CourtListener 10618924•People v. Hartwell CA4/1
Full text
Filed 6/27/25 P. v. Hartwell CA4/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THE PEOPLE, D085452
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v. (Super. Ct. No. INF2300006)
TEDDY KAISER HARTWELL,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Riverside County,
Charles J. Koosed, Judge. Affirmed.
Kenneth H. Nordin, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief Attorney
General, Charles C. Ragland, Assistant Attorney General, Melissa Mandel
and Tami Falkenstein Hennick, Deputy Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and
Respondent.
INTRODUCTION
A jury convicted appellant Teddy Hartwell of burglarizing the homes of
six families over a period of several weeks in April 2021. Among the evidence
linking Hartwell to the burglaries were shoe prints found at or near some of
the victims’ homes that matched shoes found in Hartwell’s vehicle, as well as
various victims’ personal property that officers found in the car and
Hartwell’s home following his arrest.
On appeal, Hartwell contends the trial court erred in denying his
motion to suppress statements he made at the police station after his arrest
that tended to place him near some of the crime scenes at the time of the
burglaries. According to Hartwell, the officer violated his Miranda1 rights by
failing to either end the interview or ask solely clarifying questions when
Hartwell made a reference to an attorney early in the interview. Hartwell
also argues the judgment must be reversed because the prosecutor
erroneously presented evidence that made mention of his use of a gun in
connection with evidence of prior similar crimes admitted under Evidence
Code section 1101, subdivision (b), despite the trial court’s ruling prohibiting
any reference to firearms in connection with that evidence.
We find no merit in Hartwell’s arguments and therefore affirm the
judgment.
1 Miranda v. Arizona (1966) 384 U.S. 436 (Miranda).
2
I.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. Factual Background
Hartwell was charged with six counts of residential burglary stemming
from six separate home invasions that took place in the Rancho Mirage area
of Riverside County during April 2021. The evidence as to each burglary
count is recounted below, along with a summary of additional evidence
admitted at trial.
1. The April 6 Burglary (Count 1)
Diana J. lived with her husband Douglas J. in a gated community in
Rancho Mirage. On the morning of April 6, 2021, they awoke to discover
someone had been inside their home overnight and rummaged through their
things. They found the door to their garage left open, a car door was open,
cupboards throughout the home were open, and someone had cut a hole in
one of their screen doors. The couples’ home security system indicated that
the interior door between the garage and laundry room had been left ajar at
2:00 a.m.
Among the items missing from their home were Diana’s purse, a
jewelry box, and Douglas’s money clip, which had cash, credit cards, and a
driver’s license in it. The jewelry box was found dumped outside, as was
Diana’s purse. Her cash, credit cards, driver’s license, and coin purse were
missing from the purse, however. Diana was alerted by email from one of her
credit card issuers that someone had attempted to use a credit card at a gas
station in Indio, California at 2:17 a.m. on April 6, 2021.
3
Police officers were able to obtain surveillance video from the gas
station where someone attempted to use Diana’s credit card. At the time
Diana’s credit card was declined at a pump, the video showed a dark-colored
vehicle at the gas station. A Chevrolet Malibu with license plate 8RZF371
was identified by a license plate reader located at an intersection
approximately one mile from the victims’ home at approximately 11:33 p.m.
on April 5, 2021. Investigators determined the Malibu had been rented by
someone named Sandra Barton, and Hartwell was listed as an additional
driver on the rental contract.
2. The April 7 Burglary (Count 2)
Heather P. and Herbert N.’s home in a gated community in Rancho
Mirage was burglarized overnight between April 7 and April 8, 2021.
Heather and Herbert found the drawers in a closet pulled out and turned
upside down. An expensive wallet containing $1,000 cash had been taken out
of Heather’s purse, and a jeweled watch band was separated from the watch
face and taken. In addition, a small handgun was taken.
Security footage from the nearby Westin Mission Hills showed the
Chevrolet Malibu entering the gated community where Heather and Herbert
lived at 11:44 p.m. on April 7 and leaving at about 12:22 a.m. on April 8. The
Malibu was also spotted by a license plate reader near the gated community
at 11:34 p.m. on April 7.
3. The First April 15 Burglary (Count 3)
On April 15, 2021, a Riverside sheriff’s community service officer was
dispatched to an area in Rancho Mirage in response to a call about women’s
purses that were found in a bush. The bush was located near the home of
Margie and Donald B., and Margie identified one of the purses as belonging
to her. The credit cards that had been inside the purse were missing.
4
Officers conducted an inspection of the couple’s residence and determined
that an intruder had entered the home through a sliding door that opens to
an area abutting a golf course.
4. The Second April 15 Burglary (Count 4)
That same morning, April 15, 2021, John and Michelle B., who lived on
the same street as Margie and Donald, awoke to find their home had also
been burglarized overnight. Their patio screen door was left partially open,
and drawers were open in most of the rooms, including the room in which the
couple had been sleeping. A cell phone and gold earrings were missing.
A license plate reader recorded the Malibu approximately a mile from
John and Michelle’s home at about 12:15 a.m. the morning of April 15, 2021.
And surveillance video from a home not far from both John and Michelle’s
home and Margie and Donald’s home showed a Malibu parked near the
victims’ residences at around 12:45 a.m. on April 15, 2021.
