In re A.L. CA4/1

CourtListener 10591563CalctappMay 23, 2025

Full text

Filed 5/23/25 In re A.L. CA4/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION ONE

STATE OF CALIFORNIA

In re A.L., a Person Coming Under
the Juvenile Court Law.
D084994
SAN DIEGO COUNTY HEALTH
AND HUMAN SERVICES
AGENCY, (Super. Ct. No. NJ15940)
Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

J.H.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of San Diego County,
Nadia J. Keilani, Judge. Affirmed in part, conditionally reversed in part, and
remanded with directions.
Michelle D. Pena, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant.
Claudia G. Silva, County Counsel, Lisa M. Maldonado, Chief Deputy
County Counsel, and Kristen M. Ojeil, Deputy County Counsel, for Plaintiff
and Respondent.
This is the third appeal filed by J.H. (Mother) in this dependency
matter involving serious physical harm A.L. (Minor) suffered, or was at risk
to suffer, from Mother’s excessive disciplinary practices. Mother’s first
appeal from the juvenile court’s jurisdictional order was dismissed. (In re
Sade C. (1996) 13 Cal.4th 952, 994.) In her second appeal, we affirmed the
juvenile court’s finding at the contested six-month review hearing that it
would be detrimental to return Minor to Mother’s care. (In re A.L. (Jan. 6,
2025, D084095) [nonpub. opn.].)
Mother now appeals a finding of detriment at the contested 12-month
review hearing. She again contends substantial evidence does not support
the court’s finding that it would still be detrimental to return Minor to
Mother’s care. We again disagree. Substantial evidence supports the court’s
finding that it would not be safe to return Minor because Mother still has not
engaged in important components of her case plan designed to eliminate the
reasons for detention. We, thus, affirm this portion of the order.
However, Mother also contends that the Agency and the court did not
adequately inquire of Father R.L. or extended paternal family members

about whether Minor is an Indian child1 as required by the Indian Child
Welfare Act (25 U.S.C. § 1901 et seq.) (ICWA) and Welfare and Institutions

Code2 section 224.2. The Agency concedes conditional reversal is prudent to

ensure proper ICWA inquiry.3

1 We use the term “Indian” to remain consistent with language used in
the Act itself, but understand that descriptors like “Native American” are
generally preferable.
2 All statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions Code unless
otherwise indicated.
3 Father is not a party to this appeal.

2
We accept the concession and conditionally reverse the juvenile court’s
order finding that ICWA does not apply. We remand with instructions for the
Agency and the juvenile court to comply with the statutory inquiry
requirements.
BACKGROUND
A. Prior History
We incorporate from our prior opinion the more detailed background
and procedural history of this matter through the contested six-month review
hearing held on May 13, 2024. (In re A.L. (Jan. 6, 2025, D084095) [nonpub.
opn.].)
Briefly, this case commenced in June 2023 following reports of Mother’s
excessive discipline of Minor that included yelling at, pinching, and hitting
Minor. These practices left Minor with bruises and scarring consistent with
physical abuse as well as emotional trauma. Mother did not believe hitting a
child with a belt or pinching was physical abuse. She said she disciplined
Minor the way she was disciplined, which was the way passed down in her
culture.
One of Mother’s primary goals in the initial case plan was to show that
for at least six months she used positive disciplinary methods that do not
involve physical or emotional harm to Minor. To facilitate this goal, the plan
included a parenting education program, a 52-week child abuse treatment
program, and conjoint therapy with Minor when appropriate. The Agency
provided Mother with paperwork in August 2023 to enroll in the child abuse
group class. Mother thought the program was too long and waited for the
court to order her to participate.
At the contested adjudication and disposition hearing in October 2023,
the court denied Mother’s request to strike the child abuse class from the case

