CourtListener 10534912•In re A.S. CA5
Full text
Filed 5/6/25 In re A.S. CA5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIFTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
In re A.S. et al., Persons Coming Under the
Juvenile Court Law.
MERCED COUNTY HUMAN SERVICES F088690
AGENCY,
(Merced Super. Ct. Nos. 23JP-00146-A,
Plaintiff and Respondent, 23JP-00146-B)
v.
ORDER MODIFYING OPINION
R.S., [CHANGE IN JUDGMENT]
Defendant and Appellant.
THE COURT:
It is ordered that the opinion filed herein on April 21, 2025, be modified as
follows:
1. On page 13, under “DISPOSITION,” the sentence beginning “The
juvenile court’s orders” is deleted and replaced with:
This appeal is dismissed.
Except for the modification set forth, the opinion previously filed remains
unchanged. This modification changes the judgment.
FRANSON, A.P.J.
WE CONCUR:
PEÑA, J.
MEEHAN, J.
2.
Filed 4/21/25 In re A.S. CA5 (unmodified opinion)
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIFTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
In re A.S. et al., Persons Coming Under the
Juvenile Court Law.
MERCED COUNTY HUMAN SERVICES F088690
AGENCY,
(Super. Ct. Nos. 23JP-00146-A,
Plaintiff and Respondent, 23JP-00146-B)
v.
OPINION
R.S.,
Defendant and Appellant.
THE COURT*
APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Merced County. Donald J. Proietti,
Judge.
Lelah S. Forrey-Baker, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant
and Appellant.
No appearance for Plaintiff and Respondent.
-ooOoo-
* Before Franson, Acting P. J., Peña, J. and Meehan, J.
Appellant R.S. (father) is the father of A.S. (born in 2011) and T.S. (born in 2013)
(collectively, the children), who are the subjects of this dependency case. Father appeals
from the juvenile court’s September 10, 2024 orders at the Welfare and Institutions Code
section 366.261 hearing selecting legal guardianship with maternal relatives as the
permanent plan and denying his request for visitation with the children. On that same
date, the court also denied the paternal grandmother’s request for de facto parent status
and for placement.
After reviewing the juvenile court record, father’s court-appointed counsel
informed this court she could find no arguable issues to raise on father’s behalf. This
court granted father leave to personally file a letter setting forth a good cause showing
that an arguable issue of reversible error exists. (In re Phoenix H. (2009) 47 Cal.4th 835,
844.)
Father filed a letter brief arguing that the requests of the children that they live
with paternal grandmother were not considered; that it is detrimental for the children to
lose contact with father; and that the legal guardians have refused to work with paternal
grandmother and extended family on visitation. The letter concludes by asking that this
court “consider the children’s wishes in allowing contact and visitation with [paternal]
grandmother … and father.” We conclude father fails to set forth a good cause showing
that any arguable issue of reversible error arose from the hearing. (In re Phoenix H.,
supra, 47 Cal.4th at p. 844.) Consequently, we dismiss the appeal.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
Referral and Detention
On October 8, 2023, the Merced County Human Services Agency (agency)
received a call from law enforcement in response to a murder investigation. The
1 All further statutory references are to the Welfare and Institution Code unless
otherwise stated.
2.
children’s mother was deceased and father was being taken to the hospital. Law
enforcement released the children to the agency.
That same day, the agency spoke to paternal grandmother, who reported ongoing
domestic violence between mother and father. Paternal grandmother also reported father
had problems with alcohol abuse and had previously been in a rehabilitation facility in
2022. Paternal grandmother had been with the children that day, shopping and going out
to eat, and when they returned home, mother and father were gone.
The children were placed into foster care. While paternal grandmother was
considered for placement, the agency was unable to clear her for emergency placement.
Father was released from the hospital, arrested, and booked into the local jail the
following day, with criminal charges including murder.
The agency filed a section 300 petition on October 10, 2023, alleging the children
were described by section 300, subdivisions (b)(1) and (g), due to mother being deceased;
father’s perpetration of domestic violence and prior arrests for the same; father’s
untreated alcohol abuse; father’s incarceration and murder charge; and the lack of a
viable safety plan for the children with relative/nonrelative extended family members.
