In re A.M. CA2/8

CourtListener 10304148CalctappDec 24, 2024

Full text

Filed 12/24/24 In re A.M. CA2/8
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION EIGHT

In re A.M. et al., Persons Coming B332952
Under the Juvenile Court Law.
Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. 20CCJP03787A-C
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILY SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

C.C.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County. Marguerite D. Downing, Judge. Affirmed.
Benjamin Ekenes, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Brian Mahler, Deputy County
Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
_____________________________
SUMMARY
The father in this dependency proceeding appeals from
orders terminating jurisdiction over his three children and
awarding sole legal and physical custody to mother with
unmonitored visitation for father. He contends the orders were
an abuse of discretion because there was no substantial evidence
supporting them. Alternatively, he argues the award of sole legal
custody to mother was an abuse of discretion.
We affirm the orders.
FACTS
Father C.C. and mother N.M. have three children, A.M.,
born in 2016, El.M., born in 2018, and Er.M., born in 2019. The
children were detained by the Los Angeles County Department of
Children and Family Services (Department), and in July 2020,
the children were removed from father and released to mother,
with monitored visitation for father.
In September 2020, the court sustained allegations that
father physically abused A.M. by striking the child with a belt,
and that father and his female companion, D.J. (later his wife),
had a history of domestic violence and of engaging in violent
altercations in the presence of the children. (Welf. & Inst. Code,
§ 300, subds. (a), (b) & (j); further undesignated statutory
references are to the Welfare and Institutions Code.) The
allegations described three different incidents in April and June
2020. Allegations that mother failed to protect the children were
also sustained.
Father was ordered to enroll in parenting classes,
individual counseling, and a 52-week domestic violence program.
Mother was ordered to participate in various family maintenance
services.

2
In April 2021, the court found continued supervision to be
necessary.
In September 2021, mother sought a psychiatric evaluation
and was diagnosed with a mood disorder and given a referral for
outpatient mental health services, but she was not prescribed
any medication and was released home.
On April 20, 2022, the Department filed a status review
report recommending mother be given sole physical and joint
legal custody of the children. In that report, the Department
stated there were ongoing issues regarding father’s other
dependency case with his wife D.J. “Due to the father[’]s second
open DCFS case with his wife, [D.J.], Father . . . reported that he
currently does not have stable housing. Father reported that he
is currently between places and lives between hotels, his pastor’s
home and at times at his place of business.”
On May 13, 2022, the Department filed a subsequent
petition under section 342, alleging that mother was “unable and
unwilling to provide the children with ongoing care and
supervision.” Mother had reported that she felt “overwhelmed”
and could no longer care for the children due to her mental health
issues. She provided the Department with written and verbal
consent to detain the children. Mother was “open and honest
about her instability and lack of being able to continue to provide
the children with the necessary care they need.”
On May 16, 2022, the court ordered the children removed
from mother, with monitored visitation and Department
discretion to liberalize visits. In the May 13, 2022 detention
report, the Department stated the children could not be placed
with father because he was not in compliance with his court-
ordered services, and in addition, “has another open case with the

3
Department in which he is receiving Family Reunification
services for the child [M.C.].”
On June 1, 2022, the court ordered father to be removed
from county jail, where he was then incarcerated, and
transported to a June 17, 2022 adjudication hearing. Father had
been arrested on May 26, 2022 for violation of a domestic violence
court order, and the Department asked that his unmonitored
visits revert to monitored visits. Father was released from jail
but as of June 15, 2022, had not been responsive to Department
attempts to contact him. The court temporarily limited father’s
visitation.
On July 21, 2022, the court sustained the Department’s
section 342 petition, removed the children from mother, ordered
counseling, and ordered mother to participate in an Evidence
Code section 730 evaluation and follow all recommendations.
The court also granted the Department’s request to revert
father’s visits to monitored visits.
The Department’s July 21, 2022 report contained a full
description of the April 2021 petition on behalf of father’s other
child, M.C., and the domestic violence allegations that were
sustained against father and his wife D.J. in that case in July
2021. (This information appears in later reports as well.) The
Department reported that father was “not in compliance with his
Court ordered case plan regarding the child [M.C.] and he was
recently incarcerated for several days for violating a protective
order.”
On October 20, 2022, the Department requested a “walk-
on,” because father was “exhibit[i]ng threatening and erratic
behavior, and the Department is requesting a temporary
restraining order for the children, the current caretaker, and the

