CourtListener 10282376•Johnson-Smith v. Davis CA2/1
Full text
Filed 11/22/24 Johnson-Smith v. Davis CA2/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
JASLEEN JOHNSON-SMITH, B324161
Plaintiff and Respondent, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. 22TRRO00360)
v.
CARLOS RONDELL DAVIS
III,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Gia G. Bosley, Judge. Affirmed.
Ahrony Appeals Law Group and Orly Ahrony for Defendant
and Appellant.
Law Office of Leslie Ellen Shear and Julia C. Shear
Kushner for Plaintiff and Respondent.
__________________________________
Appellant Carlos Rondell Davis III appeals from a three-
year Domestic Violence Prevention Act (DVPA) restraining order
issued in favor of respondent Jasleen Johnson-Smith. He argues
that substantial evidence does not support the court’s finding of
“abuse” as defined by Family Code section 6203.1 We disagree
and affirm.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND2
A. Johnson-Smith Requests a Domestic Violence
Restraining Order Against Davis
On May 3, 2022, Johnson-Smith requested a domestic
violence restraining order against Davis. She explained that she
and Davis had been “dating” since March 2017, and the two
shared a child.3 She asserted Davis “physically, verbally, and
mentally abused [her] for the past five years.”
Johnson-Smith claimed that their child visited with Davis
on May 1 and, the next day, Johnson-Smith found a mobile phone
in her car “that was inside of a toybox that the respondent sent
home with our child.” She believed that Davis used the phone’s
tracking feature to discover her location because she refused to
tell him where she lived. Johnson-Smith also related an incident
from March 23, where Davis pushed her and tried to take her
purse to retrieve her car keys. She additionally claimed that he
1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Family
Code.
2 We limit our summary to the facts and procedural history
relevant to the issues raised on appeal.
3 At the time the request for restraining order was filed,
their son was two years old.
2
“threw a safe” at her in front of their son and Davis’s 13-year-old
daughter. She stated that Davis called her more than 50 times
and texted her more than 100 times per day, even after being
asked to stop. If Johnson-Smith “blocked” Davis, he would switch
to e-mails. She elaborated that all contact took place during the
hours that their son was at daycare.
Johnson-Smith also alleged that, on unspecified dates,
Davis: (1) “dragged me through the house by my hair”; (2)
“punched me in the head”; (3) “took my glasses off my face and
broke them”; (4) “[t]ook my car keys and parked my car in the
middle of the street and left it”; (5) “[t]hrew a drink on me and
our son while he was sleeping”; and (6) “[l]ocked me out of the
house and made me sleep in my car.” Johnson-Smith
additionally claimed that Davis “sent me videos of himself saying
he would commit suicide if I did not come back.”
The court issued a temporary restraining order, protecting
Johnson-Smith, her son, her sister, and a friend, until the
restraining order hearing date. Davis was specifically ordered
not to contact Johnson-Smith or any of the protected persons,
“directly or indirectly, by any means, including by telephone,
mail, email, or other electronic means.” Additionally, sole legal
and physical custody of their son was awarded to Johnson-Smith,
with no visitation permitted.
B.Davis Responds to Johnson-Smith’s Request
In June 2022, Davis responded to Johnson-Smith’s
request.4 He “vehemently” denied that he placed his “work cell
4 After Johnson-Smith filed her request, Davis filed his own
request for a restraining order. The two requests were
considered simultaneously by the court, and the court denied
(Fn. is continued on the next page.)
3
phone” in their son’s toybox as a means to track Johnson-Smith.
He claimed their son was playing with the cellphone before
Johnson-Smith’s cousin picked him up and, in Davis’s “haste to
gather our son’s things,” the cellphone was “inadvertently placed
in a Hot Wheels carrying case.” Davis added that, “a short time
after” their son was picked up, he noticed his work cellphone was
missing and contacted Johnson-Smith to ask if she had come
across it “because, as I explained, I believed that our son had
inadvertently taken it or it had somehow got swept into his Hot
Wheels carrying case as I was packing up his things.” Despite
“two separate inquiries,” Johnson-Smith denied having the
phone.
