In re Thomas C. CA2/3

CourtListener 10585804CalctappMay 16, 2025

Full text

Filed 5/16/25 In re Thomas C. CA2/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION THREE

B340890
In re Thomas C., a Person Coming
Under the Juvenile Court Law. (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. 21LJJP00036A)

LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILY SERVICES,

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

C.C.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County, Donald A. Buddle, Jr., Judge. Affirmed.
Jesse Frederic Rodriguez, under appointment by the Court
of Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Tarkian & Associates and Arezoo Pichvai for Plaintiff and
Respondent.
‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗

Caitlin C. (mother) appeals from a juvenile court order
terminating her parental rights. Her son, Thomas, became a
dependent of the juvenile court as a result of mother’s ongoing
and unresolved substance abuse. Mother repeatedly relapsed on
drugs and failed to reunify with Thomas. Thomas was in foster
care for over three and a half years before the matter proceeded
to a hearing to select a permanent plan. Thomas’s foster parents
wanted to adopt him. Mother argued that the parental benefit
exception to adoption applied. The juvenile court found mother
had not maintained regular visitation and contact with Thomas,
but also found Thomas had a substantial, emotional attachment
to mother and that he would benefit from continuing the
relationship. However, the court ultimately concluded mother
failed to establish that the termination of parental rights would
be detrimental to Thomas. We affirm the juvenile court order.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
From 2016 to 2018, Thomas was a dependent of the
juvenile court due to mother’s substance abuse. Mother
completed a case plan and dependency jurisdiction was
terminated.
In December 2020, then five-year-old Thomas again came
to the attention of the Los Angeles County Department of
Children and Family Services (DCFS). DCFS received referrals
suggesting mother had treated Thomas roughly while in public
and she did not seem “mentally stable.” During an investigation,
mother tested positive for methamphetamine, amphetamine, and
marijuana. The juvenile court detained Thomas from the parents

2
and eventually sustained a petition based on mother’s ongoing
substance abuse.1 In March 2021, the court removed Thomas
from mother and ordered family reunification services.
Initial Reunification Period
By mid-May 2021, mother had completed an inpatient drug
treatment program. But in mid-June 2021, mother was
discharged from an intensive outpatient program after she did
not attend required group meetings, missed drug tests, and asked
to withdraw from the program. In July and August 2021, mother
tested positive for methamphetamine, amphetamine, and
marijuana.
While in the inpatient program, mother “was very involved
with . . . Thomas” and “called and video chatted with [him]
almost every night.” After mother completed the inpatient
program, however, she attended only three of 12 in-person visits
scheduled between June and August 2021. Mother also had
weekly 30-minute video chats scheduled with Thomas. According
to the caregiver, mother often called late or missed the video
visits. When the video visits did occur, mother was “engaged”
and talked to Thomas “about school, his toys, and trucks.”
Thomas was diagnosed with fetal alcohol spectrum disorder
and was assessed for Regional Center services. A medical
examination form reported: “[Foster mother] is doing a
remarkable job of working with Thomas. In the absence of [a
professional assessment] and intervention program, she has
worked diligently with Thomas and great progress has been
made. This child has [a] combination of [likely]

1 Father’s whereabouts were unknown to DCFS and the
juvenile court for most of the dependency proceedings. He died in
2023.

3
neurodevelopmental issues due to . . . serious prenatal exposures
to alcohol and meth and as many as four and a half years of . . .
serious neglect in the care of his mother. [Foster mother] has
provided him with a warm, stable, structured and encouraging
environment that is simply exemplary.”
At the September 2021 six-month review hearing, the court
continued mother’s reunification services. Over the next six
months, mother was repeatedly discharged from treatment
programs and tested positive for methamphetamine,
amphetamine, and marijuana. Between late June 2021 and mid-
January 2022, mother attended 15 of 28 scheduled in-person
visits with Thomas. One of those visits was cut short because
mother appeared to be under the influence. Two visits were
canceled because either Thomas or the monitor was ill. Mother
missed the remaining 11 visits.
The reports summarizing mother’s visits were positive.
The monitor described Thomas running to mother when she
arrived at the visits, hugging her, kissing her, playing with her,
and having a good time. On one occasion in September 2021,
Thomas did not want to leave at the end of the visit. On another
occasion, Thomas “screamed [with] joy to see mother” when she
unexpectedly arrived at a visit with the maternal grandmother.
Thomas and mother said they loved each other and held each
other. Thomas was excited and happy to see mother.
By this time, Thomas was in a new foster placement and
was receiving services for autism. A Regional Center report
indicated Thomas had visits scheduled with mother once a week
for two to three hours and daily telephone calls. However, the
foster mother reported that mother missed visits and phone calls.

