People v. Fogle CA3

CourtListener 10357200CalctappMar 17, 2025

Full text

Filed 3/17/25 P. v. Fogle CA3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

THIRD APPELLATE DISTRICT

(Shasta)
----

THE PEOPLE, C100010

Plaintiff and Respondent, (Super. Ct. Nos.
CRF14010005555, 01F5555,
v. 14F6222 & CRF1400006222)

WILLIAM THOMAS FOGLE,

Defendant and Appellant.

After a court trial, the trial court found defendant William Thomas Fogle to be a
sexually violent predator (SVP) under the Sexually Violent Predators Act (SVPA) (Welf.
& Inst. Code,1 § 6600 et seq.) and committed him to the custody of the State Department
of State Hospitals (DSH) for an indeterminate term. Defendant contends insufficient
evidence supports the trial court’s findings because the two testifying psychologists
completed their reports two years before his trial. He also argues the psychologists
improperly relied only upon his past offenses in making their determinations. We shall
affirm.

1 Further unspecified section references are to the Welfare and Institutions Code.

1
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
In 2002, defendant pleaded guilty to lewd or lascivious acts with a child under 14
years of age. (Pen. Code, § 288, former subd. (a).) The trial court sentenced him to six
years in state prison.
In 2015, defendant pleaded guilty to annoying or molesting a child and admitted
he had a prior serious or violent felony conviction. (Pen. Code, §§ 647.6, subd. (c)(2),
1170.12.) The trial court sentenced him to 12 years in state prison.
In February 2022, the prosecution filed a petition in each of defendant’s prior
cases to commit defendant as an SVP. The matter proceeded to a court trial in November
2023.
The prosecution presented testimony from the 2015 victim, G.M.2 When she was
about nine or ten years old, she lived in a mobile home park. One day while she was in
the laundromat, the defendant came in, picked up a red bra that was way too big for
G.M., and asked if it would fit her. He told her she was pretty and repeatedly asked if he
could lick her private parts. She ran home to her mother.
The second victim, A.K., testified about an incident that happened with defendant
when she was approximately six years old. She wanted money for ice cream, so she went
to defendant’s apartment to ask for some. Defendant invited her in and the two went into
his bedroom. Defendant told her she would have to work for the money and tried to lift
up her dress. She blocked him and said no. He tried to put his hand up the back of her
dress and again she told him no. He then exposed his penis to her and said, “Why don’t
you just touch me?” She again told him no and pulled away, but defendant grabbed her
hand and made her touch him. She kept pulling away and saying no. Defendant gave her
money and ultimately let her go out to play. A.K. remembered defendant kissed her on
the cheek a few times.

2 To protect their privacy, we refer to the victims by their initials. (Cal. Rules of
Court, rule 8.90(b)(4).)

2
The prosecution presented the testimony of two psychologists. The first, Dr. Laljit
Sidhu, testified he has been licensed since 2004 and has conducted over 850 sexual
violent predator examinations for the state.
Dr. Sidhu evaluated defendant in December 2021. As part of his evaluation, he
interviewed defendant for two hours. Dr. Sidhu spoke with defendant about the offenses
for which he was convicted, his psychological development, his criminal history, his
treatment, and his substance abuse. Dr. Sidhu also examined several documents,
including police reports, court records, and parole records. Dr. Sidhu confirmed
defendant had a conviction for a qualifying offense.
Dr. Sidhu determined defendant had two mental health disorders: pedophilic
disorder3 and alcohol abuse disorder. Dr. Sidhu based the diagnosis of pedophilic
disorder on defendant’s multiple incidents of engaging in inappropriate behavior with
minors. These multiple incidents demonstrated defendant lacked volitional control as he
committed those crimes despite the fact that he underwent treatment and had previously
been evaluated by the DSH evaluators to determine if he was an SVP.4 Defendant
informed Dr. Sidhu he believed his prior treatment had been useless, and the doctor
concluded defendant had not learned anything from that treatment.
For Dr. Sidhu’s risk assessment of defendant’s sexual offense recidivism, he used
the Static-99R instrument and considered dynamic factors. Defendant scored a three on
the Static-99R. He received negative points for his age, and positive points for his prior
sexual offenses, prior sentencing dates, the fact that the victims were strangers, and for
his indecent exposure. This score placed defendant in a category of offenders that had a
reoffense rate of approximately 7 percent in five years, and 10 percent in 10 years.

3 Due to defendant’s experience with adult partners, Dr. Sidhu concluded his
pedophilic disorder was of a nonexclusive type.
4 Those doctors did not find that he met the SVP criteria.

