CourtListener 10362627•In re A.S. CA1/4
Full text
Filed 3/21/25 In re A.S. CA1/4
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or
ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FOUR
In re A.S. et al., Persons Coming
Under the Juvenile Court Law.
SONOMA COUNTY HUMAN A171549
SERVICES DEPARTMENT,
(Sonoma County
Plaintiff and Respondent, Super. Ct. Nos. DEP6709,
v. DEP6710, DEP6711, DEP6712)
R.S.,
Defendant and Appellant.
In this dependency proceeding involving four siblings (collectively, the
Children), the juvenile court terminated the parental rights of the Children’s
parents, G.D. (Mother) and R.S. (Father), at a hearing under Welfare and
Institutions Code section 366.261 and selected adoption as the permanent
plan for the Children. On appeal, Father contends this court should
conditionally reverse and remand for the Sonoma County Human Services
Department (the Department) to provide the juvenile court with
documentation pertaining to notices that were sent pursuant to the Indian
1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions
Code.
1
Child Welfare Act of 1978 (25 U.S.C. § 1901 et seq.; ICWA) and related
California law, so the court can determine whether ICWA applies. The
Department concedes a conditional reversal is appropriate, and we agree. We
will conditionally reverse the juvenile court’s order and remand for
compliance with ICWA.
I. BACKGROUND
On October 19, 2022, the Department filed a section 300 petition
alleging the Children fell within the jurisdiction of the juvenile court based
on the unsafe and unsanitary condition of the family home, as well as the
parents’ verbal arguments and alcohol abuse. The Children had been
removed from parental custody and placed in foster care.
As to ICWA, the Department attached to the petition a form for each
child (Judicial Council form ICWA-010(A)) stating that a social worker had
spoken with the parents, and that these inquiries provided no reason to
believe the child was an Indian child. But another checked box on the form
states the Department “contacted the tribe(s) that the child may be affiliated
with and worked with them to establish whether the child is a member or
eligible for membership in the tribe(s).” The form states that information
about these contacts is attached, but no additional attachments are included.
After a detention hearing on October 20, 2022, the court ordered that
the Children remain out of parental custody. In a report for the hearing, the
Department stated Father had reported that he is eligible to enroll in the
Chumash tribe and another tribe whose name he did not know how to spell or
pronounce, and that his father (the Children’s paternal grandfather) had a
roll number. At the detention hearing, Father completed a “parental
notification of Indian status” form (Judicial Council form ICWA-020) stating
he may be a member or eligible for membership in the Chumash and
2
“Seseman (Santa Cruz)” tribes (the latter of which was later clarified by a
paternal aunt to be the Salinan tribe, one that is not federally recognized).
Mother completed a form stating she was not aware of any Native American
heritage. The minute order for the detention hearing states inquiry was
made as to Indian heritage and the issue was reserved.
In a report filed in November 2022 in advance of the jurisdiction and
disposition hearing, the Department outlined its efforts to obtain information
about the Children’s possible Indian ancestry. On October 18, 2022, a social
work supervisor contacted the Santa Ynez Band of Chumash Indians and
spoke to their ICWA representative, who stated it did not appear that the
paternal grandfather, Father, or the Children were eligible for enrollment.
On October 26, 2022, Father’s counsel provided the Department with
additional information by email about the paternal grandfather, including an
image of a letter from the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA) certifying that the
paternal grandfather was enrolled as a California Indian. The certification
stated that the paternal grandfather (Frederick S.) was named on the
Judgment Fund Roll of California Indians with a specified enrollee number
and date of birth. The letter stated Frederick S.’s “degree of Indian blood”
was “3/16 Chumash/Salinan.”
A few days later, Father told the Department that he is likely eligible
for enrollment in the Chumash Tribe based on his father’s status, but he had
not pursued it and did not have an enrollment number. Father stated an
uncle in Southern California might have more information, but Father did
not provide contact information for the uncle despite the Department’s
request.
A social worker for the Department contacted the Children’s paternal
aunt (Father’s half-sister through a shared father), who stated she has
3
ancestry through the Chumash and Salinan tribes. The paternal aunt stated
she had an enrollment number but was unable to locate it.
As to Mother’s side of the family, the Department spoke with Mother,
who stated she was not aware of any Native American ancestry. When the
Department asked about Mother’s relatives for purposes of inquiring about
possible Indian heritage, Mother provided contact information for her father.