4
At the April 25, 2022 12-month review hearing, the juvenile
court terminated mother’s reunification services and set a
permanency planning hearing pursuant to Welfare and
Institutions Code section 366.26 for August 2022.2
Permanency Planning Period
In the August 2022 section 366.26 report, the foster parents
reported their concern that Thomas had “difficulty regulating,
especially after visitation and that he makes up stories that they
are certain are not true.” They told a social worker that Thomas
had difficulty sleeping and was frequently afraid there were
monsters under his bed. Occasionally he played with fecal
matter and smeared it on the walls, explaining that it was a
monster he had to crush and smear so that it would not return.
Since the last report, mother had 27 visits scheduled. Ten
of the visits could not take place because mother, Thomas, or the
visit monitor was ill, in quarantine due to COVID-19, or Thomas
and the foster parents were away. At another 10 of the visits,
only the maternal grandmother was present. Mother attended
the seven remaining visits. The report acknowledged that
mother missed some visits due to restrictions at her treatment
facilities. The report further acknowledged that Thomas looked
forward to the visits and that, when mother did visit, she was
loving and attentive.
However, the foster parents told the social worker that
when Thomas returned home from visits he was sometimes “very
angry” and upset because mother would promise to take Thomas
with her but failed to follow through. They reported Thomas
expressing anger towards mother after a recent visit, saying:

2 All further statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.

5
“ ‘She told me I was going home with her today. She lied to me.
She hates me. Everyone hates me.’ ” Thomas then ripped the
head off a teddy bear mother had given him. Thomas was so
upset that the foster parents contacted his therapist for an
emergency session, which lasted two hours until Thomas was
“able to better regulate his mood.” More generally, the foster
parents observed that Thomas was “often out of sorts for a couple
days and is kind of stand offish and distant” after visits with
mother.
DCFS informed the court that Thomas’s foster parents
were interested in adopting him. Thomas had been placed with
them since January 2022. Thomas had adjusted to the foster
home and said he liked living with the foster parents. A social
worker observed that he appeared comfortable and was bonding
with the foster father.
When a social worker interviewed the now seven-year-old
Thomas, he “expressed confusion over going home to his
biological family vs staying with his current family. The child
calls the caregivers Mom and Dad and states ‘They are real good
people. Real good. I miss my (bio) Mom but I love this Mom too.
I want to stay here but I want to go home too.’ ” According to the
foster parents, when Thomas learned that they were adopting
another child in the home, and that child’s last name would be
changed to the foster parents’ last name, Thomas asked if he
could have that name too.
The section 366.26 hearing was continued to November
2022. In a November section 366.26 addendum report, the foster
parents reported that Thomas was receiving counseling “because
he needs a lot of help with learning to cope and dealing with his
anger issues.” He also continued receiving Regional Center

6
services. Asked about the foster parents, Thomas said: “ ‘My
mom, I love her so much. She’s nice to me. She feeds me, she
lets me go outside and play. My dad, I love him too. Yes, I want
my mom and dad to take care of me until I’m grown up. They
keep me safe.’ ”
The section 366.26 hearing was continued to January 2023,
then again to February 2023. In a further supplemental
section 366.26 report filed in February 2023, DCFS reported that
mother was having telephone or virtual visits every night.
However, mother repeatedly called outside of the arranged time
for the visits, including when Thomas was getting ready for
school or after he was asleep. A social worker “reported [that]
due to the child’s psychological and emotional needs, structure is
important in helping the child maintain emotional stability.” The
virtual/telephone visit schedule was therefore changed to every
Friday, Saturday, and Sunday. Although the visits were
scheduled to last one hour, they typically lasted only around 20
minutes because of Thomas’s short attention span. The foster
mother reported that she frequently had to “remind the mother
not to make promises to the child as he becomes very
dysregulated and upset when the mother does not follow
through.” On one phone call, mother put a man on the line who
was “someone from her meetings.” The man “made a promise to
Thomas that he could not keep.” Thomas “was angry, tore out
the frame of his window and made holes in the walls” at the
foster home. The visitation monitor told mother the man should
not have been talking to Thomas.
Twenty-eight in-person visits had been scheduled since the
last detailed report to the court. Mother attended 17 of the visits.
Seven of the visits could not take place due to Thomas, mother, or

7
the visit monitor being ill or in COVID-19 quarantine, or Thomas
was unavailable. Two visits did not take place because mother
failed to confirm in advance. The maternal grandmother
attended three visits without mother, including on one of the
occasions that mother was ill. However, the visitation monitor
reported that mother almost never canceled a visit. The monitor
further indicated that mother was loving and attentive with
Thomas and played well with him.
The social worker for the case reported that mother and
Thomas were bonded and had a loving and affectionate
relationship. They frequently shared a secret saying that meant
“I love you” at the end of visits. Yet, the social worker also
reported that Thomas had significant special needs and
“participated in a high level of services” that included weekly
therapy, wraparound services, and twice daily medication.
Mother’s unfulfilled promises to Thomas that he would be going
home to live with her were “difficult for [him] to process.” While
Thomas was usually in a good mood both before and after visits,
he became dysregulated if mother disappointed him by not
following through on her promises that he could return home
with her. In such situations, the foster mother “redirected the
child and distracted him with an outing to bring balance back to
his emotional state.”
The social worker was also concerned that mother had not
demonstrated any new skills or behaviors that would allow her to
meet Thomas’s “significant needs.” Mother continued to struggle
with substance abuse and had been discharged from multiple
treatment programs. Although Thomas talked about “going
home” to mother, the social worker reported that “this happens
mostly when it is time for another visit.”

