Microwave Dynamics v. Parvin CA4/3

CourtListener 10335660CalctappFeb 19, 2025

Full text

Filed 2/19/25 Microwave Dynamics v. Parvin CA4/3

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION THREE

MICROWAVE DYNAMICS, INC., et
al.,
G062428
Plaintiffs and Appellants,
(Super. Ct. No. 30-2021-
v. 01182199)

PARVIN, LLC, OPINION

Defendant and Respondent.

Appeal from a judgment of the Superior Court of Orange County,
Nick A. Dourbetas, Judge. Affirmed in part, reversed in part.
Palmieri, Tyler, Wiener, Wilheim & Waldron, and Erin K.
Oyama, for Plaintiffs and Appellants.
Snell & Wilmer, and Jeffrey M. Singletary, for Defendant and
Respondent.
This case involves a dispute over different monthly rental
schemes in a commercial property lease and in a subsequent addendum to
that lease, as well as distributions allegedly owed under an operating
agreement. In 1993, three brothers, Peter Adel, Shaun Adel, and Brian Adel
(Adel brothers), formed Microwave Dynamics, Inc. (Microwave Dynamics)
which “makes telecommunications and satellite equipment for commercial
aerospace and defense industry.” In 2010, the Adel brothers formed Parvin,
LLC (Parvin) to acquire commercial property for Microwave Dynamics’ use.
Peter Adel had 30 percent ownership interest in Parvin, Shaun Adel had 50
percent, and Brian Adel 20 percent. The following year, Microwave Dynamics
and Parvin entered into a 20-year lease with a monthly rental scheme
allowing for annual increases. Four months later, they signed an addendum
which changed that rental scheme. From the inception of the lease,
Microwave Dynamics paid Parvin the base rent pursuant to the original
lease, not the addendum. In August 2020, for the first time Parvin attempted
to increase Microwave Dynamics’ monthly rent pursuant to the annual
increase provision in the lease. Microwave Dynamics objected and this
litigation ensued.
Following a bench trial, the trial court concluded the parties
waived their rights to the rental scheme set forth in the addendum, and that
Peter Adel was entitled to a pro rata share of distributions from Parvin.
Peter’s award, however, was offset by a judgment against Microwave
Dynamics for certain rent-related expenses incurred from 2011 through 2014.
Microwave Dynamics and Peter Adel appealed.
Microwave Dynamics contends the trial court erred in
determining it had waived the rental scheme set forth in the addendum. We
conclude substantial evidence supports the trial court’s waiver finding. Peter

2
Adel appeals from the portion of the court’s judgment offsetting his award
with the judgment against Microwave Dynamics. We conclude the trial court
could not offset the award because there was a lack of mutuality between
Peter’s claims against Parvin and Parvin’s claims against Microwave
Dynamics. Accordingly, we affirm in part, reverse in part, and remand for
further proceedings.
I
PROCEDURAL HISTORY
A. Complaint, Answer, and Cross-Complaint
On May 19, 2022, Microwave Dynamics and Peter Adel
(collectively “Plaintiffs”) filed a first amended complaint against Parvin,
asserting causes of action for breach of contract and declaratory relief. The
complaint alleged that Microwave Dynamics and Parvin entered into a 20-
year leasing agreement on January 1, 2011 (the “Lease”), which was
amended on April 22, 2011 (the “Addendum”). The monthly rental rate under
the Lease was $16,500, plus triple net expenses, but the rental rate could be
adjusted after the first year. In contrast, the Addendum limited the rental
rate to debt obligations and triple net expenses, and provided no annual
increases. Parvin never adjusted the rental rate until August 18, 2020, when
it attempted to increase the rental rate to $19,744. Microwave Dynamics
objected to the rental increase, arguing that Parvin waived the contractual
right to adjust the rent because it did not exercise that right within the “‘first
successive twelve-month period following the first day of the first full
calendar month of the term.’” After Parvin served Microwave Dynamics with
a 3-day notice to pay the newly adjusted rent or quit the property, Microwave
Dynamics paid the adjusted rental rate under protest and filed suit seeking a
judicial determination of the lease terms and specific performance.

