In re T.N. CA4/3

CourtListener 10441962CalctappMay 1, 2025

Full text

Filed 5/1/25 In re T.N. CA4/3

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION THREE

In re T.N., a Person Coming Under
the Juvenile Court Law.

ORANGE COUNTY SOCIAL
SERVICES AGENCY,
G064851
Plaintiff and Respondent,
(Super. Ct. No. 24DP0591)
v.
OPINION
E.N. et al.,

Defendants and Appellants.

Appeals from orders of the Superior Court of Orange County,
Daphne Grace Sykes, Judge. Dismissed as to Defendant and Appellant E.N.
Affirmed as to Defendant and Appellant J.H.
David Dickey, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant E.N.
Sarah Vaona, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant J.H.
Leon J. Page, County Counsel, Debbie Torrez and Aurelio Torre,
Deputy County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
No appearance by the Minor.
* * *
E.N. (Mother) and J.H. (Father) appeal orders declaring their
son, T.N., a dependent of the juvenile court and maintaining his placement
with his maternal aunt. Targeting the disposition order, Father contends the
court prejudicially erred by applying the wrong legal standard in denying his
request to have T.N. placed in his care. We disagree and affirm that order.
Mother appealed various orders of the court, but her appellate attorney filed
a brief stating he was unable to find any issues to argue on appeal and asking
us to independently review the record for possible error as to Mother. We
decline that request and dismiss Mother’s appeal.
STATEMENT OF FACTS
I.
EVENTS LEADING UP TO T.N.’S DETENTION
This case has its roots in South Carolina, where T.N. was born in
2016. At that time, Mother and Father were unmarried and separated. They
remained estranged the first few years following T.N.’s birth, and Father had
virtually no contact with T.N. during that period. When T.N. was about four

2
years old, however, Father took care of him for a week or two while Mother
1
was receiving treatment at a mental health facility in South Carolina.
Upon leaving the facility, Mother lived with Father and T.N. in
South Carolina for a few months. But one evening in 2021, she absconded
with T.N. in the middle of the night and took him to California. Father called
Mother repeatedly to find out where she was, but his calls went unanswered.
He did not learn Mother’s whereabouts or talk to T.N. again until this case
2
arose in 2024.
As a single parent with mental health issues, Mother had a hard
time when she arrived in Southern California. She was able to reach out to
her mother and her sister, as well as other relatives who live in the area, and
at first they were willing to take her and T.N. into their homes and help
them. Over time, however, they developed concerns about Mother’s mental
health and drug use. When they confronted Mother with those concerns, she
became defensive and accused them of sexually abusing T.N. as part of a
pedophilia ring. This caused a huge rift between Mother and her family. It
also left Mother and T.N. without a place stay. They ended up going from
shelter to shelter until Mother was able to obtain a housing voucher for an
apartment in Huntington Beach in early 2024.

1
The record does not disclose why Mother was treated at that
time, but in this case, she reported she suffers from posttraumatic stress
disorder (PTSD), attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), anxiety,
and major depression. She also admitted she had a drug problem in the past
and is currently taking a variety of prescription medications for her various
mental issues.

2
According to a 2020 South Carolina family court order, Father
shares legal custody of T.N. with Mother. He did not, however, seek legal
recourse after Mother ran away with their child.

3
By that time, T.N., who has autism and speech issues that
significantly affect his communication and social interaction, was seven years
old and had already been enrolled in several different schools. His teachers
were concerned his lack of stability was hampering his ability to make
progress on his individualized education plan, but Mother was convinced
T.N.’s teachers were not doing enough to assist and protect him. She kept
T.N. home from school some days, and on the morning of May 2, 2024, she
sent the principal at T.N.’s school a rambling email that was so bizarre the
3
principal called the police.
That led to a welfare check at Mother’s apartment later that day.
During the check, officers noticed the apartment was dirty and unkempt. And
when they questioned Mother about T.N., her responses were incoherent and
paranoid. The officers ended up taking Mother into custody pursuant to
Welfare and Institutions Code section 5150, which authorizes a temporary
hold to permit a psychological evaluation of people who are considered a
danger to themselves or others.4 T.N. was taken to a children’s home for his
protection.
A few days later, respondent Orange County Social Services
Agency (OCSSA) filed a child welfare petition alleging Mother and Father
had failed to protect and support T.N. (§ 300, subds. (b), (g).) At the detention
hearing on May 7, 2024, the juvenile court determined there was sufficient

3
Among other things, Mother alleged in the email that someone
was hanging dirty laundry on the trees outside of T.N.’s classroom.

