In re N.D. CA2/3

CourtListener 10360724CalctappMar 20, 2025

Full text

Filed 3/20/25 In re N.D. CA2/3

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION THREE

In re N.D., a Person Coming Under B334119
the Juvenile Court Law.

LOS ANGELES COUNTY (Los Angeles County
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN Super. Ct. No. 23LJJP00314A)
AND FAMILY SERVICES,

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

Y.L.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County, Jennifer W. Baronoff, Juvenile Court Referee. Affirmed.
Benjamin Ekenes, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, Jane Kwon, Deputy County Counsel,
for Plaintiff and Respondent.
‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗

Appellant Y.L. (father) appeals from juvenile court
jurisdictional findings and dispositional orders asserting
dependency jurisdiction over minor child N.D. We affirm the
orders.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
I. Facts
In 2013, the juvenile court sustained allegations that N.D.
was endangered by her mother’s conduct. The court gave father
sole custody of N.D.
On September 15, 2023, the Los Angeles County
Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS) received a
referral indicating that father “whooped” N.D. on the buttocks
with a belt. N.D. was 16 years old at the time. N.D. told mother
about the incident and mother picked her up from school. Mother
then contacted law enforcement. N.D. told Los Angeles Sheriff’s
Department deputies that father spanked her with a belt two
times on September 13 because he was upset that a friend gave
her a ride home from school. She said father also spanked her
with a belt, including the belt buckle, eight or 10 times in July of
2022 after learning that she had a Snapchat account. N.D.
reported that it was “common” for father to hit her with a belt,
but she also said the two specific instances she described were
“the only notable occurrences.”
The deputies took N.D. to a hospital for a medical
evaluation. She reported pain and had a green and yellow, six-

2
by-five centimeter bruise on her right buttock, which was
diagnosed as a hip contusion. According to N.D.’s medical
records, a contusion is a deep bruise resulting from “a blunt
injury to tissues and muscle fibers under the skin” which can be
painless or “may stay painful and swollen for a few weeks.” N.D.
told a nurse that father hit her twice with a belt on September 13
after learning that she got a ride home from school. She also
reported that father said, “ ‘ “you are lucky I only hit you twice, I
wanted to hit you more. Stop crying or I will hit you more.” ’ ”
The deputies also interviewed father on September 15. He
said that he caught N.D. having a relationship with a boy and
texting the boy about how to sneak into father’s home. Father
had tried talking to N.D. about “how dangerous it is” to have boys
inside the home. Father disciplined N.D. on September 13 “but
only with a belt to her buttocks twice, and did not aim for her
face, back or any other areas.” He said that he only used the belt
for disciplinary purposes.
A DCFS social worker interviewed mother and N.D. on
September 15. N.D. told the social worker that on September 14,
father found a photo of her with a boy from school. Father
became “extremely upset” because he did not allow N.D. to have a
boyfriend. N.D. said this was not the first time he used a belt for
discipline, and she reported that father did not know how to
communicate with her other than yelling at her, insulting her, or
using the belt. She had bruises on her buttocks from father
spanking her with a belt. N.D. ran away from father’s home that
evening. She called mother and told her that she did not feel
comfortable or safe staying with father, and mother picked her
up. N.D. was afraid father would hit her again if she went home.

3
She said he had hit her previously, but she did not report those
incidents because she was afraid.
A DCFS social worker interviewed father on September 18.
He admitted to using a belt to discipline N.D. “but he only hit her
twice.” Father asserted he was right to discipline N.D. however
he wanted, including with a belt. He was “adamant” that he did
not do anything wrong. Father said his actions were justified
because N.D. snuck out with a boy and disobeyed father’s rules.
Father was not aware that hitting a child with a belt over their
clothes could leave marks and he did not know if N.D. had
bruises. Paternal grandmother told a DCFS social worker that
father was strict and may have anger issues, but she did not
know he had used a belt for disciplinary purposes.
In October, father told a DCFS social worker that he
usually disciplined N.D. by taking away her electronics or
limiting her activities. Father reported that he had only spanked
her with a belt on two occasions. According to father, on
September 14 he found pictures on N.D.’s phone depicting “a man
sneaking into her room, in [father’s] house,” and father became
scared because he did not know the man. He later learned that
N.D. had a boyfriend and spanked her with a belt. Later that
day, “after cooling off,” father spoke to N.D. “about being safe and
careful” and instructed her to not lie to him. Father explained
that the first time he spanked N.D. with a belt, two years earlier,
was after he found out N.D. “was talking with men” on Snapchat.
Father was “shocked” that N.D. was behaving rebelliously. He
reported that he had not been “worried about the law, DCFS, or
[the] Court” when he spanked N.D., but he now understood the
law and would not spank her with a belt again.

