CourtListener 10291934•People v. Anderson CA2/6
Full text
Filed 12/11/24 P. v. Anderson CA2/6
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION SIX
THE PEOPLE, 2d Crim. No. B333330
(Super. Ct. Nos. BA511952,
Plaintiff and Respondent, BA516342)
(Los Angeles County)
v.
LEMUEL ARLINGTON
ANDERSON,
Defendant and Appellant.
Lemuel Arlington Anderson appeals the judgment after a
jury convicted him of three counts of procuring and offering false
or forged instruments (Pen. Code,1 § 115, subd. (a)). Anderson
also admitted a prior “strike” allegation (§§ 667, subds. (b)-(j),
1170.12), which the trial court dismissed. The trial court
suspended imposition of sentence and placed Anderson on two
years’ probation.
1 Further unspecified statutory references are to the Penal
Code.
Anderson contends his convictions should be reversed
because there was insufficient evidence that he knowingly
committed the offenses. We affirm.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY
This case involves three properties in Los Angeles: the 85th
Street property, the 104th Street property, and the 116th Street
property.
Prosecution evidence
Derek Shepherd owned the 85th Street property with his
wife since 2005. They purchased the property at the trustee’s
sale, lived there from 2005 to 2018, and then used it as rental
property. Shepherd did not know Anderson. He never rented the
property to Anderson or to a man named Robert Latham, Jr.
(Robert Latham), who Anderson said was his uncle. Shepherd
said Anderson and Robert Latham never lived there. The
prosecution presented a copy of a grant deed, which showed the
transfer of the property from Robert Latham to Anderson.
Shepherd testified that he never gave them permission to record
any documents against the property.
Luz Rodriguez lived at the 104th Street property since she
and her ex-husband purchased it in 1997. The prosecution
presented a copy of a grant deed, which showed the transfer of
the property from Robert Latham to Anderson. Rodriguez said
she did not know Anderson or Robert Latham, nor did they have
permission to record any documents against her property.
Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Detective Christopher Derry
testified that Alice M. O’Field quitclaimed the 104th Street
property to Lee T. Pate in 1993. He also testified that Pate
transferred the property to Willie Latham, a single man, and
Pate as tenants in common in March 1996. A trustee’s deed upon
2
sale was recorded in October 1996, following Pate’s default on the
loan and a foreclosure auction. A grant deed was recorded in
July 1997, transferring the property from Benjamin Hernandez
to Luz Rodriguez and her ex-husband. Anderson recorded a
grant deed on the property in December 2021, transferring
ownership of the 104th Street property from Robert Latham to
Anderson. Latham’s signature on the deed was notarized in
November 2021.
Walter Latham lived at the 116th Street property for about
52 years with his wife, Willie Latham,2 and their son. The
prosecution showed him a grant deed transferring the property
from Anderson to his cousin, David Smith. Walter Latham
testified that he did not know Anderson or David Smith. He also
denied giving them permission to record any documents against
the property.
Detective Derry testified there was a joint tenancy grant
deed recorded on the 116th Street property in April 1972,
transferring ownership of the property from a man named Luis
Machado to Walter and Willie Latham, as husband and wife.
There was a trust transfer deed recorded in August 2010,
transferring ownership from Walter and Willie Latham to their
2 The Willie Latham associated with the 104th Street
property is a male and the Willie Latham associated with the
116th Street property is a female. The record does not reflect
there was any relationship between the two. And neither Walter
or Willie Latham, husband and wife, are related to Robert
Latham.
3
living trust. O’Field was not on the chain of title.3 Trevor Wiltz,
a notary public, testified that he notarized a grant deed on the
116th Street property for Anderson in October 2022 at a UPS
store in Culver City.
Detective Derry investigated the properties. Wild deeds
involving Anderson were recorded on all three properties. A wild
deed is a deed recorded outside the chain of title. The jury was
presented with a surveillance video from December 2021 showing
Anderson in line at the Los Angeles County Registrar Recorder’s
Office to record documents on the 85th and 104th Street
properties. The jury also saw surveillance video from October
2022 showing a man recording a document on the 116th Street
property. The prosecution asserted the man was Anderson. The
defense asserted David Smith recorded the document.
In February 2022, Detective Derry interviewed Anderson to
discuss the 104th Street property. The jury was presented with
an audio recording and transcript of the interview. During the
interview, Anderson said, “[T]here’s nothing to be said anymore
man. I filed . . . that planning to get the fake deeds off my
property.” Anderson also said, “[Y]a’ll let these people go in my
house. I put locks on it. Ya’ll let them people go right back up in
there man. . . . They been in my people’s houses for years. Years
and years.” Derry showed Anderson a copy of the grant deed
Anderson recorded on the 104th Street property. Derry asked,
“I’ve got some questions because there’s a dispute over this
property. . . . a couple questions I have is Robert Latham, the
person that signed this, who is this man to you?” Anderson
cursed at Derry and replied, “Robert Jr.’s my motherfucking
3 Detective Derry did not retrieve records prior to 1985 for
any of the three properties.
