CourtListener 10666929•Olivas v. Amerit Fleet Solutions CA4/3
Full text
Filed 9/5/25 Olivas v. Amerit Fleet Solutions CA4/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION THREE
FRANCISCO OLIVAS,
Plaintiff and Appellant, G064590
v. (Super. Ct. No. 30-2022-
01276928)
AMERIT FLEET SOLUTIONS,
INC., OPINION
Defendant and Respondent.
Appeal from a judgment of the Superior Court of Orange County,
Sandy N. Leal, Judge. Affirmed.
Wellman & Warren, Scott Wellman and Michael Bazyler for
Plaintiff and Appellant.
Perkins Coie, Jacob Dean and Heather M. Sager for Defendant
and Respondent.
1
Francisco Olivas sued his former employer, Amerit Fleet
Solutions, Inc., for discrimination, retaliation, and related claims. Amerit
successfully moved for summary judgment.
We affirm. We find no abuse of discretion in the trial court’s
evidentiary rulings excluding certain evidence submitted by Olivas. And after
independently reviewing the record, we conclude that Amerit demonstrated it
had legitimate, nondiscriminatory, nonretaliatory reasons for putting Olivas
on a leave of absence and for later terminating his employment. Further,
Olivas did not raise a triable issue concerning pretext.
FACTS
Amerit provides vehicle fleet maintenance and repair services for
clients like AT&T and Amazon. In 2010, Olivas began working for Amerit as
a fleet manager, where he supervised repair work on over 1,200 AT&T
vehicles at garages throughout Southern California.
Amerit conducted company-wide layoffs in 2016, and several of
Olivas’s mechanics—including his son Jafet Olivas1—were let go as a result.
Upset about his son’s termination, Olivas sent an e-mail to management
complaining that he (Olivas) was “not valued” and had “no support at any
level,” and that this made him feel “discriminated against” and like he
received “disparate treatment.”
In a subsequent meeting with Amerit’s vice president of strategic
operations, Olivas (then in his mid 60’s) explained he was being treated
differently because he is “‘old and Latino.’” He was told the layoffs were
1 Because Jafet shares his father’s last name, we refer to him by
his first name. We mean no disrespect.
2
necessary to save money. After that meeting, he did not hear anything
further from human resources in response to his complaint.
According to Olivas, in the years that followed, he felt his
colleagues excluded him from meetings and dinners, did not seek his input,
gave him fewer resources and support than other fleet managers, and mocked
his accent.
In November 2020, AT&T’s asset protection group received a
complaint that Olivas was diverting repairs that should have been performed
by Amerit “‘in-house’” to a repair shop owned by Olivas’s family member.
AT&T asked Amerit to immediately remove Olivas from the AT&T account
pending its investigation of the potential conflict of interest. Amerit did so
and placed Olivas on a paid administrative leave.
During its investigation, AT&T learned that between 2016 and
2020, Olivas had sent over $485,000 in repair work on AT&T vehicles to a
company called Golden State Fleet Solutions, which Olivas’s son Jafet owned
and operated out of Olivas’s house. After completing its investigation in
January 2021, AT&T asked Amerit to permanently remove Olivas from
AT&T’s account based on the investigation’s findings.
Meanwhile, Amerit’s human resources personnel conducted their
own investigation, independent of AT&T’s. When interviewed, Olivas
admitted that his son Jafet operated a fleet management business out of
Olivas’s home, that Olivas had sent AT&T work to Jafet’s company, and that
Olivas had never notified Amerit in writing about Jafet’s involvement with
the company. After further investigation, Amerit determined Olivas had sent
nearly $500,000 in work to Jafet’s company without disclosing that
3
relationship, and in doing so had violated the conflict of interest policy in
Amerit’s employee handbook.2
In January 2021, while Olivas was still on a paid leave of
absence, Amerit’s human resources representative called him to discuss the
possibility of having him return to manage fleet services for a different
Amerit client, Amazon. Olivas said he might be interested but ultimately
wanted to return to the AT&T account.
