CourtListener 10310623•People v. Martinez CA2/2
Full text
Filed 1/8/25 P. v. Martinez CA2/2
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION TWO
THE PEOPLE, B335299
Plaintiff and Respondent, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. BA507358)
v.
SALVADOR ERIC MARTINEZ,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County. Robert C. Vanderet, Judge. Affirmed in part, reversed in part,
and remanded with directions.
Megan L. Denkers Baca, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief Assistant
Attorney General, Susan Sullivan Pithey, Senior Assistant Attorney
General, Stephanie C. Brenan and Gabriel Bradley, Deputy Attorneys
General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
________________________________
Salvador Eric Martinez appeals the judgment entered following a
jury trial in which he was convicted of first degree residential burglary
(Pen. Code,1 § 459) with a person present (§ 667.5, subd. (c)(21)).
Appellant admitted suffering a prior conviction qualifying as a “strike”
under the Three Strikes law. (§§ 667, subds. (b)–(j), 1170.12, subds.
(a)–(d).) The trial court sentenced appellant to a term of eight years in
state prison, consisting of the mid-term of four years doubled for a prior
strike.
Appellant contends that his constitutional right to effective
assistance of counsel was infringed because defense counsel failed to
request a jury instruction on voluntary intoxication. Appellant asserts
that there was no justifiable reason to withhold the request, and the
instruction was essential for the jury to understand the defense theory
of the case. We conclude that appellant fails to demonstrate ineffective
assistance of counsel. We additionally find, however, that appellant’s
second argument—that he was not properly admonished before
admitting a prior strike—has merit, and we therefore remand for
further proceedings on the prior strike conviction and a new sentencing
hearing.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
Jorge Monroy lived on South Union Avenue in Los Angeles. He
rented a room in a three-bedroom apartment from Carmen Rosales,
who lived in another room of the apartment.
On the afternoon of March 19, 2022, Monroy, who had just
returned home from work, was alone in the apartment. Rosales was
hospitalized at the time. Monroy heard a knock on the back door and
saw appellant standing there. Monroy had known appellant, who is
Rosales’s son, for several years, and Monroy used to socialize with
appellant when appellant lived in the apartment. By March 2022,
1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.
2
however, appellant had not lived in the unit for over a year, and
instead had been sleeping on the sidewalk nearby.
Monroy opened the door and told appellant that he could not let
him enter. Appellant asked to come in again, and Monroy again
declined. When Monroy saw that appellant was beginning to get upset,
Monroy closed the door and walked into his bedroom. The bedroom was
near the door and Monroy could see and talk to appellant through the
bedroom window.
Appellant continued asking to be let in, and as Monroy
repeatedly refused, appellant grew angrier and louder. Appellant
suddenly yanked on the bars covering Monroy’s window, apparently
trying to dislodge them. He eventually gave up and instead grabbed a
broom standing nearby. Using the broom handle as a club, appellant
smashed Monroy’s window and destroyed a window screen, causing
glass and other debris to fly toward Monroy.
After appellant broke much of the window’s glass, he reached his
hand into the bedroom, rifling through Monroy’s possessions, knocking
some over, including a microwave, and taking others. He then set his
sights on Monroy’s second window. Grabbing a metal pipe (the broom
having broken in the mayhem), appellant smashed the glass with a
loud crash.
Appellant then ransacked items from the second window. He
pulled out a bottle of wine or liquor, and grabbed a plastic bin where
Monroy stored coins, jewelry, and rent money. Monroy was able to
seize the rent money from appellant’s hands, but appellant got away
with the other items in the bin. Altogether, appellant carried off
numerous items, including at least one bottle of wine or liquor,
Monroy’s personal papers, keys, snacks, various writing implements,
change, and jewelry.
Around the time that appellant finished taking property from the
second window, Monroy called 9-1-1, afraid that appellant would move
on to other windows. After Monroy made the call, appellant walked
3
from the rear of the apartment building to the front. As he did so, he
ripped up Monroy’s papers and scattered the shreds and other items
around the sidewalk. He then sat near the front door and started
eating Monroy’s snacks and drinking his alcohol.
Police officers arrived about 10 to 15 minutes after Monroy’s
9-1-1 call. Officer Jason Mijangos made contact with appellant.
