In re A.L. CA2/5

CourtListener 10375337CalctappApr 9, 2025

Full text

Filed 4/9/25 In re A.L. CA2/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not
certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been
certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION FIVE

In re A.L., a Person Coming Under B335909
the Juvenile Court Law. (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No.
23CCJP03887A)

LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILY SERVICES,

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

D.C.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court Los Angeles
County, Cathy Ostiller, Judge. Affirmed.
Gina Zaragoza, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel and Avedis Koutoujian, Deputy
County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.

________________________________

D.C. (mother) challenges the juvenile court’s order
declaring A.L. (minor) a dependent under Welfare and
Institutions Code section 300, subdivisions (b)(1) and (c).1
Respondent Los Angeles County Department of Children and
Family Services (Department) contends the appealed
jurisdictional findings are supported by substantial evidence. We
affirm.

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND2

Mother and J.G. (father) are the parents of minor, born in
September 2014.3 During the relevant time frame, mother and
father shared custody of minor under a family law order, with
minor spending Tuesdays and Thursdays from after school until

1 All statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code, unless stated otherwise.

2 Consistent with our standard of review, we state the facts
in the light most favorable to the juvenile court’s findings,
resolving all conflicts and drawing all reasonable inferences to
uphold the court’s order, if possible. (In re R.T. (2017) 3 Cal.5th
622, 633.)

3 Father has not appealed.

2
6:30 p.m. and every other weekend from Friday to Monday with
father. All other times were with mother. The parents
exchanged custody outside a police station.

Initial allegations and interviews

The Department began the current investigation in October
2023, after a referral alleging mother physically abused minor by
hitting him on the leg. In his first interview with a social worker,
minor reported he had been sleeping, and mother woke him up
screaming “I’m tired of this fucking shit” and hitting him on the
leg. Minor reported that “mother was mad because of the court
things.” Minor began to cry and mother told him to go back to
sleep. Minor felt safe and comfortable at home with mother, but
wanted to spend more time with and live with father.
Mother told the social worker father was using the child
welfare system and law enforcement as a weapon against her.
Minor had behavioral issues; he would call mother a “fuckin[’]
bitch” and hit her when he was upset. Mother was scared to
correct minor because he would constantly threaten to report that
mother hit him, even though she did not. Mother was concerned
about minor and believed he needed help to manage the family
dynamic. Maternal cousin was also concerned about minor
because he was displaying signs of emotional distress such as
having a blank stare and being violent. The cousin felt minor
was stuck in the middle of the parents’ resentments, and she felt
minor made it difficult for mother to correct his behavior because
he was constantly threatening to tell his dad that mother hit him,
even though mother did not hit minor.

3
After father complained that the social worker was taking
mother’s side and calling minor a liar, the Department agreed to
conduct a second interview using different social workers.
During the second interview, minor stated his parents did not get
along and that his mother thought his father was “coaching” him,
but that was not true. Departing from statements made to the
first social worker, minor now stated that mother “is ‘abusing’
and ‘intimidating’ him and tells him to lie to police and social
workers. [Minor] stated he loves both his parents but feels safer
with his father.” Minor added that mother screams and curses at
maternal grandmother and spanks minor’s two year old half-
sister. Minor stated he was tired of talking to police and social
workers.
Minor’s elementary school principal said the parents’
relationship was volatile. Minor’s teacher described minor as
bright and capable, but also said he was physical with other
students and sometimes a pathological liar. The teacher said
mother and father made allegations against each other and were
using the child in the middle of their issues. Minor had never
mentioned any abuse by parents to either the teacher or the
principal.
A mental health clinician conducting a phone evaluation on
October 23, 2023 was concerned about minor’s behavior, as
mother reported minor had slapped her in the mouth the day
before, and minor was throwing things at mother and giving her
the middle finger during the interview. The clinician observed
mother to be overwhelmed. The clinician recommended intensive
behavioral intervention services and wraparound services for
minor, and also services for mother out of concern for mother’s

4
stress levels and mother’s belief that she was being watched by
father.
Minor’s doctor reported to the social worker that minor was
seen on five separate occasions between October 23 and
November 1, 2023. Mother and father attended the visits
separately. Medical staff was concerned about minor’s emotional
state, and the doctor had observed minor acting aggressively with
mother and then denying that he hit mother despite the doctor
having observed him doing so. Minor had also stated mother and
an older sibling had hit him.

