Wang v. Taylor CA2/5

CourtListener 10292373CalctappDec 12, 2024

Full text

Filed 12/12/24 Wang v. Taylor CA2/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION FIVE

QINGFEN WANG, B334667

Plaintiff and Appellant, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No.
v. 21STCV30687)

THOMAS TAYLOR et al.,

Defendants and Respondents.

APPEAL from judgments of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Margaret L. Oldendorf, Judge. Affirmed.
Law Offices of Ping C. Shen and Ping C. Shen for Plaintiff
and Appellant.
Cole Pedroza, Kenneth R. Pedroza and Kristin M. Tannler;
Reback, McAndrews & Blessey, Thomas F. McAndrews and Tracy
D. Hughes, for Defendants and Respondents.
I. INTRODUCTION

Qingfen Wang (plaintiff) brought an action for negligence
against the Pasadena Advanced Surgery Institute1 (PASI) and
medical malpractice against Dr. Thomas Taylor (defendants) for
injuries she suffered during a medical procedure. PASI filed a
motion for summary judgment that Dr. Taylor joined (defendants’
summary judgment motion). The trial court granted defendants’
summary judgment motion and entered judgments in their favor.
On appeal, plaintiff contends the court erred in excluding her
evidence and there were triable issues of material fact concerning
her causes of action. We affirm.

II. BACKGROUND

A. Plaintiff’s First Amended Complaint

On October 18, 2021, plaintiff filed her first amended
complaint. She alleged she hired Dr. Taylor to perform
abdominoplasty surgery on October 12, 2020, at PASI. When
plaintiff awoke from the surgery, her right leg was bandaged and
no one explained the nature of her injury or how it happened.
Two weeks later, plaintiff returned to see Dr. Taylor. He
told her she had suffered a minor injury on her thigh, but did not
tell her what had happened. Later, Dr. Taylor gave plaintiff a
medical report that stated that “something was wrong with the
Bovie pad that was used in the operation, which caused her right
thigh to be burned seriously.”

1 Incorrectly named as “Pasadena Advanced Surgery Center”
in plaintiff’s action.

2
Dr. Taylor gave plaintiff an ointment for her burn but, after
several months, the burn had not healed. The injury began to
heal after plaintiff received treatment from a second doctor.
Plaintiff saw a third doctor to evaluate “what had happened
during the operation and how the skin can get recovered.” That
doctor opined plaintiff suffered a third degree burn. With
treatment, the burn would have “55% improvement.” The cost of
that treatment would be $42,000.
Plaintiff alleged PASI provided medical equipment for her
abdominoplasty surgery. It breached its duty of care to plaintiff
by “not providing a qualified, useable proper [B]ovie pad or not
providing other qualified accessories.”
Plaintiff alleged Dr. Taylor breached his duty of care to her
“by not using the [B]ovie pad properly or conduct[ing] the whole
operation proper[l]y.”

B. Defendants’ Summary Judgment Motion

On August 3, 2023, PASI filed a summary judgment
motion.2 It argued that its care and treatment of plaintiff
complied with the standard of care.3

2 On August 17, 2023, Dr. Taylor filed a notice of joinder and
joinder in PASI’s summary judgment motion and a supporting
separate statement of undisputed material facts. Plaintiff did not
oppose the joinder, and the trial court granted Dr. Taylor’s
joinder.

3 PASI argued plaintiff’s action against it properly was for
professional negligence—i.e., medical malpractice—and not for
ordinary negligence. The trial court agreed. Plaintiff does not
challenge the court’s ruling in her appeal.