According to human resources, they called Olivas in early March
to offer him the Amazon position.3 The following week, Olivas did two
interviews for the Amazon account. However, he told both interviewers he
would prefer to return to his AT&T role. These comments made the
interviewers question whether Olivas was the right fit for the position.4
2 Although Amerit rolled out several updated versions of its
employee handbook during Olivas’s employment, at all times its conflict of
interest policy provided that “[e]mployees are expected to avoid situations
that create an actual or potential conflict [of interest] between the employee’s
personal interests and [Amerit’s] interests.” Olivas admits receiving the
handbook but denies violating the conflict of interest policy.
3 Olivas maintains he never received an actual offer on the
Amazon account.
4 For example, after interviewing Olivas on March 8, one
interviewer noted in a post-interview e-mail to human resources that he
wanted to “pass on” Olivas, whom he described as eager to return to AT&T,
“disgruntled and reluctant to be interviewing,” and lacking “the passion I
would expect from a candidate.” The other interviewer similarly noted on
March 9 that Olivas was not a “long ter[m] solution” for the role because he
repeatedly referenced “wanting to go back to his AT[&]T position,” which did
not “encourage[ the manager] to invest the time and energy into training”
him on Amazon. Even so, Amerit’s human resources representative insists
Amerit planned to honor the Amazon offer.
4
On March 10, just days after the interviews, Olivas’s attorney
sent a letter to Amerit advising that “Olivas recently informed me that
[Amerit has] offered him reinstatement in a position different from what he
has worked at for multiple decades and for which he is not properly trained.”
Counsel went on to demand that “Olivas be immediately reinstated to his
previous position” and asserted that if Amerit failed to do so, Olivas would
have no choice but to proceed with “asserting his rights and remedies.”
Amerit understood this letter to be a rejection of any Amazon
offer and inferred Olivas was no longer interested in exploring other
opportunities with Amerit. Since AT&T had asked that Olivas be
permanently removed from its account, and since returning him to the AT&T
account was not an option, Amerit continued Olivas’s paid leave of absence.
After that exchange, Olivas had no further direct
communications with Amerit. According to Olivas, this was because he had
been instructed not to contact any Amerit employees.
In September 2021, Olivas (through counsel) filed an
administrative complaint with the Department of Fair Employment and
Housing, which provided him a right-to-sue letter. The complaint, which was
served on Amerit, alleged that Amerit and AT&T had discriminated and
retaliated against Olivas because of his race and age, among other reasons.
On January 27, 2022, Amerit’s human resources representative
called Olivas twice, but he did not answer. Olivas was terminated the
following day due to his “lack of communication.”
Olivas sued both Amerit and AT&T. In his operative first
amended complaint, he asserted causes of action for age and race
discrimination, failure to prevent discrimination, retaliation, and wrongful
termination in violation of public policy.
5
Amerit moved for summary judgment, asserting Olivas’s claims
were time-barred, he could not prove a prima facie case, and he was
terminated for legitimate, nondiscriminatory, nonretaliatory reasons. Olivas
opposed the motion and submitted declarations from himself, his son Jafet,
and three other Amerit employees in support. In its reply, Amerit lodged 35
objections to segments of those declarations, asserting grounds including lack
of personal knowledge or foundation.
The trial court granted summary judgment for Amerit. It began
by sustaining (at least in part) 29 of Amerit’s 35 evidentiary objections,
though it did not specify on what grounds. It then found that a question of
fact existed as to whether the matter involved a continuing violation, and
thus rejected Amerit’s argument that Olivas’s claims are time-barred. On the
merits, the court concluded Amerit showed a legitimate, nondiscriminatory,
nonretaliatory reason for Olivas’s termination—his lack of communication—
and found Olivas failed to demonstrate pretext. The court then entered
judgment for Amerit.
DISCUSSION
I.
THE TRIAL COURT DID NOT ABUSE ITS DISCRETION BY
EXCLUDING SEGMENTS OF OLIVAS’S SUPPORTING DECLARATIONS
We begin with the evidentiary rulings, which we review for abuse
of discretion. (Doe v. Software One, Inc. (2022) 85 Cal.App.5th 98, 104.) We
have reviewed the challenged declarations of Olivas, Jafet, and three other
Amerit employees and discern no abuse of discretion in the trial court’s
evidentiary rulings.