Attached ICWA-010 forms indicated no reason to believe the children were or are Indian
children, as reported by paternal grandmother.2
Father refused to be transported from jail and was therefore not present at the
detention hearing on October 11, 2023. Paternal grandmother, paternal step-grandfather,
maternal aunt Angelina, and a 15-year-old maternal half sibling were present at the
hearing. All relatives except paternal step-grandfather were asked about Indian heritage
and the juvenile court concluded the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA) did not apply.
2 Father later submitted an ICWA-020 form stating he had no known Indian
ancestry.
3.
The juvenile court found that the agency made a prima facie case that the children
came within section 300, subdivisions (b)(1) and (g), and ordered them detained. While
paternal grandmother requested placement, the court informed her it could not place the
children with her that day, but asked the agency to clear a relative home for the children
as soon as possible. A jurisdiction and disposition hearing was scheduled for
November 1, 2023.
Jurisdiction and Disposition
Father appeared at the November 1, 2023 hearing and again indicated he had no
known Indian ancestry. The juvenile court again found ICWA inapplicable. The
jurisdiction hearing was rescheduled to November 29, 2023, as the agency had not yet
filed its report.
At the November 1, 2023 hearing, the juvenile court suspended all communication
between the children and paternal grandmother, as the court had been provided
information that paternal grandmother was discussing inappropriate information with the
children. The maternal aunt caregiver, who was present at the hearing, was instructed not
to allow the children any unsupervised, unauthorized communication with any relative or
friend without permission from the agency. The court ordered the agency to follow up on
information it received about one of the children’s possible marijuana use.
Father requested the juvenile court authorize telephone calls for him with the
children, but the court stated it would address that issue at the continued hearing. In the
meantime, the court suspended all contact between father and the children due to the
criminal case that brought the matter into the dependency court.
At the November 29, 2023 hearing, paternal grandmother requested visitation with
the children. The juvenile court ordered that the visits remain suspended pending further
review at the continued hearing now set for January 3, 2024.
The agency’s report prepared for the jurisdiction and disposition hearing
recommended that father not be offered reunification services pursuant to section 361.5,
4.
subdivision (e)(1),3 and that the juvenile court set a section 366.26 hearing to select a
permanent plan for the children. The agency further recommended that the court order
monthly communication in the form of letters and photographs between father and the
children when the children were ready and if such communication was not detrimental to
them. The agency planned to schedule supervised monthly visits between the children
and grandparents if not detrimental to the children.
The children, who were placed with maternal aunt, were interviewed and reported
mother and father consumed alcohol multiple times a week, which caused them to
become “ ‘a whole different person’ ” and engage in arguing. A.S. reported not seeing
any physical altercations between mother and father as he would go outside when they
argued. He stated that he wished to stay with maternal aunt and did not wish to return
home. T.S. reported no domestic violence between mother and father, but also said she
was outside and did not really know what was happening. She felt safe with maternal
aunt, but did not know where she wanted to live.
Father agreed to participate in an interview on December 4, 2023. He reported
some past criminal history of domestic violence, but that all charges were dropped. He
admitted to recently being arrested and charged with the murder of mother. Father
admitted having an alcohol issue and stated he was drinking and blacked out on the day
mother died. He had previously participated in a rehabilitation program in Mexico from
November 2022 to January 2023. Father described several instances of domestic
violence and that the children at times had tried to intervene. Father did not know why
the agency was involved and said that his pending criminal case should not make a
difference in the children’s case because he was innocent until proven guilty and had not
been convicted.
3 Section 361.5, subdivision (e)(1) provides, inter alia, that if a parent is
incarcerated, the court shall order reunification services unless it finds by clear and
convincing evidence that those services would be detrimental to the children.
5.
The agency’s report detailed police calls from mother and father’s address,
including a suicide attempt by father, a violation of a restraining order, and
three domestic violence calls between July 2022 and July 2023. The next call occurred
on October 8, 2023, the date on which mother succumbed to multiple stab wounds.
The agency’s report stated that paternal grandmother’s home did not clear
emergency relative placement on October 10, 2023, as one member of the household did
not clear the criminal/child welfare portion of the screening process. The agency
submitted a referral to the resource family approval unit for processing paternal
grandmother’s placement request through the standard process. Father stated that he
wanted the children placed with paternal grandmother.
