CourtListener 10633895•In re Michael P. CA2/7
Full text
Filed 7/16/25 In re Michael P. CA2/7
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION SEVEN
In re MICHAEL P. et al., B338193
Persons Coming Under the
Juvenile Court Law. (Los Angeles County Super.
Ct. No. 20CCJP04033A, C)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF
CHILDREN AND FAMILY
SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
KELLY P.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County, Tiana J. Murillo, Judge. Affirmed.
Lillian Hamrick, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Kimberly Roura, Senior Deputy
County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
____________________________________
INTRODUCTION
Kelly P. appeals from the juvenile court’s orders denying
her petitions under Welfare and Institutions Code section 388
and appointing a legal guardian for her sons Michael and
William.1 Kelly received 15 months of family reunification
services, but failed to make substantial progress in addressing
the issues that led the court to assert jurisdiction over the boys.
More than three years after the Department intervened,
and long after the court terminated reunification services, Kelly
finally began a substance abuse treatment program. After she
completed that program, she filed section 388 petitions seeking
custody of Michael and William or, in the alternative, additional
family reunification services. By that time, however, the boys
had been in foster care for almost four years and had finally
settled in the home of their great-aunt Maura C. with hopes of
adoption.
We conclude the juvenile did not err in ruling Kelly’s recent
efforts, while commendable, came too late. Therefore, we affirm.
1 Statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions
Code.
2
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. The Juvenile Court Declares Michael and William
Dependent Children of the Court and Removes Them
from Kelly
In July 2020 the Los Angeles County Department of
Children and Family Services received a referral claiming Kelly
physically attacked the maternal grandmother Margarita P.
(with whom Kelly and her six children2 lived) while under the
influence of a narcotic and in the presence of the children. The
oldest child, Michael (11), left Margarita’s apartment to get help
from a neighbor and to call the police. William (9) intervened to
protect Margarita and pulled Kelly to the ground. Kelly bit
William on the shoulder, leaving a mark.
The court detained all six children from Kelly. Neither
Michael’s biological father, Mauricio C., nor William’s biological
father, Julio D., was involved with the family, and the
Department initially could not locate either one. Joshua F. is the
father of Kelly’s other four children, but he did not live with the
family. The Department placed Michael and William with
maternal great-aunt Connie M.
In December 2020 the juvenile court sustained a petition
under section 300, subdivisions (a), (b), and (j). The court found
true allegations that Michael and William had suffered, or there
was a substantial risk they would suffer, serious physical harm
inflicted nonaccidentally or accidentally because (1) Kelly had a
2 Only Michael and William are at issue in this appeal.
When the Department intervened, Kelly’s children ranged in age
from 11 years old to three months old.
3
history of engaging in violent altercations, including one with
Margarita where Kelly bit William when he tried to protect
Margarita; (2) Kelly’s companion Joshua physically abused
Michael by hitting the child with his fists, and Kelly failed to
protect Michael from Joshua; (3) Kelly physically abused the
children by striking them with a cell phone charger cable and a
belt; (4) Kelly had a history of substance abuse, was a current
abuser of marijuana and amphetamine, and used illegal drugs in
the presence of the children, all of which rendered her unable to
provide the children with regular care and supervision; and
(5) Joshua had a history of illegal drug use, including
amphetamine and methamphetamine, and was a current abuser
of marijuana. The court also found true allegations that Kelly
and Joshua had previously abused one or more of the siblings and
that there was a substantial risk Michael and William would be
abused or neglected, within the meaning of section 300,
subdivision (a) or (b).
The juvenile court declared Michael and William dependent
children of the court, removed them from Kelly, and ordered
family reunification services for Kelly. Kelly’s case plan included
a drug and alcohol rehabilitation program, weekly drug testing,
a 12-step program, and individual counseling and courses to
address case issues, including anger management, age-
appropriate discipline, substance abuse, and the effect of family
violence and drug abuse on children. The court ordered
monitored visitation for Kelly and gave the Department
discretion to liberalize visitation. The court bypassed
reunification services for Mauricio and Julio, the biological
fathers of Michael and William, respectively, under section 361.5,
subdivision (b).