3
The complaint also alleged that pursuant to an Operating
Agreement, executed by the Adel brothers on or about June 18, 2010, Peter
was entitled to distributions from Parvin. However, on information and
belief, the complaint alleged that Parvin distributed at least $100,000 to
Shaun and Brian, and none to Peter in violation of the Operating Agreement.
Peter also alleged that in violation of the Operating Agreement, he was
denied access to Parvin’s books and records.
The Lease provided that the monthly rental rate was $16,500.
Microwave Dynamics also was responsible for utilities, insurance property
taxes, and reasonable repairs, i.e., triple net expenses. Under paragraph 5,
the Lease provided: “The rental specified is based upon the Basic Index (as
herein defined), and shall be subject to adjustment, up or down as the case
may be, as of the first successive twelve (12) month period following the first
day of the first full calendar month of the term (each) such twelve month
period being herein referred to as a (‘Year’). The amount of monthly rent
actually payable for each year of the term after the first year shall be equal to
the product of (I) the index (as hereinafter defined) most recently published
prior to the beginning of the year for which the adjustment is made,
multiplied by (ii) the rental specified in Clause 5 hereof prior to any
adjustment, divided by (iii) the Basic Index.”
“Notwithstanding anything in this Lease to the contrary, the
monthly rent for any year shall never be less than the rental specified above.
‘Index’ shall mean the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers for
Los Angeles-Long Beach-Anaheim, CA (1967:100) published by the Bureau of
Labor Statistics, United States Department of Labor. ‘Basic Index’: shall
mean the Consumer Price Index most recently published prior to the
Commencement Date. If the Index as now constituted, compiled and

4
published shall be requested to furnish a statement converting the Basic
Index to a figure that would be comparable in another Index published by the
Bureau of Labor Statistics and such other Index shall be used in computing
the adjustment in rental provided herein.”
The Addendum provided: “The rent payable by Tenant under the
Lease is limited to: [¶] a. Debt service payable to the Interim/Third Party
Lender on its loan(s); [¶] b. Debt service payable to CDC (‘CDC’) and the U.S.
Small Business Administration (the ‘SBA’) on the 504 Loan; [¶] c. Real Estate
and rental taxes, association fees/dues, utilities, insurance, and reasonable
repair replacement reserves to the extent that Tenant, in accordance with the
Lease, is not paying any or all of such items.”
Parvin filed an answer, generally denying the factual allegations
and raising numerous affirmative defenses, including setoff.
On March 11, 2021, Parvin filed a cross-complaint against
Microwave Dynamics, alleging causes of action for declaratory relief and
breach of action. Parvin sought a judicial determination that the monthly
rent rate was $20,338.38 from January 1, 2021, through December 31, 2021.
Parvin also sought damages for breach of the lease in an amount to be
determined at trial, but no less than $194,768 based on annual Consumer
Price Index (CPI) increases.
Microwave Dynamics filed an answer to the cross-complaint,
generally denying the factual allegations and raising numerous affirmative
defenses.
B. Bench Trial
The parties waived their right to a jury trial on their respective
claims. Before the bench trial, the parties filed their respective trial briefs

5
and stipulated to joint trial exhibits, which included the Lease and the
Addendum.
1. Trial Briefs
Parvin’s trial brief argued that it had been seeking an increase in
rent for many years, but Microwave Dynamics refused and continued to only
pay $16,500 monthly. It contended that even if the court were to find the rent
was a fixed $16,500, Microwave Dynamics would still owe at least $112,585
in back rent. As to the alleged unequal distributions to Peter, Parvin
contends that “funds were diverted (whether intentional[ly] or inadvertent is
immaterial) from Parvin to Microwave Dynamics’ benefit to pay for [its] triple
net expenses under the commercial lease. The unequal Parvin distributions
complained of were made in an effort [to] equalize the parties’ accounts based
on these improperly diverted funds.”
In plaintiffs’ trial brief, Microwave Dynamics argued the parties
did not dispute the validity of the Addendum, and under its terms, the base
rent was lower than $16,500 and there were no annual increases. Microwave
Dynamics argued it overpaid rent by $142,647. Peter Adel argued he was
entitled to 30 percent of Parvin distributions based on his share of the
company. He acknowledged Parvin’s Operating Agreement does not specify
how distributions would be allocated, but argued that under Corporations
Code section 17704.04, subdivision (e), “[i]f the operating agreement does not
otherwise provide, profits and losses shall be allocated in proportion to the
value, as stated in the required records, of the contributions the limited
liability company has received from each member.” As to the defense based
on Peter’s payment of Microwave Dynamics’s triple net expenses with checks
drawn from Parvin’s accounts, Peter argued (1) those payments were made