Although appellant understood Officer Mijangos’s commands, he
initially did not comply and so was detained. Thereafter, appellant was
cooperative with officers and the search, detention, and arrest all went
without incident. Appellant had no problem understanding everything
that Officer Mijangos said and was cognizant of what was happening.
He appeared calm.
Officer Mijangos testified that appellant “might have appeared to
be under the influence from an unknown narcotic,” as he initially did
not follow instructions to stand up, and that appellant’s “pupils
appeared to be that he was either coming down from being under the
influence or he was currently under the influence.” Officer Mijangos
was not certain, however, that appellant was actually intoxicated.
When appellant was searched, bags containing Monroy’s jewelry
were found in his pockets. Monroy’s keys and writing materials were
also recovered.
DISCUSSION
I. Appellant Fails to Demonstrate Ineffective Assistance of
Counsel
Appellant first contends that trial counsel was ineffective for
failing to request a jury instruction on voluntary intoxication, namely
CALCRIM No. 3426.2 Appellant asserts that an instruction on
2 CALCRIM No. 3426 provides, in part, that the jury “may
consider evidence, if any, of the defendant’s voluntary intoxication only
in a limited way. [The jury] may consider that evidence only in
deciding whether the defendant acted . . . with” the requisite intent.
4
voluntary intoxication would have been consistent with his defense,
and that by failing to request the instruction, counsel effectively
withdrew the defense. According to appellant, had the instruction been
given, there is a reasonable probability that the jury would have
determined that specific intent was not proven and thus found
appellant not guilty of burglary.3
A. Applicable legal principles
The standard for deciding an ineffective assistance of counsel
claim under either the Sixth Amendment to the United States
Constitution, or article I, section 15 of the California Constitution, is
“ ‘whether counsel’s conduct so undermined the proper functioning of
the adversarial process that the trial cannot be relied on as having
produced a just result.’ ” (In re Valdez (2010) 49 Cal.4th 715, 729
(Valdez), quoting Strickland v. Washington (1984) 466 U.S. 668, 686
[104 S.Ct. 2052, 80 L.Ed.2d 674] (Strickland).) To establish ineffective
assistance, a defendant must show both that “counsel’s performance
was deficient”—that is, the attorney’s “representation fell below an
objective standard of reasonableness” “under prevailing professional
norms”—and that “the deficient performance prejudiced the defense.”
(Strickland, supra, 466 U.S. at pp. 687, 688; see also Valdez, supra, 49
Cal.4th at p. 729.)
In assessing a claim of deficiency, “[j]udicial scrutiny of counsel’s
performance must be highly deferential.” (Strickland, supra, 466 U.S.
3 Although claims of ineffective assistance of counsel are
generally raised by petition for writ of habeas corpus (People v. Pope
(1979) 23 Cal.3d 412, 426, overruled on another ground in People v.
Berryman (1993) 6 Cal.4th 1048, 1081, fn. 10), the claim may be made
on appeal in limited circumstances, including when “ ‘there simply
could be no satisfactory explanation’ ” for counsel’s acts or failures to
act. (People v. Haskett (1990) 52 Cal.3d 210, 248 (Haskett).) Because
appellant makes this type of argument here, we exercise our discretion
to address the issue.
5
at p. 689.) The court “evaluate[s] the conduct from counsel’s
perspective at the time,” avoiding the “distorting effects of hindsight.”
(Ibid.) “Because of the difficulties inherent in making the evaluation, a
court must indulge a strong presumption that counsel’s conduct falls
within the wide range of reasonable professional assistance; that is, the
defendant must overcome the presumption that, under the
circumstances, the challenged action ‘might be considered sound trial
strategy.’ ” (Ibid.)
A defendant who establishes deficient performance must still
show prejudice. (Valdez, supra, 49 Cal.4th at p. 729.) “This second
part of the Strickland test ‘is not solely one of outcome determination.
Instead, the question is “whether counsel’s deficient performance
renders the result of the trial unreliable or the proceeding
fundamentally unfair.” ’ ” (In re Hardy (2007) 41 Cal.4th 977, 1019.)
“It is not enough ‘to show that the errors had some conceivable effect on
the outcome of the proceeding.’ ” (Harrington v. Richter (2011) 562 U.S.