Father appeared at the January 3, 2024 jurisdiction hearing via video. Paternal
grandmother appeared in court with retained counsel Retained counsel stated that he was
also representing father in a civil nature outside of the dependency proceedings, but was
told by the juvenile court that he was not allowed to act as co-counsel for father in the
dependency case. The court declined to lift the no contact order between paternal
grandmother and the children, but asked the agency to look into it.
After paternal grandmother and her counsel were excluded from the hearing,
father submitted on the jurisdictional issues and requested a contested hearing on
disposition. The juvenile court found the allegations of the section 300 petition true, the
children to be juvenile dependents, and ordered the children removed from father’s
custody. The court did not lift the no contact order between father and the children
pending the next hearing. A contested disposition hearing on whether reunification
services should be bypassed was set for February 27, 2024.
Father was not present at the February 22, 2024 readiness conference, but counsel
represented that father would not be contesting the agency’s recommendations.
Father was present at the hearing on February 27, 2024, at which time he waived
his right to a contested disposition hearing, requested supervised phone calls with the
6.
children, and placement of the children with paternal grandmother. The juvenile court
bypassed reunification services for father, finding that providing such services would be
detrimental to the children. It found the current relative placement necessary and
appropriate, and continued to order no contact for the children with father and paternal
grandmother. The court requested a court-appointed special advocate (CASA) for the
children.
A section 366.26 hearing was set for June 20, 2024.
Paternal Grandmother’s Request for De Facto Parent Status, Petition to Change
Placement, and Challenging the Relative Placement
Concurrent to the jurisdiction and disposition hearings for father, several other
matters were filed by paternal grandmother: a request to be declared a de facto parent; a
section 388 petition to change the placement from maternal aunt to paternal grandmother;
and a motion to challenge the relative placement pursuant to section 361.3. All were
scheduled for April 9, 2024, and then, over the course of numerous continuances, to
July 30, 2024, which eventually coincided with the section 366.26 hearing.
Counsel for the children filed an opposition to paternal grandmother’s request for
de facto status, indicating that paternal grandmother lived two hours away from the
children from 2018 through 2023 and saw them only every other weekend but never
assumed a day-to-day role in their lives.
The agency filed an opposition to paternal grandmother’s request for de facto
parent status and placement of the children in her home. The agency argued paternal
grandmother did not meet the criteria to be designated a de facto parent under California
Rules of Court, rule 5.502(1), and placement with her would not be in the children’s best
interest. The agency detailed several phone calls between paternal grandmother and
father between October 2023 and April 2024. The agency informed paternal grandmother
that there was to be no communication between father and the children on October 11,
2023. On October 14, 2023, paternal grandmother expressed knowledge of that directive
7.
with father, and yet she allowed phone calls between the children and father on several
occasions during early unsupervised visits between paternal grandmother and the
children. During one phone call, T.S. broke down and could not speak due to crying;
during another call, father used profanity with A.S. and asked if he was going to “ ‘do me
like that’ ” by spending time with the child’s maternal half sister.
The agency filed a report pursuant to section 361.3 in which it recommended the
children remain in maternal relative placement and that the juvenile court deny paternal
grandmother’s request for placement, as paternal grandmother was aware of ongoing
domestic violence in the home since at least 2020 and knew about father’s substance
abuse issues, but did not file for guardianship of the children or attempt to remove them
from mother and father. Paternal grandmother had also allowed the children to speak to
father over the telephone after they were detained.
The agency reported that the children were doing well in the placement with
maternal aunt and uncle, and were receiving services. A.S. expressed a desire to stay
with maternal aunt as he feared paternal grandmother would hinder communication with
his mother’s side of the family. T.S. stated she liked living with maternal aunt and uncle,
but would like to live with paternal grandmother because she was more familiar with her.
She also said she was not opposed to staying where she was.
The social worker met with father, who said he wanted the children moved to
paternal grandmother’s home, for her to have legal guardianship of the children, and to
have the children returned to him if he is able to “beat” his criminal case. Father claimed
maternal aunt and uncle engaged in criminal behavior, used drugs, and only took
placement of the children for the money, allegations which the agency determined to be
unfounded. Maternal aunt and uncle had met the criteria for emergency placement back
in October 2023, thus allowing placement of the children with them when the children
were detained.
