CourtListener 10588286•Smith v. Bridle Path Homeowners Assn. CA2/6
Full text
Filed 5/21/25 Smith v. Bridle Path Homeowners Assn. CA2/6
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION SIX
RAY SMITH, et al., 2d Civil No. B331987
(Cons. w/B333758)
Plaintiffs and Appellants, (Super. Ct. No. 56-2019-
00523695-CU-CO-VTA)
v. (Ventura County)
BRIDLE PATH HOMEOWNERS
ASSOCIATION, INC.,
Defendant and Respondent.
Appellants own homes in a Simi Valley planned
equestrian community known as Bridle Path. Respondent, the
Bridle Path Homeowners Association, Inc. (hereafter, HOA),
governs the community. For many years, the HOA watered and
maintained landscaping on parkways and slopes that are
adjacent to the bridle path and other common areas. These areas
are, however, located on appellants’ lots. In 2018, the HOA
notified appellants that it would no longer maintain those areas.
Appellants contend the City of Simi Valley’s (City) development
permit and other resolutions require the HOA, rather than
individual homeowners, to maintain the disputed areas. The
trial court entered judgment in favor of the HOA, finding that the
community’s Covenants, Conditions and Restrictions (CC&Rs)
placed that responsibility on appellants. It also awarded the
HOA its attorneys fees of $174,984.90. Appellants contend the
trial court erred. We affirm.
Facts
The City of Simi Valley Planning Commission (SVPC)
authorized development of the first phase of the Bridle Path
planned community in 1976, subject to several conditions. (SVPC
Resolution Nos. 69-75, 79-76.) These conditions required the
developer to adopt CC&Rs approved by the City Attorney and to
adopt a landscaping plan approved by the City’s landscape
architect. Condition C-8 provided, “The developer shall form a
homeowners association in the form of CC&Rs acceptable to the
City Attorney and the Director of Environmental Affairs which
shall be responsible for maintenance of these areas: 1) Common
Areas; 2) Bridle Trails at Streets; 3) Bridle Trails Easements at
Housing Areas and at Open Recreation Areas; 4) Landscaped
Parkways Along Interior Streets; 5) The Landscaped Backup
Parkway on First Street; 6) The ‘Streetscape’ Trees, Including
Trees Behind the Sidewalks, and Trees on Both Side of the Bridle
Trails, Along Public Streets; 7) Extraordinary Maintenance of
Public Streets Relating to Cleaning of Horse Manure and Other
Work Items Related to Horse Use; 8) Structural Integrity and
Appearance of Walls and Fences Along Common Areas and
Bridle Trail Accessways.”
The original CC&Rs provided that the HOA was
“charged with the management and maintenance of all of the
common properties. All improvements located within the
2
common properties, such as landscaping . . . shall be maintained
in a safe condition and a state of good repair.” Homeowners were
obligated to water, fertilize and maintain “parkway trees,”
defined as trees “installed in the five foot area between the front
curb and the bridle path or in the five foot area adjoining the
sidewalk . . . .” Homeowners were also responsible for
maintaining fences, trees and ground cover installed on their lot
prior to the first sale. In addition, each homeowner is obligated
to “keep that portion of the bridle path which fronts on or is on
the lot of such owner, clear of debris.”
In 1985 and 1986, the City adopted resolutions
approving the annexation of Tract 4038 to the Bridle Path
community, subject to CC&Rs approved by the City. (SVPC
Resolution Nos. 10-85, 11-85.) These CC&Rs incorporate the
original CC&Rs and require individual lot owners to “continually
maintain in a good condition landscaping” on the owner’s lot, to
“maintain the parkways adjacent to his Lot in a safe condition[],”
and to “maintain the portions of any bridle path adjacent to such
Owner’s Lot . . . .” They also obligate the HOA to maintain
common areas and “all bridle paths . . . .”