3
The doctor found three different dynamic factors applied to defendant. These
included: (1) his sexual preoccupation coupled with alcohol use; (2) his sexual
preference for children; and (3) his resistance to rules and supervision. On this final
point, Dr. Sidhu found it significant that defendant had a parole violation, had not
completed his sexual offender treatment, and said that treatment was not helpful. On
cross-examination, Dr. Sidhu agreed he had incorrectly concluded defendant had not
completed his treatment program. Dr. Sidhu testified that the current information that he
had completed the program did not change his analysis because defendant said he did not
learn anything from the program.
Dr. Sidhu concluded there was a serious and well-founded risk defendant would
reoffend. The doctor explained this conclusion was based on defendant’s risk score on
the Static-99R coupled with the fact that he had engaged in predatory behavior, believed
he did not need treatment, and failed to benefit from his prior treatment. Based on
defendant’s age of 60 years old at the time of his evaluation, the doctor put defendant in
the average category of risk, although if he were younger, the doctor would conclude
defendant was at a much higher risk.
On cross-examination, Dr. Sidhu confirmed his report had been completed in
December 2021. He did not update that report and was “somewhat surprised that an
update was not requested at this point.” Dr. Sidhu explained he did not have the authority
to request an update. Dr. Sidhu stated, “Generally, it is advisable that an update be done
about once a year or so because reports can essentially become obsolete or they can
become old.” He did confirm that it would have been useful to know whether defendant
had undergone any additional treatment. Ultimately, however, the doctor testified the
report contained all of the information relevant to his analysis and that he would not
change or revise anything in his report.

4
The prosecution also presented the testimony of psychologist Dr. Craig Teofilo.
Dr. Teofilo testified he has been licensed since 2001 and has conducted close to 500 SVP
evaluations.
Dr. Teofilo evaluated defendant in November 2021. He spoke with defendant for
two hours and 40 minutes the first time and about five minutes the second time.
Dr. Teofilo concluded defendant had the requisite conviction that qualifies him for SVP
status. He also concluded his prior crimes were predatory in nature.
Dr. Teofilo diagnosed defendant with pedophilic disorder, exhibitionistic disorder,
alcohol use disorder, and stimulant or methamphetamine disorder.
As to the pedophilic disorder, the doctor found relevant defendant’s admissions he
exposed himself to a 12-year-old girl in 1984. The doctor also considered that defendant
admitted to exposing himself to his daughter’s friend in 1990. Dr. Teofilo also
considered defendant’s convictions for his conduct against A.K. and G.M. Finally, he
considered defendant’s prior admissions that he exposed himself to children and that he
found children arousing and attractive. The doctor concluded defendant represented a
highly repetitive sex offender with four detections, one additional investigation, and
crimes that involved children that spanned over 31 years. The doctor also noted
defendant had been caught, punished, and undergone treatment, yet he offended again,
demonstrating his volitional impairment. Dr. Teofilo concluded defendant “is a man who
cannot control his deviant sexual urges to touch, be with, [and] sexualize children.”
Defendant’s prior arrests also demonstrated to Dr. Teofilo that defendant found
something about the act of showing himself to children excites defendant sexually. This
was the basis for the diagnosis of exhibitionistic disorder.
In making the determination that defendant was likely to engage in sexually
violent criminal behavior, Dr. Teofilo used a risk assessment protocol that looks at two
separate static risk instruments and a dynamic risk assessment tool and considers
protective factors that may mitigate the risk.

5
In his evaluation of defendant under the Static-99R, Dr. Teofilo scored defendant
as a four. This placed defendant well above the average risk category. Averaging the
results of the Static-99R and the Static-2002R, Dr. Teofilo concluded defendant’s
potential reoffense rate was 20 percent over the next five years and 27 percent over the
next 10 years.
Dr. Teofilo also used a separate risk assessment tool called the Violence Risk
Scale Score, Sex Offender Version. The doctor scored defendant as a 37 on this scale
which again placed him in the well-above-average risk category. The doctor concluded
defendant was likely to engage in sexually violent predatory behavior.
Dr. Teofilo testified he believed defendant was likely to reoffend without
treatment on a custodial basis because defendant did not think he needed treatment.
Further, defendant had previously completed outpatient sexual offender treatment and
then reoffended. To make matters worse, he reoffended even after being evaluated for an
indeterminate civil commitment. Thus, his prior conviction, his prior incarceration, his
prior treatment, his prior supervision, and the fear of civil commitment had not been
effective in preventing him from committing more sexual crimes.
Dr. Teofilo concluded defendant was predatory in nature. He based this
conclusion on the fact that none of the victims were his children or lived in his home. At
best they were casual acquaintances and strangers.
Defendant did not testify or present any evidence on his own behalf.
In addressing defendant’s argument that the doctor’s reports were stale, the trial
court found, “in hearing the doctors’ testimony with regard to their opinions, just the time
passage that has occurred between their evaluation and now, the Court doesn’t find that
time passage alone, led the Court to conclude that [their] opinions were not credible. [¶]
I do find the doctors’ opinions credible. They did an independent evaluation that they
went through thoroughly in their testimony, and both came to the same conclusion.
That’s significant to the Court.”

