CourtListener 10586685•In re S.S. CA2/8
Full text
Filed 5/19/25 In re S.S. CA2/8
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION EIGHT
In re S.S., Persons Coming B338293
Under the Juvenile Court Law. (Consol. w/B339388)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY (Los Angeles County
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN Super. Ct. No. 22CCJP01650A)
AND FAMILY SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
W.E.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from order of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County. Tiana J. Murillo, Judge. Affirmed.
Marissa Coffey, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Appellant.
Tarkian & Associates and Arezoo Pichvai for Plaintiff and
Respondent.
Anuradha Khemka, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Respondent Minor.
——————————
W.E. (Mother) appeals from the trial court’s order denying
her motion under Welfare and Institutions Code1 section 388.
We affirm the order because the trial court reasonably concluded
that Mother did not establish that reopening Mother’s family
reunification services was in the child’s best interests. Mother
visited this child inconsistently resulting in an atrophied relation
between Mother and child. We affirm.
BACKGROUND
I. Mother’s dependency history with S.S.
S.S. is now seven years old. On April 29, 2022, the
Los Angeles County Department of Children and Family Services
(DCFS) filed a petition alleging Mother placed S.S. and her
younger sister, Emilia, at risk of harm because (1) Mother did not
protect them from her male companion’s physical abuse of S.S.;
(2) Mother did not protect the children from the male
companion’s domestic abuse of Mother; (3) Mother did not protect
the children from the male companion’s substance abuse; and
(4) Mother herself abused substances. When DCFS filed the
petition, S.S. was four years old. At the outset of the case, the
trial court granted an emergency removal, and DCFS placed S.S.
in the home of the foster parents that cared for her throughout
the dependency case. However, Emilia and S.S. were placed with
two different foster parents. At the time of the jurisdiction and
1 All further undesignated statutory citations are to the
Welfare and Institutions Code.
2
disposition report, S.S. and her sister remained placed with their
respective foster parents.
On June 16, 2022, the trial court found jurisdiction on the
theories alleged: Mother’s substance abuse; and Mother’s failure
to protect S.S. and Emilia from the risks associated with Mother’s
male companion. On August 12, 2022, the trial court removed
S.S. from Mother. As a result, S.S. and her sister remained in
their two placements with different foster parents. For S.S., the
trial court ordered that Mother’s visits be monitored, and ordered
three visits per week.
During the first six-month reunification period, Mother’s
visitation was inconsistent. Then Mother requested visits once a
week to focus on her programs and her employment. DCFS also
noted that Mother cared for her children when she did visit.
At the six-month status review, the trial court found Mother’s
progress to be unsubstantial and terminated Mother’s family
reunification services. The trial court also set a selection and
implementation hearing under section 366.26.
In the report for the section 366.26 hearing filed on
June 13, 2023, DCFS noted that Mother visited once a week
despite the trial court ordering three visits a week. At some
point, Mother’s schedule included two visits a week, but Mother
was only attending one visit a week. Thereafter, Mother again
narrowed her visitation schedule to only a single visit per week.
At the time of the June 2023 report, Mother visited once a week
for two hours and arrived late to visits. However, the visits were
frequently extended, and the visits ran past their scheduled time.
On holidays or other special occasions, Mother’s visits with S.S.
ran as long as six hours.
3
From July 2022 to May 2023, Mother missed about one
third of her weekly visits as she was no longer attempting to visit
more than once a week. S.S.’s foster mother assisted in
facilitating visits by picking up Mother for visits and driving
Mother home or to work after visits. Relatedly, DCFS noted its
concern that Mother would not attend visits without the foster
mother facilitating visits. In addition to Mother missing visits,
the visits that did take place included little communication
between Mother and S.S. Mother was also unable to engage with
S.S. Mother’s relationship with S.S. appeared to be atrophying,
and S.S. sought out Mother less frequently for affection as time
passed. Despite these challenges, S.S. still missed and loved
Mother.
The June 2023 report also summarized phone and video
contact, and Mother and S.S. were initially scheduled for three
calls a week. However, the calls were halted because Mother did
not call. In addition, S.S. declined to talk to Mother on the phone
on some occasions.
In the August 2023 permanency planning report, DCFS
noted that Mother visited S.S. inconsistently since the last
hearing. In addition, Mother’s whereabouts were unknown for
most of May and June 2023. Thereafter, on July 28, 2023, DCFS
created a visitation schedule for Mother, where Mother had in-
person visits on Tuesdays for two hours and virtual visits on
Sundays for two to three hours. A social worker noted that
Mother made minimal effort to engage with S.S. during a visit
that the social worker witnessed. According to S.S.’s foster
mother, S.S. and Mother did not appear to have a bond.
On August 30, 2023, the trial court identified adoption as
the plan for S.S.