4
All further statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code, unless otherwise stated.

4
cause to keep T.N. at the children’s home. It also ordered OCSSA to provide
reunification services for Mother and Father.
II.
PROGRESS ON SERVICE PLANS
Over the next five months leading up to the October 2024
jurisdiction hearing, T.N.’s parents had varying degrees of success on their
respective reunification plans. Mother was resistant to therapy and drug-
tested only irregularly. She also accused OCSSA of mishandling her case and
continued to make unfounded allegations against her family and others.
When told T.N. was going to be placed with his maternal aunt (M.A.) in
Hemet, Mother objected on the basis M.A. and her husband had sexually
abused T.N. Finding no truth to that allegation, OCSSA placed T.N. in M.A.’s
care on July 1, 2024.
T.N. adjusted well to this placement and has been attending a
new school that serves his special education needs. Although he reported he
misses Mother, he did not have good things to say about Father. When
interviewed by the social worker, T.N. claimed Father was a “bad guy” who
had touched his “‘wiener’” and “‘butt.’” But T.N. had no memory of that
actually happening; he was merely repeating what Mother had told him. He
also said Mother had told him Father was dead. As it turned out, the
authorities found no evidence Father had physically or sexually abused T.N.
At the outset of his service plan, Father told his social worker he
wanted to reconnect with T.N. and have T.N. placed with him in South
Carolina. As the case progressed, however, Father struggled to keep up with
his plan. Despite having a past opioid addiction and current mental health
issues (PTSD and social anxiety), Father was reluctant to enroll in the drug
testing program, mental health services, and parenting classes that were

5
recommended to him by his social worker. Father felt those services were
largely unnecessary because he was already undergoing therapy and drug
testing through his own provider in South Carolina. His social worker was
concerned, however, because Father’s drug testing program in South
Carolina did not call for random testing. When Father finally enrolled in an
approved testing program, he failed to show up for all but one of his tests,
and the one test he did complete came back positive for marijuana.
Father also was slow to initiate phone call visits with T.N.
Blaming his busy schedule, health issues, and communication problems with
T.N.’s caretaker M.A., Father missed both of his scheduled calls in July 2024.
In August, Father threatened to stop participating in his service plan
altogether, unless M.A. was more accommodating of his schedule.
Father was particularly concerned about scheduling the calls
with T.N. around his work schedule. Despite repeated requests, however, he
did not always inform M.A. of his work schedule in a timely fashion.
Consequently, his first phone visit with T.N. did not take place until
September 4, 2024, four months after T.N. was detained. The visit went well,
and T.N. was happy to learn he had a father, but Father did not follow up on
the call. Even though he was authorized to have twice-weekly phone visits
with T.N., the next one did not occur until September 27. And in the wake of
that visit, Father was not receptive to the social worker’s requests for an
update on his service plan.
III.
THE JURISDICTION HEARING
Following several continuances, one of which was due to Mother’s
recent pregnancy, the jurisdiction hearing finally began on October 21, 2024.
At the hearing, Mother denied most of the allegations that had been leveled

