In re S.T. CA2/1

CourtListener 10324166CalctappJan 30, 2025

Full text

Filed 1/30/25 In re S.T. CA2/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION ONE

In re S.T. et al., Persons B334924
Coming Under the Juvenile (Los Angeles County
Court Law. Super. Ct. No. 22CCJP01020)

LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF
CHILDREN AND FAMILY
SERVICES,

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

A.A.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County, Marguerite D. Downing, Judge. Affirmed
with directions.
Elizabeth C. Alexander, under appointment by the
Court of Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel and Jacklyn K. Louie, Principal
Deputy County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
____________________

This appeal involves mother’s claims the juvenile court
committed the following reversible errors: (1) It should not have
terminated jurisdiction at the Welfare and Institutions1 Code
section 364 hearing because substantial evidence demonstrated
circumstances requiring continued jurisdiction; (2) it abused its
discretion in not giving mother joint legal custody with father
over their children, S.T. and A.T.; and (3) it abused its discretion
in not giving mother overnight visitation.
Mother misconceives our standard of review of a court’s
termination of dependency jurisdiction at a section 364 hearing.
Because she had the burden of proof below to show that
continued jurisdiction was necessary and failed to meet that
burden, to demonstrate error on appeal she must show that as a
matter of law, the evidence compelled a finding in her favor.
(In re J.M. (2023) 89 Cal.App.5th 95, 111.) She has failed to
make that showing.
The juvenile court did not abuse its discretion in denying
mother overnight visitation. There was evidence below that
mother used cocaine during the reunification period, and when
under the influence of cocaine, had difficulty controlling her
impulses.

1 Undesignated statutory citations are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.

2
Finally, as reflected in the transcript of proceedings and
the juvenile court’s minute order, the court did award mother
joint legal custody, although the final custody order does not so
reflect. We thus remand solely for the purpose of allowing the
juvenile court to correct the judgment to reflect joint legal
custody. In all other respects, we affirm.

BACKGROUND
Mother A.A. and father have two children, S.T. (born in
2016) and A.T. (born in 2018). Father also has two children with
J.W.2 Prior to the dependency proceedings, mother and father
were involved in numerous domestic disputes, and each called
law enforcement.
During the dependency proceedings, S.T. and A.T. lived
with maternal grandmother until they moved in with father.

1. The court sustains the section 300 petition
DCFS filed a petition on March 18, 2022 under section 300,
subdivisions (a), (b)(1), and (j).
As later sustained, DCFS alleged that mother and father
“have a history of engaging in violent physical altercations. On
or about 02/02/2022, the father choked the mother with the
father’s hands, in the presence of the children. The father
attempted to strike the mother with the father’s fist. The father
threw objects towards the mother. The father struck and forcibly
pushed the mother. The father broke down a door in the

2 Father and J.W.’s children were declared dependents of
the juvenile court in 2019. In February 2022, the juvenile court
terminated dependency jurisdiction and awarded J.W. sole legal
and physical custody of her children with father.

3
children’s home, while the mother and children were in the room.
The father took the mother’s phone when the mother attempted
to call law enforcement. The violent altercation resulted in the
mother sustaining injuries to the mother’s neck and knee, bruises
to the mother’s body and lacerations to the mother’s face, chest,
arms and legs. The father was arrested for . . . intimate partner
violence. On 1/1/2021, the father shoved and struck the mother.
On a prior occasion, the father forcibly threw a cellular phone
towards the mother, inflicting a bruise to the mother’s eye. On
prior occasions, the mother and father engaged in domestic
violence. The children’s paternal half-siblings . . . are prior
dependents of the juvenile court due to the father’s violent
conduct against the half-siblings’ mother. The violent conduct by
the father against the mother, endangers the children’s physical
health and safety, creates a detrimental home environment and
places the children at risk of serious physical harm, damage and
danger.” (Capitalization omitted.)
DCFS further alleged father “has a history and is a current
abuser of alcohol and marijuana, which renders the father
incapable of providing the children with regular care and
supervision. On 2/25/2022, the father had a positive toxicology
screen for marijuana. On or about 02/02/2022 and prior
occasions, the father was under the influence of alcohol, while the
children were in the father’s care and supervision. The children
are of such a young age requiring constant care and supervision
and the father’s substance abuse interferes with the father’s
ability to provide regular care and supervision of the children.
The father has a history of a criminal conviction for” driving
under the influence, and his substance abuse “endangers the