Medications

Based on reports from mother and father, minor was likely
prescribed medication for ADHD after the Department began its
investigation. Father did not consent to administering
medication to minor, and minor’s version of events evolved over
time. Minor first told father and the social worker that he had
been strapped down and forced to take medications. Minor later
denied that he had made any such statements or had even
spoken to a social worker. Still later, when the social worker was
informing father about minor’s denial, minor interrupted and
contradicted the social worker’s account, stating “ ‘that they tied
him up with a rope.’ ” While father reported to the social worker
that he had taken minor to the emergency room for dizziness,
diarrhea, and vomiting after being forced to take medication,
mother denied giving minor any medication in the past week, and
also denied forcing minor to take medication.

5
Psychiatric hospitalization

On November 2, 2023, minor was taken by police to Olive
View-UCLA psychiatric emergency room after hitting mother
with a baseball bat. Mother called the social worker to report she
was in emotional distress and was driving behind the police car.
A police detective who was already working with the family based
on father’s prior child abuse reports expressed “strong concerns”
about minor’s emotional well-being, noting he was “acting out in
aggressive behaviors.” The detective had called father to inform
him of minor’s actions, along with mother’s report that minor had
tried to attack her with knives, but reported “that father was not
shocked at child’s behavior and did not seem to care if mother
was injured.” Minor was discharged on November 3, 2023, after
being observed with a calm demeanor and stating he had been
playing baseball with a friend in the house, had hit mother
accidentally, and was remorseful.
The social worker interviewed mother and minor privately
at mother’s home on November 3, 2023. Mother and minor
separately recounted that they got into an altercation after
mother took a phone away from minor, causing him to become
upset. Minor started hitting mother with his hands, and then
picked up a bat and was hitting her with the bat. Mother became
scared and called the police, who took minor to Olive View.
Minor reported that at the hospital, he was in a room alone, and
it felt good to be alone. He liked being in the hospital, the room
had a nice bed, and he got to watch cartoons. Minor also told the
social worker about an earlier incident where, after watching a
cartoon, he put tape over his eyes and mouth and was walking
around with knives to scare people in the home. Mother

6
separately confirmed the incident and showed the social worker a
video of minor holding butter knives, with blue tape over his
mouth and eyes.
Mother was worried about minor’s challenging behaviors,
explaining that he has run out into the street, would start hitting
her if she tried to prevent him from leaving the home, and would
touch things even after she warned him they were hot and he
could burn himself. Discussing a safety plan to mitigate minor’s
violent behaviors, mother agreed to have minor go to his father’s
home for the weekend, starting that afternoon, even though she
did not want minor to be with father for longer periods of time.

Petition and hearing

The Department filed a petition on November 13, 2023,
alleging minor was a dependent under section 300, subdivisions
(b)(1) and (c). Both counts were based on the parents’ ongoing
custody dispute and continuing accusations against each other of
coaching, abuse, or neglect of minor, and alleged that minor had
been subjected to numerous interviews with medical and mental
health professionals, social workers, and law enforcement, and
that minor had been placed “at substantial risk of suffering
serious emotional damage as evidenced by severe anxiety,
depression, withdrawal and aggressive behavior towards self and
others.”
At the adjudication hearing in January 2024, mother’s
counsel asked the court to dismiss mother from both counts. The
court sustained both counts against both parents, with some
amendments. The sustained b-1 count alleged that minor was
“subjected to numerous interviews with social workers, law

7
enforcement officers, medical professionals and mental health
professionals, as a result of ongoing allegations of abuse or
neglect to the child by both parents. The father has spoken
negatively about the mother in the presence of the child and the
mother has spoken negatively about the father in the presence of
the child. The child reported feeling sad being in the middle of
the parents’ custody dispute. The detrimental and endangering
situation created for the child by the mother and father, places
the child at substantial risk of suffering serious emotional
damage as evidenced by severe anxiety, depression, withdrawal
and aggressive behavior towards self and others.”
As amended, the c-1 count stated: “[Mother and father]
placed the child in a detrimental and endangering situation and
emotionally abused the child. Such emotional abuse consisted of
the child’s parents subjecting the child to numerous interviews by
law enforcement, [the Department], and medical professionals
regarding allegations of abuse of the child by the mother. The
father discusses the allegations of abuse by the mother in front of
the child. Furthermore, the father’s allegations of abuse of the
child by the mother remain unsubstantiated. The child has been
taken to urgent care multiple times and has been interviewed by
law enforcement and filed several police reports for alleged
assaults by mother [] or half sibling [G.]. Law enforcement has
designated one law enforcement officer to handle the father’s
continued complaints against the mother. The parents have
engaged in a contentious custody battle with ongoing turmoil and
stress for the child. Such conduct by the child’s mother and
father places the child at substantial risk of suffering serious
emotional damage as evidenced by severe anxiety, depression,
withdrawal and aggressive behavior towards self and others. The