To provide an illustrative example, many of Amerit’s objections
concerned statements by the declarants that “everyone” at the garage or “[a]ll
6
of the workers,” drivers, or fleet managers at Amerit knew that Jafet was
Olivas’s son. Those statements lack foundation, and the declarations do not
establish how the declarants would have personal knowledge about what
dozens of other employees might know.
The same can be said of the statements by both Olivas and his
colleague Miguel Ramirez regarding the relative qualifications of various
Amerit employees who were or were not promoted, as well as statements
about purported statistics on the race of Amerit fleet managers. Similarly,
statements like Olivas’s averment that “The pretextual nature of this is
clear” could be properly excluded as argumentative. Excluding those and the
other challenged statements did not exceed the bounds of reason. (See
Denham v. Superior Court (1970) 2 Cal.3d 557, 566.)
II.
SUMMARY JUDGMENT WAS APPROPRIATE
That brings us to the merits of Amerit’s motion. “‘On review of an
order granting or denying summary judgment, we examine the facts
presented to the trial court and determine their effect as a matter of law.’
[Citation.] We review the entire record, ‘considering all the evidence set forth
in the moving and opposition papers except that to which objections have
been made and sustained.’ . . . [¶] Summary judgment is appropriate only
‘where no triable issue of material fact exists and the moving party is entitled
to judgment as a matter of law.’” (Regents of University of California v.
Superior Court (2018) 4 Cal.5th 607, 618; see Code Civ. Proc., § 437c, subd.
(c).)
When a defendant employer moves for summary judgment on the
grounds that it had nondiscriminatory reasons for terminating an employee,
“‘“the employer satisfies its burden as moving party if it presents evidence of
7
such nondiscriminatory reasons that would permit a trier of fact to find, more
likely than not, that they were the basis for the termination. [Citations.] To
defeat the motion, the employee then must adduce or point to evidence
raising a triable issue, that would permit a trier of fact to find by a
preponderance that intentional discrimination [or retaliation] occurred.’””
(Wilkin v. Community Hospital of Monterey Peninsula (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th
806, 822 (Wilkin).)
Olivas spends much of his briefing attacking the reasoning
behind the trial court’s ruling. For example, he asserts the court focused on
facts unrelated to lack of communication when evaluating whether Amerit
established a legitimate nondiscriminatory reason for the termination, and it
failed to discuss the evidence Olivas presented on pretext, such as the fact
that Olivas could have been reached through his attorney. He further
contends that the conflict of interest violation and the Amazon offer are “red
herring[s]” because the stated reason for his termination was lack of
communication, not the conflict of interest or rejection of the Amazon
alternative. But we review only the ruling of the trial court, not its rationale,
and we affirm summary judgment on any correct ground if the parties had an
adequate opportunity to address it below. (Nicoletti v. Kest (2023) 97
Cal.App.5th 140, 144.)
Having considered the record de novo, we conclude Amerit
satisfied its burden of showing it had legitimate, nondiscriminatory,
nonretaliatory reasons for the adverse employment actions taken against
Olivas. Amerit established Olivas was placed on a paid leave of absence
because Amerit believed he sent his son’s company nearly $500,000 worth of
work that should have been performed by Amerit in-house in violation of
8
Amerit’s conflict of interest policy.5 After AT&T asked Amerit to permanently
remove Olivas from its account, Amerit kept Olivas on that paid leave of
absence because Olivas (through counsel) rejected any alternative position by
insisting he be returned to the AT&T account. And after receiving no
indication over the following 10 months that Olivas would be willing to
return to Amerit in any capacity other than working for AT&T, Amerit
terminated Olivas for lack of communication.
Since Amerit satisfied its initial burden of showing legitimate,
nondiscriminatory, nonretaliatory reasons for Olivas’s leave and termination,
the burden shifted to Olivas to raise a triable issue that intentional
discrimination or retaliation occurred. (Wilkin, supra, 71 Cal.App.5th at p.
823.)
“Proof of discriminatory intent often depends on inferences rather
than direct evidence,” and as a result, “‘very little evidence of such intent is
necessary to defeat summary judgment.’” (Nazir v. United Airlines, Inc.
(2009) 178 Cal.App.4th 243, 283.) Even so, the employee’s evidence remains
subject to careful scrutiny, must relate to the motivation of the decision
makers, and must show an actual causal link between the prohibited
motivation and the adverse employment action. (Foroudi v. Aerospace Corp.