4
B. Kelly Does Not Substantially Comply with Her Case
Plan, and the Juvenile Court Continues Family
Reunification Services
In June 2021 the court held the six-month review hearing
under section 366.21, subdivision (e). Prior to the hearing the
Department reported Michael and William had moved to a second
placement with a non-family member, and later to a third
placement. Kelly made some effort to comply with her court-
ordered case plan. The Department reported Kelly was
participating in an anger management class, a parenting class, a
domestic violence class, and individual counseling. Regarding
weekly drug testing, Kelly tested negative on three occasions, but
was a “no show” for the other 16 tests during the period of
supervision. Regarding visitation with Michael and William, the
Department said Kelly was “inconsistent with calling her
children” and only “sporadically” called the children and logged in
for virtual visits. Kelly visited the children in person once3 and
did not consistently maintain contact with the Department. In a
last minute information report, the Department stated Kelly
enrolled in substance abuse counseling in April 2021 but
attended only one session.
The court found that Kelly had not substantially complied
with her case plan and that returning Michael and William to
Kelly would create a substantial risk of detriment to their safety
and well-being. The court ordered the Department to provide
additional family reunification services, but warned Kelly that
3 Because of the COVID-19 pandemic, the Department
facilitated mostly virtual visits during this time.
5
the court would seriously consider terminating those services at
the next hearing if she continued to miss drug tests and visits.
C. Kelly (Still) Does Not Substantially Comply with Her
Case Plan, and the Court Terminates Family
Reunification Services
After the six-month review hearing Michael and William
moved to a new (their fourth) placement, this time with Mr. and
Mrs. U. For the next review hearing the Department reported
Kelly had complied with some aspects of her case plan. Although
Kelly was attending an anger management class and had
completed a parenting class, she was still not participating in a
substance abuse program. Kelly attended only two substance
abuse program sessions in May 2021 and said “she did not
understand why she needed to do a substance abuse program.”
Kelly appeared only twice for random drug testing during the
period of supervision (testing negative both times). She claimed
she lost her identification card and could not test on the other
occasions. And Kelly was not participating in a 12-step program,
as required by her case plan. Regarding visitation, the
Department reported that Kelly had only one in-person visit with
Michael and William during this period and that she called the
boys inconsistently. The Department recommended terminating
Kelly’s reunification services and continuing monitored
visitation.
The Department also submitted concurrent planning
assessments. The Department identified Mr. and Mrs. U. as
possible long-term foster parents or legal guardians for the boys.
At the 12-month review hearing in November 2021 the
juvenile court found returning Michael and William to Kelly
6
would create a substantial risk of detriment. The court also
found Kelly had not substantially complied with her case plan
because she had not participated in a substance abuse program,
appeared consistently for drug testing, or visited the children
regularly. The court terminated her family reunification
services. The court set the matter for a permanency planning
hearing under section 366.26 on February 28, 2022 and
transferred educational rights for Michael and William to Mr.
and Mrs. U.
D. Permanency Planning Is Delayed
Permanency planning for Michael and William lasted more
than two years. The boys initially adapted well to their
placement with Mr. and Mrs. U., who agreed in early 2022 to
serve as legal guardians for both boys, and in May 2022 the court
identified legal guardianship as the permanent plan for Michael
and William. In June 2022, however, Michael asked the
Department to move him from the home of Mr. and Mrs. U.,
saying the couple was too strict. Mr. and Mrs. U. later withdrew
their consent to guardianship, after both Michael and William
became discontented with the placement. The Department
placed Michael with another foster parent at the end of
June 2022. After Michael left the home, William became
increasingly frustrated with Mr. and Mrs. U. and began regularly
yelling at and disrespecting them. William later admitted Kelly
asked him to sabotage his placement with Mr. and Mrs. U. so
that William could request placement with his half siblings’
foster family and then sabotage their plans for permanency.
Because of these issues, the Department requested, and the court
granted, additional time for permanency planning.