3
plan. The court said the class was “probably the most pivotal part of her case
plan given the allegations that the [c]ourt has already found to be true.”
The psychologist who evaluated Mother in January 2024 found she met
the criteria for delusional disorder as well as a personality disorder not
otherwise specified with primary features of paranoid personality, and
borderline personality disorders. She exhibited “fixed beliefs of a persecutory
nature” which were “primarily related to racial injustice and bias.” She had
an impaired ability to regulate her emotions, anger, insight, and judgment.
She was unable or unwilling to acknowledge her role and responsibility in the
removal of Minor or to place Minor’s needs ahead of her own. After a
discussion with a cultural consultant, the psychologist determined Mother’s
behaviors were “primarily related to mental health issues and real or
perceived traumas” rather than “cultural influences.”
The psychologist recommended intense outpatient treatment,
medication evaluation, and individual therapy with a therapist who matches
Mother’s cultural and ethnic background. The psychologist also
recommended child abuse prevention classes so Mother could “gain increased
awareness and knowledge of the symptomology of abuse, effects of
abuse/neglect on children, and develop skills to decrease potential for abuse
in the future.”
Mother began participating in parenting education in March 2024. She
started a child abuse group class at the end of April 2024, just before the
contested six-month review hearing. The therapist who facilitated the child
abuse class identified red flags from her initial interview with Mother in
April 2024, including statements that Mother believed family members were
trying to murder her. But the therapist agreed to evaluate Mother’s
participation in the child abuse prevention group.

4
B. 12-month Review Period
On May 20, 2024, about a week after the contested six-month review
hearing, Mother was discharged from the child abuse class. Her erratic
behavior during sessions made several other clients ask to the leave the group
because they felt Mother created a hostile environment. Mother’s demeanor
cycled from calm to hostile and then to distraught and emotionally dramatic
within seconds. Mother accused both the facilitator and others in the group of
racial discrimination. She also made statements that appeared delusional
(e.g., Mother stated she “was in the public eye,” she “works with celebrities,”
and she “has visions and premonitions”). As a result, the facilitator
determined Mother was not appropriate to participate in group therapy. The
facilitator recommended that Mother receive individual treatment to stabilize
her mental health before returning to a group class. The social worker
provided Mother with referrals for individual therapy and encouraged Mother
on numerous occasions to participate. Mother declined.
Minor returned to Polinsky Children’s Center (PCC) on June 6, 2024
because prior caregivers could no longer care for her. Minor was placed in a
resource home on July 10, 2024.
Mother engaged in parenting education through June 22, 2024. Her
visits with Minor were supervised by PCC staff until Mother became upset
during a visit on June 29, 2024, which frightened Minor. After this incident,
Mother declined the Agency’s offers to arrange visits at a visitation center or
with an Agency social worker.
The new caregiver supervised phone visits between Mother and Minor.
Minor told the caregiver she feared Mother and asked the caregiver not to tell
Mother about any poor behavior. The caregiver expressed concern that
Mother coached Minor during phone calls, such as by telling Minor not to talk

5
to people involved in the case and instructing Minor not to take prescribed

medication.4
Mother did not complete a child family team (CFT) meeting in August
2024. She left the call when the group began discussing concerns about
Minor’s medication, Mother’s discharge from the child abuse class, and
Mother’s lack of participation in therapy. Mother did not respond to attempts
to reconnect with her for the balance of the CFT.
In August 2024, after a lengthy absence from the case, Father began
participating in the proceedings. He said he wanted Minor and he was
willing to do whatever it took to get his daughter back.
At the request of the parents, the Agency continued to explore
placement options with relatives or family members out of state. A person
Mother suggested for placement in another state was denied approval.
At the scheduled 12-month permanency review hearing, Mother
requested a trial on the issues of returning Minor to her care and the terms of
the updated case plan which required her to participate in individual
therapy.
C. Contested 12-month Review Hearing
The contested hearing occurred on September 16, 2024. The court
admitted the Agency reports of September 5 and 16, 2024 with attachments
as well as a report from the court appointed special advocate dated
September 5, 2024.
The Agency recommended continued reunification services for both
parents to the 18-month review date and Minor’s continued placement in the

4 Minor refused to take her medication in August 2024. Minor had a
harder time calming down and her behavioral issues increased since she
stopped taking the medication.

