In re G.G. CA6

CourtListener 10364781CalctappMar 26, 2025

Full text

Filed 3/26/25 In re G.G. CA6
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SIXTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

In re G.G., a Person Coming Under the H051524
Juvenile Court Law. (Santa Clara County
Super. Ct. No. 23JV46125A)

THE PEOPLE,

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

G.G.,

Defendant and Appellant.

The juvenile court adjudged the minor, G.G., a ward of the court after sustaining
an allegation that G.G. committed second degree robbery (Pen. Code, § 211).1 The
juvenile court found not true an allegation that G.G. personally used a handgun in the
commission of the robbery (§ 12022.53, subd. (b)).
G.G. asserts that substantial evidence does not support the finding that he
committed second degree robbery. We will affirm the judgment.

1
Unspecified statutory references are to the Penal Code.
I. BACKGROUND
A juvenile wardship petition alleged that G.G. committed second degree robbery
(§ 211) and that he personally used a handgun in the commission of the robbery
(§ 12022.53, subd. (b)). At the contested jurisdictional hearing, a gas station/convenience
store clerk testified that two juveniles entered the store. The clerk testified that after a
while, the two juveniles brought a drink and a bag of chips to the counter. The clerk
testified that the two juveniles told him their items were free and he responded that they
needed to pay. A third juvenile wearing a hooded sweatshirt featuring the letters “GAP”
then came into the store and asked the other two what was taking so long. The clerk
testified that as he was setting the items aside, one of the juveniles grabbed a bag of chips
and the group left the store. The clerk initially testified that the third juvenile with the
“GAP” sweatshirt—later identified as G.G.—was the one who grabbed the bag of chips.
However, on cross-examination, the clerk testified that the third juvenile did not take
anything.
The store’s manager testified that the clerk alerted him to the situation, and that as
he came out from his office, he saw the three juveniles leaving the store. The manager
testified that he ran after the three juveniles. Outside the store, the manager testified, one
of the juveniles had his hand under his shirt about waist high and said “stay away or we
will shoot you,” or words to that effect. The manager told police who responded to the
store that he saw this juvenile display a handgun. However, at the jurisdictional hearing,
the manager testified that he only saw “like a silver object” that could have been a
handgun but also could have been “like a buckle of belt or something else.” The manager
testified that his statement to police was the result of “panic.”
The manager repeatedly told police that the juvenile wearing the “GAP” hooded
sweatshirt was the one who displayed a gun and made the statement about shooting the
manager. At the jurisdictional hearing, the manager initially testified that he did not
remember what the person who displayed the object and made the statement was

2
wearing. However, after having his recollection refreshed with his statement to police,
the manager testified that the person was wearing a “Gap hoodie.”
On cross-examination, G.G.’s counsel asked: “Do you think that the person who
you saw have their hands under their sweater[] could have been someone that was not
wearing the Gap sweater?” The manager replied that he was “not sure” because he was
afraid at the time of the event. G.G’s counsel also asked the store manager on cross-
examination, “today do you think that it’s possible that one of the kids that didn’t have
the Gap sweater is the one that kind of made that gesture under their jacket, is that
possible?” The manager replied “[n]o” before stating: “I think, like, I’m not hundred
percent sure but it was wearing hoodie.” When G.G.’s counsel asked the manager to
clarify, the manager responded: “That guy was wearing hoodie.” G.G.’s counsel then
asked again: “[I]s it possible that the kid who was wearing the hoodie that was not the
Gap hoodie could have been the one who made the gesture, is that correct?” The
manager replied: “Yeah, maybe.” The manager testified that his perception may have
been affected by flashbacks of a prior robbery he experienced.
The prosecution also called three San Jose police officers. One officer testified
that when she contacted the store manager soon after the incident, the store manager
could not talk and was “breathing heavily” and “shaking.” This officer testified that the
manager’s demeanor “progressively got worse” to the point where medical attention was
offered and the manager had to sit down. The officer testified that the store manager
identified the juvenile with the “Gap gray sweater” as the one who pulled out a gun, and
that the store manager was “unwavering” on this point. This officer initially testified that
video from the store’s interior showed the third juvenile with the “GAP” sweatshirt take
the bag of chips while the other two also grabbed items. However, on cross-examination,
the officer agreed upon viewing the video that the third juvenile with the “GAP”
sweatshirt did not appear to take anything from the store.

