CourtListener 10588252•In re L.R. CA2/2
Full text
Filed 5/21/25 In re L.R. CA2/2
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has
not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION TWO
In re L.R., a Person Coming B333926
Under the Juvenile Court Law. (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. 23CCJP01720)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILY SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
GLENN K.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from the judgment of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Mark A. Davis, Judge. Affirmed.
Paul A. Swiller, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Aileen Wong, Deputy County
Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
******
Glenn K. (father) appeals from a judgment declaring his
son L.R. (born November 2021) a dependent of the court. Father
challenges the juvenile court’s jurisdictional finding of domestic
violence as to both parents. We find substantial evidence
supports the challenged finding; therefore we affirm the
judgment.
COMBINED FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL
BACKGROUND
Initial investigation
On January 18, 2023, the Clark County, Nevada child
welfare agency filed a petition for child protection on behalf of
L.R., alleging Erika R. (mother) neglected L.R., mother’s mental
health and/or drug use impacted her ability to care for L.R.,
mother lacked resources to provide for L.R.’s basic needs, and
father abandoned L.R. by failing to have contact with mother and
L.R. and failing to provide for financial support for the child.1
The Clark County child welfare agency was unable to determine
whether father posed other risks to the safety of L.R. due to lack
of contact. L.R. was removed from mother on December 31, 2022.
On March 28, 2023, the Los Angeles County juvenile court
accepted jurisdiction of this matter from Clark County, Nevada
1 Mother is not a party to this appeal.
2
pursuant to the Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and
Enforcement Act (Fam. Code, § 3400 et seq.).
Although L.R. was detained in Nevada, mother reported
they are residents of Los Angeles County, were homeless and
previously stayed at the Salvation Army in Santa Monica,
California. Shortly thereafter the child was detained in Nevada,
and mother’s and father’s locations were unknown.
On the day of L.R.’s detention, mother had approached law
enforcement claiming all of her possessions had been stolen at a
McDonald’s restaurant. Mother had no way to care for L.R., no
support in the area, and no plan. Mother was informed L.R. could
not sleep on the street, but no shelter could be provided to them.
Mother became belligerent and threatened to throw hot coffee on
the law enforcement officers. As an officer was entering the
passenger side of a patrol vehicle, mother threw her cup of coffee
at the vehicle. Mother was arrested, and L.R. was taken to a
shelter.
Mother was released from custody on January 1, 2023, and
her whereabouts were unknown for two days. Mother, who
appeared to have mental health issues, was later found near a
McDonald’s restaurant. She was unable to provide a safe plan for
L.R. and said they would be fine to sleep on the Las Vegas strip
over the weekend. Mother claimed to be the child’s pediatrician,
and L.R. had only her breast milk as food despite being of an age
where he should be consuming other forms of nutrition. The
names of relatives provided by mother appeared to be fictitious,
and they were unable to be located. L.R. remained detained in
shelter care.
A Nevada social worker contacted the Salvation Army and
met with mother’s case manager, who confirmed mother
3
previously resided at the shelter. Mother and L.R. had moved in
on February 10, 2022, and left on October 26, 2022. Mother did
not advise the shelter she was leaving. The case manager
contacted mother once to ask her to retrieve her belongings.
Mother complied by retrieving a couple of items. The case
manager believed mother had mental health problems. As to
father, mother claimed he was abusive and the reason they were
not together. The case manager never met father and had no
information about him. Mother had listed no emergency
contacts. The case manager observed that mother was not
always honest.
On April 4, 2023, the social worker located father and the
following day spoke with father’s roommate, who reported mother
had been staying with them but left the previous night. Mother
and father were getting into many arguments and causing a lot of
problems in the home. Mother was asked to leave and given a
ride to the train station, where she said she was going to Georgia.
The social worker asked the roommate to give father her business
card.
On April 6, 2023, the social worker received a call from
father, who did not know mother’s whereabouts. He confirmed
mother had showed up at his residence for a couple of days and
said L.R. had been taken by a child welfare agency. Father had
last seen L.R. a couple of months after his birth. Father and
mother were together during mother’s pregnancy, but then
mother disappeared. Father had only seen L.R. two or three
times.