3
In support of defendants’ summary judgment motion, PASI
submitted Dr. Athleo Cambre’s declaration and other evidence.
Dr. Cambre declared he was board certified as a Diplomate of the
American Board of Plastic Surgery and had been a staff surgeon
at California hospitals since 1992. Currently he was a staff
surgeon at Southern California Hospital in Los Angeles and
Cedars Sinai Medical Center in Beverly Hills. Dr. Cambre
reviewed plaintiff’s PASI medical records, photographs of
plaintiff’s burn wound, Dr. Brent Moelleken’s subsequent medical
evaluation report of plaintiff (Dr. Moelleken was the second
doctor plaintiff saw), and declarations from biomedical
engineering expert Peter Crosby and PASI medical personnel.
Dr. Cambre opined that “the care and treatment provided by Dr.
Taylor and the PASI staff at all times was within the applicable
standard of care.”
PASI also submitted Crosby’s declaration. Crosby declared
he had a graduate degree in biomedical engineering and had
worked in the medical device industry for over 45 years. He
opined it was “more likely than not that the burns observed in
Plaintiff were caused by a defective electrosurgery pad.”
Plaintiff did not file written objections to PASI’s evidence
as she was required to do by California Rules of Court, rule
3.1354(b). Instead, in her opposition to PASI’s summary
judgment motion she argued that Crosby’s expert opinion lacked
foundation and he was unqualified to opine on “whether the
defects of the Bovi[e] Pad can be found in a surgical room.” The
trial court rejected plaintiff’s “objections.”
In support of her opposition to defendants’ summary
judgment motion, plaintiff submitted a request for judicial notice
that attached three exhibits and her counsel’s declaration that

4
attached plaintiff’s declaration and four other exhibits. On
various grounds, PASI objected to plaintiff’s request for judicial
notice in its entirety, to parts of plaintiff’s declaration, and to
each of the remaining four exhibits attached to counsel’s
declaration. The trial court sustained each of PASI’s objections.
The trial court granted defendants’ summary judgment
motion. It ruled that in medical malpractice cases expert opinion
testimony is required to prove or disprove the defendant met the
standard of care unless the negligence is obvious to laymen. It
noted Dr. Cambre declared “‘the care and treatment provided by
Dr. Taylor and the PASI staff at all times was within the
applicable standard of care.’” Accordingly, PASI was entitled to
summary judgment unless plaintiff presented conflicting expert
opinions. Plaintiff did not present conflicting expert opinions or
show the negligence that caused her injury was obvious to
laymen.

III. DISCUSSION

A. Standards of Review

“A trial court properly grants summary judgment where no
triable issue of material fact exists and the moving party is
entitled to judgment as a matter of law. (Code Civ. Proc., § 437c,
subd. (c).) We review the trial court’s decision [on a summary
judgment motion] de novo, considering all of the evidence the
parties offered in connection with the motion (except that which
the court properly excluded) and the uncontradicted inferences
the evidence reasonably supports. [Citation.]” (Merrill v.
Navegar, Inc. (2001) 26 Cal.4th 465, 476.)

5
“[I]n moving for summary judgment, a ‘defendant . . . has
met’ his ‘burden of showing that a cause of action has no merit if’
he ‘has shown that one or more elements of the cause of action
. . . cannot be established . . . . Once the defendant . . . has met
that burden, the burden shifts to the plaintiff . . . to show that a
triable issue of one or more material facts exists as to that cause
of action . . . .’” (Aguilar v. Atlantic Richfield Co. (2001) 25
Cal.4th 826, 849.)
“We review a trial court’s rulings on the admissibility of
evidence for abuse of discretion, and we will not reverse absent
‘“a showing the trial court exercised its discretion in an arbitrary,
capricious, or patently absurd manner that resulted in a manifest
miscarriage of justice.”’ [Citation.]” (Pilliod v. Monsanto
Company (2021) 67 Cal.App.5th 591, 630.)

B. Application of Legal Principles

“[I]n any medical malpractice action, the plaintiff must
establish: (1) the duty of the professional to use such skill,
prudence, and diligence as other members of his profession
commonly possess and exercise; (2) a breach of that duty; (3) a
proximate causal connection between the negligent conduct and
the resulting injury; and (4) actual loss or damage resulting from
the professional’s negligence. [Citations.]” (Borrayo v. Avery
(2016) 2 Cal.App.5th 304, 310, internal quotation marks omitted
(Borrayo).)
“When a defendant health care practitioner moves for
summary judgment and supports his motion with an expert
declaration that his conduct met the community standard of care,
the defendant is entitled to summary judgment unless the

6
plaintiff comes forward with conflicting expert evidence.
[Citation.]” (Borrayo, supra, 2 Cal.App.5th at p. 310; Powell v.
Kleinman (2007) 151 Cal.App.4th 112, 123 [“Whenever the
plaintiff claims negligence in the medical context, the plaintiff
must present evidence from an expert that the defendant
breached his or her duty to the plaintiff . . .”].)

