CourtListener 10313589•Hernandez v. Alvarez CA2/5
Full text
Filed 1/14/25 Hernandez v. Alvarez CA2/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FIVE
FERNANDO HERNANDEZ et al., B330404
Plaintiffs and Respondents, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No.
v. KC069491)
GEORGE ALVAREZ,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County, Thomas C. Falls, Judge. Affirmed.
George Alvarez, in pro. per., for Defendant and Appellant.
Shaumyan & Derbarseghian, Alfred Shaumyan and Aren
Derbarseghian for Plaintiffs and Respondents.
________________________
Defendant and appellant George Alvarez appeals from a
judgment following a bench trial in favor of plaintiffs and
respondents Fernando Hernandez and Maria De Jesus
Hernandez in this action arising out of a real property purchase
agreement. Because the record is inadequate to allow review on
appeal, we affirm.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
In June 2018, the plaintiffs filed the operative third
amended complaint against Alvarez and others alleging several
causes of action, including breach of contract, misrepresentation,
fraud, and unjust enrichment. The plaintiffs attached a purchase
agreement executed in 2005.
In July 2019, Alvarez filed an amended answer to the
complaint. Among other issues, he asserted the affirmative
defense of novation, alleging that the parties substituted a new
agreement for the one alleged in the complaint, and the
Hernandezes were the ones who breached the new agreement.
In May 2022, the matter was called for a jury trial, but
Alvarez failed to appear. The court entered a default and a
default judgment against Alvarez, but later set them aside based
on error.
On February 6, 2023, Alvarez filed a motion for judgment
under Code of Civil Procedure section 631.8, raising several
arguments based on a 2016 agreement between the parties.
On February 7, 2023, the matter was called for trial again.
No reporter’s transcript or settled statement is part of the record
on appeal. The minute order reflects that there was no
appearance for Alvarez. Fernando testified, and several exhibits
2
were admitted in evidence. The trial court found Fernando
credible. The court found there was an existing contract for the
purchase of a home, and Fernando made a down payment and
paid taxes on the property. The court further found that Alvarez
breached the purchase agreement and took advantage of
Fernando, and then Alvarez sold the home without Fernando’s
knowledge.
The trial court issued a proposed statement of decision on
February 28 2023. Alvarez filed objections to the proposed
statement of decision. Among other issues, he argued the
proposed statement of decision failed to rule on his affirmative
defense of novation based on the 2016 agreement. He asserted
the findings were inconsistent with the terms of various
agreements. Alvarez also argued that the Hernandezes were
required to amend their complaint to refer to the 2016
agreement.
The Hernandezes opposed Alvarez’s motion for judgment
under Code of Civil Procedure section 631.8. They argued the
evidence showed they were the true owners of the property and
had made a decade of mortgage and property tax payments; there
was no evidence the parties intended to cancel or substitute the
original purchase agreement by entering into the 2016
agreement. The 2016 agreement simply confirmed the
Hernandezes paid down the loan principal to allow them to get a
new loan. Alvarez filed a reply arguing that the Hernandezes
failed to prove their claims at trial.
The court entered a final statement of decision on April 17,
2023. The court found the testimony and the evidence offered at
trial was credible. The court noted Alvarez chose not to
3
participate at trial, so there were no objections made to the
evidence presented.
The Hernandezes entered into a purchase agreement with
Alvarez in June 2005 to buy the property for $325,000, for which
Alvarez provided financing, and Alvarez told them they could
have as long as they needed to pay off the financing. The
Hernandezes made the required down payment of $6,500, paid
the taxes on the property, moved in and improved the property,
and made mortgage payments to Alvarez. Alvarez repeatedly
confirmed the payments made were mortgage payments, not rent
payments. The Hernandezes were not tenants. In 2016, the
Herenandezes tried to refinance the loan from Alvarez by getting
a conventional loan from a lender, and signed an agreement with
Alvarez confirming the sale with the new financing. Alvarez,
however, refused to allow the refinancing of the loan; instead, he
sold the property to third-parties who evicted the Hernandezes.
