CourtListener 10281550•People v. Rivera CA1/2
Full text
Filed 11/21/24 P. v. Rivera CA1/2
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not
certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been
certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION TWO
THE PEOPLE,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
A169694
v.
SEVION MICHAEL RIVERA, (Humboldt County
Super. Ct. No. CR2202614)
Defendant and Appellant.
Defendant Sevion Michael Rivera pled guilty to receiving stolen
property (Pen. Code, § 496, subd. (a))1 and was ordered to pay $7,852.90 in
victim restitution. Defendant appeals from the restitution order. He argues,
and the Attorney General agrees, that there is an insufficient evidentiary
basis for the restitution award. We accept the Attorney General’s concession,
and we therefore reverse the restitution order and remand the matter for
further proceedings.
1 Further undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.
1
BACKGROUND
The Facts
According to the probation report, on May 19, 2022, Davis D.,2 the
victim in this case and defendant’s former friend, reported to the police that
someone had broken into his apartment while he was out of town. Davis
reported that the following were missing: several firearms (a Smith and
Wesson model 60, a .38 special revolver, a Stoeger Arms shotgun, a Henry
Repeating Arms AR-7 .22 rifle, and an AMT Backup semiautomatic .38
pistol), one box of miscellaneous ammunition, and “other items.” Davis’s
girlfriend also reported that her laptop and gaming console were taken from
Davis’s apartment.
Davis told police that he believed defendant was the culprit based on
their previous interactions. Defendant and Davis recently had a falling out
after defendant visited Davis’s apartment and apparently became upset when
he noticed a pair of his AirPods were missing. Defendant threatened to break
into Davis’s apartment and steal some of his belongings.
Later on May 19, Davis reported to police that defendant had contacted
their mutual friend and that defendant may have given her some of Davis’s
stolen property. A police officer contacted the mutual friend, who reported
defendant had asked her to temporarily hold onto some of his belongings
because he had been kicked out of his residence. She agreed to do so, and
defendant dropped off the items in two large trash bags. When Davis
informed his friend that the trash bags may possibly contain stolen firearms,
she turned over the trash bags to the police.
Inside the trash bags were a black Paradigm sub-woofer speaker; a pair
2 We omit Davis’s last name to protect his privacy interests. (See Cal.
Rules of Court, rule 8.90(b)(4).)
2
of AKG N90Q headphones; a case of Norske drill bits; a Sony stereo; two
Dewalt cordless drills; a silver Pro laptop; an Adidas bag; a Krome gun
cleaning supply case; a DoorDash carry bag; a white Sony PlayStation 5
controller; a black Logitech computer keyboard; one pair of blue jeans; one
Fanatec F1 gaming steering wheel; and an empty FN Five Seven pistol case.
The Proceedings Below
On September 19, 2022, the Humboldt County District Attorney filed a
felony complaint charging defendant with first degree burglary (§§ 459, 460,
subd. (a)) (count 1) and receiving stolen property with a value exceeding $950
(§ 496, subd. (a)) (count 2).
On March 16, 2023, defendant pled guilty to count 2 in exchange for the
dismissal of count 1. On April 25, the trial court placed defendant on two
years’ probation and reserved the issue of victim restitution.
On May 30, the People filed a motion for an order awarding Davis
$7,852.90 in victim restitution. Attached as “Exhibit A” to the motion were
screenshots of various items listed on retail websites. These items were a set
of used Klipsch speakers ($239.99); a 65-inch QLED TV ($3,999.99); a
Yamaha receiver ($399.95); a Panasonic LCD display ($1,307.99); a Logitech
wireless keyboard and mouse set ($54.99); a Gamerstation gaming console
($1,550); a “Pre-Built Entry Level Gaming PC” ($950); a “Dell Latitude 10-
Key Work/School Laptop” ($375 to $400); a Ryzen 5 gaming console ($650);
and a Henry AR-7 semiautomatic rifle ($299.99). The total cost of these
items is $9,827.90 with the lower value of the laptop, or $9,852.90 with the
higher value of the laptop.