In mid-November 2022, with the information it had gathered, the
Department sent the first of two sets of ICWA notices (Judicial Council form
ICWA-030) and filed them with the court. The notices were sent to the
Sacramento office of the BIA; the Santa Ynez Band of Chumash Mission
Indians; the Coastal Band of the Chumash Nation; and the Tejon Indian
Tribe. (In a later report, the Department stated that notice was not required
to be sent to the Salinan tribe because it is not federally recognized.)
According to the Department’s reports, after sending this set of notices, the
only tribal response it received was from the Santa Ynez Band of Chumash
Indians (dated either November 30, 2022 or December 9, 2022), which stated
the Children were not enrolled members and were not eligible for enrollment.
The record does not show that the Department provided the response or any
return receipts to the court.
At the conclusion of the combined jurisdiction and disposition hearing
on December 19, 2022, the juvenile court sustained the allegations of the
petition and declared the Children to be dependents. The court ordered
visitation and directed that reunification services be provided to Mother and
Father. As to ICWA, the orders for the hearing state that there is a question
under ICWA as to the paternal grandfather and that there is a reason to
know the Children are Indian children. The court set a hearing for March 29,
2023 for an update on ICWA.
4
In a report for the March 29, 2023 hearing, the Department described
its inquiry efforts, the notices it had sent, and the one response it received.
At the hearing, the court found ICWA did not apply to the Children.
The dependency case proceeded, and consistent with the Department’s
recommendations, the court continued reunification services at the six-month
and 12-month review hearings but directed at the 18-month hearing that
reunification services be terminated and that a section 366.26 selection and
implementation hearing be set.2 In reports for these hearings, the
Department stated it had no new information that would suggest ICWA
might apply.
In its report for the section 366.26 hearing in October 2024, the
Department recommended termination of parental rights and stated the
Children were likely to be adopted by relative caretakers in Michigan
(Mother’s cousin and the cousin’s husband), with whom the Children had
been placed since June 2024. As to ICWA, the Department reported it had
inquired of Mother’s cousin, who stated she recalled some discussion in the
family of potential heritage in the distant past, but she could not provide any
further details. The Department continued its inquiries, including searching
for the parents and their relatives on the Lexis/Nexis database. In
August 2024 Mother refused to disclose any further information about her
family and stated she knew she had no Indian ancestry.
For his part, in August 2024 Father declined to provide any
information for the maternal side of his family, but he provided the name and
telephone number of his paternal uncle, Freeman S. A Department social
2 Both parents filed notices of intent to file writ petitions challenging
the order setting a section 366.26 hearing, but only Mother filed a petition.
(G.D. v. Superior Court (Sept. 3, 2024, A170745) [nonpub. opn.].) We denied
the petition in September 2024. (Ibid.)
5
worker spoke with Freeman S., who stated his family had Cherokee,
Chumash, and Salinan ancestry. Freeman S. provided additional
information, including enrollment numbers, and referred the social worker to
his sister Freida for further information. The social worker made several
attempts but was unable to reach Freida or leave a message because her
voicemail box was full.
On August 30, 2024, the Department sent a second set of ICWA notices
with the additional information it had obtained about paternal family
members. Notices were sent to the BIA; the Santa Ynez Band of Chumash
Mission Indians; the Coastal Band of the Chumash Nation; the Tejon Indian
Tribe; the Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma; the Eastern Band of Cherokee
Indians; and the United Keetoowah Band of Cherokee Indians. The notices
included the updated information the Department had obtained, including
the names, tribal affiliations, and enrollment numbers of the paternal
grandfather (Frederick S.), two paternal great uncles (Freeman S. and Frank
S.), and a paternal great aunt (Freida S.).
As of October 1 and 3, 2024, when the social workers signed the
section 366.26 report, the Department had not received any information in
response to the notices that would suggest the Children were Indian children.
The Department noted the court’s earlier finding that ICWA did not apply
and requested that the court “continue to find” that ICWA did not apply to
the Children. The record does not show that the Department provided any
return receipts to the court.
At the section 366.26 hearing on October 10, 2024, the court adopted
the Department’s recommendations, terminated Mother’s and Father’s
parental rights, and selected adoption as the Children’s permanent plan. The
6
record does not show the court made an ICWA finding after the updated
ICWA notices were filed.