7
Regarding visitation, the Department reported in late 2021
Kelly visited the boys inconsistently, sometimes failing to show
up for visits after confirming the day before. During the first half
of 2022 Kelly and Margarita visited the children regularly (every
other weekend), but Kelly tended to spend time with her
daughters rather than with Michael and William. During the
second half of 2022 Kelly did not visit the children for several
months. When she did visit, she tended to focus her attention on
Michael, saying that he “is her baby and that he is the most
special of all siblings.”
The Department updated the court in late October 2022
and identified adoption as the most appropriate plan for Michael
and William. Because neither of the boys’ foster parents
committed to adoption or legal guardianship, the Department
hoped to recruit an adoptive family for both boys. On
November 4, 2022 the court identified adoption as the permanent
plan for Michael and William.
The Department updated the juvenile court again in
January 2023. The Department had placed Michael and William
with Maura (the maternal great-aunt) in December 2022. Maura
told the Department she wanted to adopt both boys. The court
granted the Department’s request for additional time to assess
the situation. Meanwhile, Kelly continued to have monitored
visitation with the boys every other weekend. At one point,
however, the case social worker suspended Kelly’s visits because
Kelly was “unable to abide by the rules in the visitation
agreement and failed to take the several warnings to correct her
behaviors during visits with children.”
In May 2023 the Department reported that Maura still
wanted to adopt Michael and William and that the Department
8
had approved Maura for adoption. The boys had settled into
their new home and wanted Maura to adopt them. Regarding
visitation, Kelly visited the boys only three times between the
middle of December 2022 and the end of May 2023 and did not
call them at all. Michael and William told the case social worker
that they no longer wanted to visit with Kelly. The Department
recommended the court terminate Kelly’s parental rights so the
Department could move forward with the adoption process.
In an August 2023 report the Department said Michael and
William continued to be comfortable in Maura’s home and
wanted Maura to adopt them. The Department said Kelly
contacted the case social worker on August 7, 2023 to report she
had been participating in an outpatient drug rehabilitation
program for the past two months. Kelly also said she wanted to
“reverse” the orders terminating her parental rights for all her
children and wanted Maura to become a legal guardian (rather
than an adoptive parent) for Michael and William. Kelly visited
Michael and William once in July 2023 and once in August 2023.
Kelly gave birth to another child (her seventh) on August 16,
2023.
In December 2023 the Department reported Michael and
William continued to live comfortably with Maura. Between mid-
August 2023 and mid-December 2023 Kelly visited the boys only
once. The Department recommended the court terminate Kelly’s
parental rights and order the Department to facilitate the boys’
adoption. The court scheduled a hearing on whether to terminate
parental rights and select a permanent plan for January 2, 2024.
9
E. Kelly Files Petitions Under Section 388 Seeking
Custody of Michael and William or Reinstatement of
Family Reunification Services
On December 29, 2023 Kelly, claiming a change of
circumstance, filed petitions under section 388 asking the
juvenile court to return Michael and William to her custody or, in
the alternative, to reinstate family reunification services. Kelly
stated that during the pendency of the case, she completed
23 parenting classes, 20 domestic violence classes, 22 anger
management classes, 23 individual counseling sessions, and
online parenting classes. In addition, Kelly said, she completed
an eight-month outpatient drug rehabilitation program on
December 8, 2023. As part of that program, she participated in
96 group therapy and 11 individual therapy sessions. Kelly said
she was participating in an aftercare program and was living a
healthy, drug-free life. Kelly also said that she visited the boys
every weekend or every other weekend for two to six hours per
visit and that she spoke to the boys using a video conferencing
software application at least three times a week. Kelly said she
was working part time and was taking a job training course to
learn medical billing. Kelly and her infant son were living with
Margarita. The court set a hearing on the section 388 petitions
for February 8, 2024 and continued the section 366.26 hearing to
that date.