6
by Brian, not Peter; and (2) any “embezzlement” of Parvin’s funds thus would
have been committed by Microwave Dynamics or Brian, not Peter.
The bench trial on the claims was held in January of 2023.
2. Peter Adel’s Testimony
Peter testified that, when he and his brothers formed Microwave
Dynamics in 1993, Shaun owned 50 percent of the shares, Peter 30 percent,
and Brian 20 percent. In 2014, Shaun started his own business, and his
shares were split between Peter and Brian, resulting in Peter owning 60
percent of Microwave Dynamics. In 2018, Peter acquired Brian’s shares,
making him the sole owner of Microwave Dynamics.
The Adel brothers decided to purchase a commercial property to
save on rent, and in 2010, they formed Parvin to acquire the property. The
property was 10,000 square feet, and Microwave Dynamics was and remains
the only tenant. After Parvin acquired the property, Microwave Dynamics
spent approximately $850,000 to improve the building in 2011.
Shaun was responsible for finding financing to purchase the
property. The Adel brothers took out two loans: a Small Business
Administration loan (SBA loan) and a loan from a commercial bank. The
latter was paid off in the beginning of 2021, but the SBA loan was still
outstanding at the time of trial.
Peter testified Brian was the Chief Financial Officer (CFO) of
Microwave Dynamics from the inception of the company until November
2018. During that time, Brian sent rent checks in the amount of $16,500 to
Parvin. After November 2018, Peter began paying the rent to Parvin. He paid
$16,500 in rent because Brian was paying that amount and Peter “assumed
that that’s the right amount.”
Peter recalled that around May 2019, his brothers discussed

7
selling Parvin’s commercial property, which Microwave Dynamics was
renting. Shaun wanted to increase the rent to increase the valuation of the
property. Peter refused. Peter also testified that no one ever mentioned
reserving the right to increase the base rent until August 2020. After the
increased rent was demanded, in January 2021, Peter began paying the
increased rent under protest. He sent two checks for the rent: one in the
amount of $16,500, and one in the amount of $3,244, representing the
increased rent. In March 2022, after becoming aware Parvin was conceding
the validity of the Addendum, Peter began sending rental checks in the
amount of $6,264.97. On cross-examination, Peter acknowledged he was
aware the Addendum existed in January 2021, after receiving the 3-day
notice to pay the increased rent. However, he was not comfortable making a
claim that the rent should be paid consistent with the Addendum until it was
authenticated in early 2022 by his brothers at their respective depositions.
He denied intentionally waiving his right to enforce the Addendum.
Peter testified he may have received one distribution from Parvin
in 2011, but he never received any distributions from 2020 until present.
Peter also made several requests to access Parvin’s books and records since
2020, but was denied.
3. Brian Adel’s Testimony
Brian testified that, in January 2015, he conducted an audit of
Microwave Dynamics and determined that from 2011 through 2014, Parvin
was paying for some triple net expenses that should have been paid by
Microwave Dynamics. After 2015, Microwave made all the payments required
under either the Lease or the Addendum. Brian testified that Microwave
returned $35,000 to Parvin, but still owed around $70,000. Asked how Parvin
was able to make these payments on behalf of Microwave Dynamics, Brian