6
resource home. The Agency clarified that although there were no visits
between Minor and Mother from June 29, 2024 to August 28, 2024 due to
Mother’s schedule, the two visited twice a week over the two weeks before the
contested hearing.
Based on the opinions of professional providers, the Agency believed
Mother needed to address her mental health issues before she could address
the child abuse and physical discipline issues that brought Minor into
detention. Since Mother had made no progress with those aspects of her case
plan, the Agency believed it would be detrimental to return Minor to her care.
Mother’s counsel asked no questions of the social worker and offered no
affirmative evidence. Mother’s counsel said Mother anticipated completing
the parenting class soon and she was “ready to actively participate in therapy
at this time.” Counsel said the recent visits with Minor were positive and
Minor wanted to return to Mother. Counsel asked the court to find it would
not be detrimental to return Minor to Mother’s care. Alternatively, counsel
submitted on the Agency’s recommendation to continue services to the 18-
month date. Counsel asked the court to modify Mother’s case plan to allow
her to address the child abuse component in individual therapy.
Minor’s counsel conveyed Minor’s wishes to live with Mother. However,
as the guardian ad litem, counsel believed it was in Minor’s best interests to
remain with the current caregiver and continue to receive services. Minor’s
counsel agreed that Mother needed to participate in individual therapy and
child abuse prevention before it would be safe to return Minor to her care.
Mother left the proceedings early, saying she needed to get to a class.
When Minor asked Mother not to leave, Mother said she would call her later.

7
The court adopted the Agency’s recommendations. The court found the
return of Minor to either parent would create a substantial risk of detriment
to her safety, protection, and emotional well-being.
The court found Mother had not made significant progress in her case
plan. Mother engaged in only a few classes dealing with her mental health
needs and she was not a good candidate for a group setting to deal with child
abuse classes. Emphasizing that both are “hugely important components of
her case plan,” the court determined it would not be safe to return Minor to
her care. The court found Minor’s placement in a licensed foster home was
necessary and appropriate.
The court ordered continued reunification services for both parents.
The court ordered the Agency to find a therapist for Mother who could
provide both individual therapy and components of a child abuse class, noting
the 18-month date was in January 2025. Mother appealed.
DISCUSSION
I.
Substantial Evidence Supports the Juvenile Court’s Detriment Finding
Mother contends there was insufficient evidence for the court’s finding
that it would be detrimental for Minor to return to Mother’s care because the
court focused on Mother’s progress with her case plan rather than Minor’s
safety. We disagree.
“The purpose of the California dependency system is to protect children
from harm and to preserve families when safe for the child.” (Tracy J. v.
Superior Court (2012) 202 Cal.App.4th 1415, 1424.) Because family
reunification is the goal throughout dependency proceedings until
reunification services are terminated, there is a statutory presumption that a
child removed from a parent child will return to parental custody “unless the

8
court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the child to
their parent . . . would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety,
protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child.” (§ 366.21,
subd. (e)(1); Tracy J., at p. 1424.) The Agency bears the burden of
establishing that detriment. (Ibid.)
The juvenile court must consider “the efforts or progress, or both,
demonstrated by the parent . . . and the extent to which they availed
themselves of services provided . . . .” (§ 366.21, subd. (e)(1).) The standard
for establishing detriment is high. “ ‘It cannot mean merely that the parent
in question is less than ideal, did not benefit from the reunification services
as much as we might have hoped, or seems less capable than an available
foster parent or other family member.’ [Citation.] Rather, the risk of
detriment must be substantial, such that returning a child to parental
custody represents some danger to the child’s physical or emotional well-
being.” (In re Yvonne W. (2008) 165 Cal.App.4th 1394, 1400.)
We review the court’s finding of substantial risk of detriment for
substantial evidence. (Yvonne W., supra, 165 Cal.App.4th at p. 1400.) “We
review the evidence most favorably to the prevailing party and indulge in all
legitimate and reasonable inferences to uphold the court’s ruling.” (In re
Mary B. (2013) 218 Cal.App.4th 1474, 1483.)
Here, as required by statute, the court considered multiple information
sources to arrive at its decision: the Agency reports; the CASA report; the
positions of the parties; and Mother’s progress with services. After hearing
this evidence, the trial court determined that returning Minor to either
parent would be detrimental. The court specified the factual basis for its
decision by explaining that Mother had not made progress on important