4
children’s physical health and safety and places the children at
risk of serious physical harm, damage, [and] danger.”
Social workers interviewed mother, father, and S.T.
Mother and father each blamed the other for the domestic
violence. S.T. described mother and father as having “ ‘a
thousand fights.’ ” Father admitted using marijuana once or
twice a month to alleviate insomnia, backaches, joint pain, and
anxiety. Father reported he had “slowed down [his] drinking”
and did not drink and drive. Father also reported mother used
cocaine, which mother denied. She claimed, “I don’t use cocaine
at all.” Mother told the social worker father abused her causing
cuts on her knee, neck, and face as well as bruises on her arms.
Mother reported father drank alcohol when he felt stress.
In May 2022, mother pleaded no contest to the section 300
petition, and the juvenile court sustained all allegations against
father and assumed jurisdiction over the children. The juvenile
court removed the children from their parents’ custody and
placed them with maternal grandmother. The court ordered
mother to randomly test for controlled substances, attend
domestic violence and parenting classes, and individual
counseling. The court ordered father to participate in the
following: drug and alcohol programs and random drug testing,
52-week domestic violence class, parenting class, and individual
counseling. The court ordered monitored visitation for both
parents. The court ordered DCFS to provide family reunification
services for both parents.

5
2. The court sustains a section 342 petition regarding
mother’s conduct
On September 8, 2022, DCFS filed a section 342 petition.3
DCFS alleged that mother has a history of substance abuse and
currently abused cocaine and marijuana which rendered her
incapable of providing S.T. and A.T. with regular care and
supervision. On August 25, 2022, mother tested positive for
cocaine and marijuana. The section 342 petition contained no
allegations against father.
In October 2022, the juvenile court sustained the
allegations in the section 342 petition. The court ordered mother
to participate in a substance abuse program with random testing
and a 12-step program.

3. Father’s conduct during the reunification period
In September 2022, DCFS reported father tested positive
for marijuana in February 2022 and in August 2022. He missed
16 tests scheduled from April 2022 through August 2022. Father
enrolled in domestic violence and parenting classes and was put
on a wait list for individual counseling. In September 2022,
DCFS also reported the children enjoyed visiting with father.

3 Section 342, subdivision (a) provides: “In any case in
which a minor has been found to be a person described by
Section 300 and the petitioner alleges new facts or circumstances,
other than those under which the original petition was sustained,
sufficient to state that the minor is a person described in
Section 300, the petitioner shall file a subsequent petition. This
section does not apply if the jurisdiction of the juvenile court has
been terminated prior to the new allegations.”

6
In November 2022, DCFS reported father missed all his
drug tests in September and October. DCFS indicated that when
a social worker asked father about his missed tests, father stated
he did not know how to test and was having difficulty working
and “juggl[ing]” all of his services. Father was attending
domestic violence and parenting classes and recently moved off a
wait list for individual counseling.
In its November 28, 2022 report, DCFS reported father was
partially compliant with his case plan. Father continued
domestic violence classes and also took anger management
classes. Father consistently visited the children, and the social
worker “observed no child safety issues with father as father is
very hands on with the children and he observes when the
children [are] at risk[,] . . . he redirects them away from [the
risk].” According to the social worker, father responded
appropriately, patiently, and lovingly towards the children.
Father bonded with the children and was “making an effort to
drug test.” Father began therapy and reported it was helping
him.
In January 2023, the court allowed father unmonitored
visits in addition to his monitored visits. In other words, some of
father’s visits were monitored and some were unmonitored. In
February 2023, DCFS requested the juvenile court order father’s
visits monitored because father had tested positive for marijuana
on January 30, 2023. DCFS reported father refused to work with
the social worker because he believed DCFS showed favoritism
toward mother. In March 2023, the juvenile court ordered
father’s visits monitored.
In June 2023, father told a social worker that he lived with
his aunt and worked several jobs to support the children. Father