4
former social workers.” The Department asked the court to set a
hearing. The next day, Judge Philip Soto, standing in for Judge
Marguerite Downing, obtained father’s agreement “not to harass,
molest or annoy, or disturb” the two social workers and the
caretaker; not to send any threats or messages to them; and not
to go to the caretaker’s home or visit the children there, calling
this an “informal stay-away order.” The court set the matter for
a progress report on father’s visits and threats in a month’s time,
and stated that there would be no need for a restraining order
“[i]f this has all been resolved.” The court told father he was “on
a destructive path,” and the court wished to guide him off that
path.
On March 1, 2023, the court found continued jurisdiction
necessary, and ordered the children placed at home with mother,
with family maintenance services. Father had not completed his
programs and “housing appears to be an issue,” so the court gave
the Department “discretion to liberalize and or return the
children to [father].”
At the final hearing on October 23, 2023, the Department
recommended findings that continued court supervision was not
necessary, and return of the children to father would create a
substantial risk of detriment to their wellbeing. The Department
recommended termination of jurisdiction with sole physical
custody to mother, joint legal custody and overnight visits for
father.
The children’s counsel argued for continued jurisdiction,
mother agreed with the Department’s recommendation, and
father asked to close the case with joint physical and legal
custody and overnight visits. The court terminated jurisdiction
with sole legal and physical custody to mother, staying the order

5
until October 30, 2023, when the juvenile custody order was
received, signed and filed. The order also provides for
unmonitored visits for father to be arranged between the parents,
and overnights from Saturday at 10:00 a.m. to Sunday at 7:00
p.m. or any other agreed schedule, and specifies that father’s
wife, D.J., “may not be present during Father’s visits with
children.”
Father filed a timely appeal.
DISCUSSION
“ ‘When making a custody determination in any
dependency case, the court’s focus and primary consideration
must always be the best interests of the child.’ ” (In re N.M.
(2023) 88 Cal.App.5th 1090, 1094.) “ ‘[T]he juvenile court has
broad discretion to make custody orders when it terminates
jurisdiction in a dependency case.’ [Citation.] We review a
custody (or ‘exit’) order . . . for abuse of discretion, and will not
disturb the order ‘unless the court “ ‘ “exceeded the limits of legal
discretion by making an arbitrary, capricious, or patently absurd
determination.” ’ ” ’ [Citation.] ‘ “ ‘The appropriate test for abuse
of discretion is whether the trial court exceeded the bounds of
reason. When two or more inferences can reasonably be deduced
from the facts, the reviewing court has no authority to substitute
its decision for that of the trial court.’ ” ’ ” (Ibid.)
Father’s first argument is that the court’s basis for the
custody order was “the other case”—M.C.’s case—and that any
evidence presented in that case “was not before the court in this
proceeding, and is not before this Court on appeal.” Father
asserts that the Department did not request judicial notice of any
documents in M.C.’s case, or attach any documents from M.C.’s
case to the social workers’ reports, or even ask the court to refer

6
to any specific documents in M.C.’s case. Ergo, father concludes,
there is no substantial evidence to support the custody order,
citing In re Ricardo L. (2003) 109 Cal.App.4th 552 (Ricardo L.).
Father’s analysis is faulty for multiple reasons.
The Department submitted three documents as exhibits at
the hearing, to which father did not object. These were the status
review report filed August 23, 2023 (dated Sept. 6, 2023), and
“last minute” reports filed September 1, 2023 and October 17,
2023. The Department’s risk assessment on August 16, 2023,
was that the children were at low risk of future abuse or neglect
under the mother’s care, and at high risk of future abuse or
neglect under the father’s care. No other evidence or witnesses
were produced by father or anyone else.
At the hearing, father’s counsel argued for joint physical
and legal custody, pointing to the case worker’s report that the
children “seemed happy when they were with their father” and
that her observation during a visit “suggested a positive and
engaging relationship” between father and children; and father
had finished his case plan “besides a few weeks of D.V. [domestic
violence].” Under questioning by the court, referring to the
children’s counsel’s statement that father “only completed 35 out
of the 52-week program,” father’s counsel admitted that “[h]e still
has more D.V. to go.”
The last minute information also stated that father and
mother agreed on a schedule for father’s overnight visits, after
which father repeatedly complained to the social worker that
mother did not pick up the children on time. Mother stated her
excuses, and when the social worker said she had been informed
in the past that the parents were coparenting well, “mother
expressed that they would now have to work things out more