The HOA later recorded amended CC&Rs providing,
“It shall be the responsibility of each Lot Owner to maintain the
parkways adjacent to this Lot in a safe condition and free from
trash, weeds or other debris and public nuisances. Such
maintenance shall include the maintenance of hedges, trees,
shrubs, other plantings, fences and other permitted structures in
a neat and safe condition and in a good state of repair.”
Appellants purchased their lots after these amended CC&Rs
were recorded.
3
In 1990, the City adopted Resolution No. 90-88
annexing Tract 4038 to the Simi Valley Landscape District No. 1
as Zone 66. Appellants’ homes are located in Zone 66. A memo
prepared by City staff explained that “Zone 66 is proposed for
annexation as a Fallback zone, with the Bridle Path Homeowners
Association being responsible for maintenance of the landscaped
areas. . . . The developer has complied with the conditions of
entitlement by applying for annexation, installing the required
landscaping and irrigation systems . . . and maintaining the
landscaping in good condition . . . . Annexation to the Landscape
District as a Fallback zone ensures the continued, proper
maintenance of public landscaping (enriched parkways, integrity
of slopes, and proper drainage) by the Bridle Path Homeowners
Association.”
Because Zone 66 was a “fallback zone,” the
“home/property owners associations or some other entity” would
be responsible for maintaining the landscaping. If that entity
dissolved, the City could “assume maintenance of the landscaping
and assess the property owners for all required maintenance
expenses.” Staff further noted that the community’s CC&Rs
“detail the homeowners association’s responsibilities for
maintaining the common landscaped areas of the development,
including the parkways and slopes identified within Zone 66 . . . .
The fact that the Bridle Path Homeowners Association has been
maintaining these areas in good condition since January 1989 is
evidence of the property owners’ understanding and acceptance of
these responsibilities.”
A report prepared by a City Planner noted that, “The
annexation area will have Fallback status, with the Bridle Path
Homeowners Association having responsibility for its landscape
4
maintenance. Proposed for annexation are the parkways and
slopes along [streets in the tract].” The landscaping plan had
been prepared by the developer and approved by City staff. It
was estimated that the annual cost to maintain this landscaping
was $74,700. Because the area was a Fallback zone, “no
assessment is levied. This zone is maintained by the Bridle Path
Homeowners Association.”
The HOA paid to water and otherwise maintain
landscaping in the disputed areas for about 40 years, from the
time of the annexation until 2017. In 2018, the HOA board
proposed an amendment to the CC&Rs that would have
“clarify[ied]” that, “it shall be the exclusive duty of each Owner to
. . . (a) Maintain all landscaping on his or her lot, wherever
located . . . ; (b) Maintain the parkway adjacent to his or her Lot,
and all improvements located in such areas . . . .” This proposed
amendment was not adopted.
When the HOA notified appellants that it would no
longer maintain landscaping in the disputed area, appellants
filed their complaint for injunctive relief, a declaratory judgment,
breach of contract and breach of fiduciary duty.
Trial Court Ruling
After a three-day, non-jury trial, the trial court found
in favor of the HOA. It concluded that the CC&Rs and City
resolutions required appellants to “maintain their properties and
adjoining parkways,” and that the City resolutions annexing
their tract did not require maintenance by the HOA. The
CC&Rs, which obligated homeowners to maintain the disputed
areas, were consistent with the City’s resolutions because, “the
City’s concern is that the landscape be maintained, not
necessarily who pays for or performs the maintenance.” When
5
the City approved the annexation of Tract 4038, Bridle Path’s
CC&Rs had already been adopted and recorded. The CC&Rs
“detail how responsibility for landscape maintenance throughout
the development is apportioned: the Association takes care of the
common area, except for parkways adjacent to private lots. Lot
owners take care of their own property, as well as adjacent
parkways.”
Contentions
Appellants contend the conditions of approval
attached to the annexation and development of Tract 4038
require the HOA, rather than homeowners, to maintain
landscaping in the disputed areas and that the CC&Rs cannot
supersede those conditions. They contend the trial court erred in
awarding attorney fees because their action is not one to enforce
the CC&Rs.