9
aspects of her case plan: addressing her mental health needs and

participating in child abuse courses.5 (§ 366.21, subd. (f)(1)(C).
This is not a situation where a parent’s progress in reunification
services is simply less than ideal. (See e.g. David B. v. Superior Court (2004)
123 Cal.App.4th 768, 798 [evidence that a father was poor was not sufficient
evidence of detriment when the record showed he participated in services];
Blanca P. v. Superior Court (1996) 45 Cal.App.4th 1738, 1748 [an opinion
that a mother failed to internalize lessons from her participation in parenting
classes was not sufficient evidence of detriment].) Rather, the record here
supports the juvenile court’s finding that it was not safe to return Minor to
Mother’s care without substantial risk to Minor’s physical or emotional well-
being because Mother has not participated in important aspects of her case
plan. (In re Joseph B. (1996) 42 Cal.App.4th 890, 899–900.)
Mother was offered child abuse prevention courses in July 2023. The
juvenile court described Mother’s participation in these courses as “the most
pivotal part of her case plan” due to the allegations of child abuse from
excessive discipline. Yet, Mother did not agree to participate in the courses
until late March 2024. She completed only three classes by the time of the
contested six-month review hearing in May 2024. (In re A.L. (Jan. 6, 2025,
D084095) [nonpub. opn.].) After the contested six-month hearing, she
attended only one more class and was removed from the group because of her
behavior.
A detailed report from the child abuse class facilitator shows Mother
appropriately participated in only two of the four group child abuse

5 As will be seen, Mother’s mental health challenges play a significant
role in Mother’s inability to manage aspects of her program, including child
abuse classes.

10
prevention sessions Mother attended. In the other sessions, her mood rapidly
cycled from “well-controlled, to hostile and aggressive towards others, to
sweet and cooperative.” In the last session, Mother became hostile and
aggressive and accused the therapist and other group members of racial
discrimination. She later became emotionally dysregulated, cried
uncontrollably, and began talking about having visions and premonitions.
The group’s facilitator removed Mother from the class not because
Mother overshared, but because her mental health issues made the leader
and other group members feel unsafe. The therapist concluded Mother
needed psychiatric evaluation and treatment to stabilize her mental health
issues before she could return to a group session. An Agency psychologist
agreed with the assessment. This was consistent with the opinion of the
psychologist who evaluated Mother in January 2024. The evaluating
psychologist determined Mother’s behaviors appeared “primarily related to
mental health issues and real or perceived traumas” rather than “cultural
influences.” Mother’s mental health issues impaired her ability to regulate
her emotions and impaired her ability to prioritize the emotional needs and
safety of Minor. These issues required intense outpatient services,
medication evaluation, and individual therapy along with child abuse
prevention classes.
Based on these recommendations, the social worker provided Mother
with resources for individual therapy. At least six times after discharge from
the group class, the social worker encouraged or requested Mother to
participate in individual therapy. But Mother disregarded these requests to
stabilize her mental health. It was not until the contested 12-month hearing
that her attorney indicated for the first time Mother was willing to
participate in therapy to satisfy the case plan.

11
Minor loves Mother and wishes to return home. However, there was
evidence that Mother’s behavior during a recent visit frightened Minor and
caused her to cry. Minor’s caregiver reported that Minor still fears Mother
enough to ask the caregiver not to report Minor’s misbehaviors.
Mother did participate in parenting education with a family support
partner for a few months. However, her inflexibility for visits prevented her
from completing the program. The fact that Mother removes herself from
calls or proceedings when concerns are raised about Mother’s behavior and
progress also supports the finding that it is not yet safe to return Minor to
Mother’s care.
For all these reasons, substantial evidence supports the court’s finding
of detriment.
II.
Conditional Reversal is Appropriate for Adequate ICWA Inquiry
A. Background of ICWA Inquiries
At the inception of the case in July 2023, the Agency asked Mother
about Native American ancestry. The court also inquired of Mother during
an initial hearing. Based on oral histories from her mother’s side of the
family, Mother reported that the family may have Choctaw heritage. Upon
further investigation, both a maternal grandfather and a maternal great-
grandmother denied Native American heritage. The Agency sent a letter to a
maternal aunt who did not respond. The Agency sent an informal inquiry to
several Choctaw tribes. The Choctaw Nation of Oklahoma responded saying
Minor is not an Indian child. Responses from the other Choctaw tribes
remained pending. Mother also provided a parental notification of Indian
status form (ICWA 020) indicating none of the Indian status options applied.