Father admitted occasionally smoking marijuana and
drinking alcohol. He denied violence between him and mother,
saying he and mother would occasionally argue, but he always
4
would walk away before things got physical. Father had two
teenage children who resided with their mother in New York.
Father denied any prior child welfare involvement.
On April 7, 2023, mother reported having arrived in
Georgia with no plans to return to Los Angeles. Mother was
concerned about L.R. being released to father, saying father was
violent towards her, and she and L.R. had a restraining order
against father, though the restraining order might have expired
and had not been renewed. Mother stated father was verbally
abusive and lashed out towards her while she was pregnant.
Once, while she was pregnant, father headbutted her. Mother
did not want to talk about the situation further because it was
traumatic. Mother said father had never been involved in L.R.’s
care, smoked cigarettes and consumed alcohol. She heard he
used cocaine, but was unsure.
On April 10, 2023, father advised the social worker he had
a six-month old daughter, Juliana C., but did not know where his
daughter’s mother, Tina, had taken the baby. Father also said,
“it happened after she disappeared and left when she was
pregnant then it happened again and now I am at this point
where all I want is at least be a part of my children [sic] life.”
L.R. remained in a foster home in Nevada.
Petition, detention and reports
On May 18, 2023, the juvenile court exercised its discretion
pursuant to Welfare and Institutions Code section 331 and
ordered the Los Angeles County Department of Children and
5
Family Services (DCFS) to file a section 300 petition on behalf of
L.R.2
On May 22, 2023, a section 300 petition was filed on behalf
of L.R., alleging pursuant to section 300, subdivision (a), count
one: “On a prior occasion, the child [L.R’s] mother . . . and the
child’s father . . . engaged in a violent altercation in which the
father struck the mother’s head with the father’s head when the
mother was pregnant with the child. . . . Such violent conduct on
the part of the father against the mother endangers the child’s
physical health and safety, creates a detrimental home
environment, and places the child at risk of serious physical
harm, damage and danger.” Pursuant to section 300, subdivision
(b), count one, the petition alleged mother had mental and
emotional problems rendering mother unable to provide regular
care for the child. Count b-2 set forth the same domestic violence
allegations alleged in count a-1.
At the May 23, 2023 detention hearing, the juvenile court
found father to be the alleged father of L.R. Father’s request for
custody was denied and L.R. was ordered detained from parental
custody.
In the June 28, 2023 jurisdiction/disposition report, the
dependency investigator reported that on June 7, 2023, L.R. was
brought to Los Angeles and placed with a foster mother.
The dependency investigator was also able to locate a
restraining order protecting mother, but it did not name father as
the restrained party. Father denied having been served with or
having any knowledge of a restraining order against him. The
2 All further statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.
6
dependency investigator was unable to locate mother for an
interview.
Father denied any violence with mother, including hitting
mother’s head while she was pregnant. He had no criminal
history for domestic violence. When asked why mother would say
he hit her, father claimed she is an angry individual and for an
unknown reason does not want him to have their son.
Father admitted to having arguments with mother that
almost became physical and that mother slapped him a couple of
times, but he claimed to have kept his composure and left the
house. Father believed mother was trying to provoke him to hit
her so anytime things became too aggressive or overwhelming, he
grabbed his belongings and left.
Father described an incident during which mother took a
vendor’s items without paying. The vendor talked to father, who
asked mother about it. Mother became upset, started to scream,
and threw the stolen goods on the table. The vendor then offered
mother the stolen items prompting mother to become more upset.
She then refused the items, and attempted to flip the table.
Father held the table down while mother walked away cursing.
Maternal uncle, Marcus R., denied any knowledge of the
identity of L.R.’s father. He was unaware of any violence
between mother and any partner. Marcus had no concerns
regarding mother’s mental health and denied knowledge of
mother having panic attacks, making bizarre statements, or
exhibiting aggressive behavior.
