CourtListener 10663303•People v. Hernandez CA2/3
Full text
Filed 8/29/25 P. v. Hernandez CA2/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION THREE
THE PEOPLE, B337345
Plaintiff and Respondent, Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. XSCTA159260
v.
TOMAS MICHAEL
HERNANDEZ,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County, Teresa P. Magno, Judge. Affirmed.
Richard B. Lennon and Jennifer Peabody, under
appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant and
Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief
Assistant Attorney General, Susan Sullivan Pithey, Assistant
Attorney General, Wyatt E. Bloomfield and Chelsea Zaragoza,
Deputy Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
_________________________
Tomas Michael Hernandez appeals from the trial court’s
execution of a suspended prison sentence after the court found
him in violation of his probation. We find no abuse of discretion
and therefore affirm.
FACTS AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND1
1. Hernandez enters the victim’s home late at night
On January 4, 2023, at about 11:05 p.m., Jackie V.
was sitting at her dining room table when she saw a man
later identified as Hernandez looking through the glass in her
unlocked door. Hernandez opened the door and came into the
victim’s home. She pushed him out and locked the door. The
victim told her husband what had happened. He went outside
and found Hernandez sitting on a chair in front of the garage.
Sheriff’s deputies arrived. After being advised of his rights,
Hernandez told the deputies he’d gone into the home to “ ‘come
up.’ ” According to the probation report, that phrase “commonly”
refers to “stealing.”
The victim told a probation officer she’d been frightened
and she injured her hand when she pushed Hernandez out
the door.
2. The charges and grant of mental health diversion
The People charged Hernandez with first degree residential
burglary, person present. The People alleged Hernandez had a
prior strike, also for first degree residential burglary. The People
alleged five aggravating factors under rule 4.421 of the California
1 A preliminary hearing apparently was conducted in
this case on January 25, 2023. No reporter’s transcript or
minute order of the hearing is included in the record on appeal.
We therefore take the facts from the probation report, as does
Hernandez in his opening brief.
2
Rules of Court, including that Hernandez engaged in violent
conduct that indicated a serious danger to society, that he had
served a prior term in prison or jail, and that, at the time of
the offense, he was on probation or parole.
On July 10, 2023, Hernandez’s counsel filed a motion
for pretrial mental health diversion under Penal Code sections
1001.35 and 1001.36.2 Hernandez attached a psychological
evaluation by Dr. Ann L. Walker. Dr. Walker diagnosed
Hernandez with bipolar disorder as well as severe opioid,
stimulant (amphetamine), alcohol, and cannabis use disorders.
Dr. Walker stated Hernandez had told her he’d used
heroin, methamphetamine, and cannabis, and drunk alcohol,
on the day of the offense. Hernandez “reported that he was out
of his mind” when he committed the crime. He “thought that he
was at his aunt’s house.” In Dr. Walker’s opinion, Hernandez
was “appropriate for a dual diagnosis treatment program.”
Hernandez also attached to his motion for diversion a
letter from Next Level Up Recovery that he had been accepted
into its residential drug and alcohol program.
The parties appeared before the court (Judge Tammy
Chung Ryu) on July 24, 2023. The prosecution did not oppose
Hernandez’s motion or object to mental health diversion. The
court found Hernandez both eligible and suitable for mental
health diversion and therefore granted his motion. The court
ordered Hernandez conditionally released to the program.
The court ordered Hernandez to follow all of the program’s
rules, to take his prescribed medication, and not to leave the
program without prior approval. The court noted Hernandez
2 References to statutes are to the Penal Code.
3
also would receive “mental health service[s] and treatment
through Kedren.” The court ordered Hernandez to stay away
from the victim, to make restitution to the victim, and not to
possess any burglary tools. Hernandez confirmed he understood
all the conditions of the diversion and promised to comply
with them. The court set the date of September 26, 2023 for
confirmation that Hernandez had been transported to the
program.
Just over two weeks later, on August 9, 2023, counsel
appeared before the court (Judge Hector E. Gutierrez).
Hernandez also was present in custody. The prosecutor had
given defense counsel two “arrest reports.”3 The prosecutor
told the court, “[Hernandez] has already walked away from [the
live-in drug treatment program] and been arrested two times.”