As for the March 2022 incident, Davis denied pushing
Johnson-Smith, trying to take her purse to take her car keys, or
throwing a safe at her. Instead, Davis claimed that he informed
Johnson-Smith that he would be taking the BMW that she
typically drove—but which Davis owned—to see his
grandmother, because the car Davis usually drove lacked
sufficient gas to get him to his destination, and he “did not want
to stop for gas for safety reasons.” Davis alleged that Johnson-
Smith followed him outside to the car, “under the guise of
removing her stuff” but in reality to provoke a confrontation. As
Johnson-Smith “grew louder,” Davis saw his 13-year-old
daughter standing at the doorway to the home, holding Davis’s
and Johnson-Smith’s son. Davis decided to go back into the
house to “diffuse the confrontation.” When Davis took his son
from his daughter, he set the BMW keys down, and Johnson-
Davis’s request. Because that denial is not at issue in this
appeal, we do not discuss the evidence and testimony relating
solely to Davis’s request.
4
Smith placed them in her purse. When Davis asked for the keys
back, Johnson-Smith refused, stating, “that’s my gas. I’m not
giving you the keys until I burn the gas.” Davis went to get the
keys from the purse, and Johnson-Smith prevented him from
doing so, pushing him, pulling him, and grabbing his shirt.
Davis “decided that given the confrontation over the keys,
it would be best if I got some things and left for the night.”
Johnson-Smith gave Davis the safe after she removed her things,
and he retrieved some money. As he was exiting his son’s room,
money in hand and the safe tucked under his arm, he felt the safe
slipping. He intended to let the safe drop onto a couch in the
room, but it fell on the floor. Davis denied that his daughter was
present during the incident.
Davis “[s]hamefully” admitted that he did call, text, and e-
mail Johnson-Smith excessively, but alleged that this was
“behavior that we both engaged” in. He described it as “childish
and immature of both of us but certainly not one-sided,
harassing, or disruptive of her peace as Petitioner would like this
Court to believe.” He also claimed that, since the TRO, Johnson-
Smith repeatedly called him to “taunt, ridicule and harass” him,
despite his requests that she stop.
Davis admitted “there were incidents in which
confrontations turned physical,” but claimed that “each and every
confrontation was escalated and or initiated by” Johnson-Smith,
and “[t]o the extent I responded with the use of any physical
force, it was only to protect myself and stop Petitioner’s
aggression.” For instance, Davis claimed that the drink he
supposedly threw at Johnson-Smith resulted from Johnson-Smith
throwing “a spiked wooden apparatus she uses to separate hair”
at him. Davis was holding a drink at that time and, when he
5
used his arm to block the apparatus from hitting him, the liquid
from his drink flew out and landed on Johnson-Smith.
Regarding parking Johnson-Smith’s car in the middle of
the street, Davis explained that her car was parked behind his
when he needed to leave, and she refused to move it. He then
took the keys to move the car and was intending to move it back
after he moved his car out of the driveway. However, Johnson-
Smith came out of the home after he parked the car in the street
and moved his car out of the driveway, so rather than move her
car back onto the driveway, he handed her the keys and left.
Finally, as to locking Johnson-Smith out of the home, Davis
stated that she was visiting his home and being “loud,”
“aggressive,” and “obnoxious,” so he asked her to leave. After she
did, he locked the door to his home, but he “did not force her to
sleep in her car.”
C. The Court Hears Johnson-Smith’s Request
The hearing on the restraining order was continued several
times at the request of the parties. The court ultimately set a
hearing on August 11, 2022, with the TRO being left “in full force
and effect” until this date.
The restraining order hearing occurred over three days in
August and September 2022. Five witnesses testified: Johnson-
Smith, Latoya Thornton, Sade Ross, Davis, and Shanequa Lee.
Lee’s testimony was irrelevant to the issues on appeal. We
summarize the relevant portions of the remaining witnesses’
testimony below.
1. Johnson-Smith
Johnson-Smith testified that she dated Davis “on and off
for the past five years” beginning in March 2017, and the two
6
shared a son together. She stated the relationship was “okay” at
first, but that Davis became “controlling and abusive.” In
September 2018, the two moved in together. She lived with
Davis “off and on” until March 2022. She alleged that Davis
knowingly gave her a sexually transmitted disease when she was
pregnant with their son.