6
against her. Although she admitted she had experienced mental health issues
in the past, she claimed they were sufficiently resolved to allow her to regain
custody of T.N. Mother also expressed great displeasure to the court about
the way her case was being handled. Insisting that OCSSA had abused her,
lied to her, and prevented her from telling her side of the story, she
threatened to report her case workers to the FBI. That was right before she
told the judge she was going to have a “fucking seizure” and abruptly left the
courtroom.
Father testified via Zoom from South Carolina. He admitted he
was not present at T.N.’s birth and has not been actively involved in his life.
However, he said that was because Mother fled with T.N. and he did not
know where they were living. Now that this case has come up, he wants to
make up for lost time and have T.N. placed with him as soon as possible.
Speaking to his ability to care for T.N., Father said that, like
T.N., he had a speech impediment while growing up, so he could relate to
T.N.’s situation and help him overcome his speech issues. Father also said
there is a school for autistic children close to his home that would be a good
fit for T.N. if he came to live with him in South Carolina.
Although he works long hours, Father said his employer would be
flexible if he needed to change his schedule to care for T.N. Father also
maintained he has a good support system of people who could help him look
after T.N., including his adult son from a previous relationship who currently
lives with him, as well as other relatives and friends.
Father testified he went through a rough patch in 2015–2016
while caring for his elderly parents before they died and said he still suffers
from PTSD and anxiety from that experience. But he has managed to get
those issues under control with the help of counseling. Father also sustained

7
severe neck and back injuries in a car accident around that time, and during
his rehabilitation, he became addicted to opioids that were prescribed to
relieve his pain. However, he said he was able to overcome his addiction by
completing a 12-step program and using the prescription drug Suboxone,
which he still takes on a regular basis.
As a condition of his Suboxone prescription, Father has had to
drug test regularly. He said he has tested clean the last four years, and the
only reason he tested positive for marijuana during his service plan in this
case is because he took a gummy supplement not knowing it contained THC.
In addition to continuing his drug testing, Father said he would be willing to
enroll in parenting classes and partake in any other services his social
worker recommended, so long as he could do them online and they were not
too expensive.5
Regarding visitation, Father testified he has had about five to
seven phone calls with T.N. since this case began, and their conversations
have been “going great.” In addition, his adult son has talked to T.N. and is
excited about the prospect of connecting with his half-brother. Father
admitted, however, he had not talked to T.N. much in the weeks leading up
to the jurisdiction hearing. He said that was because he had been working a
lot, his adult son had been in the hospital, and the time difference between
California and South Carolina was difficult to navigate.
Father also blamed his social worker and M.A. for not doing more
to facilitate visitation between him and T.N. To prove he was doing as much
as he could on his end, Father produced numerous text messages between

5
Father told the social worker he only makes enough money from
his job as a deli clerk to live paycheck to paycheck.

8
him, M.A., and the social worker. The messages show M.A. and the social
worker reached out to Father on numerous occasions to assist him with
visitation and other aspects of his service plan. They also show that, despite
some delays and grumbling on Father’s part, he generally was receptive to
these efforts. But despite the good intentions of everyone involved, Father
was having a difficult time squeezing T.N. into his hectic life.
Testifying on behalf of OCSSA, the social worker acknowledged
that Mother and Father miss T.N. and want to reunite with him.
Nevertheless, the social worker did not believe it would be in T.N.’s best
interest to be placed in their care at this time because T.N. has been through
a lot, he is currently in a secure placement, and he is receiving all the
services he needs to meet his needs, including therapy and special education.
Among other things, the social worker cited Mother’s mental health issues
and ongoing concerns about Mother’s potential substance abuse as reasons
for not returning T.N. to her care. Indeed, the social worker believed Mother
needed to make much more progress on her service plan before she could be
trusted to care for T.N. on her own.
With respect to Father, the social worker was worried T.N. did
not have a foundational relationship with him. She said children need “safe
consistency” in their lives, and moving T.N. across the country to live with
Father and other people he hardly knows would undermine that goal,
especially because T.N. has special needs and has been doing well in his
current placement.
Moreover, the social worker said that, despite her many efforts,
she had been having difficulty communicating with Father and had been
unable to assess his home or confirm he could meet all of T.N.’s needs. She
has reached out to Father on numerous occasions but has only spoken to him