86, 104 [131 S.Ct. 770, 178 L.Ed.2d 624].) Rather, “[t]he likelihood of a
different result must be substantial, not just conceivable.” (Id. at p.
112.)
B. Analysis
As noted, appellant contends that trial counsel was ineffective
because she failed to request a jury instruction on voluntary
intoxication (CALCRIM No. 3426) and, according to appellant, thereby
effectively withdrew any such defense. It is appellant’s burden to prove
ineffective assistance. (Haskett, supra, 52 Cal.3d 210, 248.) We
conclude that appellant does not meet his burden.
1. Evidence of voluntary intoxication affecting
appellant’s ability to form specific intent is lacking.
“Evidence of voluntary intoxication is admissible solely on the
issue of whether or not the defendant actually formed a required
specific intent.” (§ 29.4, subd. (b).) “Burglary is a specific intent crime.
[Citation.] It requires not only that a defendant enter a structure, but
6
that he or she do so with a particular objective in mind: larceny (or any
other felony).” (People v. Hendrix (2022) 13 Cal.5th 933, 939.) A jury
instruction on voluntary intoxication is a “pinpoint” instruction that the
trial court is required to give only if properly requested. (People v.
Verdugo (2010) 50 Cal.4th 263, 295 (Verdugo).) “ ‘[A] defendant is
entitled to such an instruction only when there is substantial evidence
of the defendant’s voluntary intoxication and the intoxication affected
the defendant’s “actual formation of specific intent.” ’ [Citation.]”
(Ibid.) Consequently, “[e]vidence of voluntary intoxication without
evidence of its effect on a defendant’s ability to formulate specific intent
is insufficient to establish the defense.” (People v. Serrano (2022) 77
Cal.App.5th 902, 918 (Serrano).)
For example, in People v. Williams (1997) 16 Cal.4th 635, 677,
our Supreme Court found that a voluntary intoxication instruction was
unwarranted when the record contained comments that the defendant
was “ ‘probably spaced out,’ ” “ ‘doped up,’ ” and “ ‘smokin’ pretty
tough’ ” around the time he committed four murders. “Assuming this
scant evidence of defendant’s voluntary intoxication would qualify as
‘substantial,’ there was no evidence at all that voluntary intoxication
had any effect on defendant’s ability to formulate intent.” (Id. at
p. 677–678.)
A similar analysis applies here. Evidence that appellant may
have been intoxicated at the time he committed the burglary was
minimal. Monroy testified that, around the time of the incident,
appellant “wasn’t like a normal person,” and was not “in command” of
his “five senses.” Monroy explained, however, that the basis for his
observation was “the way that [appellant] reacted. When I said no, and
he hung onto the bars in the window, somebody that is in control of
their five senses does not do that.” Appellant did not become “out of
control” until Monroy repeatedly refused to let him enter the
apartment, signifying that appellant’s unhinged behavior was induced
primarily (if not entirely) by anger. Additionally, although Officer
7
Mijangos testified that appellant “might have appeared to be under the
influence” based on his initial failure to follow an instruction and the
appearance of his pupils, the officer noted that he was “not certain” of
the assessment. Furthermore, Officer Mijangos did not observe
appellant until after the incident, while there was evidence that
appellant may have been drinking Monroy’s alcohol prior to the officer’s
arrival.
Even if we were to assume that appellant was voluntarily
intoxicated at the time of the incident, however, that would not lead us
to conclude that the intoxication affected appellant’s formation of
specific intent. (See Serrano, supra, 77 Cal.App.5th at p. 918.) The
evidence supports a contrary conclusion. The course of the burglary
was not just a fleeting event. Appellant separately shattered two
windows and reached in through each, picking and choosing what he
wanted. The items stolen included jewelry, coins, alcohol, and snacks,
and would have also included Monroy’s rent money had Monroy not
snatched it away. After taking numerous items, appellant disposed of
the ones that held no value to him (ripping Monroy’s papers into
shreds), and kept the remainder, placing valuables such as jewelry in
his pockets. Although appellant was clearly aggravated, he
demonstrated deliberation and purposefulness in the burglary.
Moreover, when police officers arrived shortly after the incident,
appellant was generally cooperative, appeared calm, and had no
problem understanding instructions.