After the TRO was granted, Davis sent Johnson-Smith over
100 text messages, despite Johnson-Smith asking him to stop.
He also called her five times from his own phone number, despite
her answering once and asking him to stop calling. Johnson-
Smith believed Davis also called her over fifty times from a
“Restricted” phone number.5 Johnson-Smith also testified about
several specific incidents of abuse.
(a) November 2019 Incident
In November 2019, when Davis was six months pregnant,
the two were arguing about Davis’s infidelity, and Davis threw a
32-inch television at Johnson-Smith, causing her to leave and
sleep in her car that night.6
(b) October 2020 Incident
In October 2020, during an argument about Davis’s
infidelity, Davis reached up to Johnson-Smith’s face and broke
her glasses in half. He then punched her in the head three times.
5 Johnson-Smith recorded herself answering one such call
and, when she asked who was calling, the caller stated “Carlos.”
This recording was played for the court; the male voice identified
as “Carlos” asked Johnson-Smith if he could see their son.
6 Johnson-Smith also testified—about the same incident—
that Davis “kicked [her] out.”
7
At some point thereafter, Johnson-Smith sent Davis a text
message stating she only sent him $450—apparently for rent—
“because you broke my glasses and I have to pay over $300 to get
new ones.”
(c) May 21, 2021 Incident
On May 21, Johnson-Smith was lying in bed with her son,
putting him to sleep. Davis came in the room and began
complaining that Johnson-Smith was not paying enough
attention to him and refused to have sex with him. Johnson-
Smith replied that he should find somebody else to give him the
attention he wanted, and Davis, who was holding a drink in his
hand, threw the drink in Johnson-Smith’s face; the liquid landed
on both Johnson-Smith and their son. Johnson-Smith denied
threatening or throwing anything at Davis. She testified that the
“spiked wooden apparatus” that Davis claimed she threw at him
was not purchased until January 2022; a receipt reflecting this
purchase was admitted into evidence.
(d) March 23, 2022 Incident
When Johnson-Smith returned to Davis’s house on March
23, he screamed and cursed at her because she had not been
answering his calls or texts. When she complained of his
controlling behavior and stated she was breaking up with him, he
demanded she return the keys to his car. Johnson-Smith agreed,
but stated she wanted to first remove her and their son’s things
from the car.
On Johnson-Smith’s second trip from the car into the home,
Davis grabbed her and started dragging her around the house,
while their son was grabbing her leg, screaming and crying, and
Davis’s daughter was standing and staring at them. Johnson-
8
Smith told Davis’s daughter to call the police because Davis had
struck Johnson-Smith in the past. Johnson-Smith was scared
Davis might hit her in front of the children. Davis’s daughter
went to get her phone and then returned and asked Johnson-
Smith if she really wanted her to call the police. Johnson-Smith
affirmed that she did and, as Davis’s daughter was about to dial,
Davis went to her, grabbed her, and pinned her to the wall,
saying: “You’re going to call the police on me? I’m your dad.
Don’t you ever fucking turn on me. Don’t turn on me. I’m your
dad.” Johnson-Smith got between Davis and his daughter and
stated that if he hit his daughter, Johnson-Smith would call the
police. Johnson-Smith then gave Davis the car keys; Davis
looked at them, said, “Fuck both of you,” and walked away.
Johnson-Smith then went to her son’s room and lay down
in bed with him, trying to calm him down. Davis’s safe was
located in that room, and he walked in to open it. Johnson-Smith
informed him that the key to the safe was on the key ring that
Johnson-Smith had just handed to him, and Davis threw the ring
at her and told her to open the safe. Johnson-Smith opened the
safe, removed a document pouch that she stored in the safe, and
then handed the safe to Davis. Davis started screaming that
Johnson-Smith “always [did] this to him, that [she] always g[o]t
him upset,” and then acted like she did not know why he was
mad. He then took money out of the safe and threw the safe at
her, which caused their son to start screaming again. The safe
landed by Johnson-Smith’s feet.