8.
Paternal grandmother’s resource family approval remained in progress as she had
not yet completed the requirements. The agency was concerned with paternal
grandmother’s ability to keep the children safe from father.
On May 30, 2024, the juvenile court held a review of case status hearing and
granted paternal grandmother’s request for written opinion from the children’s therapist
regarding contact with paternal grandmother and father. The court also approved a
request from the agency to administer psychiatric medication to A.S. on an emergency
basis to treat his posttraumatic stress disorder and sleep issues.
At a status review hearing on June 13, 2024, the juvenile court again denied father
and paternal grandmother’s requests for visitation, after counsel for the children stated
she had spoken to A.S.’s therapist, who recommended against visits.
De Facto Parent Request and Relative Placement Hearing
On July 30, 2024, the juvenile court first addressed paternal grandmother’s request
for de facto parent status. Paternal grandmother testified at the hearing, and the court
received into evidence a ledger showing paternal grandmother’s rental of a different
home for two months beginning in October 2023. A deputy sheriff testified in order to
authenticate jail call recordings between father and paternal grandmother.
The hearing was continued to September 10, 2024, at which time paternal
grandmother concluded her testimony. The juvenile court noted that father had been
bypassed for reunification services and therefore, had very little say, if any, as to the
children’s placement. The court did not find that paternal grandmother provided a regular
basis for the substantial care necessary to elevate her to de facto parent status and did not
act as a parent to the children on a day-to-day basis, and denied her request.
As for paternal grandmother’s request for placement, the juvenile court concluded
that the only reasons to remove the children from their current placement would be
because A.S. was not thriving and T.S. said she would rather live with paternal
grandmother, although she was not opposed to staying where she was. The court noted
9.
paternal grandmother’s admission that father had gang involvement as a teenager, and
that A.S.’s behavior issues predated his detention. Since the children had gone through a
very traumatic experience, the court did not think A.S.’s behavior was due to maternal
aunt and uncle’s care, and it refused to separate the siblings.
Addressing the section 361.3 relative placement factors, the juvenile court noted
that one factor outweighed all the others: the fact that mother was murdered, which
father was accused of, and that paternal grandmother maintained deep ties and
connections to father. The court denied paternal grandmother’s request for change of
placement, stating that it did not find credible paternal grandmother’s testimony that she
could divest herself from father’s control, and she could not therefore provide the
children with a safe, secure environment.
Section 366.26 Report and Hearing
In its June 20, 2024 report in anticipation of the section 366.26 hearing, the agency
recommended legal guardianship with maternal aunt and uncle and that dependency be
dismissed. The report indicated that the children were not generally adoptable due to
their older age, they were receiving mental health services, and A.S. exhibited specific
behaviors affecting his progress in school. The report also noted maternal aunt and uncle
were unwilling to adopt the children and one of the children had expressed a preference
for legal guardianship over adoption. The agency recommended proposed orders that
removal of the children from maternal aunt and uncle, whom they had been placed with
since October 11, 2023, would be detrimental to their wellbeing, and that father have
supervised visitation only if in the children’s best interests. Paternal grandmother’s
resource family approval application was still listed as pending.
The report repeated conversations with father in which he stated he wanted the
children placed with paternal grandmother in legal guardianship. It also repeated
statements from A.S. that he wanted to remain in maternal aunt and uncle’s home and be
adopted by them. In May 2024, A.S. had attempted suicide by ingesting medication he
10.
found in some of father’s possessions. He was placed on a section 5150 hold and
subsequently prescribed psychiatric medication. He later stated that he felt loved and
cared for by maternal aunt and uncle, especially after his suicide attempt. The report
repeated the statements of T.S. that she would like to live with paternal grandmother, but
was not opposed to remaining with maternal aunt and uncle.
The maternal aunt and uncle received criminal and child welfare history clearance
for foster and adoption certification from the resource family team.
The contested section 366.26 hearing was scheduled for July 30, 2024, in order to
accommodate father’s criminal hearing schedule. Father subsequently stated he would
submit on the section 366.26 recommendation, but the only issue going forward was his
request for phone calls with the children.
