CourtListener 10306334•In re Matthew M. CA2/7
Full text
Filed 12/31/24 In re Matthew M. CA2/7
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION SEVEN
In re Matthew M., et al., Persons B330336
Coming Under the Juvenile Court
Law.
LOS ANGELES COUNTY (Los Angeles County Super.
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN Ct. No. 20CCJP03451D-G)
AND FAMILY SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
MARISOL B.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Cathy Ostiller, Judge. Dismissed.
Serobian Law and Liana Serobian, under appointment by
the Court of Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Office of the County Counsel, Dawyn R. Harrison, County
Counsel, Kim Nemoy, Assistant County Counsel, and Sally Son,
Senior Deputy County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
____________________
Marisol B. (Mother) challenges the sufficiency of the
evidence supporting the juvenile court’s jurisdictional findings
pertaining to Mother’s four children. While her appeal was
pending, the juvenile court terminated jurisdiction and granted
Mother sole legal and physical custody of the children. Because
we cannot provide Mother any effective relief—that is, relief that
“ ‘can have a practical, tangible impact on the parties’ conduct or
legal status’ ” (In re D.P. (2023) 14 Cal.5th 266, 277 (D.P.))—we
dismiss her appeal as moot.
PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
Mother and Rodrigo M. (Father) have four children:
Matthew (born 2014), Jayden (born 2017), Nathan (born 2020),
and J.M. (born 2022). In May 2023 the Los Angeles County
Department of Children and Family Services (Department) filed
a petition under Welfare and Institutions Code section 300,
subdivisions (a), (b)(1), and (j),1 alleging the children were at
substantial risk of suffering serious physical harm as a result of
(1) Mother and Father’s history of violent altercations in the
children’s presence (counts a-1 and b-1); (2) Mother’s and
Father’s physical abuse of the children (counts a-2, a-3, b-2, b-3, j-
1, and j-2); (3) Mother’s instruction to Matthew to lie about the
parents’ violent altercations and physical abuse of the children
(counts a-1, a-2, b-1, b-2, and j-1); and (4) each parent’s failure to
protect the children from the other’s physical abuse (counts b-2,
b-3, j-1, and j-2).
In June 2023 the court sustained all counts, declared the
children dependents of the court, and ordered them to remain in
1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.
2
Mother’s custody. The court removed the children from Father
under section 361 and ordered monitored visits for him. The
court ordered Mother to participate in a domestic violence
support group, parenting and family preservation programs, joint
counseling with Father, and individual counseling.
Mother timely appealed. Father did not appeal the court’s
jurisdictional findings.
In July 2024 the juvenile court terminated its jurisdiction
with a final custody order awarding Mother sole legal and
physical custody of the children and granting monitored
visitation for Father.2 Neither Mother nor Father appealed from
the order terminating jurisdiction.3
DISCUSSION
A. Mootness and Dependency Appeals
“A court is tasked with the duty ‘ “to decide actual
controversies by a judgment which can be carried into effect, and
not to give opinions upon moot questions or abstract propositions,
or to declare principles or rules of law which cannot affect the
matter in issue in the case before it.” ’ ” (D.P., supra, 14 Cal.5th
at p. 276.) “A case becomes moot when events ‘ “render[ ] it
impossible for [a] court, if it should decide the case in favor of [the
2 The Department’s request for judicial notice of the juvenile
court’s custody order and the July 26 and August 7, 2024 minute
orders is granted. (See Evid. Code, §§ 452, subds. (c)-(d), 459; In
re J.R. (2022) 82 Cal.App.5th 569, 579.)
3 We requested, and the parties submitted, supplemental
briefing on whether we should dismiss Mother’s appeal as moot
in light of the juvenile court’s termination of jurisdiction with an
award of sole legal and physical custody to Mother.
3
appellant], to grant him [or her] any effect[ive] relief.” ’ ” (Ibid.,
third and fourth brackets added; accord, In re Gael C. (2023)
96 Cal.App.5th 220, 264.) Relief is “effective” where a party
complains of “ongoing harm” that is “redressable or capable of
being rectified by the outcome the [party] seeks.” (D.P., at
p. 276.) In other words, “relief is effective when it ‘can have a
practical, tangible impact on the parties’ conduct or legal status.’