The maternal great-aunt/adoptive maternal grandmother,
Angela W., stated she knew L.R.’s biological father. According to
Angela, mother informed Angela that mother allowed father to
see L.R. when he was born, but mother had concerns about father
7
not having a stable home. Mother had never spoken to Angela
about domestic violence with father; however, Angela was not
privy to all of mother’s secrets—noting mother had not informed
Angela of L.R. having been detained. Angela saw no signs of
abuse to mother nor did she see anything that alerted her to any
abuse. Angela also denied knowledge of mother making bizarre
statements, having panic attacks, or being aggressive.
Mother’s previous case manager at Salvation Army said
mother disclosed that father was abusive. When father came on
the property, mother left the shelter because she did not feel
comfortable with father knowing her location. Late one night
mother grabbed her belongings, went to a motel, and reached out
to explain she had left because father knocked on her door. While
mother was in the shelter, she did not have visitors. Another
individual, who brought father to the shelter, was in the same
program with mother and claimed to be aware father was abusive
to mother. The case manager denied mother had ever mentioned
a restraining order. Mother spoke little about father and did not
disclose any domestic violence with father until after he came to
the shelter.
The former case manager had no concerns regarding
mother’s mental health. She had not observed mother having
panic attacks, acting bizarrely or aggressively. Mother was
always calm even when she was upset.
Fatima B., mother of father’s older children, denied any
violence between her and father. She and father did not fight or
have arguments.
The social worker for father’s child, Juliana C., reported
that Juliana’s mother had not mentioned domestic violence
involving father.
8
As of June 27, 2023, mother’s whereabouts remained
unknown.
An August 2, 2023 last minute information for the court
reported mother had contacted the social worker on July 27,
2023, stating she had a job in Atlanta, but returned to Los
Angeles for L.R.’s dependency case.
Mother claimed she once had a restraining order against
father due to the headbutting incident described in the section
300 petition, though she did not have a copy of the order. Mother
did not file it herself but had a homeless advocate fill it out on
her behalf. Mother did not go to court in connection with the
restraining order against father. Mother disclosed having a
history of being in relationships where there was violence
between her and her partner.
Mother recounted two incidents involving violence with
father. Both occurred before L.R. was born, though mother could
not recall the dates.
The first incident occurred before she became pregnant.
Mother admitted the incident was “probably her fault.” She and
father were verbally arguing, thinking father was going to hit
her, she hit him first.
The second incident happened while she was pregnant.
Mother and father were arguing and yelling when father
headbutted her. Mother reacted by pulling father’s hair and
trying to pull out his dreadlocks. Mother indicated father had
said some hurtful things to her, without providing further detail
about the incidents. Mother denied mental health issues, but
admitted to having anxiety and that she threw coffee at the police
officers in Las Vegas. She denied making bizarre statements to
authorities in Las Vegas.
9
The August 2, 2023 last minute information for the court
contained father’s report that mother stopped by his home, but
they did not talk about the dependency proceeding because he did
not want to make mother upset at him. The social worker opined
father lacked the tools to have appropriate conversations with
mother without mother escalating and becoming upset. Father
allowed mother to visit and stay at his home and to participate in
a zoom video call with L.R. The social worker also noted mother
disclosed violence with father but would stay with him when she
visited Los Angeles.
On August 29, 2023, the dependency investigator reported
a dependency petition had been filed on behalf of father’s
daughter, Juliana C. Father was nonoffending in the petition.
A September 7, 2023 last minute information for the court
reported the dependency investigator had made contact with
biological maternal grandmother, Marion S., who denied mother
ever disclosed to her any domestic violence with father. She also
denied mother displaying any mental health problems, having
panic attacks or acting aggressively.
In an October 16, 2023 last minute information for the
court, the dependency investigator reported father did not have a
dependency history in New York.
Adjudication
The adjudication and disposition hearing regarding L.R.
was held on October 16, 2023. Father was present by
speakerphone. The court admitted DCFS’s reports into evidence
and took judicial notice of all prior petitions, case plans and court
orders.
