CourtListener 10622889•People v. Bloxton CA2/2
Full text
Filed 7/3/25 P. v. Bloxton CA2/2
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION TWO
THE PEOPLE, B337143
Plaintiff and Respondent, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. NA018339)
v.
DANTE LAVELL BLOXTON,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County, Daniel J. Lowenthal, Judge. Affirmed.
Jonathan E. Demson, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief
Assistant Attorney General, Susan Sullivan Pithey, Assistant
Attorney General, Steven D. Matthews and Michael J. Wise,
Deputy Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
_______________________________
Dante Lavell Bloxton appeals from the trial court’s denial
of his petition for resentencing pursuant to Penal Code
section 1172.6.1 The court denied the petition after a full
evidentiary hearing, following remand by the appellate court.
Finding no error, we affirm.
BACKGROUND
I. Procedural Background
In May 1997, a jury found Bloxton guilty of first degree
murder (§ 187, subd. (a)) and four counts of second degree
robbery (§ 211). It also found true (i) a robbery-murder special
circumstance allegation (§ 190.2, subd. (a)(17)), and (ii) personal
use of a firearm (§ 12022.5, subd. (a)) and principal armed with a
firearm (§ 12022, subd. (a)(1)) enhancement allegations.
Bloxton was sentenced to life imprisonment without the
possibility of parole (LWOP), plus 15 years. Specifically, the trial
court sentenced Bloxton to a term of LWOP plus five years for the
firearm enhancement on the murder count, and a consecutive
term of 10 years for one of the second degree robbery counts
(comprised of a base term of five years plus five years for the
firearm enhancement). The court stayed or concurrently ran the
sentences for the remaining counts.
Bloxton appealed his conviction and we affirmed. (People v.
Bloxton (July 23, 1998, B113892) [nonpub. opn.].)
In 2018, Bloxton filed a petition under section 1172.6
seeking resentencing for his murder conviction. That
1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.
Effective June 30, 2022, section 1170.95 was renumbered to
section 1172.6, with no change in text. (Stats. 2022, ch. 58, § 10.)
We refer to the statute only by its current number for clarity and
convenience.
2
section provides a procedural mechanism for those previously
convicted of felony murder, among other things, to seek
resentencing. The trial court summarily denied his petition. We
affirmed based on the special circumstance true finding. (People
v. Bloxton (July 29, 2021, B307556) [nonpub. opn.].) However, our
Supreme Court granted review and transferred the case back to
us for reconsideration in light of People v. Strong (2022)
13 Cal.5th 698 (Strong). (People v. Bloxton, review granted
Oct. 13, 2021, trans. Oct. 19, 2022, S270612.)
After reconsideration, we remanded the case to the trial
court based on Strong’s holding that findings issued by a jury on
special circumstances that predated intervening Supreme Court
decisions do not warrant a summary denial of a section 1172.6
petition. Instead, such cases must proceed to an evidentiary
hearing. (People v. Bloxton (Nov. 10, 2022, B307556) [nonpub.
opn.], citing Strong, supra, 13 Cal.5th at p. 720.)
The trial court held the evidentiary hearing in January
2024. After taking the matter under submission, it denied the
petition, finding beyond a reasonable doubt that Bloxton was
guilty of first degree murder because he was a major participant
in the underlying robbery and acted with reckless indifference to
human life.
Bloxton timely appealed. (§ 1237, subd. (b); Cal. Rules of
Court, rule 8.308(a).)
II. Factual Background
At the evidentiary hearing, the prosecution entered into
evidence the record of conviction including the trial transcripts.
3
A. Evidence Presented at Trial
Our July 23, 1998 unpublished opinion affirming Bloxton’s
conviction summarized the evidence as follows:
“[S]hortly before 10 p.m. on August 22, 1993, appellant was
one of a group of young Black men who approached Alfredo
Bernal and Albert Laracuente as they used public telephones at a
Long Beach gas station. Appellant and one of his companions
were armed, one with an automatic handgun and the other with
a shotgun. Appellant had a white substance on his face.
“The man who held the handgun demanded Bernal’s
money. After taking his wallet and jewelry, the men moved him
to the side of the Bronco he was driving that evening. Bernal’s
wife, Rosalva Alverez, was dragged from the Bronco by her hair,
and her jewelry and money were taken from her.
“As Laracuente walked from the telephones back to the
Camaro he was riding in, one of the men pointed a gun at his
face. Laracuente, Bernal, Alverez, and another man who had
been seated in the Camaro were placed together near the Bronco
and forced to empty their pockets. When Laracuente made a
comment, he was told he would be shot if he did not ‘shut up.’
