People v. Ramos CA2/7

CourtListener 10318598CalctappJan 22, 2025

Full text

Filed 1/22/25 P. v. Ramos CA2/7
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has
not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION SEVEN

THE PEOPLE, B335043

Plaintiff and Respondent, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. BA496684)
v.

EVELIO RAMOS,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County, Michael Garcia, Judge. Affirmed.
The Justice Firm and Joseph Anthony Virgilio for
Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief
Assistant Attorney General, Susan Sullivan Pithey, Senior
Assistant Attorney General, Kenneth C. Byrne and Sophia A.
Lecky, Deputy Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
________________________
Evelio Ramos was charged with and convicted of numerous
acts of sexual abuse against his young stepdaughters over a
period of about six years. At trial, the prosecution introduced
evidence that he also committed non-sexual physical abuse
against his stepchildren. Because Ramos was not charged with
those acts of physical abuse, he contends the trial court abused
its discretion under Evidence Code section 3521 by allowing the
jury to hear about them. We conclude otherwise. The trial court
reasonably determined the probative value of the evidence was
not substantially outweighed by the risk of undue prejudice.
Among other things, the evidence of non-sexual physical abuse
showed Ramos’s disposition for domestic violence and provided
proof of duress, which was relevant to the charged sexual
offenses. The probative value of the uncharged non-sexual
physical abuse evidence also was not substantially outweighed by
the risk it would evoke unfair emotional bias in the jury. It was
far less inflammatory than the evidence of the charged sexual
abuse, which included graphic testimony of forcible sex crimes
against a child. For these reasons, we affirm.

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

A. Ramos Sexually Abuses Denise for Several Years
Denise is the youngest of six siblings, three of whom—
Doris, Elizabeth, and Jimmy—lived together with her, their
mother, and Ramos. Denise was around seven years old when
Ramos married her mother and the family moved to a house
together. The sexual abuse began shortly thereafter.

1 All further undesignated statutory references are to the
Evidence Code.

2
Ramos began by groping Denise. In one early incident,
Denise recalls being in the backyard and Ramos asking her if she
wanted him to touch her, which she understood to mean in a
sexual way. Gradually, Ramos began grabbing Denise’s breasts
and buttocks over her clothes while making inappropriate
comments. Eventually Ramos would put his hands underneath
her pants or inside her shirt.
Soon thereafter, Ramos started regularly digitally
penetrating Denise’s vagina. Ramos would ask her to help him
carry his tools to the shed in the backyard. There Ramos would
put his hands inside her pants and insert his fingers into her
vagina. It hurt because Ramos had big hands and long
fingernails. Denise told Ramos it was painful, but he ignored
her. He would keep his fingers inserted in her vagina for about a
minute. When he removed his fingers, he would smell them. He
would then act like nothing had happened. Ramos did this more
than 15 times in the shed.
Ramos would also molest Denise in the shower. While
Denise was showering, he would unlock the bathroom door and
pull back the sliding glass shower door. Ramos would then fondle
Denise’s breasts and digitally penetrate her vagina, leaving his
fingers inside her for a few minutes. Ramos did this between five
and 10 times in the shower and bathroom.
Starting when Denise was about eight or nine years old,
Ramos would force Denise to touch and stroke his penis, and to
put it in her mouth. On some occasions, Ramos would ask Denise
to come to the basement to help him with a chore and would
touch her breasts, put his hands inside her pants, and insert his
fingers into her vagina. Ramos would then remove his erect
penis from his pants and make her put it in her mouth. He

3
would grab Denise’s head or hair to force her to keep his penis in
her mouth. This would make her gag and choke, which disgusted
her. Ramos did this about 10 to 15 times in the basement.
On other occasions, Ramos would take Denise on errands in
his pickup truck. While in the truck, Ramos would sometimes
remove his penis, grab Denise’s wrist, and make her stroke his
penis. Other times Ramos would touch her breasts or vagina.
Ramos would also masturbate in Denise’s presence. These
incidents also occurred in the hallways and living room of the
house.
When Denise was still about eight or nine years old, Ramos
began penetrating her vagina with his penis. Ramos did this at
least 40 times—about half of which occurred before Denise
turned 11 and about half of which occurred after Denise turned
11. Denise recounted how Ramos would take her to his bedroom,
lock the door, and toss her on the bed. He would then take off her
pants and hold her down by her wrists. Ramos would force his
penis inside her vagina—starting with just the tip, but eventually
forcing it entirely inside her. This was painful. When Denise
would not comply, Ramos would raise his voice and make an
angry face. Denise felt scared, uncomfortable, and threatened.
Sometimes it would cause tearing and bleeding, and Denise
would go to the bathroom afterwards to clean up the blood and
cry. In addition to the bedroom, Ramos would also rape Denise in
the shed and basement.
During these years, siblings observed that Denise was
severely depressed, engaged in self-harm, and barely ate. She
would often have dark circles under her eyes from not sleeping.
Denise was always sad and would beg her siblings not to leave
her alone with Ramos. She also rarely wanted to sleep in her

4
own room, preferring instead to sleep with her older sister Doris.
Eventually Ramos forbade Denise from sleeping in Doris’s room.