Given this set of facts, substantial evidence did not support a
theory that appellant’s ability to form the specific intent for burglary
was impaired by voluntary intoxication. If defense counsel had
requested the instruction, the trial court likely would have refused it.
(See Verdugo, supra, 50 Cal.4th at p. 295.) Accordingly, counsel’s
decision not to request the instruction was not ineffective assistance.
8
2. The omission of a voluntary intoxication instruction
could be considered reasonable trial strategy.
Appellant, asserting that there was sufficient evidence to support
a voluntary intoxication defense, contends there could be no conceivable
tactical reason for trial counsel to withhold a request for a voluntary
intoxication instruction. Appellant maintains that the instruction was
entirely consistent with the defense theory, and that the instruction
was essential for the jury to understand the defense.
In reviewing a claim of ineffective assistance, we do “ ‘ “ ‘not
second-guess reasonable, if difficult, tactical decisions in the harsh light
of hindsight.’ ” ’ ” (People v. Coffman and Marlow (2004) 34 Cal.4th 1,
86.) Because the record contains no discussion regarding counsel’s
reasons for not requesting a voluntary intoxication instruction,
appellant’s claim of ineffective assistance will be rejected unless there
could be no satisfactory explanation for the omission. (People v.
Castillo (1997) 16 Cal.4th 1009, 1015.)
We conclude that trial counsel reasonably could have chosen not
to request a voluntary intoxication instruction as a matter of trial
strategy. Contrary to appellant’s argument that his defense hinged on
a lack of specific intent due to voluntary intoxication, the record reveals
that the defense was based on a combination of factors. Although trial
counsel repeatedly emphasized a claimed lack of specific intent, counsel
did not ground the argument primarily on claimed intoxication.
Instead, trial counsel focused on appellant’s rage.
In trial counsel’s opening statement, she stated that, after
initially speaking with Monroy, appellant “completely broke down,”
“threw a tantrum,” and while “incapable of containing his emotions and
his frustration, lashed out.” This line of reasoning was echoed in
closing argument. Recounting the testimony, counsel stated that, after
Monroy repeatedly refused to let appellant enter the apartment,
appellant “completely became irrational and unreasonable, kind of
throwing a tantrum,” “lost complete control and was lashing out,” was
9
“wreaking havoc and tossing things around,” and was “seeing red,
frustrated, overcome with emotion, not being able to come in.” Counsel
then argued: “I submit to you that my client had no specific intention
to commit any theft, to do anything. Much like a child who throws a
tantrum who is just wreaking havoc, there is no intention to do
anything, it’s just a tantrum.”
Counsel also posited another reason that appellant lacked
specific intent—that, based on appellant’s actions soon after
rummaging through the windows, he did not actually intend to steal
anything. Counsel noted how appellant did not run or hide after
Monroy called 9-1-1, but instead “took a seat” near the front door.
Counsel continued, “Typically thieves, people who do things with the
intent to steal, leave. They get their loot and they go. No one stays at
the scene of the crime hoping to be caught.”
Only then did counsel turn to the intoxication argument,
recounting Officer Mijangos’s testimony that appellant might have
been under the influence of an unknown narcotic. Counsel continued to
emphasize other reasons for appellant’s behavior, however, stating: “I
submit to you, people who are out of control and under the influence
don’t form specific intent. . . . [Appellant] did not form the specific
intent to steal. He didn’t have an intention. He was upset, he was
frustrated, angry. Just lashed out. . . . [I]ndicia of an intent to steal, it
means you take the goods and go, to leave, to hide, to discard of them.
Not to stay at the scene and quite literally wait for the police, which is
what we have here.”
The record thus demonstrates that the defense strategy was not
to focus on possible intoxication, but instead to argue lack of specific
intent based on several factors, primarily that appellant threw a
“tantrum.” Requesting a voluntary intoxication instruction could have
undercut appellant’s defense by calling attention to a defense that was
weak (intoxication) at the expense of theories that had better
evidentiary support (throwing a “tantrum” and not leaving the scene).
10
Importantly, the evidence showed (and counsel argued) that appellant
did not get upset and begin his rampage until his requests to enter the
apartment were repeatedly denied. A theory that appellant lost control
of his temper and lashed out was more compatible with this set of facts
than an argument that appellant acted out because of intoxication.