The prosecutor said Hernandez’s parole officer had called her
and reported Hernandez had been arrested on August 2 and
again on August 5. She continued, “[H]e’s also on other people’s
property during both of these arrests. One is an observation
arrest by law enforcement and one is where a civilian has
to call the police because he’s on their property.”
Defense counsel told the court “[t]he primary reason”
Hernandez left the program “was to see his family, his
grandmother, his mother, his siblings.” Counsel continued,
“He had not seen them in person for two years . . . . He made
an emotional decision and left the program to see them. They
did not let him stay with them, and it was at that point that
he relapsed.”
3 The arrest reports are not included in the record on appeal.
4
The court stated it had read the arrest reports. The court
noted, “[T]he first details an incident on Wednesday, August 2nd
. . . at approximately 4:30 in the morning where a sheriff’s deputy
on patrol observed the defendant in the front yard of a residence,
ducking behind some bushes. . . . The defendant admitted he
was on parole for burglary and that he did not live in the area.”
Hernandez had methamphetamine on his “person.” Of “more
concern” to the court was a second incident three days later:
“[A]t approximately 11:30 in the evening . . .
the sheriff’s department responded to a call
of a prowler. A citizen informed the sheriff’s
department that a male adult was standing on
his porch with a bottle of beer. . . . [S]heriff’s
department personnel responded to the
location, contacted defendant Hernandez,
and he appeared to be under the influence.
Narcotic paraphernalia was recovered from
his person, and the citizen informed sheriff’s
deputies that he saw the defendant walking
onto the driveway and looking through the
windows of his parked cars. The defendant
then sat on his front porch. When the citizen
opened the door to the porch, the defendant
said that he was looking for his friends.”
Based on these arrests, the court terminated mental
health diversion, reinstated criminal proceedings, and scheduled
a pretrial conference.
5
3. Hernandez pleads to the charge and agrees to
complete a residential program
On October 3, 2023, both sides announced ready and
the case was assigned to Judge Teresa P. Magno for trial.
The prosecution offered to strike Hernandez’s strike and to
ask the court to sentence him to the midterm of four years in
the state prison. The court then gave Hernandez an indicated
sentence of the upper term of six years, execution suspended,
with probation and a six-month residential program. The
prosecutor objected. Hernandez told the court he wanted
the suspended prison time and the program.
Hernandez then waived his rights and pleaded no contest
to the charge. He admitted the person-present allegation, his
strike prior, and three of the aggravating circumstances.4
Defense counsel located a residential program for
Hernandez at the Tarzana Treatment Center. On November 21,
2023, the court sentenced Hernandez to the upper term of six
years, suspended execution of that sentence, placed Hernandez
on formal probation for two years, and ordered him “to serve two
to three months in a residential dual-diagnosis program through
Tarzana.” The court also ordered Hernandez to complete any
outpatient program that Tarzana designated and to report to
probation. The court ordered Hernandez conditionally released
to Tarzana to be transported to the program. Hernandez
confirmed he understood and accepted all of the terms and
conditions of his probation.
4 The prosecutor struck the other two aggravating
circumstances.
6
The court cautioned Hernandez:
“So I’m giving you the program ‘cause you’ve
requested a program and, hopefully, you were
sincere in wanting to go through a program
instead of just saying the stuff to get you out
of custody. It’s up to you. . . . [¶] But in terms
of the program, you’re ordered to remain
in the program, abide by all their rules and
regulations, to not leave the program unless
you have my permission or the program’s
permission. If, however, in your mind you
believe you have a valid excuse for leaving,
you’re ordered to show up to my court the
first business day—okay?—and tell me what’s
going on. If you do that, I promise to keep an
open mind and listen. Okay? [¶] But if you
leave the program . . . and I do not hear from
you, you’re leaving me with one impression,
and that is you would rather just spend
six years in state prison.”
Hernandez said he understood and agreed.
4. Hernandez’s court-ordered treatment program
discharges him within days
Hernandez was admitted to the Tarzana Treatment Center
on December 1, 2023. Four days later, on December 5, 2023,
the program expelled him for violating its rules. A psychologist’s
note states, “Over the past week I have received numerous
reports from staff about patient non[-]compliant behavior.”
Hernandez had been “caught writing love letters” to another
patient after he had been told not to communicate with her and
7
he’d signed an acknowledgement of that instruction. Hernandez
then was “caught in a group” that patient attended; it was not
Hernandez’s assigned group. Even though staff “redirected” him,
he “attempted to attend another group she was in later that day.”