8
DCFS reported that Thomas and the foster parents—now
the prospective adoptive parents—had developed a strong bond.
The social worker found “the prospective adoptive parents to be
attentive to Thomas’[s] high needs and that they have found
effective strategies for managing [his] behaviors and [anger] after
he is disappointed by his mother.” DCFS opined that Thomas’s
attachment to the caregivers “has allowed Thomas to feel loved,
safe, secure and connected emotionally.”
Further Reunification Services
In November 2022, mother had filed a petition pursuant to
section 388, asking the court to return Thomas to her custody or
to reinstate reunification services. Mother reported that she
planned to complete her programs by the end of the month, had
tested negative, and was “continu[ing] her sobriety.” Mother said
she was visiting Thomas every Saturday and had telephone or
virtual visits every day. DCFS opposed mother’s request, noting
that she had just been asked to leave another substance abuse
program. At a February 2023 hearing, mother testified that she
had completed a substance abuse program, had mental health
services scheduled, and she had completed individual counseling
and a parenting class. The juvenile court granted mother’s
petition and ordered further reunification services.
In late February and early March 2023, mother twice
attempted to take Thomas out of school without permission. On
the second attempt, school security escorted mother off campus.
In an August 2023 report, DCFS informed the court that after
mother’s section 388 petition was granted, the social worker had
to remind mother not to speak to Thomas about going home and
not to introduce her male companions to Thomas because “it
triggers the minor’s behaviors.” According to Thomas’s therapist,

9
Thomas had expressed the feeling: “If ‘my mommy can be with
her friends why can’t she be with me.’ ” DCFS opined that
mother’s mental health prevented her from grasping what she
was told, and she needed weekly reminders. DCFS reported that
in December 2022, after mother “began to visit” Thomas, his
“behaviors went from aggressive to toys and objects to aggressive
towards people.”
Thomas was taking medication for ADHD, but he “has hurt
animals when angry, has broken [iPads], broken the room in his
wall [sic] from banging his second iPad, and spreads feces on
walls when upset. The caregiver . . . makes sure the minor takes
his medication daily and makes sure that he makes all his
therapeutic appointments.”
Mother tested negative for drugs until July 2023, when she
had a positive test for methamphetamine. Mother denied using
drugs. She claimed that the positive test must have been the
result of touching methamphetamine at a friend’s house.
Because of mother’s positive test, DCFS did not switch
mother to having unmonitored visits. Mother had weekly in-
person monitored visits and telephone calls three days each
week. DCFS reported: “[Thomas] is excited to see [mother].
When CSW arrives to pick up [Thomas] for visits, [he] instantly
states, ‘We are going to see my mom . . . but I’ll be back to my
momma [caregiver] right?’ ” Mother was “loving and affectionate”
with Thomas.
In September 2023, the juvenile court terminated mother’s
reunification services and set a new date for the section 366.26
hearing in November 2023.

10
Further Permanency Planning
In a November 2023 section 366.26 report, the foster
parents reported that Thomas was “very needy,” but they were
assisting him in receiving behavioral and mental health services.
Thomas had been in their home for nearly two years and they
still wanted to adopt him.
The report summarized prior reports about mother’s visits.
In addition, the foster mother reported that Thomas had visits
with the maternal grandmother and “he anxiously waits for these
visits by the door.” The adoptions social worker observed Thomas
standing by the door, “waiting for the monitor to pick him up for
his visit.” According to the foster mother, after the weekly visits
with mother, Thomas became depressed, then violent. He would
break things, “punch people and say mean things after his visits.”
Thomas, now eight years old, told the adoptions social
worker he had “ ‘everything he needs, has a roof over his head, a
place to sleep, and a backyard to play soccer in.’ ” He said that
although he “ ‘love[d] it’ ” at the foster parents’ home, he wanted
to “go back with his family.”
In November 2023, the section 366.26 hearing was
continued to December. Mother filed another section 388
petition, asking for reinstatement of her reunification services.
Mother contended that she had completed an inpatient substance
abuse program, had remained sober, and continued to try to visit
Thomas regularly. The petition asserted that both Thomas and
mother had special needs, and Thomas’s acting out behavior after
visits with mother demonstrated their strong bond.
The December section 366.26 hearing was continued to
March 2024.

11
In March 2024, DCFS reported that Thomas was “well
bonded” to the foster mother and they had a loving relationship.
The foster mother reported that when a visit was canceled with
mother, Thomas tended to “go backwards,” get upset, and break
things. In mid-February 2024, mother did not show up for a visit.
Thomas was upset when he returned home and broke a vase.
The foster mother further reported that mother’s visits were
“triggering” for Thomas and their telephone calls seemed
“forced.” The foster mother opined that during the telephone
visits, Thomas “acts more like the parent and mother more like
the child.”
A March 2024 supplemental section 366.26 report
summarized mother’s visits in the 2023 calendar year. According
to the report, mother attended 6 visits alone and 26 visits with
the maternal grandmother. As in past reports, DCFS informed
the court that mother was loving towards Thomas during visits.
Thomas looked forward to visits and cried when they were
canceled. The longtime visitation monitor noted that mother
needed coaching about basic parenting skills, “such as limiting
phone time during visits and limiting sweets and snacks before
meals.” There was also concern that mother blurted out difficult
information—such as news of the deaths of father and the
maternal grandfather—without any recognition of Thomas’s
“developmental considerations.” Mother sporadically called
Thomas on Fridays. According to the foster mother, the calls
were usually short, and mother would tell Thomas she was
calling because the maternal grandmother told her to. Mother
seldom asked Thomas how he was doing. Instead, Thomas asked
mother questions, such as whether she was eating or suggesting
that she drink more water.