One of the men stated he was going to kill all of the victims
because they were Mexican.
“The robbers ransacked the Bronco, looking for additional
valuables. Turning to the Camaro, they discovered that a White
man, David Hoppes, was sitting in the back seat, and pulled him
out. As they started to walk away, one of the men said something
about shooting someone. The assailants returned to the victims
and began to beat Hoppes. He broke free and ran across the
street. One of the men, Efron Bullard, stating he was going to kill
Hoppes because he was White, shot him in the leg. Hoppes
staggered to the side walk and fell. The assailants followed, and
Bullard fired multiple shots into Hoppes’ body, killing him.
4
“Police officers who responded to the scene of the shooting
found a number of shell casings and some spent bullets near an
apartment building across the street from the gas station. As
they gathered these items, two or three women came out of the
apartment building and asked questions about the officers’
activities and findings. Several months later, Detective Dennis
Robbins prepared a photographic lineup containing appellant’s
photograph. The lineup was shown to Laracuente, who identified
appellant’s photograph as that of one of the assailants. At trial,
Bernal and Alverez identified appellant as a participant in the
offenses.
“In a custodial interview conducted on December 8, 1993,
appellant stated he and another man, Chris, acted as lookouts for
the men who committed the offenses at the gas station. According
to appellant, a man named Ed[2] shot Hoppes with a .22 rifle.
Appellant stated two others, Stevey, known as ‘Spoon,’ and a man
from Insane were also involved in the robberies. He stated he,
Stevey and the other robbers were from the 83rd Street Hoover
gang. Appellant’s street name was ‘Crim,’ short for Criminal. He
admitted he had acne cream on his face on the night of the
shooting, and claimed the shooter also wore acne cream.
Appellant stated that following the robberies and shooting, he
went into the apartment building and stayed there until two
girls, Creole and Young Creole, told him the police had left the
area.
“In a second interview conducted on the following day,
appellant stated he and his companions sneaked up to the people
at the gas station, and he went through their pockets while his
2 Bullard is sometimes referred to as “Ed.” There was no
dispute at trial that he had been identified as the shooter, and
that Bloxton was not the actual shooter.
5
companions held the victims at gunpoint. He also participated in
the search of the Bronco. Appellant admitted that he and the
others pulled Hoppes from the Camaro. He stated that Ed
wanted to kill Hoppes because he was White. Appellant admitted
that he told Ed, ‘ “I don’t care,” ’ and then participated in the
beating and went through Hoppes’ pockets, looking for money.
When Hoppes broke free and ran, Stevey chased and caught him.
Appellant followed Ed as he crossed the street and shot the
victim.
“Appellant identified himself, Ed, Stevey and a member of
the Insane Crips as participants on the crimes. He denied that
Chris played any part in the incident. Appellant admitted that
only he had acne cream on his face, and claimed only Ed had a
gun. Following the shooting, he and his companions entered the
apartment building.
“On December 10, 1993, the police found wallets and a
license plate on the roof of the building. One of the wallets
contained Bernal’s identification.
“In a third interview conducted on December 12, 1993,
appellant identified a photograph of the person he had described
as a member of the Insane Crips. He also identified a photograph
of Young Creole, and provided the police with information about
certain people who lived in the apartment building across from
the gas station. He stated again that Ed had said he wanted to
kill Hoppes because he was White. Appellant admitted having
told Ed he did not care.” (People v. Bloxton, supra, B113892.)
B. Additional Evidence Presented at the
Evidentiary Hearing
Bloxton also testified at the January 2024 evidentiary
hearing. On direct examination, he testified that the plan was
only to rob, not to murder anyone and that he was unarmed. He
was asked to join the robbery “five minutes or less” before the
6
robbery occurred. He did not know the actual shooter, Bullard,
because he (Bloxton) had just moved to the area. Bloxton was
19 years old at the time of the shooting.
During the robbery, “they”3 noticed the victim (Hoppes) in
the back seat of the Camaro, and when “they” tried to remove
him, there was an “immediate struggle” at that point. Bloxton did
not hear the actual shooter (Bullard) talk about killing everyone
because they were Mexican, and he did not hear anyone talking
about killing the passengers who were taken out of the cars.