8
explained that Microwave Dynamics had purchased the building and opened
an account to provide capital for Parvin, and quitclaimed the building and
any remaining amounts in the account to Parvin when Parvin was formed.
Some of that money was distributed to the Adel brothers in 2011.
Brian testified he did not receive any distribution from Parvin
from 2012 through 2016. In 2019, Parvin distributed around $73,000 total to
the Adel brothers. Brian did not recall whether there was a distribution in
2020. In 2021, there was a distribution of around $149,000 total, but Peter
didn’t receive any of the distribution. There was no distribution in 2022.
Brian testified that, from 2011 through 2018, on behalf of
Microwave Dynamics, he paid $16,500 for rent to Parvin. He never
considered what the Addendum said about the rental amount, and the
$16,500 amount was never equal to the debt service on the bank and SBA
loans. During this time period, he served as the CFO for Microwave
Dynamics and the manager and bookkeeper for Parvin.
4. The Trial Court Decision
Following trial, the court determined as follows: “[The] Court
finds the rent was properly set at $16,500.00, and that the parties did not act
on the addendum, but rather always acted on the original lease. [¶] [The]
Court finds the parties did not act on the Consumer Price Index (CPI)
increases until January 2021. [The] Court indicated the calculations of the
CPI increases would start January 1, 2021, going forward on an annual basis.
CPI increases are to be determined and agreed upon by the parties, according
to the Los Angeles-Long Beach-Anaheim CPI Index in the lease.”
It further determined that “Microwave Dynamics has overpaid
rent from January 2021 through February 2022, and underpaid from March
1, 2022 through January 1, 2023.”

9
As to the distribution-related claims, the court found “Parvin,
LLC owes Peter Adel $63,857,” but that “Microwave Dynamics owes Parvin,
LLC $70,000.” It concluded that Peter was the prevailing party against
Parvin, and ordered Parvin to grant Peter access to its books within 30 days.
Parvin was the prevailing party against Microwave Dynamics.
5. Stipulated Order
Subsequently, the parties met and conferred to determine the
annual CPI increases and the calculations of the various damages amounts.
They expressly stated that the calculations were completed “without waiver
to any rights to appeal.” The parties agreed that pursuant to the trial court’s
rulings, judgment would be entered in favor of Parvin and against Microwave
Dynamics in the total amount of $106,938.96, consisting of $100,795.96 in
back rent, plus $70,000 for triple net expenses owing from 2011 through
2014, offset by Peter’s award of $63,857. The monthly base rental rate for the
calendar year 2023 would be $18,718.42; the Addendum had no force or
effect; and starting on January 1, 2024 and every January 1st thereafter, the
monthly rental rate would be increased consistent with Section 5 of the
Lease. The parties further stipulated Parvin would provide Peter access to its
books and records by March 2, 2023.
The trial court signed the stipulated order, and it was entered as
a judgment on February 22, 2023. Microwave Dynamics and Peter Adel then
appealed.
II
WAIVER
Microwave Dynamics contends the trial court erred in
determining that “by its conduct [it] waived the rental scheme set forth in the
Lease addendum in favor of that set forth in the original lease.” “To establish

10
waiver under generally applicable contract law, the party opposing
enforcement of a contractual agreement must prove by clear and convincing
evidence that the waiving party knew of the contractual right and
intentionally relinquished or abandoned it. [Citations.] . . . Under the clear
and convincing evidence standard, the proponent of a fact must show that it
is ‘highly probable’ the fact is true. [Citation.] The waiving party’s knowledge
of the right may be ‘actual or constructive.’ [Citation.] Its intentional
relinquishment or abandonment of the right may be proved by evidence of
words expressing an intent to relinquish the right or of conduct that is so
inconsistent with an intent to enforce the contractual right as to lead a
reasonable factfinder to conclude that the party had abandoned it.” (Quach v.
California Commerce Club, Inc. (2024) 16 Cal.5th 562, 584.)
“Whether there has been a waiver is a question of fact.
[Citations.] We review the trial court’s finding of waiver under the deferential
‘substantial evidence’ standard. [Citations.] ‘Where findings of fact are
challenged on a civil appeal, we are bound by the “elementary, but often
overlooked principle of law, that . . . the power of an appellate court begins
and ends with a determination as to whether there is any substantial
evidence, contradicted or uncontradicted,” to support the findings below.
[Citation.] We must therefore view the evidence in the light most favorable to
the prevailing party, giving it the benefit of every reasonable inference and
resolving all conflicts in its favor in accordance with the standard of review so
long adhered to by this court.’” (Bickel v. City of Piedmont (1997) 16 Cal.4th
1040, 1052-1053, superseded by statute on other grounds as stated in Eller
Media Co. v. City of Los Angeles (2001) 87 Cal.App.4th 1217, 1219, fn. 3.)
Where, as here, the substantial evidence test applies and “the evidence gives
rise to conflicting reasonable inferences, one of which supports the finding of