12
The report provided an analysis of the factors necessary to
determine whether the parental benefit exception to adoption
would apply. DCFS opined that there was a significant positive
emotional attachment between mother and Thomas, that Thomas
would benefit from continuing his relationship with his biological
family, and that he would experience “a high amount of loss” if
visits with mother and the maternal grandmother were
terminated. Nonetheless, DCFS opined that adoption would
create a new sense of stability for Thomas over time and that it
was the most beneficial permanent plan. Although DCFS
therefore recommended that the juvenile court terminate
parental rights, it also noted it was “equally clear” that Thomas
looked forward to visits with his family and “the visits are
essential to the child’s positive self-image.” DCFS suggested it
was in Thomas’s best interest for the court to refer the matter for
a post-adoption contact agreement.
DCFS interviewed Thomas for a separate response to
mother’s section 388 petition. Thomas told a social worker he
called the foster parents “mom” and “dad.” He also called mother
his “mom.” He was aware that he had a visit with mother the
day of the interview and would be picked up soon for the visit.
He told the social worker that visits with mother made him
happy. Without prompting, Thomas volunteered: “ ‘I want to go
back with mom. I miss them so much. . . . I miss her so much. I
want to play with her every day. She makes me happy.’ ” When
asked with whom he would want to live if he could not return to
mother, Thomas answered, “ ‘I would like to stay here [with the
foster parents] but I want to go to mom.’ ” When asked again
about his wishes if living with mother was not an option, Thomas
said he would want to visit mother. The social worker asked how

13
he would feel if he was not able to see mother. He responded, “ ‘I
would feel really sad. I really want to be with her.’ ”
The visitation monitor indicated mother’s visits were
consistent and she rarely missed a visit unless she was in
treatment or there were unforeseen circumstances. Thomas
anticipated and looked forward to visits. When asked what she
thought would happen if Thomas stopped seeing mother, the
monitor said she did not know. She explained: “[I]t is a hard
situation because he looks forward to the visits but he also
worries about mother so there is some anticipation on his part
every week.” She recounted that she had recently told Thomas
they could only wait for 15 minutes after the scheduled visit time
for mother and the maternal grandmother to arrive. When
mother and the maternal grandmother were late after that,
Thomas watched the clock until 15 minutes had passed, then said
it was time to leave. He cried, “but seemed to accept the
situation.”
The foster mother opined that mother’s commitment to the
visits and telephone calls was influenced by the maternal
grandmother who told her to attend and to make the calls. The
foster mother felt that Thomas acted like a parent during the
calls with mother. She further observed that Thomas acted out
after mother disappointed him. She said “mother doesn’t seem to
see how she hurts him when she doesn’t answer the phone,
arrives late for a visit or blurts out bad news.”
According to the foster mother, Thomas looked forward to
coming home after a visit with mother and did not talk about her
or say he wanted to see her on any day other than the scheduled
weekly visit day. She believed Thomas’s “eagerness for the visit
is actually the ‘routine’ of visiting his mother and the worry that

14
comes with it because he doesn’t do well with change.” The foster
mother believed Thomas’s focus on visiting was not necessarily
because of his attachment to mother, but was due to his need to
have things go as planned. The foster mother also opined that
mother had not grown or improved, she continued to relapse, and
she kept “making the same mistakes that end up hurting”
Thomas.
DCFS concluded Thomas would be at high risk of future
abuse or neglect in mother’s care and recommended that the
juvenile court deny mother’s section 388 petition. In March 2024,
the juvenile court denied the petition. The section 366.26 hearing
was continued to July 2024.
In a July 2024 supplemental section 366.26 report, DCFS
informed the court that the foster parents still wanted to adopt
now nine-year-old Thomas, they were not interested in pursuing
legal guardianship, and they wanted a closed adoption. The
foster mother believed that “constant contact” was not beneficial
for Thomas. She opined that mother had a negative impact on
him. When a social worker commented that the court would like
to continue Thomas’s visits with mother and the maternal
grandmother because there was a bond between them, the foster
mother responded: “ ‘There is no bond. [Thomas] is autistic and
this is just routine for him.’ ”
According to the foster mother, when the longtime
visitation monitor told Thomas that he would be having his last
visit with mother, Thomas was “fine” and had no reaction. The
foster mother also reported that mother displayed “odd behavior”
during her telephone calls with Thomas and inappropriately
discussed case information with him. In a later conversation, the
foster mother told a social worker that she believed Thomas’s

15
visits with mother were detrimental to him. She repeated that
there was no bond between Thomas and mother and asserted
that mother went weeks without calling him. Mother had not
had a visit with Thomas since April 2024, after DCFS stopped
providing a monitor for the visits.
In an update on recent visitation, DCFS reported that
mother missed two visits in April 2024 because she was
reportedly ill. Only the maternal grandmother visited. On
Thomas’s birthday in mid-May, mother attempted to call Thomas
three times during the day, while he was at school. When
Thomas got home, he called mother, who said she would call him
back. She did not. When Thomas called her again later, mother
answered the phone, said, “ ‘I’m smoking,’ ” and hung up. DCFS
continued to recommend termination of parental rights.
In early June 2024, the foster mother reported that mother
and the maternal grandmother showed up at the church the
foster parents and Thomas attended. Mother “threw a fit and
was crying and yelling and was asked to leave.”
In July 2024, one of the social workers told the foster
mother that DCFS was concerned that Thomas’s mental health
might be negatively affected after the adoption was finalized
because a closed adoption would cut off all contact with his
biological family. The foster mother subsequently agreed that
Thomas could call mother and the maternal grandmother on
birthdays—theirs and his—and that he could ask for permission
to call them at other times. The foster mother said she was
comfortable with Thomas having contact with his biological
family after the adoption was finalized, so long as the contact was
“child led.”