4
uncle. That’s his Goddamn mama’s house. He signed the shit
over to me. Enough fucking said!” Anderson ended the
interview.
Anderson later called Detective Derry. Anderson told
Derry that Robert Latham was his mother’s brother. Derry
asked Anderson who prepared the deed transferring the property
from Robert Latham to himself, and Anderson replied that it was
his attorney. When asked for the name of his attorney, Anderson
said he would call Derry “right back” with the name. Anderson
never called back.
The Shepherds filed a police report with respect to the 85th
Street property, and two other detectives interviewed Anderson.
The jury was presented with the audio and transcript of that
interview. During the interview, Anderson said that Alice
O’Field was his grandmother. He said the Shepherds “think that
my grandmother’s property belongs to them, and it doesn’t.” The
detective asked whether he was present when the grant deed
signed by Robert Latham was notarized. Anderson replied that
he took his uncle to a UPS store to get the deed notarized.
Anderson also said he got the grant deed from an attorney and
that he “can’t say no more, other than . . . this is all the real-deal
paperwork here to my grandmama’s place.” When the detective
asked who the attorney was, Anderson replied, “I rather not even
speak on nothing because my attorney told me not to. . . . I will
contact him and have him get ahold of you guys and go from
there.”
Anderson also said that when his grandmother passed
away in 1996, she signed over the 85th Street property to his
uncle, and he signed it over to Anderson. He said that
“squatters” moved onto the property, claimed it was theirs, and
5
made up fake deeds. Anderson said he filed a complaint with the
Department of Consumer and Business Affairs against the
Shepherds. Anderson also said he put locks on the house about a
month prior, but the locks were later removed. When asked who
stayed at the property after his grandmother passed away,
Anderson said he did not know and that he was in Wisconsin at
that time. When asked if Anderson visited the property after his
grandmother died, his response was, “What does that have to do
with this here?” And when asked why he and his uncle did not
transfer the 85th Street property after his grandmother’s death,
Anderson replied, “What the fuck—I mean, excuse me. What can
he do? He can’t do nothing.” He also said, “I don’t know nothing
about none of this stuff. I’m new to everything. . . . I’m doing
what I can.”
Defense evidence
Anderson testified on his own behalf. He moved from
Wisconsin to Los Angeles in September 2021 after he heard his
uncle Robert Latham’s properties were available to him by
conveyance. He testified that Alice O’Field was his grandmother,
and Robert and Willie Latham were O’Field’s sons and
Anderson’s uncles.
Anderson testified that O’Field, his uncle Willie Latham,
and Lee T. Pate owned the 104th Street property. He said that
after O’Field and Willie Latham died in 1996 and 1997,
respectively, the property remained empty, but still belonged to
his family. He did not know Luz Rodriguez, who claimed
ownership of the property. He also did not know Rodriguez
recorded a deed on the property. He said that Robert Latham
and Samuel Henderson, a family friend, told him that the people
living in the property had “fraudulent documents.” Anderson had
6
Blair Earkman, a bookkeeper, draft a deed to the property.
Anderson got the deed notarized, and then recorded it in
December 2021. Anderson also put bills in his name, obtained
homeowner’s insurance on the property, and paid utilities. He
also attempted to turn the property into a business and had
Spectrum drop off cable boxes and a business phone. At the time
of trial, Anderson believed that he legally owned the 104th Street
property and that the other deeds on the property were
fraudulent. He denied that Rodriguez bought the property and
claimed it never went into foreclosure.
Anderson also testified the 85th Street property was
O’Field’s home. He said she bought the property in 1975 and that
the Shepherds’ documents were fraudulent. Robert Latham and
Henderson told him there were issues with ownership of this
property. Anderson recorded the deed on this property around
the same time as the 104th Street property. He tried to clear the
ownership issue by putting bills in his name and obtaining
homeowner’s insurance on the property. He also filed a “criminal
complaint” in 2021 regarding the 85th Street and 104th Street
properties. He alleged that a court ordered the properties be
granted to him, but the current owners continued to dispute
ownership. He also filed a complaint with consumer affairs. He
had Earkman prepare a deed transferring the 85th Street
property from Robert Latham to himself. Anderson believed he
legally owned the property.
Blair Earkman testified that he was the bookkeeper who
prepared the grant deeds for Anderson on the 85th and 104th
Street properties. The grant deeds transferred the properties
from Robert Latham to Anderson.
7
Anderson testified that his uncle Willie Latham owned the
116th Street property and that it was transferred from Lee T.