L.R.’s counsel argued the court should sustain the domestic
violence count based on mother’s statements, noting while father
10
denied domestic violence, he admitted mother slapped him and
punched him, and provoked him to hit her. For those reasons,
L.R.’s counsel asked the court to sustain count b-2.
Father’s counsel asked the court to dismiss counts a-1 and
b-2, both of which alleged domestic violence, due to lack of
evidence. Father’s counsel noted mother was an unreliable
witness, stating mother had “extreme mental health issues” and
“is constantly making up stories about who she is and speaking
erratically.” Counsel pointed out no other witness reported
observing or hearing about any abuse or violence between the
parents.
The juvenile court sustained counts b-1, concerning
mother’s mental and emotional problems, and b-2, concerning
domestic violence between the parents. The court found DCFS
met its burden of providing sufficient evidence to make the
findings.
The court declared L.R. a dependent of the court under
section 300, subdivision (b), ordered L.R. removed from parental
custody, ordered family reunification services for the parents, and
set the matter for a six-month review hearing.
On December 15, 2023, a notice of appeal on behalf of
father was filed by his counsel.
DISCUSSION
I. Whether father’s appeal is justiciable
The parties disagree whether father’s appeal is justiciable.
Father’s sole argument on appeal is the evidence did not support
the domestic violence count as to him. Father acknowledges that
jurisdiction would remain based on the unchallenged counts as to
mother regardless of the outcome of this appeal. DCFS argues
11
this court should dismiss father’s appeal because this court
cannot provide father with any effective relief. (In re I.A. (2011)
201 Cal.App.4th 1484, 1490 [“An important requirement for
justiciability is the availability of ‘effective’ relief—that is, the
prospect of a remedy that can have a practical, tangible impact
on the parties’ conduct or legal status.”].)
Under the doctrine of justiciability, reversal and remand is
not required if one or more of several findings made by the
juvenile court is unsupported by substantial evidence. (In re
Jonathan B. (1992) 5 Cal.App.4th 873, 876.) “‘We uphold
judgments if they are correct for any reason, “regardless of the
correctness of the grounds upon which the court reached its
conclusion.”’” (Ibid.) “‘When a dependency petition alleges
multiple grounds for its assertion that a minor comes within the
dependency court’s jurisdiction, a reviewing court can affirm the
juvenile court’s finding of jurisdiction over the minor if any one of
the statutory bases for jurisdiction that are enumerated in the
petition is supported by substantial evidence. In such a case, the
reviewing court need not consider whether any or all of the other
alleged statutory grounds for jurisdiction are supported by the
evidence.’” (In re I.J. (2013) 56 Cal.4th 766, 773.)
However, an exception exists where the outcome of the
appeal could be “‘the difference between father’s being an
“offending” parent versus a “non-offending” parent.’” (In re
Quentin H. (2014) 230 Cal.App.4th 608, 613.) An appellate court
may find it appropriate to exercise its discretion to hear the
appeal on the merits in this situation, particularly where the
finding could result in consequences for the parent in this or
other dependency proceedings. (Ibid.)
12
Here, the true finding regarding domestic violence is the
difference between father being an offending or a nonoffending
parent. Thus, the finding could have consequences in this or
other dependency or family law proceedings. We note father has
another child who is the subject of a dependency petition. Thus,
the finding could affect him even if there remain grounds for
jurisdiction of L.R. due to mother’s neglect. For these reasons, we
exercise our discretion to review father’s appeal on the merits.
II. Applicable law and standard of review
Jurisdiction is warranted under section 300, subdivision
(b)(1), if the child has suffered, or there is a substantial risk the
child will suffer serious physical harm or illness as a result of the
failure of his parent to adequately supervise or protect the child.
In order to make the necessary showing, three elements are
required: (1) neglectful conduct or an inability to protect the
child; (2) causation; and (3) serious physical harm or injury to the
minor, or a risk of such harm. (In re Joaquin C. (2017) 15
Cal.App.5th 537, 560–561.) A current risk of harm may be shown
by past conduct if there is reason to believe the conduct will
recur. (In re S.F. (2023) 91 Cal.App.5th 696, 712–713.)