In its response to Kelly’s section 388 petitions the
Department reported on its most recent interview with Kelly in
December 2023. During the interview the Department
investigator discussed with Kelly the Department’s prior
involvement with the family: In 2015 the Department (among
other things) had removed Kelly’s children after one of them
10
tested positive for amphetamine at birth. Although Kelly
participated in a substance abuse program during the prior
dependency case, she ultimately relapsed. During the
December 2023 interview Kelly minimized the problems arising
from her long-standing substance abuse. Because Kelly
displayed a lack of insight about her earlier relapse, the
Department questioned how much benefit she received from the
program she completed in 2023. And though Kelly denied using
drugs with Joshua, the Department observed Kelly’s prior period
of sobriety (2015-2017) was while he was incarcerated. The
Department reported that Kelly said she had been sober since
June 2022, but that she did not seek prenatal care until
May 2023, which was the same month she started the drug
rehabilitation program, only three months before she gave birth
to her youngest child. The Department also reported that Kelly’s
aftercare program would last only two to three months and that
Kelly did not have a 12-step sponsor.
F. The Court Denies the Section 388 Petitions and
Continues the Hearing Under Section 366.26
The court denied the section 388 petitions on February 8,
2024. The court found Kelly did not meet her burden to
demonstrate either that there was a changed circumstance or
that reinstating reunification services or making a change in
placement was in the best interests of Michael and William. On
the issue of whether Kelly had shown a changed circumstance,
the court acknowledged that Kelly made “quite a lot of progress”
during the case and that Kelly recently completed a drug
rehabilitation program. But the court also said that Kelly lacked
insight into her drug use and that she minimized prior incidents
11
of violence in the home involving Michael. The court also stated
Kelly appeared to minimize issues (such as drug use and
domestic violence) regarding Joshua. In addition, the court said,
the most substantial changes Kelly made occurred after her
seventh child was born—just a few months before the hearing.
Regarding the best interests of Michael and William, the court
found that the boys were differently situated from Kelly’s new
baby and that the boys deserved permanency, given that the case
had been pending for such a long time (approaching four years.)
Regarding permanency planning, counsel for Michael and
William told the juvenile court that, contrary to the Department’s
prior reports, the boys no longer wanted to be adopted. The court
continued the hearing under section 366.26 and ordered the
Department to meet with Michael, William, and Maura to discuss
permanency options.
G. The Court Selects Legal Guardianship as the
Permanent Plan
The court held the permanency planning hearing on
May 23, 2024. The court found that Maura was willing to adopt
Michael and William, but that the boys did not want the court to
terminate Kelly’s parental rights to facilitate adoption. The court
selected legal guardianship with Maura as the permanent plan
and issued letters of guardianship.
On May 28, 2024 Kelly filed a notice of appeal challenging
the February 8, 2024 orders denying her section 388 petitions
and the May 23, 2024 orders selecting legal guardianship as the
permanent plan. We granted Kelly’s request for relief from her
untimely appeal from the February 8, 2024 orders.
12
DISCUSSION
A. Applicable Law and Standard of Review
Section 388, subdivision (a)(1), provides: “Any parent or
other person having an interest in a child who is a dependent
child of the juvenile court . . . may, upon grounds of change of
circumstance or new evidence, petition the court in the same
action in which the child was found to be a dependent child . . .
for a hearing to change, modify, or set aside any order of court
previously made or to terminate the jurisdiction of the court.” To
prevail on a section 388 petition, the petitioner must show ““‘by a
preponderance of the evidence (1) that there is new evidence or a
change of circumstances and (2) that the proposed modification
would be in the best interests of the child.’”” (In re Malick T.
(2022) 73 Cal.App.5th 1109, 1122, italics omitted; see In re
Stephanie M. (1994) 7 Cal.4th 295, 317; In re Matthew M. (2023)