On January 18, 2024, the trial court held a restitution hearing. The
parties relied on the submitted documents and oral argument; neither
presented any new evidence or testimony, including from Davis, who
3
apparently was present at the hearing.3
Citing People v. Holmberg (2011) 195 Cal.App.4th 1310 and People v.
Scroggins (1987) 191 Cal.App.3d 502, defense counsel argued “there has to be
a connection between the victim’s loss and the defendant’s crime,” and here,
there was no evidence that defendant possessed the items claimed in Exhibit
A to the People’s restitution motion.
The prosecutor responded, “There most certainly is a connection to the
defendant and the items that the People have addressed in their motion.”
The prosecutor reasoned that defendant threatened to burglarize Davis’s
apartment “because there was some thought that maybe the victim had taken
his Airpods,” and “[l]ow [sic] and behold, the victim’s apartment does shortly
thereafter get burglarized.” The prosecutor went on, “The defendant did
plead guilty to being in receipt of stolen property. That property was the
victim’s property in this case.” The prosecutor then explained that although
some items were returned to the victim, others were not, and that “[t]he
items that the People have addressed in our motion here were the items that
were not returned to the victim.”
Following that argument, the trial court granted the People’s motion
and ordered the $7,852.90 sought in victim restitution. The court stated,
“[Defendant] pled guilty to possession of stolen property, specifically, that
property belonging to the individual who provided the information that the
District Attorney filed . . . [T]he named victim in the matter isn’t requesting
3 The hearing transcript states that the “victim” was present but does
not identify who it was. It may be inferred that Davis was present, based on
the fact that the restitution motion was brought in his name, the parties
referred to only one victim throughout the hearing, and the parties
mentioned the “victim’s” apartment that was burglarized, clearly referring to
Davis’s apartment.
4
restitution for any items that had been returned, just for the items that were
not returned.
On January 19, defendant filed a notice of appeal.4
DISCUSSION
The Law and the Standard of Review
“Restitution is constitutionally and statutorily mandated in California.
([Citation]; Cal. Const., art. I, § 28, subd. (b).) The constitutional mandate for
restitution is carried out through Penal Code section 1202.4 . . . .” (People v.
Keichler (2005) 129 Cal.App.4th 1039, 1045, fn. omitted.) Section 1202.4,
subdivision (f) states, “in every case in which a victim has suffered economic
loss as a result of the defendant’s conduct, the court shall require that the
defendant make restitution to the victim or victims in an amount established
by court order, based on the amount of loss claimed by the victim or victims
or any other showing to the court.” (§ 1202.4, subd. (f).) Restitution “shall be
of a dollar amount that is sufficient to fully reimburse the victim or victims
for every determined economic loss incurred as the result of the defendant’s
criminal conduct . . . . (§ 1202.4, subd. (f)(3), italics added.) Courts have
interpreted section 1202.4, subdivision (f) to require a causal connection
between the defendant’s criminal conduct of which he or she was convicted
and the victim’s loss. (See People v. Holmberg (2011) 195 Cal.App.4th 1310,
1321; People v. Jones (2010) 187 Cal.App.4th 418, 424–427.) Recoverable
economic losses include the full or partial value of stolen property. (§ 1202.4,
subd. (f)(3)(A).) And “[t]he value of stolen . . . property shall be the
4 The trial court did not issue a written restitution order until January
31. Defendant requested that we treat his notice of appeal as having been
filed immediately after issuance of the January 31 restitution order (Cal.
Rules of Court, rule 8.308(c)), which request we granted.
5
replacement cost of like property . . . .” (Ibid.)
A defendant is entitled to a hearing to “dispute the determination of the
amount of restitution.” (§ 1202.4, subd. (f)(1).) At a restitution hearing, the
victim bears the initial burden of establishing the loss (People v. Giordano
(2007) 42 Cal.4th 644, 664) by a preponderance of the evidence (People v.