3
A second officer testified that when he responded to the store, he viewed a photo
taken from the surveillance video footage and he identified G.G. as the person in the
“GAP” hooded sweatshirt based on his previous contacts with G.G. This officer testified:
“When they showed me the photograph I knew it was [G.G.] instantly.”
A third officer testified that police obtained a warrant to search G.G.’s mother’s
residence. This officer testified that in a bedroom identified as G.G.’s police found a
“gray hooded sweater with the letters gap, G-A-P” on top of a hamper. This officer also
testified that they found “10 BB guns and Airsoft guns” in G.G.’s mother’s bedroom.
G.G.’s father also briefly testified for the prosecution, identifying the residence at
which G.G. and G.G.’s mother lived. Video from the store’s interior was introduced into
evidence. No video from the store’s exterior was introduced.
The defense called one witness. Dr. Kathy Pezdek, a psychology professor, was
recognized as an expert in “cognitive psychology, eye[]witness memory and
identification.” Dr. Pezdek testified about seven factors she identified as potentially
impacting the accuracy of eyewitness identification in the instant matter. For example,
she testified that “[t]he presence of a weapon is a salient form of distraction” that “lowers
the probability of a correct identification,” and that “at a high level of stress your ability
to encode the details of that person are inhibited.” However, she also testified that if a
person in the store manager’s situation was looking at a person wearing a sweatshirt with
large “GAP” lettering on it, “that would be a notable detail that he probably has correct.”
Dr. Pezdek also testified on cross-examination that other factors that can negatively affect
eyewitness identification such as lighting conditions or alcohol and drug use were not
implicated in the instant case.
Following arguments, the juvenile court adjourned to consider the evidence.
When the matter resumed nearly three weeks later, the juvenile court sustained the
second degree robbery count. The court stated that it found all the witnesses to be

4
credible, and it noted that “Dr. Pezdek’s testimony was very enlightening and educational
also.”
The juvenile court stated that “it’s very clear to the Court that [G.G.] was the
youth that was wearing the Gap sweatshirt” based on the surveillance video and the
clothing found in G.G.’s room. The court found that the prosecution proved the robbery
allegation beyond a reasonable doubt, stating: “The property was taken, it was not his
own, taken from his immediate presence. Court believes that [G.G.] did use fear or force
in the asportation of the crime -- portion of the crime. And I’ll tell you, this part was not
a hard call for the Court[;] it’s pretty clear to the Court that [G.G.] participated in this
crime of second degree robbery.”
The juvenile court then found that the prosecution did not prove the personal use
of a handgun allegation beyond a reasonable doubt. The juvenile court stated that the
store manager stated “five to seven times” the night of the event that the person wearing
the “GAP” sweatshirt pulled out a gun. The court stated that when the store manager
testified at the hearing that he was not sure he saw a gun, the manager “seemed very
emotional, seemed like he was still scared.” The juvenile court stated that “[i]t’s clear to
me that the evening this happened [the manager] truly believed he saw a gun.” However,
the court stated that it “didn’t see any evidence that any gun had been found” because
“though there were . . . Airsoft type of guns found in his mother’s home, none matched
the actual description of the gun given by the witness.” The juvenile court stated that
with “the witness wavering and with no gun being shown to this Court I just can’t -- I
can’t find by beyond a reasonable doubt that [G.G.] did indeed use a gun.”
The juvenile court then stated that its finding regarding the personal use of a
handgun allegation did not affect its finding that G.G. committed second degree robbery.
The court stated: “But I do not doubt at all that he gestured and with a gesture either
reaching to his waistband or reaching under his sweatshirt along with the words of, you

5
know, stop or -- stop following or we’ll shoot or I’ll shoot, those two things combined I
think make up the fear that is a part of a second degree robbery charge.”
The juvenile court required G.G. to serve 10 days in the Community Release
Program, and the court released G.G. to the custody of his parents on probation with
certain conditions imposed.
G.G. timely appealed.
II. DISCUSSION
G.G. contends that substantial evidence does not support the juvenile court’s
finding that he committed second degree robbery, citing issues with witnesses’
identification. He asserts that the store’s clerk “incorrectly attributed the taking of
merchandise to the third juvenile wearing the GAP hoodie,” and that the clerk did not
witness the actions outside the store, so the clerk did not witness an act of robbery. G.G.
then argues that the store manger’s testimony was inconsistent with his statement to
police, because the manager testified that he was not certain whether he saw a handgun
during the incident and was not certain that the person in the “GAP” sweatshirt was the
one who made the gesture and statement.
G.G. notes that video surveillance footage contradicted witnesses’ accounts that he
was the one who took the bag of chips. He argues that the store manager’s statements to
police that the person identified as G.G. made the gesture and statement was a product of
the manager’s “highly emotional state” when these statements were made. He further
asserts that at one point in his testimony, the store manager testified that the “GAP”
wording was on the back of the sweatshirt rather than the front, thus rendering his
identification unreliable. G.G. also cites the testimony of Dr. Pezdek to argue that the
eyewitness identification of G.G.’s role in the incident was not reliable.
G.G. concludes by asserting: “A rational trier of fact would not rely on [the store
manager’s] prior statement to determine beyond a reasonable doubt that Appellant was
correctly identified as the juvenile who had made a gesture, but then go on to find that