After the incident, Davis sent Johnson-Smith a text
message stating, among other things, that he “fucked up big on
that throwing shit,” that he had been upset his cousin attempted
suicide, and “that’s why I was upset[;] yes I threw the safe[;] I
9
was wrong.”7 In another text message responding to one from
Johnson-Smith stating that she was “walking away,” Davis
stated that he “was wrong for grabbing your purse” and that it
was done “out of frustration.” He also admitted he “pinned” his
daughter because “[h]er mouth was disrespectful” but stated he
did not “whoop” her.
(e) May 2, 2022 Incident
Johnson-Smith’s cousin picked up Johnson-Smith’s son
from Davis on May 1, 2022. On May 2, Johnson-Smith
discovered a cellphone in a toy box that her son brought back
from the visit. Johnson-Smith believed Davis deliberately placed
the cellphone in the toy box to learn her address, using the
phone’s “Find my iPhone” feature. He had previously called and
texted her “excessively,” asking for her new address, which she
refused to provide because she did not know “what he’s going [to]
try to do to me.”8 When Davis called and asked whether she had
the phone, Johnson-Smith lied because she was afraid that he
had already tracked her address, and because she wanted him to
admit that he knew the phone was in their son’s toybox.
7 In another text message, Davis denied throwing the safe
at Johnson-Smith, stating: “I threw the safe on the floor.”
8 Davis had shown up at previous residences and called and
texted “excessively” to try to force Johnson-Smith to come outside
to talk to him. And he had previously tracked her location by
instructing his 13-year-old daughter to turn on the location
service in her cellphone when she was with Johnson-Smith.
10
2. Latoya Thornton
Thornton is Johnson-Smith’s cousin. She testified that, “on
the day of the toy box incident,” she and her children were
picking up Johnson-Smith’s son from Davis and were loading his
things into their car when Davis told her to “wait a minute.” He
went back into the house and returned a few minutes later with a
Hot Wheels toybox. Thornton’s children took the box, and
Thornton’s daughter told her brother to give Davis’s son one of
the toy cars from the box. But as Thornton’s son went to open the
box, Davis “abruptly yelled out, ‘No. Don’t open it’ ” and added,
“ ‘You’re going to get him started.’ ” The children obeyed and put
the box in the trunk without opening it. The previous times
Thornton picked up Johnson-Smith’s son from Davis, the Hot
Wheels toy box had not been taken from Davis’s home.
3. Sade Ross
Ross is Johnson-Smith’s friend. She testified that she was
on the couch at Davis’s and Johnson-Smith’s home in May 2021,
when she saw Davis go into a room to speak with Johnson-Smith.
Ross heard Johnson-Smith repeatedly ask Davis to turn the light
off because she was putting their son to sleep, and then Ross
heard a sudden gasp. Ross asked Johnson-Smith if she was okay,
and Johnson-Smith responded, “He just threw a drink in my
face.” Ross observed that Johnson-Smith was “doused” in
something.
Ross also testified that Johnson-Smith “often” asked her to
go with her to pick up her son “because of the fear.” She related
one incident in 2022 where Johnson-Smith picked up her son
from Davis at the son’s daycare and, as Johnson-Smith was
putting her son into the car seat, Davis asked to speak with her.
Johnson-Smith responded that she did not have time to talk and,
11
as Ross and Johnson-Smith were leaving, Ross heard Davis call
Johnson-Smith a “stupid fuck” and a “dumb fuck.”
4. Davis
Davis admitted that he contacted Johnson-Smith after
being served with the TRO, which he understood to be a violation
of the TRO. However, he claimed Johnson-Smith also called him
several times through FaceTime; Davis stated that Johnson-
Smith had several “negotiating factors that she wanted [him] to
address or otherwise resolve in lieu of her stopping the
restraining order” proceedings. Davis testified that Johnson-
Smith did not request a restraining order because she feared him,
but because he “exposed” her fraud; he claimed to have alerted
the Crystal Stairs day-care program that Johnson-Smith had
additional income that would have disqualified her from
receiving aid.9 He testified there were several instances in which
Johnson-Smith was physically aggressive towards him and hit
him. He also testified about several of the incidents in which
Johnson-Smith claimed he was abusive.
(a) May 21, 2021 Incident
Davis stated that Johnson-Smith threw a “wooden
apparatus” at him during an argument about his infidelity.
When Davis moved his arm to block the object, some of the drink
9 Johnson-Smith testified that Crystal Stairs was an
organization that provided day-care to low-income individuals
who qualified for their services, and that she received aid from
Crystal Stairs.