16
Section 366.26 Hearing
Thomas testified at the July 2024 section 366.26 hearing.
He explained that he calls the foster parents “mother” and
“father” and he likes living with them because they “mean a lot”
to him. When asked if the social worker or his therapist had
explained to him that the judge had to make a decision about
where he would live and whether he would keep having visits
with mother, Thomas answered: “Yes. And I do want to still have
visits. [¶] . . . [¶] Because I want to spend more time with my
mom and my grandma. [¶] . . . [¶] They just mean a lot to me.
That’s why.” He said he would be sad if the judge said he could
not see them anymore. He testified that if it were up to him, he
would live with his own family. He explained: “Because I really
miss my own family. If there is one thing I’m still sad about, it’s
about my grandpa because something made me sad about him,
like he died.” He testified that he talked to mother on the phone
“sometimes, not that much.” After his testimony, Thomas sat in
mother’s lap with his face buried in her neck. According to
Thomas’s counsel, he was crying.
A social worker who had serviced the case for two years
also testified. She indicated she had no concern about the effect
the termination of parental rights would have on Thomas’s
physical or emotional well-being. She did not believe it would
have any effect “[b]ased on the fact that we have arranged for a
level of visitation after, that is pretty much in line with what’s
been going on, I think he’ll—he won’t notice the difference.”
When asked if she would have concerns about terminating
parental rights if she knew Thomas’s visits would not continue,
the social worker answered: “Yes. That’s why I called for myself
and worked it out for myself.”

17
The social worker opined that permanently severing
relations between Thomas and his family would have a
detrimental effect on him. But when asked specifically about
severing the relationship with mother, the social worker testified:
“I can’t predict the future, but Thomas is bonded to his family, to
people, not just his mom.” She had observed that when Thomas
saw his mother that morning at the courthouse, he ran up to her
and gave her a hug. However, when he saw the foster mother
arrive in her car to pick him up from court, “he ran to her, said
‘Mommy’ and gave her a big hug.” His actions were nearly
identical with both women. The social worker testified that
Thomas received benefits from being in the foster parents’ home,
namely “consistent love, safety, the stability of a sober parent,
the reliability that comes with having a sober parent, who is
ready and willing to be present.”
During the arguments of counsel, the juvenile court
indicated that it was “assuming that if the court goes along with
the Department’s recommendation to terminate parental rights,
the court is assuming that [Thomas] will no longer see his
mother.” The court found Thomas credible, except for his
perception of time. The court also found the foster mother
credible “for the most part,” noting that her statements were
corroborated by parties who were either independent or did not
have a bias or motive to lie. The court disagreed with the foster
mother’s assessment that Thomas and mother did not have a
bond. But the court also noted that the foster mother had been
caring for Thomas since January 2022, and “she is frankly in a
better position to know what makes [Thomas] tick than the
court.”

18
The court reviewed the reports of mother’s visitation and
concluded she had attended around 57 percent of her visits from
June 2021 through December 2023. The court noted mother
missed all of her scheduled visits in June 2021, most of July
2021, and half of August 2021. She missed all of her visits in
January, March, June, and July 2022. She did not consistently
begin visiting Thomas until January 2023. The court rejected the
visitation monitor’s statement that mother’s visitation was
consistent. Although mother’s visits became more regular
throughout 2023 and “possibly 2024,” the court found mother had
not shown consistent visitation.
Despite that finding, the court considered the other
elements of the parental benefit exception to adoption. The court
found Thomas has a “substantial, emotional attachment to
mother and that he would benefit from continuing the
relationship.”
To evaluate detriment, the court considered that the foster
parents had cared for Thomas through his challenging behaviors,
ensuring that he received services, and, because of their care,
Thomas had adjusted well. The court noted instances when the
foster mother had helped Thomas “restore his emotional balance
after a disappointing visit with his mother.” The court
acknowledged that “the caregiver’s ability to regulate [Thomas]
after visits may differ from guiding him from the complete
termination . . . of his relationship with his mother and
grandmother for that matter . . . .” However, the past incidents
suggested to the court that the foster mother could provide
support in the future and Thomas could manage disappointment.
The court also noted the improvement in Thomas’s behavioral
issues. It attributed “his immense progress to the care and

19
stability provided by his caregivers and expect[ed] that it will
continue even if his mother’s parental rights are terminated.”
The court reasoned that Thomas has a strong bond with the
caregivers and he spoke highly about the entire foster family.
The court thus concluded: “Considering the care and
stability the caregivers have provided for Thomas and [mother’s]
inconsistent ability to set healthy boundaries, her ongoing issues
with substance abuse, and issues with considering [Thomas’s]
developmental issues, which previously negatively impacted
[Thomas], terminating her parental rights would not be
detrimental to Thomas, weighing against permanency and
stability that he will gain from adoption. [¶] Although the record
indicates terminating parental rights will lead to emotional
instability, sadness, or acting out as it has in the past when
[mother] made different promises, the court believes [Thomas’s]
progress in his different services along with caregiver’s ability to
support him through challenges will help him overcome any
negative impact of terminating his mother’s parental rights.
Thus mother has failed to establish the parental bond exception
exists and not meeting the third prong as termination of
relationship with [Thomas] is not detrimental weighed against
balance of having stability of adoptive home with [the foster
parents] who [are] bonded to him and his needs, including
tending to his challenging behaviors and ensuring he receives
services required, like therapy.”
The court found no exception to adoption applied and
terminated parental rights. Mother timely appealed.