6
Appellant did not personally use a firearm in apparent contradiction to that same
statement. [The manager] confirmed during his testimony that another of the three
juveniles could have been the juvenile who made the gesture. A rational trier of fact
would not have found beyond a reasonable doubt that Appellant was the juvenile who
made the gesture described by [the manager].”
The Attorney General responds by noting that an officer identified G.G. from the
surveillance video as the person wearing the “GAP” sweatshirt, and that the juvenile
court “reconciled the inconsistencies in the clerk’s and store manager’s testimony as
being the product of their fear.” The Attorney General asserts that the sole issue on
appeal is whether G.G. was properly identified, and that the credibility of witnesses is
the exclusive province of the trier of fact.
A. Legal Principles
“We review [G.G.’s] contentions using the same standard of review that applies
in adult criminal cases. [Citation.] Specifically, we determine whether substantial
evidence—‘evidence that is reasonable, credible, and of solid value’—supports the
juvenile court’s findings. [Citation.] We view the evidence ‘in the light most favorable
to the prosecution and presume in support of the [findings] the existence of every fact the
[court] could reasonably have deduced from the evidence.’ [Citation.] We ‘accept [all]
logical inferences that the [court] might have drawn from the . . . evidence’ [citation], but
reject inferences ‘ “based on suspicion alone, or on imagination, speculation, supposition,
surmise, conjecture, or guess work” ’ [citations]. We will reverse only if ‘ “it appears
‘that upon no hypothesis whatever is there sufficient substantial evidence to support’ ”
the [court’s findings].’ [Citation.]” (In re I.A. (2020) 48 Cal.App.5th 767, 778 (I.A.).)
“Robbery is the felonious taking of personal property in the possession of another,
from his [or her] person or immediate presence, and against his [or her] will,
accomplished by means of force or fear.” (§ 211.) Robbery has six elements: (1) the
defendant took property that was not his or her own; (2) the property was in the

7
possession of another person; (3) the property was taken from the other person or the
other person’s immediate presence; (4) the property was taken against that person’s will;
(5) the defendant used force or fear to take the property or to prevent the person from
resisting; and (6) when the defendant used force or fear, he or she intended to deprive
the owner of the property permanently or to remove the property from the owner’s
possession for so extended a period of time that the owner would be deprived of a major
portion of the value or enjoyment of the property. (See CALCRIM No. 1600.) “[A]
defendant who uses force or fear in an attempt to escape with property taken by larceny
has committed robbery. [Citations.]” (People v. Williams (2013) 57 Cal.4th 776, 787.)
“The crime of robbery includes the element of asportation, the robber’s escape
with the loot being considered as important in the commission of the crime as gaining
possession of the property.” (People v. Estes (1983) 147 Cal.App.3d 23, 27.) Thus,
“[i]t is sufficient to support the conviction that appellant used force to prevent the [other
person] from retaking the property and to facilitate his [or her] escape.” (Id. at p. 28.)
“Whether defendant used force to gain original possession of the property or to resist
attempts to retake the stolen property, force was applied against the [other person] in
furtherance of the robbery and can properly be used to sustain the conviction.” (Ibid.)
“[T]he willful use of fear to retain property immediately after it has been taken from the
owner constitutes robbery.” (People v. Flynn (2000) 77 Cal.App.4th 766, 772.)
B. Substantial Evidence Supports the Juvenile Court’s Finding
Substantial evidence supports the juvenile court’s conclusion that G.G. was the
third juvenile depicted in the video footage as wearing the “GAP” hooded sweatshirt.
An officer “instantly” identified G.G. as the person wearing this sweatshirt based on their
past interactions. In addition, a “GAP” sweatshirt matching that in the video footage was
found in G.G.’s bedroom.
The evidence did not demonstrate that G.G. physically took the bag of chips from
the store. While the clerk and an officer initially testified that the person wearing the