5. The April 29 Burglary (Count 5)
On the night of April 29, 2021, Dennis and Linda B. were hosting their
daughter Denise and her husband Ernesto for an overnight visit at their
home in a gated community in Rancho Mirage. At some point after 10:00
p.m., Ernesto was getting ready for bed and he walked into the kitchen to get
a glass of water. At that point, Ernesto saw a man wearing a black hoodie
and a mask going through things on the kitchen counter. Ernesto yelled at
the man and tried to grab him, but the man was able to escape through a
sliding door while carrying away Linda’s purse. In addition, Dennis’s money
clip, which had approximately $400 cash in it, was missing from a bowl in the
kitchen.
5
6. The Early Morning April 30 Burglary (Count 6)
Renee S. and Sanford A. lived just down the street from Dennis and
Linda in the same gated community. In the early morning hours of April 30,
2021, Renee awoke to find the sliding back door open and her purse missing.
Later that day, someone found Renee’s purse on the golf course on which her
home was located. It was missing $20.
Arturo R. lived across the street from Renee and Sanford. At around
10:40 p.m. the night of April 29, 2021, his security system indicated there
was movement around his home. Arturo checked his security cameras and
saw an unknown person, wearing a mask and gloves, trying to gain entry to
his home. Arturo called police, and an officer responded to the scene. The
officer found that two screens had been removed from two windows, and the
screen to the sliding glass door to the patio was left open, but the door itself
was still closed and locked. The officer found a shoeprint on an air
conditioning unit located next to one of the windows where a screen had been
removed.
7. A Security Officer Witnesses Unusual Activity On April 29
Overnight between April 29 and 30, Angelica M. was working as a
security guard at the Forest Lawn Mortuary, which also had a mini-storage
business on site. The mortuary and mini-storage business were located
across the street from the homes burglarized or almost burglarized the night
of April 29 and early morning of April 30.
At 10:22 p.m. on April 29, Angelica noticed a silver Ford Mustang
parked in the parking lot of the mini-storage business. She found it unusual
because it was “way past the hour for any vehicle to be there normally.” She
walked around the vehicle and looked to see if anyone was near it because
she planned to ask the individual to leave. Angelica took photographs of the
6
vehicle, noted the license plate number, and then left to continue her patrol.
At 11:43 p.m., Angelica returned to where the Mustang was parked. This
time she saw an individual “with” the Mustang. She advised the man he was
on private property and needed to leave, and he did so without incident.
An officer who had responded to the burglary calls in the area
inspected the area where Angelica had seen the Mustang parked. The officer
observed shoe impressions in a sandy area next to where the Mustang had
been. The shoeprints that were left in the mini-storage parking area were
later matched with the shoeprint that had been left on the air conditioning
unit at Arturo’s home. They also matched shoeprints officers found in a wash
behind the homes that were burglarized or had suffered an attempted
burglary in the overnight hours between April 29 and April 30.
8. Hartwell’s Arrest and Further Investigation
At approximately 2:00 a.m. on April 30, 2024, a Palm Springs police
sergeant recognized a silver Mustang as one for which a “BOLO” or “be on the
look out” had been issued. The Mustang’s driver had been identified as the
suspect in connection with crimes that had been committed in the Riverside
Sheriff’s jurisdiction. The police sergeant conducted a traffic stop of
Hartwell, the Mustang’s driver, as he was leaving a gas station. The officers
initially held Hartwell at gunpoint, and he complied with their directions.
The Palm Springs police then turned him over to the Riverside Sheriff’s
office.
Riverside County Sheriff’s Department officers conducted a search of
the Mustang pursuant to a warrant. Officers found two money clip wallets in
the vehicle, as well as a backpack containing a tablet and cellular phone. A
black ski-mask and shoes were found in the vehicle’s trunk. The shoes
matched the footprints officers had found on the air conditioning unit, in the
7
wash behind the burglarized homes, and in the mini-storage parking lot near
the burglarized homes where Hartwell’s Mustang had been parked.
When investigators searched Hartwell’s apartment, they recovered the
wallet of one of the burglary victims, as well as a debit card belonging to
another victim.
9. Hartwell’s Prior Convictions for Similar Offenses
On January 22, 2016, victim Rodney T. was living in Palm Springs
when he awoke to find Hartwell standing in his kitchen. Hartwell was
dressed in black jeans and a black hoodie, and wore a black bandana across
his face. Rodney began yelling and ran toward Hartwell. Hartwell grabbed
Rodney’s wallet and cell phone off the counter and ran out the back door.
Rodney began chasing Hartwell, but eventually gave up and called 911. At
trial, the parties stipulated to informing the jury the trial court had “taken
judicial notice that on July 11th, 2016, Teddy Hartwell pled guilty in
Riverside County case Number INF1670035 to entering a residence [in Palm
Springs and] committing a theft on January 22nd, 2016.”
On the morning of March 10, 2016, a Riverside Sheriff’s deputy
responded to a call from victim Monica Y. about a burglary that had taken
place in the City of Rancho Mirage. Monica believed someone had entered
her home and taken some of her belongings. The deputy observed an open
window and open door in the house, and then found some of Monica’s
belongings, including a purse, wallet, drawer from a jewelry box, behind a
wall located at the rear of her residence. The parties stipulated to informing
the jury the trial court had “taken judicial notice of the fact that on July 11th
of 2016, Teddy Hartwell pled guilty in Riverside County Case Number
INF1670121 to entering the residence [in Rancho Mirage], and committing a
theft on March 10th of 2016.”
8
B. Procedural Background
Hartwell was charged by amended complaint with six counts of
residential burglary (Pen. Code,2 § 459; counts 1-6).3 The operative charging
document also alleged that someone other than an accomplice was present in
the residences during the commission of the crimes (§ 667.5, subd. (c)(21)),
and that Hartwell had suffered two prior strike convictions (§§ 667, subds.
