CourtListener 10364771•People v. Pardo CA3
Full text
Filed 3/26/25 P. v. Pardo CA3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THIRD APPELLATE DISTRICT
(Sacramento)
----
THE PEOPLE, C098996
Plaintiff and Respondent, (Super. Ct. No. 21FE015723)
v.
SUSAN PARDO,
Defendant and Appellant.
A jury found defendant Susan Pardo guilty of first degree burglary and assault
with a deadly weapon. On appeal, defendant contends the trial court prejudicially
violated her constitutional right against self-incrimination when it admitted into evidence
her statements to police made without a prior warning under Miranda v. Arizona (1966)
384 U.S. 436 (Miranda). Because the People demonstrate any alleged error was harmless
beyond a reasonable doubt, we affirm.
1
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
Late on September 11, 2021, Rick H. was at a casino while Nancy I. watched his
sons until he returned. At approximately midnight, Nancy was sleeping on the couch
when she awoke to defendant inside the house knocking on Rick’s bedroom door calling
for Rick’s son. Rick testified he had dated both defendant and Nancy before the incident
but was not in a relationship with defendant at the time and had just started to “talk[]” to
Nancy again after not dating her for seven years. Nancy and defendant had never met
before. Defendant and Nancy each testified they were in a “girlfriend/boyfriend”
relationship with Rick at the time of the incident. Defendant testified Rick had invited
her over, but Rick did not corroborate this testimony.
After banging on Rick’s bedroom door, defendant asked Nancy if Rick was home.
Nancy said he was not and told defendant to leave. Defendant left briefly and then
returned to introduce herself, say “negative things” about Rick, and warn Nancy to stay
away from him. Nancy again told defendant to leave.
Defendant testified that Nancy physically pushed her out of the house, but Nancy
denied this and testified she only “motioned [defendant] to . . . leave.” Home video
surveillance showed defendant telling Nancy, “Be careful . . . . Yeah yeah you should be
careful,” and Nancy responding, “[h]ead out the door. [K]eep movin’. . . . Just keep it
movin’. . . . I’m here with the boys, ’kay?” Nancy then locked the previously unlocked
door and went to Rick’s bedroom. Nancy called Rick and Rick told Nancy that defendant
was not invited to his house. After leaving Rick’s house, defendant drove to her house
and upon reflection decided to go back to Rick’s house to confront Nancy as to why
Nancy had pushed her. Defendant grabbed a hammer “in case [Nancy] wanted to hurt
[her].”
Before making her way back to Rick’s house, defendant left Rick three voicemail
messages at around 2:30 a.m. One message provided in part: “You’re fucked. That
bitch is fucked. I’m gonna break her fuckin’ knees, and I’m gonna break yours. . . . I’m
2
there at your house. You better . . . call the fuckin’ cops. Have your mom come pick the
kids up. . . . I’m gonna fuck you up. I’m gonna break her fuckin’ legs. Don’t let her
come at me with something’ ’cause guess what? . . . I’m not comin’ with rocks and a
sock. I’m comin’ with fire.” Another voicemail stated in part: “I’m gonna beat her . . . .
She’s gonna get her ass beat up.” Defendant attributed these voicemails to having “too
much to drink” that night.
Nancy testified she was on the phone with Rick in his bedroom when defendant
walked in and immediately “jumped on [her] and hit [her] in [the] head with a hammer.”
Nancy struggled for the hammer and in the process was hit with the “claw part” of the
hammer in her chest, back, and legs roughly six times. Nancy eventually took control of
the hammer and hit defendant, which ended the altercation. Nancy called 911 and told
dispatchers she was hit with a hammer while sleeping.
Defendant told a different story. Defendant testified she entered through Rick’s
unlocked front door and made her way to Rick’s bedroom since Nancy was not on the
couch. Once defendant entered the bedroom, Nancy “came towards [defendant], . . .
pulled the hammer from [defendant’s] sleeve and proceeded to beat [defendant] up and
hit [defendant] with the hammer.” Defendant did not “believe [she] fought back” but
testified she “fought for [her] life” and “did not try to fight [Nancy] . . . like two people
that engage and want to fight back and forth.” Once defendant got away from Nancy, she
went to her car and called 911.
Rick testified he was on the phone with Nancy during the altercation and heard
Nancy say “ ‘[o]h shit’ ” and “ ‘[s]he’s in my room,’ ” as well as sounds of a fight.
At around 4:14 a.m., Elk Grove Police Officer Evan Kwan was dispatched to the
scene of the incident. Upon arrival, Officer Kwan observed a car parked on the street
with defendant in the driver’s seat. Defendant had a laceration and blood on her head.
Officer Kwan approached defendant’s car, confirmed defendant’s name, and twice
requested she step out of the car. Defendant denied these requests because she felt as if
3
she could not comply. Officer Kwan asked where the hammer was, and defendant
confirmed it was in the house. While struggling to get her driver’s license out of her
wallet, defendant asked to go to the hospital and Officer Kwan said she likely would go.