4
In October, N.D. told a DCFS social worker that father had
spanked her with a belt on two occasions, sometimes spanked her
with an open hand, and typically took away her phone as
discipline. She reported that a few weeks before the September
2023 incident, father found out she had a boyfriend and
instructed her to have no further contact with the boy. On
September 13, she was walking home from school when the boy’s
mother saw her and offered a ride home. N.D. accepted the offer.
Father became “upset” when he learned about this and he hit her
“ ‘hard’ ” with a belt two times. It was painful and N.D. cried.
The belt left two red marks which later bruised. N.D. did not tell
father about the marks or bruises. N.D. also reported that father
spanked her “ ‘hard’ ” with a belt five or eight times on July 25,
2022, after learning she had a Snapchat account. Father had
drunk two beers, but N.D. denied that he was intoxicated. N.D.
cried. The belt left one mark which later became a bruise. On
both occasions, father called N.D. a “ ‘bitch and a hoe.’ ” N.D.
reported that father felt “betrayed because she disobeyed his
rules as he expects a lot from her.” She felt safe in father’s home
and wanted to remain there, but she added that “they were just
not seeing things eye to eye” and continued to experience
“tension.”
In early December, N.D. told a DCFS social worker that she
continued to have disagreements with father. Specifically, on
December 6, father “caught” her talking to a boy on FaceTime,
became angry, and called her “ ‘ “selfish” ’ ” and an “ ‘ “idiot.” ’ ”
N.D. reported that father took away her phone and television but
did not physically discipline her. N.D. said she felt safe in the
home. Father confirmed that he disciplined N.D. for talking to a
boy on FaceTime but he denied yelling at her or calling her

5
names. Father told the social worker “ ‘he was just trying to talk
to [N.D.]’ ” and “ ‘just wants her to be honest with him.’ ”
According to father, N.D.’s grades were falling “ ‘because of [N.D.]
having visits with her mother.’ ”
Paternal grandmother, paternal aunt, and father’s ex-
girlfriend each separately reported to a DCFS social worker that
they had no concerns about father physically abusing N.D.
Father applied to the Father Strong parenting program on
October 12, and as of December 12 his enrollment was still
pending. On December 18, father was on a waitlist for individual
and joint counseling.
II. Procedure
On September 19, 2023, DCFS filed a Welfare and
Institutions Code section 300 petition as to N.D.1 The petition
alleged that N.D. had “suffered, or there is a substantial risk that
the child will suffer, serious physical harm inflicted
nonaccidentally upon the child by the child’s parent or guardian”
and that father failed to adequately supervise or protect N.D.
from serious physical harm. The petition further alleged that
father “physically abused” N.D. by striking her buttocks with a
belt on at least two occasions, that this abuse was excessive and
caused unreasonable pain and suffering, and that it endangered
N.D.’s physical health and safety and put her at risk of serious
physical harm, damage, and danger.
At the December 18, 2023 adjudication hearing, father
argued that the court should dismiss the petition because
spanking N.D. with a belt was reasonable discipline and because

1 All further undesignated statutory references are to the
Welfare and Institutions Code.

6
evidence of bruising did not compel a finding of child abuse.2
Father further argued that there was no risk of future harm
because he had enrolled in services and N.D. reported feeling safe
in his home.
The court sustained the petition and found true the
jurisdictional allegations. It explained:
This was not a disciplinary measure reasonable
in kind and degree. [¶] [N.D.] reported she had marks
and bruises on her bottom. That was certainly
consistent with the finding on the medical records.
According to the exam, she had green- and yellow-
colored bruises to her right buttocks. The patient
[N.D.] also showed the physicians a picture of her
bruise that she took on the day of the incident. It had
two patterned bruises to the right buttocks.
The court is also, in looking at the totality of the
circumstances, not only looking at the black belt folded
in half hitting her, but I’m also looking at -- and I
would note that [N.D.] reported it hurt and she started
to cry.
I’m also looking at the fact that it has happened
before, that she is a teenager, and that there were

2 Father cited a case describing the parental disciplinary
privilege in the context of child abuse reporting, and recognizing,
in dicta, that dependency law “ ‘provides that in the absence of
‘serious physical injury,’ the ‘serious physical harm’ that will
warrant assertion of juvenile court jurisdiction ‘does not include
reasonable and age-appropriate spanking to the buttocks.’ ”
(Gonzalez v. Santa Clara County Dept. of Social Services (2014)
223 Cal.App.4th 72, 86, fn.11 (Gonzalez), quoting § 300, subd.
(a).)