9
on one occasion. And although they have texted back and forth multiple
times, she did not hear from Father at all in the weeks leading up to the
jurisdiction hearing. Father blamed this on his busy and ever-changing work
schedule, but the social worker was concerned about his lack of basic
communication with her.
The social worker also expressed concern about Father’s phone
visits with T.N., but it wasn’t the substance of the calls that troubled her;
rather, she was worried the visits were too inconsistent and infrequent.
Whereas Father claimed he had talked to T.N. up to seven times over the
course of the case, the social worker put the number closer to four. The social
worker also said she would like to see Father participating in parenting
classes and complying with random drug testing before T.N. could be placed
in his care.
IV.
THE JUVENILE COURT’S RULINGS
Based on this record, the juvenile court determined there was
sufficient evidence to sustain the allegations that Mother and Father had
failed to protect and support T.N. The court therefore declared T.N. a
dependent of the court.
The court then heard arguments on the issue of placement.
Counsel for OCSSA asserted it would be premature to return T.N. to the care
of Mother or Father at this time. While recognizing that might be an option
at some point in the future, counsel argued Mother was currently unfit to
care for T.N. and it would be “detrimental to [T.N.’s] emotional well-being to
release him to [Father] right away, given that there’s been [an] absence in
the last couple of years, minimal phone calls and contact.” Accordingly,
OCSSA’s attorney urged the court to “find by clear and convincing evidence

10
that return[ing T.N.] to either parent would be contrary to [T.N.’s] best
interest and there’s a substantial danger to his physical and emotional well-
being if he were returned home today.”
In so arguing, OCSSA’s attorney did not bring up the fact that
Mother had custody of T.N. at the time he was detained, while Father was a
noncustodial parent. But T.N.’s attorney did. She correctly pointed out that,
because Mother was the custodial parent when T.N. was detained, her
request to have T.N. returned to her care was governed by section 361, while
Father’s request for custody was governed by section 361.2 because he was
the noncustodial parent when this case arose. (Both statutes are discussed
more fully below.)
Citing the “unique circumstances of this case,” T.N.’s attorney
also reminded the court T.N. has special needs due to his autism and speech
delay and he had just become stabilized in his current placement with M.A.’s
family. Counsel contended, “To disrupt that again and to have [T.N.] restart
all of that in a new environment with people he . . . is not currently familiar
with . . . would be extremely detrimental to his emotional and mental well-
being.” T.N.’s counsel also voiced concerns about Father’s ability to protect
and provide for T.N. if the child were returned to his care.
In response to these remarks, Father’s attorney argued there was
insufficient evidence to justify keeping T.N. in his current placement, and
T.N. should be placed in Father’s care. Counsel’s argument was based on his
belief Father was making a good-faith effort on visitation and other aspects of
his case plan. He also relied on the fact Father was not the “offending”
parent, meaning he was “not the reason as to why this case was brought up.”
After hearing from all the parties, the juvenile court ruled, “The
welfare of the child requires that custody be taken from the parents and

11
vested with the Social Services Director for suitable placement.” In
conjunction with that ruling, the court found “by clear and convincing
evidence that [section] 361[, subdivision] (c)(1) and (5) appl[y] and to vest
custody with parents would be detrimental to the child . . . .”
Although the juvenile court denied Mother’s and Father’s
requests to have T.N. placed in their custody, it did authorize continued
reunification services and visitation for both. Citing Mother’s “significant”
mental health issues, however, the court ordered her to undergo a
psychological examination pursuant to Evidence Code section 730 as part of
her service plan. A six-month review hearing was scheduled for April 7, 2025.
DISCUSSION
I.
FATHER’S APPEAL
Father’s appeal is limited to the juvenile court’s disposition order.
He contends the court prejudicially erred by failing to expressly consider his
status as a noncustodial parent when making its order. OCSSA concedes the
court erred in this regard. However, it maintains Father forfeited his right to
raise this issue on appeal, and, in any event, the error was harmless. We find
OCSSA’s forfeiture argument unavailing, but we agree the court’s error was
not prejudicial.
As set forth above, the juvenile court cited section 361,
subdivision (c) in making its disposition ruling. As relevant here, that
provision provides, “A dependent child shall not be taken from the physical
custody of their parents . . . with whom the child resides at the time the
petition was initiated, unless the juvenile court finds clear and convincing
evidence” (ibid.) there “would be a substantial danger to the physical health,
safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the minor if the