Father appealed the order terminating parental rights.3
II. DISCUSSION
Father argues this court should conditionally reverse and remand for
the Department to comply with the reporting requirements of the California
statutes implementing ICWA, and for the juvenile court to determine
whether ICWA applies after considering the information provided by the
Department. The Department states it does not oppose a conditional reversal
and remand for these purposes. We agree conditional reversal and remand
are appropriate.
Under California’s statutory provisions implementing and
supplementing ICWA, juvenile courts and child welfare agencies have a duty
to inquire of a dependent child’s extended family members and others about
whether the child is or may be an Indian child. (§ 224.2, subds. (a)–(c); In re
Dezi C. (2024) 16 Cal.5th 1112, 1125 (Dezi C.).) If, as a result of these
inquiries or other information, there is a reason to know the child is an
Indian child, the agency must send notice of the dependency proceeding to
the appropriate tribes. (§§ 224.2, subd. (f), 224.3, subds. (a)–(b); Dezi C., at
p. 1133.) In conjunction with the notice requirement, the agency generally
must file with the juvenile court “[p]roof of the notice, including copies of
notices sent and all return receipts and responses received.” (§ 224.3,
subd. (c).) The juvenile court is to consider this information in determining
whether ICWA applies to the proceeding. (§ 224.2, subd. (i)(1)–(2).)
Here, the Department inquired of relatives and sent ICWA notices to
tribes, but as the parties note, the record does not show that the Department
3 Mother did not appeal.
7
provided the court with any return receipts or responses it received from the
tribes. In its reports, the Department referred to a response it received from
the Santa Ynez Band of Chumash Indians (following the first set of notices)
stating the Children were not eligible for enrollment, but the Department did
not attach the response. In addition, although Father does not raise this
issue in his appellate brief, the Department suggests it should have made
and documented efforts to contact the tribes to conduct further inquiries
(outside the formal notice process) after it obtained tribal enrollment
numbers for paternal family members. (See § 224.2, subd. (e)(2)(C).) Finally,
the juvenile court did not make an express ICWA finding after the filing of
the updated notices (which included more information than the first notices
and were sent to a broader set of tribes).
On this record, we agree with the parties that, under Dezi C.,
conditional reversal and remand are appropriate. Although Dezi C. focused
on the inquiry phase of the ICWA process and held conditional reversal is
required when an agency’s initial inquiry is inadequate (Dezi C., supra, 16
Cal.5th at pp. 1125, 1128, 1136, 1152), the errors that occurred here
(including the failure to complete the notice process by properly documenting
it) have similarly resulted in an incomplete record that makes it difficult to
determine whether tribal interests were adequately protected. (See Dezi C.,
at pp. 1138–1139 [compliance with statutory inquiry and notice procedures is
essential to protect the rights of Native American tribes to intervene in an
appropriate case and to make tribal eligibility determinations]; In re Kenneth
D. (2024) 16 Cal.5th 1087, 1101–1102 [“On a well-developed record, the court
has relatively broad discretion to determine whether the agency’s inquiry was
proper, adequate, and duly diligent on the specific facts of the case. However,
8
the less developed the record, the more limited that discretion necessarily
becomes.”].)
For the above reasons, and in light of the Department’s concession that
remand is appropriate, we will conditionally reverse with directions for the
Department to comply with the inquiry, notice, and documentation
requirements of sections 224.2 and 224.3 and California Rules of Court,
rule 5.481(a)(5). (See Dezi C., supra, 16 Cal.5th at p. 1136.) If the juvenile
court determines that ICWA does not apply, then the court shall reinstate the
order terminating parental rights. (Dezi C., at pp. 1137–1138, 1152.) If the
court concludes ICWA applies, then it shall proceed in conformity with ICWA
and California implementing provisions. (Dezi C., at pp. 1138, 1152.)
III. DISPOSITION
The order terminating parental rights is conditionally reversed. The
matter is remanded to the juvenile court for compliance with the inquiry and
notice requirements of sections 224.2 and 224.3 and the documentation
provisions of California Rules of Court, rule 5.481(a)(5), consistent with this
opinion. If the juvenile court thereafter concludes ICWA does not apply
(§ 224.2, subd. (i)(1)–(2)), then the court shall reinstate the order terminating
parental rights. If the juvenile court concludes ICWA applies, then it shall
proceed in conformity with ICWA and California implementing provisions.
(See 25 U.S.C. § 1912(a); §§ 224.2, subd. (i)(1), 224.3, 224.4.)
STREETER, J.
WE CONCUR:
BROWN, P. J.
GOLDMAN, J.
9
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.