Standard of Review
We review questions of law de novo and the trial
court’s findings of fact for substantial evidence. (Professional
Engineers in California Government v. Kempton (2007) 40 Cal.4th
1016, 1032; Pearce v. Briggs (2021) 68 Cal.App.5th 466, 473-474.)
We review the amount of attorney’s fees awarded by the trial
court for abuse of discretion. (Mountain Air Enterprises LLC v.
Sundowner Towers, LLC (2017) 3 Cal.5th 744, 751.)
Discussion
Responsibility for Landscape Maintenance
The trial court concluded appellants were bound by
the CC&Rs to maintain the landscaping on their respective lots,
including in the disputed area. It concluded the CC&Rs were not
in conflict with conditions imposed by the City because the City
approved the CC&Rs and appellants purchased their lots subject
6
to them. Appellants contend these findings are incorrect as a
matter of law. In their view, the original conditions attached to
the development permit and subsequent statements by City staff
require the HOA, not individual homeowners, to maintain the
landscaping. We disagree.
The Subdivision Map Act authorizes a city to impose
conditions on the development of a subdivision like the Bridle
Path community. (Gov. Code, § 66411; Hill v. City of Clovis
(2000) 80 Cal.App.4th 438, 445.) Here, the City conditioned its
approval of the annexation and development of Tract 4038 on the
adoption of CC&Rs and a landscaping plan that were acceptable
to the City. Among other things, the City required that, “All
landscaping shall be continually maintained in good condition
and shall be watered and kept clean and weed free. . . . In
addition, it shall be the responsibility of the property owner to
maintain parkways adjacent to his property in a safe
condition . . . . The maintenance of the parkway shall include the
maintaining of hedges, trees, shrubs, other plantings, fences, and
other permitted structures in a neat and safe condition and in
good repair.”
The developer complied with these conditions by
recording CC&Rs that require each homeowner to maintain
landscaping on the owner’s lot including the adjacent parkway
and bridle path. At that point, the developer was the “property
owner” referred to in Condition C-8 because no individual lots
had been sold. Two years later, the HOA recorded an
amendment that added an identical provision to another article
of the CC&Rs. The CC&Rs also require the HOA to “maintain all
bridle paths within the above described real property and all
properties annexed thereto . . . except to the extent that the
7
Owners are required to do so . . . .” The City annexed Tract 4038
to its Landscaping District No. 1 in 1990, two years after these
CC&Rs were recorded.
Like the trial court, we conclude the City’s adoption
of Resolution 90-88 confirmed its approval of the amended
CC&Rs. As noted above, those CC&Rs assign to the individual
homeowner the responsibility of maintaining landscaping on his
or her lot and on adjacent parkways and bridle paths. Statements
by City staff cannot alter or amend previously recorded CC&Rs.
(Citizens for Covenant Compliance v. Anderson (1995) 12 Cal.4th
345, 349 (Anderson).)
This conclusion is consistent with the original
conditions of approval and the original CC&Rs. The original
planned development permit required the developer to form an
HOA and to adopt CC&Rs that were approved by the City
Attorney and Director of Environmental Affairs. The developer
complied with that condition by recording CC&Rs providing for
an HOA that is “charged with the management and maintenance
of all the common properties.” They also require each
homeowner to maintain the trees, ground cover, and parkway
trees installed on their lot as well as the portion of the bridle
path that is adjacent to their lot. We can infer these CC&Rs were
acceptable to the City because the City approved later
development permits without requiring any amendments to
them.
Each appellant purchased his or her lot in the
development after the CC&Rs were adopted. Appellants had
constructive notice of their contents and are bound by them.
(Anderson, supra, 12 Cal.4th at p. 349.) Because the CC&Rs
assign to individual homeowners the responsibility for
8
maintaining landscaping on their lot and adjacent parkway and
bridle path, the trial court correctly concluded that appellants are
responsible for maintenance of those areas.