7
statements that -- by [N.D.] that at least during one of
the incidents her father was under the influence of
alcohol. She reported he had had two beers. She
denied he was drunk or intoxicated, but that’s
something the court is considering.
The court is also considering statements from
the J.D.X. report that the father was extremely upset
and called her a bitch and a ho from the situations that
she was in, in addition to the use of the belt to hit her.
So this is -- the court is kind of looking at the
whole picture, and based on the derogatory language,
the possible use of alcohol, as well as the bruising,
[N.D.]’s age, the fact that it happened more than once,
and that she -- it caused her to run away to her mother
because she was fearful of her father, there is no world
in which that this was reasonable discipline in kind
and degree.
This is normal teenage behavior that was met
with -- that was met with physical abuse. And so the
court is sustaining this as an A-1 and B-1.
Father did not object to the juvenile court’s ruling or its
reasoning.
On December 22, at the disposition hearing, the court
declared N.D. a dependent of the court, released her to father,
and ordered family maintenance services.
Father timely appealed the juvenile court jurisdictional
findings and dispositional orders.

8
DISCUSSION
Father argues that the juvenile court erroneously sustained
jurisdictional allegations that N.D. suffered or would face a
substantial risk of harm. For the following reasons, we disagree.
I. Applicable Law and Standard of Review
The juvenile court may assume dependency jurisdiction if
“[t]he child has suffered, or there is a substantial risk that the
child will suffer, serious physical harm inflicted nonaccidentally
upon the child by the child’s parent or guardian.” (§ 300, subd.
(a).) The court may also exercise jurisdiction after finding “[t]he
child has suffered, or there is a substantial risk that the child will
suffer, serious physical harm or illness, as a result of . . . [¶]
(A) The failure or inability of the child’s parent or guardian to
adequately supervise or protect the child.” (Id., subd. (b)(1)(A).)
“For purposes of [section 300, subdivision (a)], a court may
find there is a substantial risk of serious future injury based on
the manner in which a less serious injury was inflicted, a history
of repeated inflictions of injuries on the child or the child’s
siblings, or a combination of these and other actions by the
parent or guardian that indicate the child is at risk of serious
physical harm. For purposes of this subdivision, ‘serious physical
harm’ does not include reasonable and age-appropriate spanking
to the buttocks if there is no evidence of serious physical injury.”
(§ 300, subd. (a).) The latter limitation is consistent with “the
long-standing principle of California law that ‘ “a parent has a
right to reasonably discipline his or her child and may administer
reasonable punishment . . . .” ’ ” (In re D.M. (2015) 242
Cal.App.4th 634, 640–641 (D.M.).)
We review jurisdictional findings “ ‘ “in the light of the
whole record” ’ ‘to determine whether it discloses substantial

9
evidence—that is, evidence which is reasonable, credible, and of
solid value . . . .’ ” (In re I.C. (2018) 4 Cal.5th 869, 892.) “ ‘In
making this determination, we draw all reasonable inferences
from the evidence to support the findings and orders of the
dependency court; we review the record in the light most
favorable to the court’s determinations; and we note that issues
of fact and credibility are the province of the trial court.’ ” (In re
R.T. (2017) 3 Cal.5th 622, 633 (R.T.).) “The appellant has the
burden of showing there is no evidence of a sufficiently
substantial nature to support the findings or orders.” (In re E.E.
(2020) 49 Cal.App.5th 195, 206.)
II. Substantial Evidence Supports the Juvenile Court’s
Jurisdictional Findings
Father first argues that there was insufficient evidence to
support that N.D. suffered serious physical harm or physical
abuse. We disagree. There is no dispute that father hit N.D. on
her buttocks with a belt five to 10 times on July 25, 2022, and
twice on September 13, 2023, leaving marks and bruises on both
occasions. Father admitted that he hit N.D. with a belt, and N.D.
reported the details of the two incidents consistently to DCFS
social workers, medical professionals, and law enforcement. Her
bruises from the September 2023 incident were observed by law
enforcement, a DCFS social worker, and during a medical
examination. She was diagnosed with a contusion, which medical
records describe as a deep bruise that can “stay painful and
swollen for a few weeks.” N.D. also reported that it was
“common” for father to use a belt for discipline, though the only
specific instances she identified were the two described above.
Based on the whole record, substantial evidence supports a
finding that N.D. suffered serious physical harm as a result of