4
In the September 2023 last minute report for the selection
and implementation hearing under section 366.26, DCFS noted
that Mother had difficulty visiting S.S. because of the distance
between S.S.’s placement and Mother’s inpatient program. The
treatment center was a two-hour drive from S.S.’s placement. In
addition, Mother’s treatment program would not let her leave
without a staff member, and the program had insufficient staff to
accompany Mother to visits. After making some adjustments
including allowing some visits at Mother’s recovery home, visits
became more consistent beginning in July 2023. In addition, the
updated schedule included two in-person visits a week. DFCS
again noted its concerns that Mother and S.S. did not interact in
visits, Mother rarely called, Mother’s moods were unpredictable
in visits, and S.S. increasingly showed less affection towards
Mother.
In December 2023, Mother completed her six-month, in-
patient substance abuse program. When she completed the in-
patient program, DCFS met with Mother to create a new
visitation schedule. In January 2023, Mother was eligible to
move to a less restrictive facility, but she had some problems with
funding. Nonetheless, the new weekly visitation schedule
included two in-person visits for three-hours each. In addition,
Mother had one three-hour video visit per week, and Mother was
free to call S.S. during the week. However, mid-week calls
became challenging because of S.S.’s extracurricular activities
and homework. From December 27, 2023 to January 25, 2023,
Mother visited S.S. one time in-person for one hour. Mother also
had one twenty-minute video session, one five-minute video call
where Mother called after the appointed time, and one attempted
call made after the appointed time where S.S. was unavailable.
5
In a status review report for the post permanent plan
review filed on February 14, 2024, DCFS noted Mother was
complying with her case plan for the youngest sibling. DCFS
again noted that Mother did not appear to have a bond with S.S.,
and that S.S. was “almost indifferent” to the idea of seeing
Mother. S.S. would also feel sick and throw up prior to visiting
Mother on occasion. The visitation log for October to January
2023 reflected inconsistent in-person and video visits.
On April 4, 2024, Mother filed a motion under section 388
asking the trial court to return S.S. to Mother’s home or to
reinstate family reunification services with overnight or
unmonitored visits. In her motion, Mother explained she
completed her entire case plan except the 12 Step meetings, and
she was attending those. Mother pointed out that S.S. lived with
her the first four years of life. In addition, she argued that she
and S.S. shared a strong bond, which established that it was in
S.S.’s best interest to change the court’s prior orders. Mother also
attached a declaration providing that S.S. called her “Mommy”
and hugged and kissed her when visits began and when they
ended. The declaration also provided that Mother brought toys,
snacks, and clothing for S.S. on visits. In addition, Mother noted
that S.S. cried at the end on a December 2023 visit because S.S.
did not want Mother to go and S.S. told Mother that S.S. missed
her on another visit. Finally, Mother explained that she was
unable to visit S.S. frequently when Mother was in her sober
living program.
From late February to early May 2024, Mother missed
multiple in-person visits and multiple video visits. The therapist
who monitored visits noted that S.S. greeted Mother as a family
friend, and that S.S. called Mother by her first name. The
6
therapist also concluded that Mother and S.S. did not share a
bond. The social worker monitored one visit during this period
and concluded that Mother and S.S. did not have an attachment.
The DCFS report notes that during the visits S.S. played on her
own and minimally interacted with Mother.
DCFS prepared a report to address Mother’s section 388
motion. S.S. said that she did not always feel happy while
visiting Mother, but that she feels sad when she does not visit
Mother. When asked if she missed Mother, S.S. said she missed
her younger sister. S.S. also indicated she preferred to live with
her foster mother instead of Mother while noting that she loved
Mother. S.S. also expressed wanting her foster mother present
during visits with Mother. In addition, Mother said she visits
S.S. once a week on Tuesdays and she does not miss visits. The
weekend in-person visits and video visits were cancelled because
of Mother’s work schedule. Mother also explained her plan to
welcome S.S. back into her home including having a bed for her.
In the same report, DCFS noted that S.S.’s youngest
sibling, a son who was younger than both Emilia and S.S., had
been removed from Mother initially but was back in Mother’s
care. Because of Mother’s progress on her case plan, DCFS
recommended to the trial court to close the youngest sibling’s
case with Mother retaining custody.
In the section 388 report, the foster parents reiterated their
view that Mother and S.S. do not share a bond, and that for the
last six months, S.S. had not shown excitement for visits. They
also indicated that Mother stared at her phone during visits.
The social worker also reiterated her perspective that Mother and
S.S. did not have a bond. She explained that S.S. asked the
foster parents to end Mother’s visits early, and Mother spent her
7
time on the phone while visiting S.S. The social worker said
Mother cancelled one visit per month and visited S.S. three times
per month.