Officer Kwan again asked defendant to get out of her car, to which defendant responded
she would not. Officer Kwan made no further attempts to get defendant out of her car
and indicated medical personnel would shortly arrive to tend to her injuries.
While waiting for medical personnel to arrive, Officer Kwan asked defendant what
had happened and why she was there. Defendant explained she was there to see Rick,
and Officer Kwan asked, “You came back with a hammer? . . . Why?” Defendant stated,
“Because I wanted to just hit her. For her being rude to me. Nothing to do with him. I
had it. She took it [from] me, and she hit me. And hit me and hit me, and I ran.”
Defendant further admitted she hit Nancy “because . . . [Nancy] pushed [her] out” and
she “just wanted to hit [Nancy] in the leg because . . . she was really mean.” Officer
Kwan clarified defendant’s statements and asked follow-up questions.
Once paramedics arrived, they began to treat defendant while Officer Kwan
continued to ask questions about the altercation. Officer Kwan stayed within six feet of
defendant while medical personnel treated her. Officer Kwan went with defendant in an
ambulance to the hospital, during which defendant continued to answer Officer Kwan’s
questions.
Before trial, defendant filed a motion in limine to suppress body camera footage of
her statements to Officer Kwan. The issue before the trial court was whether defendant
was in custody for purposes of Miranda. The trial court denied defendant’s motion and
found a reasonable person absent defendant’s injuries would feel free to leave
considering the interview setting, Officer Kwan’s conduct, and defendant’s injury
limitations.
At trial, the prosecution played an edited version of the body camera footage for
the jury that included several incriminating statements from defendant to Officer Kwan.
4
During closing arguments, the prosecution relied on the totality of the evidence when
making its case for conviction and, in rebuttal argument, emphasized how defendant’s
statements to police were inconsequential to its case. After 44 minutes of deliberation,
the jury found defendant guilty of first degree burglary and assault with a deadly weapon.
As to the burglary, the jury found true that defendant used a deadly weapon. The trial
court imposed a sentence of five years for the burglary conviction and attached
enhancement and stayed a three-year term pursuant to Penal Code section 654 for the
assault with a deadly weapon conviction.
Defendant appeals.
DISCUSSION
Defendant argues her statements to Officer Kwan should have been suppressed
because she was “subject[ed] to the equivalent of a custodial interrogation” in violation
of Miranda and, “[h]ad her statements to the officer been excluded, . . . the jury could
have concluded based on the testimonial evidence that [defendant] unlawfully entered
Rick’s house, not to commit an assault, but to commit a trespass, because there would
have been no evidence of [defendant]’s alleged objective to specifically harm Nancy that
morning with the hammer.” (Boldface omitted.) We disagree defendant was prejudiced
by the admission of her statements to Officer Kwan and thus do not need to decide
whether defendant was subjected to a custodial interrogation under Miranda.
Accordingly, we hold that any error in admitting evidence of defendant’s statements to
Officer Kwan was not prejudicial because the error was harmless beyond a reasonable
doubt. (Cf. People v. Thomas (2011) 51 Cal.4th 449, 498; People v. Cunningham (2001)
25 Cal.4th 926, 994.)
Admission of a defendant’s statements in violation of Miranda is subject to the
harmless error standard of Chapman v. California (1967) 386 U.S. 18. (People v. Sims
(1993) 5 Cal.4th 405, 447.) “That test requires the People ‘to prove beyond a reasonable
doubt that the error complained of did not contribute to the verdict obtained.’ ”
5
(People v. Henderson (2020) 9 Cal.5th 1013, 1029.) “Because confessions ‘ “[a]lmost
invariably” will provide persuasive evidence of a defendant’s guilt . . . , the improper
admission of a confession is much more likely to affect the outcome of a trial than are
other categories of evidence, and thus is much more likely to be prejudicial under the
traditional harmless-error standard.’ ” (Ibid.)
Our Supreme Court recognized that “erroneous admission of a confession ‘might
be found harmless, for example, (1) when the defendant was apprehended by the police in
the course of committing the crime, (2) when there are numerous, disinterested reliable
eyewitnesses to the crime whose testimony is confirmed by a wealth of uncontroverted
physical evidence, or (3) in a case in which the prosecution introduced, in addition to the
confession, a videotape of the commission of the crime.’ ” (People v. Henderson, supra,
9 Cal.5th at p. 1030.) “This requires that we make a judgment about the significance of
the statements to reasonable jurors, when measured against the other evidence considered
by the jurors independently of those statements.” (People v. Roberts (2017)
13 Cal.App.5th 565, 577.)
Here, defendant’s confession added little to the probative value of the overall
evidence and, contrary to defendant’s argument, her testimony did not support a finding
she lacked the felonious intent required of a burglary when considered with the rest of the
evidence.1 (Pen. Code, § 459 [burglary requiring entry into to the home with the intent to
commit a felony].) Rather, it is “ ‘ “clear beyond a reasonable doubt that a rational jury
would have found . . . defendant guilty” ’ ” absent the confession, and in light of her
testimony, because the independent evidence overwhelming supports the finding that
1 Defendant relies on her testimony to demonstrate prejudice. She fails to
acknowledge that even if her statements to Officer Kwan were inadmissible for the
prosecution’s case in chief because of a Miranda violation, the statements would have
still been admissible to impeach her testimony. (Harris v. New York (1971) 401 U.S.