B. Ramos Sexually Touches Elizabeth
Ramos also sexually abused Denise’s older sister Elizabeth
once when she was 13 years old. Elizabeth was lying in bed
pretending to be asleep. Ramos entered her room, closed the
door, lay on top of her, and rubbed her vagina over her clothes in
a circular motion with his elbow. Elizabeth felt disgusted but did
not react out of fear Ramos would make her do chores. Elizabeth
did not realize this conduct was not normal until she was 15
years old.

C. Denise and Elizabeth Report the Sexual Abuse
Ramos continued to sexually abuse Denise until she
reported it at age 13. She first told her older brother, Jimmy,
during a late-night conversation. Jimmy was upset and cried.
Days later, angry about the sexual abuse his sister had suffered,
Jimmy stabbed Ramos with a kitchen knife and ran off. Ramos
was taken to the hospital. Doris, the eldest sibling living in the
house, came home that night and found out about the sexual
abuse. Doris got upset and called their mother, who was at
Ramos’s bedside at the hospital. Doris demanded that her
mother come home so they could go to the police station to report
the abuse. Their mother was reluctant at first but eventually
complied.
At the police station, Denise cried and was unable to speak.
She wrote down her answers to police interview questions
instead. Police also interviewed Elizabeth. Before the interview,
the children’s mother tried to persuade Denise and Elizabeth that
someone other than Ramos must have sexually assaulted Denise.

5
Denise confirmed it was Ramos. Their mother’s insistence
confused Elizabeth, who later realized her mother was trying to
manipulate her to disbelieve Denise’s allegations. During the
police interview, Elizabeth recounted physical abuse by Ramos
but did not mention the incident in which Ramos touched her
sexually. The incident was “in the back of [her] head,” she “didn’t
really know how to bring it up,” and she “didn’t know if that was
the correct moment for [her] to say anything.” Elizabeth was also
worried about being taken away from her mother.
After the police interviews, a medical forensic exam was
conducted on Denise at a rape center. There were no physical
findings from the exam. This was not unusual because over 50
percent of sexual assault victims have no visible physical injuries.
For prepubescent children, that number is 80 percent. Injuries to
the vagina that occur when a child is age nine or 10 would not
show up when an exam is conducted years later at age 13.
Shortly after the police got involved, the children’s mother
took Elizabeth out of school to meet with an attorney. Their
mother told Elizabeth to make Ramos “look better” and that she
could get in trouble or deported if Ramos’s case got more serious.
At the attorney’s office, Elizabeth felt pressured not to say
anything about Ramos’s sexually abusing her because she did not
want anything to happen to her mother. Upon leaving the
attorney’s office, the children’s mother bought Elizabeth her first
cell phone. Elizabeth was happy about receiving the phone but
later realized that her mother was trying to “manipulate” and
“brainwash” her.
Within a month after Denise initially reported Ramos’s
sexual abuse, Denise and Elizabeth were removed from their
mother’s care. This was initially very emotional and difficult.

6
After becoming more comfortable in foster care, and with the help
of therapy and social workers, Denise was able to talk about the
sexual abuse she suffered. Denise originally had not told anyone
about the abuse because she did not think anyone would believe
her. Ramos had also told Denise that if anyone found out, it
would hurt her mother and break up their family. It took
Elizabeth one or two years in foster care to report what Ramos
had done to her. As a result of the abuse, Elizabeth was
hospitalized twice for mental health concerns and contemplated
suicide to avoid seeing Ramos again.