7
stated he was ready to have the children placed in his custody
and changed his work schedule to make it easier to care for them.
In June 2023, DCFS also reported father tested positive for
marijuana once in January 2023 and tested negative for all
substances 16 times between February 2023 and May 2023.
Father missed one test in April and one test in May. DCFS’s
June 2023 report indicated father had completed parenting,
domestic violence, and anger management programs. Father
engaged in individual therapy and according to the therapist,
father was consistent with his therapy. Although father initially
was reluctant to participate in a drug program, he enrolled after
finding a program that would also allow him to work and spend
time with the children.
DCFS’s June 2023 report indicated that a month earlier,
DCFS had liberalized father’s visits to unmonitored. DCFS
opined the children would be safe in father’s home if father
continued to receive services. DCFS reported father “has
provided for [the] children and . . . . has been working to ensure
extra shifts at the many jobs that he currently has so that he is
able to provide financially for his household . . . .” The social
worker concluded father improved his parenting skills, and father
believed he had as well. DCFS recommended the juvenile court
terminate its jurisdiction and place the children in father’s home.
On June 9, 2023, the social worker received certificates
showing father completed parenting, domestic violence, and
anger management programs. DCFS allowed father to have an
overnight visit and father reported he planned to purchase bunk
beds for the children. Maternal grandmother reported the
children were fine after the overnight visit with father.

8
On June 21, 2023, the juvenile court ordered the children
placed in father’s home. The court found father had made
substantial progress towards mitigating the circumstances that
had initially led to the children being placed outside his care.
The court found placing the children in father’s care “would not
create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or
physical or emotional well-being” of the children. S.T. told the
social worker he “is doing good” in father’s home. S.T. said he felt
safe and comfortable in father’s home and never saw father drink
alcohol or smoke. A.T. also reported feeling safe and comfortable
with father and said, “she loves her dad and that she misses her
mother.”
In December 2023, DCFS reported the children were still
living with father and doing well. The social worker observed
that father and S.T. had “open communication.” DCFS reported
father “missed some of his drug tests” because he was “involved
with the children’s education, searching for consistent
employment and maintaining the children’s visitation schedule
with their mother . . . .” From the beginning of July through the
end of November, father tested negative for controlled substances
17 times. He missed eight tests in the same time period.
According to DCFS, father enjoyed having the children in his
home and developed daily routines for them. DCFS reported that
father loved the children and the children loved him.

4. Mother’s conduct during the reunification period
In August 2022, maternal grandmother reported mother
was under the influence of a substance in front of the children.
S.T. told maternal grandmother to keep the door locked to stop
mother from hurting maternal grandmother.

9
Mother acknowledged her cocaine use on August 26, 2022,
and she told the social worker she had been using cocaine once or
twice weekly for a year. That same day mother tested positive for
cocaine. Three days later mother entered an in-patient substance
abuse clinic. The social worker expressed concern about
“mother’s ongoing substance abuse and the aggression” she
displays when under the influence. DCFS also reported the
children were bonded to mother.
In October 2022, DCFS reported mother admitted that she
had been using cocaine on the weekends and sometimes during
the week. Mother informed a social worker that after drinking
alcohol, she would snort cocaine. Mother explained she was
“dancing to pay off [her] DUI and that’s where” she started using
cocaine. Mother asked for a referral to an in-patient drug
treatment program. Father told the social worker he first noticed
mother using cocaine in 2016.
In November 2022, DCFS reported that in connection with
her in-patient program, mother was taking parenting classes,
enrolled in a 12-step program, and engaged in therapy. Maternal
grandmother reported mother was bonded with the children.
Mother had not used cocaine since her admittance to the in-
patient program. Mother consistently visited the children and
showed an understanding of child development.
On January 7, 2023, mother’s therapist diagnosed mother
with severe cocaine use disorder. According to the therapist,
mother had difficulty controlling impulsive behavior. Mother
disagreed that she had severe cocaine disorder. On January 11,
2023, the court allowed mother unmonitored visitation.
In June 2023, DCFS reported mother had relapsed. Mother
admitted using cocaine and drinking alcohol. Mother said she