Someone made “threats” toward Hoppes, “because when the
struggle happened with Mr. Hoppes, that’s simultaneously
threats were being made.” He testified that when he said “I don’t
care,” “I wasn’t referring to I don’t care about him dying or
anything like that. It was an argument between me and the
actual killer at the time, that I wasn’t able to articulate when I
was—when I was being interrogated.” When Hoppes ran, the
actual shooter started running, and then Bloxton ran. Before the
victim ran, the shooter was saying he wanted to shoot someone,
and Bloxton told the shooter, “ ‘No, don’t do it.’ ” Bloxton testified
he was running to try to stop the shooter from shooting, although
he also testified that he “didn’t even know he was going to shoot
the guy.”
On cross-examination, Bloxton admitted Bullard said he
“ ‘should’ ” shoot the White man (Hoppes) and Bloxton responded,
“ ‘I don’t care.’ ” Bloxton did not help Hoppes to get away or
render aid after he was shot, instead panicking and running
away.
3 As in People v. Emanuel (2025) 17 Cal.5th 867, at times it
is not clear what is meant by the use of certain pronouns during
Bloxton’s testimony at the evidentiary hearing, so we use quotes
to avoid possible misinterpretation. (Id. at p. 879, fn. 2.)
7
C. Trial Court’s Ruling
In denying the petition, the trial court noted that after
Bullard told Bloxton that Bullard was going to kill Hoppes,
“Bloxton’s response conveyed approval.” The court found beyond
a reasonable doubt that Bloxton was guilty of felony murder as a
major participant who acted with reckless indifference to human
life. The court ruled that although “the accuracy of Mr. Bloxton’s
testimony, during the evidentiary hearing, was belied by the
record of conviction, the court was moved by Mr. Bloxton’s
description of his lifelong mental health challenges” and invited
him to file a petition for resentencing under section 1172.1.
DISCUSSION
I. Standard of Review
We review the trial judge’s fact finding for substantial
evidence. (People v. Clements (2022) 75 Cal.App.5th 276, 298.)
The question when evaluating a special circumstance finding is
“whether, when evidence that is reasonable, credible, and of solid
value is viewed ‘in the light most favorable to the prosecution,
any rational trier of fact could have found the essential elements
of the allegation beyond a reasonable doubt.’ ” (People v. Clark
(2016) 63 Cal.4th 522, 610 (Clark).) The review on appeal is
different from the role of the trial court in deciding the
section 1172.6 petition in the first instance: “While the trial judge
must review all the relevant evidence, evaluate and resolve
contradictions, and make determinations as to credibility, all
under the reasonable doubt standard, our job is to determine
whether there is any substantial evidence, contradicted or
uncontradicted, to support a rational fact finder’s findings beyond
a reasonable doubt.” (Clements, at p. 298.)
8
II. Evolution of the Major Participant with Reckless
Disregard for Human Life Standard
Section 189, subdivision (e) provides that: “A participant in
the perpetration or attempted perpetration of a felony listed in
subdivision (a) in which a death occurs is liable for murder only if
one of the following is proven: [¶] . . . [¶] . . . (3) [t]he person was a
major participant in the underlying felony and acted with
reckless indifference to human life, as described in subdivision (d)
of Section 190.2.”
The language in sections 190.2, subdivision (d) and 189,
subdivision (e)(3), derives verbatim from the United States
Supreme Court’s decision in Tison v. Arizona (1987) 481 U.S. 137
(Tison), which upheld a death sentence against a challenge under
the Eighth Amendment to the United States Constitution.
(People v. Estrada (1995) 11 Cal.4th 568, 575.) The incorporation
of Tison’s standard in section 190.2 brought California’s capital
sentencing statutory law into conformity with prevailing Eighth
Amendment doctrine. (Estrada, at p. 575.)
Subsequently, the California Supreme Court provided
substantial guidance on the meaning of the two statutory phrases
“major participant” and “reckless indifference to human life.”
(People v. Banks (2015) 61 Cal.4th 788, 801–804 (Banks); Clark,
supra, 63 Cal.4th at p. 616.) It was on the basis of these two
decisions that we previously remanded this case to the trial court
to conduct the evidentiary hearing at issue here.
In Banks, the California Supreme Court explained that
“Tison and a prior decision on which it is based, Enmund v.
Florida (1982) 458 U.S. 782 [(Enmund)] collectively place conduct
on a spectrum, with felony-murder participants eligible for death
only when their involvement is substantial and they demonstrate
9
a reckless indifference to the grave risk of death created by their
actions.” (Banks, supra, 61 Cal.4th at p. 794.) “Somewhere
between them, at conduct less egregious than the Tisons’ but
more culpable than Earl Enmund’s, lies the constitutional
minimum for death eligibility.” (Id. at p. 802.) And the court
explained that Enmund’s conduct does not represent the
constitutional maximum for death ineligibility; that is, Enmund
does not represent “the most culpable one can be and yet still be
constitutionally ineligible for death, such that any variation could
move one into the death-eligible zone.” (Banks, at p. 811.)