20
DISCUSSION
I. The Parental Benefit Exception to Adoption
Once the juvenile court has terminated family reunification
services, the focus of the case shifts from reuniting the child with
a parent to providing the child with a permanent, stable
placement. (In re S.G. (2024) 100 Cal.App.5th 1298, 1313.) At
the section 366.26 hearing, if the court finds by clear and
convincing evidence that the child is likely to be adopted, the
court must terminate parental rights to allow for adoption, unless
the parent establishes that termination would be detrimental to
the child for one of several reasons set forth in section 366.26,
subdivision (c). (In re Caden C. (2021) 11 Cal.5th 614, 630
(Caden C.).) The “ ‘statutory exceptions merely permit the court,
in exceptional circumstances [citation], to choose an option other
than the norm, which remains adoption.’ [Citation.]” (Id. at
p. 631.)
Mother contends the juvenile court here erred by failing to
apply the parental benefit exception. Under section 366.26,
subdivision (c)(1)(B)(i), the juvenile court may choose a
permanent plan other than adoption when it finds termination of
parental rights would be detrimental to the child because the
parents have maintained regular visitation and contact with the
child and the child would benefit from continuing the
relationship.
In Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at page 636, our high court
explained that a “parent asserting the parental benefit exception
must show, by a preponderance of the evidence, three things.
The parent must show regular visitation and contact with the
child, taking into account the extent of visitation permitted.
Moreover, the parent must show that the child has a substantial,

21
positive, emotional attachment to the parent—the kind of
attachment implying that the child would benefit from continuing
the relationship. And the parent must show that terminating
that attachment would be detrimental to the child even when
balanced against the countervailing benefit of a new, adoptive
home.”
We review the first two elements for substantial evidence.
(Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at pp. 639–640.) We do “ ‘not
reweigh the evidence, evaluate the credibility of witnesses, or
resolve evidentiary conflicts.’ [Citation.] The [juvenile court’s
factual] determinations should ‘be upheld if . . . supported by
substantial evidence, even though substantial evidence to the
contrary also exists and the . . . court might have reached a
different result had it believed other evidence.’ ” (Id. at p. 640.)
We review the third element for abuse of discretion. We will find
an abuse of discretion “only when ‘ “ ‘the . . . court has exceeded
the limits of legal discretion by making an arbitrary, capricious,
or patently absurd determination.’ ” ’ [Citation.]” (Id. at p. 641.)
II. The Juvenile Court Did Not Err in Concluding the
Parental Benefit Exception Did not Apply
A. Regular visitation and contact
Mother contends the evidence was insufficient to support
the juvenile court’s finding that mother did not show regular
visitation and contact with Thomas. Mother relies on several
DCFS reports which, starting in August 2022, indicated mother
visited and contacted Thomas regularly. However, mother
ignores that the juvenile court explained that it had looked at the
number of visit opportunities and independently analyzed
whether mother’s visitation was regular and consistent, omitting
times when visits could not take place due to illness or other

22
similar circumstances. Based on that independent analysis, the
court rejected at least some of the reports’ summary statements
that mother consistently visited. Indeed, the court pointed out
that mother missed all of her visits in four months of 2022 and
did not begin to visit consistently until 2023. (In re Eli B. (2022)
73 Cal.App.5th 1061, 1070–1071 [record supported finding that
father failed to show regular visitation where he missed nearly
40 percent of all visits during two-year period after reunification
services were terminated and had significant gaps in visitation].)
Mother suggests it is unclear if the court was taking into
account telephone or other virtual visits. Yet, a September 2021
report indicated that mother routinely missed telephone visits
and, as of March 2024, mother called only sporadically.
Thus, while the evidence may have been in conflict, there
was substantial evidence to support the juvenile court’s finding
that mother’s visitation and contact with Thomas was not
regular. We need not affirm on this ground alone, however.
Despite finding a lack of regular visitation and contact, the
juvenile court continued to assess the other two elements of the
parental benefit exception. The court found mother established
that Thomas has a substantial, positive, emotional attachment to
her. We therefore turn to the third element.
B. Detriment
The juvenile court determined that mother did not show
that terminating Thomas’s attachment to her would be
detrimental even when balanced against the benefit of a new
adoptive home. We find no abuse of discretion.
The juvenile court acknowledged that terminating parental
rights would lead to Thomas experiencing “emotional instability,
sadness, or acting out.” Yet, the court also considered that