12
minor were returned home” (id., subd. (c)(1)) or the child “has been left
without any provision for their support (id., subd. (c)(5)).
By its terms, section 361, subdivision (c) governs the removal of a
dependent child from a custodial parent, which in this case was Mother. Once
removal is ordered under section 361, section 361.2 then applies to placement
with a noncustodial parent, which in this case was Father. Section 361.2
states in pertinent part: “If a court orders removal of a child pursuant
to Section 361, the court shall first determine whether there is a parent of the
child, with whom the child was not residing at the time that the events or
conditions arose that brought the child within the provisions of Section 300,
who desires to assume custody of the child. If that parent requests custody,
the court shall place the child with the parent unless it finds that placement
with that parent would be detrimental to the safety, protection, or physical or
emotional well-being of the child.” (§ 361.2, subd. (a).)
OCSSA concedes the juvenile court did not expressly apply
section 361.2 as to Father, even though he was seeking custody of T.N. as a
noncustodial parent. Nevertheless, OCSSA argues Father forfeited his right
to raise this issue on appeal because he did not object on that basis when the
juvenile court issued its ruling. We do not agree.
Generally, a party who fails to raise an issue in the trial court is
deemed to have forfeited the issue for purposes of appeal. (In re Lorenzo C.
(1997) 54 Cal.App.4th 1330, 1338.) The rule is designed to encourage parties
to bring errors to the attention of the trial court so they may be corrected. (In
re Sheena K. (2007) 40 Cal.4th 875, 880–881.) The rule also guards against
gamesmanship because it would be unfair to both the trial court and
opposing counsel to allow a party to take advantage, on appeal, of an alleged
error that could have been addressed and/or corrected when it was originally

13
made in the lower court. (In re M.H. (2016) 1 Cal.App.5th 699, 713–714; In re
Dakota S. (2000) 85 Cal.App.4th 494, 501.)
Here, however, those fairness concerns do not come into play
because, although Father failed to apprise the juvenile court section 361.2
was the controlling statute for purposes of assessing his custody request,
T.N.’s attorney made that point clear in her argument. Quoting directly from
the statute, she properly recognized that, as a noncustodial parent seeking
custody, Father was entitled to have T.N. placed with him unless it would be
detrimental to T.N.’s safety or emotional well-being. Because this alerted
both OCSSA’s counsel and the juvenile court to the proper standard for
adjudicating Father’s placement request, the purpose of the forfeiture rule
would not be advanced by applying it here. We therefore turn to the merits of
Father’s argument.
As set forth above, section 361.2 requires a dependent child to be
placed with a noncustodial parent unless the agency can show such
placement would be detrimental to the child’s well-being. By creating a
presumption in favor of placement with a noncustodial parent, the statute
“furthers the legislative goals to . . . place a child in the care of a parent when
safe for the child, strengthen the child’s relationship with siblings and other
relatives, and avoid the child’s placement in foster care.” (In re Nickolas T.
(2013) 217 Cal.App.4th 1492, 1505–1506.) Moreover, “[t]o comport with due
process, the detriment finding must be made under the clear and convincing
evidence standard.” (In re C.M. (2014) 232 Cal.App.4th 1394, 1401.)
It is undisputed the juvenile court erred by failing to expressly
apply section 361.2 as to Father. Nevertheless, “‘[w]e cannot reverse the
court’s judgment unless its error was prejudicial, i.e., “‘it is reasonably
probable that a result more favorable to the appealing party would have been