The next day staff saw Hernandez “carrying on a long
conversation with the same female.”
Hernandez also tried to “manipulate” staff members into
giving him more pain relievers. When the program discharged
Hernandez, it instructed him to report to his probation officer
“for placement or remand to custody.”
5. The probation violation hearing and execution
of sentence
On December 11, 2023, Hernandez’s counsel told the court
he’d been “kicked out of the Tarzana program.” The court issued
a no-bail bench warrant. Hernandez apparently was arrested
on the warrant.5 Hernandez appeared in court in custody on
December 19. A supplemental probation report dated January 2,
2024 stated Hernandez never reported to probation. His parole
agent stated that “[u]nder the supervision of parole, [his] conduct
ha[d] been poor and he absconded from parole after leaving
[Tarzana Treatment Center].”
On March 27, 2024, the court conducted a formal probation
hearing. Stan Galperson, a director at the Tarzana Treatment
Center, testified he discharged Hernandez because “he was
5 The supplemental probation report reflects a December 8
detention or arrest for “disorderly conduct: intoxicated drug/
alcohol” in violation of section 647, subdivision (f), as well as
a December 18 warrant for a parole violation.
8
manipulating staff to get extra medication on a couple of
occasions.” Galperson explained,
“He went to the nurse’s station to ask for pain
relievers. He had already taken it that day.
He was told he’d have to come back after
eight hours. He wasn’t satisfied with that.
[¶] He went to the other nurse’s station and
did the same thing. There, he was told ‘no.’
[¶] Then he went to a third staff member . . .
a technician, and asked them again. [¶] We
call that ‘splitting staff’ and it’s manipulation.
We have a low tolerance for that.”
Another “really concerning piece,” Galperson said, was
Hernandez’s communications with “a female patient.” Tarzana
Treatment “prohibit[s] relationships in the program.” Hernandez
continued to violate that prohibition “even after he signed [a]
document” agreeing to follow the rule. Hernandez was warned
again. His misconduct continued. He was warned a second time.
On the day the program discharged Hernandez, he “was
found in the cafeteria, sitting at the same table and carrying on
a conversation with the female.” He was brought to Galperson’s
office. Galperson “confronted” him. Hernandez “made like he
didn’t know what [Galperson] was talking about.”
After the prosecutor laid the necessary foundation, the
court admitted into evidence as a business record6 a 17-page
packet of documents from Tarzana Treatment Center.
Defense counsel told the court he did not plan to call any
witnesses “with respect to the violation,” but he did want to call
6 See Evid. Code, § 1271.
9
a family member “for a mitigation statement for sentencing.”
Zulema Maldonado, Hernandez’s aunt, then testified. Maldonado
said both of Hernandez’s parents were addicted to drugs and
alcohol, and his mother was “using” during her pregnancy.
Maldonado testified that, when Tarzana Treatment discharged
Hernandez, she tried to help him get back into that program
or another program but the program didn’t respond.
The court found Hernandez in violation of the terms of his
probation. Defense counsel asked the court to give Hernandez
“another chance.” The prosecutor argued Tarzana Treatment
had given Hernandez “multiple chances” and he “did not comply.”
The court told Hernandez it was “saddened” to execute his
sentence, but the court had given him a chance—over the
People’s objection—and Hernandez “couldn’t even follow
the simple rule of staying away from another attendee in
the program.” The court then executed the six-year sentence
and awarded Hernandez his credits.
DISCUSSION
1. Governing law and standard of review
The prosecution must prove the facts supporting
a probation revocation by a preponderance of the evidence.
(People v. Gray (2023) 15 Cal.5th 152, 163; People v. Rodriguez
(1990) 51 Cal.3d 437, 447.) After finding a defendant has
violated probation, a trial court has discretion either to reinstate
probation on the same or modified terms or to terminate
probation and commit the defendant to prison “if the interests
of justice so require.” (§ 1203.2, subd. (b); People v. Bolian
(2014) 231 Cal.App.4th 1415, 1420; People v. Medina (2001)
89 Cal.App.4th 318, 321.) The court has “very broad discretion
10
in determining whether a probationer has violated probation.”
(Rodriguez, at p. 443.)
