In re C.E. CA5

CourtListener 10376150CalctappApr 10, 2025

Full text

Filed 4/10/25 In re C.E. CA5

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIFTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

In re C.E., a Person Coming Under the Juvenile
Court Law.

THE PEOPLE, F088284

Plaintiff and Respondent, (Super. Ct. No. JW119562-02)

v.
OPINION
C.E.,

Defendant and Appellant.

THE COURT*
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Kern County. Marcus Cuper,
Judge.
Courtney M. Selan, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant and
Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief Assistant Attorney General,
Kimberley A. Donohue, Assistant Attorney General, Eric L. Christoffersen and Chung Mi
Choi, Deputy Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
-ooOoo-

* Before Meehan, Acting P. J., DeSantos, J. and Fain, J.†
† Judge of the Fresno Superior Court, assigned by the Chief Justice pursuant to
article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution.
Minor C.E. contends on appeal that the juvenile court’s disposition order must be
reversed and the matter remanded because there is insufficient evidence to support his
commitment to a secure youth treatment facility (SYTF). The People disagree. We
affirm.
PROCEDURAL SUMMARY
On May 7, 2024, a notice of violation of minor’s probation was filed in Kern
County Juvenile Court pursuant to Welfare & Institutions Code section 777,
subdivision (a)(2),1, 2 alleging minor violated the terms of his probation by failing to obey
his parent.
On May 10, 2024, the juvenile court held an initial section 777 hearing. Minor
denied the allegation.
On May 22, 2024, the juvenile court held a readiness hearing. The court ordered
minor to remain detained in the youth detention center pending further proceedings.
On June 3, 2024, the juvenile court held a contested jurisdictional hearing. The
court took judicial notice of the two underlying petitions in case Nos. JW119562-00 and
JW119562-01, and all prior orders. The court found minor was a person described by
section 777. It ordered minor to remain detained pending a contested disposition hearing.
On June 17, 2024, the juvenile court held a contested disposition hearing. The
court found the available confinement time was three years and awarded minor 94 days
of predisposition custody credits. The court committed minor to the Kern Crossroads
Facility, a SYTF.
On July 1, 2024, minor filed a timely notice of appeal.

1 All statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions Code.
2 The record indicates that a petition against minor was filed on September 28,
2021, alleging minor committed felony elder abuse (§ 368, subd. (b)(1)), with an
applicable maximum term of confinement of three years.

2.
FACTUAL SUMMARY
Minor’s mother testified at the May 22, 2024 readiness hearing and the June 3,
2024 contested jurisdictional hearing on the section 777 probation violation petition in
case No. JW119562-02.
At the May 22, 2024 readiness hearing, minor’s mother stated,

“Right now, [minor’s conduct is] verbal because he’s on probation
and he knows that he can’t do anything else, but he just screams and yells
and tells me exactly how everything is going to go, and it’s always his way.
And it goes on every night for about an hour and a half, and then I’ve had
to lock myself in my room to get away from him. And then he tries to get
into my room, and it just is a continual attack pretty much on me,
sometimes, verbal attack. And I guess just swearing me out. And he’s even
admitted before that the only reason he’s not doing anything physically is
because he’s still on probation, but I have seen him control himself. So I
know he can do it.”
At the June 3, 2024 contested jurisdictional hearing, minor’s mother stated minor
“want[ed] to be in charge” all the time in their home. He frequently followed her around
the home and would not let her have any “peace.” She stated he was in a state of
“constant battle” and that she believed he was also stealing things from around the home.
She testified he would frequently “scream[ ]” at her, even when she said she did not want
to continue talking to him, and that she would lock herself in her bedroom to get away
from him. However, she said he would continue screaming at her from outside her
bedroom door and would attempt to unlock the door with a screwdriver.