We first detail the relevant facts in Enmund, as described
by the California Supreme Court in Banks. Enmund purchased a
calf from a man and learned in the process that the seller was in
the habit of carrying large sums of cash on his person. A few
weeks later, Enmund drove two armed confederates to the seller’s
house and waited nearby while they entered. When the seller’s
wife appeared with a gun, the confederates shot and killed both
the seller and his wife. Enmund then drove his confederates
away from the scene and helped dispose of the murder weapons.
(Banks, supra, 61 Cal.4th at p. 799.) On these facts, the Supreme
Court reversed the death sentence, finding a broad consensus
against imposing the death penalty “where the defendant did not
commit the homicide, was not present when the killing took
place, and did not participate in a plot or scheme to murder.”
(Enmund, supra, 458 U.S. at p. 795.)
In Tison, two brothers helped plan and carry out the escape
of two convicted murderers from prison—one of whom, the
defendants’ father, was serving a life sentence for killing a guard
in the course of a previous escape. The brothers brought a cache
of weapons to the prison, arming both murderers, and held at
10
gunpoint guards and visitors alike. As part of the ongoing escape,
the brothers participated in stopping and capturing “an innocent
family whose fate was then entrusted to the known killers [they]
had previously armed.” (Tison, supra, 481 U.S. at p. 151.) The
brothers robbed the family and then held them at gunpoint while
the two murderers deliberated whether the family should live or
die. The brothers then stood by while all four family members
were shot. They did not make any effort to help the victims,
although they later stated they were surprised by the shooting.
(Id. at pp. 139–141; Banks, supra, 61 Cal.4th at p. 802.)
On these facts, the United States Supreme Court upheld
the death penalty for the Tison brothers, holding that the
evidence supported a finding of major participation in the felony
committed, combined with reckless indifference to human life.
(Tison, supra, 481 U.S. at p. 158.)
In Banks, the court explained that “[w]ith respect to
conduct, Tison and Enmund establish that a defendant’s personal
involvement must be substantial, greater than the actions of an
ordinary aider and abettor to an ordinary felony murder such as
Earl Enmund.” (Banks, supra, 61 Cal.4th at p. 802.) The court
then provided guidance for future cases, holding: “Among those
factors that distinguish the Tisons from Enmund, and thus may
play a role in determining whether a defendant’s culpability is
sufficient to make him death eligible, are these: [(1)] What role
did the defendant have in planning the criminal enterprise that
led to one or more deaths? [(2)] What role did the defendant have
in supplying or using lethal weapons? [(3)] What awareness did
the defendant have of particular dangers posed by the nature of
the crime, weapons used, or past experience or conduct of the
other participants? [(4)] Was the defendant present at the scene
11
of the killing, in a position to facilitate or prevent the actual
murder, and did his or her own actions or inaction play a
particular role in the death? [and] [(5)] What did the defendant
do after lethal force was used? No one of these considerations is
necessary, nor is any one of them necessarily sufficient. All may
be weighed in determining the ultimate question, whether the
defendant’s participation ‘in criminal activities known to carry a
grave risk of death’ [citation] was sufficiently significant to be
considered ‘major.’ ” (Banks, at p. 803, fn. omitted.)
Considering these factors, the Banks court concluded that
the evidence placed the nonshooter defendant, Lovie Troy
Matthews, at the Enmund end of the Tison-Enmund spectrum as
it related to the “major participation” requirement, acting solely
as the getaway driver for an armed robbery. (Banks, supra,
61 Cal.4th at pp. 804–805.) The court explained there was no
evidence Matthews played any role in planning the robbery; no
evidence he procured weapons; no evidence any of the
participants had previously committed murder, attempted
murder, or any other violent crime; Matthews was absent from
the scene of the crime and there was no evidence that he saw or
heard the shooting; and he had no immediate role in instigating
it, nor could he have prevented it. (Id. at p. 805.) The court also
found insufficient evidence of “reckless indifference,” where
“nothing at trial supported the conclusion beyond a reasonable
doubt that Matthews knew his own actions would involve a grave
risk of death.” (Id. at p. 807.)
In Clark, the California Supreme Court concluded it need
not decide whether a nonshooter defendant was a major
participant because the evidence was insufficient to uphold a
finding that he acted with reckless indifference to human life.