[Citation.] It follows that, to show a need for effective relief, the
plaintiff must first demonstrate that he or she has suffered from
a change in legal status.” (Id. at p. 277.)
“[W]hen a parent has demonstrated a specific legal or
practical consequence that will be averted upon reversal, the case
is not moot, and merits review is required.” (D.P., supra,
14 Cal.5th at p. 283.) Accordingly, “a case is not moot where a
jurisdictional finding affects parental custody rights [citation],
curtails a parent’s contact with his or her child [citation], or ‘has
resulted in [dispositional] orders which continue to adversely
affect’ a parent.” (Id. at pp. 277-278; cf. In re N.S. (2016)
245 Cal.App.4th 53, 61 (N.S.) [mother’s appeal from jurisdictional
findings was moot where juvenile court had since awarded her
custody of child].) “Although a jurisdictional finding that a
parent engaged in abuse or neglect of a child is generally
stigmatizing, complaining of ‘stigma’ alone is insufficient to
sustain an appeal. The stigma must be paired with some effect
on the [parent’s] legal status that is capable of being redressed by
a favorable court decision.” (D.P., at p. 277.)
An appeal of jurisdictional findings may be rendered moot
where findings “have been made as to both parents but only one
parent brings a challenge.” (D.P., supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 283;
accord, In re M.C. (2023) 88 Cal.App.5th 137, 150-151 [“ ‘Because
4
the juvenile court assumes jurisdiction of the child, not the
parents, jurisdiction may exist based on the conduct of one parent
only.’ ”]; In re M.W. (2015) 238 Cal.App.4th 1444, 1452.) “A
reviewing court must ‘ “decide on a case-by-case basis whether
subsequent events in a juvenile dependency matter make a case
moot.” ’ ” (D.P., at p. 276.)
Even where an appeal is moot, however, “courts may
exercise their ‘inherent discretion’ to reach the merits of the
dispute.” (D.P., supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 282.) “A reviewing court
must decide on a case-by-case basis whether it is appropriate to
exercise discretionary review to reach the merits of a moot
appeal.” (Id. at p. 287.) Among the factors reviewing courts may
consider is whether a challenged jurisdictional finding could
affect future dependency proceedings, for example, by influencing
the Department’s decision to file a new dependency petition. (Id.
at p. 285.) Also pertinent is “whether the jurisdictional finding is
based on particularly pernicious or stigmatizing conduct”: “The
more egregious the findings against the parent, the greater the
parent’s interest in challenging such findings.” (Id. at pp. 285-
286.) Courts may also consider “why the appeal became moot.”
(Id. at p. 286.) For example, “[p]rinciples of fairness” may favor
discretionary review of a case rendered moot “by the prompt
compliance or otherwise laudable behavior of the parent
challenging the jurisdictional finding on appeal.” (Ibid.)
B. Mother’s Appeal Is Moot
Mother challenges the sufficiency of the evidence
supporting the court’s jurisdictional findings, but Father did not
appeal. Even if we reversed the court’s jurisdictional findings as
to Mother, the findings as to Father would stand and the juvenile
court’s exercise of jurisdiction over the children would not be
5
disturbed. (See In re Briana V. (2015) 236 Cal.App.4th 297, 308
[a “ ‘jurisdictional finding good against one parent is good against
both’ ”].) This posture provides one basis for concluding Mother’s
appeal is moot. (See D.P., supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 283.)
Mother’s appeal is moot for a second reason as well: In
July 2024 the juvenile court terminated jurisdiction and awarded
Mother sole legal and physical custody. Therefore, “no effective
relief can be granted. Mother has been awarded custody of [the
children], and the jurisdictional findings are not the basis of any
current order that is adverse to her.” (N.S., supra,
245 Cal.App.4th at p. 61.) Were we to reverse the jurisdictional
findings, that would not change Mother’s legal status with
respect to her parental rights. Because Mother “has not
demonstrated a specific legal or practical consequence that would
be avoided upon reversal of the jurisdictional findings,” her
appeal is moot. (D.P., supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 273; see also In re
Rashad D. (2021) 63 Cal.App.5th 156, 163 [“An order terminating
juvenile court jurisdiction generally renders an appeal from an
earlier order moot.”].)