She continued,

“It just depends on what he wants at the time and the day. It’s
usually at nighttime. Not always. But usually at night. And depends on if
he wants to go to bed or doesn’t want to go to bed or if he wants something,
and he wants his answer. And when I don’t give it to him, he just yells give
me the right answer now. Give it to me now. And it just continues to
escalate. And I say I’ve already given you an answer. I’m not going to
answer you anymore, and I just get quiet and that makes him angry. [¶] …
[¶]

3.
“He just gets more escalated at being angry. Because he’s on
probation, he doesn’t do anything about it except yell. [¶] … [¶]

“Well, in the past, it was because of physical abuse, but this time it’s
just that he won’t leave me alone and won’t stop yelling and bothering me.
And like I said, he just irritates me enough that I can’t take it anymore and I
just want to be left alone, but he comes to the door and screams through the
door or gets a screwdriver or something and tries to unlock the door. And I
ask him what are you going to do once you get in here? And he says, well,
I just want to talk to you, and I said, well, we’ve already talked.”
DISCUSSION
Minor contends the juvenile court abused its discretion when it committed him to
a SYTF. The People disagree. We agree with the People.
A. Background
May 24, 2024 Probation Report
The May 24, 2024 probation report recommended minor be committed to Kern
Crossroads Facility, a SYTF.
It stated minor’s mother submitted an application for petition on May 1, 2024,
stating minor failed to obey her, and that “ ‘I am afraid for my life every day [because of
minor] and never know what’s going to happen.’ ” She stated she filed the petition
because minor was out of control and “[she] was losing [her] mind,” and she did not want
to continue living under the same circumstances going forward.
It stated minor’s mother said all the circumstances that led to the petition were
true, and that she believed minor needed to be held accountable for his actions. However,
she stated she was interested in minor being enrolled in a treatment program, rather than
being held in custody. She also stated she believed the youth detention center would be
more appropriate for minor than commitment to a SYTF.
The report stated that since being placed on probation, minor had performed
marginally, and that despite being referred all the resources available to aid in redirecting
his behavior, he failed to do so. Accordingly, the report stated the probation officer “felt

4.
the minor need[ed] higher sanctions due to his failure to abide by the terms of his
probation.” The report recommended minor be committed to Kern Crossroads Facility, a
SYTF, because of his failure to obey his mother and the safety risk to his mother. The
report stated, “It is felt a long-term commitment to [a SYTF] will afford the minor the
opportunity to receive more intensive services, while affording him the tools needed to
redirect his behaviors upon his release.… [M]inor has been afforded multiple
opportunities to redirect his behavior and has failed to do so.”
June 17, 2024 Disposition Hearing
At the June 17, 2024 disposition hearing, the juvenile court committed minor to
Kern Crossroads Facility, a SYTF.
Defense counsel argued commitment of minor to a SYTF was not appropriate
because it would be the wrong environment for him. She stated minor had been using the
services offered to him and attempting to redirect his behavior, although not necessarily
with success, and had been attending school satisfactorily. She also noted that his
previous physically violent behavior towards his mother had ended and that he was
taking his medications and participating in counseling. She also argued he behaved well
in the youth detention center and asked the court to have minor remain there for an
additional period of time.
The prosecution explained minor was not suitable for commitment to camp based
on a previous incident involving animal cruelty. He argued that although the petition was
only for a probation violation, it was caused by the “same type of behavior that’s just
continuing.… [H]e’s still not obeying his mother. She feels she can’t control him.… [I]t
is just still the same behavior that’s persisting which hasn’t been remedied yet.” He
explained, “And as to why the [prosecution’s] requesting a commitment program is the
minor has had multiple opportunities in the [y]outh [d]etention [c]enter, but these
problems keep arising. They haven’t fixed anything.” He stated that although minor’s
mother was now asking for minor to be committed to the youth detention center, she

5.
originally “thought that a longer commitment program would be needed to hold him
accountable and help him rehabilitate.”
The juvenile court stated,

“All right. So I do recall this, and when I was reviewing this, my big
question was—because I do believe a commitment program is appropriate
at this time based on everything before me. I thought camp would be a
slightly less restrictive program, but I had forgotten about the information
that I highlighted in the previous report regarding the animal cruelty.

“So based on that, the Court has read and considered probation’s
report dated May 24th, 2024. I’ll make the following findings and orders
based on the information therein: The available confinement time is
three years minus 94 days credit for time served. [C.E.], already a ward of
the juvenile court, is continued on probation not to exceed his 21st birthday.
He has been tried on probation, in the custody of his mother, and in the
[y]outh [d]etention [c]enter and has failed to reform.