Attorney Fees
Appellants contend the trial court erred as a matter
of law when it awarded attorney fees to respondent because this
is not an action to enforce the CC&Rs and is instead an action to
enforce the City’s resolutions and conditions of approval. We are
not persuaded.
Civil Code section 5975 requires an award of
attorneys fees to the prevailing party “[i]n an action to enforce
the governing documents” of an HOA. (Id., subd. (c); LNSU #1,
LLC v. Alta Del Mar Coastal Collection Community Assn. (2023)
94 Cal.App.5th 1050, 1082 (LNSU); Chee v. Amanda Goldt
Property Management (2006) 143 Cal.App.4th 1360, 1380-1381
[fees awarded to prevailing party in action for breach of a
contractual obligation created by CC&Rs and for declaratory
relief adopting plaintiff’s interpretation of CC&Rs].) To
determine whether an action is one to enforce the governing
documents, we examine the allegations in the operative
complaint. (LNSU, supra, at pp. 82-83.)
The operative complaint here is appellants’ Second
Amended Complaint. That pleading alleges that the controversy
between the parties “involves different interpretations of the
documents setting forth the obligations for maintenance as to
whether they are to be done by the [HOA] or the individual
homeowners.” These obligations stem, at least in part, from the
CC&Rs because the City required the adoption of acceptable
CC&Rs.
9
Appellants’ first cause of action for injunctive relief
alleges a controversy exists between the parties “concerning their
respective rights and duties in that [appellants] contend that the
CC&Rs are unclear as to defining their specific duties and
maintenance requirements . . .” while the HOA “contends that
the CC&Rs are clear and controlling . . . .” Appellants’ third
cause of action for breach of contract describes the CC&Rs as a
contract and alleges the HOA has breached that contract as well
as the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing arising
from it. Finally, appellants allege the HOA breached the
fiduciary duty owed to its members. The CC&Rs are the only
source of that duty.
Appellants also acknowledged in discovery responses
that their claims were based at least in part on alleged violations
of the CC&Rs. For example, appellants’ responses to several
special interrogatories describe their contention that the HOA
breached “an implied or tacit agreement” when it interpreted
Article X, section 7 of the CC&Rs “to cover the areas in dispute in
this lawsuit.” In response to another special interrogatory,
appellants stated, “Yes, we contend the [HOA] breached
provision[s] of the CC&Rs and owe attorney fees.” Appellants
also asserted their claim that the HOA owes them a fiduciary
duty “based on all agreements and duties set forth therein.” This
statement appears to include the CC&Rs, which their previous
answers described as a contract.
In light of these statements by appellants the trial
court did not err when it concluded this action was one to enforce
the governing documents of the HOA.
Appellants further contend the trial court abused its
discretion when it declined to apportion or reduce attorneys fees
10
to account for claims unrelated to enforcement of the governing
documents. They assert that the only claim relating to the HOA’s
governing documents was the claim relating to HOA member
voting rights that was not referred to at trial. We disagree.
All of appellants’ claims were based, at least in part,
on the CC&Rs. The City’s development conditions required the
adoption of CC&Rs which are the governing document defining
the parties’ responsibilities for landscape maintenance. There is
no basis for apportioning fees under these circumstances. (Akins
v. Enterprise Rent-A-Car Co. (2000) 79 Cal.App.4th 1127, 1133
[apportionment not required where issues are “so interrelated
that it would have been impossible to separate them into claims
for which attorney fees are properly awarded and claims for
which they are not”].)
Conclusion
The judgment is affirmed. Costs to respondent.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.
YEGAN, J.
We concur:
GILBERT, P. J.
BALTODANO, J.
11
Jeffrey Bennett, Judge
Superior Court County of Ventura
______________________________
Decker Law and James Decker, Griffin Schindler,
Aisling Gorman, for Plaintiffs and Appellants.
HPS Associates and Arthur R. Petrie, Dan E. Heck,
for Defendant and Respondent.
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.