(c), (e)(1); 1170.12, subd. (c)(1)) and two serious felony priors (§ 667, subd.
(a)). The existence of several aggravating factors was also alleged.
A jury trial on the amended complaint commenced in late August 2023.
The jury convicted Hartwell on all six burglary counts on September 5, 2023.
He admitted the prior conviction allegations, as well as the aggravating
factor allegations.
On November 3, 2023, the trial court sentenced Hartwell to a total
term of 150 years to life. That term was composed of six indeterminate terms
of 25 years to life on counts 1 through 6, plus a concurrent determinate term
of 32 months on count 7. The court struck punishment for the serious felony
prior allegations.
2 Further statutory references are to the Penal Code unless otherwise
indicated.
3 Hartwell was originally charged with six counts of residential burglary
(counts 1-6) and one count of unlawfully receiving stolen property (§ 496,
subd. (a); count 7). Hartwell was tried on those seven counts in June 2023.
The jury convicted Hartwell on the receiving stolen property count but was
unable to reach unanimous verdicts on the six burglary counts. The
information was subsequently amended, but continued to charge the six
counts of residential burglary and still erroneously included the seventh
count for receiving stolen property, despite the fact that Hartwell had been
convicted on that count.
9
II.
DISCUSSION
A. The Trial Court Did Not Err in Denying Hartwell’s Motion to Suppress
Hartwell contends the trial court erred in denying his motion to
suppress his police station interview with Riverside County Sheriff’s
Sergeant James Mills. According to Hartwell, the trial court improperly
analyzed the issue involved in the motion to suppress by failing to conclude
that Sergeant Mills had a duty to clarify what Hartwell contends was an
“initial invocation of his right to counsel under Miranda.” As we explain, we
disagree with the premise of Hartwell’s argument and conclude the trial
court ruled properly on Hartwell’s motion to suppress.
1. Additional Background
During trial, defense counsel moved to exclude Hartwell’s interview
with Sergeant Mills, arguing Hartwell invoked his right to have counsel
present at the interrogation before Sergeant Mills advised him of his
Miranda rights. The court held a hearing under Evidence Code section 402
to learn more about the underlying facts of the interview. Sergeant Mills
testified, and the court admitted the audio of Sergeant Mills’s interview with
Hartwell, as well as a transcript of the interview.
Sergeant Mills testified that he interviewed Hartwell on April 30, 2021,
following Hartwell’s arrest. When Sergeant Mills initially introduced himself
by name to Hartwell, he asked, “How you holding up so far, man?” Hartwell
began complaining about his arrest and about “sitting in the car for about
two hours and then get[ting to the station] and it’s the same shit.” Sergeant
Mills then removed Hartwell’s restraints, and somewhat jokingly engaged
10
with Hartwell about the fact that Hartwell was no longer restrained.4
Hartwell declined Mills’s offer of food, saying “I’m not even hungry,” but
accepted the offer of coffee. Mills then introduced himself to Hartwell,
indicating he “work[s] for the county obviously.” Mills told Hartwell he had
been called into the station because of a call that had been made to police
about a suspicious person. Mills then asked Hartwell some basic
biographical information, such as his full name, what name he goes by, and
his birthdate.
After Hartwell provided his birthdate, Mills repeated it back to
Hartwell, and Hartwell then said, “Yeah. ‘Cause, yeah, I was, I was getting
pissed dude to where I was gonna,—the other guy was kinda rude and I was
gonna tell him like dude, if you guys can’t tell me why I’m here, if I’m getting
arrested, then I’m gonna call my dad so I can call my lawyer just to get the
fuck out of here, then you guys can let me know. I was getting frustrated
dude.”5 As Hartwell was talking, Mills made various statements indicating
he was listening to Hartwell, such as “Yeah,” and “I got you, man,” and
“Yeah. I got you.”
4 For example, Mills said at one point, “You know I don’t recommend
trying to run away when you’re in the police station. We’ve had people do it
in the past—[¶] . . . [¶] yeah. It doesn’t, it doesn’t work out too well, you
know. Typically, by the time you’re in the police station, you’re not getting
away too much. You know what I mean?”
5 The written transcript of the interview varies in minor, non-
substantive ways from the formulation we quote here, which is based on our
review of the audio recording of the interview. Because the court admonished
the jury that the audio recording constituted the evidence of Hartwell’s
interview, where there are slight differences between the audio recording and
the written transcript, we rely the audio recording.
11
After Hartwell said, “I was getting frustrated, dude,” Mills responded,
“And, and, and, yeah, I, I understand that. You know, you, you had a long
night. Nobody likes being put in the back of a cop car, drug around, not told
any fuckin’ questions—" Hartwell then said, “[D]ude, it was just the way it
happened, dude.”
Hartwell continued to relate how his night had been interrupted by his
arrest, and complaining about how officers had drawn guns on him and told
him not to “do nothing stupid or we’ll, we’ll shoot.” Hartwell mumbled, while
Mills apologized about how things had occurred and then changed the subject
to ask Hartwell where he was residing. Mills continued to talk with
Hartwell, making small talk and asking him biographical information. Mills
eventually began to ask Hartwell about the kind of car he was currently
driving, as well as other cars he had been driving recently.