10
father’s conduct. (In re Mariah T. (2008) 159 Cal.App.4th 428,
438 [punishment with a belt to stomach and forearms causing
“deep, purple bruises” was sufficient to support a finding of
serious physical harm]; cf. Gonzalez, supra, 223 Cal.App.4th at p.
92 [in the context of reporting child abuse to a federal database,
recognizing that “the presence of lasting bruises or other marks
may support a finding that a parent crossed the line between
permissible discipline and reportable abuse”].)
Father asserts N.D.’s injuries were not severe enough to
support a finding of serious physical harm. However, the sole
legal authority on which he relies, In re Adam D. (2010) 183
Cal.App.4th 1250, is inapposite. In that case, the appellate court
described a juvenile court’s finding that a parent engaged in age-
appropriate discipline by punishing the child with a belt and
causing marks that lasted two days but did not bruise. (Id. at p.
1254.) That finding was not relevant to any issue on appeal and
the appellate court’s recitation of it is not persuasive or binding
on this court. (Areso v. CarMax, Inc. (2011) 195 Cal.App.4th 996,
1006 [“observations by an appellate court are dicta and not
precedent”].) Moreover, N.D.’s injuries were more severe. The
marks described in Adam D. lasted only two days, did not bruise,
and apparently did not cause lasting pain; in contrast, N.D. was
still in pain two days after the incident and still had a six-by-five
centimeter green and yellow bruise.3

3 Father notes that N.D. told law enforcement that she
experienced pain on the day father struck her. He argues that
this implies she was no longer in pain by the time she spoke to
law enforcement, two days later. However, N.D. reported pain to
medical professionals after she spoke to law enforcement,
indicating her pain lasted for at least two days. In any case, to

11
Father also argues that he did not physically abuse N.D.,
but merely committed “inappropriate discipline.” However,
father fails to explain the legal significance of this supposed
distinction. Father observes that “ ‘ “serious physical harm” does
not include reasonable and age-appropriate spanking to the
buttocks’ ” (§ 300, subd. (a)), but he does not claim that he
engaged in “age-appropriate spanking,” nor does he articulate
any reasoned argument that his admittedly inappropriate
discipline qualifies for this exemption.
Next, father contends there was insufficient evidence to
support the allegation that N.D. faced a substantial risk of
serious physical harm in the future. We again disagree. Father
contends the only evidence on this point related to father’s past
behavior. Yet, in assessing the current or future risk of harm,
the juvenile court may consider a parent’s previous conduct. (In
re Jasmon O. (1994) 8 Cal.4th 398, 424 [“ ‘a measure of a parent’s
future potential is undoubtedly revealed in the parent’s past
behavior with the child’ ”]; § 300, subd. (a) [in assessing the risk
of future harm, the juvenile court may consider past injuries and
“other actions by the parent or guardian that indicate the child is
at risk of serious physical harm”].) Here, N.D.’s injuries
combined with father’s overall conduct support the juvenile court
ruling. Father was “adamant” that he had the right to punish
N.D. however he wanted, including with a belt. He admitted that
he had disciplined N.D. before “cooling off,” and stated that he
“was not worried about the law, DCFS or [the] Court” when he
struck her. Father had drunk two beers before one incident, and

the extent the record could support father’s position, we view the
evidence in the light most favorable to the juvenile court’s ruling.
(R.T., supra, 3 Cal.5th at p. 633.)

