CourtListener 10641251•In re A.J. CA2/1
Full text
Filed 7/25/25 In re A.J. CA2/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
In re A.J. et al., Persons B341241
Coming Under the Juvenile (Los Angeles County
Court Law. Super. Ct. No. 21CCJP04085)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF
CHILDREN AND FAMILY
SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
J.J.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from the jurisdictional and dispositional orders of
the Superior Court of Los Angeles County, Syna N. Dennis,
Judge. Appeal dismissed.
John M. Kennedy, under appointment by the
Court of Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and William D. Thetford, Principal
Deputy County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
____________________
Mother appeals from the juvenile court’s jurisdictional and
dispositional orders. She contends the court erred in sustaining
allegations she failed to protect her children and requiring her to
attend therapy and parenting classes. We conclude her claims
are moot and also decline to exercise our discretion to consider
them. We therefore dismiss the appeal.
BACKGROUND
Mother has two children—A.J. (born in 2021) and A.L.
(born in 2022). A.J. and A.L. have different fathers. During the
current dependency proceedings, the children remained in
mother’s custody.
1. First dependency proceeding
The first dependency proceeding commenced after a doctor
reported A.J. had two posterior rib fractures “highly probably”
caused by physical abuse. The fractures occurred in July 2021
after mother and A.J.’s father struggled over A.J. with each
trying to take A.J. away from the other.
In April 2022, the juvenile court sustained allegations A.J.
suffered two posterior rib fractures consistent with inflicted
trauma, which fractures were the product of mother’s and A.J.’s
father’s “deliberate, unreasonable, and neglectful acts . . . .”
Specifically, the court sustained allegations mother and father
2
“pulled” A.J. “back and forth in an effort to remove the child from
one another’s hold.” The court also found mother and A.J.’s
father had a history of violent altercations in A.J.’s presence.
The juvenile court terminated jurisdiction on April 19, 2023
with an order granting the parents joint legal custody and
mother sole physical custody.
2. Second dependency proceeding
In June 2024, the Los Angeles County Department of
Children and Family Services (DCFS) filed a second dependency
petition, alleging J.L. (A.L.’s father), endangered A.L. when, in
A.L.’s presence, J.L. engaged in a violent altercation with an
unknown person and brandished a firearm. DCFS alleged
mother knew or reasonably should have known J.L. possessed a
loaded weapon and mother allowed J.L. to live in the family home
and have unmonitored contact with the children. The juvenile
court sustained the allegations under Welfare and Institutions
Code section 300, subdivision b(1) (failure to protect) and
subdivision j (abuse of sibling). DCFS further alleged J.L. was
arrested for possession of a firearm and that A.L. and A.J. were
at risk of serious physical harm, damage, and danger. According
to DCFS, J.L. exposed A.L. to a dangerous situation by carrying a
firearm while caring for A.L.
In interviews with social workers, mother described the
events set forth in the petition. According to mother, an
unknown person almost drove into J.L. and A.L. in a DMV
parking lot. J.L. argued with the unknown person and handed
mother his fanny pack. Later, law enforcement searched mother
and found a gun in the fanny pack. Mother reported she did not
know J.L. was carrying a gun and asserted she would “never
allow father to bring firearms near her children.” Mother told the
3
social worker J.L. was not physically abusive towards her
although once, she and J.L. had a verbal altercation and she
asked J.L. to leave the home. J.L. returned home a week later.
Mother claimed she would ask J.L. to move out to allow the
children to continue living with her.
When a social worker interviewed father, he stated that
mother “ ‘had nothing to do with this.’ ” Father explained that as
he was walking with mother and A.L. inside the DMV parking
lot, an unknown driver said, “ ‘Get your ass on the sidewalk.’ ”
Father replied, “ ‘[B]itch, there is no sidewalk.’ ” The driver
exited the car and shoved father, at which point father showed
the driver his firearm. Father stated he kept the firearm hidden
in bushes outside the apartment where he lived with mother and
the children. Father denied bringing the firearm inside the
house or “around” the children.
Prior to the jurisdictional hearing, mother enrolled and
participated in parenting and domestic violence classes. Mother
said, “ ‘[W]e all need therapy.’ ” Mother told the social worker
she would not allow father “to immediately move back in when he
is released from jail.” Mother also reaffirmed that she was
unaware of J.L.’s gun and stated J.L. hid it from her. Mother
informed the social worker, “ ‘Every time he gets caught, the
police confiscate the weapon. So I didn’t know he had it. There
are a lot of things that he doesn’t tell me, and I have to find out
from his mom. It’s just the lifestyle he grew up around. I told
him to let it go; I don’t like gangs.’ ” Mother told the social
worker that father “ ‘never said anything to [her] about having a
gun in the bushes.’ ” Mother added, “ ‘There aren’t really that
many bushes out there anyways.’ ”
4
The social worker concluded mother’s claim not to have
known about the gun in the fanny pack was not reasonable:
“Although the mother stated she wasn’t aware [father] possessed
a gun, the mother has been involved and/or made aware of
several past inciden[ts] where [J.L.] has dangerously used a
weapon he was not authorized to have. Mother reported she is
not sure how [J.L.] keeps obtaining guns because they are always
confiscated by law enforcement. . . . [D]espite mother allegedly
being unaware that the bag [father] gave her at the DMV
contained a gun, she reasonably should have known based on
their history.”