8
detrimental and endangering situation created for the child by
the mother and the father, and the parents’ ongoing emotional
abuse of the children, places the child at substantial risk of
suffering serious emotional damage as evidenced by severe
anxiety, depression, withdrawal and aggressive behavior towards
self and others.” At disposition, the court ordered the parents to
participate in services and a mediation to assist with resolving
disputes over custodial time. Mother appealed.

DISCUSSION

Mother contends the evidence is insufficient to sustain the
juvenile court’s jurisdictional findings under section 300,
subdivisions (b) and (c). Mother acknowledges that father has
not appealed either jurisdictional finding, but asks us to review
the evidentiary support for the findings against her. While
mother does not contest that minor suffered serious emotional
harm, she argues that father caused the harm, and the court
erred in sustaining the section 300, subdivision (c), finding
against both parents, rather than against father alone. She also
claims there is nothing in the record to support the conclusion
that minor has suffered or is in danger of suffering serious
physical harm, a necessary prerequisite for a jurisdictional
finding under section 300, subdivision (b).

A. Justiciability

It is well settled that juvenile court jurisdiction attaches to
children, not their parents. (In re I.A. (2011) 201 Cal.App.4th
1484, 1491 (I.A.).) As a general rule, a jurisdictional finding as to

9
one parent is good as to both. (In re Briana V. (2015) 236
Cal.App.4th 297, 308.) Regardless of the outcome of mother’s
appeal, the juvenile court will continue to exercise jurisdiction
over minor. However, this court retains discretion to address the
merits of a challenge to a jurisdictional finding, even if
overturning that finding will have no immediate effect on the
assertion of jurisdiction. (I.A., supra, 201 Cal.App.4th at pp.
1494–1495.) Although “no single factor is necessarily dispositive
of whether a court should exercise discretionary review of a moot
appeal,” (In re D.P. (2023) 14 Cal.5th 266, 287 (D.P.)) appellate
courts often reach the merits when a juvenile court’s
jurisdictional findings could have consequences for the appellant
beyond jurisdiction, or when a challenged finding “is based on
particularly pernicious or stigmatizing conduct.” (Id. at pp. 285–
286.)
Mother contends her appeal is not moot because the
sustained jurisdictional findings against her will have
implications in future family law and dependency proceedings.
She alternatively asks us to exercise our discretion to review the
merits of her appeal even if it is moot.
We disagree that mother has identified “a specific legal or
practical consequence that will be averted upon reversal,” that
would require us to review an otherwise moot question. (In re
D.P., supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 266.) The court’s disposition order
kept the custody arrangement between mother and father the
same, and the possibility that mother would be impacted by the
sustained findings in future family law proceedings is negligible,
because the findings are against both mother and father. “[T]he
juvenile court must never, for illegitimate tactical reasons,
become a new front in a family law war.” (In re D.B. (2020) 48

10
Cal.App.5th 613, 622.) Nevertheless, given the nature of the
jurisdictional allegations, we exercise our discretion to reach the
merits of her appeal.
“ ‘When a dependency petition alleges multiple grounds for
its assertion that a minor comes within the dependency court’s
jurisdiction, a reviewing court can affirm the juvenile court’s
finding of jurisdiction over the minor if any one of the statutory
bases for jurisdiction that are enumerated in the petition is
supported by substantial evidence. In such a case, the reviewing
court need not consider whether any or all of the other alleged
statutory grounds for jurisdiction are supported by the
evidence.’ ” (In re I.J. (2013) 56 Cal.4th 766, 773.) We limit our
focus to the evidence in support of the finding under section 300,
subdivision (c).