Pate to Willie Latham in the “late 80’s, early 90’s.” He said his
uncle did not sell the property before he passed away and that
Walter Latham filed a fraudulent deed on the property. He
testified that Walter Latham and his wife, Willie Latham, were
not family, and he did not know a female named Willie Latham.
Henderson informed Anderson about the fraudulent deed about
six months after he recorded the deeds on the other properties.
Anderson had Earkman prepare a deed transferring the property
from Anderson to David Smith (Anderson’s cousin). He said he
transferred the deed to Smith because the City of Norwalk
refused to let Anderson record the property in his own name. He
had the property conveyed to Smith because he wanted to get his
cousin out from Skid Row. The deed was notarized and recorded
in October 2022. Anderson and Henderson drove Smith to the
county recorder’s office, and Smith forged Anderson’s signature
on the recorded document. At the time of trial, Anderson
believed Smith legally owned the property.
DISCUSSION
Anderson contends there was insufficient evidence to
support that he knowingly filed false or fraudulent documents.
We are not persuaded.
Under section 115, subdivision (a), a person who
“knowingly procures or offers any false or forged instrument to be
filed, registered, or recorded in any public office within the state
. . . is guilty of a felony.”
We review sufficiency of evidence challenges to the
judgment of conviction for substantial evidence. We review the
whole record “in the light most favorable to the judgment to
8
determine whether it contains substantial evidence—that is,
evidence that is reasonable, credible, and of solid value—from
which a reasonable trier of fact could find the defendant guilty
beyond a reasonable doubt.” (People v. Albillar (2010) 51 Cal.4th
47, 60 (Albillar).) If the evidence reasonably justifies the trier of
fact’s finding, we do not reverse even if the evidence might also
reasonably justify a contrary finding. (Ibid.) We do not reweigh
evidence. The credibility of witnesses and the weight to be
accorded to the evidence are exclusively within the province of
the trier of fact. (Ibid.)
Here, substantial evidence supports the jury’s finding that
Anderson knowingly filed false or fraudulent documents. The
prosecution presented evidence of the deeds recorded by
Anderson and the surveillance videos of the deeds being recorded.
The current owners of the properties testified that they did not
know Anderson and that he never had permission to record
documents on their properties. Detective Derry also testified as
to the chain of title on the three properties. His testimony
showed that Anderson’s deeds were “wild deeds,” refuting
Anderson’s testimony that the properties, including the 104th
Street property, still belonged to his family and that the other
deeds from the current owners were fraudulent.
The jury also considered evidence of Detective Derry’s
interviews with Anderson, in which Anderson said an attorney
prepared the deeds. Anderson could not provide the name of the
attorney and never called Derry back with the name of the
attorney. It was later revealed that Earkman, a bookkeeper,
prepared the deeds. The jury also considered Anderson’s
interview with two other detectives, in which Anderson again
could not provide the name of the attorney who prepared the
9
deeds. When asked about the deeds, Anderson said he would
“rather not . . . speak on nothing” because his attorney told him
not to, and said he would have his attorney contact the
detectives. The record does not show this happened. Anderson
also could not answer why the 85th Street property transferred to
him in 2021 and not in 1996 after his grandmother’s death. The
jury could infer from Anderson’s evasiveness and inconsistent
testimony that he knew of his wrongdoing.
Anderson also testified that the City of Norwalk refused to
let Anderson record the property in his own name. Consequently,
he had Smith record a deed transferring the 116th Street
property from Anderson to Smith. He also testified that Smith
forged Anderson’s signature on the deed. A jury could reasonably
infer from this testimony that Anderson knew the deed to the
116th Street property was false and fraudulent when he recorded
it.
Anderson contends the evidence supports that he did not
know the deeds he recorded were false. He points to evidence
that he consistently maintained his family still owned the
properties and that he had no awareness of the foreclosures and
sales of the properties. But on a substantial evidence review, we
construe the evidence in the light most favorable to the
prosecution—not the other way around. (Albillar, supra, 51
Cal.4th at p. 60.)
The jury was properly instructed on the elements of the
crime and mistake of fact, including that they must not find
Anderson guilty if they had “reasonable doubt about whether [he]
had the mental state required for filing a false document.” We
presume the jury understood and followed the instructions.
(People v. Coffman and Marlow (2004) 34 Cal.4th 1, 107.) The
10
jury evidently did not find Anderson’s testimony credible and
rejected his defense. We will not disturb the jury’s credibility
assessments and weighing of evidence.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.
BALTODANO, J.
We concur:
YEGAN, Acting P. J.
CODY, J.
11
Craig Richman, Judge
Superior Court County of Los Angeles
______________________________
Paul Stubb Jr., under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief
Assistant Attorney General, Susan Sullivan Pithey, Assistant
Attorney General, Jonathan J. Kline and Herbert S. Tetef,
Deputy Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.