Mills then asked if Hartwell had ever been arrested before, and
Hartwell conceded had had just “got off parole and all that.” At that point,
Mills explained, “So, but because you, you’ve been arrested before, you know,
before I ask questions, because right now you’re not free to go. Okay. Um, I
think they made that pretty obvious when with the ways your night has gone
so far. So I would like to get some clarity to this but before I ask you
questions, because you’re not free to go, I have to advise you of your Miranda
rights. Do you recall what those are?” Hartwell, responded, “Yeah.” Mills
further explained, “So right now, technically, you are in custody and then I’m
going to ask you questions about what happened tonight. So that is where
Miranda applies, so I have to read you these things and then after we’re done
reading those, like I said, my whole goal here is to just get some clarity for
both of us. Okay. So, after I’m done reading you those, then we’ll go from
there. Obviously you know your options ‘cause like you said, you’ve been
12
down this road before, you know. And you know how the process will go
either way.”
Before Mills was able to read Hartwell his Miranda advisements,
however, Hartwell interrupted and asked, “[C]ould I say something? You
said that someone called and said I, I didn’t belong . . . .” Mills explained that
police had been called to check on some homes where “somebody” had been
where they did not belong. He then advised Hartwell of his rights under
Miranda, and asked Hartwell whether he understood them. Hartwell
indicated he did, and Mills said, “Okay. So, you were telling me you were at
the casino.” Hartwell proceeded to answer Mills’s questions without
hesitation.6
Hartwell did not confess to the burglaries during the interrogation.
However, he did admit to certain facts that placed him in the areas where the
crimes occurred, thereby tending to corroborate other evidence investigators
had obtained that indicated his involvement in the crimes. For example,
Hartwell answered questions about why the car he had been driving was
recorded on traffic cameras near some of the burglarized homes during the
times those burglaries occurred. Hartwell said he was in the area to go
swimming, thereby effectively conceding he was near some of the victims’
homes at the time of the crimes.
At the end of the evidentiary hearing, defense counsel argued that
Hartwell had invoked his right to counsel when he said he wanted to call his
dad in order to call his lawyer. According to defense counsel, Sergeant Mills
should have at that point either allowed Hartwell to call his dad or sought
6 The transcript of this conversation from the point immediately after Mills
gave the Miranda advisements through its conclusion comprises approximately
80 pages.
13
clarification from him. Defense counsel also asserted that Hartwell did not
knowingly, willingly, or intelligently waive his rights following Sergeant
Mills’s Miranda admonition. According to counsel, Hartwell’s “kind of more
of a uh-huh kind of reply” was insufficient to register a knowing and
intelligent waiver of those rights. For those reasons, trial counsel argued, all
statements Hartwell made to Sergeant Mills should have been suppressed.
The prosecutor argued that Miranda rights cannot be asserted prior to
the commencement of an interrogation and statements like the one Hartwell
made have been held to be an insufficient invocation of an individual’s
Miranda rights.
The trial court determined Hartwell’s purported invocation was
ambiguous, explaining:
“I think he could have invoked [Miranda] at that time, but
I think his invocation is ambiguous. It’s not unambiguous,
and here’s why. . . . Case law talks about invoking
Miranda in an unambiguous way to the point where the
officer would reasonably understand that that’s what the
defendant is doing, and it has to be with respect to
Miranda. And here’s the nuance in all of this. He’s
not—he’s not saying he wants a lawyer before talking to
anybody. He’s saying he wants a lawyer to get out of jail.
That’s—that’s a huge distinction under case law.
[¶] . . . . It’s very clear on page 6, starting at line 18 when
the defendant says ‘I want to call my dad so I can call my
lawyer.’ Mills says, ‘I got you, man.’ Defendant says, “Just
to get the fuck out of here.’ That had nothing to do with
Miranda. And there’s cases that—pretty close on point
that it needs to be, otherwise it’s ambiguous.”
14
The court explained that it understood the law as requiring a request
for counsel to be “unambiguous in a very particular sense,” such “that a
reasonable officer would know that the defendant’s request for counsel was
unequivocal for purposes of interrogation.” The court discussed several cases
and then repeated that Hartwell’s statement was ambiguous, and,
“[m]oreover, he continue[d] to talk,” thereby indicating he was not interested
in having an attorney present in order to talk with Mills. The court also
ruled that Sergeant Mills gave the appropriate Miranda warnings, and the
record sufficiently reflected Hartwell understood his rights and waived them.
The trial court admitted Hartwell’s full interview with Mills.
2. Analysis
Hartwell contends that by saying the words “so I can call my lawyer” in
the earliest stages of his conversation with Mills he ambiguously invoked his
right to the assistance of an attorney under Miranda, requiring the
suppression of his statements to Mills. According to Hartwell, under the rule
announced in United States v. Rodriguez (2008) 518 F.3d 1072, 1080
(Rodriguez) and People v. Duff (2014) 58 Cal.4th 527 (Duff), Mills had only
two options available to him once Hartwell made an ambiguous invocation of
the right to have counsel present during the interview: (1) stop talking with
Hartwell, or (2) ask only clarifying questions to better ascertain whether
Hartwell was indeed invoking his Miranda right to have an attorney present
during his interrogation. According to Hartwell, because Mills continued to
talk with him instead of doing one of those two things, anything said after
this invocation should have been suppressed. As we explain, we disagree
with Hartwell’s contention.
15
“Concerned that ‘without proper safeguards the process of in-custody
interrogation of persons suspected or accused of crime contains inherently
compelling pressures’ that might lead an accused person to make statements
in derogation of his or her Fifth Amendment privilege against self-
incrimination, the United States Supreme Court, in Miranda, required law
enforcement agencies to advise the accused of certain rights and to honor the
accused's exercise of those rights. (Miranda, supra, 384 U.S. at p. 467.)