“Previous orders of the Court have not been effective in his
rehabilitation. Custody of the minor is taken from his mother and he is
committed to [a SYTF]. He shall remain in the [y]outh [d]etention [c]enter
pending delivery thereto and shall obey all rules and regulations of the
[y]outh [d]etention [c]enter and said [SYTF] commitment program. Upon
completion, he’ll be released to the custody of his mother. All prior orders
not specifically set aside or modified are to remain in full force and effect.”
B. Law
Section 202 provides:

“Minors under the jurisdiction of the juvenile court as a consequence of
delinquent conduct shall, in conformity with the interests of public safety
and protection, receive care, treatment, and guidance that is consistent with
their best interest, that holds them accountable for their behavior, and that is
appropriate for their circumstances. This guidance may include punishment
that is consistent with the rehabilitative objectives of this chapter.” (§ 202,
subd. (b).)
In deciding a minor’s placement, “ ‘the juvenile court [has] maximum flexibility to
craft suitable orders aimed at rehabilitating the particular ward before it.’ ” (In re James
R. (2007) 153 Cal.App.4th 413, 432; In re Carlos J. (2018) 22 Cal.App.5th 1, 7.)

6.
Dispositional orders must conform with the purposes of juvenile delinquency laws, which
are “twofold: (1) to serve the ‘best interests’ of the delinquent ward by providing care,
treatment, and guidance to rehabilitate the ward and ‘enable him or her to be a
law-abiding and productive member of his or her family and the community,’ and (2) to
‘provide for the protection and safety of the public ….’ ” (In re Charles G. (2004) 115
Cal.App.4th 608, 614.) To accomplish these purposes, the juvenile court “has statutory
authority to order delinquent wards to receive ‘care, treatment, and guidance that is
consistent with their best interest, that holds them accountable for their behavior, and that
is appropriate for their circumstances.’ ” (Id. at p. 615; see § 202, subds. (a), (b), & (d).)
When determining the appropriate disposition in a delinquency proceeding, the
juvenile courts are required to consider “(1) the age of the minor, (2) the circumstances
and gravity of the offense committed by the minor, and (3) the minor’s previous
delinquent history.” (§ 725.5.) It must “consider ‘the broadest range of information’ in
determining how best to rehabilitate a minor and afford him adequate care.” (In re
Robert H. (2002) 96 Cal.App.4th 1317, 1329.)
A disposition hearing record should reflect evidence that the proposed means of
rehabilitation will result in probable benefit to the minor, and that the goals of the
juvenile law could not have been met by a less restrictive placement. (In re Michael D.
(1987) 188 Cal.App.3d 1392, 1396; In re Miguel C. (2021) 69 Cal.App.5th 899, 906.)
“After finding that a minor is a [ward of the court], the court shall hear evidence on the
question of the proper disposition to be made of the minor. The court shall receive in
evidence the social study of the minor made by the probation officer and any other
relevant and material evidence that may be offered, including any written or oral
statement offered by the victim …. In any judgment and order of disposition, the court
shall state that the social study made by the probation officer has been read and that the
social study and any statement has been considered by the court.” (§ 706.)

7.
Section 875 governs the commitment of a juvenile ward to a SYTF, which
replaced the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation, Division of Juvenile Justice
as the most restrictive placement alternative. (In re Tony R. (2023) 98 Cal.App.5th 395,
406; In re J.B. (2022) 75 Cal.App.5th 410, 413, fn. 3; see § 736.5.) It provides, in
pertinent part, that to commit a minor to SYTF:

“(a)(3) The court has made a finding on the record that a less restrictive,
alternative disposition for the ward is unsuitable. In determining this, the
court shall consider all relevant and material evidence, including the
recommendations of counsel, the probation department, and any other
agency or individual designated by the court to advise on the appropriate
disposition of the case. The court shall additionally make its determination
based on all of the following criteria:

“(A) The severity of the offense or offenses for which the ward has
been most recently adjudicated, including the ward’s role in the
offense, the ward’s behavior, and harm done to victims.