88 Cal.App.5th 1186, 1194.)
Because Kelly had the burden to demonstrate there was
new evidence or a change of circumstance, we review the juvenile
court’s finding Kelly failed to meet her burden by determining
whether the evidence compels a finding in her favor on that issue
as a matter of law. (See In re Matthew M., supra, 88 Cal.App.5th
at p. 1194 [“If the juvenile court has ruled the moving party failed
to carry his or her initial burden to demonstrate new evidence or
change of circumstance, the first step of the analysis, the
question for the reviewing court is whether that finding is
erroneous as a matter of law.”].) Specifically, we determine
whether “the evidence ‘was (1) “uncontradicted and
unimpeached” and (2) “of such a character and weight as to leave
no room for a judicial determination that it was insufficient to
13
support a finding.’”” (In re Luis H. (2017) 14 Cal.App.5th 1223,
1227; see In re I.W. (2009) 180 Cal.App.4th 1517, 1528,
disapproved on another ground in Conservatorship of O.B. (2020)
9 Cal.5th 989, 1003, fn. 4.)
“We review the court’s best interest determination, the
second step, for abuse of discretion and may disturb the exercise
of that discretion only in the rare case when the court has made
an arbitrary or irrational determination. [Citation.] We do not
inquire whether substantial evidence would have supported a
different order, nor do we reweigh the evidence and substitute
our judgment for that of the juvenile court. [Citation.] We ask
only whether the juvenile court abused its discretion with respect
to the order it made.” (In re Matthew M., supra, 88 Cal.App.5th
at pp. 1194-1195; see In re Stephanie M., supra, 7 Cal.4th at
p. 318; In re Malick T., supra, 73 Cal.App.5th at p. 1123.)
B. The Juvenile Court Did Not Err in Ruling Kelly
Failed To Demonstrate a Substantial Change in
Circumstance
“‘Not every change in circumstance can justify modification
of a prior order’” under section 388. (In re N.F. (2021)
68 Cal.App.5th 112, 120; see In re A.A. (2012) 203 Cal.App.4th
597, 612.) “‘“[T]he change in circumstances must be
substantial.”’” (In re Malick T., supra, 73 Cal.App.5th at p. 1122;
see In re J.M. (2020) 50 Cal.App.5th 833, 845.) And where, as
here, the juvenile court has terminated a parent’s reunification
services, a substantial change means “the problem that initially
brought the child within the dependency system [has been]
removed or ameliorated.” (In re A.A., at p. 612; see In re J.M., at
p. 846 [“parent establishes a substantial change of circumstances
14
for purposes of section 388 by showing that . . . he or she has
resolved the previously unresolved issues supporting juvenile
court jurisdiction”].) Here, the bases of the juvenile court’s
jurisdiction were Kelly’s history of physical altercations in the
presence of the children, history of substance abuse, physical
abuse of the children, and failure to protect the children from
physical abuse by Joshua.
In her section 388 petitions Kelly argued there was a
substantial change in circumstance because she (finally) was
complying with her case plan. Kelly submitted certificates
showing that she completed parenting, domestic violence, and
anger management classes and that she participated in
individual counseling sessions. But because all of that evidence
related to Kelly’s progress during the early stages of the case
(2020-2021), it did not support her petitions under section 388.
“A parent establishes a substantial change of circumstances for
purposes of section 388 by showing that, during the period
between termination of reunification services and the permanency
planning hearing, he or she has resolved the previously
unresolved issues supporting juvenile court jurisdiction.” (In re
J.M., supra, 50 Cal.App.5th at p. 846, italics added.) “‘[T]he term
“new evidence” in section 388 means material evidence that, with
due diligence, the party could not have presented at the
dependency proceeding at which the order, sought to be modified
or set aside, was entered.’” (In re D.B. (2013) 217 Cal.App.4th
1080, 1093; see In re Matthew M., supra, 88 Cal.App.5th at
p. 1195 [mother’s explanation of her opposition to vaccines,
initially expressed at the six-month hearing, was not “new”
evidence that would support section 388 petition].)
15
Kelly also argued there was a significant change of
circumstance because she had recently completed an outpatient
drug rehabilitation program and was participating in an
aftercare program. The court acknowledged Kelly’s significant
progress in addressing her substance abuse, but found that
progress, without more, did not show a significant change of
circumstance. Kelly complains the juvenile court did not give her
evidence sufficient weight. As discussed, however, we do not
consider whether the evidence could have supported a different
finding. The question is whether the evidence compels a finding
in Kelly’s favor as a matter of law. And it does not. “The fact
that the parent ‘makes relatively last-minute (albeit genuine)
changes’ does not automatically tip the scale in the parent’s
favor.” (In re D.R. (2011) 193 Cal.App.4th 1494, 1512.)