Specifically, the accused must be warned ‘prior to any questioning that he
has the right to remain silent, that anything he says can be used against him
in a court of law, that he has the right to the presence of an attorney, and
that if he cannot afford an attorney, one will be appointed for him prior to
any questioning if he so desires.’ ” (People v. Gonzalez (2005) 34 Cal.4th
1111, 1122 (Gonzalez).)
“In Edwards v. Arizona (1981) 451 U.S. 477, 101 S.Ct. 1880, 68 L.Ed.2d
378 [(Edwards)], the court added ‘a second layer of prophylaxis for the
Miranda right to counsel.’ ” (Gonzalez, supra, 34 Cal.4th at p. 1122.)
Edwards held that “an accused, . . . having expressed his desire to deal with
the police only through counsel, is not subject to further interrogation by the
authorities until counsel has been made available to him, unless the accused
himself initiates further communication, exchanges, or conversations with
the police.” (Edwards, supra, 451 U.S. at pp. 484–485.)
A statement obtained in violation of a suspect's Miranda rights may
not be admitted to establish guilt in a criminal case. (People v. Sims (1993) 5
Cal.4th 405, 440.) “In reviewing the trial court's denial of a suppression
motion on Miranda and involuntariness grounds, ‘ “ ‘we accept the trial
court's resolution of disputed facts and inferences, and its evaluations of
credibility, if supported by substantial evidence. We independently
16
determine from the undisputed facts and the facts properly found by the trial
court whether the challenged statement was illegally obtained.’ ” ’
[Citations.] Where . . . an interview is recorded, [however,] the facts
surrounding the admission or confession are undisputed and we may apply
independent review.” (Duff, supra, 58 Cal.4th at p. 551.) California courts
review issues concerning the suppression of a defendant’s statements on
Miranda grounds under federal constitutional standards. (People v. Nelson
(2012) 53 Cal.4th 367, 374.)
Hartwell’s contention that his comment about calling his father so he
could call his lawyer constituted an ambiguous invocation of his right to have
an attorney present at the interrogation requires consideration of the rules
for interpreting asserted invocations of Miranda’s right to counsel. The
purpose of the Miranda-Edwards guarantee is to “protect . . . the suspect’s
‘desire to deal with the police only through counsel.’ ” (McNeil v. Wisconsin
(1991) 501 U.S. 171, 178 (McNeil), quoting Edwards, supra, 451 U.S. at
p. 484.) Because of this, the invocation of one’s right to counsel for purposes
of Miranda’s protections occurs “only when the suspect ‘ha[s] expressed’ his
wish for the particular sort of lawyerly assistance that is the subject of
Miranda.” (McNeil, at p. 178.) Consequently, an invocation of Miranda’s
protections “requires, at a minimum, some statement that can reasonably be
construed to be an expression of a desire for the assistance of an attorney in
dealing with custodial interrogation by the police.” (Ibid., italics added.)
When considering whether a suspect has invoked the right to
counsel—i.e., whether he has expressed a desire for the “particular sort of
lawyerly assistance” (McNeil, supra, 501. U.S. at p. 178) addressed by
Miranda—courts typically apply an objective inquiry. (Davis v. United States
(1994) 512 U.S. 452, 459 (Davis) [in post-waiver context, whether a suspect
17
has invoked his right to counsel under Miranda and Edwards “is an objective
inquiry”]; People v. Williams (2010) 49 Cal.4th 405, 428 (Williams) [objective
inquiry applies to assessing whether suspect asserted rights at initial
admonition stage].) This is because, unlike the question whether a suspect’s
“waiver” of his rights was made knowingly and voluntarily—a question that
involves an evaluation of the suspect’s state of mind—the question of the
clarity of an asserted invocation of a suspect’s Miranda rights “must include
a consideration of the communicative aspect of the invocation— [i.e.] what
would a listener understand to be the defendant's meaning.” (Id. at
p. 428, italics added.)
A court considering “the communicative aspect” of an asserted
invocation of Miranda’s right to counsel may determine the suspect’s
statement to be one of three things: (a) a clear and unambiguous
communication of a current desire to have counsel’s assistance during an
interrogation (see, e.g., Davis, supra, 512 U.S. at p. 459), (b) an equivocal and
ambiguous communication from which a listener could reasonably conclude
the suspect might have a current desire to have counsel’s assistance during
an interrogation (see ibid.), or (c) a statement that unambiguously does not
express a current desire to have counsel present during an interrogation (see
18
McNeil, supra, 501 U.S. at p. 178).7 In order for a court to conclude that a
suspect has expressed an unequivocal and clear invocation of the right to
counsel for Miranda purposes, the suspect “ ‘must articulate his desire to
have counsel present [at the interrogation] sufficiently clearly that a
reasonable police officer in the circumstances would understand the
statement to be a request for an attorney[’s presence].’ ” (People v.