6
The trial court found defendant was an SVP under the SVPA. The trial court
committed defendant to DSH for treatment and confinement for an indeterminate term.
Defendant timely appealed.
DISCUSSION
Defendant argues substantial evidence does not support the trial court’s finding
that “he suffered from a mental disorder that currently prevented him from controlling
sexually violent behavior such that it rendered him dangerous beyond his control,”
(boldface omitted) because the psychologists’ opinions were based on two-year-old
evaluations. Defendant further asserts the psychologists improperly relied solely on his
past offenses in rendering their opinion that he suffered from a mental disorder that made
him a danger to others. We disagree.
A. The SVPA
Under the SVPA, a “ ‘[s]exually violent predator’ ” is “a person who has been
convicted of a sexually violent offense against one or more victims and who has a
diagnosed mental disorder that makes the person a danger to the health and safety of
others in that it is likely that he or she will engage in sexually violent criminal behavior.”
(§ 6600, subd. (a)(1).) The phrase “ ‘[d]iagnosed mental disorder’ ” includes “a
congenital or acquired condition affecting the emotional or volitional capacity that
predisposes the person to the commission of criminal sexual acts in a degree constituting
the person a menace to the health and safety of others.” (§ 6600, subd. (c).)
To commit defendant as an SVP, the trial court must find defendant was
previously convicted of a violent sexual offense and suffered from a mental disorder
affecting his volitional or emotional capacity, thereby making him a danger to others
because he is likely to engage in sexually violent criminal behavior. (People v. Poulsom
(2013) 213 Cal.App.4th 501, 517.)
The term “likely” does not require a finding it is more likely than not the person
will reoffend. (People v. Superior Court (Ghilotti) (2002) 27 Cal.4th 888, 916.) Whether

7
a person poses a “danger to the health and safety of others” (§ 6600, subd. (a)) “does not,
by common understanding, evaporate with an expert’s prediction that the sufferer’s risk
of reoffense is no greater than 50 percent.” (Ghilotti, supra, at p. 920.) At the same
time, a finding of such danger requires “much more than the mere possibility that the
person will reoffend.” (Id. at p. 922.) Thus, the prosecution must prove beyond a
reasonable doubt at trial defendant “present[s] a substantial danger, that is, a serious and
well-founded risk” defendant will commit such crimes if released. (People v. Roberge
(2003) 29 Cal.4th 979, 988; §§ 6600, subd. (a), 6604.)
B. Substantial Evidence
Defendant challenges the sufficiency of the evidence supporting the conclusion
that he suffers from a mental disorder that currently prevents him from controlling
sexually violent behavior such that it renders him dangerous beyond his control.
Defendant focuses on the allegedly stale nature of the psychologists’ evaluations because
they were conducted approximately two years before trial.
We review the sufficiency of the evidence in a sexually violent predator case
under the same substantial evidence test used in criminal appeals. (People v. McCloud
(2013) 213 Cal.App.4th 1076, 1088.) “In assessing the sufficiency of the evidence, [the
court] review[s] the entire record in the light most favorable to the judgment to determine
whether it discloses evidence that is reasonable, credible, and of solid value such that a
reasonable trier of fact could find the defendant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.”
(People v. Bolin (1998) 18 Cal.4th 297, 331.) Reversal for insufficiency of the evidence
is warranted only if it appears that ‘ “upon no hypothesis whatever is there sufficient
substantial evidence to support [the conviction].’ ” (Ibid.)
Defendant’s initial argument is that the SVP statute requires that the evaluations
be conducted on a yearly basis, pointing to section 6604.9. That section, however,
requires annual examinations for persons who have been determined to be an SVP and
committed to the DSH. (§ 6604.9, subd. (a).) This section thus establishes the opposite