There was also evidence Kelly had previously attempted
but failed to maintain sobriety. In 2015 the Department removed
Kelly’s children after one of them tested positive for
amphetamine at birth, and Kelly was participating in a
substance abuse program at that time. Where, as here, a
substance abuse problem is persistent despite attempts at
treatment, the court is not compelled to find a material change in
circumstance after a brief period of sobriety. (See, e.g., In re N.F.,
supra, 68 Cal.App.5th at p. 121 [no changed circumstance where
the mother recently completed a residential drug treatment
program but had previously completed similar programs and
relapsed]; In re C.J.W. (2007) 157 Cal.App.4th 1075, 1081
[parents’ most recent efforts at sobriety “were only three months
old” and did not demonstrate a changed circumstance]; In re
Cliffton B. (2000) 81 Cal.App.4th 415, 423 [parent’s seven months
of sobriety since his last relapse were insufficient to show a
16
changed circumstance, given the parent’s history of drug use,
periods of sobriety, and relapses]; see also In re Kimberly F.
(1997) 56 Cal.App.4th 519, 531, fn. 9 [“It is the nature of
addiction that one must be ‘clean’ for a much longer period than
120 days to show real reform.”].)
Kelly argues the juvenile court applied the wrong legal
standard by requiring her to demonstrate a “fully changed”
circumstance rather than a “changing” circumstance. The
juvenile court, however, articulated the correct standard. The
court stated: “The [section] 388 standard is well known to all of
you, which is, number one, there has to be a changed
circumstance, and number two, there has to be—if there is a
changed circumstance, I have to find it’s in the children’s best
interest to change a prior court order.” And the court properly
applied that standard at the hearing. True, the court observed
the situation was also “changing” in that Kelly was continuing to
make progress: “Even if [Kelly] had met her burden on the first
prong of showing a fully changed rather than what I believe I see
here which are changing circumstances that remain in progress
and remain changing, especially as I said it does appear in part
that the birth of the child, the youngest child, may also be further
motivating mother, which is great, but I don’t believe that that
shows a fully changed circumstance here.”4 But as discussed,
4 This part of the court’s articulation of the standard, though
it finds support in the case law (see, e.g., In re Ernesto R. (2014)
230 Cal.App.4th 219, 223 [mother’s “recent sobriety reflects
‘changing,’ not changed, circumstances”]), was not entirely
correct. As discussed, the issue is whether the change is material
or substantial, not whether the change is independent of, or part
of the process of, changing. Indeed, a circumstance that is
changing has, by definition, changed, though it may not have
17
recovery from drug addiction is an ongoing process, not
something that happens overnight.
Citing In re S.S. (2020) 55 Cal.App.5th 355, Kelly argues
“the juvenile court was ‘too cavalier given the important role
section 388 petitions play in the constitutionality of California’s
dependency scheme.’” The father in S.S. did not have stable
housing or employment at the outset of the dependency
proceedings, but asked the juvenile court to change the custody
order after he stabilized his situation. The court in S.S. did not
decide whether the juvenile court erred in denying the father’s
section 388 petition, but commented generally that a parent’s
recent change of circumstance should not be dismissed:
“Although the developments were recent, [the father] testified he
had finally obtained a permanent full-time job at higher pay as
well as health care and childcare assistance that would benefit
[the child]. He also testified he had nearly completed individual
counseling and parent education. While these developments
were new, the court’s determination that father had established
only that his circumstances were ‘changing, not changed,’ was too
cavalier given the important role section 388 petitions play in the
constitutionality of California’s dependency scheme.” (S.S., at
pp. 379-380.)
The juvenile court did not dismiss Kelly’s progress, nor was
the court “cavalier” in its approach. To the contrary, the court
diligently reviewed not only Kelly’s petition and the
Department’s response, but also the entire case file for Michael
changed enough to be a substantial or material change. Except
perhaps at infinitesimal intervals, where t2 – t1 approaches 0,
changing is a change.