Cunningham (2015) 61 Cal.4th 609, 646, italics added (Cunningham),
quoting Davis, at p. 459.) An ambiguous or equivocal invocation of Miranda’s
right to counsel, on the other hand, is one for which “ ‘a reasonable officer in
light of the circumstances would have understood [to signify] only that the
suspect might be invoking the right to counsel’ ” (Williams, supra, 49 Cal.4th
at p. 428, italics added, quoting Davis, at p. 459) for purposes of custodial
interrogation. It is self-evident that a statement that does not meet either of
7 The significance of the distinction between an ambiguous invocation of
Miranda’s right to counsel and a clear and unequivocal invocation is relevant in
the context of when in the interrogation process the asserted invocation has
occurred. Only a clear and unequivocal invocation of either of the Miranda-
based rights (i.e., the right to remain silent and/or the right to the assistance of
counsel at a custodial interrogation) is sufficient to stop an interrogation that is
taking place after the suspect has waived his Miranda rights. (See, e.g., Davis,
supra, 512 U.S. at p. 459 [post-waiver invocation of Miranda right to counsel
must be clear and unambiguous]; Berghuis v. Thompkins (2010) 560 U.S. 370,
382 [post-waiver invocation of Miranda right to remain silent must be clear and
unambiguous].) Although the United States Supreme Court has not set out a
different standard when a suspect ambiguously invokes the right to counsel
after being advised of his Miranda rights but before waiving those rights, the
Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals concluded in Rodriguez, supra, 518 F.3d at page
1080, that a different standard applies when a suspect has been admonished
with the Miranda warnings but has not yet waived those rights. In such a
circumstance, a suspect need not make a clear and unambiguous invocation in
order to stop the interrogation; rather, an ambiguous invocation is enough to
limit the officer to asking questions meant only to clarify whether the suspect
intended to invoke his Miranda rights through the equivocal statement. (Ibid.)
19
these standards is, necessarily, not an invocation of Miranda’s right to
counsel. (See McNeil, supra, 501 U.S. at p. 178 [request for the assistance of
attorney at bail hearing is not an invocation of Miranda’s right to an
attorney].)
Hartwell does not argue that his reference to “my lawyer” was an
unambiguous invocation of his right to counsel. Rather, he asserts it was an
equivocal invocation of the right to have counsel present at the interrogation.
Hartwell contends that under Rodriguez, supra, 518 F.3d at page 1080 and
Duff, supra, 58 Cal.4th at page 551, when a suspect ambiguously invokes his
right to the assistance of an attorney during a custodial interrogation before
that suspect has waived his Miranda rights, the officer conducting the
interrogation has a duty to clarify the suspect’s ambiguous invocation or stop
the interview.8 We reject Hartwell’s reliance on these authorities however,
because we do not agree that his reference to a lawyer constituted an
ambiguous invocation of his Miranda right to an attorney.
Again, an invocation of one’s right to an attorney for Miranda purposes
must reflect a suspect’s desire to have the assistance of counsel in dealing
with a custodial interrogation. (McNeil, supra, 501 U.S. at p. 178.)
Hartwell’s statement did not reflect such a desire. Hartwell began by
complaining about being arrested and being made to wait for hours without
8 Hartwell contends that the California Supreme Court adopted the
Rodriguez rule for pre-waiver ambiguous invocations of Miranda’s right to
counsel in Duff, supra, 58 Cal.4th at page 551. However, we read Duff as
merely assuming the Rodriguez rule applies, without formally adopting it.
(See Duff, at p. 554; see also People v. Flores (2020) 9 Cal.5th 371, 424, fn. 15
[explaining that in Duff the Supreme Court “acknowledged the Ninth
Circuit's ruling in Rodriguez without expressly approving or rejecting it”].)
20
being told what was going on.9 Mills, in response to Hartwell’s complaints,
took the conversation in a different direction by engaging in small talk and
offering Hartwell food and coffee. Mills then asked Hartwell some basic
biographical information, including Hartwell’s birthdate. As Mills was
repeating Hartwell’s birthdate back to him, Hartwell then said the words on
which he is relying as constituting an invocation: “Yeah [that is my
birthdate]. ‘Cause, yeah, I was, I was getting pissed dude to where I was
gonna,— the other guy was kinda rude and I was gonna tell him like dude, if
you guys can’t tell me why I’m here, if I’m getting arrested, then I’m gonna
call my dad so I can call my lawyer just to get the fuck out of here, then you
guys can let me know. I was getting frustrated dude.” Hartwell’s words, in
context, involved him recounting his prior complaints about how he had been
treated and how he was feeling/what he had been thinking when he was
arrested. Hartwell’s use of “was gonna tell,” specifically, expressed that he
was narrating a past intention or plan that he had later abandoned.
Hartwell’s comments cannot reasonably be understood to have been
communicating to Mills that he had a then-current desire for the assistance
of an attorney at the interview. Rather, a listener would have understood
Hartwell to be conveying a story of what he had been thinking in the past.
Moreover, Hartwell’s comments also cannot be reasonably understood
to have conveyed a specific desire “for the particular sort of lawyerly
assistance that is the subject of Miranda” (McNeil, supra, 501 U.S. at p. 178).
Hartwell’s previously abandoned plan was not to ask for an attorney to assist
him in dealing with police questioning, but instead was to “call [his] dad so
9 For example, Hartwell can be heard complaining that he was left
“sitting in the car for about two hours and then get here and it’s the same
shit.” He then said, “I just wanna know what’s going on.”
21
[he could] call [his] lawyer . . . just to get the fuck out of here.” By this,
Hartwell expressed that he had been thinking of calling a lawyer to help get
him released from custody, not to assist him with any future interrogation.
Thus, no reasonable listener would have understood Hartwell’s statement
about calling his dad to call his lawyer to be suggesting that Hartwell was, at
that point in time, thinking of calling his father to obtain an attorney for the
purpose of assisting him with police interviews.
As a result, Hartwell’s reference to a lawyer would not have put a
reasonable officer on notice that Hartwell might have wanted an attorney
present during the interrogation. (See Williams, supra, 49 Cal.4th at p. 428.)