The section 366.26 hearing did not take place until September 10, 2024, at which
time the juvenile court found that removal of the children from their current relative
placement would be detrimental to their wellbeing and ordered them into a permanent
plan of legal guardianship with the maternal relative caregivers.
As for father’s request for visitation, the juvenile court concluded that, due to the
circumstances in which father was alleged to have murdered mother, the children should
not have contact with father, including any phone conversations, at this time, but
determined to leave the issue open in the future if the children expressed an interest in
contact with father. The court ordered no contact or visitation, direct or indirect, between
father and the children, subject to revision or modification at a later date, if appropriate,
by the family law court.
A hearing was set for October 2, 2024, to confirm that legal guardianship had been
effected and letters of guardianship had been signed, which would allow the court to
terminate dependency at that time.
Father filed a notice of intent to file writ petition on September 18, 2024, and this
court deemed the notice of intent a notice of appeal on September 26, 2024.
11.
DISCUSSION
An appealed-from judgment or order is presumed correct. (Denham v. Superior
Court (1970) 2 Cal.3d 557, 564.) It is the appellant’s burden to raise claims of reversible
error or other defect and present argument and authority on each point made. If the
appellant fails to do so, the appeal may be dismissed. (In re Sade C. (1996) 13 Cal.4th
952, 994.)
By the time a case reaches the section 366.26 hearing, the juvenile court has
determined, based on extensive evidence, that the dependent child or children cannot be
safely returned to the parent’s custody. At a section 366.26 hearing, if the court orders a
legal guardianship for the children, as it did here, “[t]he court shall also make an order for
visitation with the parents or guardians unless the court finds by a preponderance of the
evidence that the visitation would be detrimental to the physical or emotional well-being
of the child.” (§ 366.26, subd. (c)(4)(C).) By adding this statutory provision, “the
Legislature made clear its intent to require juvenile courts to make visitation orders in
both long-term foster care placements and legal guardianships.” (In re M.R. (2005) 132
Cal.App.4th 269, 274.) A court accordingly has a statutory obligation to make an order
for visitation at a section 366.26 hearing unless it affirmatively finds that visitation with
the parent would be detrimental to the child. (§ 366.26, subd. (c)(4)(C); see also M.R., at
p. 274 [under section 366.26, “the trial court was required to make a visitation order
unless it found that visitation was not in the children’s best interest”].) “Detriment
includes harm to the child’s emotional well-being.” (In re Brittany C. (2011) 191
Cal.App.4th 1343, 1357.)
Father, in essence, is contending the juvenile court failed to consider the detriment
a lack of visitation would have on the children. Father provides no authority for his
argument. Nevertheless, we have reviewed the record as it relates to the section 366.26
hearing and visitation and find no error occurred here.
12.
At the time of the section 366.26 hearing, a no visitation order was in place, based
on an earlier and continued finding of detriment to the children if visitation were to occur.
The juvenile court had before it evidence that earlier phone calls between father and the
children (which paternal grandmother had allowed despite a directive to the contrary) had
resulted in one phone call in which T.S. had broken down and could not speak due to
crying; and that during another call, father used profanity with A.S. and asked if he was
going to “ ‘do me like that’ ” by spending time with the child’s maternal half sister. At a
status review hearing on June 13, 2024, the court again denied father’s requests for
visitation after counsel for the children stated she had spoken to A.S.’s therapist, who
recommended against visits. And at the September 10, 2024 section 366.26 hearing, the
court addressed father’s request for visitation and concluded that, due to the
circumstances in which father was alleged to have murdered mother, the children should
not have contact with father, including any phone conversations, at that time, but
determined to leave the issue open in the future if the children expressed an interest in
contact with father. The court ordered no contact or visitation, direct or indirect, between
father and the children, subject to revision or modification at a later date, if appropriate,
by the family law court.
There was substantial evidence to support the denial of visitation. (See Fabian L.
v. Superior Court (2013) 214 Cal.App.4th 1018, 1028 [on substantial review, we
“ ‘review the record in the light most favorable to the court’s determinations and draw all
reasonable inferences from the evidence to support the findings and orders’ ”].) We
reject father’s claims to the contrary.
DISPOSITON
The juvenile court’s orders are affirmed.
13.
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.