1. Plaintiff’s Evidence

Plaintiff argues the trial court erred in sustaining PASI’s
objections to evidence she submitted in opposition to defendants’
summary judgment motion. We reject plaintiff’s deficient
argument.
Plaintiff’s entire argument is: “Plaintiff submitted multiple
pieces of evidence as supporting documents in Opposition to the
Motion for Summary Judgment. However, the trial court rejected
the evidence without a valid reason. The user instruction for the
Bovie Pad, declaration of Plaintiff, and other evidence submitted
proved at least there are triable issues in the case.”
Plaintiff fails to set forth all of the evidence to which PASI
objected, to state the grounds for PASI’s objections, to discuss the
relevant law concerning PASI’s objections, or to explain how the
trial court erred in its rulings. We treat as forfeited perfunctory
arguments made without adequate legal argument. (L.O. v.
Kilrain (2023) 96 Cal.App.5th 616, 620; Tilbury Constructors, Inc.
v. State Comp. Ins. Fund (2006) 137 Cal.App.4th 466, 482; People
v. Harper (2000) 82 Cal.App.4th 1413, 1419, fn. 4.)

7
2. Plaintiff’s Medical Malpractice Claim Against PASI

Plaintiff contends there is a triable issue of material fact
regarding whether PASI was negligent in providing a defective
Bovie pad. Essentially, her contention challenges Crosby’s
qualifications as an expert witness and the probative value of his
opinions. Plaintiff’s contention fails.
PASI submitted a medical expert witness declaration from
Dr. Cambre who declared that the care and treatment PASI’s
staff provided plaintiff “was within the applicable standard of
care.” Thus, PASI was entitled to summary judgment unless
plaintiff produced conflicting medical expert witness evidence.
(Borrayo, supra, 2 Cal.App.5th at p. 310.) Plaintiff did not
produce such evidence. Her challenge to Crosby’s qualifications
and opinions, even if well taken, did not overcome that deficiency.
Accordingly, the trial court did not err in granting summary
judgment as to plaintiff’s medical malpractice claim against
PASI.

3. Plaintiff’s Medical Malpractice Claim Against
Dr. Taylor

Plaintiff contends there is a triable issue of material fact
regarding whether Dr. Taylor performed the abdominoplasty
surgery negligently. In support of her contention, she argues the
evidence showed Dr. Taylor admitted his fault after the surgery
and he did not check the Bovie pad after he repositioned plaintiff
during the surgery. Plaintiff’s contention fails.
PASI submitted a medical expert witness declaration from
Dr. Cambre who declared that the care and treatment Dr. Taylor

8
provided plaintiff “was within the applicable standard of care.”
Thus, Dr. Taylor was entitled to summary judgment unless
plaintiff produced conflicting medical expert witness evidence.
(Borrayo, supra, 2 Cal.App.5th at p. 310.) Plaintiff did not meet
that burden. Her claims about Dr. Taylor’s alleged post-surgery
admission of fault and Dr. Taylor’s alleged failure to check the
Bovie pad after he repositioned plaintiff during surgery, even if
well taken, did not overcome that deficiency.4 Accordingly, the
court did not err in granting summary judgment as to plaintiff’s
medical malpractice claim against Dr. Taylor.

4 We also hold that this evidence could not have defeated
defendants’ summary judgment motion because the trial court
ruled it was inadmissible and we upheld that ruling above.

9
IV. DISPOSITION

The judgments are affirmed. Defendants are entitled to
their costs on appeal.

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

KIM (D.), J.

We concur:

HOFFSTADT, P. J.

MOOR, J.

10

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.