“(B) The ward’s previous delinquent history, including the adequacy
and success of previous attempts by the juvenile court to rehabilitate
the ward.

“(C) Whether the programming, treatment, and education offered
and provided in a [SYTF] is appropriate to meet the treatment and
security needs of the ward.

“(D) Whether the goals of rehabilitation and community safety can
be met by assigning the ward to an alternative, less restrictive
disposition that is available to the court.

“(E) The ward’s age, developmental maturity, mental and emotional
health, sexual orientation, gender identity and expression, and any
disabilities or special needs affecting the safety or suitability of
committing the ward to a term of confinement in a [SYTF].” (§ 875,
subd. (a)(3).)
Where a ward has a multi-year history of failed placements, the court may order a
SYTF commitment to protect the minor and the public. (See In re A.R. (2018) 24
Cal.App.5th 1076, 1080–1082.)

8.
The standard of review in juvenile commitment decisions is abuse of discretion.
(In re Joey G. (2012) 206 Cal.App.4th 343, 346.) A court abuses its discretion when it
acts “ ‘in an arbitrary, capricious or patently absurd manner that resulted in a manifest
miscarriage of justice. [Citations.]’ ” (People v. Rodrigues (1994) 8 Cal.4th 1060, 1124–
1125, abrogation recognized by People v. Leon (2020) 8 Cal.5th 831, 848.) Reviewing
courts “ ‘must indulge all reasonable inferences to support the decision of the juvenile
court and will not disturb its findings when there is substantial evidence to support them.
[Citations.]’ ” (In re Lorenza M. (1989) 212 Cal.App.3d 49, 53.) Unless the record is
entirely devoid of evidence to support the court’s factual findings, the decision to commit
a minor should not be disturbed. (Nicole H. (2016) 244 Cal.App.4th 1150, 1154.)
“ ‘Substantial evidence’ is evidence of ponderable legal significance, evidence that
is reasonable, credible and of solid value.” (Roddenberry v. Roddenberry (1996) 44
Cal.App.4th 634, 651.) “ ‘ “In determining whether there was substantial evidence to
support the commitment, we must examine the record presented at the disposition hearing
in light of the purposes of the Juvenile Court Law.” ’ ” (In re Oscar A. (2013) 217
Cal.App.4th 750, 756.) Accordingly, “when we assess the record in light of the purposes
of the Juvenile Court Law [citation], we evaluate the exercise of discretion with
punishment and public safety and protection in mind.” (In re Lorenza M., supra, 212
Cal.App.3d at p. 58.)
C. Analysis
Here, there is sufficient evidence to support the juvenile court’s commitment of
minor to a SYTF.
The juvenile court heard counsel’s arguments and stated that it read and
considered the probation report.
The probation report recommended minor be committed to a SYTF because of his
failure to obey his mother and the safety risk to minor’s mother. It stated that since being
placed on probation, minor had performed marginally, and that despite being referred all

9.
the resources available to aid in redirecting his behavior when placed on probation, he
failed to do so. Accordingly, the report stated the probation officer “felt the minor
need[ed] higher sanctions due to his failure to abide by the terms of his probation.” It
stated minor’s mother submitted the petition for minor’s probation violation because
minor failed to obey her, and that she was “ ‘afraid for [her] life every day [because of
minor] and never kn[ew] what[ was] going to happen.’ ” She stated she filed the petition
because minor was out of control and “ ‘[she] was losing [her] mind,’ ” and did not want
to continue living under the same circumstances going forward. The report stated, “It is
felt a long-term commitment to [a SYTF] will afford the minor the opportunity to receive
more intensive services, while affording him the tools needed to redirect his behaviors
upon his release.… [M]inor has been afforded multiple opportunities to redirect his
behavior and has failed to do so.”
The juvenile court stated it was considering whether a SYTF was an appropriate
disposition for minor, “based on [all the evidence] before me,” as required by
section 875, subdivision (a)(3). The court then explained it had considered the less
restrictive, alternative disposition of camp, but that minor did not qualify for placement in
camp because he was involved in an earlier animal cruelty incident. It then stated that,
based on the information before it, it was placing minor in a SYTF, because “[p]revious
orders of the Court have not been effective in his rehabilitation.”
Here, the juvenile court’s statement that it considered the probation report, as
required by section 706, shows it appropriately considered the required factors under
section 875, subdivision (a)(3), as all of the factors under section 875,
subdivision (a)(3)(A) through (E) were discussed by the probation report in its
recommendation for minor’s commitment to a SYTF.
Pursuant to section 875, subdivision (a)(3)(A), the probation report considered by
the juvenile court discussed the severity of minor’s most recent offense, his probation
violation, his role in the offense, his behavior, and the harm done to the victim, his