12
(Clark, supra, 63 Cal.4th at p. 611.) The Clark court noted there
was both a subjective and objective element to reckless
indifference, quoting Model Penal Code section 2.02,
subdivision (2)(c): “ ‘A person acts recklessly with respect to a
material element of an offense when he consciously disregards a
substantial and unjustifiable risk that the material element
exists or will result from his conduct. The risk must be of such a
nature and degree that, considering the nature and purpose of
the actor’s conduct and the circumstances known to him, its
disregard involves a gross deviation from the standard of conduct
that a law-abiding person would observe in the actor’s
situation.’ ” (Clark, at p. 617.)
The Clark court “set out a nonexhaustive list of
considerations relevant to [the reckless indifference standard],
including [(1)] use of or awareness of the presence of a weapon or
weapons, [(2)] physical presence at the scene and opportunity to
restrain confederates or aid victims, [(3)] the duration of the
crime, [(4)] knowledge of any threat the confederates might
represent, and [(5)] efforts taken to minimize risks.” (Strong,
supra, 13 Cal.5th at p. 706, citing Clark, supra, 63 Cal.4th at
pp. 618–623.) Both Clark and Strong noted that the “major
participant” and “reckless indifference” elements significantly
overlap. (Strong, at p. 706, Clark, at p. 615.)
Clark then applied this standard and the factors spelled
out in Banks and other appellate cases to the facts of the case.
First, the prosecution evidence was that there was only one gun
at the scene, and Clark was not carrying it. (Clark, supra,
63 Cal.4th at pp. 618–619.) Second, Clark was waiting across the
parking lot when the shooting occurred. (Id. at pp. 619–620.)
Third, the robbery was planned to occur after closing time, when
13
most of the store employees were gone, and the period of
interaction between perpetrators and victims was designed to be
limited. (Id. at pp. 620–621.) Fourth, because Clark was across
the street from the scene, “[he] had no opportunity to observe
anything in [the shooter’s] actions just before the shooting that
would have indicated that [the shooter] was likely to engage in
lethal violence.” (Id. at p. 621.) Finally, there was evidence Clark
made some efforts to minimize the risks of violence, such as not
loading the gun or loading it with only one bullet; however, the
court determined Clark’s subjective risk mitigation efforts did not
necessarily foreclose an objective finding he acted with reckless
indifference. (Id. at p. 622.) Turning to the objective facts, the
court concluded that “there appear[ed] to be nothing in [Clark’s]
plan that one c[ould] point to that elevated the risk to human life
beyond those risks inherent in any armed robbery,” which is
insufficient to show reckless indifference to human life. (Id. at
p. 623.)
Most recently, in People v. Emanuel (2025) 17 Cal.5th 867
(Emanuel), the California Supreme Court applied the Banks and
Clark standard on reckless indifference to a resentencing petition
filed under section 1172.6. After detailing the history of the major
participant and reckless indifference standards, the Supreme
Court held that the facts before it did not support a finding of
reckless indifference, reversing the denial of resentencing.
Specifically, the evidence showed Emanuel set out to commit a
robbery in a public place in the middle of the afternoon. He was
not armed and he did not know his confederate was armed or
likely to use lethal force. The crime unfolded without a prolonged
period of restraint. When met with unexpected resistance from
the victim, Emanuel told his confederate, “ ‘let’s go,’ ” and began
14
to walk away. (Emanuel, at p. 896.) The court concluded his
conduct in fleeing the scene without rendering aid after the
shooting was ambiguous; it could have reflected a lack of regard
for the victim, a desire to avoid arrest, or both. (Id. at p. 893.)
However, as the remaining factors weighed against a finding of
reckless indifference, the court concluded that standing alone, the
last factor was insufficient to demonstrate reckless indifference.
(Id. at p. 891.)
III. Application of the Law to the Facts
A. Major Participant
Applying the law from these decisions and others to the
facts from the evidentiary hearing in this case, we conclude the
evidence here overwhelmingly supports a finding of reckless
indifference.
1. Use of or Awareness of the Presence of
Weapons and Knowledge of Cohort’s
Likelihood of Killing
There was evidence that Bloxton as well as another
confederate was armed, one with an automatic handgun and one
with a shotgun. Although Bloxton testified at the evidentiary
hearing that he did not have a gun, the jury and the court found
otherwise.4 And Bloxton conceded that he knew that someone
else involved in the robbery had a gun.
While there was no evidence in the record that Bloxton had
knowledge of Bullard’s likelihood of killing prior to participating
in the robbery, the evidence is uncontested that he was informed
4 “The findings of the trial court upon conflicting evidence
are conclusive.” (Emanuel, supra, 17 Cal.5th at p. 885, fn. 7,
citing Wilbur v. Wilbur (1925) 197 Cal. 1, 7.)
