CourtListener 10646330•People v. Lu CA2/8
Full text
Filed 8/1/25 P. v. Lu CA2/8
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION EIGHT
THE PEOPLE, B337815
Plaintiff and Respondent, Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. BA495163
v.
STEVEN LU,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County. Lisa Lench, Judge. Affirmed.
Andrea Keith, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Appellant.
No appearance for Plaintiff and Respondent.
__________________________
Defendant Steven Lu appeals from his conviction by a jury
on September 13, 2023, of two counts of grand theft from an elder
or dependent adult, in violation of Penal Code section 368,
subdivision (d), a felony. We affirm.
Overview
Defendant was a relationship banker at a JP Morgan
Chase branch bank in Los Angeles County. He met the victim,
Marion Poulter, an elderly woman in her 80’s, for the first time
on March 17, 2018, when she came into the bank where he
worked. On March 20, 2018, Ms. Poulter wrote a check to
defendant for $25,000, with the memo notation, “Thanks for your
help.” On March 30, 2018, she wrote another check to defendant
for $15,000. By April 5, 2018, Ms. Poulter had signed trust
documents under which defendant was a 75 percent beneficiary,
a durable power of attorney for healthcare in favor of defendant,
and a durable power of attorney for asset management in favor of
defendant.
The Testimony
The jury trial took place over nine days between August 30
and September 13, 2023.
Tiffanie Bell was vice president and branch manager of the
Chase branch in Altadena where defendant worked. There was a
Bank of America financial center 20 steps away, where Ms.
Poulter had multiple accounts. Ms. Bell received training about
twice a year in identifying elderly people who might be
susceptible to fraud or financial abuse, and was a “mandatory
reporter” of suspected abuse (as was defendant).
On March 17, 2018, Ms. Bell observed Ms. Poulter sitting
at defendant’s desk with a big stack of paperwork; she was there
for about three hours, an unusual amount of time. Defendant
told Ms. Bell that Ms. Poulter was confused about her accounts,
and needed assistance with understanding what was going on
2
with her accounts. Defendant wanted to open an account for her
and bring over $700,000 to Chase. Ms. Bell refused to let
defendant open an account for Ms. Poulter. At some later date,
Ms. Bell became concerned when she observed defendant talking
to Dominick Divine, a financial advisor at the branch, about
opening an account for someone in the same dollar amount. She
spoke to Mr. Divine and understood defendant was trying to set
up an investment account for a family friend. Ms. Bell was
concerned that defendant was acting unethically. After speaking
with other bank employees about defendant’s attempts to open a
new account, Ms. Bell reported defendant to the bank’s
investigations team. The investigations team interviewed
defendant by telephone that same day, and after the interview,
defendant resigned.
As stated at the outset, Ms. Poulter signed the documents
creating her living trust on April 5, 2018. The documents were
prepared by defense witness James Helms, an estate planning
lawyer who had retired by the time of trial. Defendant made the
appointment with Mr. Helms for the estate planning documents.
Mr. Helms met with Ms. Poulter several times. He testified there
were warning signs about defendant, but Ms. Poulter did not
seem confused or unable to understand. Mr. Helms concluded
she and defendant were true friends.
Thomas Hoffman is an estate planning attorney who met
alone with Ms. Poulter on April 11, 2018, for at least an hour or
two. Attorney Helms had referred Ms. Poulter to Mr. Hoffman
for purposes of providing a certificate of independent review,
which is intended to determine whether the disposition in an
estate planning document is the result of fraud, duress or undue
influence. Mr. Hoffman did not sign the certificate, as he was
uncomfortable with offering an opinion as to Ms. Poulter’s
susceptibility to fraud, duress or undue influence.
3
Dominick Divine testified, confirming Ms. Bell’s description
of their encounter about opening an investment account for a
family friend, Ms. Poulter. Mr. Divine said he would have to
meet with Ms. Poulter. They set up a meeting for a Saturday,
but when defendant brought Ms. Poulter to the bank, Ms. Bell
would not let them in and they left.
Ahmad Mehaidly was a private client banker at Chase’s
main office in Pasadena, where defendant had worked before his
transfer to the Altadena branch. Defendant contacted Mr.
Mehaidly in early April to open a trust account, for which
defendant would be trustee, for his family friend, Ms. Poulter.
Defendant emailed Mr. Mehaidly the trust documents, and they
met, along with Ms. Poulter, on April 12, 2018. At the meeting,
defendant brought an addendum Mr. Mehaidly had not seen
before, which showed defendant as a beneficiary of the living
trust. Mr. Mehaidly spoke to Ms. Poulter alone and questioned
her about how she knew defendant; she gave inconsistent
answers and said she was making defendant a beneficiary
“because he takes care of her.” Mr. Mehaidly did not open an
account; he consulted with the Pasadena branch manager, Benny
Sanchez, who told defendant they would not open an account.