D. Denise, Jimmy, and Elizabeth Testify About Ramos’s Non-
sexual Physical Abuse Towards Them
While testifying about the home dynamics, Denise, Jimmy,
and Elizabeth also testified about non-sexual physical abuse
Ramos inflicted on them.
Denise testified that Ramos hit her, Jimmy, and Elizabeth
with his hands, belts, hangers, cables, or any other object within
his reach. If she or her siblings were farther away, Ramos would
throw objects at them. This physical abuse occurred almost
daily. Ramos did not physically abuse Denise’s older siblings
because they were adults. Doris lived in the home, but due to her
busy schedule, she spent limited time there, usually leaving early
in the morning and returning late at night.
The beatings sometimes left marks on Denise’s arms,
buttocks, and back. Although teachers at school never asked
Denise about the marks, her mother was aware of the physical
abuse. Sometimes Denise’s mother would tell Ramos to stop, but
other times she would watch and not intervene. Denise never
reported the physical abuse because she thought it was a normal
part of life to be hit and beaten every day.

7
Jimmy testified that once Ramos moved in with him and
his siblings, he became physically abusive toward Jimmy’s
mother and the rest of the family. The abuse occurred about once
a week and included slapping, choking, and hitting them with
objects. Jimmy explained that Ramos had a terrible temper.
Whenever Jimmy or his sisters heard Ramos’s truck arriving
home from work, they would leave the house to avoid being
around him.
Jimmy described one incident where Ramos strangled him
with both hands, squeezing so hard that Jimmy could not breathe
for about 10 seconds. Sometimes Jimmy fought back. Ramos
once slapped Jimmy, which began a fight between the two,
leaving Jimmy with a shirt covered in blood. Jimmy also
witnessed Ramos physically abuse his sisters Denise and
Elizabeth by slapping them, pulling their hair, and pinching
them. The siblings testified that Ramos was the most brutal with
Jimmy, because he was a boy.
Elizabeth testified that early on Ramos and the children
got along well. But after returning from his honeymoon with
their mother, Ramos’s behavior changed. He became demanding,
was quick to anger, and would throw food or hit their mother if,
for example, dinner was not ready when he came home from
work. Ramos also hit their mother when she tried to prevent him
from striking Elizabeth or her siblings. Elizabeth explained that
Ramos would pull her hair, throw things at her, and hit her with
belts, chargers, and hangers, leaving marks on her arms, legs,
buttocks, and head.
Elizabeth would cry herself to sleep and had problems at
school because of the abuse. She spoke to her school counselor in
ninth grade “mostly every day,” but she never disclosed the

8
physical abuse out of fear that her family would be separated by
social workers, which Ramos had threatened would happen.
Elizabeth felt too scared to speak up.

E. The Charges, Jury Verdicts, and Sentence
The Los Angeles County District Attorney charged Ramos
as follows: with respect to Denise, with one count of committing
a lewd or lascivious act on a minor under 14 years old (Pen. Code,
§ 288, subd. (a); count 1); two counts of oral copulation or sexual
penetration with a child 10 years old or younger (Pen. Code,
§ 288.7, subd. (b); counts 2 & 8); one count of forcible rape of a
child under 14 years old (Pen. Code, § 261, subd. (a)(2); count 5);
one count of forcible oral copulation of a child under 14 years old
(Pen. Code, § 288a, subd. (c)(2)(B); count 6);2 one count of sexual
intercourse with a child ten years or younger (Pen. Code, § 288.7,
subd. (a); count 7); and one count of sexual penetration by force of
a child under 14 years old (Pen. Code, § 289, subd. (a)(1)(B); count
9); and with respect to Elizabeth, with one count of committing a
lewd or lascivious act on a minor under 14 years old (Pen. Code,
§ 288, subd. (a); count 4).3
As to counts 1, 4, 5, 6, and 9, the district attorney alleged
Ramos committed the offenses against more than one victim each
under the age of 14. (Pen. Code, § 667.61, subd. (j)(2) & (e).)
A jury found Ramos guilty as charged and found true the
multiple-victim allegation.

2 Renumbered as Penal Code section 287, subdivision
(c)(2)(B).
3 An additional count for continuous sexual abuse of Denise
in violation of Penal Code section 288.5, subdivision (a), was
dismissed. ~(1 CT 236, 285)~

9
The trial court sentenced Ramos to state prison for a total
term of 180 years to life, consisting of consecutive terms of 25
years to life for counts 1, 4, 5, 6, 7, and 9 plus 15 years to life for
counts 2 and 8.
Ramos timely appealed.