15
of Bullard’s likely intention to kill someone while the robbery was
in progress when Bullard said he was going to kill one of the
victims because he was White. “A defendant’s knowledge of a
confederate’s likelihood of using lethal force, which may be
evident before or during the felony, is significant to the analysis
of the defendant’s mental state.” (In re Scoggins (2020) 9 Cal.5th
667, 681 (Scoggins), citing Clark, supra, 63 Cal.4th at p. 621.)
2. Duration of the Crime
There is no evidence of the specific length of time the
robbery took from beginning to end, but the sequence of events
shows that multiple people, including most consequentially
Hoppes, were restrained for a significant period. “Courts have
considered ‘whether a murder came at the end of a prolonged
period of restraint of the victims by defendant’ in analyzing the
defendant’s culpability.” (Scoggins, supra, 9 Cal.5th at p. 680,
quoting Clark, supra, 63 Cal.4th at p. 620.)
Initially, victim Bernal was approached while at a
telephone at the gas station by a group of men, two of whom were
armed with an automatic handgun and a shotgun. After one of
the men took Bernal’s property, the robbers moved him to the
side of Bernal’s Bronco and dragged his wife from the Bronco by
her hair, taking her jewelry and money.
Around the same time, victim Laracuente also stopped with
some friends at the same gas station to make a phone call. He
and his friends were made to empty their pockets while standing
alongside Bernal and his wife. A threat was made to kill all the
Mexicans, and Laracuente was told that if he did not shut up he
was going to get shot.
After all the money had been taken from those who were
outside the cars, Bloxton and his confederates discovered Hoppes
16
in the back seat of Laracuente’s car. They took Hoppes out of the
car by force and beat him. Bullard said he was going to kill
Hoppes because he was White. Bloxton said, “I don’t care.” After
Hoppes was beaten, he began to run. While he was crossing the
street, Bullard shot him in the leg. As Hoppes staggered to the
sidewalk and collapsed, Bullard and Bloxton followed, and
Bullard shot him. Then Bloxton and his confederates all fled.
From this summary it is apparent the robbery was
significant enough in duration to have several different parts,
first robbing the Bernal party and then the Laracuente party,
including those who were making the phone calls and those who
were waiting in the cars, removing them from the vehicles and
holding them at gunpoint, including a threat to kill all the
Mexicans, and another to shoot Laracuente. The crime did not
stop there. It continued when Hoppes was spotted in the back
seat of one of the cars, dragged out, and beaten; and when
Bullard stated his intention to shoot Hoppes. At some point,
Hoppes got up, ran across the street, and collapsed, with a shot
fired as he was running, and more shots fired after his collapse.
Again, while Bloxton denied some of the above conduct at
the evidentiary hearing, the trial court found his testimony was
“belied” by the record. Indeed, some of Bloxton’s testimony at the
evidentiary hearing was also internally inconsistent: on the one
hand, he testified he tried to stop Bullard from shooting both by
saying “no, don’t do it” and by running after him; on the other
hand, he testified he did not know Bullard was going to shoot
Hoppes.
Thus, in contrast to the facts in Banks, Clark, Scoggins and
Emanuel, the shooting here was not simply a short encounter but
a series of different events getting progressively more violent. It
17
included a period of restraint of the victims at gunpoint, with
three threats to use violence over the course of the robbery.
3. Efforts Taken to Minimize the Risk of
Violence
Contrasted with Clark, Banks, Scoggins and Emanuel, the
record here does not reflect Bloxton made efforts either in
advance or as the robbery progressed to minimize the risks of
violence. (Cf. Emanuel, supra, 17 Cal.5th at p. 895 [Emanuel
unarmed during robbery at a public park in the middle of the
afternoon]; Scoggins, supra, 9 Cal.5th at p. 683 [Scoggins’s plan
was for a daytime confrontation in a public parking lot without
the use of weapons]; Clark, supra, 63 Cal.4th at pp. 621–623
[Clark and his confederates waited until after a store was closed
before they began their robbery of the store, there were not
supposed to be any bullets in the gun, and the gun only had one
bullet in it]; Banks, supra, 61 Cal.4th at p. 811 [no evidence
Matthews knew there would be a guard present or that he would
be armed].)