12
while N.D. reported that he was not intoxicated, he may have
been at least somewhat impaired. These facts suggest father
believed he was right to punish N.D. with a belt and did so
without considering the consequences. In turn, the evidence
supports a finding that there was a substantial risk father may
use similar punishment in the future.
Father argues that there was no risk of future harm
because he enrolled in services and said that he would no longer
spank N.D. with a belt, and because N.D. eventually said she felt
safe in the home. However, even if some evidence might support
father’s position, we view the record in the light most favorable to
the juvenile court ruling. (R.T., supra, 3 Cal.5th at p. 633.)
Father also contends the juvenile court erred because it did not
expressly state that its ruling was based on then-current
circumstances.4 He forfeited any such argument, however, by

4 We recognize that there is a split of authority regarding
whether a juvenile court may exercise jurisdiction based solely on
a past incident of serious physical harm, without finding a risk of
current or future harm. Some courts have held that “the question
under section 300 is whether circumstances at the time of the
hearing subject the minor to the defined risk of harm.” (In re
Rocco M. (1991) 1 Cal.App.4th 814, 824, overruled on another
ground in In re R.T. (2017) 3 Cal.5th 622, 629; see In re Carlos T.
(2009) 174 Cal.App.4th 795, 805 [quoting Rocco M.].) Others
have concluded that “an allegation that a child has suffered
serious physical harm inflicted nonaccidentally by a parent or
guardian is sufficient to establish jurisdiction . . . .” (In re David
H. (2008) 165 Cal.App.4th 1626, 1644; In re J.K. (2009) 174
Cal.App.4th 1426, 1436 [following David H.].) We need not weigh
in on this split, however, because we conclude that substantial
evidence supports that N.D. suffered serious physical harm in the

13
failing to object after the juvenile court articulated its reasoning.
(In re D.P. (2023) 92 Cal.App.5th 1282, 1292 (D.P.) [“In
dependency proceedings, as elsewhere, a litigant forfeits an
appellate argument by failing to raise it before the trial court”].)
Moreover, “ ‘ “[i]t is judicial action and not judicial reasoning
which is the subject of review.” ’ ” (In re Jonathan B. (1992) 5
Cal.App.4th 873, 876.) As we have discussed, the record as a
whole supports the juvenile court’s jurisdictional findings.
Father argues in the alternative that the juvenile court
considered improper factors in its oral ruling. Father forfeited
this claim by failing to raise it below. (D.P., supra, 92
Cal.App.5th at p. 1292.) But even if he had preserved this
contention, we would reject it. At the hearing, father argued that
he had a right to reasonably discipline N.D. “Whether a parent’s
use of discipline on a particular occasion falls within (or instead
exceeds) the scope of this parental right to discipline turns on
three considerations: (1) whether the parent’s conduct is
genuinely disciplinary; (2) whether the punishment is
‘necess[ary]’ (that is, whether the discipline was ‘warranted by
the circumstances’); and (3) ‘whether the amount of punishment
was reasonable or excessive.’ ” (D.M., supra, 242 Cal.App.4th at
p. 641.) The juvenile court found that father’s discipline was not
reasonable, citing several specific circumstances. Father argues
the juvenile court improperly considered that he drank two beers
before punishing N.D. and “called her a bitch and a ho.” Yet,
both facts are relevant to whether the discipline was excessive—
father’s alcohol use suggests he was impaired and prone to act

past and that she was at risk of future harm at the time of the
hearing.

14
unreasonably, and his use of derogatory slurs indicates he was
unable or unwilling to control his temper. Father also claims the
court improperly considered that N.D. ran away from home
because she feared father, but the child’s subjective reaction to
physical discipline is at least somewhat probative of whether that
discipline was excessive. Father further argues that the juvenile
court erred in reasoning that he punished N.D. for “normal
teenage behavior.” However, this was plainly relevant to
whether the discipline at issue was “ ‘warranted by the
circumstances.’ ” (Ibid.)
Father relatedly contends the juvenile court failed to
consider or determine whether his actions were “genuinely
disciplinary.” (D.M., supra, 242 Cal.App.4th at p. 641.) Yet, the
record is silent on this factor, and therefore we presume the court
appropriately considered it in rendering its decision. (Brewer v.
Carter (2013) 218 Cal.App.4th 1312, 1320.)
Finally, father argues that the juvenile court’s dispositional
orders must be reversed. This argument, however, is contingent
on the success of father’s challenge to the court’s jurisdictional
findings. Because we reject father’s contentions as to the
jurisdictional findings, we also reject his challenge to the
dispositional orders.

15
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court orders are affirmed.

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

HANASONO, J.*

We concur:

EDMON, P. J.

ADAMS, J.

* Judge of the Los Angeles Superior Court, assigned by the
Chief Justice pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the California
Constitution.

16

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.