8
“GAP” sweatshirt was the one who grabbed the bag of chips, video footage demonstrated
that one of the other juveniles was the one who physically took the bag of chips, as the
witnesses acknowledged on cross-examination.
While G.G. was not the person who physically took the item, substantial evidence
supports the juvenile court’s finding that G.G. committed second degree robbery by using
force or fear during the asportation phase. The store manager was “unwavering” in
telling police that the person wearing the “GAP” hooded sweatshirt was the one who
pulled out what the store manager thought was a gun and who made the statement about
shooting the manager. At the jurisdictional hearing the manager testified that the item he
saw may not have been a handgun; however, he testified after having his recollection
refreshed that the person who made the gesture and the statement was the one wearing
the “GAP” hooded sweatshirt. The fact that the manager testified on cross-examination
that he was “not sure” on this point did not require the juvenile court to credit the
testimony on cross-examination over the manager’s statements to police and his
testimony on direct examination. In addition, even as he admitted his lack of certainty as
to the identity of the person who made the gesture and statement, the manager reaffirmed
that the person was wearing the “GAP” hooded sweatshirt.
The juvenile court concluded that issues with the manager’s testimony were the
result of the manager still being “very emotional” and “scared” during his testimony.
The juvenile court was in the best position to assess the manager’s demeanor and
credibility. “Conflicts and even testimony which is subject to justifiable suspicion do not
justify the reversal of a judgment, for it is the exclusive province of the trial judge or jury
to determine the credibility of a witness and the truth or falsity of the facts upon which a
determination depends. [Citation.] We resolve neither credibility issues nor evidentiary
conflicts; we look for substantial evidence. [Citation.]” (People v. Maury (2003) 30
Cal.4th 342, 403.) The witness testimony in this matter, combined with video footage
and discovery of the “GAP” sweatshirt in G.G.’s bedroom, provides substantial evidence

9
to support the juvenile court’s finding that G.G. committed second degree robbery. As
the prosecutor noted in argument, one of the other two juveniles was not wearing clothing
that could be mistaken for the “GAP” hooded sweatshirt. In addition, the second
juvenile left the store carrying items in each hand. This provides further support for the
juvenile court’s finding that G.G. was the one who made the gesture and statement
toward the store manager.
G.G. further argues that the store manager’s testimony is not credible in part
because at one point he testified that the “GAP” letters were on the “back side” of the
sweatshirt. However, the manager testified on redirect that the letters were on the “front
center” of the sweatshirt. We also disagree with G.G. that an inherent contradiction
exists between the juvenile court’s finding that G.G. committed robbery during the
asportation phase and its not true finding that G.G. personally used a handgun. The
juvenile court found that the store manager believed he saw a gun and that G.G.
threatened to shoot the manager while making a gesture toward his waist and displaying a
“silver” object. Even if the evidence did not prove beyond a reasonable doubt that G.G.
actually used a handgun, substantial evidence supports the juvenile court’s finding that
G.G. used force or fear through the threat of a shooting in the asportation phase.
G.G. also asserts that the store manager’s testimony is not credible because of
eyewitness identification factors identified by Dr. Pezdek. The juvenile court stated that
it considered this testimony, and it nonetheless concluded that the manager accurately
identified the person who made the gesture and statement as the person wearing the
“GAP” hooded sweatshirt. As Dr. Pezdek testified, a sweatshirt with large “GAP”
lettering would be a notable feature that the store manager “probably has correct.” While
G.G. argues that “the juveniles were similarly dressed and had a similar appearance to
one another,” a police officer had no difficulty identifying G.G. as the one wearing the
“GAP” sweatshirt, an item of clothing the witnesses found distinctive. Video from the

10
store revealed that neither of the other two juveniles had lettering on their clothing that
could be mistaken for the “GAP” lettering on G.G.’s sweatshirt.
The juvenile court’s finding that G.G. committed second degree robbery is
supported by “ ‘evidence that is reasonable, credible, and of solid value.’ ” (I.A., supra,
48 Cal.App.5th at p. 778.) Although the evidence showed that G.G. did not physically
grab the bag of chips, he used force or fear in the asportation of the item. G.G. does not
argue that he is not culpable for the robbery in any respect other than arguing that he was
not the person who made the gesture and statement. Viewed in the light most favorable
to the challenged order, substantial evidence supports the juvenile court’s finding.
III. DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s dispositional order is affirmed.

11
Greenwood, P. J.

WE CONCUR:

Grover, J.

Wilson, J.

H051524 People v. G.G.

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.