Here, the evidence shows that Bloxton was asked to join in
a robbery shortly before it was to begin. There is no evidence he
played any role in its planning. So while we cannot evaluate
whether Bloxton attempted in advance to minimize the risks
involved, the evidence shows that he willingly participated in a
nighttime robbery at a little before 10:00 p.m. at a gas station. A
gas station is a place open to the public, but the record is not
clear as to how many people were, or were likely to be, present at
the time of the incident. The jury also found that Bloxton was
armed with a gun, as was Bullard. There was no evidence that
either gun was only for show; in fact, multiple shots were fired
and a number of shell casings and spent bullets were recovered.
18
4. Physical Presence at the Scene and
Opportunity to Restrain Confederates or
Aid Victims
Finally, it is uncontested that Bloxton was personally
present during the entirety of the robbery, that he heard Bullard
say he should kill Hoppes because Hoppes was White, and that
Bloxton responded, “I don’t care.”5
The California Supreme Court could have been writing
about this case when it held: “ ‘Proximity to the murder and the
events leading up to it may be particularly significant where . . .
the murder is a culmination or a foreseeable result of several
intermediate steps, or where the [co-]participant who personally
commits the murder exhibits behavior tending to suggest a
willingness to use lethal force. In such cases, “the defendant’s
presence allows him to observe his cohorts so that it is fair to
conclude that he shared in their actions and mental state. . . .
[Moreover,] the defendant’s presence gives him an opportunity to
act as a restraining influence on murderous cohorts. If the
defendant fails to act as a restraining influence, then the
defendant is arguably more at fault for the resulting murders.” ’ ”
(Emanuel, supra, 17 Cal.5th at p. 889, quoting Clark, supra,
63 Cal.4th at p. 619.)
Bloxton was personally present and aware of the risk of
impending lethal violence once Bullard announced his intention
to shoot Hoppes and could have either aided Hoppes in fleeing or
tried to restrain Bullard. (Cf. Clark, supra, 63 Cal.4th at p. 621
5 While Bloxton testified during the evidentiary hearing that
he did not mean “I don’t care about him dying,” he never
explained what he did mean. Moreover, the trial court’s finding
on conflicting evidence is binding.
19
[“Nor did defendant have an opportunity to observe [the
shooter]’s response to [the victim’s] unanticipated appearance or
to intervene to prevent her killing.”].) This weighs heavily in
support of finding reckless indifference.
It is also uncontested that Bloxton followed Bullard in
running after Hoppes (although Bloxton disputed why he ran)
and that, after Bullard shot Hoppes, Bloxton ran away without
aiding Hoppes. We assign little weight to these facts and consider
them neutral, since they are ambiguous and could be interpreted
merely as an attempt “ ‘to flee the scene as quickly as possible to
avoid arrest, whether or not he understood the extent of [the
victim’s] injuries.’ ” (Emanuel, supra, 17 Cal.5th at p. 894.)
We decline to adopt either party’s argument, made prior to
the Supreme Court’s analysis in Emanuel, about whether Bloxton
took enough steps to prevent the shooting, or was in a position to
have prevented the shooting. As the Emanuel court said: “The
essential question underpinning our analysis is not whether [the
nonshooter] did enough to stop [the killer’s] unplanned act of
violence; it is whether [the nonshooter] acted with the requisite
mens rea, i.e., reckless indifference to human life. The focus
should not be on the ultimate efficacy of his actions, but on what
his actions reveal about his mental state.” (Emanuel, supra,
17 Cal.5th at p. 891.)
Thus, while a rapidly unfolding crime may not provide
sufficient time to support a finding of reckless indifference, such
a finding can be made even when the opportunity to do so is brief,
in cases where the shooters “made their intentions clear,
affording each defendant ‘the time to observe and react before the
murder.’ ” (Emanuel, supra, 17 Cal.5th at p. 892, quoting In re
Loza (2017) 10 Cal.App.5th 38, 53.) Here, similar to Loza and In
20
re McDowell (2020) 55 Cal.App.5th 999, 1014, the shooter made
his intention clear and Bloxton had an opportunity to say or do
something to deescalate the situation. Instead, he made his
indifference (“I don’t care”) clear.
5. Bloxton’s Age
Bloxton argues his age at the time of the crime, 18 or 19,6
should also be considered as a factor in determining whether he
acted with reckless indifference. This was mentioned only
conclusorily at the evidentiary hearing, at which his attorney
argued: “I believe [Bloxton] was 19 years old at the time of this
incident. His youth is a factor.” The age factor was not mentioned
at all in Bloxton’s evidentiary brief before the trial court, which
focused appropriately on the factors in Banks and Clark.
