Lieutenant Taylor who told him about Topal’s earlier outburst in Santa
Ana. Dahl further spoke to other OCSD personnel who told him that Topal
“was irate and would just fly off the handle. And I was told to be careful.”
At the end of January 2019, Dahl told Topal by phone “that there
was nothing else that I could do. That [the matter regarding the trailers] had
been thoroughly investigated . . . .” Topal’s reaction was “very upset. Very
enraged.” Topal yelled and screamed at Dahl while using profane language.
On July 11, 2019, Topal came to the Lake Forest station, but
Dahl was not available.
The Charged Misdemeanor Conduct (July 12, 2019, to May 28, 2020)
On July 12, 2019, Captain Dahl spoke to Topal on the phone and
repeated that there was nothing else that he could do for him. Dahl later
testified that Topal “became extremely irate, yelled, screamed, called me
several names. [Topal] said that I wasn’t helping him out, said that Dubsky
hadn’t helped him out, and said that Valentine hadn't helped him out.” Dahl
said: “During the phone call, [Topal] made several statements that had
caused me some concern. One of them was to state that he was [an] angry
American, he had said that he was a terrorist in action. I tried to ask him,
what is a terrorist in action mean? He said he had friends that were
terrorists. He said that he had a violent past, or history.” Topal told Dahl
that “he wanted people to know that he was [being] threatening.”
After that phone call, Captain Dahl “was worried. I was worried
for the safety of our staff, I was worried for myself. I didn’t know what he was
capable of or who he was. I didn’t know much about him other than what I
had read, and what I had read and heard so far wasn’t good.”
On August 14, 2019, Topal again contacted Captain Dahl. Topal
4
“was extremely upset, extremely irate right off the bat on the phone call.”
Topal referred to the incident involving the trailers, and “[h]e was again
irate, rambling on. Not being clear in what he was looking for. But he threw
out a statement in there that there had been several shootings recently, and
he would hate to see that happen again.” Dahl stated “that I was very aware
of four shootings that had just occurred recently, . . . three of them actually
within the last couple of weeks in the United States.” Dahl asked Topal
“whether or not he felt he was going to shoot police officers, or -- or had the
intent to kill any of my staff.” Topal did not give Dahl a clear response.
A couple of hours later, Topal walked into the lobby of the Lake
Forest station. Dahl met Topal face-to-face for the first time and “he was
calm when he walked in.” Topal had a magazine in his hand, and he opened
it “up and said that he wanted me to read a couple of articles within that
magazine.” Both articles had to do with workplace safety, and one of them
specifically talked “‘about the importance of training employees to be
prepared for active shooting incidents.” Dahl told Topal that he interpreted
what he was doing as a threat; Topal denied making a threat, “but then he
couldn’t explain why he brought the article in.” Topal said he was familiar
with rifles, but he said that he did not own one.
After Topal left the station on August 14, 2019, Captain Dahl
described his reaction as: “Apprehensive. I was worried about my safety,
worried about my station, my employees’ safety. We don’t have a lockdown
parking facility, so our staff comes in and out of there on a regular basis in
their private cars and then they get into their patrol cars and drive. [¶] I
clearly had some extreme worries about that, enough to the point to where I
have a family and I went home and addressed it with my family. Told them to
be aware of the vehicles that [Topal] drove, be aware of him, and then what
5
actions they needed to take -- like, go inside, disengage, leave, run --
whatever if he came by or came around.”
Captain Dahl also took additional safety measures at the Lake
Forest station. Dahl had various safety items installed in the building
including bullet proof glass, lockers near the front of the building with bullet
proof vests and shotguns, and an emergency panic button. Dahl warned his
deputies, and pursued possible prosecution of Topal, but “I was under the
understanding by county counsel and some other people that [Topal] needed
to be direct in his threat to me, and not indirect, necessarily.”
After the August 14 incident, Topal stopped making routine
phone calls to the OCSD. In the first few months of 2020, Topal made a
couple of short calls, but none of them were threatening.
The Charged Felony Conduct (May 28, 2020)
On May 28, 2020, Topal again called Captain Dahl at the Lake
Forest Station. Topal was upset and said that Lieutenant Taylor had
admitted sending the FBI to his home. Dahl told him that he was not aware
of this. Topal then “got very, very upset. Started screaming and yelling. Said
that we didn’t do anything to help him. That we’ve been no assistance to him
whatsoever.”