Among the “red flags” were the discrepancy in how defendant and
Ms. Poulter knew each other and “being beneficiary getting a big
chunk of her nest egg.” Mr. Mehaidly raised the topic of making
a report of potential elder abuse with his manager, but his
superiors were already reporting the incident.
Veronica Mendoza was assistant manager at the Bank of
America branch in Altadena, located near the Chase branch.
Ms. Poulter was a frequent client, coming in several times a
week, and had multiple accounts. Defendant came in with
Ms. Poulter in March 2018, asking to close out her accounts, and
wanted cash. The branch didn’t have that amount of cash on
4
hand (over $200,000) “at the moment.” Defendant spoke for
Ms. Poulter (a red flag), and when Ms. Mendoza asked to speak to
Ms. Poulter privately, “he refused to allow her to do so.”
Ms. Mendoza insisted; she testified Ms. Poulter “was a little
confused,” and “wasn’t sure why she was closing out the
accounts,” and defendant had instructed her to do so. Then
defendant “barges into the office and says that the conversation
was over.” They exchanged words; Ms. Mendoza asked an
associate to call the police, who arrived and spoke to defendant
and Ms. Poulter, who were allowed to leave. Ms. Mendoza
reported the incident, and several days later the accounts were
closed.
Jason Jones, a detective in the county sheriff’s fraud and
cybercrimes bureau, received a suspected elder abuse report
made by a bank employee concerning Ms. Poulter and defendant
dated April 13, 2018. Detective Jones collected multiple such
reports from Adult Protectives Services as part of his
investigation. He interviewed Ms. Poulter on September 19,
2018. This was recorded and played for jury. Detective Jones
testified it was clear she had some mental impairments. She
could not remember details about things he expected her to know;
“didn’t seem to have much of a grasp as far as her finances go”;
and couldn’t remember meeting defendant at Chase Bank or the
name of the bank.
Detective Jones testified he subpoenaed various bank
records. The $25,000 and $15,000 checks to defendant drawn on
one of Ms. Poulter’s accounts were deposited into defendant’s
bank account at the Bank of America. On April 11, 2018,
hundreds of thousands of dollars from accounts at another
institution were transferred to new accounts opened at Wells
Fargo; the account holders were Ms. Poulter’s living trust and
defendant.
5
Elizabeth Torres Jaquez was a probate court investigator.
In January 2019, defendant was seeking to be conservator over
both the person and estate of Ms. Poulter. Ms. Jaquez
interviewed Ms. Poulter. She concluded Ms. Poulter needed a
conservator, but was concerned about appointing defendant.
Eventually, Ms. Poulter’s sister was appointed temporary
conservator, and Ms. Jaquez recommended that a third non-
related professional conservator be appointed.
Tamiel Holloway, a probate and special education attorney,
was appointed in January 2019 to represent Ms. Poulter in the
investigation of the proposed conservatorship. Ms. Holloway met
with Ms. Poulter on January 10, 2019. Ms. Poulter could not
recall where all her money was. Ms. Holloway reviewed Ms.
Poulter’s estate planning documents, including the durable power
of attorney for asset management designating defendant as her
agent. In her January 2019 report to the court, Ms. Holloway
recommended the court should suspend the testamentary
document, refer the case to the Public Guardian’s office, and
consider the appointment of a professional financial fiduciary.
In early February 2019, Ms. Holloway received several confused
calls from Ms. Poulter, and “[i]t wasn’t clear she knew how to
operate the phone.”
Ms. Holloway was interviewed by Detective Jones, and
provided him with the estate planning documents, as well as
copies of the $25,000 check and the $15,000 check made out to
defendant from Ms. Poulter. The check copies had been given to
her by defendant’s then-counsel.
She made a report to Adult Protective Services because “some of
the activity looks like it could be suspicious.”
Dr. Diane Homeier is an experienced geriatrician who also
ran an elder abuse forensic center. Both Adult Protective
Services and the Public Guardian had concerns about
6
Ms. Poulter’s ability to make financial decisions for herself.
Dr. Homeier performed an evaluation and conducted cognitive
testing of Ms. Poulter on February 20, 2019. Dr. Homeier also
reviewed Ms. Poulter’s Kaiser medical records from 2017 to 2019,
as well as reports from Adult Protective Services. Dr. Homeier
noted that Ms. Poulter had “admitted to some memory issues” in
October 2017. In September 2018, she admitted having more and
more trouble with her memory, and in October 2018, a
comprehensive memory evaluation was done at Kaiser. Her
scores were in the moderate to severe range of cognitive deficits;
the Kaiser notes indicated a diagnosis of dementia most likely
due to Alzheimer’s disease.