While the California Supreme Court has not yet addressed
this factor, some appellate courts have held that a defendant’s
youth is a relevant factor in determining whether the defendant
acted with reckless indifference to human life. (Emanuel, supra,
supra, 17 Cal.5th at p. 885, fn. 6, citing cases.) For example, in
People v. Pittman (2023) 96 Cal.App.5th 400, 416–417, the court
acknowledged numerous appellate decisions treating a
defendant’s youth, defined roughly as 25 years or younger, as a
factor within the totality of the circumstances relevant to the
requisite mental state for felony murder. Those cases reason that,
in light of our evolving understanding of adolescent brain
development, “it is far from clear [whether a juvenile could be]
actually aware ‘of particular dangers posed by the nature of the
6 The record is conflicting on this point. While Bloxton
testified that he was 19 at the time of the crime, his birthdate as
recorded on other documents would indicate that he was 18.
21
crime, weapons used, or past experience or conduct of the other
participants.’ ” (People v. Harris (2021) 60 Cal.App.5th 939, 960.)
On the other hand, the United States Supreme Court in
Tison affirmed a death sentence for two brothers who were
19 and 20 at the time of a crime in which they were determined
to be major participants acting with reckless indifference. (Tison,
supra, 481 U.S. at pp. 142, 151–152, 158.)
Moreover, some courts have concluded that age is more
appropriately considered in connection with the question of
parole and when the individual should be released. (People v.
Mitchell (2022) 81 Cal.App.5th 575, 595.) Indeed, that is what the
trial court thought at the end of the evidentiary hearing here,
after finding sufficient evidence of reckless indifference: “[T]he
court was moved by Mr. Bloxton’s description of his lifelong
mental health challenges. Because of Mr. Bloxton’s history of
mental illness . . . , age at the time of the offense, and length of
incarceration, the court invites him to file a petition for
resentencing under . . . Section 1172.1.”
We need not reach that issue here because, even assuming
that age is a proper factor to be considered, it would be the only
factor mitigating against a finding of reckless indifference. Given
the overwhelming evidence of the necessary mens rea in this
case, we would not find that consideration of Bloxton’s age alone
is strong enough to counter all the other factors discussed above.
6. The Totality of the Circumstances
In sum, all but one of the above factors weigh in favor of a
finding of deliberate indifference. The factor of age—which has
not yet been endorsed by our Supreme Court—is the only one
that would weigh against a finding of reckless indifference. This
is indeed the rare case in which the evidence supplies
22
information about the defendant’s actual state of mind between
the time that the killer stated his intent or plan to potentially kill
the victim, and the time that the killing took place. Bloxton
“d[id]n’t care.”
Bloxton claims this case is analogous to People v.
Underwood (2024) 99 Cal.App.5th 303 (Underwood), but we
disagree. While in both cases the nonkiller defendants only
intended at the outset to participate in a robbery, not a murder,
there are key differences. First, there was no evidence in
Underwood that the nonkiller defendant (Underwood) knew that
his confederate had a weapon (knife), and Underwood himself
was unarmed. (Id. at p. 317.) Second, the duration of the incident
was only “a few minutes” from the time Underwood and his
confederate approached the victim to the time they fled. (Id. at
p. 318.) The apparent commonality that Bloxton points to is that,
despite Underwood’s presence at the scene, the court found the
absence of reckless indifference.
In Underwood, the nonkiller defendant (Underwood) told
the police that when the killer threatened to kill the victim,
Underwood tried to stop him, but stumbled and fell on his knees,
failing to prevent the murder. (Underwood, supra, 99 Cal.App.5th
at p. 310.)7 As related to Underwood’s presence at the murder,
the court held: “Underwood was not present for a long sequence
of events that culminated in murder. The mugging and stabbing
unfolded within a few minutes—in a ‘blink of an eye’ according to
[one witness] . . . . [¶] . . . [¶] . . . Considering the totality of the
7 The Court of Appeal in Underwood noted that the trial
court did not believe Underwood’s testimony that he tried to stop
the killer. (Underwood, supra, 99 Cal.App.5th at p. 315.)
23
circumstances, the evidence shows Underwood participated in a
crime of opportunity that was spontaneous and happened
quickly.” (Id. at pp. 320–321.)
That is not this case. Without revisiting all the factors
above, the crime at issue here was much more prolonged and
included several periods of restraint. The killing of Hoppes did
not occur in the “blink of an eye” but involved dragging him out of
a car, beating him, Bullard proposing to kill Hoppes, and then
Hoppes fleeing across the street. With at least three factors
radically different, Underwood does not support reversal in this
case.
DISPOSITION
The order is affirmed.
RICHARDSON, J.
WE CONCUR:
LUI, P. J.
ASHMANN-GERST, J.
24
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.