10
left an outpatient program because she was going to school and
working. Mother stated, “[F]ather is a great father and takes
great care of the kids” and mother would like the children to be
placed with father. Mother indicated she could not “take on th[e]
responsibility of [her] children, go to work, go to school,” and
participate in the court-ordered programs. Mother wanted to
return to an in-patient or out-patient program. Mother entered a
program but was discharged for breaking the program’s rules.
DCFS reported mother continued visiting the children
without a monitor but stopped testing for controlled substances.
In May 2023, mother admitted she had relapsed and was using
cocaine and alcohol. On June 20, 2023, DCFS filed a request to
change a court order asking the court to order mother’s visits
monitored. DCFS repeated that mother was discharged from her
drug treatment program.
On June 27, 2023, maternal grandmother told the social
worker mother was in a “drug induced slumber.” Maternal
grandmother stated, “If she gets belligerent or breaks windows,
as she has done, I’m having her arrested.” Maternal
grandmother stated that “[h]opefully the Father can keep [the
children] long term, because right now, their mother can be no
good to them, aside for visits.”
On June 28, 2023, mother told a social worker that she was
being admitted into an in-patient drug treatment program. A
July 25, 2023 letter from the treatment facility indicated
mother’s random drug tests were negative.
On July 26, 2023, the court ordered mother’s visits
monitored. In November 2023, mother was living in a “sober
living home.” Effective December 9, 2023, mother was permitted
unmonitored visits. In December 2023, DCFS reported that the

11
children enjoy their visits with mother. DCFS stated, “[M]other
loves her children and the children love mother.” Mother tested
negative for controlled substances from July 2023 through
November 2023.

5. In its section 364 report, DCFS recommended
terminating jurisdiction; after a section 364 review
hearing, the juvenile court terminated jurisdiction
On June 21, 2023, when the juvenile court ordered the
children placed in father’s custody, the court continued the
matter for review pursuant to section 364 in December 2023. In
its December 2023 report, DCFS recommended the court
terminate jurisdiction. DCFS further recommended mother and
father have joint legal custody and father sole physical custody.
At a hearing on December 20, 2023, no witness testified.4
Mother’s counsel and the children’s counsel requested the court
continue jurisdiction. The children’s counsel asked the juvenile
court to retain jurisdiction because counsel was “not comfortable
with overnight” visits by mother at that time and the children
“would like overnights with their mother . . . .” Mother’s counsel
argued that continued jurisdiction would give her “more time
with the children in the form of overnight visits.” Mother’s
counsel also requested that if the court terminate jurisdiction, it
award her joint legal custody and overnight visits.

4 The court excluded mother’s letter from a parenting
instructor and program director at the sober living house where
mother was living. The court found the letter was hearsay and
its description of mother’s “wonderfulness” was essentially
irrelevant. On appeal, mother does not argue the court erred in
excluding the evidence.

12
Father’s counsel argued the children were residing with
father and have been safe in his care. DCFS’s counsel requested
the court close the case with the parents having joint legal
custody and father having physical custody. DCFS acknowledged
that mother had made progress but was not ready yet for
overnight visits. DCFS argued there were no safety concerns for
the children in father’s care.
The court found the conditions that had justified the initial
assumption of jurisdiction no longer existed and did not appear
likely to exist if supervision is withdrawn. “Therefore, continued
jurisdiction of these children is no longer necessary” and the
court terminated its jurisdiction with a “juvenile court final exit
order giving the parents joint legal, sole physical [custody] to the
father, unmonitored day[ visits] for the mother.”
The juvenile court’s minute orders recite that the court
awarded mother and father joint legal custody. The juvenile
court’s final judgment, however, does not include a check in the
form allowing the parents “share joint legal custody . . . .”

DISCUSSION

A. Mother’s Claim That Substantial Evidence Would
Have Supported Continued Jurisdiction
Demonstrates No Error
Mother argues that the juvenile court erred in terminating
dependency jurisdiction at the section 364 hearing because
“substantial evidence supported conditions existed which would
justify initial assumption of jurisdiction over the children, and
those conditions were likely to exist if supervision was
withdrawn.” Mother’s argument is based on an incorrect
standard of review.

13
Section 364 governs status review hearings for dependent
juveniles who are not removed from a parent’s home or who are
returned to a parent. (In re J.M., supra, 89 Cal.App.5th at
p. 110.) “At a section 364 hearing, ‘the court shall determine
whether continued supervision is necessary. The court shall
terminate its jurisdiction unless [DCFS] establishes by a
preponderance of evidence that the conditions still exist which
would justify initial assumption of jurisdiction . . . or that those
conditions are likely to exist if supervision is withdrawn.’ (§ 364,
subd. (c).) Thus, ‘[w]here, as here, the social services agency
recommends termination of jurisdiction, termination will be the
“default result” unless either the parent, the guardian, or the
child objects and establishes by a preponderance of the evidence
that conditions justifying retention of jurisdiction exist or are
likely to exist if supervision is withdrawn.’ [Citation.]” (In re
J.M., supra, at pp. 110–111.)
Because mother had the burden of proof below to show
retained jurisdiction was necessary, we review whether the
evidence “ ‘compels a finding in favor of the appellant as a matter
of law[.]’ ” (In re J.M., supra, 89 Cal.App.5th at p.111, quoting
In re I.W. (2009) 180 Cal.App.4th 1517, 1528, overruled in part on
other grounds as stated in Conservatorship of O.B. (2020)
9 Cal.5th 989, 1010, fn.7.) The record does not support such a
finding.
The dependency proceedings commenced because of
domestic violence and father’s marijuana use. Father reported he
stopped using and consistently tested negative for controlled
substances for several months before the juvenile court
terminated jurisdiction. Additionally, there was no domestic
violence between mother and father after father began