It therefore cannot be viewed as constituting either an unambiguous or an
equivocal “expression of a desire for the assistance of an attorney in dealing
with custodial interrogation by the police.” (McNeil, supra, 501 U.S. at
p. 178.) For this reason, the trial court correctly declined to suppress
Hartwell’s statements made to Mills after Hartwell made a reference to
having thought about calling his father to call an attorney during the pre-
interrogation portion of the interview in question.
B. Hartwell’s Claim of Prosecutorial Error Has Been Forfeited, and He
Fails to Establish Ineffective Assistance of Counsel
Hartwell complains that the prosecutor committed prejudicial
prosecutorial misconduct when she had a witness read aloud from and
displayed on a projector a copy of an apology letter Hartwell had written,
without redacting a portion of the letter in which he mentioned that during
one of the crimes he had told the victim he had a gun. According to Hartwell,
the prosecutor’s showing of this portion of the letter violated a court order
prohibiting the prosecution from telling the jury that Hartwell had told the
victim he had a gun during the burglary of this victim’s home.
22
1. Additional relevant background
By pretrial motion, the prosecutor moved to admit evidence of
Hartwell’s prior convictions, obtained through a plea agreement, under
Evidence Code section 1101, subdivision (b). The trial court agreed to take
judicial notice of the existence of Hartwell’s prior convictions in order to
assess the motion, and concluded that evidence of his convictions for those
offenses was admissible because the offenses were sufficiently similar to the
charged offenses to prove identity, intent, and a common plan or scheme.
However, the court was “a little concerned” that one of the prior convictions
was for a robbery, even though it had been based on a similar entry into an
occupied residence, but no robbery had been charged in the current case. The
court determined that it would allow the prosecution to use the fact of
Hartwell’s prior convictions, but would prohibit the prosecution from
referring to a statement Hartwell had made to that victim during the
commission of the crime about having a gun, which was the conduct that
formed the basis for Hartwell’s plea to a robbery. The court instructed the
prosecutor to admonish witnesses not to comment on the statement about the
gun, and not to ask any questions that would elicit a reference to Hartwell’s
gun comment to the victim during the crime. The court also indicated that a
proposed stipulation to be read to the jury “avoid[ ] any notion that [Hartwell]
threatened anybody with a gun or even has a gun because that could be very
inflammatory.”
At trial, the prosecution generally presented evidence regarding
Hartwell’s prior convictions in accordance with the trial court’s ruling. The
prior victim was not asked about and did not discuss Hartwell’s reference to a
gun in connection with the prior conviction for robbery. Nor did the arresting
officer refer to Hartwell’s comment about having a gun. However, after
23
testifying about arresting Hartwell and Hartwell’s admissions in connection
with the prior convictions, the officer testified that Hartwell wrote an apology
letter to the victim while being held in jail. The prosecutor requested that
the officer be permitted to read the letter to the jury, and defense counsel
expressly declared no objection to the letter being read aloud. Defense
counsel requested, however, that the letter be published on the overhead
projector. The prosecutor agreed, and the court allowed use of the overhead
projector. As the letter was projected for the courtroom to see, the officer also
read it aloud, as follows:
“I write you this letter to show how sorry and misguided
I’ve been. It was a stupid act of mine and very regret[ ] it. I
was only trying to commit my son and sign him for—up for
baseball. If I had and way to bring it back or find another
way to put my son up for baseball. It was stupid and not
smart. I hope you can forgive me and understand I didn’t
mean to hurt anybody or try to. P.S. I’m sorry for saying I
had a gun, but you were a fast runner. Please accept my
apologies and I hope you get you personal property back,
please. And again, I’m sorry.”
Defense counsel registered no objection during or after the reading of
the letter.
Later that day, outside the presence of the jury, the trial court noted
that “the gun comment . . . came in through the apology letter,” despite the
court’s efforts to keep it out of the jury’s knowledge. The court said that what
occurred “did not make me happy, but . . . in the big scheme of things, it
probably doesn’t have much impact. I don’t imagine either one of you is going
to emphasize this. So let’s just make sure it doesn’t happen [again]. I’m
assuming we’re not going to hear about that case any more.”
The prosecutor apologized and stated she had forgotten that Hartwell
had mentioned his comment about the gun in his apology letter.
24
2. Analysis
“The standards governing review of [prosecutorial] misconduct claims
are settled. ‘A prosecutor who uses deceptive or reprehensible methods to
persuade the jury commits misconduct, and such actions require reversal
under the federal Constitution when they infect the trial with such
“ ‘unfairness as to make the resulting conviction a denial of due process.’ ”
[Citations.] Under state law, a prosecutor who uses such methods commits
misconduct even when those actions do not result in a fundamentally unfair
trial.” (People v. Friend (2009) 47 Cal.4th 1, 29 (Friend).) Given that these
standards are objective, “the term prosecutorial ‘misconduct’ is somewhat of a
misnomer to the extent that it suggests a prosecutor must act with a culpable
state of mind. A more apt description of the transgression is prosecutorial
‘error.’ ” (People v. Hill (1998) 17 Cal.4th 800, 823, fn. 1.)10
“[W]hether done intentionally or not” (Friend, supra, 47 Cal.4th at p.
33), a prosecutor commits prosecutorial error by “eliciting or attempting to
elicit inadmissible evidence in violation of a court order” (People v. Crew
(2003) 31 Cal.4th 822, 839).
However, to preserve a claim of prosecutorial error, a defendant
generally is required to register an objection in the trial court and request
that the jury be admonished to disregard the alleged impropriety. (People v.