3. Additional dependency referrals and incidents
involving mother
In addition to referrals related to the first sustained
petition, in August 2023, a caller reported to DCFS an incident at
a train station involving mother and J.L. Although the record of
this incident is sparse, apparently the caller stated that mother
had called J.L. after an unidentified male harassed her at a train
station by calling her names. When J.L. arrived at the train
station, he had a firearm and “hit[ ] the random man multiple
times.” DCFS’s description refers to A.J. and A.L. as “Victim(s)”
but does not elaborate other than to characterize the incident
under the title, “General Neglect.” DCFS describes the
disposition as “INCONCLUSIVE for allegations of General
Neglect.” (Boldface omitted.)
Reflecting another incident, an officer’s crime/incident
report stated that on March 8, 2024, officers were dispatched to
mother’s home. Mother told officers she and J.L. had a physical
altercation in a vehicle in the children’s presence. J.L. slapped
mother on the right side of her face causing her to bleed. Mother
5
exited the vehicle and J.L. drove away before mother could
remove the children. After a caller reported the incident to
DCFS, DCFS found the allegations inconclusive for allegations of
emotional abuse.
4. After a hearing, the juvenile court modified and
sustained the second dependency petition
No one testified at the hearing giving rise to this appeal.
The juvenile court struck the allegation that mother knew of
J.L.’s possession of a loaded weapon. The court sustained the
remaining allegations against mother.1 The court found mother
“reasonably should have known” J.L. possessed a loaded weapon
in close proximity to A.L. The court then removed the children
from J.L.’s custody and ordered they remain in mother’s custody.
The court ordered mother to participate in parenting classes and
individual counseling.
On June 16, 2025, the juvenile court terminated
jurisdiction, leaving A.L. in mother’s custody.2 The court also
terminated jurisdiction over A.J. and awarded mother sole legal
and physical custody of A.J.
DISCUSSION
Mother contests only the jurisdictional findings against her
as not supported by substantial evidence. She asserts we should
exercise our discretion to review the jurisdictional findings
1 Mother does not contest the court’s jurisdictional findings
against J.L. We thus do not address them.
2 On our own motion and finding good cause, we take
judicial notice of the juvenile court’s orders dated June 16, 2025
and June 18, 2025 terminating jurisdiction over A.J. and A.L.
6
because the juvenile court’s dispositional order requiring her to
attended classes and counseling was based on those findings and
because mother is “truly non-offending.”
Because the juvenile court terminated jurisdiction,
mother’s arguments are moot. Mother retained full custody of
the children, and having terminated the dependency proceedings,
the court no longer has jurisdiction to enforce attendance at
classes and counseling. (In re D.P. (2023) 14 Cal.5th 266, 276
(D.P.) [case is moot when it is impossible to grant an appellant
effective relief].)
We recognize, “[e]ven when a case is moot, courts may
exercise their ‘inherent discretion’ to reach the merits of the
dispute.” (D.P., supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 282.) For example, a
parent’s meritorious challenge to a jurisdictional finding may be
moot, and thus evade review, where there is a separate
“ ‘ “unassailable jurisdictional finding” ’ ” unrelated to the
appealing parent. (Id. at p. 283.) In determining whether to
exercise discretion, an appellate court may also consider whether
a jurisdictional finding could potentially impact current or future
dependency proceedings. (Id. at p. 285.) “Ultimately, in deciding
whether to exercise its discretion, a court should be guided by the
overarching goals of the dependency system: ‘to provide
maximum safety and protection for children’ with a ‘focus’ on ‘the
preservation of the family as well as the safety, protection, and
physical and emotional well-being of the child.’ [Citations.]” (Id.
at pp. 286–287, italics added.)
We decline to exercise our discretion to reach the merits of
mother’s appeal. We do not agree with mother’s assertion that
she is “truly non-offending” because in a prior dependency case,
the juvenile court sustained allegations A.J. suffered broken ribs
7
because of mother’s and A.J’s father’s abuse. The allegations
against mother here are no more egregious than those in the
prior case.
Assuming arguendo the juvenile court should not have
sustained the jurisdictional allegations against mother, the
juvenile court could still order mother to attend counseling and
parenting classes, especially given the multiple prior dependency
proceedings and mother’s stated need for therapy. (In re D.L.
(2018) 22 Cal.App.5th 1142, 1148 [juvenile court has authority to
order nonoffending parent to participate in services].)
Considering the merits of mother’s appeal would not further
preservation of the family or the children’s safety because the
court terminated jurisdiction with an order granting mother sole
custody of A.J. and leaving A.L. in mother’s custody. Finally, we
discern no legal issue of continuing public interest capable of
evading review that would support our addressing an otherwise
moot appeal. (In re Erica R. (2015) 240 Cal.App.4th 907, 911
[court exercised discretion to reach the merits of minor’s
challenge to an electronic search condition even though minor’s
successful completion of probation rendered her challenge moot].)
For all these reasons, we decline to exercise our discretion
to consider the merits of mother’s appeal and dismiss the appeal.
8
DISPOSITION
The appeal is dismissed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.
BENDIX, J.
We concur:
ROTHSCHILD, P. J.
WEINGART, J.
9
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.