12
in his hand splashed onto Johnson-Smith.10 Contrary to
Johnson-Smith’s testimony that she purchased the apparatus in
2022, Davis claimed Johnson-Smith had been using it since 2018
or 2019.
(b) March 23, 2022 Incident
Davis testified that on the night of the March 23 incident,
as he was arriving home, he learned that his cousin had
attempted suicide. He told Johnson-Smith—who had been home
all day with the children—that he needed to “see about [his]
family” and would be taking the BMW. Johnson-Smith told him
that she first needed to remove some things from the car but,
when she went to the car, she did not take anything out. After
Davis realized Johnson-Smith was stalling, he returned to the
house; Johnson-Smith informed him that she did not want him to
take the BMW until “she drove her gas out of it.”
Davis put down the BMW keys to go to the bathroom, and
Johnson-Smith put them in her purse. When Davis went to
10 On cross-examination, an audio recording was played for
Davis. Davis identified the voices on the recording as his and
Johnson-Smith’s. In the relevant portion of the recording,
Johnson-Smith states: “Stop shining the light in my face.
Carlos, I’ve asked you several times to stop shining that light in
my face.” The two then engage in a mostly unintelligible
conversation before Johnson-Smith says: “Did you just throw—”
and Davis responds: “I sure did” before Johnson-Smith finishes
with “alcohol on me?” We then hear a child begin to cry, and
Johnson-Smith say to someone, “He just threw alcohol on me.”
After the recording was played, Johnson-Smith’s counsel asked
Davis whether he intentionally threw a liquid on Johnson-Smith;
Davis responded, “Yes.”
13
retrieve them, Johnson-Smith tried to stop him, and accused him
of intending to go see another woman. Davis denied dragging
Johnson-Smith around the house, testifying it would have been
impossible for him to do so because there was a “malunion” of two
bones in his left forearm that required extensive corrective
surgery.
After Davis retrieved the car keys, he asked Johnson-Smith
to open the home safe to give him some cash because he “needed
gas to put into the vehicle to leave.”11 She initially refused but
then opened the safe, took out some of her documents, and then
handed him some cash before locking the safe back up. Davis
denied throwing the safe at Johnson-Smith. He claimed instead
that, first, the safe fell from his hands to the ground, and then
after he picked it up again, he threw it to the ground. Davis also
denied getting into a physical altercation with his daughter that
evening. Due to the lateness of the hour, Davis ended up not
visiting his family. Johnson-Smith did not express any fear of
Davis, and the two slept in the same bed that night and engaged
in intimate relations.
(c) May 2, 2022 Incident
Davis admitted to bringing his son’s toy car box to
Thornton’s car and telling Thornton and her children not to open
it but claimed he did so because his son “goes crazy over his cars”
and that, if they opened the box, there would be “Hot Wheels
11 In his response to Johnson-Smith’s request for a
restraining order, Davis claimed he needed to take the BMW that
Johnson-Smith drove because his car had insufficient gas to get
him to his destination, and he “did not want to stop for gas for
safety reasons.”
14
everywhere.” Some hours later, Davis could not locate his work
cellphone; he texted Johnson-Smith to ask whether she had seen
the cellphone.
Davis testified that, before Thornton picked his son up, his
son was playing with the work cellphone; Davis did not mind
because the phone was out of charge. Davis denied ever trying to
“track down” where Johnson-Smith was living.
D. The Court Issues a Three-Year Restraining
Order
After both sides rested and gave closing arguments, the
court found that Johnson-Smith was credible and met her burden
for a restraining order. The court stated that “most of the acts of
domestic abuse that the court finds to be true were admitted by”
Davis. The court noted that, although Davis denied trying to
take Johnson-Smith’s purse in his written declaration responding
to her request for a restraining order, he admitted to it when
testifying in court. Citing text messages Davis sent to Johnson-
Smith, the court also found that Davis’s daughter was present
when he threw the safe, and that he pinned his daughter against
the wall. The court additionally referenced the communications
from Davis to Johnson-Smith after the TRO was granted and
noted that the only allegation Davis denied in those texts was
that he placed his cellphone in the toy box to track Johnson-
Smith. The court found credible Johnson-Smith’s testimony that
Davis threatened to commit suicide if Johnson-Smith did not
return to him.