222, 225-226.)
6
defendant intended to assault Nancy with a deadly weapon that morning. (People v.
Delgado (2018) 27 Cal.App.5th 1092, 1109.)
First, as the People argue, defendant left voicemails that unequivocally expressed
an intent to harm Nancy. Defendant specifically threatened to “beat” “[t]hat bitch,”
referring to Nancy. In another voicemail to Rick before the assault, defendant threatened
to “break” Rick’s and Nancy’s knees. In that same voicemail, defendant told Rick he
“better . . . call the fuckin’ cops” because she planned to “fuck [Rick] up,” break both of
his legs, and “break [Nancy’s] fuckin’ legs.” Defendant further suggested in the
voicemail she planned to bring a weapon, stating, “I’m not comin’ with rocks and a sock.
I’m comin’ with fire.” We agree with the People that defendant’s voicemails made less
than two hours before the altercation show defendant intended to harm Nancy with a
deadly weapon prior to her final return to Rick’s house that morning.
Second, the People point to video evidence from Rick’s home video surveillance
that corroborates defendant’s voicemail threats. The video surveillance captured
defendant warning Nancy to “[b]e careful” before her subsequent voicemails. This
further supports the conclusion defendant returned later that morning with the intent to
commit a felonious act against Nancy and not merely to verbally confront her, as she
testified. Akin to “videotape of the commission of [a] crime,” the home surveillance
footage and defendant’s voicemails affirmatively express an intent to harm Nancy that
morning, which would establish the requisite intent of burglary. (People v. Cahill (1993)
5 Cal.4th 478, 505; see Pen. Code, § 459.)
Third, as the People argue, Nancy’s testimony and evidence related to her injuries
also support a finding of defendant’s felonious intent. After the altercation, Nancy told
dispatchers that “[defendant] . . . hit her with a hammer” while “[she] was sleeping.” In
the same call, Nancy stated defendant told her, “ ‘I’m going to do this’ ” before “hit[ting]
[her] up side [sic] the head.” At trial, the jury was shown and Nancy testified to
photographs of injuries to her arms, leg, chest, back, neck, and head. Elk Grove Police
7
Officer Essam Vigil testified to seeing some of these same injuries when she arrived to
Rick’s house that morning thereby further corroborating Nancy’s testimony. Taken
together, defendant’s recorded statements before the altercation on the home surveillance
footage and voicemails, along with Nancy’s injuries and her 911 call, overwhelmingly
support the jury’s finding that defendant had the intent required for burglary.
Moreover, this is not a case where a defendant’s confession was the “centerpiece
of the prosecution’s case in support of a conviction,” but rather it was an additional piece
that further corroborated all the other evidence presented at trial. (People v. Cahill,
supra, 5 Cal.4th at p. 505; see People v. Polk (2010) 190 Cal.App.4th 1183, 1198
[holding that the defendant’s statements were used only for impeachment purposes and
the prosecution’s closing argument relied mainly on other evidence to support its case].)
The prosecution’s closing argument relied partly on defendant’s testimony and its
inconsistency with the body camera footage. But the prosecution also pointed to Nancy’s
911 call, the other three witnesses’ testimony, Nancy’s injuries, blood stains in the house,
and defendant’s voicemails to bolster its case for a conviction. The prosecution
specifically relied on defendant’s voicemails to argue that defendant’s “intentions [were]
clear that morning.”
In fact, the prosecution’s rebuttal closing argument addressed the strength of its
case without a need for the body camera footage: “Let’s assume we take away Officer
Kwan’s body cam and . . . defendant’s confession to him. . . . We would have a 9-1-1
call right after an incident happened where [Nancy] is hit in the head with a hammer and
calls 9-1-1. We’d have Nancy[’s] . . . testimony. We’d have . . . defendant on scene . . .
we’d have Nancy’s injuries. . . . [¶] And that would be beyond a reasonable doubt.”
Defendant’s intent was not proven solely by a confession, instead it was supported
through witnesses, physical evidence, video surveillance, a 911 call, and unequivocal
voicemail messages. It is also telling that the jury took only 44 minutes to find against
defendant on both counts. Accordingly, we conclude the People have “ ‘prove[d] beyond
8
a reasonable doubt that the error complained of did not contribute to the verdict
obtained.’ ” (People v. Elizalde (2015) 61 Cal.4th 523, 542.)
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.
/s/
ROBIE, J.
We concur:
/s/
HULL, Acting P. J.
/s/
KRAUSE, J.
9
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.