On May 17, 2024, the trial court held the hearing for
Mother’s section 388 motion. DCFS recommended partially
granting Mother’s section 388 motion to reinstate family
reunification services for Mother with S.S. Consistent with
DCFS’s position, Mother narrowed her request and asked that
the trial court reinstate family unification services. The trial
court’s tentative was to deny the motion.
Mother testified that she was living with her sister. Before
changing jobs, she worked on Saturdays, which interfered with
visits. She played school and soccer with S.S. on visits, S.S.
would run toward her and call her “mommy,” and S.S. hugged
her at the end of visits. Mother also denied that she is on her
phone during visits. Mother indicated that S.S. said she missed
Mother a lot after Mother completed the drug program. In
addition, she visited four to five times a week after leaving her
previous job, and she had a strong bond with S.S. However, she
conceded that S.S. lost some love for her, and she wanted to get it
back. If her motion was granted, Mother’s plan was to take S.S.
to school, hug her, and make up for lost time.
S.S.’s counsel called the foster mother to testify. She
testified that Mother had not texted to check on S.S. the previous
month except for S.S.’s birthday. The foster mother also
acknowledged that Mother came to S.S.’s birthday party that the
foster mother had for S.S. Over the last two years, Mother sent
text messages less than once a month regarding S.S. Mother
called S.S. for video visits maybe a few times a year.
8
After hearing argument, the trial court ruled that Mother’s
progress in her case plan and Mother’s custody of the youngest
child satisfied Mother’s burden to establish changed
circumstances. Regarding S.S.’s best interests, the trial court
explained, “[A]t this point, we are even beyond the two-year
service date that mother would have otherwise been entitled to
under the law. That would have expired, I believe, last month.
And I am specifically not—finding today that it is not in [S.S.’s]
best interest to ask the child to wait six [] additional months for
mother to do more services to see if mother and child can reunify.
That is essentially what the Court is being asked to do. And, on
this record, I don’t believe that it’s in the child’s best interest.”
The trial court elaborated, “[N]or do I see a robust record or
robust evidence to suggest that mom is visiting as much as she
can and is making all efforts to visit as much as she can.”
The trial court also found the foster mother’s testimony more
convincing than Mother’s.
Thereafter, in a later hearing, the trial court terminated
Mother’s parental rights over S.S.
DISCUSSION
1. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in
denying Mother’s section 388 motion
Mother’s notice of appeal encompasses both the
termination of her parental rights and the denial of her
section 388 motion. In this appeal, Mother challenges the ruling
denying her section 388 motion. If Mother prevails in her appeal
of the section 388 ruling, she asks this court to reverse the
termination of her parental rights as well. S.S. is the respondent
who defends the trial court’s order on appeal, and DCFS takes no
9
position on the appeal because DCFS recommended that the trial
court grant, in part, Mother’s motion.
Under section 388, a petitioner may request that a judicial
officer modify an earlier dependency order. (In re Jasmon O.
(1994) 8 Cal.4th 398, 414–415.) In this context, a petitioner has
the burden to show: (1) a change of circumstances; and (2) that
changing the previous order would be in the child’s best interests.
(In re Malick T. (2022) 73 Cal.App.5th 1109, 1122.) A section 388
motion “is addressed to the sound discretion of the juvenile court
and its decision will not be disturbed on appeal in the absence of
a clear abuse of discretion.” (In re Jasmon O., at pp. 415–416.)
Both Mother and S.S. do not contest the trial court’s ruling
that Mother established a change of circumstances. Thus, we
turn to the trial court’s ruling that the proposed change would
not be in S.S.’s best interests.
We find no abuse as the record amply supports the trial
court’s determination that additional family reunification
services for Mother were not in S.S.’s best interests. Consistent
with the record, the trial court noted that Mother was visiting
S.S. infrequently. Further, while Mother testified to the
contrary, the social worker, the therapist, and the foster parent
all indicated that S.S. had grown distant from Mother and that
S.S. and Mother did not interact during visits. The trial court
also reasonably concluded that postponing stability for S.S. also
weighed against granting Mother’s petition. As the Supreme
Court explained in considering a section 388 motion, “[I]t is
within the court’s discretion to decide that a child’s interest in
stability has come to outweigh the natural parent’s interest in
the care, custody and companionship for the child.” (In re
Jasmon O., supra, 8 Cal.4th at p. 419.) There, the Supreme
10
Court noted that after an 18-month period where reunification
services are available, the primary concern under the law is
providing a stable, permanent home for a child. (Id. at p. 421.)
Given the record here, the trial court properly exercised its
discretion in denying Mother’s section 388 petition.
DISPOSITION
The trial court’s order denying Mother’s section 388 motion
is affirmed.
VIRAMONTES, J.
WE CONCUR:
STRATTON, P. J.
WILEY, J.
11
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.