The court found Davis not to be credible when he testified
that he did not know his cellphone was in his son’s toy box. The
court also believed that Davis threw a liquid on Johnson-Smith,
and that Davis’s denial was not credible. The court stated that,
15
while the incident itself was not compelling, “in the context of all
the other situations where the court did not find the respondent’s
testimony to be credible, it was just one more instance that added
to the court’s conclusion that the court is disinclined to believe
the testimony of the respondent.” The court added that
“generally[,] the court did not find the respondent’s testimony to
be credible.” The court granted Johnson-Smith a three-year
restraining order against Davis. Davis timely appealed.
E. The District Attorney Brings and Dismisses
Charges Against Johnson-Smith
Following Davis’s appeal, we granted his request to
augment the record with a misdemeanor complaint filed by the
People against Johnson-Smith. The complaint charged Johnson-
Smith with six counts based on calls and text messages allegedly
originating from Johnson-Smith to Davis: two counts of violating
Penal Code section 422, subdivision (a) (criminal threat); two
counts of violating Penal Code section 653m, subdivision (a)
(addressing obscene language and a threat to another by way of
an electronic communication device); and two counts of violating
Penal Code section 653m, subdivision (b) (repeated attempts at
communicating with another by way of an electronic
communication device).
We later granted Johnson-Smith’s request to judicially
notice the People’s dismissal of all charges against Johnson-
Smith, along with the prosecutor’s remarks to the court that it
had “come to light during numerous prosecutors reviewing this
matter, that there are some very significant victim credibility
issues in this case” and that the prosecutor “filed this case based
on certain assumptions and understandings that turned out not
to be accurate.”
16
DISCUSSION
“ ‘Under the DVPA, a court is authorized to issue a
protective order “ ‘to restrain any person for the purpose of
preventing a recurrence of domestic violence and ensuring a
period of separation of the persons involved’ ” upon “reasonable
proof of a past act or acts of abuse.” ’ [Citation.] The DVPA
defines ‘abuse’ as ‘any of the following: [¶] (1) To intentionally or
recklessly cause or attempt to cause bodily injury. [¶] (2) Sexual
assault. [¶] (3) To place a person in reasonable apprehension of
imminent serious bodily injury to that person or to another. [¶]
(4) To engage in any behavior that has been or could be enjoined
pursuant to Section 6320.’[12] (§ 6203, subd. (a).) ‘Abuse is not
limited to the actual infliction of physical injury or assault.’ (Id.,
subd. (b).)” (Parris J. v. Christopher U. (2023) 96 Cal.App.5th
108, 115–116.)
Here, the court expressly found that Davis threw liquid in
Johnson-Smith’s face, tried to take Johnson-Smith’s purse from
her arm, threw a safe while his daughter was present, pinned his
daughter against the wall, and made repeated attempts to
contact Johnson-Smith after the issuance of the TRO. Johnson-
Smith also testified to other acts of abuse, and the court found
her to be credible and Davis not to be credible.
Davis argues the court erred in finding that “abuse”
occurred because: (a) the court made no factual findings that
would support a conclusion that Davis placed Johnson-Smith in
12 Section 6320 permits enjoining “molesting, attacking,
striking, stalking, threatening, sexually assaulting, battering, . . .
harassing, telephoning, . . . destroying personal property,
contacting, . . . coming within a specified distance of, or
disturbing the peace of the other party.” (§ 6320, subd. (a).)
17
reasonable apprehension of imminent serious bodily injury; and
(b) the findings the court made did not constitute disturbing the
peace. “ ‘To the extent that we are called upon to review the trial
court’s factual findings, we apply a substantial evidence standard
of review.’ ” (In re Marriage of G. (2017) 11 Cal.App.5th 773,
780.) We hold that substantial evidence supports the court’s
findings.