Topal told Captain Dahl that he was happy that he had been
personally responsible for Lieutenant Valentine being fired (Valentine had
been promoted). Topal said “that he had always wished that he had beat the
sh*t out of [Valentine] . . . and still wishes he could beat the sh*t out of him.”
Dahl later said that Topal also told him that he “didn’t know what he was
capable of.” Topal then told Dahl: “‘I will f*cking kill you.’” After Dahl tried to
get Topal to repeat what he had just said, there was dead silence, and then
6
Topal hung up the phone.
After this phone call, Dahl immediately got a hold of a lieutenant
and an investigative sergeant who were in a nearby office. Dahl said, “I
contacted the investigator immediately. I felt that [Topal] shouldn’t be out on
the streets. I didn’t know what he was capable of or what was going on. So we
worked with the investigators and one of our investigative teams to go make
an arrest on the crime.”
Captain Dahl later testified that “the fact that [Topal] said he
was going to kill me, after everything else that had come along, caused me a
lot of concern.” Dahl testified that the threat upon his life “made me worried.
It made me worried for my safety, my family’s safety, and the employees that
are there. I don’t know what he is capable of, as he stated. I don’t know much
about him besides the little information he’s given me. I don’t know what his
motivations are.” Dahl had another BOLO created for the safety of his Lake
Forest staff, which he later briefed them on during meetings.
Captain Dahl again took protective measures with his family.
Dahl said, “I have three kids and I spent time sitting down with them. I
brought in a BOLO. I said, look at this person. Look at the vehicles. The
truck, the Camry. If you see him around the neighborhood, around the home -
- because this does happen; I’ve taken classes that are specific to this type of
personal officer safety -- then let us know what’s going on. [¶] Come in the
house, get away from him, tell me right away, call 911 -- whatever you need
to do. But don’t engage, don’t talk, and don’t stand there.”
Dahl was later asked at trial if he feared for his own safety at
that time. Dahl responded, “Absolutely.” Dahl then added, “I still worry about
him. I don’t know what he’s capable of or what he’s going to do or where he’s
going to show up.”
7
Court Proceedings
On July 1, 2020, the People filed a two-count complaint. Count
one alleged that on May 28, 2020, Topal committed a felony by threatening a
2
public official. (Pen. Code, § 76, subd. (a).) Count two alleged that between
July 12, 2019, and May 28, 2020, Topal committed a misdemeanor by making
harassing and annoying communications. (§ 653m (a).)
On December 11, 2020, Topal filed a motion for the discovery of
Captain Dahl’s personnel records. (See Pitchess v. Superior Court (1974) 11
Cal.3d 531 (Pitchess).) The trial court conducted an in-camera review of the
records, and then denied the Pitchess discovery motion.
On September 6, 2022, following a preliminary hearing, the
People filed an information alleging the same counts that had been alleged in
the earlier complaint.
On November 6, 2023, a five-day jury trial began. Topal testified
and admitted that he was aggravated with various members of the OCSD,
and that he had used foul language, but he said that he never intended to
threaten anyone with violence. Topal said the magazine article about
workplace shootings was not what he intended Captain Dahl to read. Topal
testified that as far as referencing the Las Vegas shooting incident, he “didn’t
mean anything with it.” Topal denied making the statement to Dahl: “‘I’m
going to f*cking kill you.’”
During closing arguments, Topal’s counsel argued that “the
hardest question in this case, I think you’ll agree with this, is trying to figure
out what’s going on inside of Gary Topal’s head. This whole case is about one
2
Further undesignated statutory references are to the Penal
Code. We shall also omit the word “subdivision” or its abbreviation.
8
thing. It’s about intent. What did he mean?”
The jury found Topal guilty of the charged crimes. The trial court
suspended the imposition of a sentence and granted Topal formal probation
for two years with various terms and conditions, which included 80 hours of
community service, and an anger management course.
II.
DISCUSSION
Topal claims: A) a statute of limitations violation; B) the trial
court erred by not instructing the jury on the lesser included offense of
attempting to threaten a public official; and C) this court should conduct an
independent review of a police officer’s personnel records.
A. Statute of Limitations
Topal claims that his misdemeanor conviction for making
annoying and harassing communications must be reversed because it was in
violation of the statute of limitations. We disagree because the misdemeanor
prosecution commenced within one year of the offense.
This is a pure question of law that we review de novo. (See People
v. Brown (2018) 23 Cal.App.5th 765, 772 [“‘application of the statute of
limitations on undisputed facts is a purely legal question’”].)