B. Substantial evidence that parents’ volatile relationship
caused serious emotional harm

We review the juvenile court’s jurisdictional findings for
substantial evidence. “ ‘In reviewing a challenge to the
sufficiency of the evidence supporting the jurisdictional findings
and disposition, we determine if substantial evidence,
contradicted or uncontradicted, supports them.” (In re I.J.,
supra, 56 Cal.4th at p. 773.) “ ‘ “We do not reweigh the evidence
or exercise independent judgment, but merely determine if there
are sufficient facts to support the findings of the trial court.
[Citations.]” ’ ” (Ibid.) “Substantial evidence must be of
ponderable legal significance. It is not synonymous with ‘any’
evidence. [Citation.] The evidence must be reasonable in nature,
credible, and of solid value.” (In re Dakota H. (2005) 132

11
Cal.App.4th 212, 228.) “ ‘ “The ultimate test is whether it is
reasonable for a trier of fact to make the ruling in question in
light of the whole record.” ’ ” (In re Yolanda L. (2017) 7
Cal.App.5th 987, 992.)
The purpose of juvenile law “is to provide maximum safety
and protection for children who are currently being physically,
sexually, or emotionally abused, being neglected, or being
exploited, and to ensure the safety, protection, and physical and
emotional well-being of children who are at risk of that harm.” (§
300.2, subd. (a); see also In re Nolan W. (2009) 45 Cal.4th 1217,
1228 [the “goal of dependency proceedings is to safeguard the
welfare of California’s children”].)
Under section 300, subdivision (c), a juvenile court may
exert dependency jurisdiction if the child “is suffering serious
emotional damage, or is at substantial risk of suffering serious
emotional damage, evidenced by severe anxiety, depression,
withdrawal, or untoward aggressive behavior toward self or
others.” This jurisdictional ground authorizes intervention by the
juvenile court in two situations: “(1) when parental action or
inaction causes the emotional harm,” that is, “when parental
fault can be shown; and (2) when the child is suffering serious
emotional damage due to no parental fault or neglect, but the
parent . . . [is] unable [herself] to provide adequate mental health
treatment.” (In re Roxanne B. (2015) 234 Cal.App.4th 916, 921
(Roxanne B.).) In the first situation involving parental fault, the
Department must prove (1) serious emotional damage suffered by
the child, (2) offending parental conduct, and (3) causation. (In re
Brison C. (2000) 81 Cal.App.4th 1373, 1379; Roxanne B., at p.
921.)

12
Mother acknowledges that there was evidentiary support in
the record for the juvenile court’s finding that minor was
suffering serious emotional damage. Mother also admits that
there was evidence to support that father engaged in the
emotionally abusive tactics alleged in the petition. Nonetheless,
mother contends there was no substantial evidence to support a
finding that she—rather than father alone—had caused
emotional harm to minor.
Mother’s argument highlights the facts supporting father’s
culpability in causing minor’s emotional distress, but we are
unconvinced by her argument that there was no substantial
evidence that she too acted in ways that contributed to minor’s
emotional harm. Mother’s argument ignores the fact that it was
the conflict-laden dynamic between herself and father that either
caused, contributed to, or aggravated minor’s emotional harm.
The Department’s investigation started after minor reported that
mother came into his room at night and hit and cursed at him.
Mother acknowledged that minor needed help with the family
dynamic, and that she was scared to correct minor because minor
would threaten to accuse her of violence. There was substantial
evidence that the relationship between mother and father was
volatile and they were unable to coparent minor. School
personnel described the parent’s relationship as volatile and that
the parents put the child in the middle of their conflict. Minor
also reported the conflict between the parents to the social
worker and that it made him sad to be in the middle.
Despite minor demonstrating increasingly volatile and
aggressive behaviors, mother and father had not been able to
reach agreement on medication for minor, so mother had not

13
given minor prescribed ADHD mediation even though minor was
hospitalized for hitting mother with a baseball bat.
The foregoing constitutes substantial evidence to support
the court’s decision to sustain the section 300, subdivision (c)
allegation against both parents, rather than against father alone.

14
DISPOSITION

The juvenile court’s order is affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.

MOOR, J.

We concur:

HOFFSTADT, P. J.

BAKER, J.

15

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.