18
and William, as well as the files for their siblings. The court
carefully considered all the evidence relating to the nearly four
years of dependency proceedings and concluded, in the context of
the entire history of the case, Kelly had not yet achieved a
sufficient level of stability and sobriety to constitute a significant
change of circumstance. (See In re N.F., supra, 68 Cal.App.5th at
p. 120 [“In determining whether the petitioning party has carried
his or her burden [on a section 388 petition], ‘the court may
consider the entire factual and procedural history of the case.’”].)
Given that Kelly filed her section 388 petitions only a few weeks
after she completed a substance abuse treatment program, the
evidence did not compel a different conclusion.
C. The Juvenile Court Did Not Abuse Its Discretion in
Ruling the Proposed Modifications Were Not in
Michael’s or William’s Best Interests
Even if Kelly had shown a substantial or material change
in circumstance, the juvenile court did not abuse its discretion in
ruling it was not in Michael’s or William’s best interests to return
either of them to Kelly or to reinstate family reunification
services. “[B]est interests is a complex idea” that requires the
court to consider a variety of factors. (In re Kimberly F., supra,
56 Cal.App.4th at p. 530.) Where, as here, “a section 388 petition
is filed after family reunification services have been terminated,
the juvenile court’s overriding concern is the child’s best
interests. [Citation.] The parent’s interests in the care, custody
and companionship of the child are no longer paramount; and the
focus shifts to the needs of the child for permanency and
stability.” (In re Malick T., supra, 73 Cal.App.5th at pp. 1122-
19
1123; see In re Stephanie M., supra, 7 Cal.4th at p. 317; In re
J.M., supra, 50 Cal.App.5th at p. 847.)
In her section 388 petition Kelly alleged changing custody
or resuming reunification services was in the boys’ best interest
because she visited Michael and William frequently, supported
and encouraged them, and remained bonded with them
throughout the dependency proceedings. There was, however,
plenty of contrary evidence. As discussed, during the extended
proceedings in this case Kelly called and visited the boys
sporadically, occasionally failing to call for months at a time.
And at most, Kelly visited with the boys and their siblings for a
few hours every other weekend. Though Kelly may have
sometimes offered support and encouragement, there was also
evidence she engaged in less healthy interactions. For example,
Kelly consistently favored one or two of the children when she
visited with all them. She also encouraged William to disrupt his
placement with Mr. and Mrs. U. so he could join his siblings, with
the end goal of disrupting the siblings’ permanency plans. These
types of interactions injected chaos and instability into the boys’
lives. (See In re J.C. (2014) 226 Cal.App.4th 503, 527 [“after
reunification services have terminated, a parent’s petition for
either an order returning custody or reopening reunification
efforts must establish how such a change will advance the child’s
need for permanency and stability”]; In re Anthony W. (2001)
87 Cal.App.4th 246, 251-252 [“children should not be made to
wait indefinitely for mother to become an adequate parent”].) In
contrast, Maura provided Michael and William with a stable and
loving home and was willing to adopt them. Both boys felt
comfortable in her care and, until Kelly attempted to reunify with
them in 2024, the boys wanted Maura to adopt them. (See In re
20
N.F., supra, 68 Cal.App.5th at p. 122 [juvenile court did not
abuse its discretion in denying a section 388 petition where the
child “was thriving in [the caregiver’s] stable home and was
bonded to them,” the caregivers “loved [the child] and were
committed to providing her permanency through adoption,” and
the mother’s “circumstances were unstable”].)5
DISPOSITION
The orders are affirmed.
SEGAL, J.
We concur:
MARTINEZ, P. J.
FEUER, J.
5 As stated, Kelly also appealed from the court’s legal
guardianship orders. Kelly argues only that the juvenile court
erred in making those orders because it did so after erroneously
denying her petitions under section 388. Because the court did
not err in denying the petitions under section 388, Kelly’s
challenge to the guardianship orders fails.
21
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.