10.
mother. It stated he was disobeying her to the extent that she was “ ‘afraid for [her] life
every day and never kn[ew] what[ was] going to happen.’ ” The court also heard her
testimony during the readiness hearing that she was so afraid of minor that she was
locking herself in her room most nights.
Pursuant to subsection (a)(3)(B) of section 875, the probation report also discussed
minor’s delinquent history and failures of previous attempts at rehabilitation. The
juvenile court confirmed it considered this factor, as it stated that “[p]revious orders of
the Court have not been effective in [minor’s] rehabilitation.”
The record also reflects the court’s consideration of section 875,
subdivision (a)(3)(C), of whether the “programming, treatment, and education offered
and provided in a [SYTF] is appropriate to meet the treatment and security needs of the
ward,” as the probation report stated, “[i]t is felt a long-term commitment to [a SYTF]
will afford the minor the opportunity to receive more intensive services, while affording
him the tools needed to redirect his behaviors upon his release.…”
Pursuant to subdivision (a)(3)(D) of section 875, the record also shows the
juvenile court considered “[w]hether the goals of rehabilitation and community safety can
be met by assigning the ward to an alternative, less restrictive disposition that is available
to the court.” Here, the probation report stated, “minor has been afforded multiple
opportunities to redirect his behavior [when assigned to an alternative, less restrictive
disposition] and has failed to do so,” and recommended minor be committed to a SYTF
because of his failure to obey his mother and the safety risk to minor’s mother. The court
also stated it had considered the less restrictive, alternative disposition of camp, but that
minor did not qualify for placement in camp because he was involved in an earlier animal
cruelty incident and that “[p]revious orders of the Court [placing minor in an alternative,
less restrictive disposition] have not been effective in his rehabilitation.”
Last, the record shows the juvenile court considered the requirement of
section 875, subdivision (a)(3)(E), to consider minor’s “age, developmental maturity,

11.
mental and emotional health, sexual orientation, gender identity and expression, and any
disabilities or special needs affecting the safety or suitability of committing” minor to a
SYTF, as the probation report discussed those factors and that minor’s mother wanted
him committed to a less restrictive, alternative disposition, and the court heard minor’s
mother’s testimony during the jurisdictional hearing that she would prefer he be
committed to an alternative, less restrictive disposition, despite earlier stating that she
thought that a longer commitment program would be needed to hold him accountable and
help him rehabilitate.
Minor also argues the juvenile court erred when it placed him in a SYTF, rather
than returning him to the youth detention center, because he had “already succeeded”
when placed in youth detention, showing placement in the less restrictive program would
be successful. However, as the court stated, it did not believe the youth detention center
offered the appropriate services to rehabilitate minor, and that the more extensive services
offered at a SYTF would be beneficial to him.
Accordingly, in light of the dual purposes of juvenile law to rehabilitate minor and
protect the public, there is sufficient evidence to support the juvenile court’s commitment
of minor to a SYTF. As the juvenile court’s statement reflects, the proposed means of
rehabilitation of committing minor to a SYTF will result in probable benefit to minor, and
the goals of the juvenile law of protecting the public, including minor’s mother, and
rehabilitating minor, could not have been met by a less restrictive placement. (See In re
Michael D., supra, 188 Cal.App.3d at p. 1396; In re Miguel C., supra, 69 Cal.App.5th at
p. 906; see Nicole H., supra, 244 Cal.App.4th at p. 1154 [Unless the record is entirely
devoid of evidence to support the court’s factual findings, the decision to commit a minor
should not be disturbed].)
DISPOSITION
The disposition order is affirmed.

12.

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.