Anger is a common reaction to a denied request, something the jury
was likely to understand.
We cannot find that counsel’s performance fell below the
prevailing standard of reasonableness simply because she chose to
focus on defenses with better evidentiary support. Voluntary
intoxication was an argument that was essentially tacked on to the
larger theory that appellant ransacked Monroy’s apartment in a fit of
rage and did not intend to leave with any property. Counsel was not
under an obligation to request a jury instruction on a theory that was
largely peripheral to, and in some respects inconsistent with, the
primary theory of the defense. (See People v. Weaver (2001) 26 Cal.4th
876, 926 [“where counsel’s trial tactics or strategic reasons for
challenged decisions do not appear on the record, we will not find
ineffective assistance of counsel on appeal unless there could be no
conceivable reason for counsel’s acts or omissions”]; see also People v.
Sedeno (1974) 10 Cal.3d 703, 717, fn. 7, overruled on other grounds in
People v. Breverman (1998) 19 Cal.4th 142, 165 [counsel should request
instructions that explain theories upon which the defense “rests”].)
3. There was no reasonable probability of a different
outcome.
Finally, if appellant were able to show that trial counsel was
deficient, he would also need to demonstrate “a reasonable probability
that, but for counsel’s unprofessional errors, the result would have been
different.” (People v. Kelly (1992) 1 Cal.4th 495, 520.) Appellant fails
to make this showing.
The jury instruction that appellant argues should have been
requested, CALCRIM No. 3426, provides that the jury “may consider
11
evidence, if any, of the defendant’s voluntary intoxication only in a
limited way,” “in deciding whether the defendant acted” with the
requisite intent, in this case, permanently depriving Monroy of his
property or removing it for an extended period of time. Other
instructions that were given in this case, however, adequately informed
the jury on the requirement of specific intent. (See People v. Garcia
(2022) 76 Cal.App.5th 887, 894 [“ ‘The failure to give an instruction on
an essential issue, or the giving of erroneous instructions, may be cured
if the essential material is covered by other correct instructions
properly given’ ”]; People v. Castillo (1997) 16 Cal.4th 1009, 1016
[“ ‘ “The absence of an essential element in one instruction may be
supplied by another or cured in light of the instructions as a whole” ’ ”].)
For example, the jury was instructed with a modified version of
CALCRIM No. 251, including that “burglary requires proof of a specific
intention or mental state,” and that appellant “must not only have
committed the prohibited act, but must have done so with a specific
intent.” The jury was then instructed with a modified version of
CALCRIM No. 1700, which contained the following language: “To
prove that the defendant is guilty of the crime, the People must prove,
one, that the defendant entered a building or a room within a building;
and two, at the time when he entered, he intended to commit theft.”
Additionally, the jury was instructed on theft with CALCRIM No. 1800,
providing in part: “When the defendant took the property, he intended
to deprive the owner of it permanently, or to remove it from the owner’s
possession for so extended a period of time that the owner would be
deprived of a major portion of the value or enjoyment of that property.”
As noted above, defense counsel repeatedly focused on the issue
of specific intent, including in connection with appellant’s claimed
intoxication. Contrary to appellant’s argument that trial counsel
“effectively withdrew” the defense of a lack of specific intent, the issue
was front and center before the jury.
12
Moreover, if a voluntary intoxication instruction had been
requested and given, there is not a reasonable probability that the
verdict would have been more favorable to appellant. Evidence of
voluntary intoxication was thin, and evidence that it affected
appellant’s ability to form specific intent was lacking. Meanwhile, the
evidence of guilt was overwhelming. Appellant not only “entered”
Monroy’s apartment by breaking the windows and reaching in, he
deliberately picked and chose from items that were within arm’s reach.
He kept property that he determined had sufficient value, stuffing
some of it in his pockets, and discarded the rest.
In determining whether appellant committed burglary, the jury
was faced with the issue of whether he formed specific intent. In fact,
the jury posed a question during deliberations, asking “how we
establish or define intention.” After being again instructed that “words
not specifically defined in the instructions are to be used in their
ordinary, everyday meaning,” the jury deliberated further, finally
concluding that the charge of burglary (including specific intent) was
proven beyond a reasonable doubt. It is not reasonably probable that a
voluntary intoxication instruction would have changed this result.