11
the trial court, the trial court’s finding is conclusive on appeal. [Citation.]
That rule applies even where the standard of proof in the trial court was
‘clear and convincing evidence’ rather than ‘a preponderance of the evidence.’”
(Rubin v. Los Angeles Fed. Sav. & Loan Assn. (1984) 159 Cal.App.3d 292, 298
(Rubin).)
Here, Microwave Dynamics does not argue it was unaware of the
rental scheme set forth in the Addendum, which was executed in April 2011.
Any contrary contention would not be supported by the record because Peter,
its Chief Executive Officer, and Brian, its CFO from 2011 through November
2018, were signatories of the Addendum. Thus, Microwave Dynamics had
knowledge of the rental scheme in the Addendum.
However, the evidence established that from 2011 through early
2022, Microwave Dynamics did not act consistent with the rental scheme set
forth in the Addendum. Rather than paying an amount equal to the debt
service on two loans, as set forth in the Addendum, it paid the base $16,500
rent set forth in the Lease. Brian testified he never considered the Addendum
when paying the monthly rental rate and the $16,500 amount never equaled
the debt service on the loans. When Brian left in November of 2018, Peter
continued to pay the $16,500 base amount. After Parvin sought an increased
rent, Peter continued to pay the $16,500 base amount and paid the difference
between the base amount and the increased amount under protest. Peter
never asserted the rental scheme in the Addendum should apply until March
2022. The record thus shows by clear and convincing evidence that
Microwave Dynamics through its conduct over a decade waived any right to
enforce the rental scheme set forth in the Addendum.
Microwave Dynamics argues that Peter is the only individual
who can waive a contractual right on behalf of Microwave Dynamics and thus

12
the prior conduct of Brian should not be considered. Even if true, the evidence
does not suggest Brian was acting contrary to Peter’s wishes when he made
the $16,500 payments. Peter never expressed that the rental scheme in the
Addendum applied until March 2022, and his continuation of the same
payments after Brian left indicates that Brian was acting with the scope of
his authority when he made the $16,500 payment. Although Peter testified
he never intended to have Microwave Dynamics waive its rights under the
Addendum, a subjective intent to waive is not required for a finding of waiver
by conduct. (See, e.g., Rubin, supra, 159 Cal.App.3d at p. 298 [holding
appellant “is mistaken in urging that no waiver could be found in the absence
of its actual subjective intent to waive its rights”]; Oakland Raiders v.
Oakland-Alameda County Coliseum, Inc. (2006) 144 Cal.App.4th 1175, 1194
[“where a party’s conduct is so inconsistent with the intent to enforce a legal
right, the intention to give up that right will be presumed, notwithstanding
evidence that the party did not subjectively ‘intend’ to relinquish it”];
McDanels v. General Ins. Co. (1934) 1 Cal.App.2d 454, 460 (McDanels)[“To
constitute a waiver there must be an existing right, a knowledge of its
existence, and an actual intention to relinquish it, or such conduct as
1
warrants an inference of the relinquishment.” (Italics added)].) The trial court
properly found waiver by conduct.
III
SETOFF
With respect to Peter’s claims relating to the Parvin
distributions, the trial testimony established that the distributions to Peter