The court acknowledged Alvarez’s argument that the 2016
agreement was a novation, and therefore, was the governing
contract between the parties. The court agreed the 2016
agreement governed, but found that the uncontradicted evidence
established the Hernandezes’ payments toward the purchase
price under the 2005 agreement were transferred and applied to
the 2016 contract, and it was Alvarez who breached the parties’
agreement. The court noted that Alvarez’s arguments were not
evidence and his posttrial attempt to argue the case was
inappropriate.
The court found the Hernandezes could recover $239,496
that they paid to Alvarez, with interest on the judgment. The
court entered judgment in favor of the Hernandezes. Alvarez
4
filed a timely notice of appeal, choosing to proceed without a
record of the oral proceedings.
DISCUSSION
Alvarez contends the trial court erred by finding ambiguity
in the terms of a written contract, accepting testimony that
contradicted the written terms, and awarding damages based on
an agreement that was not pled in the complaint. We conclude
that on appeal, Alvarez has failed to state the facts in the light
most favorable to the judgment, as required by the standard of
review, and the record is inadequate to review Alvarez’s
contentions of error.
A judgment or order of the lower court is presumed to be
correct; the appellant has the burden of overcoming this
presumption by affirmatively showing error on appeal by an
adequate record. (Ketchum v. Moses (2001) 24 Cal.4th 1122,
1140–1141.) Under California Rules of Court, rule 8.120(b), “[i]f
an appellant intends to raise any issue that requires
consideration of the oral proceedings in the superior court, the
record on appeal must include a record of these oral proceedings
in the form of one of the following: [¶] (1) A reporter’s transcript
under rule 8.130; [¶] (2) An agreed statement under rule 8.134; or
[¶] (3) A settled statement under rule 8.137.”
“Briefs must provide argument and legal authority for the
positions taken; they may not rely upon matters which are not
part of the record on appeal. Without the proper record, we
cannot evaluate issues requiring a factual analysis. The evidence
is presumed sufficient to support the judgment.” (Pringle v. La
Chapelle (1999) 73 Cal.App.4th 1000, 1003.) “Where no reporter’s
5
transcript has been provided and no error is apparent on the face
of the existing appellate record, the judgment must be
conclusively presumed correct as to all evidentiary matters. To
put it another way, it is presumed that the unreported trial
testimony would demonstrate the absence of error.” (Estate of
Fain (1999) 75 Cal.App.4th 973, 992.)
Without a reporter’s transcript, we cannot undertake a
meaningful review of Alvarez’s contentions on appeal. It is clear
from the minute order and the statement of decision that
Fernando testified about the parties’ agreements in 2005 and
2016, and the mortgage payments made toward the purchase
price. We do not reweigh the credibility of witnesses or the
evidence presented at trial. (Lenk v. Total–Western, Inc. (2001)
89 Cal.App.4th 959, 968 [appellate court defers to trier of fact
regarding credibility of witnesses]; Howard v. Owens Corning
(1999) 72 Cal.App.4th 621, 631 [appellate court does not reweigh
evidence].) Alvarez contends the plaintiffs were required to
allege the 2016 agreement in the complaint, but it was Alvarez’s
responsibility to introduce evidence about that agreement, as it
was the basis for his affirmative defense. Nothing prevented
Alvarez from appearing at trial and introducing the 2016
agreement, or objecting to extrinsic evidence about that
agreement and the import of that evidence, but he chose not to
participate at trial. Without a transcript, we must assume the
extrinsic evidence presented at trial supported the trial court’s
interpretation of the agreements between the parties and the
court’s finding that Alvarez breached the purchase agreement.
6
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed. Respondents Fernando
Hernandez and Maria De Jesus Hernandez are awarded their
costs on appeal.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.
MOOR, J.
WE CONCUR:
HOFFSTADT, P. J.
KIM (D.), J.
7
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.