DISCUSSION

A. Because the Trial Court Conducted a Section 352 Analysis
in Admitting the Non-Sexual Physical Abuse Evidence,
Ramos’s Challenge to the Evidence on That Ground Is
Preserved on Appeal
The People argue that Ramos forfeited his section 352
challenge to the trial court’s admission of the non-sexual physical
abuse evidence by failing to raise it below. Ramos claims his trial
counsel was constitutionally ineffective for “failing to
meaningfully object” to the admission of the physical abuse
evidence under section 352. Because Ramos’s trial counsel
objected generally to the non-sexual physical abuse evidence, and
the trial court ruled “on a [section] 352 analysis that it [wa]s
admissible,” we address Ramos’s evidentiary challenge on its
merits and need not address Ramos’s claim of ineffective
assistance of counsel.
To preserve a claim that a trial court abused its discretion
in admitting evidence, a party must make a timely and specific
objection. (§ 353, subd. (a); People v. Brooks (2017) 3 Cal.5th 1,
42.) Ordinarily, this means that to argue on appeal that evidence
should have been excluded under section 352, the party needs to
have made a meaningful objection on those specific grounds in
the trial court. (See People v. Valdez (2012) 55 Cal.4th 82, 138–
139 [defendant’s objection on relevance and foundation grounds

10
did not preserve for appeal the argument that certain evidence
should have been excluded under section 352].) However,
because “[t]he purpose of this rule is to encourage parties to bring
errors to the attention of the trial court, so that they may be
corrected” (In re S.B. (2004) 32 Cal.4th 1287, 1293, citing People
v. Saunders (1993) 5 Cal.4th 580, 590), an “objection will be
deemed preserved if, despite inadequate phrasing, the record
shows that the court understood the issue presented” (People v.
Scott (1978) 21 Cal.3d 284, 290).
Here, the trial court understood the nature of Ramos’s
challenge to the non-sexual physical abuse evidence and
conducted a section 352 analysis. Ramos’s attorney objected to
the evidence, referring to it with the shorthand “1101 evidence.”4
The People specified that this evidence consisted of “prior
complaints of physical abuse by all of the People’s witnesses
[who] are stepchildren of Mr. Ramos,” explained the nature of the
evidence, and argued for its admission. Although Ramos’s
counsel did not specifically mention section 352 in making the
objection, the trial court nonetheless ruled that the evidence was
admissible on a “[section] 352 analysis.” (See People v. Lewis
(2001) 25 Cal.4th 610, 637 [“evidence of uncharged misconduct
‘“is so prejudicial that its admission requires extremely careful
analysis”’ and to be admissible, such evidence ‘“must not
contravene other policies limiting admission, such as those
contained in . . . section 352”’”], quoting People v. Ewoldt (1994) 7
Cal.4th 380, 404 (Ewoldt); see also § 1109 [admission of evidence
of child abuse and other domestic violence is subject to a section

4 Section 1101 sets forth limitations on the admission of
evidence of character or prior bad acts.

11
352 analysis].) We will therefore address Ramos’s section 352
challenge on its merits.

B. The Trial Court Did Not Abuse Its Discretion in Admitting
the Uncharged Acts of Physical Abuse Under Section 352
Under section 352, the trial court “in its discretion may
exclude evidence if its probative value is substantially
outweighed by the probability that its admission will . . . create
substantial danger of undue prejudice, of confusing the issues, or
of misleading the jury.” “‘[T]he probative value of the evidence of
defendant’s uncharged offenses is the tendency of that evidence
to demonstrate the existence of’ the fact for which it is being
admitted . . . .” (People v. Walker (2006) 139 Cal.App.4th 782,
806–807, quoting Ewoldt, supra, 7 Cal.4th at p. 404.)
“‘The “prejudice” referred to in . . . section 352 applies to
evidence which uniquely tends to evoke an emotional bias against
defendant as an individual and which has very little effect on the
issues. In applying section 352, “prejudicial” is not synonymous
with “damaging.”’” (People v. Bolin (1998) 18 Cal.4th 297, 320;
People v. Garceau (1993) 6 Cal.4th 140, 178, overruled on a
different ground in People v. Yeoman (2003) 31 Cal.4th 93, 117–
118.) Relevant factors for evaluating undue prejudice in the
context of uncharged acts of domestic violence include whether
the acts were more inflammatory than the charged acts, the
recency of the uncharged acts, and the probability that the
uncharged acts evidence would confuse or distract the jury from
its main inquiry. (See People v. Jennings (2000) 81 Cal.App.4th
1301, 1315; People v. Poplar (1999) 70 Cal.App.4th 1129, 1139
(Poplar).)
Appellate courts “apply an abuse of discretion standard
when reviewing a ruling on an objection under . . . section[] 352 . .