1
We note Microwave Dynamics omitted the italicized language
when citing McDanels in discussing the elements of waiver.

13
were withheld to “equalize” the amount Microwave Dynamics owed to Parvin
for certain expenses in 2011 through 2014. The trial court ruled Peter was
entitled to $63,857 for his pro-rata share of the distributions, but that
Microwave Dynamics owed Parvin $70,000. The stipulated judgment offset or
setoff Peter’s $63,857 judgment against Parvin with Parvin’s $70,000
judgment against Microwave Dynamics.
Peter contends the trial court erred in awarding Parvin $70,000
because Parvin never affirmatively requested such damages in its cross-
complaint. Even if it had, the claim was time-barred by the applicable four-
year statute of limitations since it accrued at the latest in 2015, and the
cross-complaint was filed in 2021.
Peter further contends that the $70,000 judgment against
Microwave Dynamics could not be used to offset Peter’s $63,857 award
because there was no mutuality of interest between Peter, who brought his
claim in his capacity as a member of Parvin entitled to distributions, and
Microwave Dynamics, a corporate entity who owed Parvin damages for triple
net expenses under the Lease for the time period of 2011 through 2014, when
it was jointly owned by the Adel brothers.
Parvin concedes that it did not assert an affirmative claim in its
cross-complaint for the triple net expense discrepancy and that the trial court
cannot create such an affirmative claim. However, Parvin notes that it
asserted setoff as an affirmative defense to the first amended complaint and
substantial evidence supported the court’s setoff determination. Essentially,
Parvin argues the trial court could make its setoff ruling because Parvin
asserted a setoff affirmative defense.
We agree that the trial court’s determination that Microwave
Dynamics owed $70,000 to Parvin for triple net expenses from 2011 through

14
2014 is supported by substantial evidence, but are not persuaded that the
factual determination is relevant to the issues in this case. Under Code of
Civil Procedure section 431.70, which codifies the setoff affirmative defense,
“where cross-demands for money have existed between persons at any point
in time when neither demand was barred by the statute of limitations, and
an action is thereafter commenced by one such person, the other person may
assert in the answer the defense of payment in that the two demands are
compensated so far as they equal each other . . . .” The factual finding that
Microwave owed $70,000 and the ruling that the amount can be offset
against Peter’s distributions was made in connection with Peter’s claims for
his pro rata share of the Parvin distributions. However, Peter is the only
named plaintiff for those claims. Microwave Dynamics does not have an
interest in the Parvin distributions. Thus, there is no mutuality as required
under Code of Civil Procedure section 431.70, i.e., Microwave Dynamics never
made any demand for distributions against Parvin such that Parvin can
offset the triple net expenses discrepancy. Accordingly, Peter’s award for his
pro rata share of the Parvin distribution cannot be offset by the $70,000
discrepancy owed by Microwave Dynamics. Peter is entitled to an award of
$63,857. Moreover, because there was no affirmative claim and setoff was
asserted only as an affirmative defense, $70,000 cannot be added to the
money judgment against Microwave Dynamics for back rent. (See Morris
Cerullo World Evangelism v. Newport Harbor Offices & Marina, LLC (2021)
67 Cal.App.5th 1149, 1158 [“an affirmative defense cannot give rise to
affirmative relief such as damages”].)
Finally, we reject Parvin’s contention that by stipulating to the
judgment, Peter waived or forfeited any challenge to the setoff ruling. The
parties expressly agreed that the stipulated “calculation” of the damages

15
amounts did not constitute a “waiver of any right to appeal” the court’s
rulings. Parvin argues the calculation of damages where appellate rights
were reserved is limited to the CPI increase calculation based on the court’s
order, but there is no such limitation in the reservation of right in the
stipulation. In light of the other calculations in the stipulation, we interpret
the reservation of appeal rights to encompass Peter’s challenge to the trial
court’s setoff ruling.
IV
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed in part, reversed in part. The ruling
offsetting Peter’s $63,857 award with the $70,000 award against Microwave
Dynamics for the triple net expense discrepancy from 2011 through 2014 is
reversed. Peter is entitled to $63,857 for his pro rata share of the Parvin
distributions, and Microwave Dynamics is not liable for the $70,000 triple net
expenses discrepancy for the reasons stated in this opinion. The remaining
rulings are affirmed. The superior court is ordered to correct the judgment in
a manner consistent with this opinion. The parties shall bear their own costs
on appeal.

DELANEY, J.

WE CONCUR:

MOORE, ACTING P. J.

GOETHALS, J.

16

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.