II. Remand Is Required Due to Lacking Advisements
Appellant’s second primary argument is that the trial court erred
in sentencing him as a second strike offender without proper
advisement or waiver of his constitutional rights. We agree with this
contention.
A. Relevant proceedings
Before opening statements, outside the presence of the jury,
counsel and the trial court discussed and agreed upon bifurcating
aggravating circumstances and prior strikes from the trial of the
substantive offense. The court noted, in reference to appellant’s prior
record, “I mean, usually people will stipulate to those afterwards, but
we’ll deal with that when we get to it.”
13
During jury deliberations, again outside the presence of the jury,
defense counsel informed the court: “With respect to the priors,
[appellant] would waive the right to jury on the priors.” When the trial
court inquired, “Will you stipulate to them or just have a court trial?”
counsel responded, “We would likely stipulate. I’d wait to hear the
verdict and then we’ll move from there.”
After the verdict was read and the jury dismissed, appellant
admitted the prior strike convictions:
“[Prosecutor]: Mr. Salvador Eric Martinez, do you admit that you
were charged in—or excuse me, convicted in case number
BA432498, with violations of Penal Code section 211 and Penal
Code section 459 in the first degree with a conviction date of
September 10th, 2015, in Los Angeles County?
“[Appellant]: Yes.
“[Prosecutor]: Counsel join in the stipulation?
“[Defense counsel]: Yes.
“[Prosecutor]: People join.
“The Court: Okay.”
At the sentencing hearing, the trial court sentenced appellant “to
serve eight years in the state prison, which is the midterm doubled” for
a prior strike.
B. Applicable legal principles
“When a criminal defendant enters a guilty plea, the trial court is
required to ensure that the plea is knowing and voluntary. [Citation.]
As a prophylactic measure, the court must inform the defendant of
three constitutional rights—the privilege against compulsory self-
incrimination, the right to trial by jury, and the right to confront one’s
accusers—and solicit a personal waiver of each.” (People v. Cross
(2015) 61 Cal.4th 164, 170 (Cross).) These required advisements are
known as “Boykin/Tahl admonitions.” (People v. Howard (1992) 1
Cal.4th 1132, 1174 (Howard), citing Boykin v. Alabama (1969) 395 U.S.
238 [89 S.Ct. 1709, 23 L.Ed.2d 274] (Boykin); In re Tahl (1969) 1 Cal.3d
14
122 (Tahl).) The same requirements of advisement and waiver apply
when a defendant is asked to admit the truth of a prior conviction
allegation that can subject the defendant to increased punishment.
(Cross, supra, at p. 170, citing In re Yurko (1974) 10 Cal.3d 857, 863
(Yurko).)
Deficiencies in advisement and waiver in prior conviction
proceedings, often referred to as “Yurko error,” are “not reversible per
se.” (Cross, supra, 61 Cal.4th at p. 171.) Rather, the reviewing court
looks to whether “the record affirmatively shows” that an admission “is
voluntary and intelligent under the totality of the circumstances.”
(Howard, supra, 1 Cal.4th at p. 1175; Cross, supra, 61 Cal.4th at
p. 171.) The appellate court examines “ ‘the entire proceeding’ to
assess whether the defendant’s admission of the prior conviction was
intelligent and voluntary in light of the totality of circumstances.’ ”
(People v. Mosby (2004) 33 Cal.4th 353, 361 (Mosby).)
C. Analysis
This case presents a “silent record,” in that the record is devoid of
any express advisement or waiver of rights before appellant’s
admission of a prior conviction. (See Mosby, supra, 33 Cal.4th at
p. 361.) Trial counsel, acting on appellant’s behalf, stated that
appellant “would waive the right to jury on the priors,” and would
“likely stipulate” to prior strikes. Appellant later admitted to the prior
strike convictions, as read into the record by the prosecution. Notably
absent in any of these exchanges was an express advisement of
appellant’s Boykin/Tahl rights or an associated personal waiver by
appellant.