A. Reasonable Apprehension of Imminent Serious
Bodily Injury
Davis argues that the court made no factual finding that
would provide an objective basis for Johnson-Smith to be “in
reasonable apprehension of imminent serious bodily injury.” But
in explaining its ruling granting the restraining order, the court
found that Davis threw a safe at Johnson-Smith, and pinned his
daughter to the wall. These findings are supported by solid
evidence of ponderable legal significance, and we have no trouble
concluding that such actions would place Johnson-Smith in
reasonable apprehension of imminent serious bodily injury both
to herself and to Davis’s daughter. This is especially true
considering Johnson-Smith’s testimony regarding past acts of
violence committed by Davis against her, such as Davis throwing
a television at her, Davis breaking her glasses in half while she
was wearing them, and Davis punching her in the head three
times.
Davis additionally contends “the record is clear” that
Johnson-Smith was the aggressor in the couple’s relationship,
citing his own testimony and the fact that the People filed
criminal charges against her. But the trial court expressly found
Davis’s testimony not credible. And the People dismissed the
18
charges filed against Johnson-Smith, with the prosecutor citing
“very significant victim [i.e. Davis] credibility issues.”
Citing Cueto v. Dozier (2015) 241 Cal.App.4th 550, 559,
Davis also contends that “[t]o determine whether a ‘reasonable
apprehension of imminent serious bodily injury’ amounts to
abuse under the Act, courts must determine ‘by a preponderance
of the evidence that the protected party entertains a ‘reasonable
apprehension’ of future abuse.’ ” To the extent Davis argues the
court needed to find a reasonable apprehension of future abuse
before issuing the restraining order, he misrepresents the holding
of Cueto. Cueto addressed whether a restraining order should be
renewed. (Id. at p. 553.) Noting that the DVPA “does not provide
a standard for a trial court to apply in deciding whether to grant
a renewal request,” the appellate court noted a previous court’s
holding that “ ‘[a] trial court should renew the protective order, if,
and only if, it finds by a preponderance of the evidence that the
protected party entertains a “reasonable apprehension” of future
abuse.’ ” (Id. at p. 559.)
Here, the court was not renewing a restraining order but
granting an initial restraining order request. Section 6300
expressly states that “[a]n order may be issued under this part to
restrain any person for the purpose specified in Section 6220, if
an affidavit or testimony and any additional information
provided to the court pursuant to Section 6306, shows, to the
satisfaction of the court, reasonable proof of a past act or acts of
abuse.” (§ 6300, subd. (a), italics added.) Given this statutory
language, “[n]o showing of the probability of future abuse is
required to issue a DVPA restraining order.” (Rodriguez v.
Menjivar (2015) 243 Cal.App.4th 816, 823.)
19
B. Disturbing the Peace
Davis additionally contends that his actions were not
“abuse” because they did not “rise to the level of harassment,
disturbing the peace, or coercive control constituting abuse.” The
DVPA defines “disturbing the peace” as “conduct that, based on
the totality of the circumstances, destroys the mental or
emotional calm of the other party.” (§ 6320, subd. (c).) We
conclude that all of Davis’s actions—knowingly giving Johnson-
Smith a sexually transmitted disease, throwing a television at
her, breaking her glasses, punching her in the head three times,
throwing a drink at her, grabbing her purse from her arm,
throwing a safe at her, hiding a phone in their son’s toy box to
discover her address, and sending her over one hundred text
messages after the granting of the TRO—would destroy Johnson-
Smith’s mental or emotional calm and thus constitute “abuse.”
There is ample evidence in the record to support the court’s
findings on these issues.
Davis argues that Johnson-Smith’s testimony regarding
some of these incidents is not credible. “Credibility
determinations are the province of the trial court.” (McCord v.
Smith (2020) 51 Cal.App.5th 358, 364.) Here, the court expressly
found Johnson-Smith to be credible, and Davis not to be—a
sentiment shared by the district attorney who dismissed the case
brought against Johnson-Smith. Because credibility findings are
the province of the trial court, “we do not revisit [them].” (Rojas
v. HSBC Card Services, Inc. (2023) 93 Cal.App.5th 860, 889.)
20
DISPOSITION
The trial court’s order is affirmed. Respondent Jasleen
Johnson-Smith is awarded her costs on appeal.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED
*
KLATCHKO, J.
We concur:
BENDIX, Acting P. J.
WEINGART, J.
*
Judge of the Riverside County Superior Court, assigned by
the Chief Justice pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the
California Constitution.
21
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.