Ordinarily, a prosecution for a misdemeanor crime “shall be
commenced within one year after the commission of the offense.” (§ 802 (a).)
And generally, the “prosecution for an offense is commenced when any of the
following occurs: [¶] (a) An indictment or information is filed. [¶] (b) A
complaint is filed charging a misdemeanor or infraction. [¶] (c) The defendant
is arraigned on a complaint that charges the defendant with a felony. [¶] (d)
9
An arrest warrant or bench warrant is issued . . . .” (§ 804, italics added.)
When course-of-conduct offenses are alleged, “the limitations
period does not commence as to continuing offenses until the entire course of
conduct is complete.” (People v. Keehley (1987) 193 Cal.App.3d 1381, 1385.)
Here, the People alleged in a complaint that Topal had committed
the misdemeanor crime of making harassing and annoying communications
“between July 12, 2019, and May 28, 2020.” The one-year limitations period
for this course-of-conduct offense consequently began on May 28, 2020, and
expired on May 28, 2021. The People filed the complaint charging the
misdemeanor offense on July 1, 2020, which was well before the expiration of
the one-year limitations period; therefore, the People plainly commenced
prosecution prior to the expiration of the one-year limitations period.
Thus, we find no violation of the statute of limitations.
Topal argues: “The statute of limitations for this offense had
expired on May 28, 2021, more than one year before the information was filed
on September 6, 2022.” (Italics added.)
Topal’s argument is somewhat difficult to understand, but he
appears to be arguing that the People can only commence the prosecution of a
crime within the statute of limitations by filing an information (rather than a
complaint). Topal’s argument evidently overlooks section 804, which provides
that a prosecution can be commenced by either the filing of an information, or
by the filing a complaint charging a misdemeanor. (See § 804 (a) & (b).)
Again, the People filed a complaint charging a misdemeanor well
within the one-year limitations period. Therefore, we reject Topal’s claim that
there was a violation of the statute of limitations.
10
B. Instructional Error Claim
Topal claims the trial court erred by failing to instruct the jury on
its own motion on the lesser included offense of attempting to make a threat
against a public official. We disagree because we find that there is not
substantial evidence to support the lesser included instruction.
“‘On appeal, we review independently the question whether the
trial court failed to instruct on a lesser included offense.’” (People v. Avila
(2009) 46 Cal.4th 680, 704–705.)
A trial court has a sua sponte duty to give the jury “instructions
on lesser included offenses when the evidence raises a question as to whether
all of the elements of the charged offense were present.” (People v. Breverman
(1998) 19 Cal.4th 142, 154–155.) However, this requirement is limited: “the
existence of ‘any evidence, no matter how weak[,]’ will not justify instructions
on a lesser included offense. ” (Id. at p. 162.) A lesser included offense
instruction is warranted only if substantial evidence exists from which a
reasonable jury “could conclude ‘that the lesser offense, but not the greater,
was committed.’” (People v. Avila (2009) 46 Cal.4th 680, 704–705.)
“Every person who knowingly and willingly threatens the life of,
or threatens serious bodily harm to . . . the staff . . . or immediate family of
the staff of any elected public official . . . with the specific intent that the
statement is to be taken as a threat, and the apparent ability to carry out
that threat by any means, is guilty of a public offense . . . .” (§ 76 (a).) The
person threatened ordinarily must reasonably fear for his or her safety. (See
Ayala v. Superior Court (2021) 67 Cal.App.5th 296, 302–303.)
“An attempt to commit a crime consists of two elements: a
specific intent to commit the crime, and a direct but ineffectual act done
toward its commission.” (§ 21a.)
11
An attempted criminal threat is a lesser included offense of
making a criminal threat. (People v. Toledo (2001) 26 Cal.4th 221, 231.) In
Toledo, defendant and his wife got into an argument. (Id. at pp. 224–225.) At
one point, defendant told her, “‘You know, death is going to become you
tonight. I am going to kill you.’” (Id. at p. 225.) Defendant’s wife “responded
that she did not care, in a manner that indicated she had given up hope, and
walked away.” (Ibid.) Defendant was later convicted of several crimes,
including making an attempted criminal threat. Defendant argued on appeal
that there is no such crime. (Id. at p. 226.) The Supreme Court disagreed and
held that the offense of making an attempted criminal threat occurs when a
defendant acts with the requisite intent, but fortuity prevents the defendant
from completing the criminal threat. (Id. at p. 231) The Court explained that
in this case, defendant made a sufficient threat that was received and
understood by the threatened person (defendant’s wife), but the threatened
person was not actually in sustained fear for her safety. (Ibid.)