8
point from the one defendant endeavors to make because it demonstrates that the
Legislature knows how to require an annual report. Specifically, it requires an annual
report for persons who have been determined to be an SVP and committed to DSH.
(§ 6604.9, subd. (a).) It does not impose the same requirement for pre-commitment
offenders. Nothing in section 6600 requires a report to be prepared annually for persons
who have not yet been committed to DSH. Further, section 6603, subdivision (d)(1),
allows, but does not require, the petitioning party to obtain an updated evaluation in
anticipation of trial. Thus, there is no annual requirement applicable here.
We conclude the psychological evaluations constitute substantial evidence to
support the trial court’s findings. To the extent Dr. Sidhu and Dr. Teofilo testified
defendant had pedophilic disorder, was predatory, and was likely to reoffend, it was
solely in the trial court’s province to weigh this expert testimony and determine if it was
credible. (People v. Poe (1999) 74 Cal.App.4th 826, 831 [“It is not the role of this
[appellate] court to redetermine the credibility of experts or to reweigh the relative
strength of their conclusions”]; People v. Kerley (2018) 23 Cal.App.5th 513, 530 [“The
testimony of a single witness, if believed by the fact finder, is sufficient to prove any
fact”].) The trial court heard defendant’s argument that the testimony was stale, analyzed
it, and based on its view of the witnesses, their testimony, and the facts upon which the
opinions were based, concluded the expert testimony had not become stale in the
intervening two years.
We do not find this finding surprising given evidence supporting the experts’
opinions, including, but not limited to, defendant’s record of offending against children
starting in 1984 and that he committed these offenses even after he had been previously
convicted, treated, and subject to a prior civil commitment examination. Dr. Sidhu’s
testimony that he would not change anything in his report supports the finding these
psychologists’ evaluations remained valid despite being two years old. We may not
reweigh this testimony or determine its credibility. We thus conclude this testimony was

9
reasonable, credible, and of solid value and that a reasonable trier of fact could find
beyond a reasonable doubt defendant will likely engage in sexually violent, predatory,
criminal behavior if released.
C. Past Offenses
Defendant further argues the psychologists’ “improper reliance on [defendant’s]
past offenses was not substantial evidence that he currently suffered from a mental
disorder that made him a danger due to the likelihood of reoffense.” (Boldface omitted.)
We disagree.
The parties agree, as do we, that the state may not involuntarily commit an
individual based solely on past criminal conduct. (§ 6600, subd. (a)(3) [“Conviction of
one or more of the crimes enumerated in this section shall constitute evidence that may
support a court or jury determination that a person is a sexually violent predator, but shall
not be the sole basis for the determination”].) Indeed, in order to commit someone under
the SVPA, the statute requires the state to establish four conditions beyond a reasonable
doubt: “ ‘(1) the person has previously been convicted of at least one qualifying
“sexually violent offense” listed in . . . section 6600, subdivision (b) [citation]; (2) the
person has “a diagnosed mental disorder that makes the person a danger to the health and
safety of others” [citation]; (3) the mental disorder makes it likely the person will engage
in future acts of sexually violent criminal behavior if released from custody [citation];
and (4) those acts will be predatory in nature.’ ” (Camacho v. Superior Court of Merced
County (2023) 15 Cal.5th 354, 370.)
The record demonstrates that the psychologists did not solely focus on defendant’s
criminal convictions, but rather they considered and demonstrated their consideration of
each of the foregoing requirements.
As an initial matter, the experts properly considered defendant’s prior convictions.
(People v. Hubbart (2001) 88 Cal.App.4th 1202, 1234.) But they did not stop there.

10
For example, each psychologist identified defendant’s mental diagnosis of
pedophilic disorder.
Each further concluded defendant was likely to reoffend, citing his repeated
misconduct after being convicted and imprisoned, and reoffending after treatment and
having been subject to civil commitment proceedings. Both psychologists used the
Static-99R to assess defendant’s future dangerousness which includes factors outside of
defendant’s prior criminal conduct to assess his risk, including his age, the nature of the
victims, and the dates of the convictions. Dr. Sidhu also considered three dynamic
factors related to defendant’s sexual preoccupation, preference for children, and
resistance to rules and supervision. Dr. Teofilo similarly testified about his reliance on
factors other than defendant’s criminal convictions, including defendant’s rejection of the
prior treatment and his reoffense after the potential prior civil commitment evaluation.
Finally, both psychologists considered the predatory nature of defendant’s conduct
based on the nature of the victims. In short, the psychologists did not conclude defendant
was an SVP based solely on his prior criminal offenses.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.

\s\
Krause, J.

We concur:

\s\
Hull, Acting P. J.

\s
Renner, J.

11

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.