14
reached in the absence of the error.’”’” (In re D’Anthony D. (2014) 230
Cal.App.4th 292, 303; In re J.S. (2011) 196 Cal.App.4th 1069, 1078–1079.)
For several reasons it is not reasonably probable Father would have obtained
a more favorable result absent the error.
First, despite not expressly referencing section 361.2 in its
disposition ruling, the juvenile court found by “clear and convincing evidence”
that “vest[ing] custody with parents would be detrimental to the child.”
(Italics added.) This shows the court had serious concerns about placing T.N.
with either Mother or Father and that, even though the court cited section
361 and not 361.2 in its ruling, it ultimately applied the proper legal
standard in evaluating Father’s request for custody of T.N. (See In re
D’Anthony D., supra, 230 Cal.App.4th at p. 303 [juvenile court’s findings
under section 361 demonstrated the court’s failure to apply section 361.2 was
harmless error].)
Second, reviewing the record as a whole, there is substantial
evidence that placing T.N. with Father in South Carolina would be
detrimental to T.N.’s emotional well-being, as contemplated by section 361.2,
subdivision (a). T.N. has had very little contact with Father during his
lifetime. In fact, T.N. did not even know he had a dad until he spoke with
Father over the phone in connection with this case. Granted, that was more
Mother’s fault than Father’s. And by itself, the lack of contact would be
insufficient to deny Father’s request to have T.N. placed in his care. (In re
K.B. (2015) 239 Cal.App.4th 972, 981.) However, the lack of any meaningful
bond between Father and T.N. is a factor supporting the juvenile court’s
finding that it would be detrimental for T.N. to be placed with Father. (See In
re A.C. (2020) 54 Cal.App.5th 38, 43.)

15
One of the ways Father could have tried to start bonding with
T.N. is by having consistent phone contact with him during the pendency of
this case. In the months leading up to the jurisdiction hearing, though,
Father’s phone contact with T.N. was minimal and inconsistent. Father
blamed that on his busy work schedule, among other things. But he also
testified his employer would be flexible in allowing him to modify his
schedule to accommodate T.N.’s needs. Apparently, Father never asked his
employer to change his schedule to facilitate phone visits with T.N., or his
requests were denied. Either way, the lack of phone contact between Father
and T.N. was a troubling sign in terms of Father’s ability (or willingness) to
make T.N. a priority in his life.
During his testimony, Father blamed T.N.’s caregiver M.A. and
the social worker for not doing more to facilitate phone contact between him
and T.N. Yet the record shows M.A. and the social worker repeatedly tried to
work with Father on this issue. But despite all their efforts, Father’s busy
work schedule and other circumstances in his life prevented him from having
greater phone contact with T.N. and forging a meaningful bond with T.N.
Father also dragged his feet when it came to signing up for the
parenting classes and the random drug testing program that were
recommended to him by the social worker. And when he finally did submit to
random testing, he immediately tested positive for marijuana. By his own
admission, Father also has PTSD and anxiety, which may complicate his
ability to meet T.N.’s special needs. And his communication with the social
worker has been so spotty that she has not even been able to assess his South
Carolina home to determine whether it would be suitable for T.N.
Faced with all these issues, the juvenile court was rightly
concerned about removing T.N. from his current placement with M.A. and

16
her family at this juncture. Even if the court had expressly applied section
361.2 in making its disposition ruling, it is not reasonably probable Father
would have prevailed on his request to have T.N. placed in his custody.
Therefore, the court’s failure to do so was harmless error, and there is no
basis to disturb its ruling.
II.
MOTHER’S APPEAL
Mother’s notice of appeal identified the juvenile court’s
jurisdiction and disposition orders as the focus of her appeal. She also
challenged the court’s order requiring her to undergo a psychological
evaluation under Evidence Code section 730. As noted at the outset, however,
Mother’s appellate attorney filed a brief stating he was unable to find any
issues to raise on Mother’s behalf. Mother’s counsel asks us to independently
review the record for potential error and offer Mother the opportunity to
personally file a supplemental brief. But Mother does not have a right to such
review, and good cause for supplemental briefing has not been shown. (See In
re Sade C. (1996) 13 Cal.4th 952, 959; In re Phoenix H. (2009) 47 Cal.4th 835,
844–846.) Accordingly, we deny counsel’s requests and dismiss Mother’s
appeal.

17
DISPOSITION
Mother’s appeal of the juvenile court’s orders is dismissed. The
juvenile court’s disposition order is affirmed.

GOODING, J.

WE CONCUR:

MOORE, ACTING P. J.

MOTOIKE, J.

18

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.