Centeno (2014) 60 Cal.4th 659, 674.) Here, Hartwell’s counsel registered no
objection to the admission of the apology letter, and instead requested that it
be displayed to the jury on an overhead projector. Even after the offending
10 Consistent with Hill, supra, 17 Cal.4th at page 823, footnote 1, we will
refer to the issue raised here as involving “prosecutorial error,” rather than
“prosecutorial misconduct.”
25
words were read aloud, defense counsel said nothing. The absence of an
objection forfeits this argument on appeal.
Hartwell concedes the forfeiture of his claim, but contends that this
court should exercise its discretion to consider his claim because, he asserts,
the error alleged was so prejudicial that it infected the trial with unfairness.
Alternatively, he argues his trial counsel provided ineffective assistance by
failing to object to the gun comment being brought in through the apology
letter. We disagree with his assessment of this prosecutorial error and the
contention that trial counsel rendered ineffective assistance in connection
with it.
First, contrary to Hartwell’s assertion, the prosecutorial error at issue
here did not infect the entire trial with such unfairness that it requires
review despite the lack of an objection at trial. While Hartwell contends that
the “difference between the verdicts at the first and second trials”
demonstrates “ ‘almost to a certainty the prejudicial nature of the error,’ ” it is
simply untrue that the only difference between the two trials was the fleeting
reference to the fact that Hartwell had apologized for telling the victim of one
of his prior crimes that he had a gun, such that the different outcomes
necessarily resulted from this error.11 We also reject the notion that the
failure to redact Hartwell’s statement “P.S. I’m sorry for saying I had a gun,
but you were a fast runner” rose to the level of a federal or state
constitutional violation. The statement was, in fact, so minor and
11 In fact, Hartwell effectively concedes that this was not the only
purportedly meaningful difference in the trials. He also argues on appeal
that the inclusion of the recording of his statements to Sergeant Mills in his
second trial, as opposed to his first trial where only the written transcript of
the interview was admitted, was a prejudicial error based on the different
outcomes of the two trials.
26
inconsequential that defense counsel raised no concern either prior to the
admission the letter or after it had been read aloud and projected on screen.
In addition, despite Hartwell’s contention that any reference to a gun was
unduly prejudicial, the statement from Hartwell’s apology note implies that
he had told the victim he had a gun when in fact had not been in possession
of a gun. Such a comment, implying the lack of a gun, was unlikely to have
evoked an unfair negative emotional bias against Hartwell. (See People v.
Robinson (2005) 37 Cal.4th 592, 632 [evidence is considered prejudicial if it
predominantly tends to evoke an emotional bias while having only slight
probative value to the issues].)
Hartwell’s ineffective assistance of counsel claim similarly lacks merit.
To establish such a claim, a defendant must show both that counsel's
representation fell below an objective standard of reasonableness under
prevailing professional norms, and that counsel's deficient performance
resulted in prejudice; that is, there is a reasonable probability that, but for
counsel's failings, defendant would have achieved a more favorable result.
(People v. Bell (2019) 7 Cal.5th 70, 125.) Whether counsel's performance was
deficient, and whether the complained-of deficiency prejudiced the defendant,
are mixed questions of law and fact subject to an appellate court’s
independent review. (In re Gay (2020) 8 Cal.5th 1059, 1073.)
In considering whether an attorney’s representation fell below an
objective standard, we accord great deference to counsel's tactical decisions
and presume that counsel's actions were reasonable and can be explained as
a matter of sound trial strategy. (People v. Mickel (2016) 2 Cal.5th 181, 198;
People v. Lewis (2001) 25 Cal.4th 610, 661.) Because of the great deference
accorded to trial counsel's tactical decisions, counsel's failure to object rarely
provides a basis for finding incompetence of counsel. (Lewis, at p. 661.) We
27
therefore will reverse a conviction based on ineffective assistance grounds
only if there is affirmative evidence that counsel had no rational tactical
purpose, was asked for a reason and failed to provide one, or there could be
no satisfactory explanation. (People v. Hoyt (2020) 8 Cal.5th 892, 958.)
These standards have not been met. The record readily provides a
rational tactical purpose—and thus a satisfactory explanation—for counsel’s
decision not to object when Hartwell’s apology letter was read and visually
displayed while still including the line in which he specifically apologized for
saying he had a gun. The reference was fleeting and so minor that an
objection would have likely served only to highlight the reference to a gun.
And this is particularly so given the fact that Hartwell’s apology seemed to
imply he had not actually been armed with a gun. Counsel could have
reasonably concluded that not drawing additional attention to the gun
comment was the best course of action. (See People v. Catlin (2001) 26
Cal.4th 81, 165 [“decision whether to object, move to strike, or seek
admonition . . . is highly tactical, and depends upon counsel’s evaluation of
the gravity of the problem and whether objection or other responses would
serve only to highlight [it]”].)
This, alone, undermines Hartwell’s ineffective assistance of counsel
claim, but we also conclude there is no reasonable probability that, but for
counsel’s failure to object to the gun reference and/or ask for an
admonishment, Hartwell would have achieved a more favorable result.
Again, Hartwell’s apology about saying he had a gun implied he did not
actually have a gun during the offense. Thus, from this statement alone,
which was the only evidence about a “gun” mentioned, jurors would have
drawn the conclusion that Hartwell did not in fact have a gun during his
prior offense, diminishing concerns about potential prejudice from references
28
to use of a gun in the commission of the prior offense. In the context of the
entire trial, the passing reference to Hartwell’s apology for saying he had a
gun was so inconsequential that counsel’s decision to allow it to pass without
objection could not have had any effect on the outcome.
III.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.
KELETY, J.
WE CONCUR:
McCONNELL, P. J.
CASTILLO, J.
29
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.