Mother contends her appeal is not moot because the
jurisdictional findings could result in a report to the Child Abuse
Central Index (CACI) under the Child Abuse and Neglect
Reporting Act, Penal Code sections 11164 through 11174.3. (See
Pen. Code, § 11169, subd. (a) [providing the Department “shall
forward . . . every case it investigates of known or suspected child
abuse or severe neglect”].) Mother asserts inclusion in the CACI
could “damage her application[s] for employment, housing, and
other benefits.”
While inclusion in the CACI carries consequences for
parents, Mother’s reliance on these repercussions is speculative
6
here. (See D.P., supra, 14 Cal.5th at pp. 279-280.) If the
Department had reported Mother for inclusion in the CACI, it
would have had to provide notice to her. (See id. at p. 279; see
also In re C.F. (2011) 198 Cal.App.4th 454, 462 [“The reporting
agency must notify the known or suspected child abuser that he
or she has been reported to the CACI.”]; Pen. Code, § 11169,
subd. (c).) Mother does not claim she received such notice and
has not submitted any evidence that she is listed in the CACI.
The mere possibility of inclusion in the CACI is insufficient to
avoid the conclusion that Mother’s appeal is moot.4
C. Mother Fails To Demonstrate that Discretionary Review of
Her Moot Appeal Is Warranted
Mother requests that we exercise our discretion to hear the
merits of her appeal due to the potential prejudice from the
jurisdictional findings in future dependency or other court
proceedings. The Department indicated it would not oppose our
discretionary review of her appeal. However, after consideration
of the relevant factors, we decline to exercise our discretion to
4 We note that In re S.R., review granted September 11,
2024, S285759, is currently pending before the California
Supreme Court to address “the following issues: (1) When a
juvenile court’s jurisdictional findings establish that a parent
committed an offense that the law requires be reported to the
statewide [CACI], should an appellate court presume, on an
otherwise silent record, the offense has been or will be reported to
[the] CACI? (2) If unrebutted, is this presumption sufficient to
avoid dismissal for mootness?” Pending the Supreme Court’s
decision in In re S.R., we are bound by the court’s holding in In re
D.P., supra, 14 Cal.5th at page 280, that the mere possibility that
the Department could report Mother to the CACI is “too
speculative for purposes of avoiding mootness.”
7
reach the merits of Mother’s appeal. (See D.P., supra, 14 Cal.5th
at pp. 282-287.)
While Mother posits the jurisdictional findings could be
used against her in subsequent juvenile court proceedings or in
other unspecified court proceedings, her concerns are vague and
speculative. (See In re Rashad D., supra, 63 Cal.App.5th at
p. 164, fn. 5 [parent’s argument that jurisdictional finding might
influence the Department’s decision to file a new dependency
petition in the future deemed “too speculative to justify appellate
review of an otherwise moot case”].) Moreover, the core inquiry
in any future proceeding would be whether there is a current risk
of harm to the children, as juvenile courts must base their
decisions on present conditions, not solely on past findings. (See
In re D.D. (2019) 32 Cal.App.5th 985, 996 [a court may only order
removal if it finds the children’s physical safety or emotional
well-being are in danger]; In re I.A. (2011) 201 Cal.App.4th 1484,
1495 [deeming “speculative” the prospect that jurisdictional
finding would affect future dependency proceeding, because any
adverse orders “would require evidence of present detriment,
based on the then prevailing circumstances of parent and child”],
overruled on another ground in D.P., supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 283.)
And should Mother face a dependency case in the future, the
facts underlying the petition in this case would be available
regardless of whether the jurisdictional findings are reversed on
appeal.5 But the record would also show that the children have
5 Mother also had a prior dependency case in 2020 after
Nathan tested positive at birth for amphetamine and
methamphetamine. That case history would likewise be
available in a future dependency proceeding, regardless of the
outcome of this appeal.
8
always remained in Mother’s custody, reflecting the court’s
determination that their placement with her did not endanger
their well-being. (See N.S., supra, 245 Cal.App.4th at p. 63 [facts
that mother “took prompt and positive steps to reunite” with and
quickly regained custody of her child would be available in any
future dependency proceedings].)
Mother does not contend, and we do not find, that any other
factors support discretionary review here. Accordingly, we
dismiss the appeal as moot.
DISPOSITION
The appeal is dismissed.
STONE, J.
We concur:
MARTINEZ, P. J.
FEUER, J.
9
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.