Respondent asserts that the totality of the circumstances
warrants a finding that appellant’s admission of the prior convictions
was voluntary and intelligent. Respondent bases this argument largely
on the fact that appellant had just gone through a jury trial. Citing
Mosby, supra, 33 Cal.4th at page 364, respondent notes that appellant
had exercised his right to remain silent at trial and, through counsel,
15
confronted witnesses at trial. Mosby, however, recognized that in
similar cases, “a jury trial on a substantive offense preceded the
defendants’ admissions of prior convictions.” (Id. at p. 362.) As in this
case, though, “[t]hese defendants were not told on the record of their
right to trial to determine the truth of a prior conviction allegation.
Nor did they expressly waive their right to trial. In such cases, in
which the defendant was not advised of the right to have a trial on an
alleged prior conviction, we cannot infer that in admitting the prior the
defendant has knowingly and intelligently waived that right as well as
the associated rights to silence and confrontation of witnesses.” (Ibid.)
Respondent urges that trial counsel’s statements, prior to the
verdict, that appellant “would waive the right to jury on the priors,”
and “would likely stipulate,” as well as related comments by the
prosecution and the trial court, demonstrate that appellant was aware
of his right to a jury trial on the prior convictions, supporting a finding
that there was a voluntary and intelligent admission. A similar
argument was rejected in People v. Johnson (1993) 15 Cal.App.4th 169,
178, in which a brief reference by the trial court relating to a jury trial
for prior convictions was insufficient to demonstrate that the defendant
“ ‘not only was aware of’ ” his rights, “ ‘but was also prepared to waive
them as a condition to admitting his prior offenses.’ ” (See also Mosby,
supra, 33 Cal.4th at p. 362, citing Johnson.)
Respondent further argues that appellant’s prior criminal record
supports the conclusion that his admission of prior convictions was
sufficiently voluntary and intelligent. “ ‘[A] defendant’s prior
experience with the criminal justice system’ is, as the United States
Supreme Court has concluded, ‘relevant to the question [of] whether he
knowingly waived constitutional rights.’ ” (Mosby, supra, 33 Cal.4th at
p. 365.) While experience with the justice system is a recognized factor,
without more than respondent’s assertion that “[a]ppellant was
presumably admonished of his rights in some of or all these previous
cases,” we cannot find a voluntary and intelligent admission here. (See
16
People v. Christian (2005) 125 Cal.App.4th 688, 698 [although
defendant had prior convictions, the circumstances were too unclear to
find “present knowledge and understanding of his rights”].)
Contrary to respondent’s arguments, the deficiencies in this case
are more akin to circumstances presented in Cross. In Cross, defense
counsel stipulated that the defendant was convicted of a prior felony
offense, and the trial court immediately accepted the stipulation
without advising the defendant of his rights. (Cross, supra, 61 Cal.4th
at pp. 169, 180.) The trial court did not inquire whether the defendant
discussed the stipulation with counsel, nor did the court inform the
defendant of his right to a trial on the prior conviction allegation. (Id.
at p. 180.) Determining that the record did not demonstrate that the
defendant was aware of his right to a fair determination of the prior
conviction allegation, the Supreme Court found that the stipulation
must be set aside. (Ibid.) Similarly, in People v. Farwell (2018) 5
Cal.5th 295, 308, our Supreme Court set aside a waiver “tantamount to
a guilty plea” because the record was insufficient to show that the
defendant “entered a constitutionally valid waiver of his trial rights.”
Examination of the record in this matter, and consideration of
the totality of the circumstances, likewise leads to the conclusion that
appellant’s admission of prior strikes cannot be considered voluntary
and intelligent. No express advisements were given and no personal
waivers were obtained. The scant indications that appellant may have
been aware of his rights and prepared to waive them are too
insubstantial to support such a finding. Accordingly, appellant’s
admission to the prior robbery and burglary convictions must be set
aside.
17
DISPOSITION
The conviction is affirmed. The judgment with respect to the
sentence is reversed. The matter is remanded to the trial court with
directions to first, either hold a trial on the prior strike allegation or
properly obtain appellant’s personal admission of the prior strike
conviction(s) with the requisite advisements and waivers, and second,
hold a new sentencing hearing.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.
LUI, P. J.
We concur:
CHAVEZ, J.
RICHARDSON, J.
18
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.