12
. . [Citation.] A ruling subject to this standard of review ‘will not
be disturbed except on a showing the trial court exercised its
discretion in an arbitrary, capricious, or patently absurd manner
that resulted in a manifest miscarriage of justice.’” (People v.
Pineda (2022) 13 Cal.5th 186, 222, quoting People v. Rodriguez
(1999) 20 Cal.4th 1, 9–10.)
The evidence that Ramos physically abused the children
was relevant to issues at trial, and its probative value was not
substantially outweighed by the risk of undue prejudice, of
confusing the issues, or of misleading the jury.
For starters, “in a criminal action in which the defendant is
accused of an offense involving domestic violence, evidence of the
defendant’s commission of other domestic violence” is relevant to
show the defendant is disposed to commit domestic violence.
(§ 1109; CALCRIM No. 852A; see also People v. Johnson (2008)
164 Cal.App.4th 731, 739 [upholding the validity of CALCRIM
No. 852 with respect to section 1109 evidence].) “Domestic
violence” in this context is defined broadly to include child abuse
where, as here, the children reside with the defendant. (People v.
Dallas (2008) 165 Cal.App.4th 940, 942–943.) Moreover,
evidence of domestic violence in the form of acts of non-sexual
physical abuse is admissible to show a defendant’s propensity to
commit any type of domestic violence, including sexual offenses.
(See Poplar, supra, 70 Cal.App.4th at p. 1139 [evidence of prior
domestic violence admissible to show propensity for rape, “a
higher level of domestic violence”]; People v. Trujillo Garcia
(2001) 89 Cal.App.4th 1321, 1332–1336 [rejecting defendant’s
claim that non-sexual acts of domestic violence are inadmissible
because they “do not reflect a tendency toward sexually
assaultive behavior”].) Accordingly, evidence of Ramos’s acts of

13
non-sexual physical abuse was probative of his propensity to
commit the sexual abuse charged against him.
The evidence of non-sexual physical abuse was also directly
relevant to a common element in three of the charged offenses.
Forcible rape, oral copulation, and sexual penetration all require
the acts be “accomplished against a person’s will by means of
force, violence, duress, menace, or fear of immediate and
unlawful bodily injury on the person or another.” (Pen. Code,
§§ 261, subd. (a)(2), 287, subd. (c)(2)(B), 289, subd. (a)(1)(B).) The
trial court instructed the jury that for “duress” it should “consider
all the circumstances, including the minor’s age and her
relationship to the defendant.” (See CALCRIM Nos. 1000, 1015,
1045.) Evidence of Ramos’s physical abuse in the home was
relevant to the jury’s understanding of Denise’s relationship to
Ramos and the threat of violence that loomed over her. Indeed,
at least one court found insufficient evidence of forcible sex
crimes where, among other things, “[t]here was no evidence of a
threat or prior threat of bodily harm such as spanking.” (See,
e.g., People v. Jeff (1988) 204 Cal.App.3d 309, 326.)
In addition, the evidence of physical abuse illuminated
aspects of the home dynamics that were relevant in at least two
ways.
First, it helped explain Denise’s and Elizabeth’s delayed
reporting of the sexual abuse. The evidence showed that Ramos
was easy to anger and would frequently beat the children without
provocation. The jury was permitted to infer that the children
did not report their sexual abuse, at least in part, for fear of being
further physically abused in response.
Second, the pervasiveness of non-sexual physical abuse in
the home—which one child described as “living in Hell”—could

14
explain why Denise’s siblings did not notice the signs of sexual
abuse earlier. Denise’s not wanting to be alone with Ramos, not
sleeping or eating well, and appearing depressed were signs of
her having suffered sexual abuse but were also consistent with
being physically abused in a non-sexual way. Here, again, the
jury was permitted to infer that these signs of Denise’s sexual
abuse were less noticeable to the siblings because Ramos’s
physical abuse affected all of them.
As for undue prejudice, there is always some risk that
evidence of the defendant’s uncharged bad acts will evoke an
emotional response in the jury. But that risk did not
substantially outweigh the probative value of the evidence here.
This is particularly so because the uncharged acts of non-sexual
physical abuse—while also serious and concerning—were no
more inflammatory than the sexual abuse at issue. The jurors
heard in graphic detail how dozens and dozens of times over the
course of six years Ramos raped his stepdaughter, digitally
penetrated her against her will, and forced her to orally copulate
him starting when she was eight or nine years old. They were
unlikely to be confused or distracted by the additional evidence
that Ramos inflicted non-sexual physical abuse as well.
Because the trial court was within its section 352 discretion
to admit the evidence of uncharged acts of non-sexual physical
abuse, we affirm.

15
DISPOSITION

The judgment is affirmed.

PULOS, J.*

We concur:

MARTINEZ, P. J.

SEGAL, J.

* Judge of the San Diego County Superior Court, assigned by
the Chief Justice pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the
California Constitution.

16

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.