23
Thomas, with the assistance of the foster parents, had been able
to manage difficult feelings related to mother in the past and to
regain emotional balance. The court recognized that the
disappointment arising from mother not following through on a
promise to take him home would differ in magnitude from the
loss Thomas would experience from the termination of parental
rights. Still, the trial court reasonably interpreted the evidence
as suggesting “that the caregiver can provide support and that
[Thomas] can manage disappointment.”
Moreover, while the juvenile court did not credit the foster
mother’s opinion that there was no bond between Thomas and
mother, it found the foster mother’s other statements credible.
Indeed, as the juvenile court reasoned, the foster mother was
Thomas’s primary and daily caregiver. She observed that while
Thomas anticipated visits and talked about mother on visit days,
he did not mention mother on other days. Further, the foster
mother reported that when the visitation monitor told Thomas in
April 2024 that he was going to have his last visit with mother,
Thomas “was fine and had no reaction.” The foster mother
additionally observed that mother’s contacts with Thomas were
sometimes negative. Mother disappointed him by making
promises she could not keep, missed calls, told Thomas she was
calling because the maternal grandmother told her to, and
blurted out bad news in a way that hurt Thomas.
As the juvenile court noted, the foster mother’s
observations were corroborated by other evidence. A DCFS
report from August 2022 recounted that mother told Thomas she
would take him home, leading him to react violently and state
the mother hated him and “everyone” hated him. DCFS social
workers noted mother had to be reminded repeatedly not to share

24
inappropriate information with Thomas during visits, not to
make promises she could not keep, and not to simply “blurt out
bad news.”
In addition, the foster mother’s observation that Thomas’s
commitment to visits with mother was based on his desire for
routine, more than his attachment to mother, had at least some
support in the record. In a February 2023 report, DCFS informed
the court that although Thomas talked about going home to
mother, it mostly happened on the days of his visits. This was
consistent with the foster mother’s statements that Thomas did
not talk about mother at times other than visit days. The
visitation monitor also indicated that when, for example, a visit
did not take place because mother was too late, Thomas cried, but
was able to accept the situation. While there was evidence that
Thomas eagerly anticipated visits with mother, there was little
evidence that he had difficulty separating from mother at the end
of visits. At one point, DCFS reported that when the visitation
monitor picked him up for visits, Thomas confirmed both that he
would be visiting mother, but also that he would be returning
home to the foster parents. Indeed, even when opining that
Thomas would experience a “high amount of loss” if visits with
the mother and maternal grandmother ceased, DCFS explained:
“The child seems to respond well to his weekly routine, which
includes visitation. It is the [Department’s] assessment that
keeping his current routine as stable as possible will be a
valuable component to the child’s emotional stability.”
The juvenile court also appropriately considered the
significant benefits Thomas would receive in a new adoptive
home. The court noted Thomas had graduated from wraparound
services, he made immense progress which the court reasonably

25
attributed to the caregivers’ stability and care, and the evidence
established Thomas had developed a strong bond with the
caregivers. These findings were supported by the evidence.
Further, Thomas’s own statements and testimony
illustrated the benefits of the safety and security he stood to
receive in a new adoptive home. He called the caregivers “mom”
and “dad,” explained that he loved them, said he had everything
he needed in their home, and testified that they mean a lot to
him. A permanent plan short of adoption would risk removing
that sense of security and safety. Indeed, the foster parents
indicated they did not wish to pursue legal guardianship,
suggesting the possibility that Thomas would have to be moved to
a new placement if the juvenile court selected a permanent plan
other than adoption, or that he would face prolonged uncertainty
in foster care.
In Caden C., the court recognized that “understanding the
harm associated with severing the [parent-child] relationship is a
subtle enterprise—sometimes depending on more than just how
beneficial the relationship is. . . . Sometimes . . . a relationship
involves tangled benefits and burdens. In those cases, the court
faces the complex task of disentangling the consequences of
removing those burdens along with the benefits of the
relationship.” (Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 634.)
This was such a case. Thomas and mother have a loving
relationship that, even if not always positive, is one that Thomas
does not want to lose. Yet, there was also evidence that the
relationship is to some degree destabilizing for Thomas and that
the benefits of placement in a new, adoptive home are extremely
significant. We cannot conclude that “ ‘ “ ‘under all the evidence,
viewed most favorably in support of the trial court’s action, no

26
judge could reasonably have made the order that he [or she]
did.’ ” ’ ” (Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 641.)
In support of her argument on appeal, mother cites the
evidence of Thomas’s love for mother; his statements that she
made him happy, that he wanted to be with her, and that he
wanted to continue visiting her and would be sad if he could not.
However, the trial court recognized and acknowledged the
emotional attachment between Thomas and mother. The
existence of that relationship—illustrated by Thomas’s
statements that he wanted to continue visiting, that mother
made him happy, and that he missed her—did not eliminate the
need for the juvenile court to weigh the harm of losing that
relationship against the benefits of placement in a new, adoptive
home.
Mother also points to Thomas’s negative behaviors that
occurred after visits with mother as evidence that terminating
parental rights would be detrimental. Mother argues these
negative behaviors were “indicative of [Thomas’s] strong feelings
towards his mother” and “the solution to this concern is not to
fully sever the relationship.”
We note that the record did not lend itself to only one
interpretation of Thomas’s negative behaviors after visits with
mother. Mother appears to assert that Thomas engaged in
negative behavior after visits with mother because he was
separated from her. The foster mother, on the other hand, opined
that mother simply had a negative impact on Thomas and visits
caused him to decompensate, even if they were positive at the
time. Further, there was evidence that it was mother’s negative
behaviors that prompted at least some of Thomas’s responsive
negative conduct, such as mother missing visits, arriving late, or