14
reunification services. Father completed a 52-week domestic
violence program and parenting classes and had enrolled in
individual counseling. Mother reported father was a good father
to the children and a social worker observed father capably
parenting the children and noted the children had structure and
loved father. Significantly, the children were safe in father’s care
for several months prior to the juvenile court’s termination of its
jurisdiction. Given these facts, mother cannot demonstrate as a
matter of law that the juvenile court was required to continue its
jurisdiction.5

B. Mother Fails To Show the Juvenile Court Abused its
Discretion In Denying Overnight Visitation
Mother argues the evidence showed that she “was ready
for, and it was in the best interest of the children, for the juvenile
court to grant overnight visitation for mother.”
In issuing custody orders, the overarching factor is what
custody arrangements are in the best interest of the child. (In re
Chantal S. (1996) 13 Cal.4th 196, 206.) “ ‘[T]he juvenile court has
broad discretion to make custody [and visitation] orders when it
terminates jurisdiction in a dependency case [citation].’
[Citation.] . . . We will not disturb the juvenile court’s decision
‘ “ ‘unless the trial court has exceeded the limits of legal
discretion by making an arbitrary, capricious, or patently absurd
determination.’ ” ’ [Citation.]” (In re J.M., supra, 89 Cal.App.5th

5 Respondent argues that this court should review the
juvenile court’s order for substantial evidence. Although that
argument fails to acknowledge mother’s burden of proof, the
evidence we have described constitutes substantial evidence to
support the juvenile court’s order.

15
at pp. 112–113.) In reviewing an order for abuse of discretion, we
“ ‘must consider all the evidence, draw all reasonable inferences,
and resolve all evidentiary conflicts, in a light most favorable to
the trial court’s ruling.’ ” (In re Robert L. (1993) 21 Cal.App.4th
1057, 1067, superseded on other grounds by statute, as stated in
Cesar V. v. Superior Court (2001) 91 Cal.App.4th 1023.)
The evidence viewed in the light favorable to the juvenile
court’s order demonstrates mother (1) eventually sought
treatment but thereafter relapsed; (2) was discharged from a
drug treatment program for failing to follow the rules; and
(3) was living in a sober house at the time the juvenile court
terminated jurisdiction. Mother’s therapist diagnosed her with
severe cocaine addiction and questioned mother’s impulse control.
Maternal grandmother reported mother was under the influence
in front of the children. A social worker described mother as
aggressive when she was under the influence of a controlled
substance. Mother’s drug use and lack of impulse control
supported the juvenile court’s exercise of its discretion not to
allow mother overnight visits.

C. The Final Custody Order Must Be Corrected To
Reflect Joint Legal Custody
Mother argues the juvenile court abused its discretion in
denying her joint legal custody. In fact, the juvenile court
awarded mother joint legal custody as reflected in the court’s
statements at the hearing and its minute order. On the other
hand, the final custody order incorrectly fails to provide for joint
legal custody; it can be corrected upon remand.6 (In re

6 Respondent agrees that the final custody order should be
corrected to reflect joint legal custody.

16
Candelario (1970) 3 Cal.3d 702, 705 [“a court has the inherent
power to correct clerical errors in its records so as to make these
records reflect the true facts”]; see also People v. Little (1993)
19 Cal.App.4th 449, 452 [clerical error can be corrected at any
time].)

DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s final judgment is affirmed with
directions. The case is remanded to the juvenile court to correct
its judgment to reflect that mother and father share joint legal
custody of S.T. and A.T.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.

BENDIX, J.

We concur:

ROTHSCHILD, P. J.

M. KIM, J.

17

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.