The facts in Toledo are markedly distinguishable from the facts
in the instant case. On May 28, 2020, Topal orally communicated to Captain
Dahl a specific threat of death: “‘I will f*cking kill you.’” Dahl later explicitly
testified that he was in immediate fear for his safety based on Topal’s threat
to kill him. Indeed, Dahl testified that he still had that same fear over two
years later at the time of the trial.
Thus, we hold that the trial court did not err by not instructing
the jury on its own motion on the lesser included crime of attempting to
threaten a public official. This is based primarily on Captain Dahl’s
undisputed testimony regarding his sustained fear, as well as the
corroborative actions he took in response to that fear (hardening the sheriff’s
station, discussing Topal’s threat with his family members, etc.). There is
12
simply no evidence to support the lesser included instruction.
Topal argues “there was evidence that reasonably supported the
conclusion that . . . Dahl’s fear was not actual or not objectively reasonable.”
We disagree. Given Topal’s repeated references to mass shootings, and the
article he gave to Captain Dahl regarding active shooters, we do not think
that any juror could rationally find that Dahl’s fear was not objectively
reasonable. Indeed, this argument was never raised at trial. (See People v.
Chandler (2014) 60 Cal.4th 508, 525–526 [holding that no reasonable juror
could find the defendant’s threats insufficient to cause a reasonable person to
be in sustained fear when “the defense theory at trial did not contest the
reasonableness of the victim’s fear”].)
In any event, even if we found instructional error, we would not
find the error to be prejudicial.
Generally, “error in failing sua sponte to instruct, or to instruct
fully, on all lesser included offenses and theories thereof which are supported
by the evidence must be reviewed for prejudice exclusively under [People v.]
Watson [(1956) 46 Cal.2d 818, 836].” (People v. Breverman, supra, 19 Cal.4th
at p. 178.) Under the Watson test for prejudice, “a defendant must show it is
reasonably probable a more favorable result would have been obtained absent
the error.’” (People v. Beltran (2013) 56 Cal.4th 935, 955.)
“[T]he Watson test for harmless error ‘focuses not on what a
reasonable jury could do, but what such a jury is likely to have done in the
absence of the error under consideration. In making that evaluation, an
appellate court may consider, among other things, whether the evidence
supporting the existing judgment is so relatively strong, and the evidence
supporting a different outcome is so comparatively weak, that there is no
reasonable probability the error of which the defendant complains affected
13
the result.’” (People v. Beltran, supra, 56 Cal.4th at p. 956.)
Here, there was overwhelmingly strong evidence that Captain
Dahl was in sustained fear, which was reasonably based on Topal’s direct
threat to kill Dahl on May 28, 2020, as well as Topal’s conduct in the
preceding two years. In sum, had the jury been instructed on the lesser
included offense of an attempted threat of a public official, we do not find that
“‘it is reasonably probable a more favorable result would have been obtained
absent the error.’” (People v. Beltran, supra, 56 Cal.4th at p. 955.)
C. Motion for the Discovery of Captain Dahl’s Personnel Records
A defendant may file a discovery motion seeking the confidential
personnel file of a peace officer. (See Pitchess, supra, 11 Cal.3d 531.) If a trial
court finds good cause, the court must then hold an in camera hearing to
review all potentially relevant documents. (Evid. Code, §1045 (b).) If the court
conducts an in camera review, but then denies the Pitchess motion for the
disclosure of the materials, a reviewing court may later independently review
the records. (People v. Mooc (2001) 26 Cal.4th 1216, 1232.)
A trial court has broad discretion in ruling on both the good cause
and disclosure components of a Pitchess motion, and its ruling will not be
disturbed on appeal absent an abuse of that discretion. (Alford v. Superior
Court (2003) 29 Cal.4th 1033, 1039.)
Here, a sealed transcript of the in camera hearing was made part
of the appellate record. After reviewing that transcript, we conclude that the
trial court did not abuse its discretion in refusing to disclose the contents of
Captain Dahl’s personnel file.
14
III.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.
MOORE, ACTING P. J.
WE CONCUR:
SANCHEZ, J.
BANCROFT, J.*
*Judge of the Orange County Superior Court, assigned by the Chief Justice
pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution.
15
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.