After performing her own assessment and reviewing the
records, it was Dr. Homeier’s opinion that Ms. Poulter certainly
had a dementia syndrome and lacked capacity at the time of her
February 2019 evaluation, and “she probably lacked financial
capacity as early as December of 2017.” (This was when Ms.
Poulter was the victim of a scam involving her writing several
checks totally $50,000 for repair of her driveway.)
The defense presented many witnesses in addition to
James Helms, who prepared the trust documents (see ante, at
page 3). Eugene Alkana was an estate planning attorney who
executed a certificate of independent review after Mr. Hoffman
declined to do so. He met Ms. Poulter twice, and signed on May
21, 2018. He recalled virtually nothing about it, and testified to
what he would have done. Connie Kwok, a personal banker at
Citibank, opened a trust account for Ms. Poulter in January
2019. She noticed no red flags and could not recall if Ms. Poulter
answered her questions. Maria Klahejian was a premier banker
at Wells Fargo in April 2018, and opened the accounts there for
Ms. Poulter and defendant, but had no independent recollection
of doing so. Kevin Mehserejian was a senior financial advisor at
7
Wells Fargo who worked with Ms. Klahejian when the accounts
were opened; he recalled setting up the investment account for
defendant and Ms. Poulter and meeting with them twice, and
saw nothing that caused him concern.
Junell Mackey was a certified public accountant who
prepared tax returns for Ms. Poulter for over thirty years; the
last return was for the year 2020. She did not see a decline in
Ms. Poulter’s memory until the year before she died. Ms. Poulter
appeared to understand why she was in Ms. Mackey’s office and
was “quite coherent.” Ms. Mackey told Detective Jones that she
noticed at a meeting with Ms. Poulter that she was failing
mentally, but the date of that meeting is unclear.
Deputy District Attorney Lisa Daruty was prosecuting
cases involving vulnerable victims in 2018. This included the
elder abuse case involving the $50,000 sidewalk scam. Ms.
Daruty conducted a preliminary hearing on August 27, 2018, at
which Ms. Poulter testified. Ms. Daruty was comfortable calling
her as a witness; Ms. Poulter appeared to understand some of the
questions and not to understand others. Ms. Poulter was “kind of
confused” and sometimes didn’t understand the question so that
Ms. Daruty would have to ask it a different way and ask leading
questions, but “overall I got what I needed from her.”
The verdict and sentencing
On September 13, 2023, the jury convicted defendant on
both counts of grand theft of an elder person. Defendant waived
his right to a jury trial on aggravating factors that were alleged
in the information.
On October 18, 2023, defendant petitioned for release of
juror information so that he could investigate “potential juror
misconduct.” This was based on declarations from defendant’s
wife, Vivian Lu, and from George Lu, stating that on the last day
of trial, while waiting in line at the cafeteria, they overheard an
8
exchange between a juror and a cafeteria employee; the juror
allegedly thanked the employee for her kindness, “since I won’t
be seeing you again. This will end quickly.”
At the sentencing hearing on December 19, 2023, the court
denied defendant’s petition to release juror information, ruling
there was nothing to support defendant’s suggestion that the
jurors were discussing the matter among themselves before
deliberations began.
The court found circumstances in aggravation (the victim
was particularly vulnerable; the crime involved a taking of great
monetary value; defendant took advantage of a position of trust;
and the manner in which the crime was carried out involved
planning). (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 4.421(a)(3), (9), (11) & 8.)
Circumstances in mitigation included no previous criminal
record; “collateral consequences to a custodial sentence in terms
of his family”; and many community ties and supportive friends
and family.
The court suspended imposition of sentence, placed
defendant on probation for two years, required him to perform
500 hours of community service, ordered restitution to the estate
of Ms. Poulter of $40,000 plus 10 percent interest, and assessed
various other fees.
The Appeal
We appointed appellate counsel to represent defendant.
Appellate counsel filed a brief pursuant to People v. Wende (1979)
25 Cal.3d 436 (Wende) in which no issues were raised. The brief
included a declaration from counsel that she reviewed the entire
record and sent a letter to defendant explaining her evaluation of
the record. Counsel further declared she advised defendant of his
right to submit a supplemental brief within 30 days, and that she
sent defendant a copy of the record on appeal and a copy of her
brief. Defendant did not file a supplemental brief.
9
We have examined the entire record and are satisfied that
appointed counsel fully complied with her responsibilities and
that no arguable issues exist. (People v. Kelly (2006) 40 Cal.4th
106, 109-110; Wende, supra, 25 Cal.3d at p. 441.)
DISPOSITION
The judgment of conviction is affirmed.
RUBIN, J.*
WE CONCUR:
STRATTON, P. J.
VIRAMONTES, J.
* Retired Presiding Justice of the Court of Appeal, Second
Appellate District, assigned by the Chief Justice pursuant to
article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution.
10
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.