We review a challenge to a jurisdictional finding for
substantial evidence. (In re I.C. (2018) 4 Cal.5th 869, 892.)
“Substantial evidence is a deferential standard, but it is not
toothless. It is well settled that the standard is not satisfied
simply by pointing to ‘“isolated evidence torn from the context of
the whole record.”’” (Ibid.) “Rather, the evidence supporting the
jurisdictional finding must be considered ‘“in the light of the
whole record”’ ‘to determine whether it discloses substantial
evidence—that is, evidence which is reasonable, credible, and of
solid value . . . .’” (Ibid.)
13
If there is substantial evidence to support the juvenile
court’s findings, we uphold those findings. (In re L.Y.L. (2002)
101 Cal.App.4th 942, 947.) “We do not evaluate the credibility of
witnesses, reweigh the evidence, or resolve evidentiary conflicts.
Rather, we draw all reasonable inferences in support of the
findings, consider the record most favorably to the juvenile
court’s order, and affirm the order if supported by substantial
evidence even if other evidence supports a contrary conclusion.”
(Ibid.)
III. Substantial evidence supports the juvenile court’s
finding
Reviewing the evidence in light of the whole record, we find
substantial evidence supports the juvenile court’s decision
sustaining the domestic violence count.
Mother has consistently stated there was domestic violence
between her and father. Mother articulated two instances of
violence: first, an incident in which she anticipated father would
hit her so she hit him first; and second, an incident in which
father headbutted her while she was pregnant. In this second
incident, mother reacted by pulling on father’s hair and trying to
pull it out. While father denied being the instigator of violence,
he admitted that mother slapped him a couple of times.
Further, prior to the commencement of these proceedings,
mother had informed her former caseworker at Salvation Army
that father was physically abusive. When father came on to the
shelter’s property, mother left the shelter as she did not feel safe
with father knowing her location. Mother later reached out to
explain her reasons for having left the shelter. Mother also
revealed the domestic violence to at least one other individual at
14
the shelter. This testimony, along with mother’s consistent
allegations of abuse, constitutes substantial evidence.
A current risk of harm exists. Father allowed mother to
stay with him when she was in Los Angeles, and father’s
roommate reported mother and father were engaged in many
arguments and caused problems in the home. Father admitted
mother stopped by his home and the two continued to see each
other. Mother had a history of relationships with domestic
violence. The social worker observed that father did not have the
skills to effectively communicate with mother without the
conversation escalating.
Father argues there was a plethora of evidence suggesting
the domestic violence did not occur. Father argues mother had
mental health issues, manifesting an inability to accurately
describe reality. However, we cannot reevaluate the credibility
determinations of the juvenile court. (In re L.Y.L., supra, 101
Cal.App.4th at p. 947.) Mother’s consistent statements to more
than one individual that father acted violently towards her
constituted substantial evidence. In addition, father’s own
admission that mother slapped him a couple of times constitutes
evidence of domestic violence between mother and father.
Father points out that various maternal relatives who were
interviewed did not report being aware of any domestic violence
in mother’s relationship with father. However, the juvenile court
was not required to view this evidence as undermining mother’s
own testimony and that of her former case worker. Similarly,
father’s lack of a history of domestic violence does not require a
finding that no domestic violence occurred in this case.
“Evidence from a single witness, even a party, can be
sufficient to support the trial court’s findings.” (In re Alexis E.
15
(2009) 171 Cal.App.4th 438, 451.) In this case, mother’s
testimony provides such evidence. Under the circumstances, we
must uphold the juvenile court’s findings, even if other evidence
supports a contrary conclusion. (In re L.Y.L., supra, 101
Cal.App.4th at p. 947.)
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.
CHAVEZ, J.
We concur:
LUI, P. J.
ASHMANN-GERST, J.
16
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.