27
promising that he could return home with her. To the extent the
juvenile court considered Thomas’s acting out behavior after
visits as an indication that severing the relationship with mother
would have some benefit to Thomas, we can find no abuse of
discretion. (See Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 635 [a trial
court might find that “terminating a relationship with negative
aspects would have some positive effects that weigh in the
balance—and may tip it in favor of severing the parental
relationship to make way for adoption”].)
Mother additionally relies on the DCFS opinion that
Thomas would experience significant loss if visits with mother
and the maternal grandmother ceased, and the social worker’s
testimony that severing Thomas’s relationship with mother and
the maternal family would have a detrimental effect on him.
Undoubtedly the opinions of the DCFS social workers who
serviced the case were important for the court to consider.3
However, the application of the parental benefit exception to
adoption required more than a finding that severing the

3 We note that while DCFS opined that severing the
relationship would cause Thomas a “high amount of loss,” the
agency also believed that adoption would give him a new sense of
stability and was in his best interest. We further note that both
DCFS and the testifying social worker failed to distinguish
between Thomas’s bond with mother and his bond with the
maternal grandmother, asserting the harm would flow from the
termination of the relationship with both. The juvenile court
could not base its decision about the applicability of the parental
benefit exception on Thomas’s relationship with the maternal
grandmother. (In re Andrew M. (2024) 102 Cal.App.5th 803, 817
[juvenile court erred in applying parental benefit exception based
on child’s relationship with members of the biological family
other than the parents].)

28
relationship with mother would cause Thomas harm. The
juvenile court understood that Thomas would suffer harm from
the termination of parental rights. But mother was additionally
required to establish that the harm Thomas would suffer would
outweigh “the security and the sense of belonging a new family
would confer.” (In re Autumn H. (1994) 27 Cal.App.4th 567, 575.)
Whether the termination of parental rights would be
“detrimental” to Thomas, in the legal sense of that word, was for
the juvenile court alone to decide.
Finally, mother contends the juvenile court considered
inappropriate factors when assessing whether the parental
benefit exception applied. The record does not support this
contention.4 Mother asserts there was no basis for the juvenile
court to conclude the foster mother could provide support to
Thomas in dealing with the loss of the relationship with mother.
Yet, the juvenile court could properly extrapolate from the foster
parents’ past support provided to Thomas in dealing with difficult
situations, even if they were of lesser magnitude than the
termination of parental rights. Further, we disagree with
mother’s contention that the foster parents’ contributions to
Thomas’s care were irrelevant to the exception. The juvenile
court appropriately considered the benefits Thomas had already
reaped from a safe, secure, and supportive environment, when
weighing the harm he would suffer from the termination of

4 Mother argues at length that DCFS’s opinions considered
improper factors, such as post-adoption contact and mother’s
inability to meet Thomas’s needs. Yet, the juvenile court did not
adopt DCFS’s opinions as its own. Instead, it conducted its own
evaluation of the evidence. That DCFS may have relied on or
discussed improper factors does not invalidate the juvenile court’s
independent decision.

29
parental rights against the benefits to be gained from a new,
adoptive home.
Mother additionally argues the juvenile court should have
rejected the foster mother’s opinions and observations and
asserts the court inaccurately assessed the strength of the
relationship between Thomas and the foster parents. On appeal,
we do not reweigh the evidence or second guess the factfinder’s
credibility determinations. The record provides no basis for this
court to conclude the juvenile court should have rejected the
foster mother’s statements in their entirety. Moreover, as noted
above, the record supported the juvenile court’s conclusion that
Thomas has a strong bond with the caregivers. We disagree with
mother’s argument that Thomas’s bond with his foster parents
was irrelevant. On the contrary, whether Thomas had developed
other family-like attachments was highly relevant to what his life
would be like in an adoptive home without mother in his life.
(Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 633.)
The juvenile court’s reference to mother’s inability to set
healthy boundaries and her ongoing issues with substance abuse
was also appropriate. As mother acknowledges, the Caden C.
court reasoned that a parent’s struggles with issues that led to
the dependency may be relevant to the extent they inform the
question of whether the child would “benefit from continuing the
relationship and be harmed, on balance, by losing it[.]” (Caden
C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 638.) Here, there was evidence that
mother’s inability to set healthy boundaries repeatedly led to
hurtful interactions between mother and Thomas during visits,
contributing to his emotional instability when he returned to the
foster home or after a virtual visit was over. The same was true
of mother’s continued struggles with substance abuse. Mother’s

30
ongoing substance abuse prevented her from having the
regularity in visits that, given Thomas’s need for stable routines,
was critical to his emotional well-being. The juvenile court
properly considered these factors when attempting to
“disentangl[e] the consequences of removing those burdens along
with the benefits of the relationship.” (Id. at p. 634.)
The juvenile court’s decision was well supported by the
evidence before it. Even if other inferences could be drawn from
the evidence, that alone does not authorize this court to interfere.
The juvenile court’s decision was not arbitrary, capricious, or
patently absurd. We affirm the juvenile court order.

31
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court order is affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL
REPORTS

ADAMS, J.

We concur:

EDMON, P. J.

EGERTON, J.

32

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.