We review the trial court’s order for abuse of discretion
and its factual findings for substantial evidence. (People v.
Butcher (2016) 247 Cal.App.4th 310, 318; People v. Superior
Court (Jones) (1998) 18 Cal.4th 667, 681.) “The standard
is deferential: ‘When a trial court’s factual determination is
attacked on the ground that there is no substantial evidence
to sustain it, the power of an appellate court begins and ends
with the determination as to whether, on the entire record,
there is substantial evidence, contradicted or uncontradicted,
which will support the determination. . . .’ ” (Jones, at p. 681.)
In applying this test, we review the evidence in the light most
favorable to the court’s ruling and presume in support of the
post-judgment order the existence of every fact the court could
reasonably deduce from the evidence. (People v. Kraft (2000)
23 Cal.4th 978, 1053.)
2. Analysis
Hernandez acknowledges “[t]he decision not to reinstate
probation lies in the sound discretion of the court.” But he
contends the trial court abused its discretion because his
“criminality stems in large part [from his] addiction.” Hernandez
notes that “drug addiction is a very difficult problem to address
and that addicts have lots of setbacks.”
Hernandez says he “was terminated from the program here
because of two pretty minor rule violations.” We do not agree
with Hernandez’s characterization of his behavior. According
to the sworn testimony at the probation violation hearing,
Hernandez made repeated efforts to get more pain medication
than he was allowed by going to two different nurses and then
11
a third Tarzana Treatment employee. Plainly, lying to or
manipulating staff members to get more drugs, by a person
in a drug treatment program, is a problem. It is not surprising
that Tarzana Treatment has “a low tolerance” for a patient’s
determined efforts to break the rules in this way.
As for Hernandez’s repeated attempts to develop a
relationship with a fellow patient, program personnel explained
the rule, asked him to sign an acknowledgement of that rule
after his first violation, warned him after his second violation,
and warned him again after his third violation. When caught
violating this rule a fourth time in fewer than four days,
Hernandez did not take responsibility for his conduct. He did
not apologize and promise to do better. Instead, he pretended
not to know what the director was talking about.
On appeal, Hernandez also attempts to blame the court
for his predicament, suggesting the court lured him into an
execution-suspended sentence and “downplayed the possibility”
that that sentence would be executed if he “messed up.” The
record does not support Hernandez’s assertion. The court
explained the People’s offer, noting the “easy” “option” was
“just [to] do” the four years they had offered.
But, the court continued, if Hernandez was “actually
interested” in dealing with his addiction, the “harder option”
would be a residential program, which the court was willing
to grant over the prosecution’s objection. The court told
Hernandez it had “yet to send someone to prison” for a dirty test,
but that if he left the program, that would be “a different matter.”
At the conclusion of the later sentencing hearing, the court
again emphasized to Hernandez that, if he believed he had a
valid excuse for leaving the program, he was to come to court
12
the next business day. But, the court said, if Hernandez left the
program and the court “[did] not hear from [him],” that would
be a different situation.
In sum, Hernandez left his first court-ordered program
in fewer than 10 days and was discharged from his second court-
ordered program after only four days. He was arrested twice
and detained at least once. The arrests were for (1) hiding
behind bushes in the front yard of a residence at 4:30 in the
morning, while possessing methamphetamine, and (2) walking
onto private property, looking into the windows of the victims’
parked cars, then sitting on their porch, drinking a beer at 11:30
at night. After being discharged from Tarzana Treatment on
December 5, 2023, Hernandez was detained on December 8 by
Hawthorne police for a violation of section 647, subdivision (f).7
Hernandez never came back to court and he absconded from
parole supervision. In short, Hernandez never did a single
thing he was supposed to do. The trial court did not abuse
its discretion in executing the suspended sentence.
7 Accordingly, Hernandez’s assertion that he had not
“committed any new crime” is not accurate. (Cf. In re Coughlin
(1976) 16 Cal.3d 52, 56 [“probation may be revoked despite
the fact that the evidence of the probationer’s guilt may be
insufficient to convict him of the new offense”].)
13
DISPOSITION
We affirm Tomas Michael Hernandez’s conviction.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
EGERTON, J.
We concur:
EDMON, P. J.
KLATCHKO, J.
Judge of the Riverside Superior Court, assigned by the
Chief Justice pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the California
Constitution.
14
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.