(2020) 57 Cal.App.5th 992, 1007–1008 (Foroudi).) “[T]he ‘stronger the
5 It is immaterial whether the work actually should have been
performed in-house or whether Olivas actually violated Amerit’s conflict of
interest policy. “‘It is the employer’s honest belief in the stated reasons for
firing an employee and not the objective truth or falsity of the underlying
facts that is at issue in a discrimination case.’” (Wills v. Superior Court (2011)
195 Cal.App.4th 143, 170; see Guz v. Bechtel National, Inc. (2000) 24 Cal.4th
317, 358 [“if nondiscriminatory, [the employer’s] true reasons need not
necessarily have been wise or correct”].)
9
employer’s showing of a legitimate, nondiscriminatory reason, the stronger
the plaintiff’s evidence must be in order to create a reasonable inference of a
discriminatory motive.’” (Id. at p. 1008.)
In the face of Amerit’s showing of a legitimate reason for the
termination, Olivas “could avoid summary judgment only by offering
‘substantial evidence’ that [the employer’s] reasons were untrue or
pretextual, or that it acted with a discriminatory animus, or both, ‘such that
a reasonable trier of fact could conclude the employer engaged in intentional
discrimination.’” (See Foroudi, supra, 57 Cal.App.5th at p. 1008.)
Olivas did not carry that burden. He presented evidence that he
was mocked at Amerit for having an accent, given fewer resources, and
excluded from meetings and dinners. But he drew no connection between the
colleagues who treated him that way and the individuals who approved his
leave of absence and termination.
In an attempt to show Amerit’s reason for terminating him was
fabricated, Olivas pointed to evidence that he was told not to contact anyone
at Amerit during his leave, that Amerit could have contacted him through his
attorney but did not, and that Amerit never had any issues contacting him
before his leave. All valid points, but we do not view those facts in a vacuum.
Both Olivas and his attorney repeatedly told Amerit in the first quarter of
2021 that Olivas only wanted to return to work if it was on the AT&T
account, and their 10 months of silence after that did nothing to dispel that
notion. Olivas’s evidence is thus insufficient to create a triable issue as to
whether Amerit’s stated reason for his termination—lack of communication—
was fabricated.
Olivas insists the real reason for his January 2022 termination
was his September 2021 administrative complaint with the DFEH. Again, we
10
are not persuaded. The exhaustion of a claimant’s administrative remedies
(something that happens in every employment case), without more, is not
enough to show pretext. (Accord, Loggins v. Kaiser Permanente Internat.
(2007) 151 Cal.App.4th 1102, 1112 [fact that adverse employment action
occurred closely after employee complained to corporate compliance hotline
was insufficient to create triable issue of fact whether employer’s articulated
reason was pretextual].)
Olivas alternatively contends summary judgment was improper
because the trial court found a triable issue existed concerning the statute of
limitations. At oral argument Olivas’s counsel quoted the court’s finding that
Olivas “presented sufficient evidence to create a triable issue of fact that
Amerit’s failure to address his complaints in 2016, and the alleged
subsequent retaliatory acts[,] were part of a continuing violation.” He then
asserted it was inconsistent for the court to make that finding while
simultaneously concluding Olivas had not carried his burden on pretext.
We read the order differently. The court found a triable issue of
fact in connection with the statute of limitations—specifically, as to whether
“Amerit’s failure to address [Olivas’s] complaints in 2016, and the alleged
subsequent retaliatory acts[,] were part of a continuing violation” “for
purposes of extending the limitations period.” (Italics added.) The court did
not find Amerit actually retaliated against Olivas, as Olivas suggests, nor did
it find a triable issue existed as to the substantive merits of Olivas’s claims.
Whether a triable issue exists as to the accrual date is irrelevant to whether
11
Olivas carried his burden to show pretext. Summary judgment was therefore
appropriate.6
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed. Amerit shall recover its costs on
appeal. (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.278(a)(1).)
SCOTT, J.
WE CONCUR:
MOTOIKE, ACTING P. J.
SANCHEZ, J.
6 Olivas does not meaningfully address his claims for failure to
prevent discrimination or wrongful termination. We therefore consider any
arguments unique to those claims forfeited.
12
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.