12
A social worker spoke with Father regarding Native American ancestry
in September 2023. He answered “No” to the following questions: “1. Has
anyone in the family ever lived on a reservation? [¶] 2. Has anyone in the
family ever received any financial, medical, or education assistance from a
tribe? [¶] 3. Does anyone in the family speak a Native American language?
[¶] 4. Is anyone active in tribal activities such as tribal council meetings,
religious rituals, or powwows? [¶] 5. Is any family member a member of a
tribe or an enrolled member in a tribe?”
The Agency also left a voice message and sent a text to a paternal aunt.
There is no indication she responded.
At the contested jurisdiction and disposition hearing in October 2023,
the court found without prejudice that there was no reason to believe ICWA
applied or that Minor was an Indian child.
After being absent from the proceedings since December 2023, Father
recontacted the Agency in mid-August 2024. Father asked the Agency to
evaluate a paternal relative in another state for Minor’s placement. The
social worker contacted this family member.
At the contested 12-month review hearing on September 16, 2024, the
juvenile court again found without prejudice that ICWA did not apply.
B. ICWA Requirements and Analysis
In California dependency proceedings, the juvenile court and Agency
have an “affirmative and continuing duty to inquire” whether a child “is or
may be an Indian child.” (§ 224.2, subd. (a).) The Agency’s initial duty of
inquiry includes “asking the child, parents, legal guardian, Indian custodian,
extended family members, others who have an interest in the child, and the
party reporting child abuse or neglect, whether the child is, or may be, an
Indian child.” (§ 224.2, subd. (b).) ICWA defines “ ‘extended family

13
member’ ” by “the law or custom of the Indian child’s tribe” or, absent such
law or custom, as “a person who has reached the age of eighteen and who is
the Indian child’s grandparent, aunt or uncle, brother or sister, brother-in-
law or sister-in-law, niece or nephew, first or second cousin, or stepparent.”
(25 U.S.C. § 1903(2); § 224.1, subd. (c) [“ ‘extended family member’ . . . defined
as provided in [§] 1903” of ICWA].)
Further duties of inquiry are required where there is reason to believe
a child is an Indian child; and notice is required where there is reason to
know a child is an Indian child. (In re Dezi C. (2024) 16 Cal. 5th 1112, 1132–
1133; § 224.2, subds. (e) & (f).) Alternatively, a juvenile court may “make a
finding that an agency’s inquiry and due diligence were ‘proper and
adequate,’ and the resulting record provided no reason to know the child is an
Indian child, so ICWA does not apply. (§ 224.2, subd. (i)(2).” (In re Dezi C., at
p. 1134.) We generally review the juvenile court’s ICWA findings for
substantial evidence. Where the facts are undisputed, we independently
determine whether ICWA’s requirements have been satisfied. (In re D.S.
(2020) 46 Cal.App.5th 1041, 1051.)
Mother asserts, and the Agency agrees, conditional reversal is
appropriate for the Agency and the juvenile court to inquire of Father on the
record regarding any Indian heritage and to require him to complete an
ICWA-020 form. The record also does not indicate the Agency inquired about
Indian ancestry with the paternal relative Father identified for placement
evaluation. (In re Dezi C., supra, 16 Cal.5th at p. 1152.) For these reasons,
we agree conditional reversal is appropriate.

14
DISPOSITION
The September 16, 2024 order is affirmed in part and conditionally
reversed in part. We affirm the court’s finding regarding detriment to Minor
by placing her back in Mother’s home, which is supported by substantial
evidence. However, with respect to Father, we conditionally reverse and
remand the matter to the juvenile court with directions to comply with the
inquiry provisions of ICWA and section 224.2, including but not limited to
inquiring of Father regarding Native American ancestry, requiring him to
complete an ICWA-020 form, and inquiring of extended paternal relatives
about possible Native American heritage. If, after completing the ICWA
inquiry, neither the Agency nor the juvenile court has reason to know that
Minor is an Indian child, the court shall reinstate the findings and orders
previously entered on September 16, 2024. If, after an adequate inquiry, the
Agency or the juvenile court has reason to know Minor is an Indian child, the
juvenile court shall proceed accordingly.

RUBIN, J.

WE CONCUR:

O’ROURKE, Acting P. J.

IRION, J.

15

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.