7
effectively or make additional efforts to co-parent successfully.”
This casts some doubt on father’s counsel’s argument that the
parents “do now have a better working relationship.”
In short, the record provides substantial evidence
supporting sole physical custody to mother. This case began due
to father’s domestic violence, and when it ended, father still had
not completed the domestic violence program he was first ordered
to do in September 2020. In addition, stable housing was a
problem. As of March 1, 2023, father’s counsel admitted that
father “might not be staying at one place specifically all the
time,” and the court observed that “housing appears to be an
issue” for father. There was no evidence that father had obtained
stable housing since that time; the report filed on August 23,
2023, stated that father “appeared to have some struggles such as
lack of housing.” These points amply support sole custody to
mother.
Nor do we agree that the juvenile court “relied on evidence
outside the record in this case.” The record is replete with
information about the domestic violence allegations sustained
against father in the case involving M.C., starting with a status
review report filed in April 2022, and continuing in subsequent
reports. In the last minute information filed September 1, 2023,
the social worker reported she was aware that father had
monitored visits with M.C. At no time did father ever object to
any of this evidence. (See In re N.O. (2019) 31 Cal.App.5th 899,
935 [“ ‘A party forfeits the right to claim error as grounds for
reversal on appeal when he or she fails to raise the objection in
the trial court.’ ”].) Forfeiture applies in dependency litigation.
(Ibid.)

8
In any event, Ricardo L. does not help father. In that case,
the court found there was insufficient evidence to support a
finding of jurisdiction under section 300, subdivision (j) (where
the child’s sibling has been abused or neglected and there is a
substantial risk the child will be abused or neglected).
(Ricardo L., supra, 109 Cal.App.4th at pp. 555, 566-567.) There
was no evidence submitted to show the factual basis for the
jurisdictional findings in the case involving Ricardo’s siblings (id.
at p. 566), and even if the evidence was sufficient to show the
siblings were neglected, “there was certainly no evidence
submitted to support a finding that there was a substantial risk
Ricardo, Jr. will be neglected as defined in [the applicable
provision of section 300].” (Id. at pp. 566-567; see id. at p. 567
[“[w]ithout the history of abuse and neglect, it is nearly
impossible to determine whether Ricardo, Jr. is at risk of
suffering from the same abuse and neglect”].) The court took
jurisdiction over the children in this case in 2020, months before
the initiation of M.C.’s dependency proceedings. Ricardo L. is
entirely inapt.
Father argues that even if the evidence supported
awarding mother sole physical custody—which it does—the trial
court abused its discretion in awarding mother sole legal custody.
Father asserts the court had “no reasonable basis for issuing” the
order. He cites inapt authorities, and then cites facts about his
“positive and engaging relationship” with the children and
mother’s statement that she and father are able to coparent well.
This is nothing more than an argument that we should weigh the
evidence and substitute our judgment for that of the juvenile
court, which we may not do. Father has not shown the order was
arbitrary, capricious or patently absurd.

9
Nor has father shown any prejudice from the order. He
asserts that he is now faced with “the more stringent burden of
establishing a significant change in circumstances before a family
law court may modify the exit orders.” That burden, however,
does not constitute prejudice.
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s exit orders terminating jurisdiction
and awarding mother sole physical and legal custody of the three
children are affirmed.

GRIMES, Acting P. J.

WE CONCUR:

WILEY, J.

VIRAMONTES, J.

10

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.