Holmberg, supra, 195 Cal.App.4th at p. 1319). “ ‘At a victim restitution
hearing, a prima facie case for restitution is made by the People based in part
on a victim’s testimony on, or other claim or statement of, the amount of his
or her economic loss. [Citations.] “Once the victim has [i.e., the People have]
made a prima facie showing of his or her loss, the burden shifts to the
defendant to demonstrate that the amount of the loss is other than that
claimed by the victim.” ’ ” (People v. Chappelone (2010) 183 Cal.App.4th
1159, 1172 (Chappelone).)
“A restitution order is intended to compensate the victim for its actual
loss and is not intended to provide the victim with a windfall.” (Chappelone,
supra, 183 Cal.App.4th at p. 1172.) But “[t]here is no requirement the
restitution order be limited to the exact amount of the loss in which the
defendant is actually found culpable.” (People v. Carbajal (1995) 10 Cal.4th
1114, 1121; Chappelone, at p. 1172.) The court need only use a rational
method that is reasonably calculated to make the victim whole. (Chappelone,
at p. 1172.)
On appeal, we review a restitution award for abuse of discretion.
(Chappelone, supra, 183 Cal.App.4th at p. 1172.) The amount of the award
must also be supported by substantial evidence. (People v. Millard (2009)
175 Cal.App.4th 7, 26.) “ ‘When there is a factual and rational basis for the
amount of restitution ordered by the trial court, no abuse of discretion will be
found by the reviewing court.’ ” (People v. Mearns (2002) 97 Cal.App.4th 493,
6
499.)
The Trial Court Abused Its Discretion in Ordering Victim
Restitution in the Amount of $7,852.90
Defendant argues the trial court abused its discretion when it awarded
Davis $7,852.90 in restitution because the People did not present sufficient
evidence to support that award. The Attorney General agrees, as do we.
Defendant pled guilty to receiving stolen property, namely the items in
the trash bags that he had entrusted to his and Davis’s mutual friend and
were eventually turned over to the police. In the restitution motion and at
the hearing, the prosecutor represented that the items set forth in Exhibit A
to their motion: (a) were the same items that were contained in the trash
bags recovered by the police; (b) belonged to Davis; and (c) were never
returned to Davis. Thus, the prosecutor argued that Davis was entitled to
recover the value of the items set forth in Exhibit A. However, as the
Attorney General acknowledges, the People presented insufficient evidence to
support their representations.
For one, there were several items in Exhibit A that were never reported
as stolen, much less found in the trash bags in defendant’s possession and
later recovered by police. Those items included, for example, a flat screen
television, a Yamaha receiver, a Panasonic flat screen LCD monitor, and
three gaming computers. Moreover, although other items in Exhibit A
appear to be similar to the stolen items in the trash bags—for example,
subwoofer speakers, a Logitech keyboard, and a laptop—the People did not
present evidence demonstrating that those items belonged to Davis, and,
assuming that they did belong to him, that they were not returned to him.5
5 Regarding the laptop, it was actually Davis’s girlfriend who reported
that her laptop was stolen. Assuming that the laptop found in the trash bags
7
Therefore, as the Attorney General acknowledges, the record does not
contain evidence that “any of the items claimed were stolen from [Davis] and
not recovered.” Indeed, the People did not ask Davis to submit a declaration,
testify, or otherwise explain the actual losses he sustained. In sum, we agree
with the parties that the trial court abused its discretion in awarding Davis
$7,852.90 in restitution because the award lacks an adequate factual basis.
Accordingly, the restitution order must be vacated, and the matter remanded
to the trial court for a new restitution hearing.
DISPOSITION
The victim restitution order is reversed and the case is remanded for a
new hearing on the amount of restitution.
belonged to her, awarding Davis the value of the stolen laptop provided him
with an improper windfall. (Chappelone, supra, 183 Cal.App.4th at p. 1172.)
8
RICHMAN, ACTING P. J.
We concur.
MILLER, J.
DESAUTELS, J.
(People v. Rivera A169694N)
9
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.